The Best Games I Reviewed in 2025 - My 4.5's and 5's
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Radcliff from Board Gameco and today I'm going over my highest reviewed games of 2025. These are the games that I put out a video review in 2025. These are not specifically my 2025 games. That's important because if you did watch my uh highest re my high my top 10 games of 2025, if you did watch that video, this is going to have a few things that are not present on that video. First of all, it has a cat a cat that I'm currently kind of like giving the squishes to. But also more importantly, it has games that are not 2025 games that I reviewed in 2025. And it also has games that will be coming up in the future, like uh crowdfunding games that I reviewed in 2025. Basically, these are my highest reviewed games from 2025. Specifically, all of my 4.5s and all of my fives. I'll be going over those in order, going through my 4.5s first, then my fives.
This is also not a ranking, meaning I did not rank my 4.5s and my fives to give you the best five out of five from the five out of fives. This is me just going over all of those that you have, if you wanted a list of, hey, what are the what are the highlights of 2025? What are the best games that Alex reviewed in 2025 according to Alex, this will be that video. I'm going to dive into it shortly, but first a note. Thank you to Allplay for sponsoring the channel. You can check out a variety of things, but today we're going to focus on the fact that you can go ahead and get your hands on a custom table if you go or a regular table for that matter. You can go to allplay.com and you can check out a regular table, affordable tables like the Jasper and all of that. Or you can get a custom table to whatever specifications you want. Check them out at allplay.com. With that said, we're going to go through my 4.5s first and then we'll get into my fives from the 4.5s. And again, I kind of probably should have grouped this. In fact, you know what? I'm going to go ahead. No, it's too late now. It's too late now. I should have grouped this into like, you know, upcoming games to the future, uh, games from 2025, and games from before 2025. But, we're just going to go through it in the order that I did these videos. So, this is ordered by when I did the video roughly. I say roughly because, long story short, my own database of when I filmed the video versus when the video went up. It's not an exact correlation, but nonetheless, this should generally cover this. So, we have Casinoopoulos. Casinoopoulos is the newest game in the Spalopoulos series. I really enjoyed it. I gave it a 4.5 out of five. It felt like it was doing a few things differently. I think Spaloploolis is still my go-to. Casinopoulos had a few things that were not as intuitive, but I still very much enjoyed it. The Morrison Game Factory I gave a 4.5 out
of five. This is a good time to note that throughout this video I'm giving you the reviews I gave at the time, but I'll give you my thoughts on them as far as how things have changed. The Morrison Game Factory I gave a 4.5 out of five. I think I would bump it to a five out of five. And it's interesting because it's not a game I've played since then. This is an escape room game. You can't play it a second time. But my thoughts on on the game, my nostalgia for the game, my my wish to be able to play through it again, that has only grown. So even though I gave it a 4.5 after playing it, it has kind of lived rentfree in my head since then. And it's one of those games I I I can't stop thinking about. I can't stop recommending it. It has only grown in my head since playing it. I'm going to bump it to a five out of five. We have Minos Dawn of the Bronze Age. Really enjoy this one. Gave it a 4.5. I think it's excellent. It hasn't gone down. It hasn't gone up. It's still exactly where I thought it would be.
Daybreak is one that has shrunk a little bit before me. I gave it a 4.5 out of five. I did say in the review that I am concerned that it's a little bit too sy every time you play it. At the time, I had already played it several times and I already started to see that. The more I dove into it, the more it did become very sy. I do the same thing every single time I play it. I like that same thing that I do, but it is enough that the game shrunk a little bit for me. I would say it's gone down to a four out of five, but it's still an excellent game. Then we have Link City. Link City is another one that has gone down a little bit for me. I still think it's excellent. I still love it. It's all about placing down buildings and then creating the connections between what buildings make the most sense to place. It's not that dissimilar to a word game such as So Clover or the like, but with buildings that kind of have a thematic link as opposed to a word link. Uh overall, really enjoy it. I gave it a 4.5 out of five. Again, it has gone down a little bit for me. I'd say it's a four out of five right now. Still very much enjoy it though. There's Massive Darkness 2. I gave this a 4.5 out of five. Massive Darkness 2. I'm kind of surprised I only reviewed it in Oh, maybe I maybe I was covering the new one. Maybe that was going on. Maybe I was covering the expansion. Massive Darkness 2. Uh it's a 4.5 out of five game for me and it still very much is.
It is one of those games that I wonder if it's a forever game considering how many uh big box miniature experiences there are when it's going up against Zombide and Cthulhu Death May Die. The question is what will get played for right now. Massive Darkness 2 is still here. I just think it's an excellent game system and it's different enough that I am reluctant to get rid of it. That said, like if if everything in my collection burned down, I don't think I would repurchase it. There's too many big box miniature games that I don't get to them all, but I am still happy I have it. There's Aridia. Aridia I gave a 4.5 as well. This one has gone down a little bit for me. The rating hasn't changed because I still very much appreciate what Aridia is doing. So, I still have it as a 4.5 as far as the rating, but Aridia is one of those games that has faded a bit for me because it's a campaign game that had the problem that as soon as I stopped playing it, as soon like I gave it like, you know, whatever it was, I don't know, 20 hours, 30 hours, I don't know how long I played it for, but however much I played it, uh, I I then broke broke took a break from it for, you know, a month or two and then realized it was so much harder to get back into it because specifically the key system made it hard to kind of keep up to where you were. Uh, there's a lot of different campaign games out there. I do find campaign games are always harder to dive back into them when you give it a break. But in general, the ones that make it so that I am disincentivized from diving back in because I'm like, I just don't want to deal with figuring out what we were doing. That was a big strike against Aridia for me. I did not finish Aridia and I don't have plans to finish Ardia. I think it is a brilliant system, but I think it's a brilliant system that has the flaw that if you take a break, it is going to be hard to figure out exactly what you are up to and what you are doing. Huton. Huton is another one that that that definitely faded for me. I give it a 4.5 out of
five. I think I' I'd demote that to a four as well. Huton is very very well done. There's a lot of things about it that I really enjoy and I was very much charmed by it as I first dove into it. That said, the more I've played it, the more I find that I just prefer games like Cascadia and Calico, which are two games I constantly go back to, but they're not the only two games. Spectacular has held strong for me. It's another one of those systems. So, it's not like Cascadia and Calico are the only two games that I like in this. They are the two longest lasting and they are the bar that I grade a lot of these games against. But again, games like Spectacular, I'd have to take a look at my collection, but games like Spectacular have done equally well over time. Uh, Huton was great at first. It has gone down a little bit for me. Ready Set Bet gave that a 4.5 out of five. And I stand by that one. That rating wise, I did get rid of that one only because I find that Ready Set Bet is a game that I never play at home. It's only ever a convention or travel game. And inevitably, I don't really play my copy.
I don't think I've ever played my copy. It's possible I have, but I don't think I've ever played my copy. I've only really played it when I travel. And usually like when I travel to a convention that has it and so usually it has it. So I did get rid of Freddy's ready at Bet. I think it's a very unique experience and I'm still always happy to play it. It's more just a uh decision choice as far as what makes sense for my personal collection here. Onward I gave a 4.5 out of five. Really enjoyed that one. That's hard for me to really give you an updated opinion on because Onward I gave it a 4.5 for the prototype at the time, but has already delivered since reviewing it. Has already delivered. Uh but I haven't continued to play it since I got it. So, that's one where I'll have to give you my thoughts more as I continue to dive into it, but I do think it's one that I'm very, well, excitement wise, I'm still up there. Uh, gameplay-wise, I'll have to play it more and see. Black Forest, I also gave a 4.5 out of five. This is one that I can actually see growing based on where I am so far in it. I could see it continuing to get better over time. For right now, it's still a 4.5. I don't know if there's anything specific holding it back. I could see it growing considering the other types of games that I do give a five out of five. I could see Black Forest growing, but for right, I'm going to give it a strong 4.5. It's an O Rosenberg game. It's probably my newest favorite Oi Rosenberg game. But like when I think of would I rather play Fast for Odin or that, I think I'd rather play Black Forest, but also I've played Feast for Odin dozens of times and I'm still hot on that game. So it's a 4.5 for right now. Black Force, not Fast Odin, but we'll see what happens over time. Rackbusters. Rackbusters reloaded specifically from uh Monolith Games. I gave it a 4.5 out of five. It's only a prototype, so I don't have any new update information on on that for you, but I loved it. I thought Rackbuster did such a good job at improving the Rackbuster system. Uh, they took the
rack busters from Monolith and from Mythic. I mean, they took Monolith took it from Mythic and they did such a good job with what they did that they took a game that I wanted to love and made it a game I actually did love. I I really adored the simultaneous action system and how cooperative the game did feel as you were playing through it. There's Centuri. Santorini, not Santori. Santorini. Santorini is a game that I've had in my collection for years and I just realized I never really reviewed it. So, when I the second edition came through, I was like, "This is a good time to actually review it." I played through the second edition. Overall, I mean, there's no major changes to the game. It's still Santorini. I give it a 4.5 out of five, I still think it deserves that rating. It's one of those games I constantly return to. I'm currently currently in the middle of playing through the Riddle of the Sphinx series. Uh but whether you're playing as a two-player abstract with the thematic abilities or whether you're playing the solo mode with Riddle of the Sphinx, well solo or cooperative, it's just a very good game that I uh has stood the test of time. I've had in my collection for I want to say like eight or nine years at this point. That sounds right.
Did I get it? Whatever the first Kickstarter for Santorini was, I've had it for that long and it hasn't gone anywhere. 10 Days in the National Parks. gave that a 4.5 out of five. I love that system. It is so simple and so straightforward. I first played the 10day system way back when uh when the OP came out with the new versions of it, 10 days in the USA and then 10 days in the national parks. I think they're excellent. I would rather play national parks in the USA, but honestly, both of them are great and I'm always down to play 10 days. It's such a good game system that I have hundreds of plays between the whole series. I have hundreds of plays of 10 days. It's a great game. 4.5 out of five. There was STI. SI got a 4.5 out of five. uh that was at the time. It has grown for me since then. I think CGE did a great job with Steady. I have a few small complaints against it. It is a game that runs long and that has held it back for me. The expansion has bumped it up to a five out of five for me with still complaints. Like I still think it runs long relative to what I get out of the experience, but it's one of those games that I do want to play. I want to dive back in. I want to go into it again and find new ways to iterate or improve or just get better or combine the cards. I think the alien races are a fantastic aspect that constantly keep the game fresh. So, still very much a door set.
It has gone up for me since that initial review. Then the Lord of the Rings, Fate of the Fellowship. Gave it a 4.5 out of five. I could see it growing. It's a It's weird. This is built on the Pandemic system. There's definitely some small flaws or complaints about it. Uh the readability of the board is certainly certainly an issue. Uh the randomness of whether things will work in your favor or not. That's always been an issue with Pandemic, and you just have to embrace it or not. But Lord of the Rings, Fate of the Fellowship, I still think it's excellent. A 4.5 out of five. Not yet ready to bump it up. Certainly not yet ready to bump it down. Inc. I gave a 4.5 as well. Uh Inc is an excellent game that kind of has the um has the same system as Framework, Sagani, and Novalu Luna. Although it's not designed by U Rosenberg, and those other three are, but Inc. I think is actually better because it kind of has that system while giving you as not asymmetric, giving you variable power tiles that keep the game a little fresher every time you play it. So, it is my favorite from those. Uh it is the one that got that made me not made me that convinced me to get rid of framework. Uh those are all great systems. I'm happy to play them on BGA, but Inc. is the one which you could also play on BGA by the way, but Inc is the one that I have currently and it's the one that I'm sticking around at least for now. There's Gatsby. I gave that a 4.5 as well. Gatsby is an interesting one from Panosaurus Games. It is one that my rating is definitely higher than the average. I think it's rated like a 6.7 or something like that. Like it's not I don't know why it's so low and I'm so high in that game, but I think it's a really good two-player tug-of-war game.
The the tracks you're playing on, the way you're constantly trying to manage trying to sneak the win on your opponent, I think it's so much fun. I do wonder or worry if people play it on board game arena because I don't think that was the best implementation of the game system. I know that I loved it in person, played it on BGA and thought it was good on BGA, but thought it was much much better in person. So, I do wonder how many ratings are coming from there. But honestly, most likely it's just that I think I rate it higher than the average person. But that said, it is still a 4.5 out of five for me. I think it's an excellent two-player tugof-war and I always enjoy a good tugof-war system. There's the four shuffle expansions. This is not four shuffle Dartmore. This is four shuffle expansions. Four Shovel Dartmore should be on my list somewhere. Yeah, it is. It is coming up soon. Four Shovel expansions. Uh, actually, Four Shuff's gone up for me. That's a different story. Four shuffle expansions. Gave them a 4.5 out of five. I think they didn't really add anything that that incredible to the G to the original game, but I still very much enjoyed them for the variability they add. Thinking more accurately, they probably should be an expansion. Expansion rating wise, they probably should be a four for me because I don't rate expansions based on how think how good the overall system is or with expansions. I rate it based on what I think expansions added. I don't think expansions actually added all that much. They probably are a four out of five, but my overall enjoyment of for shuffle has only gone up to a five out of five. I adore for shuffle. So, take take read into that how you will. The expansions are okay. The game system is amazing and I think for shuffle is a good uh good system to have with it. A good a good I think for shuffle is excellent. I think expansions just added more variability to it. Logic and lore.
Technically, that one that one did go up to 25. Yeah, logic and lore. Logical and lore I gave a 4.5 out of five. I think it's an incredible two-player deduction game. One of my favorite little uh fun little two-player additions to the collection. I enjoy deduction. This is a little bit of memory combined with deduction. It's a fantastic game. Definitely a hidden gem. Check it out. That's logic and lore. Journeys of Farar the Katsuaki or Journey Safar I think it's called Journeys Safar the Katsurki. I think it's called it's terrible name. Terrible name. Great game. Gave it a 4.5 out of five. This is an upcoming game so it's a prototype. Uh so I don't have more plays of it since since covering it. I have not played it since. But I think Journeys of Far is an excellent game with incredible artwork, tells a great story, gives you a kind of a sandbox adventure that guides the players enough that you have a kind of a sense of where to go and what to do, but then at the same time, it gives you enough freedom that you really can try to develop how you want to in the game.
I think it's fantastic. Definitely worth checking out if you have a chance. Honors End from IV Studios gave it a 4.5 as well. Honors End is is a really solid cooperative deck building game that had a strong sense of teamwork as you play through it, as well as just the fun of developing your own little deck. It's a very different system uh compared to other deck builders. The way they utilize cards in the game really well done and really innovative and most importantly really different. I say most importantly because game standing out is so important when there are so many games. There are a lot of games that I give good scores to and I don't keep because I have other games that do it better. When a game manages to do things differently that is usually a point in its favor. Honest felt like a good uh variation on the deck build on the typical deck building that you expect to see. And then lastly in the 4.5s, there's the expansion for STI. Uh SI the expansion I I gave it a 4.5. It did bump the game up to me for a five out of five. As far as what the expansion is doing, though, I give it a 4.5. I really enjoyed the study expansion. I thought it added asymmetric things that were really fun. It kind of made the game faster, but not really. Like it reduced around, but you're doing extra stuff. It gave you a head start on the game, which I really enjoy. Terrifying Mars preude is is consistently one of the best expansions for a game out there. And the expansion for study is a similar kind of vibe, giving you a lot of new fun things for the game. Really recommend the expansion if you like study. Those are my 4.5s of 2025. My five out of fives are Evidel Silverst. This is one that was always a little tricky because I I I this is tricky. I did like three videos on Evidel. Well, I guess I did a gameplay, a review, and then a conversation about my review. But Evidel Silverstro is a tricky one for me because it's a five out of five game
because I like Evodel and I like Evidel Silverstro and it's doing interesting different things. But I also wasn't super enthused because this is like the fourth Avidol game now at this point and they all feel fairly sy. So it is both a five out of five because it is different and also I'm happy like I think Evid Silver Frost is excellent. Played it multiple times. Would happily play it right now. I don't know which Evidil I think is best. I'm happy to play any or all of them. So it does get and earn that five out of five. But also it kind of got a half-hearted five out of five because there's only so many ways you can repackage the same thing with small variations before I just stopped being as excited about that thing. And so Evidel Silver Frost definitely Evidel did I say Frost? Evidel Oh. Huh.
I have to check when I rated things, but I have Evidel Silverstro and Evidel Emerland both in my um both of my ratings. I have to check when my reviews went up. But for me, I have to double check this. Evident Silver Frost and Evidel Emmerand are both games that I have listed as being 2025 reviews. Do I have two Evidels in 2025? Has it been that fast? This doesn't both This doesn't change my overall opinion. Both Avidel Silverrost and Evidel Emmerand get a five out of five. They are both excellent game systems. Also, they're just more evidel. Doesn't change my opinion there. Anyways, uh from there we have Pirates of March. Pirates of Marabo was my second five out of five for the year. Kind of evident silver I guess at the very beginning of the year and then everything else came in at the tail end but a bunch came in at the tail end. We have Pirates of Marabo a five out of five. It made its way into my top four my fourth highest rated game of all time as of 2025. Uh but I love uh Pirates of Marabo. I think it's fantastic. I am always happy to play it. I finally am in middle of game of Marabo right now. It's okay, but I want to play it in person as well. I'm playing on BGA to Borgimi Marina to learn it. Uh, it's good, but I'd rather play just pirates of Maro, but I also want to play Marbo in person.
This a game system that I like it enough that I want to give it that in-person check first. Then there was Shackleton base. I gave that a five out of five as well. I will say Shackleton base and Pirates of Maro is probably equally high on when I play them versus Pirates has continued to grow with every subsequent play and Shackleton base is about the same. I still think it's a five out of five game at least for right now, but it is one that has been like, you know, lower end of the five out of five or as Pirates shot its way into the highest five out of fives. my collection. Then there's Blood Rage Vajala. This is an upcoming uh upcoming game. It's a prototype, but I thought Blood Rage Valhalla was an excellent iteration on the Blood Rage system. Uh it's been a long time since I felt that fresh feeling of a Blood Rage combos. I really think I think Blood Rage Vala gets a lot of flack, especially with Tycoon Games picking it up, especially some of the decisions they made during the crowdfunding campaign. But I think if you are a Blood Rage fan, Valhalla is worth trying out. I think it is so good and I think it really does bring that freshness back to uh what Blood Rage does well. There was Calypso. Gave that a five out of five as well. Calypso is absolutely fantastic. I love what the game is doing. Did I miss one? I missed four shuffle Dartmore. I skipped past four shuffle Dartmore. I'm sorry. I'll go back to that in a second. Sorry about that. Uh where was Calypso? Calypso is a excellent game from Inside Up Games. My favorite game from inside games. The solo and cooperative specifically is where I love that game. Uh it's excellent. I I I don't have enough positive things to say about it. I am very excited for the final game. I did have some like personal preferences as far as difficulty modes and some aspects of var variability of the game, but I do think that uh I think Calypso is incredible uh specifically for the cooperative and solo. I'm sorry, he just hugged my hand. He just like hugged my
hand. Specifically for the cooperative and solo mode. Uh jumping back a little bit to for shuffle Dartmore because I somehow skipped this on my list, but for Shuffle Dartmore gave it a 4.5 out of five. I think for shuffle is excellent. I think Dartmore is an excellent game in that system. I will say for shuffle in general has been bumped to a five out of five for me by now. I enjoy it so much. I have so much fun with it. Uh, so it's one that my rating is a 4.5. I've just continued to enjoy the game system so much that it has bumped up over time. So kind of it's out of order, but in order if you're counting where it is now. Then there's Cascadia Alpine Lakes. Another game that's upcoming. Gave it a five out of five. It is amazing. I think Alpine Lakes was a great Cascadia game system. Keeping in mind that Cascadia is a system that I gave a five out of five originally. And then every expansion or variation of Cascadia since then, I have not given a five out of five. I have been much more medium on them, ranging from good to very good to in some cases not even very good at all. Like I was pretty critical on the expansion. I was pretty critical on Junior. I do like the roller rights. So Cascadia is a system that I will always buy into anything they do, but I won't always say that I love them. I love the original Cascadia and Alpine Lakes was the second time I gave a five out of five to a Cascadia game. I think it takes what Cascadia does well and it iterates incredibly well. It gives you more complexity and more depth uh while also feeling familiar yet different enough that it's worth having both. at least for myself.
Then there's Evidel Everland. See all the things I said about Evidol already. I think Evodile is great, but I also think that they have stopped impressing me, at least for right now. I will still happily try out anything evidel. But the trying it out and being interested is very different than being excited. This is a problem that Zombicide got for a certain point in time where a certain point there's only so many ways you can tweak what Zombide is doing and you have to kind of prove your worth as opposed to me just being excited. Like right now there's a pirate zombide coming out and I am both incredibly excited for it and also like will I be excited? Like I'm I'm excited for the possibility but I'm also realistic about whether that possibility will or won't work for me. So like you know we'll see. We'll see. Time will tell. And then lastly we have Darwin's Journey. I gave it a five out of five as well. And so that was uh that was excellent. Darwin's Journey is amazing. I believe I put it as my seventh highest game of all time as of 2025. I think it was number seven. I'm pretty sure. Primal six. Star Darwin Journey was seven. Yeah, that sounds about right. But Darwin Journey is fantastic. I think it's a lot of fun. I I highly recommend it. It's one of those games that I'm constantly playing and iterating on and still very much enjoying it. Definitely recommend checking it out if you like your midweight Euro games. And those are kind of my quick summaries for 2025 highest rated games. That's 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 eight games that I gave it five out of five.
Although two of them are evid that I'm less excited about. So you can take what you want from those. A bunch of them are upcoming games. Bunch of them are from the past games. There's actually when I think of 2025 games that really got a five out of five, I don't know if I really have any. I don't think I gave a five out of five to any 2025 titles. I gave five out of fives to games before 2025 and games coming up next year, but nothing from 2025 got a five out of five. That said, there are games from 2025 that are getting a five out of five. I just didn't review them in 2025. I want to say that there's two 2025 titles that got that are getting a five out of five. And you probably saw those in my highest rated games of 2025 because I I talked about them or even just my top 100 as well. I talked with them already.
I just haven't reviewed them officially yet. Anyways, with that said, this has been a recap of my highest rated games in 2025. I hope you found this useful as a quick summary of the best as well as some minor updates on how things have developed or changed over the course of the year. As always, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Gameco. Hope you found this video helpful and until next time, I hope you have a good