Skip to main content
Loading video...

Our 23 Most Disappointing Games of 2025 with @banzainator ►►► The R&R Show Episode 111

Transcript 1:57:32

This episode of the RNR show is brought to you by Chip Theory Games, publisher of Jump Masters. And that was it. Oh, hi. There you go. I don't know what that was. I just pressed a button and weird things happen. Hello friends. Welcome to the RNR show. My name is Ruel Gabiola joined by Chris George as always. And we've got a very special guest. We've got Bosnator in the house.

Hi everyone. I think it's my first time on this show.

Really? Oh, I think you're right. Yeah.

Yeah. I'm excited to be here.

It's just we we always see your name in the chat, so it feels like we've we've we've had you here.

Yeah.

Yeah. I just had a three stream streak on Twitch chat.

Very nice.

Nice. How does it feel?

Uh you know, airy.

Oh, nice.

Very.

Yeah, that's sweet. That's real sweet.

Oh, friends, we are so excited to have Bonds here. Um if you do not know Bonds, feel free to follow her at Bonsnator here on uh Twitch. Uh she is a prolific streamer. Um I see her all the time here on Twitch and I'm very proud to call her call her one of my friends here. Um and um as you know she's in chat very often talking about games. She plays a tons of games video games, board games, you name it. And uh Buns again we are so here. Thanks for joining us. And

u Chris got any questions for Bonds before I while I try to panic and set things up here? Well, perfect. Yeah. What I always love, it's always good to let the audience know you're panicking. So, it's step one. Um, uh, no, what I was going to say, what I was going to say is, Bons, I feel like I'm going to toot your horn. I'm going to gas you up a little bit here. I think to me, you are like the number one board game streamer because there are so many there are so many like content creators out there, right, who who who just film, pre-record stuff, and whatever. But I I feel like you are the one who is sort of really um a actively always doing that live interaction and live live streaming and showing things. Um how does it feel to have earned the moniker? You've earned it. Every everybody's been saying it.

Actually, I I had a quorum with all board gaming and they said they said that we were to award you this uh this title today as the number one board game streamer around.

Well, all right. All right. Okay. Well, in that case, I'll go ahead and award myself this. I'd like to thank chat

y

and my moderators for all the hard work, you know, and I will present myself the good luck, fame, and fortune award to myself. Ignore the fact that says 2019, you know.

Nah, nah. Time is meaningless. Time's a construct, right?

What What does What do yours have to do with it?

Well, thank you. Thank you. Uh, but I will say there is a lot of good board game streamers out there, including real.

Yeah, the the live streams, you know,

YouTube, that's a whole another I mean, that's a whole another scene.

Yeah.

Uh, Bowler Dude says it's because she has such great followers. That also might be it.

It's Bowler Duty.

Bowler Duty. See, this is why you're the best in the business.

You got to pronounce the doody.

Of course. Nice.

This is why you got the award. I mean, call the call the trophy factory. It's time to give you another one.

Yeah.

Um,

RUL, have you finished your panicking yet? Are we excited to talk about Jump Masters?

Yeah, I'm going to continue to panic, Chris. But yeah, let's talk about uh Jump Masters from our sponsor, Chip Theory Games. Um, hold just a second here, folks. Get ready to

I can kind of I can kind of Yeah, you you you press play whenever you want and cut me off, but I've played Jump Masters and it's really fun. Okay.

I have It is really, really good. It is kind of like uh uh Chinese checkers.

Yes.

Where you're trying to get from one side of the board to the other before your opponent.

Are Are you ready to play it?

I am ready. Thank you. Hold that thought. We're going to go come right back to you, Bons. I appreciate that. Thank you. Um here we go. Yes, I am pressing the button right now to go over here. Jump Masters. Engage in an epic battle with customizable terrain and fight with powerful jump masters. Take turns drafting your perfect team and deploy their dice to the starting zone. In this head-to-head battle, only one question remains. Are you ready to jump? Engage in fast-paced back and forth action. Jump over your allies to energize and over your opponents to defeat them. Claim points and fight for the hill. Utilize your jump master's unique abilities to dominate the battlefield. And above all, shump masters on game found.

Okay. Yeah, friends, I am so excited about that. Uh, we are sponsored by Chip 30 games and you know if you've played Chip 30 games before, you know they're the highest quality components and um I'm we saw the video. I'm looking forward to actually holding those pieces, those dice. I know they're going to be nice and chunky and I'm sure there's going to be, you know, playmat involved and everything else. Um, Bons, you were just talking about you've actually played the game.

Yes. Yes. And it is really good. You can even play the same characters, but uh you have like a selection of characters you're going to choose and their dice have special powers and different like movement abilities. And on your turn, you can activate those abilities and try to get to the opposite side of the board as quickly as possible. And you can also like blast your opponent's dice out of there. So, it's just a race and it's really well done. I think uh Manny did a great job.

Yeah. Um, I love the fact that he's taking Chinese checkers, right, a classic game, and making it modernized. Um, he did that with Fight Five, uh, another game that if, uh, from Chip theory where Fight Five was basically the card game War, but re-implemented as like a modern, uh, board, uh, like a tactile game. Really, really fun uh, stuff. And yeah, Manny Tremble, I mean, great artist as well. Uh, be beautiful presentation. Uh, Chris, any thoughts before we get moving along here? Yeah, I think what Chip Theory does is really really extraordinary just in general in terms of their production quality. Um, I I think it's going to be a great production. I I love their usage of components in unique ways and this seems cool. I I you know, I I played Chinese checkers growing up and then I was done with it. Uh, and so it's very exciting to see like, oh, maybe this is a version to take those mechanisms like you were saying and have it be be revitalized and with Manny Treble's art is just faking always fantastic like Yeah. So, it's exciting. It's exciting to to see that collaboration continue for sure.

Agreed. Agreed. Uh, by the way, I did want to get this comment on screen here. Bons is the number one board game streamer around. Uh, thank you. Hello, my name is 11. We will continue to heap the praise on uh Bonds. But but before before we get going,

all the board gaming saying it.

Yeah, we've been all saying that she has the trophy to prove it. Um we're going to be talking about the top 12 most disappointing games of 2025, folks. And this one's always tough because there's so many games out there. Which ones do you classify as disappointing? Which ones are hits? etc., etc. Um why don't we talk a little bit about our process behind um you know, how we came up with our lists here. As always, we'll start with Chris. He always has wonderful thoughts on how we do this. Uh Chris, take it away.

Well, it was it was a tough one for for me and and I'm interested to hear hear how you did the list because as always, you know, if it's we're doing a yearly thing, the easiest thing is to go to Board Game Geek and sort by year and just scroll through. And for me, I just kind of had to keep scrolling. Like there were a lot of I was like, "Oh, played that. Oh, I I kind of like that. Okay, well, I kind of like that one, too." and and just as we went through and and scrolling and seeing all the different ones, that's um I I was it was hard for me to come up with this list and and that that makes me excited in a way. Uh but yeah, and then I picked the ones where my my first one that I'm going to talk about I actually enjoyed but my friends vehemently hated it.

So, uh I I thought that was going to be an interesting one to talk about in terms of justosition um and terms of expectation and whatever. And then and then later on it's just the ones that like I wanted more of, you know, I had a different expectation um and and it didn't hit those expectations or I wanted something different as well. And I think these it's an important list to talk about as well because that's what we're here for, right? Like we want to get the best board games into the people's hands who will enjoy them. And it's not necessarily that these games are irredeemable, although um yes, they are. And mine will never be redeemed. And I'll take that firm stance for the sake of comedy, but um yeah, I I think it's uh it's easier to uh to then classify what are the reasons why we didn't like it, why didn't it hit, and by doing that, you know, we can guide people towards games that they'll actually really enjoy.

Nice. Awesome. What about you, Buns? any thoughts on or you want to share any thoughts that you had about putting together your list of the disappointing games here?

Yeah, it was it was really difficult for me because I hate being negative when it comes to board games. You know, I just think about the whole team and the whole process that everyone has to go through to make it and like the stress of having to like get enough money to make it and like this game is putting food on people's tables. So, it's really like hard for me to be negative and be like kind of sucks and then just like walk away.

So, it's not really something that I ever do. Um, I actually said yes to RULE for today's show before I actually read what the topic was because I just like doing stuff for Rell. And then when I read this when I read the theme, I was like, why did I say yes to this? Like, I shouldn't say yes to this. But here I am. So,

Gotcha.

Your biggest disappointment is Relle. Yeah, I've read that.

Well, so the games that I'm going to be talking about today, like they're so bad that like I had to like push past my ethical and spiritual belief of trying to be positive when it comes to board games that these are so low to the ground for me that you know it's really bad. Like it's really bad.

Oh, I can't wait to hear. Yeah, I went I'm the same way, Bonds. I'm I try not to be negative and we've talked about this before when we've done this list. This isn't necessarily we hate these games or they should never be, you know, played by anyone. No, these just these were games that weren't for us and they somehow disappoint us in some certain aspects. So, uh these are our uh takes and um we'll also have Richard joining via video uh with his takes and I we all know Richard has plenty to say. So, why don't we jump into our top 12 most disappointing games of 2025? And if you're watching, please be sure to drop comments. Let us know what your games were that you were disappointed by, and we'll talk about those as we go. Here, we are recording this live here on Twitch. And for those watching on YouTube, thank you again for hanging out with us. And Chris, do you want to take things uh uh kick things off with number 12?

Yeah, I do. Uh but before we begin, I'm just going to jump out and jump back in because I think I have a bit of a delay. I think I've been jumping on your uh your sentences a bit real well. So, I'm just going to do a little quick reset. Uh and then we can and then we can start. So, I'll be back. Don't worry. Don't worry, chat. Don't miss me too much. Don't miss me. I'll be right back. I'll be right back. Everybody hold your breath. Hold your breath and I'll be back.

Okay. I'll make a disclaimer, too, Rel. Yeah. While while he's reconnecting. So, I was able to talk to a designer one time and after I talked with them and realized like they're a really cool human being. I played their game again and actually enjoyed it more because I had that like relationship.

And so that's like another disclaimer is like after, you know, meeting the person behind a game, it can actually like change a mind about it.

Oh, that's I totally get that. It's you're like actually knowing someone that's created this or a game or whatever piece of music or art or whatever,

it definitely like colors your perception of it, right? Um so that's something to take into consideration, right? So

I think that's that that's also like I try to be I I find I I am almost the I try to be the opposite just because I know that it I that can have that effect. I I'm thinking specifically for my neighbor and not friend, Yuvall. Um, who I refer to only as my neighbor and not friend because it's designed a game that I really like. And so like I I I it's it's it is there is that sort of inherent inherent bias, right? Like or or or or shifting when you know the process like there there's also games where like I've been involved in the play testing and I've been like I don't like that improve it and it's changed. So then like naturally you're going to be you know more excited in in in that aspect too.

Yeah. because you you made that change, Chris. So, now you're excited about it in a different way, right? So,

it's like, of course, of course I'm excited. I didn't like the thing and they changed the thing I didn't like. That's perfect. I wish all games could be like that, right?

Um

nice. Okay. Well, it seems like we're we're back on the same page here. Why don't we jump right into See what I did there? Jump master. Let's jump into the list here.

I see what you did. My my my number one non-disappointment is Ruel Caviola's tie-ins. That's my

Oh my god, where was that going?

Um, okay. I'm excited to talk about number 12. Number 12 is a game that I actually enjoyed, but my friends who I played it with absolutely hated it, and that was Great Western Trail El Paso. Um, and so I put this on the list because I I I think this is such an interesting game from the perspective of there's already three Great Western Trails, right? We have Great Western Trail, Great Western Trail Argentina, and we have Great Western Trail New Zealand, which is absolutely the best of the bunch. It's my number four game of all time. I freaking love [clears throat] it. Oh my goodness, I just want to eat it up and and play it right now. Um, but so so getting Great Western Trail El Paso was interesting to me because they're being they're putting this forward as kind of a introductory Great Western Trail, right? Like this is a concept. It is a paired down version.

It is everything I want in board gaming, which is like cheap components. um as cheap as you can get. Get it to the get it to the consumer's hands so that they pay the least amount of money for the mechanisms. I love that because I am cheap and poor uh and and can't afford a million games all the time. And so because of that, I was very very excited about Great Western Trail Apaso. And I think it does kind of do what it sets out to do in that it gives the same feeling as Great Western Trail but smaller and cheaper and less robust and but still managing to in a 60-minute package. It's sort of Great Western Trail in 60 minutes. You still want to skip a bunch of actions because it's not optimal for you to visit all the actions even though you the the the dopamine hits in me want to go along and hit every single action. I'm like, "Oh, okay, great. I'm hitting this one building and I'm trying to run around the whole thing as quickly as possible.

And that is sort of the core essence of Great Western Trail. Uh, and they've done a lot of of interesting things with Great Western Trail Aposo 2 in terms of the workers. They go as cards in your deck and you can play them as like one-time bonuses or you can save them up for a different use. There's a lot of interesting things. So, I was I was very excited to play this with people who had never played Great Western Trail before. So, I was on a contract um at a theater contract and I was playing with uh two of my friends, Pat and Matt, who uh are are big board gamers, right? They're they're no slouches when it comes to board gaming. Uh and they played this and they're like, "Okay, yeah, no. Well, maybe we need to play it again." We played it again, you know? Uh and then when we ranked all the games we played in the summer, it became bottom of their list for both of them. They both despised the game. And I was like, "Why do you hate the game?" And I think like I think you do lose something in Great Western Trail El Paso because you're pairing it down so much that like only the core efficiency loop remains. And if you don't gel with that like one idea of oh I want to get one action and do that action uh until the game is over then you will hate it. Like you you're you're and that's what they like hated. I like that aspect of Great Western Trail. I think it's really interesting, but like in terms of optimization, what do what do you get from El Paso that you don't get in OG Great Western Trail? Nothing.

Like there's there's there's nothing there. It's it's not bringing anything huge to the table. I would much rather play New Zealand. It gives me like that smaller hit, but I think it also

you don't get the payoff of it because you don't go on kind of this grand journey. you you you have less spaces to hit. You have less buildings to interact with. There are like less strategies. Great Western Trail has basically three strategies. You go you go builders, you go cowboys, you go engineers, right? You pick one of the workers, you optimize, and you go. Uh, a and so distilling that down, while I think it does accurately distill the game down, I don't know if it like benefits the system, which is a really interesting um, experience to have because I I think like the system is benefited potentially more by having that fuller experience by having the potential, right? the the maybe there's a possibility of doing something different whereas in El Paso it's just like crank it around and it was the like it was all of our first time playing that version like I hadn't played it before either but having come from like a decent Great Western Trail background I I'm pretty familiar with it because it's in the World Series of Board Gaming and I've gotten to commentate on it.

I've got to see it being played a bunch and so I've had to get uh to a decent uh proficiency with it. Um it it yeah it it kind of I I don't know it it I I was able to I was able to see that optimization route and that's why they wanted to play again because then they saw the optimization but even after seeing seeing the key and seeing the puzzle they're like oh that's the way to win. We don't really like the way to win because you kind of just have to run around. And I think the the downfalls of Great Western Trail that I think New Zealand fixes and kind of opens the game up are more downfall in El Paso because you have to streamline to it because it is distilling that essence. If you really don't like that essence, it's not going to be a good experience. and like the main game might give you more because at least there's more possibilities there or what what feel like possibilities even if like strategically and optimally they're not right. So that's that's kind of why I put on this list cuz I think it's it's was such a like such a confusing idea to me. Such a such a dis a mishmash and and I was so shocked by how vehemently they hated it as well. Um even though like I liked it because I like OG Great Western Trail as well because I like the that system.

So, your friends, you had said they are uh like hardcore gamers, right? Or veteran gamers. So,

yeah, they're no slouches, right?

Yeah.

So, this is actually something we're going to bring uh I'm going to bring come back to this uh because I know what games are on this list and there's one Bonds that um I I have uh um comments about, but that whole just the concept uh or the idea of who is this game marketed to? Is this something for veteran gamers or is this something for newer gamers or someone who's sort of in between? Like, hey, I play games. I've heard of Gres Western Trail. Let me try this version is see if I like it and is it geared towards that audience? Like what audience are we looking at? And then is it disappointing in the fact like as from a veteran gamer, oh, I wanted more or as a new gamer, I loved it because hey, this looks this is something I've never tried before. I want to experience more of it. Right? So maybe that's something to think about as far as, you know, audience expectation or, you know, why why we're disappointed with some of these games.

Yeah. Yeah. I think that's that's exactly it, right? And that's and that's why I wanted to put on this list because I was like, oh, I can separate myself and my own feelings versus like it could really not hit with people. Um, but I think it does it does exactly what it tries to do, which is distill Great Western Trail down. It's just by doing that it takes the it takes that core race loop efficiency and like for a lot of people that's not going to be fun.

Yeah. Yeah. It almost feels like uh because I I've played it and it does feel like if you know if you're familiar with modern games it feels like just almost like a rolling move. You're just like you know going around in a circle doing the things. Yeah. But I ultimately enjoyed it Chris. I I like it for what it was. Um, yeah, I actually thought like it might have been I think it it would hit better with veteran gamers if it was like a little shorter. I felt like for what it was, it it it was about an hour. I think it when I

Yeah,

but if something like if it was like 30 minutes, I think it'd be on point. But anyways, we've rambled on enough. Uh, Bonds, any thoughts on your end about Great Western Trail El Paso or just anything in general about this type of game?

Well, you mentioned another Great Western Trail game that you really liked. It was your favorite. Which one was it?

New Zealand.

New Zealand.

New Zealand. Okay. So, I've only played

The Great Western Trail first edition. And I really love it. And I haven't played any of the other games. So, I'll have to check out New Zealand. Oh, yeah.

Because for me, it was like, why would why do I want to buy more? I already like Great Western Trail. So, that's that's cool to know. Like, I'll I'll check out New Zealand.

I Yeah, I I'll plug New Zealand any day. I freaking love it. If you like the core Great Western Trail, for me it it fixed it fixed it in in like

it didn't feel like you had to do that specification. I think the one thing that kind of bums me about Great Western Trail is that strategically you got to go builders, you got to do this, you got to you got to just pick one lane and I felt in New Zealand it it opens that up a bit more that it gives you more possibilities to dabble in a little here, a little here, a little here. And for for me that just like Yeah. And and they added in cards too to make it more of a deck builder that like when they get into your hand, you play it and you get a bonus and you draw a new card.

And so like you're filling them with like little mini bonuses as you cycle through your deck. Oh, now you're just getting income as you're going through or whatever. So it's Yeah. Oh yeah. Yeah. Definitely try New Zealand. I haven't played Argentina. Um I think Royal's played Argentina.

Uh no, I have Argentina, but I haven't

Oh, you have Argentina? Oh, we were going to play Argentina at Dicear West and then we never did. That's what it was. That's my That's my honorable mention. Disappointment.

Yeah, we have a point.

This whole video is how we're disappointed in various ways. Like, are you gonna sucker that in?

You know what? I like this as a theme and we're going to keep it keep it going.

Oh, man. Well, let's keep the disappointment going with our number 11. That's going to be my uh game. Uh, this one, um, I got at Gen Con last year and I had never heard of this game, but then when I saw the box and I I checked it out, I was like, "Oh, this seems really cool." But unfortunately, it just didn't live up to the hype. Um, this is a game called Terrible Quest. Now, terrible being T A R A B L E as in tearing stuff up because in this game, you are literally tearing your score sheet up. Um, this is a mix of a dungeon crawl and um, a tearing game. I I don't know how else to describe it.

Oh, it's a Terran, right?

Teran, right? Yeah,

a Terran move.

It is a Terran, right? Um, you have it's a real-time game, so you're going to have a a timer. You have different goals. So, each dungeon that you go into, you have different goals, and you set the timer and you go. And what you're trying to do is tear off either the monsters or the weapons that you'll need to fight the monsters. And you do that within a specific amount of time. As you can see there, I think that's a ghost. Um, and you tear those off and hopefully you'll tear off enough to score the most points. What's really interesting is on the back side of that sheet there are little uh gold chests that represent your loot. So, if you happen to tear that off, yay, you get some points. Now, really fun concept and I did have fun with it for the first the my first play, but after that it just didn't stick with me. I I thought it'd be a lot um I don't know, I just thought it'd have a lot more legs. Um, there's a game that sort of reminds me of this called Clip Cut Parks from Renegade Game Studios that came out years ago and you literally, it was a cut and write where you would use scissors. Yes, they gave you scissors for the game and you'd cut little pieces out trying to match um these like polyominos style uh scoring conditions. This one you have to tear.

And here's what was really tough, a lot tougher than I expected. You have to be precise in this game because one little tear that if you don't tear off the exact thing you need, you don't score any points or you don't get the weapon that'll kill the the monster.

And of course, you do a couple of things and by the end of it, you have a big boss monster to go. Hopefully, you have stuff left on your sheet because if if it's off your main sheet, you don't get to use it. Um, I liked it. I just didn't love it. And I was disappointed. I mean, it was And here's the thing. I had fun with this. I'm not going to lie. I enjoyed it the first time I played it. I'd played a second time, third time, and each time it just progressively, not did it did get worse, but it just like, okay, the novelties like worn off. So, I was disappointed it didn't stay because I still have clip cup parks. I still bust that out on occasion, had the little scissors, do the little puzzle, and I feel like this didn't have enough of a puzzle to it to me. I mean, you you see exactly what you're trying to do. you tear it off, but if you're not precise, and it's way harder than you think because those little um symbols are like right next to each other. If you're not precise, it's not going to count. So, obviously, if you have like dexterity issues, this game is definitely not for you. Um but cool concept, just it didn't really stick around for me. And that's why it's our number 11 on our list of disappointing games. Number 11, Terrible Quest.

I see Cosmic Beat says, "I bought this off Bonds."

Oh. Bonds, did you play this? Did you How did What are your thoughts on this, Bonds?

I played one sheet of it for Board Games Anonymous on my channel and it was I I don't think I'm patient enough for it. So,

but someone in my chat was saying that they have it with their kids and they play with their kids and they really enjoy it and it's like [clears throat] perfect for them.

So, I think that this game is for someone, but it just wasn't for me. And so after one she I just I I sold it. So

yeah I I that's I think that's the best way um to to put it right. It's not for everyone obviously and if you have younger gamers I think it is a great game because I mean when I was young I love to tear up stuff. So this is like the perfect game for young well you know.

Yeah that was your that was your favorite pastime just tearing things up.

Just tearing things up. This game was meant for me. If if I could travel back in time Chris this is my game right here. Terrible quest.

Yeah. If I know one thing about young Rouel, it's when he it's when he was younger, he just loved to tear things. He just loved it.

That's right. Okay. Uh let's move on to number 10. And we're going to turn it over to our guest, Bonds, today for our number 10 list on most disappointing games.

My number 10 is called Pediquette. This game is published by Oink Games, and the art is absolutely beautiful, and I was really excited to try it out. I was actually touring different breweries in Southern California and there are board game vending machines that you can buy board games from. So, I was with the owner of the vending machines and he was like, "Pick any game you want out of the entire machine." And I was so excited because I love Oink games. They're kind of expensive and I love the art on this box. And so I chose out of the entire vending machine out of all the games I could have selected, I chose this one with high hopes that it would make my trip worth it. It would make my gas money worth it. We pull out the game.

The rules are confusing because it's based off of feelings.

I'm not joking.

You have to line up the numbers and then guess the the colors and try to match it all based off of the feelings. And I was I was like, "No, I already have enough emotions that I have to deal with. I don't want to implement this into a board game. I want to drink I want to drink my beer. I want to eat my food." Okay. On top of that, the card quality and the and the components of the game felt really cheap, especially for an oink game. I was very disappointed.

It felt like it was going to rip. I love Scout. It's one of my favorite board game or car games of all time and I was expecting the same quality and it just didn't have this. I am sad for Oink games because this is a waste of art that's really good art on a on a game that just doesn't live up to the art. We tried to read through the rules. We tried to play it

through out the game. I was getting more and more angry and I reached over to grab the rules and I spilled my beer. my precious glass of beer across the table and completely drenched pediat in in alcohol. And because the qualities were so cheap, they immediately disintegrated and we threw the game away. And I don't want to play this game ever again.

Oh no.

It sounds like if young Roull was there, he would have torn it up.

I would have to

He would have torn it.

That That is such a bummer because we all know Oink games. I love Oint games as well. one of my favorite publishers. And that's so disappointing to hear that the components were bad. I mean, the game obviously was no, you know, didn't live up to the hype because I I remember hearing about this and I was like, "Okay, this looks cool. Really nice art, but I can't believe that they went like with cheaper components." That's really surprising to me.

Let me read this sentence from BG. Each player secretly chooses the card they think would most properly fit into that pattern on the table. For example, if the sequence is red, red, yellow, you might feel that yellow should come next. If it's dog, cat, bird, then maybe dog feels right. But what about dog, cat, dog, cat, bird? No single answer is correct, but if someone chooses the same card as you, they both earn points. I'm sorry. Are we trying to play like apples to apples, BUT WITH OUR FEELINGS? I DON'T WANT THIS.

I hate I hate that. That That makes me angrier than anything that's ever happened to me in my life.

Thank you. That's that's no game. The reason we play games is for the rules. For the rules. Damn it.

Not the feelings.

There's one there's one core thing THAT UNIFIES US ALL AND WE FOLLOW THE RULE BOOK and you're telling me it doesn't matter.

Oh my god.

Yeah. Wow.

I'm sorry you went through this experience, Bonds.

Yeah. And we are playing two player. And I don't think this game should ever be two-player because it'd be like it'd be like you, me be like, I feel like it's yellow. And you're like, well, I feel like it's red. I I guess we're not I guess we're not getting points. Next turn.

Oops. THIS GAME IS $30.

WOW. WOW.

That That is definitely a disappointment, Bonds. Wow. What a bummer. What a bummer.

But hey, why don't we turn it over to Richard now to see what he's been disappointed by. Uh Richard, take it away with our number nine. All right, the most painful list of the year, but we got to do it. And Bons, I'm so glad to have you here. I'm a big fan. I love it whenever you appear on Roell's monthly uh tabletop recall. Uh so it's wonderful that you could join us today. And let's see, what have you folks talked about so far? Chris, I see we're starting the year off with a bang. I am sorry. You are wrong. Great Western Trail El Paso is lovely. It is wonderful. one, there's no reason to play any of the Great Western Trails when you could be playing Marra Kibbo, which is, as far as I'm concerned, superior to that entire series. And so therefore, um, El Paso does actually have a real value of getting that great uh, GWT/ Maracivo feel in like under an hour, more like, you know, 30 or 40 minutes.

Uh, it really has great vibes and also it will always be superior to the other great western trails because it took out the needless player screwage where I could figure out, oh, where's your train to go? Oh, if you want to go that way, you got to pay me taxes to go past my house. I've always hated that in Great Western Trail. I am so glad El Paso finally got rid of it. And as far as I'm concerned, it is the best of the series. So, you're wrong. All righty. Royal. Terrible quest. Oh. Uh, going after all play. Wow, we're hitting some big hitters. First, lookout games and then All Play and Well, I actually watched your video of Terrible Quest. It looked really charming. Um, granted, not my kind of game, but it's still it looked really sweet. So, looking forward to hearing you tear it apart, I suppose.

And then, oh, Bonds Pediquette. Oh my gosh, you're going after Oink games. They can't be touched. They're critical darlings, and it looks so adorable. I have not played it. So again, looking forward to hearing why uh this didn't work for you. But anyway, all right. So that was what 12, 11, and 10. So let's talk about our number nine, Unstoppable. Well, you sold me on this game. You did a great runthrough of it and so much so you did it solo. I did a solo run through on my channel as well for backers of the show along with Ham Heling. I did that back in December. And granted, this is a great solo game. It is absolutely phenomenal. Um, but here's why it disappointed the heck out of me.

It is I was about to say it's a terrible two-player game. It's not. It is barely adequate. Uh, and there's no reason for that. For folks who don't know what it is, um this is a deck building game where your deck that you're trying to build is literally trying to kill you. And you know that's the highle elevator pitch. And it's awesome. All your cards are two-sided. When you draw a card from your deck, they come out with the evil side face up. and you have to defeat your own cards so that you could then take them into your hand, flip them over, and they become a valuable thing that you can use to fight more of your deck or the big boss you're trying to beat. So clever. And then John Declair shows once again he was the creator and the master of card crafting as well. So there is a lot of really wonderful stuff here if you play it as solo. I'm disappointed because with the tiniest bit more work, um, you know, John and Renegade could have made this a great co-op as well. But the way co-op is implemented is, oh, basically I'm playing the solo game, and right next to me on the table, you're playing the solo game as well. I'm fighting my deck, you're fighting your deck, and the boss has twice as many hit points. And that's it. They really didn't do anything.

There's one thing that they did when uh you know after the new cards come out and we have to realize we have to fight our own cards so we can claim them into our hand and use them. You know the the whole crux of the game. Um in addition to me fighting the bad guys in front of me, I can fight the bad guys in front of you. And that's okay because you know sometimes I'm going to be in a better position to destroy yours or you can destroy mine. That's the tiniest bit of cooperation. But I don't understand why ca why can't I use my healing cards and heal you or well why can't I have my excess actions because hey this time I got too many action points I can't use them all. Why can't I give you my access? There are so many ways that you and I could collaborate and all of them are left out. It is a heartbreaker I have to say and I just don't know why.

Um, if we were able to do more of these overlaps between each other in addition to being able to fight e, you know, that I think would have elevated this game and I just don't see isn't the case. In 2026, there is a sequel to Unstoppable coming based on a very popular series of fantasy novels, um, Dungeon Crawler Carl. I've never read any of these books, but apparently they're excellent satires of social media culture and whatnot. And then they're also really fun adventurers. And so uh this is the first time Dungeon Crawler Carl is being turned into a uh you know a big board game. So I'm excited to be exposed to this uh world because apparently it's great. Maybe I'll read some of the books afterwards.

But also what I'm really hoping is with their second bite at the apple that Jon and Renegade will do the extra work to make the co-op game live up to the solo game. And so maybe Dungeon Crawler Carl will be in my top 10 of 2026. But uh for 2025, Unstoppable was a huge disappoint unfortunately. And it comes in at our number nine. Okay.

Okay, Richard. I loved Unstoppable, but I can see why [clears throat] it would be disappointing if you're playing at two players. Um, I totally forgot you could play it two players or it was always in my mind a solo game and I love the solo experience. It's a rogike game. You were, you know, building. Richard put it the best way possible. You're doing a deck builder, but it's trying to kill you at the same time because there's baddies on the other sides. But I love this. I love everything about this. I I think it's one of the best card crafting games out there, one of John Declair's um best games out there. Uh, but again, I I guess I can see why it'd be disappointing as a two-player game. I wouldn't want to play it two players, honestly. But, um, Chris Bonds, any thoughts on this? Have you all played um, Unstoppable?

I haven't yet.

Okay.

Yeah, I haven't either, but I was just looking at our comments. Sean up top was saying Unstoppable was good, but lacks enough to beat some other games like Star Trek Captain's Chair. Um,

Oh, okay.

as well in terms of just like it it being fine. But like fine is fine, right?

Yeah. Uh now Star Trek's Captain Share, that's a lot deeper game. Uh so this is this wasn't trying to be, you know, a David Turchie game. This is a uh you know, a little more accessible and I think they really did the card crafting uh in a great way here. But yeah, again, different uh styles of games, different audiences. Um I think Unstoppable would probably be a more approachable game. Star Trek's Captain Chair, I [clears throat] still have a headache on learning that game. Um, but it was terrific, but I have not gone back to that one, whereas I have gone back to Unstoppable quite a few times. So, um, yeah. All right, Richard, thank you for that. Uh, we're going to continue with our most disappointing games here. And Chris has got our number eight.

Richard didn't know me as well. I was in the background shouting, "You don't know me. You You don't even know what I said about Great Western. Richard, egg all over your face." And also Sean agrees with me that New Zealand's better than Mariva, although I haven't played Mariva, but New Zealand still.

Okay, nice.

Um, anyway, my number eight is a game I truly revile. Um, a a game that should be thrown into the fires of Mount Doom. Uh, a game that uh has the worst title in all of board gaming history. And that's because you can't search it on BG because they don't have a spell check or did you mean this feature even though really BGG should. Uh and this is why this is the Lord of the Rings, the Fellowship of the Rings tricktaking game.

Love the long title.

I mean, come on. Stop it. Just stop it. And you know what? And because now there's the Lord of the Rings two towers tricktaking game. Okay, we get it. We now it's a theme. Now it's a system. I the the the crew mount doom is what this is. Um but it's as if somebody played the crew and was like, "Oh yeah, the crew is fun, but what if we did less scenarios and made it less interesting and made it less relevant?" Should we do that? And let's put that out after the crew's already done it. That'll be good. Oh, but we'll make the card shiny and nobody will know. Nobody will notice because the card art is great and it's shiny cards and everybody loves shiny cards, right? Great. Now enjoy um half of the scenarios being the most basic and boring things you've ever played in tricktaking game history. Uh that are basically the intro version of the crew and it's not going to get harder from there. Um it's that's how I feel about you. The Lord of the Rings, the Fellowship of the Ring tricktaking game. Not even the trick taking. Oh, the the title makes me so mad. Um th this one like it's just it's just fine. And I and it's offensive to me how fine it is. It's a it's a porridge sandwich slapped upon a a lombus bread, you know?

It's it's just like gh why. Well, and every time I think there's going to be a new mechanism that's interesting, it's just it's just so so boring. every every single scenario is boring. And uh I just had a a very average time with it. And because of that, like I think I think it is tough. I think it's tough when you're when you're when you're taking a thing and you're like, I'm going to do what the crew does. You'd think you would be interested in doing it better. Um but they decided to go the opposite way and make it um more boring. Uh so yeah, that that's all I have to say about the crew. I thought it was fine. It wasn't It wasn't even It wasn't even bad. It wasn't even bad. It was just like, "Oh, okay. I've played any trick-taking game before. Great. I know every single strategy. The rings are Trump. You Froto always has to win the one ring. Sure. Just get better scenarios." And maybe they will in the two towers, but I'm certainly not going to try to find out because I I don't bet that they will. I think it'll be just the same. Um,

you know, I I was googling while you were ranting and when you Google Lord of the Rings trick game, it Board Game Geek titles it the Fellowship of the Ring dash tricktaking game, but then when you click on it, it says the Lord of the Rings colon the Fellowship of the Ring-trick taking game. So yeah, he can't.

Yeah. And even if you search Lord of the Rings and you're trying to search Lord of the Rings and like I tried to find it on BG for so long just it's oh it's everything about it is makes me mad.

Well, have you ever tried to search for the game? The game the card game the game that's near impossible. It is ridiculously impossible to find that on BG. But I actually I like this game a lot. And so here's my thing, Chris. I feel like because I didn't go through the entire crew, the entire I I did maybe a dozen scenarios and I really enjoyed the crew

and I did the same thing for The Lord of the Rings. I did about maybe six scenarios and I really enjoyed it. But

because I didn't dive as deep, maybe I would have seen the same things you did where the game was did not seem as difficult as the crew, but the art was definitely better and I feel like the theme was really woven into it. I thought it was great. Um, but

the art's great. production quality is great.

Yeah.

But I just like I love the cards. I mean, I do love the shiny and that's what makes me so mad is I'm just like, man, why aren't you good?

Like, why can't I play this more than one time

now?

And and enjoy myself.

Now, are you a Lord of the Rings fan? Are you one of the

Yeah. Okay. So, is that

I owned the Sylmerelion.

Oh,

I didn't read it. I didn't say didn't read it. No.

Read that?

I don't think so. It's an encyclopedia, but I owned it and that I think counts for something.

It does. Just like I own Great Western Trail Argentina. That counts for something.

Exactly. Yeah. Perfect.

But Okay. So, do you feel like your negative reaction to this is more because you're a Lord of the Rings fan or is it just okay as a Trick Taker it just doesn't work?

I think it's both. I think like I I want it to be a good Lord of the Rings game and there are great Lord of the Rings games that are out there um that people have been talking about. But I yeah I think I was just like excited for the production quality and I was excited for board gaming nowadays. You should do something different. If you're going to do the exact same game, like people do the exact same game and then they tweak one little thing and it makes for such delightful delights. Yeah. Uh and redundant redundancies. Um, but uh, yeah, it it just it just didn't do anything that was unique. And and so when you're not doing anything that's unique and there's a game that already exists that's better, then I go, why why are you here? What were you made for? Cue Billy Isish.

Yeah, I I've actually uh I played a little bit of The Crew and I didn't really like it. Um, I don't really like co-op games and when I played the Lord of the Rings trick game or however the correct title is, I did enjoy it because I knew something about Lord of the Rings and so that's what pulled me into it and I like the stained glass look,

but it was also funny because I was playing with two two me strangers. It was at Dice Tower Cruise and they started getting into a fight with each other over the game and I thought it was so entertaining. So like my memories of it is kind of entertaining actually because these two strangers I was playing with got into a fight.

Yeah.

What were over over Lord of the Rings lore or the game itself?

Yeah,

it was kind of both. Like you know you got these two nerds here who's playing with this chick that they don't know and they just like started like I don't know. I I don't remember fully but I think it had to do with like if you would have played that card then this would have happened and now we have to start over. And I was like yes co-op games. Nice, nice, nice. I Yeah. So, well, hopefully Two Towers uh redeems itself. We will see. You know, one game that I really enjoyed for as far as Lord of the Rings is concerned, the uh the Pandemic one. What is it? The Fellowship of the Rings.

Fate of the Fellowship.

Like that one or Yeah, Fate of the Fellowship. That one was like really good. Um has nothing to do with tricking, but it is a Lord of the Rings game, folks. If you're looking for one that uh Chris will not rip apart, maybe that's the one for you.

Maybe it is. Maybe it is. [clears throat]

Cool. All right, Chris, thank you so much for that. Uh we're going to move right along uh to our number seven, which is mine. Uh this one I was really looking forward to and it just didn't live up to the hype. Straight up. It was number seven, Azul Duel. Or if your name is Ruel, you would call it Azul Duell. Um this one is it's

I'm going to call it that for now on. And I'm very sorry. I'm so mad at myself. My biggest disappointment of 2026 is that I didn't come up with that. I'm so upset right now.

The Azul do well for well. Um it takes the the basics of Azul. You're drafting tiles and you're laying them on your player board, right? What I I I love, again, I love the concept of this, the idea of a zool duel where you're drafting these tiles, but now instead of placing them directly on your player board, well, you do place them there. What you're doing is there are extra tiles, the 2 by two tiles, which you will draft as well and place those. And those will determine where you can place those tiles. And it's super puzzly uh way more puzzly than the original. And then you also have uh these endame goals. So the different each game will have different endame goals. And when you draft, you take a tile of the same color and instead of pushing all the leftover tiles in the middle, now you're putting them on the on the different factories or the coasters basically, and you're going to stack them up in certain ways. And if you want to take ones off the stack, you will take the similar color. It's it's very similar in concept to the original. But as you can see as I'm sitting here wa re-watching this video and remembering my time played with this, it just made everything so fiddly and just it took away what I think what makes the original Azul so great. It's puzzly yet it's streamline.

It's elegant. I mean the it's the the epitome of elegance I think is the original Azul. This one went the opposite way. like let's just throw a bunch of different me mechanics here and yes it's a a much deeper experience but that doesn't make it better. I think it just over complicates things and I just I don't know it it just wasn't ultimately for me. I played it I played I think three times uh twice in real life, once on BGA and digital implementation's uh great. You could play it faster, but I just overall it just did not it totally fell flat with me. And I know a lot of people liked it. So I'm curious, Bonds andor Chris, like have you played it? And if so, am I wrong? Like is just was this a great game that I just didn't see or oh I don't know what what do y'all think?

Months have you played? So, this was actually also on my list.

Okay.

This is on my short list, too.

Okay. Okay. So, we're all the same boat.

Yeah. I I I am so sad. It truly is a disappointment for me because I love the tower that you put your used tokens in.

Yep.

I think that's really creative. I love the look of it. I love like the color palette. The artist did a great job.

Yeah.

I think I follow her on Instagram now. And I just love everything about this game. But every time I would take out an Azul game to play, it was always the original, even if it was two players. And I think that's y

where it's a true disappointment for me. I think that this game is almost there. They should make it a solitire game.

Yeah.

With with puzzle goals. And I think that would be like its own separate thing. Solo solitire puzzle game unrelated to Azul. I think that everything else about it is great and that's why it really was a disappointment for me because I really really wanted to like it.

Yeah.

Yeah. I I think it's it's an odd thing because most people will say to that Azul is best at two people at two players. I just played a four four player game of Zuul last night. It was great. Um but I think people really enjoy Azul any of the versions at two players. And so to just be like, well, no, no, no, no, no. This is the one for two players. It's just Azul the fifth, but they just decided to only make it playable at two players and then decided to put it forward. Like that was a good thing. It was kind of my feeling about it.

Yeah,

I also enjoyed it. It was fine. It was more Azul. Azul is a good system. I I I liked the idea of putting those pieces together and building your own board. I think building your own board, that was like my favorite part and that you you could take that as a turn. There's potentially different choices you can make on your turn to give you more variability. But like I like regular better. I like stained glass better. I like Queen's Garden better if you want to get I haven't played the summer pavilion, but I played the other three. A and for me it was just it was just more Azul and and it again had that question of why. Um, and there wasn't really a clear answer other than people like Azul, but do you want to get a fifth one? Uh, and and that just wasn't like a a good enough reason for existing for me.

I still have it. I still it's it's on the it's on the cull pile, I think,

but it's still here. Um,

yeah, it's just like I agree with with everything that both of you said. Uh it just it just felt why,

you know?

Yeah. I I I know part of my disappointment was uh the year before they came out with Splender Duel or Splender Duel and I liked that one a lot. I thought that game was solid. And Michelle and I, we played original Splender as a two-player game. Always enjoyed it. Same with original Azul. Always enjoyed it. But I felt like Splender Duel, it kept the spirit of Splender, but just added a few things, right? uh like as far as like how you draft the the gems and everything and made it a more compelling game. Whereas I think Azul uh duel just didn't do that for me. It just everything just it seemed like like Chris was saying, hey, here's here's another version of Azul, but it wasn't really compelling to me.

And there was a lot of hype.

Yeah, there was there was a ton of hype and it just did not live up to it.

Yeah. I think something interesting about the dual duels as a genre, right? like there are so many dual games um is that they often take games that are sometimes have less conflict and add more conflict or more more tugofwarss, right? Um is what is what I I find mechanically uh and and I don't like a tug-of-war mechanic in in my like that doesn't in terms of mechanisms that's not doesn't make top 100. Um, and so I think like I often I often bounce off uh duels for that for that reason. For this reason, I I liked the potential of adding in a bunch of different things to do on your turn to make like a zool is very simple. You have you just take take gems like that's it. Or CRA adds in a new mechanism that you have to like place it along in a certain pathway so you could reset. But I Yeah, it just it just felt like complication for complication's sake. Yep.

Uh and

didn't didn't kind of add it in. And yes, John Trip, I did say bounce off and that was on purpose. That is one game that would never disappoint me.

Oh, awesome. Great. Okay, so there it is. Number seven, Zu Duel. Uh let's move on to our number six. And our guest Bonds has this one.

My number six most disappointing game of 2025 is Brick Like This. It is a Lego game. And uh Foglight in chat here. So Foglight and I actually played this game at Gen Con when it was released and I had a really good time. I don't know if Fog Light did, but like we we seemed to like love the game and I was so excited. I couldn't wait to bring this home and play this with everyone. We just had such a fun time. Well, I brought it to a party and I played it with a group of engineers and my teammate was also I think they're all engineers and um I felt like an idiot because they were able to solve these puzzles where you're basically taking bricks and one person is describing the pattern and the other person has to take the bricks but they don't know what pattern they're building and the first team to do it gets all the points.

And when you play with a bunch of engineers, they already know how to like communicate with structures. And they were solving these puzzles within seconds. It was actually very impressive. And I as a normal like nerd that doesn't have that was struggling so hard and it truly it was so like not fun for me. So I checked on BG layer. I was like, what is this? Like what's the target market here? It's a party game. and I was at a party and I was not having fun at all. And and I think it would be better as like a two like just you and the other person having fun solving some puzzles to like learn how to communicate with each other and that's it. Like this is not good with a ton of people even though it's marketed for a larger group.

And I think that it's also disappointing because it followed Monkey Palace, which was released in 2024. Yeah. From, you know, David Gordon did such a good job designing Mon and Tam did such a good job designing Monkey Palace that that is that was my expectations for Lego board games. Like they have set the bar high now. Like Lego board games didn't really used to be that appealing and now they finally are. And then Brick Like This came out the next year. I was so excited. Had a fun time with Foglight at Gen Con. brought it home and now I'm like so sad and I I it's it was another like huge disappointment for me.

Yeah. Uh Bons I I totally agree with you and I I totally see where you're coming from. Uh Monkey Palace did set the bar pretty high for Lego games. Like I think of that too. Like and when I played brick brick like this, I enjoyed it. It was I think it's one of those games you play with like random people at a convention. I think it's perfectly fine. It's a party type game. But yeah, if I had to play against engineers, like I would like lose interest within a second. I'm like, oh yeah, y'all sell this. Um, so that

they were so funny. They're like just another day at work. Like,

oh, but yeah, it's it's a lighter game. And I guess you just we talked about this earlier, just you got to find the right audience for this type of thing. And um apparently you ran into the imperfect audience for for brick like this.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, but I still love Legos. I'm I'm gonna get I love Legos and I want to see more Lego games just more along the lines of Monkey Palace rather than Brick Like this.

Uh Chris, do you like Legos?

I I mean, hey, you gotta You have to. Um some people like them so much they never open them. Uh uh uh this one kind of sounds like I I feel like there's a there's there's a common theme of the games that that burn brightly very quickly and then dissipate and it's it's they're often I don't know. I don't know. I'm I'm figuring this out out as I'm speaking it. So it might be completely wrong, but uh they're they're often like very gimmick- based, right? We're talking about the tearing. We're talking about the feelings one. We're talking about like the Lego one. I can think of all these like party games where I'm like, "Oh, yeah. I play it once." I'm like, "That's fun." And like, "Oh, I have a great time with it." And then you play it again and you're and you're like, "Oh, okay. I saw everything." Like you you do see everything in that in that first play.

And I think like a good party game um can can keep you coming back and can capture that lightning in a bottle every single time and and and engages people in an exciting way, but when it is so focused on that gimmick, uh it's harder to do that.

Yeah. Well said, Chris. Well said. Okay. I was figuring it out as I was speaking it.

You know what I was going to say?

Yeah, you you nailed it. All right, let's see what Richard's got in store with us for number five. Take it away, Richard.

All right. All right. All right. Continuing on, Chris, I'm getting whiplash here. Um because I agree. Lord of the Rings Fellowship was a disappointment. It was okay and certainly it was gorgeous in his presentation. Um you know, absolutely lovely and and I mean, I guess if you really love tricktakers, sure. But it is such a huge letdown after how phenomenal the crew is um that I I just I was kind of I mean I was just hoping for oh give me the crew said in Tolken universe and it would be amazing but it did not live up to that uh that high high bar and so yeah I also was a bit disappointed with that one and let's seeel Azul duel you know what I don't really like any of the Azoul actually that's not true the garden Azul Gardens or Gardens of Azul. Uh, whatever. That one was good, but that's the least Azul like of the entire series. So, yeah, I that was never one I was really going to chase after. And then Bonds brick like this. Yeah. You know what? I could not be disappointed by this because is there a good Lego uh inspired board game? I don't think there is. I I mean I don't know anything about this one, but I mean heck, if even Reiner Kenitia couldn't make a great game out of Legos, who has a chance of doing it anyway? All right, so let's now move on to number five.

Another huge um uh uh you know, heartbreaker for me. Vantage. Oh, I love Jamie Stagmire both as a designer and as a human being. Quite frankly, he is one of the best of us. And um I'm always excited for whatever he's going to do next. And while I did not get a chance to cover Vantage on the channel, you can see Shay stepped in because uh the timings didn't work out for me. Uh I was still excited to give it a go. Although granted, I did go in a bit nervous because I am never a fan of roll to resolve stuff. Although the interesting twist here is this big sci-fi explore a planet sandbox go wherever do whatever game uh does have dice skill checks which is but the interesting thing is you it's almost impossible to fail. You'll always uh you know achieve what you need to do and rolling the dice is just more a question of how much does it hurt you? How much does it tire you out? How much does it leave you broken and battered to do whatever the skill check was. And I thought okay well that'll be interesting. And you know, Shay did a pretty good job of doing it. I know he really liked it and so many people love this game. This made so many top tens of the year for 2025. So, why was I disappointed? Um, well, surprisingly, it wasn't the dice. I'm not a fan of the dice, but I knew about them going in.

What was really disappointing for me was the aimlessness of it. It was just such a big open world and you're just supposed to go and do and see and experience and it just didn't feel structured enough for me. Like you know the the the biggest example of you know something that just didn't really work well for me and Jen is occasionally you'll meet somebody on this alien planet and they'll have some alien problem and you'll offer an ali your solution for it and they'll say fine okay yeah you just need to go north and it's going to be up there to the north and like oh okay so you'd think that means okay but if I just go like you know I don't know two three four sectors which represent cards as you know the map of the world expands and whatnot as you travel around from place to place.

If you're, oh go, I just go north a little ways and I'll see it. And no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. To get to it, you have to go north four spaces and then east two spaces. You know what that means? You're probably never going to find that thing. And it just means you just find yourself wandering around aimlessly running into just kind of a random hodgepodge of events. And I mean, this is the ultimate, you know, it's uh the journey, not the destination. And I get it. A lot of people respond really strongly to this, but for both me and Jen, we felt like there needs we we want there to be kind of an invisible hand of the designer that we feel um you know kind of guiding us along so that we are getting kind of a you know an an actual sculpted adventure as opposed to a bunch of just random stuff that happens. And um we ultimately found it, you know, just kind of well disappointing because I I'm not that it isn't well done. It's certainly well put together. And again, I can't stress so many people really love this game. But it was a big miss for me and Jen. And again, coming from one of my favorite designers of all time. It was a bit disappointing. That is number five on our list, Vantage.

Well, I just got my copy of Vantage in, so I'm still looking forward to it even though it was disappointing. Richard, I have seen uh reviews and people talking on both sides, right? I know people some people really enjoyed it, others didn't. I'm going in this as strictly a solo player. I want to solo uh play this. And I saw Bons's comment here live is recording. Bon, you've played this solo, correct?

I have multiple times and I really enjoy it. It's a great solo game. I mean, he's right. There is like that sandbox feel, but you know that going into it and it's so much fun and and I'm just going to let you know right now, like if you want a game where you're not super stressed out, if you die, it's okay. Like I die a lot in that game, but I'm not super stressed about it.

Nice. Yeah. And that seems like the experience that I want with Vantage. So, yeah,

I will be cracking it open at some point. Uh probably before [clears throat] Great Western Trail Argentina, but um we will see. Uh, Chris, any thoughts on Vantage before we move along here?

No, I haven't played it, so I I don't can't really speak to it that much, but I I I can see it being that that go on a little journey,

just have a little adventure.

Yeah.

Just have a little story. And like for me, I think I would hate it. Um because [clears throat] because I want want it to be more streamlined. I think Richard and I would be aligned in that capacity of it being aimless. Um, but but if you know that going in and that's like the vibe and you just want the chill cozy like but cozy in an adventure way, that's kind of the vibe that I'm picking up. Yeah,

there are goals and it's not necessarily cozy. You can choose to kill people in it.

Okay, that might be cozy for some. Depends what your hobbies are, right?

You can also drown. You can freeze. Like you can burn. There's like there's like

Yeah, that's so so relaxing. freezing, burning.

So, there are goals and missions and all that, but but it's okay if you die.

Okay, spoil anything else.

It's okay if you die, too. That's great. You know what? I take it back. I think I'm into it. I think I'm into it. Sign me up.

Also, if you use the the online website, then you don't have to look through each book entry, and that makes everything so much easier. I highly suggest it. Okay.

Okay. Cool. Good. Good to know. Thank you. All right. Um let's talk about more disappointing games. Uh Chris, you've got our number four for today.

Well, this one truly encaptures um the the vibe of disappointment because I so so desperately wanted to love this game. Um and I just I just didn't. And I think I've isolated why I don't. Uh and it's a shout out to somebody who I I love as a person and love having them on the channel. and we had them as a guest last week. Sorry, Cole. Um, it's it's Molly House. Molly House was uh was a disappointment for me. Um, and I I just want to love this game so much. I wanted such like the the what I love about Worldly Gig Games is the amount of care that they handle any historical subject matter, right? like they this is a game um all about queer representation and um the the idea of back in the 1800s and people you know not being able to come out with their their sexuality uh and you having to to bring joy to the entire community and I think like as a as a concept that's so great um and cool and exciting and then there's the one the one mechanism that is in this. I feel like it's in John company as well, which I also didn't really like from Worldly Gig. Again, love the production quality and loved the idea behind it, but as a game, I just think it's not fun at all. A and that's the idea of it being kind of semicooperative

in that there is there is a global parameter that you have to hit. It's like the community's happiness that has to get to a certain point and if you don't hit that, everybody loses, right? like there was always that sort of everyone loses condition which in some games I don't mind but in this one it it really felt like you're just it felt like it's a it's an awkward catch-up mechanism. It's like it's like it exists for that so that the leader doesn't become a runaway leader which is which is good. I don't like runaway leaders in board gaming, but it just felt like an obvious thing that okay, well, if you're in the lead, you're the one who has to contribute to the global parameters uh versus not doing it. It it I like there to be the ability for selfishness in games, too. And I find that can lead for a little bit more uh negotiation that can happen. But because of it, it just felt like it was a it was a bouncing back and forth. kind of felt a bit like a tug of war, but like a communal tug, so to speak. Um, uh, I think that's the expression. Uh,

tug is an expression in this in this,

I think. So, um, yeah. So, so that that was like that was pretty disappointing. There was also made of this whole like there's there's a mechanism in it where you can turn trader like it's a turning trader mechanism which I wasn't sure how how I was interested in interacting with it. And then when speaking to Cole about it, I was like, "Oh, I'm really interested in this." Uh the idea that like sometimes you have to like literally become an informant on other queer people in order to save your own life. And like you're going to be hanged if you don't turn other people in. And like that's just such a such like a gut-wrenching decision point and a gut-wrenching like thing that you would have to go through. Um, but then in the game it's it's if something gets overrun, it happens kind of infrequently. Uh, if it gets overrun, you then choose, do you become informant? Do you not? Uh, if you and if you become an informant, uh, all somebody has to do is walk over and be like, I think you're an informant, and then it flips over and you lose a bunch of points or whatever. And so mechanically, it it's not really that much of a choice. Like in terms of our game, I knew that everybody was just going to go and investigate me immediately if I was an informant. So like mechanically it didn't really give me that decision. Uh it didn't really give me that push and pull. Uh and so I was like, "Okay, I I'll pretend to be an informant. Then when you reveal me, I get an extra like two points for being on not informing people." Uh and then at the end I had a

card that um I rolled a dice and if I rolled too low I just lost. I just lost. you just lose the game. Um because you get hung and that's the reason why you would be an informant. But I also knew that wi with the table there was no way for me to to be an informant as well. You know what I mean? like I knew I was going to get investigated because it was like so simple and such an obvious thing and and the penalties weren't like were very minimal and and so like there are a lot of these things which in practice get me really excited as like in conceptually and then when it boils down to it it's like oh okay this is a this is a roll and move game where I've rolled two dice and I can choose to to move one space or I can choose to move three and also there are these there are these items that keep popping up that if I don't roll correctly to get on them or if I'm not close enough to them when they pop up, somebody else is just going to go get them. One of those items being like a get out of jail free card literally that like if I had rolled I could have ignored one of my hangings and it's just like well that just feels really powerful and oh it was on the other side of the board and somebody rolled a three before I rolled a three so couldn't get that right. Like so it just

h it pains me so much but like so much of this game theme-wise like I wanted to love this game. I wanted to like uh just be uh obsessed with it. And mechanically the roll and move didn't do anything for me. The the playing cards in the wis tricks also felt like minimal. It was just like it was scratching the surface and there were so many things that were kind of pulling it down for me. So I just like

man what a bummer to not like it. I was I was like so stoked that but um and I and I changed my opinion too after talking with Cole because I was like I read through the rule book when I was on crowdfunding and I was like I don't think I'm going to like it that much because of like the role and move because of like a few things and then and then talking with Cole he's like no no no it's actually because of this because of this because of this and I was like okay well yeah let's do it and then I played it and I was like nope nope it was going to it they did exactly what it was going to do like there all those mechanical things that I didn't think I would like it. It didn't save it. There was no way for it to to kind of uh make up for that. Uh and the theming can only get you can only get you so far.

Yeah.

So, yeah, it was a a real real friaking bummer for me and I I didn't enjoy it and could never recommend it.

Oh, that that's Yeah, Chris, I've heard a few people with similar thoughts, right? I I think most of us love the theme, right? And that's what got me excited like what a theme to, you know, make a board game about, right? the care at which the team like does their research as well like they do so much research they do such due diligence with with subject material I feel

um

and they have pages on like history right yeah in it

and that's that's why so many of us were excited but um again from what I I had a friend who bought it and I wasn't able to play uh his ver a copy of it and by the time I got around to asking he had already sold it off because again he had loved the theme but the gameplay just wasn't for him and I was like, "Oh, that's a bummer." So, I'd still like to play it at some point, but um now after hearing you and others talk about, you know, I have I understand I may have reservations about certain the the mechanics or whatever, but yeah, theme-wise, I I think we need more games like that, but hopefully games that are more approachable. Yeah. Bonds,

I'm looking at uh BGG and with all the ratings and everything, the complexity is 3.72 out of five. So, it's in the orange, so it's pretty complex.

Yeah. Yeah.

Wow. But it involves like just like a roll and move concept.

Yeah. But it's it's because like I think the complex I think that's a little high for complexity, but I think the complexity comes from the the steps that you have to do for the game like when when something is taken over for a raid. So every there are four sections where you can throw parties essentially and you're adding cubes to them and then you're trying to ditch cards into the discard pile to which will be revealed and if there's too many of a certain card then they'll raid and then it'll be that times the number of cubes which will do this and then once it's raided well then you have this penalty on top right like so it's all those like

those little little things. So the gameplay itself and the decision space itself is actually not that complicated I think. But I think the the the idea like the the little tweaks and the d uh the mechanisms behind it are are get it to that complexity rating.

Okay.

All right.

People in the chat are are saying that uh that it's also on BGA. Uh I just want to highlight one thing that Sean was saying. I think I think Molly House is something everyone should try and be open to more as a gaming experience rather than a strict game. And like yeah, I think like sure treat it as an experience. Treat it as a as a little lesson about history and like queer history. I think that's great. Yeah, for sure you should uh because you it's good to know about these things and know uh where where we come from, etc. Um but but I also think like it being on BGA then doesn't serve that purpose because I think mechanically uh what are you going to get on BGA from that? You're probably not. Yeah. Um, so I think like as a as a way to engage with it, I don't know if engaging with it on BGA is the way to do it, but I also don't know if I would say if I would want to engage with it in person,

right, that's fair. Okay, thank you. Uh, Chris, let's move on to our number three. We got three left here. Uh, this one falls to me, and this was a huge disappointment. My most disappointing game of, uh, 2025 was our collective number three, Ace of Spades. And I was hyped about this game because I loved the thought of the concept. Again, again, the concept um seemed really cool. It was a poker using poker style hands to battle. Uh it was a solo game. Apparently, you could play as as two as well. Uh but straight up, folks, um racist imagery. That's that's the heart of it. Um it was really, really disappointing to see some of this imagery in the game. Um and that's all I'm going to say about I'm not I was we were I was going to play a video, but no, I'm I'm not going to play a video cuz um yeah, we're not going to show those images. It was really disappointing in a few aspects and I'm going to be frank with y'all. I was disappointed with myself as well because we got a preview of it. A lot of us got a preview of it at Gen Con last year and we had demos, short demos of this game and I didn't see the card. There was one specific card that had this racist imagery and I missed it. either I didn't see it because the demoer did not show it or I just missed it. Um, it was a short demo, maybe five minutes. I like the gameplay. Um, but yeah, there was a big there was a big stink about it and thankfully D'Ve did the right thing.

They pulled it and um I'm think I I assume that they're going to come out with a newer version with some uh better artwork. Uh because I'm I'm curious to play it. Um maybe they'll rethe it. Uh who knows? But um

because you remember the demo, right? you enjoyed the demo, the

Yeah, the demo itself. Yeah. And I know some some content creators um actually got a copy of the game and uh you know did their video or live stream or whatever and they just passed right over it. So I think it I think a lot of us and including myself on this like we need to take a closer look at these things. Um and not just like and I get it. It's tough because we can, you know, we play so many games and we create so many videos and live streams, you know, we may not look at everything with a fine tooth comb and that's fair, but something like this, I mean, it was, you know, when I saw the card later that when people brought it up, it's like it's really obvious, folks. Um, so yeah, just moving forward, um, I I I think Dir did the right thing and hopefully, um, we can see a better version of this game. Yeah, as it stands, uh, my number three, uh, our collect number three, most of the sporting games 2025, Ace of Spades.

I'm glad you mentioned that because I completely forgot about that entire situation. And honestly, out of all the games here today, I think that one is like truly a disappointment. Like they should have done better. That should have never been even on the table. That should have gotten

That should have It should have never gone as far as it did. Yep. and for it to be sold out at Gen Con with lines down the hallway just to get their their copy signed. All these content creators making content, not realizing what was going on and then

to be discovered after Gen Con was it was discovered at Gen Con, but it blew up after Gen Con.

Yeah.

The whole situation for them to only make changes once they realized that they were probably going to financially hurt from it. Like that's not good enough. that we should not have to deal with that in 2026. And yet we do and that's that's very angering and I think for any company out there like especially us as content creators like we can't take it for granted that companies that we work with every day will be good like we now Dve has proven that we have to double check our friends in the industry which is sad like we shouldn't have to deal with that. We know people at the Vir why did this go as far as it did and why are there only changes now? So like you know we have to now take that extra precaution because of what happened. It's just frustrating all around. Yeah, I think that's Yeah, sorry Chris. I just got to jump in real quick. That's the word bonds frustrating, right? This is just frustrating on so many levels. And you know, I know some of the people dve there are good people at Dvere and it's one of those things maybe there was a blind spot or or or whatever. But it's the type of thing where we need to we need to learn lessons not only Diver but all of us learn learn lessons moving forward and either lessons as far as like representation or just lessons on let's keep a better eye out for each other or you know and again just call it out when you see it and thankfully uh again our family plays games wonderful channel they were you know among the first people that said hey this is wrong and uh kudos to Dve for listening and uh

changing but again we're just going to have to uh pay better attention Uh, sorry, Chris. Go right ahead.

No, no, no. I think I think um I was just yeah we we can we can move on pretty quickly but but uh I I think it is it's it's important to somebody in the comments was like oh we went from Molly House to Ace of Spades in terms of talking about how how we approach sort of things and just like um that uh it's it's great to celebrate the the companies who put put in the extra work of like um culture consultants and all of that sort of stuff which is uh important and important to get to get things right and and it also should It should be noted that like yes it did take some push back but there are many there are many companies out there who um also don't change when there is push back and and Devere made a made a big change as well to to to sort of listen to the community and and uh change things up. There's there's been other companies and other other things where there's a big push back and they just say well you don't like it don't buy it right. Yeah. Like that's that has been a stance of of a bunch of things. So I think like uh while while the initial I I always like it's always hard I'm always like a I'm I'm always a a bright side try try to be bright side when like in important issues or give grace in the in the important issues in that in that aspect. Um, but like I I uh, you know, don't want to minimize anything while while doing that, right? Um, but but I think just like I I thought it was it was a good resolution that like, oh, there's an issue. There's there's some there's some bad art. Well, we we will eventually pull it. And that's why like speaking up in general is important just

in in life, not just in board gaming, right? Like exactly. and seeing people how you actually respond to people speaking up instead of quashing their voices is a is a positive thing.

Right. I find

that's right. Again, well said. Thank you, Bonds. Thank you, Chris. Um, let's move on to our final two games uh on the list. And Bonds, you got number two.

Okay. So, I'm going to paint you this story. Okay. I drive I drive miles, okay, out of my my time, my weekend, my precious minutes, okay? and I choose to play board games with friends. And I walk in and there stands Rurell saying, "Do you want to play one of the most disappointing board games of 2025?" And that one is [gasps] Magical Athlete. Reel loves this game. We're at I think a full player count. Everyone is so excited. EVERYONE ON DISCORD IS BUYING THIS game left and right. You can be the baby. You could be the banana. This is a remake. Oh my gosh, Andrew Garfield. YOU COULD BE, "OH, EVERYONE wants to do this." You are rolling hollow light dice. They don't even have WEIGHT TO IT. AND YOU'RE JUST CHUCKING THEM hoping that you'll move forward. Okay? You That's it. You're just move forward. SOMETIMES BACKWARDS, BUT SOMETIMES FORWARD, but sometimes forward, but sometimes backwards, BUT SOMETIMES BACKWARDS, BUT SOMETIMES FORWARD. AND THAT'S ALL YOU'RE DOING.

THAT'S IT. THAT'S THE WHOLE GAME. I WOULD RATHER PLAY CANDYLAND. I WOULD I was losing brain cells. Everyone was laughing and smiling around me. I DIDN'T UNDERSTAND WHY THEY WERE HAVING FUN. I THOUGHT THEY WERE JOKING. I THOUGHT THIS WAS A JOKE. I THOUGHT THEY WERE ACTUALLY faking it. AND I SAW PURE JOY FROM THEM. REAL WAS so was like beaming when he was teaching everyone. I go, there's no way this game is like multiple rounds. Please let this be over. Why did I drive all the way here for game day? This is making me less interested in the board gaming hobby. I WANT TO QUIT RIGHT NOW. I'M GOING TO GO I'M GOING TO APPLY TO BE LIKE A CPA OR SOMETHING. I'D RATHER DO TAXES FOR THE REST OF MY life than have to play this game again.

That is the most disappointing board game of 2025. I don't understand why it got all the hype. I don't understand why people like it. It has cool art and fun meeples. That's it. I would rather just paint that on Candyland and and waste my time. some more.

It does seem awful. I'm interested to see why Ruella is very excited. But look, even just the sight of it brings Ruel with such a cute little smile. How could you not be having fun with that cute little smile over there, huh? My sweet Rouel.

Okay, what what I love about this is I remember the day when Bons and I played this game. And Chris, I and everyone watching, I kid you not, I could tell Bons was not enjoying this game after the first couple of rounds. I'm like, uhoh, no, someone doesn't like this game. But I didn't care. Everyone else said, "We had a great time. It was fun." And I will stand by this. I think I think Magical Athlete is one of the best games released last year. But here's the thing. I'm not going to I'm not going to pretend it's the greatest strategy game out there. It is not deep. It is not complex. friends. This is a roll and move game that is done right. It It is light. You There's nothing. You're just rolling and moving. But it's got all these wacky abilities. It's got all this um you know, I'll put it this way. If you like having fun, play Magical Athlete.

You know what? I can even tell in the YouTube video you're like, "The board flips around. THE BOARD FLIPS AROUND." GUESS WHAT? [screaming] THE BOARD flips around. I can tell you're doing that in the video. Uh, so so there's there's these abilities you roll and you move, but there's nothing else. It's it seems like a worse Formula D.

No. Okay.

Oh my gosh.

So here's the funny thing.

And Formula D is is horrendous. Formula D gets me. That's my experience.

If you didn't [clears throat] like Formula D like I didn't, uh, you will enjoy Magical Athlete because here's the reason. You're going to like it because number one, it's shorter and quicker. And number two, it's just sillier, right? It's a silly I mean it's a rolling it's a rolling right race game.

You're just racing around. It's super quick and I'm going to I I I want to be fair to Bonds. Okay. I I can get why someone would not like this game. I if you're a hardcore gamer, if you're veteran gamers, um sure, but if you like to have fun,

any decision space whatsoever is what I'm getting from this group.

Yeah. No, there is decision space and I'll tell you where it is. There is a draft before each race and you draft the racers you want. So, there are ways to like, you know, figure out, oh, I think this racer would be good for me. Uh, you you draft four racers for four races and you can put your strongest racer for the last race because that's the one that's worth mo the most points. It's wacky. It's fun. It's quick. And

you know,

one more thing. Yeah. Yeah.

One more thing. Okay. I hate it when people touch my board game pieces because I barely get to do stuff in board games. Yeah. And when you're touching my board game piece, you're kind of just making my moves for me. Why am I there? Like I don't have time for this.

Someone who shall not be named because they are lovely kept on moving my

royal.

I think you're still muted.

You're still muted. Is she really ranting this long? That was a huge mute. No, you're still muted. This is a great rant. We're hearing nothing of this rant.

Yeah, that's true.

Chris, can you can you read lips?

No, I'm saying I'm saying Bon says it was Ruel. Don't let him Don't let him do it again. Um,

now I think so animated that the mic

the mic just blew just completely disconnected.

Bod microphone. Yeah, John, that's awesome. We we should this is what magical athlete has done Ruel. This is what you have done.

It was all it was all me.

Um to be fair I remember the game the Bons was playing. Yes. And that that annoys me too when someone takes and again we won't name this lovely person but that annoys me too when I cannot like if you're playing the game for me what am I do even doing here? And I remember that and Bonds had that look of frustration. So, um, Bonds, um, I I I hear your frustration about the game. I I understand why, but, um, it's still one of the funnest games I I I've played, and I will stand by that. And, uh,

well, maybe we'll get more more rant when, uh, after we'll go to Richard's video, and maybe Bonds can uh, figure out figure out their mic while uh,

yeah,

while that's that's going on.

Okay. Uh, Richard, take us away as Bonds fix her fixes her mic. Okay, coming down to the wire. Chris Molly House, I see what you did here. Waited till Cole left the building before you stabbed him in the back. Nicely played, sir. Uh, we're getting Shakespearean. Uh, no surprise with your theater chops. Um, I will say my biggest disappointment with Molly House is that it's not a cooperative game or at least had a co-op mode because like all of Cole's games, I'm disappointed. There's no way I could like him cuz the man just loves to have players going at each other. Even in a game like this where in a perfect world, oh yeah, sure, there can be betrayers and informants and all of that, but I don't want to play that. I don't want to be a bad guy in this scenario. I want all players to work together toward towards the joy and um you know, better life that we're trying to ascribe. I don't want to be a player actually trying to rip that down. So, man, if this I mean, if ever there was a game that Cole would have been working on that could have used a co-op mode, it is um Molly House. I guess I also remember um when when Shay covered it for the channel, he mentioned that it is maybe a little overly complex. I I don't know. I don't know what it is you have to say about it, but that was my disappointment. I so want to try this, but I so want it cooperative. Let's see.

And then Royel, Ace of Spades. Yeah, that was certainly a good call. Very disappointing. Although, you know, put a silver lining on it, I was not disappointed by how Dvere handled the situation and at incredible cost to themselves. Basically scrapped the entire run. I can't even imagine how financially uh bad that must have been for them. But they stepped up and did the right thing. Said, "Yeah, we realize now we made a terrible mistake. We are going to fix this at great cost to ourselves." So, you know, at the end of the day, good on them. um for taking the right steps and we'll look forward to 2026 uh seeing them take a second shot at that one. And then Bonds, wow, magical athlete made so many top 10 of the year. I mean I I didn't Tom Vassel give it like a 10 out of 10. Um you know, and I mean and so many people seem to love it. Granted, it's not a game I'm ever going to be interested in.

Certainly, it's and they shouldn't even put two player on the box, I don't think, cuz this is a game where you wouldn't want to play with less than five. And I'm sure you've played it that way, Bon. So, I would like to hear why um you are swimming upstream. Um always ice skating uphill against the common consent because I've heard nothing but great things about Magical Athlete. Okay. Uh that was what 432, which leaves me with the number one most disappointing game. And oh, this one does break my heart so much. It is the Peak team, which you can see I did a uh solo runrough of it here um for, you know, members, backers of the channel. And um yeah, here's the deal. This is the great game. All three of the games I'm talking about today are co-op. This was a disappointing year for co-ops for me, obviously. Um but anyway, this is a great game. it. This is This is maybe designer Scott Alm's greatest design ever. Um Scott Alms, please do more co-op games. Tiny Epic Defenders is one of my all-time faves. This was fantastic. Um and you know, I love the subject matter where park rangers basically just trying to, you know, maintain the park, help people, help the animals most importantly. Uh and it has a really great pandemicesque uh you know, system of chasing after objectives. you you using multi-use cards from our hand to be able to get around really quick with different modes of transportation and an absolutely brilliant phenomenal co-op mode where you know the cards I have in my hand uh

that I draw these are not for me these don't help me I have to give these cards away to my neighbors to the left and my right so I need to look right okay you were sitting to my right well I I oh you're up in the mountains you probably need this but I could give you this helicopter card because I can see if you if you could use that helicopter you could make it down over to the forest and complete that objective. You're the only one who could do it. So, even though I want to give you this key card, I'm going to give you this helicopter card and then you bonds, what am I going to give to you instead? That is brilliant because I can't tell my teammates why I'm giving them these cards. And I hope they figure out how to use them to the best of ability that I saw. And meanwhile, you're all giving me a hand of cards as well. It is so smart. So then, why am I so disappointed? Well, there's two things. One, this is maybe the worst rule book I've ever seen. And it's weird. It's not the writing. The rulebook writing is great. The structure of the rule book is horrible. Um, you know, I talked about this in a roundup months ago. I think I've got a standalone video of this of me going into more detail, so I won't go into detail now, but [sighs] the the the publisher was trying to be clever with the way they present the information, and I think they did it in an absolutely terrible way. Um, but that was a minor thing, you know, because the game's not that complex. It's about the same level as a pandemic. So, you know, I can eventually if I play it enough, I'm not going to need the rules anyway.

My bigger issue is this creates maybe the most cardinal sin that a co-op game can do. No way to adjust difficulty levels. That's not true. They do have a way to adjust the difficulty level. If you want to make this game easier, what you have to do, the game comes, I think you play it through five chapters. Um, and every chapter introduces more mechanisms. And it's only when you play chapter five that you're playing the full game. And so uh and and by the way, this game is hard. It is challenging. So if you're playing ch you want to play the full game, because I do I want to have the unique player powers. I want to have, you know, all the cool bells and whistles that are available with the whole game active. But if you want to make the game easier, what do you do? You play an earlier chapter. You play chapter 2 where Oh, sorry. All the, you know, the event system, the uh powers, all that stuff is gone. you play a stripped down, labbotomized, introductory version of the game to make it easier. And that's just wrong. I want to be able to adjust the difficulty level of this game without literally ripping the guts out of the game. It would be like if you Oh, you want to make pandemic easier? Let's just say that all of the uh you know the that you can just find a cure for the for the pandemic anywhere. You know, if you got the cards, you you can just find the cure anywhere. You don't need to build a medical station. You don't need to travel there. Or let's just say, oh, you want pandemic to be easier. Let's just say you can give cards to anybody anytime you want. Wherever if you're standing in the same place, you don't have to to get a Chicago card. I don't have to go to Chicago and you have to

get to Chicago. I mean, and so you can say, oh, that would make pandemic easier, but it would rip the heart out of pandemic. And that's what Peak Team does for such a brilliant design. And it's so infuriating because all they had to do was say, "All right, if you would like to increase or decrease the difficulty level of the game, start with a bigger or smaller hand of cards." You know what Pandemic does. Um, well, actually, that's not exactly what Pandemic Pandemic puts stuff in the but I'm thinking of the way Pandemic scales itself for multiple players. Um, right. Uh, they could have done that here. If you start with more cards in hand, it makes the game easier. If you start with fewer cards in hand, it makes the game harder. That would have been so simple and it's infuriating and equal measures disappointing. Um, like I said, this is Scott Alm's greatest design ever. This is maybe probably the best new co-op game that has come out since The Loop that came out years ago. This would have been probably my number one ranked game of 2025 if it had not let me down so hugely on these two super important metrics for co-op gaming. And that's why, as you can tell, I'm a little disappointed um by the Peak team. Okay, everybody.

But wait, I'm not done yet. I've got seven seven more games because I'm going to give you a full top 10 disappointments today. But first of all, let's throw back to the gang and then I'll join you later after we're done with the big list.

Okay, Richard, thank you. I was pretty bummed to see this on the list as well. I love Scott Alms and just a bummer.

Yeah, I haven't played it at all. Um, it made me think of some other disappointments which would be on honorable mentions, but uh I think as per theme, we should pass it over to Richard to see how long it takes going through his honorable mentions and then we'll know how much time we have. Okay.

To talk about it.

Thanks, Chris and Chris. Uh, Richard, what else you got?

Okay, folks. I've got a full top 10 disappointments to talk about today. And I don't want to dwell on it too long because I like to accentuate the positive and eliminate the negative, except for this one time every year where we do this on the RNR. So, let me just blitz through it as fast I can so you can get back to the gang because I know they've got some dishonorable mentions as well. So again, personal disappointments for me uh in 2025 starts with number 10, Seven Wonders Dice. Come on, how could they mess this up? Um it's fine. Turning Seven Wonders into a rolling right though, that should have been a totally, you know, slam dunk knock it out of the park. I think my biggest problem with the game, well, first of all, the dice system is actually really cool. But everything else is just kind of so so. And my biggest disappointment is the thing that truly makes Seven Wonders special. The way it as a Civilization game handles players interacting with their neighbors and leaning on each other has been excised from the game entirely. If that had never existed in the original Seven Wonders, I never would have been interested in the game in the first place. Uh the fact that oh I don't have the stone but my neighbor does so I will buy it from them. How did they leave this out? It's crazy. It's crazy disappointing. At number 10

then we got number and Asian of sorts of an earlier game he had published um through Tasty Mal games who are sadly no longer with us. Um, oh, uh, uh, Old West Empressario, which is a wonderful tile laying engine building game. And so I thought, oh, he's revisiting that design. Um, you know, and it's putting in this cool funky floating uh, cities in the sky or moving, you know, instead of the American West. And I thought, oh, this is great. I loved Old West Empressario. Let's see what he does new. The main thing that was done new is that he turned from square tiles to hexagonal tiles. And this is not the first time I've seen and been proven to me uh uh that square tile

better originally um remade uh into uh Luna Architects. It was the same thing because as it happens hex tiles well they have six sides on them instead of four. So, in a a tile lane game where putting tiles next to other tiles is a big part of the puzzle, doing it doing it with hex's instead of squares is just so much easier. It's it it takes a it robs the game of so much tension and tough decision-m when oh, I CAN GET SIX tiles around this thing. And I was just both Jen and I are like, "Yeah, boy. I remember liking this so much more in Old West Empressaria." And I went back and looked and right, that was squares instead of hex's. Now, I mean, I guess Propeller Island, you know, it's probably just not targeted for me. Uh, the way original Empressario was just like perfect challenge and crunchiness and length, but Propeller Islands, I guess it's just more targeted as a gateway game, and it's probably fine at that, but that's not what I wanted, so I was disappointed. Then we got number eight, Reesside Legacy. Oh man, I've been hearing about Regisside forever.

And it went through like a a you know a complicated backstory of the publisher trying to get their rights back so that they could publish it themselves and they turned the original Critical Darling into a legacy game gen. I love legacy games. It's a co-op game. How am I not going to enjoy this, you know, fantasy boss battler um that is a legacy game that is built off of gameplay from a deck of 52 cards, right? You can play Reside right now with just any standard deck of 52 cards. But they turned it into a legacy game. So I was so excited. And honestly, Regesside Legacy, it's not you, it's me or it's me and Jen because we bumped so hard into this thing. I was so excited about it. But for some reason, Jen and I playing I mean, and what I've heard most people raving about it, they rave about it as a solo game, which is how re Regeside was originally designed first and foremost as a solo game. We played as a co-op game and we just struggled. It was so far beyond, oh, this is a fun challenge into, okay, this is just this challenge is a slog and we just feel stupid that we keep losing over and over again and the game keeps bending over backwards to take it easier on us and then we kept losing over and over. I think we quit by the second chapter. Um, which broke my heart and then we ended up sending it on down to the Dice Tower West Convention Library where you can play it now because they've got my copy. Um, or you can play it at the World Series of Board Games. Chris, maybe you should try it when you're down there because I don't know what it is. It just did not work for me and Jen at all. Um, so I was a

bit disappointed because I went in with high hopes for that one. Uh, then we got number seven. Chinita. Chicken. Chicken. Why am I disappointed? It's a Stefenfeld game. My favorite designer of all time. But now, so why isn't it my number one most disappointing? because anytime a Stefan Feld game lets me down, that's that's soul crushing cuz I love the man and uh and his designs. Now, I should I can't be too disappointed though because I knew what this game was going in. I've seen interviews with him um in German that I had to translate to see him, but he talked about how he had fond memories of being a kid playing a maritashy style games and you know, just battling with his friends and rolling big buckets of dice over and over again. And while that's not his kind of game these days, he'd always wanted to make one like that because it's, you know, for his inner child, I get it. That's cool. Um, but yeah, this is not a game for me and Jen and I knew that going in. But I just felt like I should see it anyway because I played every I'm the only person in all of board game media that has got 100% failed coverage. I've covered every single one of his games. And I'll be talking more about Chichin in my next monthly roundup. Um, but suffice to say, while there's some brilliant stuff in there, the Euroey elements he put in are gorgeous, wonderful, and smart, but they are ruined by the buckets and buckets and buckets and buckets and buckets and buckets and buckets of dice you have to roll over and over and over again in this needlessly complex and

overengineered combat system. It's just a heartbreaker um for Chichinita. Then we've got Fya's Swamp. Now, I should not have gotten my hopes up for this anyway because originally Fa Swamp, which is a remake of um Kavi or Kavai, uh originally Kavai was a three-player minimum game, and I've heard great things about it over the years, but I never saw it because I'm only a two-player gamer. But this remake with new art from my favorite artist of all time, you know, the Miko, uh said, "Hey, we've we've cracked the code. We've made it a great two-player game." So, Jeni Play is a two-player. It should still be listed as a three-player minimum game. It works as a two-player game, but every step of the way, every move I make, I'm thinking, "Yeah, I there needs to be a third player here to make this game sing." And so, I was disappointed. Uh, and a lot of people love this, and I suspect all of them were playing it with at least three players. It functions. It is a, you know, and there's even a little bit of fun to be had. But yeah, it was I mean this game needs to be at a higher player count like its predecessor was. Um but it offered two-player gaming and I was disappointed by that. Although boy it sure looked I I I love the look of it.

Okay then we got what we got 10 987. Uh that was six. Number five is um Echoes of Time. Now this was a big disappointment for me. I love Simone Luciani. I do not know the other designer Roberto P. But I was excited for this because this is a conveyor belt game. I'm always talking about conveyor belts and you know Simone Luchiani doing a conveyor belt game. Yes, please. The game has a gorgeous look. Um and it's really super smart tableau building gameplay. Um you know engine building of sorts or your engine is your, you know, you get your cards out to your conveyor belt. They're only going to stick out for so long. You need them to come out. You need to time them leaving the conveyor belt at the right time with like this phase of the moon system.

There's so much good stuff here and I really really loved this could have been a top tener of the year for me if it weren't for the fact that they threw in for no reason at all a sizable percentage of the cards in this game are take that screw you. I'm going to steal from you. I'm going to break your stuff. And it's just like why are these here? These don't need to be. These don't belong here. And every time one of those cards came out I'm like okay crap. I got to deal with this card now. I got to deal with trying to play it with to perfection so I can hurt my wife Jen to for maximum impact. No. Gosh, why? I mean, I'm reminded a few years ago of Ancient Knowledge, another brilliant engine building conveyor belt card game um that was ruined by a nasty take that cards, too. Now, eventually that game um they released an expansion that introduced enough cards that you could remove the take that cards and they were effectively replaced by more interesting and more fun ways to interact with other players. I don't have to interaction doesn't have to be me just, you know, tearing down your sand castle. There's other ways to do it, but this game chose not to do that. I can only hope. I mean, Crano is known for doing expansions.

Cranio, please, wherever you are, hear my plea. And um in that expansion, follow the example of ancient knowledge and throw some cards in that will allow us to remove the take that cards and truly make this um one of the great alltime uh conveyor belt games out there that it could potentially be. But as it is, you could probably tell I'm a little disappointed by number five, Echoes of Time. And then finally, number four, Star Trek's Caption Chair. I think my subtitle for my video when I did a runthrough for this was this is my most anticipated game ever. And I meant that I was more excited about car than any game I've ever played. And I'm not talking board games and car games. I'm talking about video games. I'm talking about anything. The only games I ever anticipated more were the games I worked on because I used to be a video game designer. So, of course, I anticipated shipping my own games more than this.

But this was my number one cuz I'm the biggest uh Trek fan out there. Oh my gosh, Star Trek Academy is so good. Oh, it's such a great time to be a Trek fan. And granted, um, Star Trek Captain's Chair is a beautiful love letter to all things Star Trek. Um, Dave Tury, who's an even bigger Trek fan than me, and his design partner Nigel Bucknell, knocked it out of the park with this game. It is a Trek lover's dream. So, why am I so disappointed? Two things. It is crazy long. Just absurdly long. I've played this game um probably eight or nine times with Jen and with another friend and no matter how many times I played it, it was always a threehour game, you know, two and a [clears throat] half to three and a half hour game. Just too long. Please, since this is a a remake or a spin-off from uh the brilliant Horizon system and they ultimately introduced that trade system or not the trade system, they introduced that accelerated system that let you cut down Imperium by when Hor Imperium Heist came out, you cut down the length of Imperium game by like 20%. Please do that for Star Trek. It's just too long. Captain's chair. But then my other problem is even if they did that I still don't know because it's just it's very t there are enough take that cards when you have when I play as Captain Pequard and you give me a card for wararf that allows me to screw with my opponents like how is Captain Pequard why does Captain Pequard

have a take that card in his deck? I actually asked Dave that at Essen last year he said well it's Warfar is going to attack the other players. Like there are a lot of things Warf can do besides attack other players. And if you're building a Peard deck, if there is ever a deck that should not have take that cards in it, it should be Picard. Kirk, sure. Cisco, definitely. Um, you know, but Peard, come on. Uh, so and the game is brilliant. And it breaks my heart that I didn't keep it because one, it's too long and two, it's too mean. It's not the complexity. I know Dave, I I've seen him comment somewhere that uh I he thinks I think it's too complex. No, I love the depth and complexity of it. I love it. I just wish you could give me that Horizons. do do what you did for Horizons, you know, give me trade instead of, you know, so I can I can alter all these attack cards and cut the game length down, but do it so that I can inflate both because that was the biggest problem with Horizons.

Hey, you could have the trade, get rid of the take that or you could have the speed up. You couldn't combine those. Anyway, long story short, I talked about this in the past. Oh, breaks my heart. Star Trek Captain's Chair. And then we already talked about number three, Unstoppable. Number two, Vantage. And number one, the Peak Team. The greatest co-op in years, except but for it was very disappointing. And that's it. I'm done. What What other ones disappointed you? How else was 2025 a year of of uh of sadness in cardboard form? Let's hear it, everybody. And oh, by the way, thanks again, Bon, for showing up. It's great to have you here.

All right. Thank you, Richard. Yeah, lots of uh disappointing games for uh Richard. I knew Star Trek I thought Star Trek uh Captain Sher would be his number one actually because I remember how hyped he was about it and then later when he did his playthrough video I was like oh he did not he didn't like it as much as he expected. So not surprising it's on the list but uh anyways uh Chris Yeah. thoughts?

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. For just for Star Trek Captain's Chair uh I know my Discord is full of solo players who love it. who are obsessed with it, who've gotten it. It is like the most talked about in the game session reports little tab that we have. Uh people are loving it. So I think I think especially as like a solo aspect and that's what Sean uh who's in my discord uh who's one of those people uh who who I love um is also saying that that yeah, it's just like was such a hit. So it was very surprising to see anybody be disappointed by it. Yeah. But um I guess I guess because I've only heard about it in that solo regard that makes sense.

Yeah. Um we got a couple of minutes left here and then we got to get going. But why don't we take uh take one of our

honorable mentions. Um we'll start with Bonds. Uh anything else you want to talk about that disappointing you this past year.

Okay. Really quick. My honorable mention for disappointing game for 2025 is Citizens of the Spark from Thunderworks Games.

The colors captivated me. I loved the card art and I was so excited to finally play it and learn it. And I don't know if it's because I got slaughtered so much or if like it was it was like half the group actually no I want to say like 90% of the group got completely slaughtered at this game and then like two people were going neck andneck on like winning. So you just had to kind of deal with the fact that you weren't going to win. You just like finish the game and there wasn't really that much of a catch-up mechanic. I will say uh uh I believe Sheay was the one that slaughtered everyone. Maybe that makes more sense.

Oh, Shay slaughters everyone at every game. So,

yeah. So, that is my honorable mention, Citizens of the Spark.

Okay. What about you, Chris? Um, anything?

Yeah, I had a few. I have one. The Star Wars Unlimited Intro Battle the Hoth set was on my list. Uh, I'll have a full review on my channel, Ruben Board, coming out soonish. Um, but it's it's just quite bad and not the way you should be introduced to the system if you've ever played a board game before.

Oh, wow.

Um, the other the other thing that was on my list was I put Nemesis Retaliation on my list as well because I really I really thought that they were pushing it forward as being like very much closer to Zombacideesque. Yes. As uh and like it was going to be a huge differentiation from regular Nemesis and it's not. It's still like 90% nemesis and I was hoping it would be 70% Nemesis. Yeah. You know, like when it's the third iteration of that system again, I I wanted uh more changes to that. Uh and having played that now a few times with my buddy Zack, I got him we got the allin together. Yeah. Um but uh yeah, so it was just like it it just is the same. And I still think lockdown is like the optimal nemesis. So I was hoping for for like more changes in that in that aspect, but those would be the ones that I I would shout out.

Got it. Okay. And the one that I would uh put on my disappointment list is a game called Collect. Uh this is a small card game released by Sean of all companies. And that got me excited. I was like, "What? They're going in this I I love that they're doing this uh small card box game. No miniatures, you know, and you could buy it direct uh retailer." And it was just a set collection race game and um had some abilities, but nothing that I felt um differentiated it from anything else um out there. I thought it was it was fine, but again, I was so hyped because Sean doesn't do this type of game. Um, but hopefully they continue to do that and we get a a better card game from them in the near future.

Folks, that's going to do things for today. Uh, want to thank Bons Bonsator again for joining us. Uh, Bonds, uh, let people know where they can find you on the interwebs.

Well, I'm glad my sound decided to turn back on after I had to hard reset everything. It just shut off on me. I was like, you you've said enough here.

Okay, I'm actually here on Twitch. I also post content to YouTube, but I'm more live streaming on Twitch. And it's twitch.tv/bombsinator b- an zi na t o r.

All right, great. And uh Chris, before we get going, any final thoughts from you, my friend?

Uh, no final thoughts. Um, really, just one. I said no, but I'm going to say say final thoughts. Uh, so yes, final thoughts. Um, yeah, like like we said at the beginning, it's always, I think, important to talk about our disappointments as well as our excitements, but that doesn't mean if you like the game, you aren't allowed to keep liking it. Uh, we want you to like your games, and you might be wrong, and it's okay being wrong, you know? You can't you can't all be right like the three of us about Magical Athlete, right?

I might I might end up liking Magical Athlete by the end of this year. Like,

yeah, we never know. Um but uh but there is one thing that I will never be disappointed with and that is the quality of chip theory games.

Jump Masters over

Yes. over on Gamefound right now. Jump Masters. This episode of the RNR show is sponsored by Chip Theory Games. Thanks again for watching folks. Take care. So long. Bye-bye.

Progress saved