Broken Meeple Podcast - Episode 105 - Intellectural Property Impact
Transcript
you're listening to the broken meele show a podcast that speaks passionately about board games for the benefit of those who play them my name's Luke Hector best known for the broken meeple YouTube channel and I'm an everyday gamer just like you and I'll be talking about reviews top 10 and just about anything that connects me to board games as long as I have a tea or coffee in hand that is so grab a cup relax and enjoy and remember it's only a game
hello everybody happy New Year this is yes 20125 and the podcast has returned mainly because I remembered oh yeah it's a Sunday and I probably should get one done yeah um last Sunday obviously I was a you know fresh back from you new year and two days of work and stuff so it's was like n it seemed a little bit early to grab a podcast really so I thought okay I'll wait till the next week and then yesterday I went to a gaming event that lasted most of the day and in an hour I need to head over to another gaming event which has started up again in the um uh South hi Tap Room Brewery I think it's called vibrant Forest Brewery or something it's a used to be a Sunday event it happened once a month you get to go there have a couple of good beers and play some games bit of a trek from where I live to get there but it's a decent little social event and that's today so that's going to take up half my day especially with the travel time but then I realized oh yeah I need to get a podcast out so uh I'm sort of recording this in the morning before I go and then I'll probably edit it when I get back so it'll probably be a bit late airing or maybe I'll just wait till Monday to air it we'll see but yes uh my day is a little bit sporadic and I'm certainly I'm quite busy at the moment but in a good way you know the I mean what I mean what happened over the holidays I went off on that two week uh Norway Cru which if you saw some of my photos on Instagram or uh you know or just like heard me talk about it then you know maybe you're on my Facebook and that so it it really was good the Norway Cruise was just what I needed I mean I ticked so many things off my box like you know snowmobile husky dog sledding ice fishing Snowshoe trekking that kind of
thing and saw some great sites saw the a Borealis several times U you know got to just see what it's like at minus 20 de with decent snow I mean our country in the UK at the moment has had a little bit of sleet in the South and a bit of snow in the north and suddenly everything's like shutting down people are grid loocking roads are likeing I mean we are truly pathetic when it comes to the winter or something and yet Norway in alter in the Arctic Circle is basically just yeah it's nearly Perpetual Darkness everything is caked in snow most electric vehicles won't work properly but we just get on with it I mean seriously credit to you know credit to the Arctic Circle Norwegian folk but I mean honestly you know the fact that they give you incentives to go and live there or something if I was 20 years younger and there was actually an opportunity I could have actually seen myself going over to live in Norway I think cuz I think just that I like cold areas I don't mind cold areas but it just the scenery in Norway when you go out and see the mountains and all the riv and the lakes and stuff it's just so nice I really like it so yeah anyway it was a good Cruise met some met some good people had some fun I was kind of done by about 10 11 days into the twoe period I think two weeks is kind of my limit for a holiday really before I start not getting homesick but wanting to get out and thinking I've done enough I'm good and the Seas were certainly pretty choppy so that didn't exactly help either but yeah I went away reset my colleague at work managed to do a great job handing with all my clients that I had to deal with handing over so I even bought her a bottle of wine to thank her
for it so you know she deserved it every drop of that wine so she enjoyed it but yeah I thought I was going to come back to like a massive stressful thing and I really haven't I mean there's still plenty of work to do and I'm not out of the woods yet but we've got people returned from maturity we've got new people you know joined and our capacity is now been uh widen well widened so that you know individual Client List we can spread out to more people I haven't got so many hard deadlines at the moment like in December where it just all comes together so I've actually come back to a relatively stressfree work environment certainly compared to the last 6 months of 2024 where it was just stress City particularly for September through to December I was like hitting burnout levels so going away on the holiday was exactly the Cure I needed on top of going to the family in Somerset for Christmas and all that lot so yeah I much need needed break much needed break from gaming in general frankly cuz I also needed to just take a break from that end of the scale and now I return freshmed you know new outlook new stuff new desire to get things sorted out work you know just yeah just generally in a pretty decent state so yeah in terms of the channel while I was gone obviously didn't exactly release anything over the I released a couple of speed reviews over the course of the cruise but uh nothing to a great extent uh but you know I have now got back into the swing of things so we already have uh the two big reviews for Shackleton Bas and andromeda's Edge doing pretty well thank
you for the feedback on those uh the top games of 24 has finally been released here we go so you know 15,000 views 96% likes you know you know yeah 28 people who think that I should have put arcs at the top of the list or something or celution but you all in all that's doing pretty well I mean look at the amount of comments loads of people just engaging that's what I like to see and a recent speed review I say speed review it hit the 20 minute mark and it went a little bit over but uh you know I'm trying to keep them short but for canopy Evergreen which is another fun little game although quite amusing that I have some people sort of go it's like oh you only like games if they look pretty and it's like um I can think of a few games on my shelf where the Aesthetics are not quite up to par and yet I still like them you know and they'll say oh you only like light games as well CU you haven't liked some of the heavier titles this year what you mean I haven't liked some some of the bone dry dull and boring Euros that 2024 was populated by no funny enough no you know a lot of people ask me if I played a game called menur or something like that and I mean honestly I have no idea what menur is Al when I first heard the title I thought that sounds like the most generic title ever what on Earth is men theur and I'm looking at it it says okay what we got here travel to the capital of ancient Egypt and take part in the development of its culture okay if this was a Civ game on Egypt I would probably have a look but then you look at the box cover and it looks pretty much identical to every Egyptian theme game ever the title means nothing to me if I don't
know what men neur is and then you actually take a look at the board itself and I'll give it credit I have seen much uglier Euro games than this um this one is actually relatively pretty even though there's not really much to look at I mean you essentially have the pieces of players a river and a bunch of yellow sand and then all that but even so as much as this one is not you know a badl looking game it just looks also quite generic I mean I'm seeing tracks I'm seeing bits for tokens I'm seeing a little grid here in the middle and I'm just like oh great is this like another dry Euro now I mean I'd have to try it to see if I like it but it kind of gives me Vibes of Ezra and nemiah or something I mean this little thing in the top here looks like a gimmick a mini gimmick version of uh the pyramid from tail to huacon so you've got the pieces to build de yeah it looks pretty but I mean is it I mean we're putting symbols on top of symbols and we're going to get points if we match the symbols I mean you know all these really dry mechanics that don't make any ftic sense but I would still try any game once so I didn't see this at Essen I mean this is a 24 pcture at Essen I never saw this game where the hell was this being sold I mean who published this one mener was um luden overa I must admit I didn't go around their Booth because luden over and Pegasus Spiel don't tend to release a lot that I'm in interested in but I mean I'd give it a look I'd play it I'll play any game once and see maybe it could win me over but everything I read here
sounds just very generic you know we've seen these mechanics before I get the idea that it's either a point salad or some kind of uh you know big points Fest or something and which kind of means yeah they're going to like it but uh I mean yeah it may be a heavy game I like heavy games fine but I mean if they if they're generic and un uninspiring then it's only going to go so far with me I'll probably like it and then go yeah that's another Point dry Euro but where's the unique innovation in it but I I say I want to try it so anybody at Handy con or that has this game wants to show me it by all means I'd be happy to jump in but you know that's the sort of feedback I've definitely had on some fronts but yeah you know four videos out there by sure check them out but thank you everybody this happened overnight so I haven't done a Facebook announcement or anything like that but the channel reached a milestone it has reached 25,000 views up views sorry views that's pathetic um 25,000 Subs we breached it it's on 25,4 at the moment so it shouldn't dip back down below it but thank you everybody I mean this is another Milestone on the way to 30,000 I guess you know we'll go for the next we'll basically do the milestones in 5,000 batches but yeah it's big milestone 25 it's kind of like that level where you know a because when you get past 25 a lot of channels that you see tend to be now in the 40 to 60 range so there's quite a gap between the 25 to
you know 40 marks you know there's not a huge amount outside there's very few that I can think of if any that are in the 30s I think most are 40 plus or less than 30 so yeah there just seems to be that sort of uh like graveyard area in the middle there but you know I'm just grateful that everybody that watches the show gives positive Fe feedback yeah some people give negative feedback but as long as it's constructive I don't mind it's when they turn it into personal flame attacks that's when it gets personal but uh and I don't like it but you I you for those who watch and for those who engage I mean by all means subscribe to the channel if you haven't already you know if you watch the videos but haven't subbed please sub because it all helps you know the algorithm all helps engagement and stuff uh but by all means comment on the videos you know tell me if you like the game tell me if you hate the game you know what are your thoughts you know even if I can't respond to every single comment I will certainly try to respond to as many as I can and you know I'm grateful to see the comments I still at least read them you know it's difficult to find the time to respond to every single comment because there's a lot of comments I mean 200 plus comments that take ages to respond to every single one but I still at least read them so it is good to you know get that level of Engagement but yeah uh as for what I'm going to start bringing out soon um you know there will be a speed reviews for stuff like um well beyond the base game I hope to do like an ancient Heritage uh expion to uh what you call it um I forget the name it's based on I'm looking at the box here but I forget what it's called forbidden knowledge or something like that but you that expansion review uh there's going to be speed reviews for a couple of
Emperor S4 games I still haven't done uh Train Station to Station by Ali cat games I need to do a speed review for I might do a speed review for Reef project by Bard and dice I don't know I only bought it on a whim I don't know if I've got time to do a full review for it but yeah there's other little bits and Bobs I'm trying to just mop oh undergrow by Alder I never got around to doing that before Christmas so I hope to do a speed review for that so yeah I'm basically mopping up games I couldn't review before Christmas and my cruise and getting them done this month but I also have to think about the top 100 question mark list yes I'm actually thinking of doing things a bit differently this time because I've taken on a lot of feedback from the whole top 100 and and stuff like that in the past especially when I said this is when I'm going to do it and there does seem to be a lot of feedback from people saying that I'm kind of bored with top 100s now or we don't really need to see a 100 we just need to see 25 or 50 and it's happening more and more as each year goes on and I must admit the more I think about it the more I'm kind of in that setting as well because when other people release their top 100 lists I find myself more drawn to the top 50 than the top 100 and you know even like the like Dice Tower ones and stuff like that so maybe I should actually take that on board so I think what I'm actually executive decision going to do this time is restrict it to 50 I don't think I'll go as low as 25 I think that's maybe cutting out a few too many games there but I think the ma absolute Max is I'll do a top 50 so
we'll do say the 26 to 50 relatively quickly maybe do it in one video maybe do it in two or maybe I'll do uh maybe I'll do two batches of 15 to get it to 20 and then do two batches of 10 to do the top 20 but I think that will do because the top 100 takes a lot of time to compile that list it takes ages to do the stats ages to do 10 plus videos you know top 10 lists are my favorite videos to do they are also the most time consuming I mean you know you see some channels out there that literally just switch the camera on talk and that's it that's their video it takes 10 minutes to edit the video and they just shove it up I mean you know low effort but the you know or low well I suppose low effort is kind of harsh you know but low time consumer it's not very timeconsuming but the the videos that I do for the top 10 I mean they've got the the video clips they've got the music they've got the lighting changes you know to make certain it's not too dark not too bright uh they've got you know and in every single segment of 10 you've got that lower third you've got the animated number which is separate you know that is plugged in on top uh you've got the picture that has to be aligned and zoomed you know to make certain it's not unclear you've then got the text in the lower f for the game and the publisher to put in and resize then the pictures go in they've got their own formatting thing to make certain that at the side of the screen and not covering my face uh you know and they're in at the right times the joke clips get inserted in so I have to watch the footage and go a joke would work quite nicely there or a video clip would work go nicely there and bul those in and all sorts have to be done just for each
segment of the top 10 so doing that 10 times in the video plus 10 times over again is quite time consuming so the idea is is that if I do 50 I should be able to keep it down to say four videos absolute Max five videos and that would make it a little bit easier to do and plus people will probably be like you know what I want to hear about your top 50 games I didn't desperately need to hear about this the you know the 100 to you know to 60 to 51 or whatever so um taking the feedback on board I kind of agree with you lot so yeah I will do that there will be 50 top 50 soon but not top 100 it's too much and like I say it'll be more of a shift because then you'll be able to see the games that fall off my top 50 games are probably going to be more impactful as to talk about than what fell off my top 100 you know who cares what happened between 100 and 101 seeing what was previously 36 now no longer in my top 50 games would probably mean more so hopefully you'll enjoy that anyway we're under 15 minutes already and I've just been giving updates on everything else so uh yeah uh let's get on with what I want to talk about so first up uh let's talk about a game I played recently it's pretty small so this shouldn't take too long it's called 5211 can anybody answer why the hell this is called 5211 I have no idea why it's called this it reimplements a games called five colors okay that explains the five what's the 211 thing I honestly don't get what this title is take a drink there but it's a
japanesey game so Japanese designer and stuff I'm pretty sure it's to that t toosi hashii that's got to be Japanese surely um let's see the publisher maybe that will tell me next move asade ganos Pegasus Plan B anded all right that didn't tell me Jack um I think it's a Japanese game from what I've heard but this one is you know essentially a small filler game so looks pretty On The Backs and somebody offered to play it with me on you know the last couple of game nights so we played a few games of this uh now and basically what it all boils down to are these colored cards and they've got Point values between two uh sorry one and six but obviously in different distributions and the idea is is that you have a hand of five cards and you I think it's five four or five cards and you play two cards out on the first turn then one card then one card so you have played four cards out and around and everybody's doing this in term but what happens is the the scoring is the value on the cards but the colors are important so when you finish the round based on player count if there's too many of a certain color out that color doesn't score at all and it moves on to the next majority color to score only the largest color scores but then if there's a tie breaker between the top two none of them score and it goes to the next color down so you're kind of trying to influence the game state so that the colors are in such a quantity in such a way that you'll benefit the most and you rinse and repeat this until the deck runs out and then score out the points there's a little what I would
like to say is a bit of a tacked on Mechanic in this where some of the uh it's not oh yes here we go some of the cards have got these little they're called Kad Doo lizards or sorry Kad Doos on there and basically if you get six of them out or again depending on player count you get a certain amount of them out then all the colors don't score and you just score the lizards for a point each and you know it's a little side thing I've yet I've seen it happen once in all the hands we've done so this is not something that happens on a common basis but uh the the whole idea of I mean I've wondered what the hell are you on about with a Kad Doo did you not mean Komodo as in the uh kodo but no apparently a Kad Doo is a real thing thing um pretty no that's not it uh okay seriously do you know how long it took me to find this if you Google Kad Doo it doesn't come up with anything because it imagines that you are finding kodo Dragon it automatically assumes it with the AI and stuff so this was a pain so I have to actually find a copy of the rule book Thank you to ultra board games blog for actually having the rule book here written out a kodo is a beautiful turquoise colored lizard found on the islands of caro and Aruba great you learn something new every day but Co blindly was it hard trying to find that okay back to the uh back to the plot so 5211 this game you know is fine but it is kind of devoid of a lot of decision making for the most of it you know I like the scoring system where like you've got to think all right are the colors about to uh you know Screw are
you about to screw over on the colors you know are you going to score are you about to get screwed out on that but the fact of the matter is you draw the cards randomly from the deck so some rounds you just have a hand that does not work I mean you could be going last and a round and by the way the rule book does not have an explanation for how you do tour and order I'm serious the rule book literally does not tell you how to decide the first player that is an utter fail I mean okay at the start of the game you could just do it randomly fine but the game should explain how it then works for the rest of the round because there is a clear advantage to going last compared to going straight first but the rule book doesn't explain so we play it where one person's first player and then it just rotates round but but for crying out loud you couldn't find room in your rule book to explain that major aspect of the game that isn't utter fail but you know I digress the game play is okay you might find yourself though where somebody puts out two orange somebody else puts out two green another person puts out green and an orange and your hand doesn't have anything of green and orange well then you are basically just wasting the hand and nothing you do is going to matter to it and this can happen more often than not but it's really just based on your hand of cards I mean you could just draw the worst card uh for the game and also these Point values range from 1 to six now there's not that many cards that are priced at four five and six most of them are one two and three but if you don't draw any of the fives and sixes then your score is capped because you just can't score a lot for your cards yeah I won this round but I've only got ones and twos so what am I supposed to do whereas you you know
you managed to jump in on a color by fluke that is winning the round and you had a six so even though I had three cards to contribute to this color I actually get less points than you because you were fluky enough to draw six so that doesn't make any sense why weren't the point values closer together why weren't they just one to four you know or two to three sorry two to four or something like that I don't get why one to six was deemed a good idea so the game just kind of lacks a lot of decision making and it lacks much in the way of fairness with you know L mitigation or anything so it does the job as a filler and I don't hate it I don't mind it but it it just has very limited scope um I don't like playing it with too many players because I think too many players just adds to the luck Factor so I feel like you're best playing this with a cap of four three player works all right so I think three or four is kind of best I think two is probably too low and five is too many but yeah I mean it's fine it does the job and I like the quirkiness with the scoring system in this but I just think the luck mitigation is too low um even for a filler and I think that you know the I the fact that you are just restricted to that hand of four cards and you could just have a round where you can't do anything it just seems a little bit n it's me it's fine I'll play it if you put it on the table but overall I just found this one you know okay at best Straight afterwards we played a game of Love Letter and I instantly had more fun with that so sometimes the old ones are
the best ones but yeah it it was interesting to try it cuz I like trying out some of these uh you know Asian quirky card games cuz you do get some utter gems in there sometimes this one just wasn't particularly one of them all right let's talk about uh uh I hate to have to talk about this cuz it feels like I'm just contributing to the um you know the hype and all the things surrounding it but let's talk about finpan oh boy um this has been doing the rounds lately hasn't it this is ston me's recent announcement and bearing in mind ston meire may not necessarily lately be the best at game design I mean let's face it uh Charter Stone expeditions Pier pendulum uh stamp swap I heard that was pretty bad you know yeah they're not exactly doing great lately with their game choices and worms span basically just rehashing wingspan but making it worse you know so you know but they are very good at business decisions when it comes to generating hype for their games or getting online awareness they clearly have done their homework as to how to manipulate people and how to get you know social Med are completely going crazy over their stuff so fair play I can't fault them from a business perspective they are a business at the end of the day and they clearly know their stuff you know I'm kind of slightly jealous of that but you know in terms of game design it's certainly been lacking but this I think is going a little bit too far okay it was bad enough with worms span at least you
could say it began with a W so from wingspan it was worms span and then at least dragons have wings so you kind of argue that as a spin-off that fine but th spam and I had to really Double Take I honestly thought this was an early April Fool's joke you I didn't believe it was a thing at first and then I saw so many threads on it and then I saw this page and it's like oh God no you are legitimately doing this aren't you you really are doing this wow um okay so on the one hand I like fish I'm totally down for learning about more fish and seeing pictures of good fish I'm totally f b with that I think as a theme I think this will be pretty cool thin span is probably the worst attempt to come up with a reason that this is a rehashed version of wingspan ever I mean the amount of memes that are going around with xpan you know literally like flogging a dead horse span and all this stuff I've seen you know it's ridiculous the memes are all over the place like I said they're good at business not necessarily game design but you know the the amount of memes is just getting a little bit ridiculous now like I literally can't turn on Facebook without seeing a ton of these memes going around and it's get tiresome already and it hasn't even been 24 hours so since I started looking it's just a kind of a mix bad like that now it's got some things going for it I mean 45 to 60 Minutes length so it thinks it's going to be shorter than wingspan although wingspan's typically only about 60 to 75 minutes in length when you play it with people who don't AP like crazy so 5
minute setup time I'll be the judge of that because very few games set up in 5 minutes in front that come out of a box so yeah I'm a bit on that and one to five players let's just assume it's a one to four player game Let's assume it's 2 to four with a variant for solo and five is too many because pretty much all the cases five is too many so what exactly is this going to be well let's see you're a marine researcher seeking to observe array of Aquatic Life in the colorful sunlight zone uh Midnight Zone and Twilight Zone Of The World season oceans I wasn't aware that they were split up into zones like this again you learn something every day um in in thin Manan God I hate that name the fish you discover over four weeks will generate a series of benefits as you dive deeper into the ocean so okay so when you look at the board I mean yes it looks gorgeous I mean I want these player boards now you even just from a prototype copy but you can definitely tell it's got the wingspan formula in here you have a tableau grid you have things in rows which clearly when you activate rows are going to get you bonuses the fish and the fish tokens and these little other tokens you place on presumably egg so I suspect they're going to feature in a similar fashion to the other one you know does or maybe it's a way of getting more fish like hatchlings and stuff but yeah there's definitely elements of the wingspan thing here I mean you can see the card layout yes they're they're horizontal now instead of vertical but you can see the iconography is very similar to what you would expect in wingspan now does
that mean I've already like decided the game's going to be terrible of course not I think that a lighter version of wingspan that's for an even more accessible audience that teaches you about really nice looking fish is certainly a lot better than a heavier version of wingspan teaching you about fictional dragons I mean they came up with a law book in that to explain what each of the Dragons was it's all made up so what do I care about your law book explaining your madeup dragons but you know a similar book to tell me about all these birds all these fish much better because at least these exist in real life it's based on reality I actually might get some learning out of this you know I've already learned that apparently there's a Twilight ghost or was it a midnight Twilight and sunlight zone I've I mean well I I don't know is that legit is there a fish expert fish expert that can tell me if that's legit maybe I've just latched onto that and assumed it was true but you know I got to be a little bit careful with that respect so you know could this be really good I don't know but it's world of wingspan so I'm people are crying out cash grab even I'm kind of thinking cash grab because this game may be really cool but I think you should stop trying to associate everything with wingspan this this kind of thing where you name something after a game that's done popular and an attempt to get the height driven is a classic business cash grab tactic it's one where you basically go right we don't reckon this game will stand alone on its own if we call it something unique in that so therefore we need to just basically say it's related to a game that was stupidly popular and
that will instantly generate height and it works as a business tactic but it's also something that makes my eyes roll you know this could have easily just being called its own thing I mean called it school of fish you know call it you know anything remote like related to fish but not fins span that is just stupid um and make it its own game and it would look pretty and I would give it a look I would happily give it a play regardless but the fact that you've basically tried to say oh it's another Wings band rehash you know a it doesn't make me you know confident that you haven't just rehashed a lot of the Mecha mechanisms and not come up with anything new here um or because it says familiar let different mechanisms well you said that about worms span and yes worms span certainly does feel pretty much like wings ban with extra steps but all the extra steps you shoved into worms ban made the game worse than Wings ban so I'm hoping that what you do here doesn't make thin span ultimately worse than worms span because that will be bad you know I would like to see this beond the the the level of wingspan and that's a tall order cuz Wings band is one of my favorite games ever and it is brilliant if this one could be slight you know not as good as Wings ban but still really really awesome I'm totally down for that but worms ban did not meet the uh you know the mark for me on that front you know check out my review for more honest details on that so you know will this be good I certainly want to review it and play it apparently this is getting um uh released around January or at least that's when you're supposed to be able
to like that's when it's launching now the only thing I'm a little bit concerned with is when it says launch on January 22nd does that mean you can buy it from this website on the 22nd because if that's the case then I'm wondering if that means you'd have to buy it from here and you would need to be uh you know the you'd have to be like one of their stonem Champions to get it cheap or something I'll bet you a million pounds this has already been sent as a copy to the the the best friends of stonem to basically give High popular reviews U verdicts for it you know I'll bet you a million quid that's already happened but so you know so definitely when you start seeing them appear check who's done them you'll know who I mean but you know I definitely want to jump into this one so I would like to get this game I'd like to give it an honest review and hope it's really good I hope you know I mean Wings sorry Wings you know ston meer started off so well for me Scythe vid culture wingspan these were brilliant games I still have them in my collection yes Cy's gone down a little bit but VI culture I still really love wingspan I still really love and I want them to go back to that level of greatness but lately they just haven't been doing it it's too much business tactics and less about good game design and it's shown it's really down my opinion of their games so I want to see them rise back up to you know to Greatness and maybe this could be the start as much as I hate the fact it's a Wings band game with fins ban in that whatever let's let's gloss over that and just jump into it with an open mind and
hope that the game stands on its own merits rather than trying to piggy back off something else to be good so yeah we'll see you know hopefully people can stop it with the memes cuz that's starting to get older very very fast but I will see if I can get a copy of this I mean if it releases in the UK around January then you bet I'm going to buy a copy of this cuz I bet you a million pounds I'm not getting a review copy of this one so you know I'll I'll pay for it with you know with my own money and you know try and get review out as quick as possible because I think we're going to need an honest review on this one cuz I worry that there's going to be a lot of artificial hype for it so we'll see but you know I'm willing to be impressed please impress me man finpan why just why okay right let's go back to the topic of the day I've got about 23 minutes before I need to start heading off so we know we'll try and keep this one relatively short but an interesting premise turned up recently um I was playing a game of Dune Imperium and dune Imperium I find above average at best and even then you need to throw in the second expansion for me to give it any more props than that because I like the immortal expansion I like the card system it throws in it makes the deck building element more interesting where in the base game and even with the first expansion the deck building simply isn't interesting enough so it's all about the work of placement and the work of placement is kind of boring not to mention your ability to actually go to where you want to go is entirely dependent on luck of the draw people seem to miss this part but the yeah I
play the base game only of it recently and I was teaching it to players they were super AP super long with their turns the game took like three and a bit hours to finish the base game of Doom with four players I nearly wanted to shoot myself I was going mad but uh you know that's more the players rather than the game although let's be honest D Imperium is not the shortest game over come on guys but the thing of something crossed my mind when I was talking about it you know we Dune Imperium is well probably one of the most like ugliest the games that has come out you know it is I'm sorry whether you love doing Imperium or not fair play to you but I do think it's overrated I think six onboard Game Geek is just taking the chronic piss but the um you know the game cover looks absolute dull as ditchwater I mean oh hang on let me get the actual uh thing up that would actually help there we go yeah I mean that that cover does not inspire you to buy the game at all and then you get into the actual game itself and you could argue that the artwork is passable but I would say at most it's passable and that's on the cards but you've then got these cards here which are just icons and then you've got the board with the cubes and these little wooden pieces that are just dull like it looks Bland it looks boring as anything so the argument I had was whether or not you love this game or not I mean fair play if you love this game then be by all means go love the game but would you have loved it as much if it wasn't based
on Dune because this came out with all the hype of the movies and yes I have watched both the Dune movies the second one is fine I don't know actually the first half of the second movie is still boring but the second half at least picks up when I don't want to say spoilers uh a character goes through a slight transformation and at that point the it becomes more interesting but the first half is still pretty bland and boring the first movie put me to sleep it apart from like a couple of cool things with the voice and you know some half decent acting in some respects man the first film drags on and on it's like 3 and 1 half hours to tell me literally nothing I mean it's supposedly the first half of the first book and I know the book's massive but Jesus get on with it but I digress so you know this came out with the popularity of the Doom movies would you have looked at this game if it wasn't attached to Dune this is a question I'd like you to ask your because I don't think this game would have got anywhere near as much traction if it wasn't attributable to do now the game is not the most ftic game in the world you could have easily pasted some generic Space theme on here so it could have been any space thing you wanted it didn't have to be Dune but if they had done that would you have given this the time of day I bet I'm willing to bet a million pounds you would not because the game just doesn't look inspiring but because it had Dune on the title everybody went towards it and then started playing it and then you know some people hate it some people like it I mean God God that looks so Bland on
that picture but you know this is this all got me thinking are there other games where the IP is the sole reason it's popular because you can imagine that some people if this had a generic Space theme on it some people would have looked at this game and probably liked it and talked High Praise of it but I bet anything it wouldn't have got the the distribution that it did it wouldn't have got like The Wider releases or anything it wouldn't have got the expansions and stuff you know this would have kind of been popular with some people and then just died a slow death you know pretty positive of that so are there other games that's a bit interesting word miniature but the you know is there other games that would have also done this so let's take a game that I really like okay let's be fair let's let's take um both sides of the story Deep Rock Galactic so deep rock Galactic this game you know is a game that I have praised I think it's my favorite Skirmish miniature game it really is something I love and part of this maybe you could argue is because I adore the video game I still play the video game I you know I think I got a spare 20 minutes I fancy doing a quick level log on favorite character is a scout get on play a game could turn it off and go elsewhere you know it's a very good pickup and play game especially when you get to the skill level that I am where not to brag but I'm pretty damn good at this game um you know so and it's a co-op so you can you know you're using your skill to help everybody but would I have liked this game enough if it wasn't Deep Rock Galactic now
I would say that it is probably true if this was just another generic Space theme it probably wouldn't have even got my interest at first but I would argue especially compared to something like Dune that with Dune I swear you could probably take that theme off and paste a new one on and it wouldn't be too difficult but this one because it's based off of video game IP there was a lot of thought put into how the characters are bed what you're doing in the game all the different aspects of the video game game are represented mechanically in this one so I think this would be a much trickier try to just replace it with a generic Space theme but certainly that helps I'm not going to lie you know if this did not have the Deep Rock Galactic theme if this was literally just space dwarf mining the board game and it was just you know a bunch of unnamed dwarfs going up against random Critters or something then yeah I'd agree I don't think this would have got the traction that it did you know we got pulled into this because it represents an IP that's popular but because they did such a good thing of representing the IP then I give it a little bit of slack you know because at least they didn't just paste on the IP for no reason I mean you w't pasted on IPS let me tell you let's see uh Naruto um okay so Naruto Naro jpin in that it's one of my favorite animes that I've watched um and yeah really cool like the anime but then you get this stuff like Naruto shapo and de building game we
know what deck building games are like when they just say deck building game they are usually horribly generic and they just have IPS pasted on them for the sake of ips well this wouldn't have got me interested to play this game regardless of the fact that you shove Naruto on the box because I kind of know that deck building games or whatever um other ones I don't know uh something uh let's see I'm trying to think of other IPS that been bolted on um if we go Marvel Dice Marvel Dice we got Marvel Dice Masters dice Throne um you know dice Master there something just called the dice game I mean to be honest actually Dice Masters is another a bad example because you know if this was just a generic dice game where you took like dice with symbols and built them up or whatever then I don't think it would have got anywhere near the popularity it did unless you made them all Marvel characters and then link the abilities and stuff like that to the Marvel characters definitely this one is an aspect where a generic theme wouldn't have worked and the Marvel IP certainly made this one uh but I think that's kind of like the argument you could see both ways there are some games where you can argue that yes the IP is the reason the game did well there are some situations where you can say that the IP helps but it doesn't matter and I suppose this is kind of where the hard bit comes in because you know I could think that maybe Doom would never have worked if you didn't have the IP Deep Rock Galactic potentially would have been the same thing but you argue that because the theme is so well represented it
would be a lot trickier to not use the IP there then we've gone to the Other Extreme where deck building dice game whatever with a generic IP is not going to matter I mean let's say it uh let's take um is there a game called there was a game called Minecraft wasn't there uh well there's been several so we got Minecraft Builders and biomes we got Minecraft Heroes of the village portal Dash Minecraft card game question mark not sure why it's got that but all right let's have a look so so this one was okay so what we got Minecraft Builders Junior whatever okay so let's take a look at the original so 2019 Minecraft Builders and biomes Minecraft is one of the most popular video game IPS that exists on the planet so much so that they're doing a movie which I swear looks terrible um I don't have an interest in Minecraft I've never played Minecraft the movie looks like it's trying to basically pull a Jumanji and with lesser no with less good characters I mean I like em Myers she's lovely um and Jason mamur can be funny but Jack Black is very hit and miss although Jack Black was also in jiman so you know you can tell it's basically just rehashing it uh but you know that alone this game's not exactly popular is it I mean it's ranked 175 overall which is actually fairly good for a game in that but I've seen this I haven't seen this played anywhere I've seen nobody like put this on the table I haven't seen any families with it I've seen no nobody have this game despite the fact I'm
seeing what clearly looked like Gamers playing it was that a publicity photo I don't know but the you know is it good to me it's published by Ravensburger which doesn't help because that doesn't exactly scream popularity with like hardcore Gamers but is the game any good I don't know but I haven't seen Minecraft fans going Dali over it despite the fact it is based off Minecraft so you know in this case did the IP make a difference I think you could probably argue no it didn't really um but you would IP improve some other games maybe well let me take one of my other favorite games literally played it the other day Sentinels and the Multiverse now I love Sentinels and the Multiverse it's about superheroes now they've invented their own kind of law but that's their own invention it's not really an IP so would I have loved this as much well I already love the game would it have been better if it was based on Marvel maybe I mean it's certain would have been quite cool but then we already have Marvel Champions on the Shelf you know it would have um uh still and I realize the picture is not up there we go yeah so Sentinels and the Multiverse you know marvel Champions is done by Marvel it's a different game and I enjoy that one a lot not as much as Sentinels though Sentinels has been in my top 10 sometimes my number one game of all time for so long you know whether in its original version or this new version which is definitely the one to get but it's generic uh well not generic sorry it is it's made up hero these are not you know these are original Heroes
they're not based off an IP and I still love the game to bits maybe if it was based on Marvel and DC maybe I wouldn't like it as much I don't know but you know maybe I would like it a little bit more just because I could say I'm going to take Doctor Strange into this combat and do this instead but then a lot of the times I'm comparing these people I mean bunker looks a bit like Iron Man and tachon is basically the flash you know they're blankly sort of half parodies of particular superheroes I mean this is literally practically the Superman Batman Iron Man The Flash and whatever you want to compare to absolute zero I guess that would be um what's his name is he called Frost or Frost zero or is he just called zero or chill something I forget what's he called in um uh in The Incredibles is like wife where's my super suit you know what this character was it Frozone or something something like weird but you know it's basically that so you know this game would have maybe been better for me if it used an IP but it didn't really need it it the game stood on its own Merit so it does go to show that you don't need an intellect and I'm realized I've been saying the word IP and not actually saying what it means but it's intellectual property you know so hopefully you got the gist of that but the the the idea with it needing an IP is you know a false one it doesn't need an IP to be popular but going back to the whole Dune Imperium thing I jumped into Sentinels because it was superhero themed you know I didn't know you know just didn't have an IP it was just made up superheroes I didn't care I jumped into it and I loved the game you know
would I have looked at it more if it was Marvel maybe but I didn't need to but I would argue something like dun Imperium did need the theme and so benefited from that um okay let's have a look at some let's have a look at the top 100 games uh sorry browse all board games let's have a look at the top 100 on board game game let's forget about where things are ranked you know it was a different story but let's look for stuff that is based off an IP so an intellectual property uh all right here we go W the ring second edition would this one have been as popular if you didn't have the IP I I think the IP certainly helps I think the fact that this is Lord of the Rings certainly gets people interested to try it but I think the game is good enough to stand on its own merits that it didn't need the Lord of the Rings IP but then the thing is what you do in the game in terms of the factions and getting the Frodo to the Mount Doom and Stu is it Mount Doom or is it Mount Doom Mount Mordor I forget Mount it's got Mount Doom is it I forget God blame it's been so long since I've watched Lord of the Rings um but uh does it say the Middle Earth jumping in uh political track Waring come on saon Shadow Armies come on somebody tell me and get me out of this oh my God yeah is it I swear is Mount Doom right I don't know that just sounds so whatever um the idea is though is that this game does have mechanics that are based off the IP it's written on so you know this you could argue that this game would just be any old generic faceof game if it didn't have the IP and
I'm I could probably side towards that argument you know you need Lord of the Rings for this one to work honestly I don't think a lot of people would have looked at it if it wasn't and so it has become quite popular as a result but providing your into two players that Star Wars perfect example actually I mean Star Wars games you know Star Trek anything that is super super welln and mainstream you know would a lot of these games work if they weren't and I I'd like to think that the IP does carry a few of these games I mean what's the recent one the Star Wars deck building game which is basically just a rehash of Star Realms now Star Realms already worked as a great game so you could argue that maybe you didn't need a IP but then if somebody just made another generic rehash of Star Realms and gave it its own IP would you have really latched onto it as much you know other than the fact that it had Star Wars in the title and let's face it you don't need star wars in the title The Star Wars deck building game doesn't have any mechanics in it that mean it must be Star Wars so you know there that's the example where I don't like them using IPS because it feels like the IP is just there to carry the game if it makes no difference to the game see my already argument with deep rock Galactic you need Deep Rock Galactic to be the IP in that one you know you don't need Star Wars and a lot of these ones but Star Wars rebellion I mean it's got its popular events I think Star Wars rebellion would have been fine if it wasn't themed on Star Wars you could have pasted did any generic Space theme over it or any other actually any other space IP really I'm pretty sure you could even make this a dune game really
if you tried but it's you know it works as a Star Wars game and it certainly is a very good game very popular but yeah you know the IP I think certainly helped to get this one known and I think that's kind of like what most of these intellectual properties are designed to do they're not designed a lot of the time to make the game better although like in D they kind of do they're more designed to to get people to want to look at it in the first place it's essentially a marketing tool when you boil it all down and I mean I wish that more people would try to use the IP properly and not just use it as a carrying tool I mean it's it kind of it's one step away from being like Sony pictures with their whole like where they' hun on to their Spider-Man villain license and then produced all those really bad movies you know Madam web and uh Craven and you know morbia and some of the Venom well to be honest none of the Venom movies were particularly good they just had their highlights now and again so you know they hun on to that license and just made God awful movies just to keep the license and now we're at the point where we're sick and tired of them that we don't want to see any of them because the IP is not working anymore uh but what else we got on here so those aren't IPS Dune so we've already got Dune Dune twice in the top 20 it's the same freaking game um but seven moners duel brass Nemesis Clank I mean these aren't IPS so where's the first IP I mean Arkham Horror okay Arkham Horror I mean the culu Mythos uh
that is certainly an IP that does uh drag a few people in although you could argue that a lot of people are actually getting turned off by this IP because it is everywhere you know you there are a lot of games out there that use the culu Mythos um without needing to I mean you've got Arkham horor the card game which is a very thematic story driven game uses the stories and the characters and the law and does a fantastic job of it on the other hand they also made a love letter culu game where is it uh Lovecraft letter um Lovecraft letter is fine I think the madness mechanic both works and doesn't work in it it's kind of a weird story but uh yeah you took a micro Game of Love Letter and pasted the IP on it and it's basically a card bluffing SL deduction card game yeah uh not sure it was needed for that so you know kind of an example of when the IP is kind of not needed uh let me put Arkham in the Box though what else from Arkham could work let's have a look so you got Arkham Horror Arkham Horror Arkham Horror Arkham Horror I mean it's all C Arkham Horror one way or the other the problem is it's showing all the um expansion packs um Arkham Express is that a culu game uh yeah Arkham Express is a Cooperative dice game uh working together to close Gates and eventually defeat the great one wow does that look horribly generic I mean it's ranked 2,924 but oh god look oh God that does
look horrible but hang on a minute did they literally just copy and paste the writing and the font from Arkham Horror second edition CU that looks exactly like it that's kind of weird but yeah kind of um an oddity in that respect but what else was I just thinking about H something came to mind in respect of like IP's used or something and I wanted to oh yeah where actually let's give an example of where the Arkham one does work actually unfathomable unfathomable and to another extent Battlestar Galactica its predecessor so you know let's give some love to both here um because I mean I think Battlestar galactor is too long for what it is and I've never watched a single episode of Battle Star Galactica so I don't get the law behind the characters I I all I knew was that people hated guas bolar so in the first game I played of this I played him just to see what would happen um you not knowing anything about the character but you know it's it's not something I feel like I want to go back and watch but uh oh actually this is actually a good example because the original Battle Star Galactica very popular but I don't think you could have made this game work if it didn't have battl Star Galactica on it I think the fact that it represented the characters the fact that it represented the story arc of being chased by the syons or whatever and like jump driving to a new part of space and the whole are you a syon are you not I think yes you could argue you could have made that into its own um non-ip thing but I think the IP really Drew people in
here you needed it to be Battle Star Galactica and that's why it was really popular because case in point as I was thinking about unfathomable Dark Moon sprung to mind because Dark Moon was meant to be the BSG express it was kind of like the short version of Battlestar galactic now Dark Moon was average at best yeah it didn't uh quite meet the mark on that one I mean it looks horrible it's not a very nice looking game at all but it tried to do this in a shorthand version but at the end of the day it just mean it felt very generic but also the dice mechanic felt like a forced version of bluffing and betrayal like sometimes you just had bad Dice and there was nothing you could do about it and this one never took on I mean people really didn't latch on to this one I mean what what is it even oh ah get my camera back on um what did it even rank as dark moon what's it ranked as 1491 that's higher than I thought it would be but still you know people don't really talk about this one at all and then we move on to unfathomable now people mostly still prefer B toore Star Galactica but there are some people who actually prefer this unimal one and I would like to try this at some point you know I want to see if it's any good but it's definitely going to be an event game and I'm going to have to know how to play it ahead of time it's going to be one of those things but I would like to play this but this works with the Arkham theme because you're on a ship and it uses the Deep ones now the Deep ones as
far as I'm aware I'm not an expert on Arkham law but they I can't remember if they infect you or it's just something about being close to them it's just like a hor Supernatural thing but basically people start getting infected quote unquote and become deep ones so you notice skin changes you notice colorization differences and ways of behavior and so the whole thing of like are you on my side are you not uh the setting the fact that you've got these deep ones in the water sort of causing havoc and that works but this is not this is using the Arkham lore and I think making it fit the game very very well now if you made this a generic IP like no Arkham law and you triy to remake Battlestar Galactica as generic theme whatever guarantee this would never have got any traction whatsoever you know I mean this one is still not overly popular I mean some people really love it but it's not exactly you know best game ever type thing but yeah come on you take a game that is thematically sound like the Battle Star galactico board game and then don't put a decent intellectual property on top of it you would have just died a quick death and nobody would have cared you know certainly this one failed at its mission to make it shorter than Battle Star gal ago cuz that's what they claimed it would but as we know Fantasy Flight is unable to ever make a game short because Fantasy Flight games doesn't know the meaning of short they just seem to make games bloated in terms of their length
but you know still want to try it but yeah that you know this theme and IP works with the game just like it did with Battle Star Galactica so yeah let's get a um uh drink here we go go there we go so yeah interesting little topic discussion i' be interested to hear your thoughts on the subject so by means if you're watching this on YouTube get your comments down below do you think that intellectual properties are the main reason a lot of games get traction uh are there examples of games where you don't think the IP mattered like you know whether it was on there or not the game was still really good or really terrible despite it however see previous point you know would it have been anywhere near as popular if cuz I think that's kind of the more aspect actually rephrase I don't want to talk about if the game is good okay whether you love dun Imperium or hate it doesn't matter at this at this point you know I don't hate Dune Imperium I just find it average I think it's horrendously overrated but I'm talking about the intellectual property would Dune Imperium have got the same level of popularity and traction if it wasn't tied to Dune and I want to see other examples of other games so other games with intellectual properties would they have been as popular if they didn't have the IP or would they have been more popular if they didn't have the IP like would it have been better if they didn't bother trying to tie it to a specific intellectual property um and now there
are situations where the intellectual property is used fantastically so I've mentioned Deep Rock Galactic and I've mentioned Battlestar Galactica and to an extent unfathomable these are examples where the intellectual property Works uh video games are pretty good for this aspect I mean this war of mine if you've ever played the this war of mine board game particularly with the second expansion the days of The Siege yeah um pretty much I don't think that would have worked anywhere near as well if you didn't make it this war of mine but the fact that this war of mine is a good game and it like the board game just sells that theme you know is another example of it working um just looking on my wall at the moment actually is there anything else I can see that's IP that's Star Wars well Star Wars outter Rim I don't think I would have really gotten into Star Wars outter Rim as much you know it's still on my shelf over there if it was just generic Space theme I mean if you made Star Wars out Star Wars outter Rim You could argue as kind of like a more better version of something like merchants of Venus or something and it's like well I didn't care about merchants of Venus you know I found it me average it best it was already dry and that but yeah you throw Star Wars into it and tie it to Bounty Huns and stuff and I love out Star Wars outter Rim it's one of my favorite games so yeah it definitely has um yeah I think the intellectual property is an interesting discussion point so what are your thoughts let me know and uh I look forward to reading some of those comments and responding when I can so anyway thank you everyone for tuning in thank you for getting me over the 25,000 sub Mark I do appreciate it if you do watch and like these videos then please sub if you haven't already I would really appreciate it I think that Bell
that you can click on that notifies you of more videos I've done is still a thing I don't know but if it is by all means cuz I do put out a lot of content despite the fact this is a hobby and uh yeah good things to come in 2025 so as much as I wasn't the biggest fan of 2024 too many bone dry Euros dominating 24 which I think a lot of people say 24 is one of their best years because they like a lot of those dry Euros whereas I don't um you know hopefully 25 brings us a little bit more theme shall we say or some more interesting settings than just generic Euro although I saw a Fred recently where somebody posted out like which anticipated games you looking for in 2025 and I just I've never heard so many generic titles in my life and I'm like oh no we're still in the Bland dry Euro territory aren't we so who knows but here's hoping that there's going to be a good 25 I probably will do a top 10 anticipated games this for 25 at some point whether I'll do it as a top 10 list I'll just make it a podcast episode we'll see but I need to do some research and actually look up some of these 25 games and see it's uh been very busy but yeah thanks everybody for tuning in uh take care remember it's only a game and I'll see you on the next episode so bye-bye take care love you all