Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 5 Industry Defining Board Games

Transcript 54:44

Hello and welcome to board shipping. My name is Wayne. I'm Matt. I'm Rob. Rob's back. Oh yes. Oh yeah. All out the cupboard. One more time. For an important one, Rob. Cuz this is it. Rob is our B stupid smashing defining guest. Yes. And this is the segue into the show which is our top five industry defining, industry shattering, industry molding games. Yes. They can say you should play or know about it or you should know about it even if you don't want to play. The shape of things that's exactly they they created the shape of things to come potentially as well. So uh these are the games that did something really special to find out what those are. Uh you should probably hit the subscribe button. Subscribe button is there somewhere. You don't need to do anything industry defining or shattering. Just press the button shattering to our hearts. To our hearts.

Absolutely. Uh, and with that, should we dive into this episode, Jess? Well, I was going to say, guys, do we have a do we have an approach that we want to talk about, but they need to subscribe and then wait after after the the song. Come on. Rolling dice. It's a vibe. It's all we need to be game for you and me. Here's what you should play and see. All right. So, first up, I want to talk to these guys about what approach do you take? How do you choose your industry shattering games? Great, great question.

Uh Matt, do we all right? I think my list is it's quite long. So picking up just five is quite um I pick uh not just in terms of like I don't know uh mechanics. I pick a couple of things even about marketwise what they how they influence the market or some of them how they have influenced like later games. Uh so I kind of like went a little bit of pick a little bit of this a little bit of that. So it's not just going to be purely on mechanics. Okay. Yep. Oh, you're up. I think mine lean a little bit more into how they've changed the shape of the market in the industry. Actually, I think that's going to be Well, you are an expert on that. An expert on the market. I think so. Some will say, some might say, some might say, it's uh so for me, I have looked a little bit at that and why I think a game has changed either the way the market and the industry works or how it's changed the culture of gaming, which I think is a big one. Interesting.

Yeah, you went um a couple of different things put together. They've either created or innovated a new game mechanism as you said there. So, um or have set new standards in some way, right? So where it might have been done before but not in such a package way. Sure. Um or otherwise created some sort of long-standing influence that is being felt right now. Okay. Okay. So I've sort of tried to blend those things together for for my choices. Yeah. Nice. Nice. What about crossovers? Any thoughts? I think you think there's going to be a few. I think there's going to be a few. I know games that kind of like they must be on this list. So, we'll do our top fives and then if they're not in this list, we're going to do some vulnerable vulnerable men. Honorable mention cuz we don't know each other.

Also, in fact, off that, do you have you have you picked like a time frame? Cuz for me, I'll say up front, I have tried challenged myself a little bit. I've picked the last 10 years. Okay. Scaling up because I mean there are things like like should chess be on this list? You know, it should. royal gang. It's a great question because you could go go you could even go back to the 1970s and go Dungeons and Dragons and June and things like that. I've I've gone from 1990. Okay. Yeah. So, a wider time frame. I think for me it's more toward end of the '9s, probably early 2000. Oh, so the last 20 I've gone broadest. Okay, good. So I think it feels like when you've gone for some of the older games, Matt, you've gone for kind ones where we're still I think some of the I'll even say for mine some of the effects we haven't necessarily seen fully play out.

Oh, I think I got one that is spicy. Seen that. Uh let's start with our number five. Rob, give us your number five. number five. Okay, channel, please promise me. Promise me you won't just close this video at this point. What I'm going to say, bear with me. Bear with Rob. What I'm going to say, you might think I'm joking, and I'm not. Ready, boys? Please don't. As I say, I've gone chronologically. I'm looking at the last 10 years. The first in my list came out in 2015. Okay. Okay. There's a game called Say It. Exploding Kittens. Are you okay? I'm going to leave the room.

What have I done? Stop the video. What have I done? Stop the video. I shouldn't get me back in the cupboard. Exploding kittens. Let me try to rationalize. I'm kidding. I'm kidding. Let me talk about why. I can understand. I can understand. I had an idea to put that kind of games in the list, but yeah. Let's see what what my reason. My reason is and and this is a little bit conjecture um but Exploding Kittens was raised $8 million on Kickstarter for many many years. It was the record-breaking game on Kickstarter and I really think it opened the floodgates for other publishers to look at Kickstarter as a very viable medium by which they can use to put games out. I I crazy as it may be, I don't think we'd have Gloom Haven without Exploding Kittens. Okay. Um, yeah, I think I think it showed that community can come first.

You can build off of a community and monetize uh that to create a game and put that out there in the world. And $8 million for many years, it held the records. And actually to this day, for a small box, what is it? 20 $20 card game. I don't Yeah, I don't think any other game has quite cracked that level. Uh, and I think it really showed a lot of consumers and a lot of publishers that Kickstarter was a viable model they could use to put their games out there into the world and for consumers to to buy them and create a nice product. There we go. Yeah, that's it. Love that. Well, I got something very similar uh but now kind of like slightly different twist and I'm talking about Zombie Side from Simon. The first Zombie Side that is Yeah. um Cards Against Humanity did or Exposing Kid did it like um toward the general consumer while Zombie did it for board gamers that wanted board games and wanted minis cuz it's Zombies being the first successful Kickstarter that opened the the doors to the million minis games that you can find smashed the market with and now we see where Simo sitting at today is how they went from there to there. But tell will tell, but it kind of like changed the market in that kind of like type of games. Um cuz now they they found that type of games. So a lot of minis, a lot of like a narrative

gaming like all these like gigantic boxes and everything found that spaces that was not on a shelf in a uh in a shop but was on Kickstarter. Um and and from then beside the million of zombie side that came out but again the the gloom maven the um all the the awakened realms products um and all the like the the shadow borns with um sworn and stuff all of that with a tons of minis probably would have not existed if the first zombie side was not that successful. we would not have that kind of general of games on our tables today. Maybe we're not going to have it anymore for a while at least, but uh we'll see what time well time will tell. But yeah.

And you Wayne, my one is from 1993. Off you go. So starting nice and early. Yeah. I had a young days when I was very young. Uh I was 10 years old when I got my first pack of these cards. It's Magic the Gathering. Okay. So Magic the Gathering for a bunch of reasons. Um, it basically invented the CCG model with the way that expansions work as well. That invented, I suppose, that competitive meta type play as well, taking your card game to a tournament and then playing that. The whole deck construction, the collectibleness, the scarcity model with value, uh, the thing with print runs of of certain types of cards going in and out of print as well. um brought that sort of deck building deck construction to the mainstream. I remember playing this in school in the school playgrounds.

Um it took the collectible card game to the competitive world as well. Um it did loads. I think without Magic the Gathering, we wouldn't have had Arkham Horror the card game or um Marvel Champions and all that sort of stuff or or or any of those sorts of games or Pokémon or Yu-Gi-Oh and and all of those came up. Definitely. Absolutely. And that's a whole scene into itself. It is board game adjacent. It is in the board game sphere, but it's also influenced like a ton of other card games as well in terms of how the cards work. Tapping is like a Yeah. like a it's like a copyrighted word, isn't it? It is. It is. You can't use that. But it's like that whole thing and just that whole model of you know I think it's industry shattering uh for a number of reasons and that's my first one. Magic the Gathering. I like it. I like it. Number four. Number four.

Number four. Rob, moving into number four. Number four. Okay, folks. This one is kind of my exploding kittens adjacent game. It's almost in some sense is the polar opposite and that's why I think it's important. And that game uh it's kind of had a couple of iterations. It's most recent iterations of the 1.5 edition which I think was in 2017. That is Kingdom Death Monster. That one. Okay. The reason I say that is because where Exploding Kittens was the small box $20 card game that broke all the records on Kickstarter. Yeah. Yeah, Kingdom Death came along and said, "Hey, that grandiose dream you've got, that insane crazy game that you shouldn't be able to make, frankly, can now be made."

You know, it is a lifestyle game of epic proportions. The kinds of funds that people have sunk into Kingdom Hearts are enough to buy a relatively nice car. As far as what I can see from when you see it on sale, it's huge. It's uh complex. Complex. It's got emergent storytelling. It's got massive campaigns. It's got the works. It's got boxes upon boxes upon boxes boxes of the wazoo. And it's almost like that polar opposite to the the little, you know, it smashed a ton of records as well on Kickstarter in in or at least it sits in those top 10 kind of biggest sales ever on Kickstarter. Yeah. And yet where Exploding Kittens came along and said, "Here's a thing for for the mass market and we're using a new model to get it out there, Kingdom of Death came along and said, hey, look what Kick Kickstarter can do. Look what it can get to the table. This huge.

Yeah, it's one of those games that is for 1% of the ball game population, but that one% it just like it becomes their life. It's just like their life game. They just play that and it's one of those like throw the sink at it game cuz it just like you got enormous boxes. got tons of expansion that you're probably never going to play. are a when but I know myself was I'm one of them that you buy just because like oh one day I'm going to finish them when I retire I think it sort of reflects what you were saying Matt about about Zombide as well because I I do think without Kingdom Death you know I said it I said it with Bloom Kit as well but I don't know if we'd had if we'd have had the likes of Bloom Haven as I say because I think it just opened the gates to this kind of large scale and you've had these these these games that are almost outdoing one another with the absolute massive scale of things like uh there was the one last year. Was it enormity? Yeah, you a pledge was somewhere around guess who bet was around $1,000, right? No. Well, yeah, the some of some of them. No, I got the I got the basic one. I got the core box and maybe one the stretch goes.

No more than that. I've been very good this year. You've been very good. I've been I've been I've not backed that much and I back always just like core and stretch go. Good on you, man. So, what's your number four? Um my number four um talking about Lord of Water Deep for one reason for one reason specifically uh cuz it's been um the first game u that I remember as a like as a Dungeon and and Dragons player brought a lot of people to board games. Okay. It's a it's a work place at the end of the day. It's a it's a simple worker placement. Uh but being linked to a very successful IP brought a lot of people toward that game and then realize that the game is actually good.

So it's not um there have been IP games before that is going to be that that were like tying like terrible mostly more terrible. That one actually it still is a very good game. Solid. Yeah. and it moved a lot of the Dungeon and Dragon, the RPG population toward the board game industry. So, it kind of like link two worlds together and it demonstrate to the market that you can do an IP game that is actually really good. Yeah. Uh and it still it's a game that people still love and still plays and um Yeah. And it's fantastic for that. It's a very sort of I think there's a there's a thing of like these disperate hobbies that are actually very very connected and like RPGs sort of skirmish kind of games like you know on the big grand scale like Warhammer and board games uh Magic the Gathering like players who are in those groups and haven't necessarily leaked over and yet so much of what you love about your hobby if you're in one of those very close like if you I always think if we can just pull a few more Warhammer folks over the board games. It's like, but I found a lot of time warmer people if you put them on um um uh board control game or like you know the the area control stuff that they they they really like it and uh I think that is where should go.

Yeah, I think Warham GW should stop making just dungeon crawler for their side games and do something slightly different. But uh we'll see. We'll see what they they want to do. And Wayne, what about your number four? Moving up to 1995. Of course, we're going back in time. Yeah. From 93 to '95. It's okay. We're getting closer to Spice Girl Scales were not still not a thing, right? No. And you, this one is the game of 1995. And it's set of katan. So, katan, I don't think I could have made this list without featuring katan because it basically created the modern hobby game renaissance. This is the modern board game renaissance. It couldn't it couldn't have occurred without class to fantastic seinal title. Um, it did a few things. It it created this sort of resource negotiation type thing in the board game as well. This modular board with a relatively light rule set as well. Um, it introduced that sort of euro mechanisms to the wider wider public where you've got this resource management as well, sort of trading with your with your partners, pretty low randomness. Well, you got the dice of course, but a relatively low randomness.

Um and uh yeah it is now even to this day uh a massive seller has spawned tons of different versions latest new edition which is real nice. I saw it I saw it yesterday. I was in down in Brighton. I went to the D saloon if D saloon is watching. Hello. Um and they made they made a call edition basically because it's it's cool. It's the square box that fits perfectly into a call. Straight in there. Yeah. just like that's marketing. Yeah. Loads of additions of it and it's a it's a very nice product. Yeah. Um still playable. It's it is playable. It's a board game. It's a very entry levelvel board games. It's a is a games that you play with families. We we younger uh family members and um yeah, not well probably not for me, not for you, not but but it's the thing. This is one of those games where even people that don't really play hobby games, they might know Katan. And that's the impact that that game has had to bring people into the hobby. So that was my number four.

Katan. You see it. Perfect. Rob, number three. What you got for us? Number three. We are zooming ahead a few years. As I say, we've we've left Kingdom Death. We left the Kickstarter thing. Left or behind? Well, we're still talking about a Kickstarter game actually, but my next game I think is redefining a genre as we speak. We're zooming ahead to 2022 and that game is Blood on the Clock Tower. So, I am a big fan of the game. I'm a big fan of the game. I'll say that. But this is I I have a lovely thing with Blood on the Clock Tower because um we were playing it from the early days. Uh we had a kind of copy that was was sent from the folks at the Pandemonium Institute. Um did some work with Shut and Sit down around the the the the review and uh then it kind of went on to Kickstarter. The game was about 2 years in the making and when it arrived I was desperately like pulling people together. I was like any friend who had even a minute amount of interest, just a minutia, like a minute amount of interest, I would I would be pulling myself like this with locking the door.

You're not leaving. It's I I'm not kidding. I literally recruited people on the street. That's how desperate I was. I met a dude on the street talking about board games and I was like, "Please come over. Come over. Come to my place." And he turned up. Uh yeah, he turned he turned up with his friends looking shell shocked and we had a great time. And brilliant. The reason however is is not my personal love blow on the clock tower. What I feel we are witnessing is uh the de facto social deduction game taking shape. I think werewolf and mafia, I've talked about them on this channel before, but I think are are kind of slowly but surely falling by the wayside. And everywhere I am now seeing blood in the clock, it is clockwise everywhere. All of the conventions, cafe, every every convention, strange games festival, all those things that are they are just pushing clock tower repeatedly and the things that are happening around the game in terms of the community is growing and growing and growing. the wacky homebrew sets you're seeing sometimes with scripts that are kind of created from the existing roles and yet plenty of scripts I've seen where people have literally homebrewed sets of roles and made their own sets and the the game has become something of a phenomenon. I think it is changing the course of of social deduction. As I say a lot of my list is looking at potentials as well as just things that have happened and I think over the next 10 years we will see blood and clock tower just become the standard. Yeah. I mean we we saw it like every convention that we goes you will see like three four five groups of of playing um

playing it and uh and those groups are always full it's just like people playing for hours and hours and then another group will fill the room and then another group it just like is and this is goes from uh air to UKG to paradise the local night shop. Yeah, exactly. And there are uh I found out that we have a local um group as well. It's um it's amazing and it's not it invites a lot of people as well that are not board gamers but they enjoy that experience. Might get to the point where it's transcending the hobby almost. Yeah. Becoming it own that. Very nice. Matt you number three. Uh my number two three um is going to be seven wonders dual. Seven Wonders Jewel specifically specifically the Jewel because I think it created the today's trend of all the million dual games. Dual games high quality ones.

Yeah. So, it's been the first game that took an existing IP, an existing board game, creating its own spin-off version dedicated to two people, and making it a game that is probably better than the than the original, at least for my my taste. Um, but it's the one that showed everybody that, oh, two-player games are actually can be good, that are not just a knockoff of um of a larger game. Uh, and now we see that many dual game came out between today like this year and last year and next year they're just like a tons of it. But the all this new iteration of the dual version, I don't think they would existed without seven wonders duo. Yeah. And the the very fortunate collaboration between two industry legends, Antoine Bowser and Bruno Catala creating something absolutely magic. I mean, yeah, Bruno is an amazing two-player game specialist. I feel like deal with some of the duel.

Yeah, he does like Splender jewel. Yeah, exactly. Like when in doubt, you're making a jewel game. Let's go. I need Yeah, I think that's a great pick, man. I like that. Uh for me, which one was it? Where did we get to the hat? The hat. Okay, next one. Moving all the way up. It's 2004. Mhm. 2004. They were done probably. Yeah. So, we skip over and rightly so. We got to 2004's Ticket to Ride by Alan Arm Moon. So, probably had to be um this was a game that basically delivered a perfect family weight game with a phenomenal production uh with a relatively accessible price point that was widely available. It won the spielaris and did gang busters sales. I mean it did still does still does. It has spawned countless iterations. It's popularized didn't invent popularized potentially innovated in some way but more popularized the root building. Exactly.

So making that as a as a mechanism all of its own commercialized the hate drafting commercializ. Yeah. It can be played friendly and chill or it can be played by board gamers bloodlettingly ruthlessly. Um, Ticket to Ride is still a fantastic game. I will still happily play Ticket to Ride, whatever version. I think it's still great. Um, it is an example of a timeless design uh that has gone on to spawn again countless iterations. Uh, it's a great system. Uh, it can't not be on my list. Yeah, perfect. It's a crazy game as well for the for the the breadth of play that is in that rule set. I I I opened a copy recently. Uh I got my sister a copy. Hello sister. Uh but the rule set I'd forgotten like I I remember playing Ticket to Ride super early into the when I got into the hobby and it felt at the time it felt like wildly complex like you know as as all our first games do, right? But then the rule set I was like oh this is like two A4 pages the whole thing. And it's like all of that game is distilled into that. Uh it's brilliant right and it's easy to Yeah. easy to to teach like and people normally get it like very quickly even if it's something that root building can can sound a little bit complex but that is it's a thing as well I think when you you're talking about kitan and the impact it's had but what I love about ticket to ride is I don't think I it never kind of left the like in terms of

the love for that game if you if you guys finished this stream if we finished this vid and we were like play a quick game ticket to that be like yeah why not probably do that. That's true. Yeah. Yeah. It's a nice feeling game and uh legacy wise um it's just one of those like it's an eternal design that I think will probably always be around as long as board games in some How many how many versions there are now? Like manyund two-player ones like you got different maps. The legacy one supposed to be really good as well. So all sorts going on there. Should we move on? Threes done. Twos, Rob. Number two. Number two. Okay, Wayne, you mentioned Magic the Gathering. I did. And I'm going to zip the CCG trend up to the modern day, as I say, with uh with my list, looking at kind of ongoing impacts. For many, many, many years, the CCG space has been dominated by what's been called the big three, which are Magic. Magic, Pokemon, and Yu-Gi-Oh as well. Uh, do people actually play Yu-Gi-Oh? No, I've never played Yu-Gi-Oh. Played it, but it's big. It's big. Yu-Gi-Oh is huge. Uh, that being said, in the last two years, two years, 2023, Disney entered the space.

Okay, here's the Lana. Lana has been deemed that that space that I mentioned, the CCG space, which has been called the big three for many, many years, is now officially called the big four because Lana has come in swinging at a seemingly impenetrable kind of fortress of of of genre and broken its way in well and truly. And I think what we are seeing is an impact in terms of games that are being released now. We've had Star Wars Limited. We've had um Alford. Um you've got the One Piece card game as well. Nice. There is an ongoing kind of resurgence of CCG to some extent. And I think Lana really is dominating that and paving the way for and showing that CCG can be done in the modern age in and it's not kind of impenetrable as I say.

It's not kind of, you know, fully paved off at this point by those those those big three. Orcana has come along, busted its way into the space and brought a lot as you know that chat we've had throughout this around bringing new players into the space of people coming into board gaming through Lana which I think is wonderful. Um and yeah, you know, I hear reports of tournaments selling out literally like in a minute. I'm I'm to be honest, I'm quite surprised when it when he came out I I was pretty interested. Um, but then I thought it's going to be a bubble. They're gonna explode. People gonna think this is the new Pokemon in terms of like not the game itself, but the rarity of the card because it was all about Charizard going out for a million pounds. And I really thought that it just was going to be a bubble and that would have lasted three four months then people will lost interest will not have actually a re like a resale value. But I was wrong. Yeah. Yeah. So, I'm really glad that I got a couple of first edition boxes upstairs open. Never open them. Time to get into it. I'm going to I'm going to wait to ch Matt. Number two. Um my number two must be uh Pandemic. Yeah. Okay. Great.

Uh Pandemic um basically brought to the to the table the cooperative between between players. Uh well before it's always been um board game market like very much one versus all uh like you know yeah um it's always been competitive. You will always compete against the other person or the rest of the table or whatever. This one came and basically they're like no you can all be friends and you can all play against the the game itself. Um and then open against the door and brought a lot of people to ah cooperative. We can play like this. Ah uh what's the next one? I can play a dungeon crawler. Oh that's cooperative. And kind of like created okay this is the puzzle everybody around. Let's try to solve the puzzle.

Uh brought like stuff like I'm not saying escape rooms but kind of like yeah a little bit. This is is it's is the game giving you a problem that everybody together needs to collaborate to solve it to contribute to solve right and and again it's a game that how many copies sold like jillion jillion uh doing a lot of different iteration of the of the game and the game system with the the pandemic system applied to different to from World of Warcraft to like they did a different Star Wars Cthulhu rings coming Yeah, exactly. Lord of the Rings one. Um, stay tuned for that one. Matt E has basically made a name for himself as the cooperative design. Daybreak as well. Daybreak, which is amazing, by the way. We're stretching his concepts further. Um, and from 2008. So, it's just a game that's got an eternal engine that just seems that you can kind of flex it and stretch it and it still holds up however you put it into a system. somehow feels cuz the only cooperative game that comes to mind for me before pandemic was there was a Kitia put out a Lord of the Rings game um and it felt a little bit dominated by a sort of luck of the draw system and you kind of it's fun to play together and have a little bit of a Lord of the Rings flavor going on but it it was just kind of go through the motions I'm sure there'll be someone who will say you're playing it wrong the beauty of pandemic is you can sit down and you really feel like you're wrangling with the system and there is

That's not to say there isn't bad luck and luck of the draw in the game, but to a large extent it feels like when you sit down and play a game of pandemic, it's like if we play this right, I think we could probably um there's a little thing called legacy after. Yeah, exactly. God might talk about it might but yeah, the legacy as well brings that concept to an extreme but in a in a good way. That's um that's very very cool. So yeah, pandemic must be on this list, right? My number two about you. My number two is uh I went up to 2004 and I jumped over 2000 which is my mistake. I put wrote it on my list wrong but we're going 2000. So the year 2000 uh this game uh again is an eternal design. Uh and it's Carcasson. Uh and the reason Carcasson is here is because of basically the word meeple. got unpopularized, maybe didn't invent, but bas potentially invented the mele as we know it today. The little fat dude, little fat chunky uh wooden dude that is because of Carcasson. Uh pretty much to the point where they now litigate, I think. Yeah, there's been um yeah, sadly started litigating because they technically own that whole concept uh which is phenomenal. It also wider than the mele thing which is something that we'll think of as board gaming terminology lexicon forever I think until eternity and for that reason alone has to be on this list. Um but also that

gentle family weight tile laying to the wider market. I mean again like katan maybe not to the same extent people might have also heard of carcasson or might have also heard of ticket to right. So these days you you saw it in the target or water whatever your Yeah. Yeah. And it's another one if you if we finish this and you like should play Kakasan. Yeah. I could play a game with Kasan. I'm always up for that. Always up for that. And it's like actually again like Ticket to Ride. It can be played. I think there's that lovely thing with Kasan where it can be played relatively gently. Play at two levels. It can be played in a kind of calm let's build this build this place out and just score our own points and or you can be the cutthroat card. Yeah, sorry that's me. I am renowned.

Can't resist jumping in your sea. That's how it's going to be. And um in terms of it ongoing legacy, I mean you're seeing loads of versions, expansions all the time, reprints. um just that sort of again that sort of shared tile laying space I think is really interesting and how Carson popularized that. Um and again I think it'll still stay around for a long time. So on to number one. Rob, what's your number one most industry defining game? Industry shattering, groundbreaking, all of that. Okay. So, um I said at the start of this, please don't for the channel. Please don't hit unsubscribe. Oh god. One is unstable unicorns. No. No. No.

Don't worry. Don't worry. To be honest, to be honest, I I might have all this unstable unicorn ever existed. One of my guilty guilty pleasures. It is not. Another one. Top five guilty pleasures. Uh, it's not unstable unicorns. Don't worry. I come with a message of hope, I think, to publishers and designers. Um, because my my I'm bringing us right to 2024 where I think the impact of this game hasn't yet been fully witnessed. I like to think that it is going to have an ongoing impact. That game is Arcs. Okay. The blighted reach. Uh, I think there are a couple of things about arcs. Firstly, from a practical standpoint, Mhm. Uh I think it's lovely to see a campaign that is in a threeact system. It is all packaged wonderfully into a box. From a pure practical standpoint, from a pure kind of box design and game standpoint, that is just lovely. You've got this huge box, a chocolate box of like emergent narrative and uh wacky stuff that is stuffed into this game. But the reason I also want to bring up arcs is because as I say a bit of a message of hope for for publishers and a bit of a message of optimism. I think that what ARCs has done very very well and other games in the leader lineup as well as the sister company whly gig I think it is able to to bring together systems that are unusual sometimes unintuitive which can be a problem for a lot of people but it's then they are things that you will not have seen before. Yeah. And in a

world where we're often subjected to kind of games that we've we feel like, hey, this is an iteration on this. And that's not a bad thing. Hey, I play tons and tons of of euros every year and I enjoy every single one of them. And yet what I think ARX has done is presented us with something that is completely left of field. And it has created a system of mechanics for starters that are unusually blended together. Uh, it's created a campaign that is wholly unique in how it's structured and it's created something that is a game that I struggle to even talk about on a pure sort of mechanics and components kind of thing that I do with a lot of games because what it has done is almost elevated a medium I think to a point where it's almost like literary on its level. It's like it is an art form more than it is a game in some ways. And that might sound a little bit Yeah, I know what you mean. I think we we felt the same with the game. It's a game that kind of like you love or you hate and but it doesn't leave you numb.

Yeah, there's something making you feel and then it's kind of like a form of art cuz it's just like you're looking at it at something you feel something you can you don't like it or you like it but I think it's very I can't imagine anyone ever sitting down to try arcs and say I'm specifically really looking at the blighted reach pain expansion here and thinking I've seen that before like that's something I've done completely left the field and as I say what I love about leader games and what they are doing is the games they are putting out continue to do that. I think Root set that in stone to a large extent, the asymmetric kind of war game that it is and it continues to be a resounding success as their latest Kickstarter proved. Oath did the same for this neverending campaign that evolves as you as you play the game. And I think Arcs is in its very early days. We've seen the Blighted Reach. I have no doubt that there are things going on behind the scenes at Lita that they are going to be putting out new campaigns that completely fundamentally alter the stories that are told through that system. And I think it shows that if you have a wacky idea and you think this game isn't like what everything else is and you know is that going to break it?

I I don't think that that is the case when you look at what ARCs has done and the success it's had. And thus I hope that you put that idea to paper. Very nice. Yeah. Love that Rob. Very, very good. Uh Matt, you're number one. Um this is very difficult because I still got so many orders, but if I have to pick one, I'll go with my heart. I'm going with something that I love. Um I would say that Gloom Maven made um made Trash Euro. Okay. Okay. Okay. So create that is has been one of the first very successful game to to take two very different generous and mixing it together and g giving something to the euro players with the with the card that the the um instead of rolling dices to um and the comparative things of like beating the game. So every every scenario is a different puzzle that you need to to sort out. at the same time is giving the heavy team from an

American, but not but not that much. Um, since you always play with your card, so you know what your deck is made of, so you can always make a choice depending. So, h it's kind of like managed to uh show to the Euro people that a a dungeon crawler can be crunchy and um and interesting and at the same times the Americaname can actually be interesting and exciting. Um so it kind of mix so it's kind of create that hybrid between theme and um and mechanics. Um then then it's been applied after that to many other games where you got now Eurogame with a strong theme uh or at the same time you got dungeon crawler uh that are very um that mechanics that very heavy influenced by the by Euro games. Um yeah so that I think that they made they made a statement that they create a kind of like a subg genre. It was also a game that was like when it people were first toing it before it was going on Kickstarter, they were like that one never sell. Yeah. And it did like loads of money. I mean it did. And was it 2017 I think. So and it absolutely killed it.

I mean like it showed what is possible through crowdfunding like with Kingdom Death Monster. We go okay here's this crazy expansive thing in a box that's the size of your table. People will buy it if it's good enough. They want that. Yeah. It's they didn't know what it most of the people they didn't understand what it was. Yeah. Until it came out. There's no publisher that would take that idea and take the risk to to do it now. Yeah. Right. And the other very cool things is that um Gloom Haven has been number one on BG for for many years and it was so cool to see an independent publisher and designer being the number one game ever in for that for that period. Um, and still now it's probably number three, number four. Yeah. And it's it was a dude that started it things. So, it's fantastic. It's crazy to me as well like that game is like 2017 or something. I think it has never quite nothing's ever quite matched it for its the the number of innovations and cool ideas and systems brought to the table in one fell swoop. You get a lot of Gloom Haven sort of uh games that clearly built on the Gloom Haven formula and some of them you know even I mean Aridia's Yeah. you you hear like all the time Gloom Haven Killer coming out and it's like maybe they are, maybe they aren't, but what is phenomenal about Gloom Haven is you can still go back and play a a single sort of scenario in there. Y and the puzzle is crazy complex

and cool. And it's just the whole thing of your character with multiple cards that are double-sided, stringing those together, the systems by which your characters retire and you evolve into or not evolve. That's potent retire different character out. It's it's it's nothing else. Yeah. And Wayne, what about your number one? I'm jumping forward to 2019. Okay. Uh and the reason I'm jumping forward to 2019 thought it was Ramy. Let's not run the car. We're not going back to that again. Uh it's because this game, I think, set a new standard for um creating retail products that are beautiful and also have the ability to bring new people into the hobby that might not have considered it to play slightly heavier games than I know what it might be.

Yeah, it's Wingspan. Yeah, it's Wings. So, um yeah, Elizabeth Harrieve and um Beth, I think. Yeah, Beth by Stonemire Games. It's a a triumph of of great marketing, great design, great artwork, a solid engine, um, and a theme again that people went birds. Who's interested in birds? Turns out freaking loads of loads and loads of people. Definitely more exciting than trading the Mediterranean. Yeah, exactly. So, a lot of people. And this is a game that is um so beautifully produced and lovingly produced that uh it just sold copies of water stones to people that might not even consider picking it up. And this is a game that I don't believe it's an intro game at all. This is not a beginner game. This is a game that's way more complicated than what it looks like going on. There's going on. And so when you start explaining that to people uh well I try to teach it to like people like oh wingspan I've heard about Wingspan.

strap in because if you've not played like a modern board game, we're going way past things like Ticket to Ride. We're going way past pandemic. We're going into like relatively in-depth engine building territory. Yeah, exactly. That's But it brought that to a mass market. Yeah. Which is amazing. It's crazy to me as well like that whole um what I've noticed at least on a personal level, I don't know if this is reflective for you guys, but where I you know, everyone has that conversation. It's like I'm into board games and and someone who doesn't know board games will be like cool monopoly like let me try and let me try and kind of ease this conversation along a little bit and and and and hopefully get someone to understand the kind of thing I'm into. The weird tipping point used to be katan actually like I used to have that conversation occasionally if someone go I've played that game katan. Yeah, I like that. And you're like great we're falling into something here where it's like maybe I can get a little bit more.

Yeah. I'm noticing now I'll be talking about ball games to people and they'll be like yeah I got wingspan for Christmas and it's like that's and again that's just on my that's personal thing I don't know if you guys have people do people do it's it's it's so giftable because it's a beautiful beautiful everything in it is beautiful like even the rule book like feels lovely and everything is like tactile it's got little tiny eggs in it it's like everything very cutesy even if the game mechanics then are more complex by the look of it the feel of it the look of it the tactical experience of opening the box the pleasure of the game itself as well as that um a theme that is I think people undervalue and underestimate the accessibleness of that theme it's not space it's not war it's not fighting it is a beautiful game about nature reserves I think yeah one of the things that he made it was just like you can sell a game even if it's not yeah a war game or there is no dungeons or much uh it's significantly more inclusive significantly wider appeal yeah I think it's lovely as well for the for Matt you mentioned earlier about Gloom Haven sort of supporting themes being put into Euro games in a bigger way but I think there's almost like that's been double teamed with Wingspan coming along and saying hey your theme doesn't have to be one of these four that all that's where we Seeing I mean even the last year you know things like rock

hard a midweight Euro game about becoming a rockar you know so things like that just and it's so much more joyous to play because so much more character form and you get this great elevation of general production in retail as well which is another reason where basically wingspan came out and anything else that wasn't that quality at retail started to look bad and comp that's true and one last things about wingspan that it's been one of the first um female designer going up in very high on the chart and that is uh it's great to see like again diversity and inclusion and uh getting those female designer up there and to with a production to back a very good game. So uh well very very well done to my ears.

Yeah. All right. Should we do a couple of honorable honorable mention? Let's do one or two. Yeah. Let me have a think. I want some. No, I want one. I want one. You want You want a horrible mention? Uh, horrible mention. Yeah, horrible mention. Robin brief. Quick honorable mention before we close. Honorable mention. My honorable mention is going to go to a game called Obsession. Obsession. Obsession. People love that freaking game. Yes, man. That game is great. I've never played it. I love that freaking game. The thing that I think is is the thing that I think Obsession has done that has kind of changed industry standards to a large extent is it really is a kind of passion project by one person Dan Alligan who put the game together built a community around it. What he has done is he's crafted a great game for starters with several expansions that just make the game better and better and better with each one. They are all fantastic. Get the whole thing, trust me. But the other thing that's great about what he's done is it it it doesn't feel like just a game because it's not a box you're buying off a shelf putting on the table and playing with your friends.

It almost feels like Dan Hanagan is there not in a creepy way. Oh dad does it. Um but he is there to kind of support you through the game and nurture you through everything about it. He's a real love letter to his his passion, which is that Victorian era, Pride and Prejudice sort of era of of England. Uh he's actually an American guy. So, you know, it's he's he when you buy the box, the core box, you'll find the rule book in there. You'll find like a a massive appendix booklet that explains like every freaking system in the game. And it's like this is the history of it. This is why this particular system. And to further that, if you ever have even like a slight issue of obsession, he is known for sorting out from component troubles right through to picking up the phone explaining the rules. He's like one step removed. He's such a love such a kind of, as I say, such a passion project.

You go on to like Board Game Geek forums, create a little community for it. It's something else. Like you find like a thread on board game that will be like, I don't know, I have a problem with randomness and obsession for example. Uh, I don't like the card draw. Dan Halagan's going to be on there as the first reply and he's like, "Glad you brought that up. Here are 17 variants that I've designed." Genuinely, his last his last expansion had a book like that thick of just his personal favorite variants that he's like, "If you like the game, here's all the things you can try to to tweak it." And to me that was a that's a real kind of yeah it's a real sort of standard for building community around the game for this is a game that's grown in popularity. I think he went from nothing toing more and more people first time designer to my knowledge. He's never put anything else out and he just you can grow a project man. I think that's great. Yeah. Matt um you actually mentioned this game just now and what I'm talking about is love letter. Love letter.

for two main reasons. That's a great shot. Actually, first first of all, we created a micro game. There was no micro game. A great shout otherwise just like a small pouch with a few cards. Um if you think that um oink all the oink game stuff there would not be oink games without love letter. And the second reason that is linked to to own games as well is because it was one of the first Japanese publisher to come to to the western world and and and that opened the doors for for the Japanese and Asian market into Europe and um and America. It's exploded, man. Like Love Letter is huge. I love that game still as well. I mean, it's so good and you still find a million different copies, a million different versions and um yeah, but on top of that, all the micro games, all the games that can fit in your pocket, they would not be there without love letters.

What you say about Japan as well is that that opening of the doors to another culture. It's, you know, gaming is something that hasn't just happened in Europe and America. And, you know, there is a massive gaming culture in Japan. anyone who sort of buys game from games from travel games online, shouts to Ben if he's watching. But uh all those wonderful sort of card games, trick takers, card sheders that born and grown at the Tokyo games market. Yeah. And you know, I think it shows that there is a massive massive culture of gaming around the world. Yeah. Yeah. That's great. Um we love Japanese games, isn't it? We do. Uh I'll have one more for you. Uh, and I say one. I'm going to go two. Oh, no. You can't. Okay. Well, we just Goodbye. I'll be real quick. Quick quick. I'll be I'll be quicker than both of you. But let's go. Go. Okay. The first one, El Grande, 1996. 1994. Can't remember. Either one of those two. Uh, every majority popularized that Wolf Gang Karma absolute legend. The Messi of Spiel.

Yes. That's what it is. They should name it after him actually because of basically popularized invented mechanism. And then Dominion 2008. That was going to be my invented deck building in the board game concept. That was going to be my next and could not be not at least not mentioned. Should we wrap this bad boy up? Let's go. So that was our video on the most industrydefiling, earthshattering games in board game history. And in Rob's case, in board game present. Yeah. And future. And future. Exactly. So uh but what did you think? Do you agree with our picks? Whose picks do you agree with the most? Let us know in the comments below. And what did we miss out, which I'm sure I'll be kicking myself. We missed this stuff. A lot of stuff in terms of like mechanics. There are a lot of great games and there's loads of things. I think this is our five peaks each of what we This wildly hard I did avoid a couple of Yeah, my cheated, but cheap things once again. No comment. No comment. Yeah. Yeah. But there are loads uh and there's lots of ways that you consider industry defining. So we thought about a few different ways, but I'd be interested to hear what you think counts as industry defining and what defines what you know what is defining.

Go on, tell me. Our patron. Our Patreon. You can defines you can define our channel cuz you can support the channel. Yeah. We can have Rob more time. We can take him out of the cupboard more often. Exactly. It's expensive. And there is you can find all the exclusive content for you. There's going to be all the exclusive content for UKG that is going to come out on all that good stuff. Exclusive stuff. Yeah, exactly. and um the previews of all the videos and all the long and it's just for buying us a coffee and supporting the channel and u making us grow basically otherwise keeping us afloat. You know what's free Rob? What's free? Hitting the subscribe button. Smash that subscribe. That's free. Okay. Shattering subscribe shattering goodness. Exactly.

Well, I do the after and we'll catch you again at the next one. and what you should play and see.

Progress saved