The Problem with Board Game Duels is...
Transcript
have you recently been board game browsing or board game shopping and notice different versions of your familiar board games maybe it might make you do a double take a triple take or even a quadruple take cuz these days there's so many different versions of our favorite games that it's almost impossible to own them all in this video we're going to open a Hannah worms and talk about the place of duel versions duel AO dual versions of some of our favorite board games and their place in this hobby what are the pros and cons let's start a conversation hi my name's Danny I'm an avid modern board gamer from Australia sharing my passion for this hobby with you my friends and my family come and join me for this journey and don't forget to subscribe for some more wholesome board game content before I dive into the pros and cons I just want to talk about two player games I'm an avid supporter of two player games in fact I have a whole shelf dedicated to two playay games and you can definitely check out some of my two-player board game videos which are really suitable for couples because I often play board games with my hubby we primarily play together and whether the game is you know four players or six players you know we always or generally play it at two and often the feeling of playing it at two can vary depending on the type of game and the type of mechanisms involved if it's area control
or if there's a little bit of bluffing it's a little bit harder to kind of encapsulate that feeling at two but generally speaking I love the kind of head-to-head feeling that you have in a strictly two-player game the idea of vying for like two or three win conditions which kind of stretches your strategy when you're playing a strictly two-play game or if you're cooperating together you kind of have 50% of the puzzle and you're kind of overlapping that information as you play when we play multiplayer style games at two players often with some games like wingspan or castles of burgundy you're kind of doing your own thing you're really rarely stepping on each other's toes so the impact of our choices tends to be less significant but there are some other games where you know if it's inish or Kemet where you're forced to like battle head-to-head it does feel a little bit more intense cuz there's only really one person you have to battle with and it does uh beg the question of we have all these really great games which are quite popular zul wingspan idel and now we're seeing a plethora of these two player versions coming out I mean even White Castle has a two-player version coming out and you know classic games like Splendor now have Splender Jewel and so because we're kind of being Onslaught with these two-player games because people have often thought well I've only got my significant other to play with I guess I will buy a two-player only game because I know that this is going to be perfect for two
players and so that does factor into whether you do need a twplay game in your collection you know if I'm only playing with my hubby then this game is going to be a perfect fit to us but I won't be able to take that game anywhere else because it's only for two players and so that's where the conundra or the thought process of having both a multiplayer version and a two-player version together side by side which if you walked into a shop for the first time and thought wow I really want to play everel and you see there's a Duo version and the original version which one are you going to buy will you buy the two-player version cuz you're only going to play two players cuz that's who you play with or will you buy the multiplayer version and play that at a two-player level which is better you're kind of faced with this moral dilemma of Play account and how do you incorporate that into your decision and I guess that's the inspiration for this video do we need both when the multiplayer version still allows you to play at two players do I need the two player only Duo version of the game and that is a big difficult question indeed because it does depend on who you are where you come from how often you play and probably what sort of game styles you do like to play now as you can see behind me me I've got quite a few Jewel versions of some of those popular games like seven wonders I've got Lord of the Rings Jewel aul duel and even to kaido Duo all of these games have um
multiplayer versions of them that were released initially that have been have sold extremely well and now has kind of allowed it to extend itself and produce these two-player versions I really want to talk about the pros of having a two-player version only on of a beloved game the first thing I want to say is that they are definitely suitable for couples if I'm thinking of a date night and I just want to play everel but I don't want to get this giant box out of my cupboard the complete edition and go hey we let's play two players as a casual player I don't think that's going to be a good fit for us especially if we don't play board games often so Duo versions of games are really a little bit more condensed they're easier to kind of get to the T and if you only got one other player who's interested in board gaming or who's kind of seminested and you're trying to get them into other board gaming then the duo versions are going to be a perfect fit it's a great way to bond with that significant other it's a great um kind of pallet cleanser if you're um you know you've got out for dinner and you just want to after dinner activity you know it definitely has that great date night feel about it but you only limited to to players the thing I've also noticed recently is that with these popular games from a publishing point of view Duo versions of popular games sell relatively better and are far
more appealing to the general public than expansions to a game so if I bought a game like Katan and then I wanted to kind of get a little bit more involved in Katana I might bu the seaf fairies expansion or the city of knights expansion and that kind of broadens the experience of Katan for me and gives me different ways to play the game but if I'm looking for or if I am a publisher trying to sell multiple copies of a game I'm going to sell more copies of a family version of Katan a simpler version of Katan a two-player version of Katan over the expansions alone and so from a sales point of view these two-player versions do have a target audience for them there is a market for people who walk by and Target and see ooh there's a two-player version of everel oh I loved everel or I heard about everel you know from my friends or I played everel before oh I definitely can get that to play with my significant other and so a person who browsing aboard game shop or he's about a Duo version is more likely to buy than if they heard about a an expansion for example and so the selling value or the marketable value of a Duo game is going to be far more potent than any other version of the game so when I reflect on what I enjoy about a two-player version of the game you in particular Splendor
Jewel which kind of has three kind of Victory conditions and I know Lord of the Rings Jewel also has three kind of Victory conditions I like that tug-of warar feeling the feeling that you kind of triangulate your Victory conditions based on how you play the sort of moves that you make and you kind of see things shift back and forth and that's what's really special about two playay games the idea that you can kind of push the opponent in One Direction and the other opponent the other person can push you in another Direction and there's this kind of triangulation of which Victory condition will we satisfy first will it be the these two or will it be the other two or will it be the other two and so that kind of adds to the juice of the game and it adds to the conflict the building tension and what I really love about the tug-of war Style Elements in the game and I think a two-player version does funnel that feeling and the moments of tension far better than say something that's designed for a multiplayer game so for example with everel at the two-player it's harder to cycle through the deck of cards because there's only two of you and you're only taking certain numbers and so when you're trying to match up little construction buildings with the people that live in or the animals that live in the building bus it's going to be you're going to have far less options because the game is geared towards multiplayer people taking cards every round so that it all turns through a little bit faster but with condensed versions like teido du Duo Everything feels a little bit
more constrictive in fact comparing tokaido Duo and tokaido I much prefer teido Duo because the board is circular the board has different regions the board feels more tense and with the three Victory conditions it feels Tighter and so I far more enjoy that experience the other thing that's a really good Pro about Dro games is the fact that old is New Again the idea that what felt fresh as an original idea or concept and that idea has kind of been experienced over time by multiple play groups multiple years all of a sudden this ID has become fresh again ooh you love worker place oh you love collecting tiles now we've repackaged it into this new product and with a zoo they've done squares they've done parallelograms they've done hexagons and now it's circles circles are like the flavor of the month and so it's like oh I loved AO so now maybe I'll take a look at this new version of aul which essentially has very similar gameplay elements with a few minor tweaks and have another look at it maybe you consider buying it because what was old is now presented as new and so you're thinking o I do need an Azo with a circle in it oh I do need an AO where I can manipulate how the Dome tiles come out oh I need an version of AO where I can stack the tiles instead of just picking from the factory tiles you know
it it it inserts into your mind this need to own everything and the completionist in me if I really like something or a line of games like I'll collect them all except for that glass of Sinatra didn't really really feel like that was a Zool at all so this what is old is new becomes this momentum of bringing classic games again to the Forefront of everyone's Minds if the designers of the game can kind of take the heart of the original game but reinvigorate it and twist it and meld it into something that is vastly different from the original but you can kind of see the leap of inspiration from the original that will really truly Elevate the game experience and some duo or duel versions of the games really do that I mean look at Lord of the Rings Jewel they've taken this IP but they've really made very very unique twists to each of the mechanics to make the game feel thematic but also incredibly exciting and tight and I think I had that same experience when when I played Splendid Jewel for the first time because the way that you get the little chips uh feels a bit more Dynamic feels a little bit tighter feels a little bit more cohesive than the original game and so a lot of jewels Duos duet games do Elevate the game or improve it a lot more at that two-play
count in fact with Splender du duet or with Splender Jewel I actually sold my original copy of Splender and now I only own the two-play version cuz I only played Splender with my hubby and so I was like well I don't need Splendor I can just have Splendor Jewel and it's such a small package I'm like look I've saved some shelf space and I get to own this fantastic game and this ladies and gentlemen is the turning point of the video if you're a big supporter of the duwel versions of these board games thank you for making it so far but now we're going to take a turn and we're going to look at the con because a lot of these jeel games are basically recycled designs yep the idea that you're playing wingspan Jewel or duet or you're playing you know everel Duo they're basically the same games but they've just really changed minor elements to it you don't really feel like you're playing a brand new game yes you may be a fan of Splendor and you want Splendor Jewel but do you have space on your your shelf for both of them some people might say yes I might say no because I have limited space is there less you know unique ideas out in the board game design universe and so when you recycle a design yes it might make you more money but the game itself is just being repackaged in a different way and we often see this with Uno where
they take the core game and every year they release a different version of Uno whether it's Uno extreme or Uno Attack or Uno teams there's always different like Little Slice variations of the same game to increase the marketability of Uno to really tap into oh you've played Uno now you can play it in teams when you could have play UNO teams with the regular Uno you know there's youo youo but you know oh my gosh Monopoly is the same there Monopoly cheaters Edition Monopoly you know speed Edition it's taking Monopoly but then repackaging it in a way to make it feel fresh but the DNA of the game is still there you're really playing the same game but from a slight different angle and for me I think I only really need to own one version of a game says the person who owns four copies of us all uh look I'm kind of on the fence I can often be sway to be like yeah I'm going to get this game that's the only version of the game I need like for example Yokohama I love the original Yokohama I don't know if I wanted to want to get Yokohama Jewel I might try it but I don't need to own it and you know with imep I love the multiplayer imep but do I need the imep jewel probably not but
whether I buy into it sometimes I have a moment of weakness and do buy into it another downside of these dual games is that it's only for two players so you know if you're someone who wants to share Splendor with three plays you can't really take your duet version and play it you might need to own the multiplayer version and so this does filter into whether you're going to own both or not and if you do buy both that's twice the amount of money that you're spending on that one game design you're also playing games that originally was suitable for two players like if I was playing you know the White Castle it's still great at two plays why do I need to play White Castle Jewel why do I need to play resak jewel the original games were kind of fine if I just played it head-to head I mean it's like the original game caters from two to four plays or two to six plays some of these other games I'm happy just playing the multiplayer version at two players I don't really see the need for a two-play version of that game that I already own and that I'm happy with and this kind of mentality can kind of be applied to like family versions of games so you know there's like sand castles of burgundy that is coming out this year which is basically a familyfriendly version of castles of burgundy and before that or after that we also had Tuscany castles of tusky which kind of feels like a middle in between ground of
or ticket toide level of castles of burgundy so you kind of think well we've got castles burgundy the card game we've got the original cast of burgundy we got C Cast of tusky and we've got s castle of burgundy that's four different versions of the same game marketed at completely different audiences it's like do we need all these I probably don't need to own them all in my collection and so I'll pick and choose which one I really gravitate towards or really enjoy the most and own that but I can play car burgundy with two I can play Carle burgundy with the people they like and I guess it all comes down to your situation if you're more family orientated then you might get a simpler version of it like my little everel that just appeals more to people who need more simpler rules but even my little everel has quite complex rules in it and so you're just these versions or offshoots of these popular games are really really taking over and almost confusing and clouding the consumer you know just cuz it says you know two play players doesn't mean that's better than the original you might buy and go o actually it's not better than the original or I'd rather just play the original and so you get this sense of buy regret I'm not saying that's the case for all dual versions of a game but that could potentially happen and so a lot of the times now that every single game almost every single game is coming out with the Dual version it does feel like lazy game design it does feel like a cash grab where it's like here's a
two-play version here's the family version here's the original version you can kind of play whichever one you like but we've kind of marketed it for all these different audiences and so I get it I understand why they're there I understand you know who they're aimed for but as a consumer and as a player I really need to think very carefully before I take a game off the shelf like that and warrant spending that hard- eared money that I've made on three almost identical games no one's forcing me to buy it but you know what I might be lured by one that has that appeal that looks different but then when I play I'm like oh this is just the same as the original so it really has to set itself apart if I really want to own that two-player version and so when you hear things like everel complete edition and then all of a sudden you see there's everel du everdale all these offsho you're like was it really the complete addition after all H maybe complete for the multiplayer version but then you've got all these other games coming out look you buy whatever you like it's an interesting topic of conversation to have because you know this is shelf space this is our valuable time this is our valuable money that we've spent or earned and so I think being aware of the role of these dual games both pros and cons is super
important so what do you think of some of these dual Duo duet versions of some of our favorite board games is it worth owning the original and this version as well you know does it take up space in your collection please uh let me know what your thoughts and opinions are in the comment section below I'd love to start a conversation with you if you found this topic really insightful and super helpful please consider liking subscribing to my channel if you really want to help this channel grow please consider heading over to my patreon page and buying me a coffee a month I would truly appreciate it thanks once again for joining me for another board game sanctu video don't forget to check out some of my other topic videos on my main page there are hundreds of other videos there to enjoy uh this is Danny S I hope to see you again for another video in this near future see you soon