22 Board Games Ranked - Episode 5
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to this month's edition of month in review so this is for september in 2021 and if you're not familiar with this series it's a it's a series where i recap all the games i've played during the month that are new to me and i rank them from my least favorite to my most favorite now i will say out of all the months i've done so far this was definitely the hardest to rank these games because i to be honest a lot of them sat around the same level so kind of um you know there really was a hairs width in between how i ranked them so who knows in a few days time this list might tweak slightly in the order but you know generally i'm happy with it and um this was a bumper month i played 22 new games so i better get it started so first off my least favorite game of the month but i will say none of these games i thought were bad this month this one is the pyramid of penguin i suppose this one was bottom simply because this one is tailored towards children it's a very light game um quite a unique game actually where one side of the table um is basically trying to collect these different items by moving this um this magnet piece or your yeah this magnetic piece around this vertical board and the other side of the table is kind of the the pen queen trying to catch all the other little penguins and by kind of snapping their magnets together and guessing where they've gone very simple kind of has a an old nostalgic toy factor to it but it works well for what it is and i think if you do have younger children this is probably a good option so i won't do that too much nice game but obviously not for me because it's a it's a kids game so at number 21 i have mr jack
pockets so i almost feel bad putting this one at number 21 because these are still really good games so this one is a really small footprint deduction game where one person and i will say this is a two player only game so one person is going to be um jack the ripper one person is going to be sherlock holmes and you are basically trying to evade charlotte comes if you're jack the ripper and of course trying to catch jack the ripper if you if you're sure that comes but the way you do this is quite interesting as you have this three by three grid of tiles all with different orientations of rows and stuff and you're trying to move these different pieces up so you've got like um watson and holmes and their dog toby and you're trying to line up so you can see all the different characters available to you and ask questions to um you know to mr jack and see if if you can see them at any time and if you can you can kind of deduce things and such and you're selecting these actions to manipulate the board as well i thought this one did a really good job of having quite a nice weighted and quite a little bit a little crunchy actually um deduction game in such a small box and such a small time frame as well so nice little deduction game if you want to get a deduction fix in no 20 minutes this is a good option so that is mr jack at number 21.
at number 20 i have escape with the aliens from outer space so this is a hidden movement style game a team versus team gamers um one players or one bunch of players is the aliens and once one side is the humans i suppose and the idea is that you're trying to reach these escape pods but some of these escape pods are shut off so you don't know you're going around this kind of hex um this kind of uh i suppose as a blueprint made up of hexes of this big building um and you don't know who's the uh who's the alien you don't know who's the humans and you're if you're the aliens you're trying to catch the humans and of course if you're the humans you're trying to evade capture and get on those escape pods a pretty good hidden movement game actually very simple and stripped back some good variation as well in terms of setups because you actually have just this booklet made up of all these different maps and you're using dry erase pens to travel and stuff you can give real information or you can get false information at times to kind of throw your opponents off track and it works well for what it is nice and fast scales well you know accommodates quite a good amount of players and if you do want a nice deduction a nice hidden movement game this is also a good option and you like your sci-fi theme again take a look at this one because it's a it's a nice solid inoffensive pleasant game at number 19 i have great planes so this was actually a little bit of a disappointment for me and particularly because it came off the back of one of my favorite games this year that i played this year mandala so this is by the same designers it's another two player game from the lookout game series um and this one has that classic
rhino kinicia feel as you are placing pieces onto this very variable map modular map made up of all these different kind of terrains and you're the idea is you're trying to control certain regions by having the most player pieces on them and it's got that kind of that real strip back mechanism where you can either spawn from one of your starting spaces or just continue from a spot where you already have a piece so a very minimalistic game one that works well for what it is um but i was a bit underwhelmed considering the hype of the mandala which i mentioned and to be honest i think i'd rather play those classic canucki games games like babylonia which i have my shelf here um blue lagoon i think they do what this game does a bit better if i'm perfectly honest so a bit of a disappointment but still not a bad game that is great planes at number 18 i have something a bit different this is a real throwback with ispahan so is from one of the oldest starry games and this one is i suppose one of the original dice drafting games as you're rolling this big bunch of dice and then turn by turn you're drafting them either to put kind of your cubes down on these different buildings and the rarity of those buildings can really change the amount of points you can get by controlling them you are collecting money to buy investments and using camels to mitigate things a real to be honest a really nice game one that i think is um it's dated pretty well maybe not in terms of its visual appeal looks you know it's like a real kind of dry dusty euro feel but the actual mechanism were fun they were snappy you know you can get this one played in under an hour has some pretty cool mechanisms in there and it
did hold up quite well but ultimately is this a game i'd lean back to i'll go back to playing again and again probably not i think this has only got a few players in it before you're ready to move on but still i'm considering this was one of the first dice drafters this one still does do dice drafting pretty well that is ispahan at number 17 i have drop it so drop it i suppose when i'm comparing the the game itself with the fun you have from the game there is a bit of um you know there's a bit of a stretch in between them because the game is so simple this is a it's barely even a dexterity game which you're placing these different shapes into this again a vertical kind of between two sheets of perspex basically you're trying to drop them and not touch not touch shape or shape or color with color and you score points depending on how high up on that border is very silly fun but one that actually works surprisingly well and and since i've got this one it's hit the table um a lot so it seems to be a hit with whoever i've played this with and it's one of those games i think it'll be difficult not to enjoy it you know a nice fun experience in 20 minutes um it has that real kind of chaotic factor as you're trying to carefully place things down but inevitably it just knocks everything over and whatever you plan just doesn't happen but it still is good fun it's it's um you know nice laugh out loud moments um you can try to be a bit tactical with how you place things and sometimes it works often it doesn't but still i think it's a good example of this style of game feels mass market but it still caters to gamers as well so that is drop it
at number 16 i have a party game with trap words so track words is a real interesting take on these word games and i really do like word games in general and party games in general and this is a strong one so this is a game where you're playing in teams and the idea is that you're trying to communicate a a word or trying to get your teammate to say a word when and one person is giving clues to try and try and you know probe that or to try and help their teammate lean towards that word but the other team have selected a bunch of words that you're not allowed to say without you knowing and then if you say one of those words you automatically lose the round um really fun and these are the kind of games that you can play with pretty much anybody they always and they always go down well and um i play a game like this anytime so i love these styler games and this is a good twist on them and still a real fun experience at number 15 i have san juan so this is a card driven version of puerto rico so puerto rico one of my favorite euro games ever and this one has a lot of mechanisms that are from puerto rico and particularly the role selection mechanism as you're choosing which role you want and then you get the kind of amped up version of that action and everybody else gets a watered-down version and this one you're kind of using cars to pay for other cars getting points in different ways i mean getting crops and selling them and stuff you know everything you'd expect from the stellar game but it's the fact that it's all card driven very easy to explain but still some a big kind of wide spectrum of different strategies you can go for
i think this one works well very smooth and pretty fast uh pretty rich experience considering you know what you have in front of you and um yeah i was i was pleasantly surprised with santa one i wasn't sure how i was going to feel about it because i am such a fan of puerto rico but i think if you wanted to get a real you know a nice fast version of it down quickly and get that get most of the experience then i think um san juan is a good option to go for at number 14 i have dark ages heritage of charlemagne this one was undoubtedly one of my most anticipated games of the year so i'm a bit sad that this came so low on the rankings it was not a bad game by any stretch but it was nowhere near as good as i was expecting so this is a 4x euro style game as you are i'm getting new technologies you'll get building armies going to attack other people building castles managing resources it really is a euro game with a dude on a map aesthetic i suppose um i suppose there was a few things that did turn me off about this one first was the pacing of the game was quite slow to get going it was a real churning game and getting that kind of snowballing effect did take its time um it also felt like you're pulling teeth a lot of the time in terms of getting resources to actually buy upgrades and buy things um so it would have been nice to have a bit of a bit of a push to get things moving additionally the dice roll in combat you know in my gut i thought i wasn't going to like it and in reality it turned out i didn't like it as well so i thought a lot of the time the investment you put into building armies just wasn't worth it when it came down to a roll of the
dice so a really ambitious design i think it nearly pulled off but it wasn't quite strong enough to be a keeper for me that is dark ages at number 13 i have dragon castle so this was another pleasant surprise of the month of me i know i've heard reasonably good things about this one over the years um and you know what this game did deliver so this is a a tile placement style game and it almost has a a mayang style feel to it as you're drafting um tiles from this preset kind of array of dominoes and then you're placing them on your unique board in order to try and match up all the symbols and then you score them by placing roofs you've got some variability in terms of getting like scoring cards and end game objectives this one was very elegant and gorgeously produced in fact perfectly produced with those kind of acrylic tiles um really understated and classy design but still but still felt deluxe and rich um i think this one is going to really stand the test of time i think um you know the years are going to treat it well and in 10 years time this is still going to feel like a pretty fresh design so i'm happy with this one that would play this one pretty much any time again nice fast experience and i think this is a really weighted well in terms of being being able to cater to kind of more more experienced gamers but still being accessible for less experienced gamers so that is dragon castle lovely game and number 12 i have allegory so allegory is actually a 2021 release so brand new plot of the presses and however i don't hear anybody talking
about this one it doesn't have a lot of buzz but this one is a set collection and bidding style game as you're collecting cards of these different suits however you've got to be careful what you bid on and what you collect because it has that kinician style scoring where out of all your suits only your lowest suit or your worst suit is going to be the one you score this is a game of small gains you know getting any points out of this one is difficult because not only are you trying to collect you know your your lowest set is going to score um there's additional symbols which you can try and collect to get more points um but that might still sound standard and the u unique thing about this game is the fact that when you win a bid or you win an auction to claim a card out of the chips that you've bid with you actually place on the remaining cards and divide them out how you see fit to kind of build the incentive to take the most you know the more neglected cards and that was really cool how the players could control that and um you know try and try and entice people into taking the cards that you don't really want yourself really clever i think there's some layers here um and some depth here that isn't quite you know apparent at first and i'm still enjoying what this one does and scales very well as well i think it's three to six players and each of this player counts um it works well because you just add more cards to the deck so that is allegory check it out uh at number 11 i have some silly fun but still um a real fun experience this is cartagena so this is an older leo culvini design and it's a racing game as you are taking the role of these pirates breaking out
of jail and then you're racing down this corridor and then trying to get to the escape boats and if you get all your all your pirates out then you're the winner at least if you do it before the other players that is but the way this game works is so so simple you just have a hand of cards and then you're playing these cards to match symbols um which kind of pop up along the way on those tunnels and then you move to the next available one to you however once someone is stood on one of those symbols if you play another card of the same type then you jump straight past it and onto the next one so you can really use your pieces other players pieces in order to really boost your card plays and jumps really far with a single action however you've got to be very careful about not to leave people behind because if you do leave them too far behind it's very hard to catch up and also you've got to be careful about keeping a steady flow of cards in your hand because sometimes if you drop back and fall to the next kind of section with with other meeples on it then you can actually draw cars to keep you moving so a really good experience like you can teach this one in 30 seconds however there are some pretty fun and fun moments in this one um it can be a little bit thinky it can be um you've got to be up uh kind of opportunistic and use the right cards at the right time to get the biggest boost um but it just works maybe a little bit too long um you know maybe 20 too long it would be nice to have a little bit shorter but still i think this is a great game that you can play with pretty much anybody but still has some decisions there that is cartagena let's get into the top 10 then so at number 10 i have aquatica so aquatica is
a pretty a pretty unique game i suppose it uses some mechanisms that i haven't seen before and particularly with your unique player board so your individual player boards you end up collecting cards from the main board and then kind of slotting them in these different kind of um slots on your player board and they all have different notches on them which give you different bonuses and i love the way you can kind of push them in to get those bonuses and they can all trigger off one another um you're buying kind of locations and new characters to use their abilities scoring points in different ways um i thought this one flowed really well um it was nice to look at well produced kind of a gateway plus style game i think there's lots of scope to add new material into this one to keep it interesting and i was just really surprised with it and the biggest thing i took away with this one was how quick it is this one only took about you know 45 minutes or so with a full play account and um you know it felt quick and snappy and engaging you can build towards something but not not not kind of go too far off the track so you don't get caught off guard by the game ending and it was just a nice solid well-rounded game that i would um i would i would suggest checking out if you like these um like these gateway plus style games this is a really strong one at number nine i have another party game so this is so clover um another 2021 release i believe this one is from the same company who put out just one which of course was a blockbuster hit from a couple of years ago and to be honest this one is
has a lot of similar similarities and a lot of shared dna with just one so it's another word association style game however in this one despite being completely cooperative like just one it works differently where you have your own player board which is basically this plastic clover and you're plugging in these four bits of cardboard into that clover and which will have a bunch of words on each of the sides or the edges and then where those two um two cards meet up on that side of the clover you're going to write a clue which which kind of merges those two words together and then once you've done that for all the sides you're going to mix them all together all these cards together with a new one as well and then kind of cooperatively you're going to try and re-configure how they fit in that in that clover now my initial impression with this one was that it's going to be way too easy because you could just match things the only way they would fit however how wrong was i when i came to thinking like that because this game is actually really difficult and because the actual words they use on those cards are a bit more complex than your standard word-based game so i thought this one worked very well um way better than i thought it would do actually i had high hopes but this one actually did exceed them i've been a big hit with who i played this with um you know being requested to bring it again to games nights so um yeah i'm happy with this one maybe it suffers a little bit because of some downtime in terms of you know sometimes you really get stuck out of putting clues down because those words are so difficult and um you can really wreck your brains about how you're gonna reconfigure them back into the um into those clovers but it's one of those games where you just pay for the experience and aren't too fussed
about how it scores but another solid party game and probably a candidate for the best party game of 2021. at number eight i have mikurinos so mikarinos is another istari game so i'm going through my estara games i picked up a few months ago this one another bright beige brown looking game this one's about collecting artifacts and from this kind of excavation i'm a very abstract gamer and area control style gamers you have these bunch of tiles onto the board which have like pyramids as blocking spaces and you're just placing cubes on them either spawning somewhere or expanding where you've already got a cube a bit faster in order to try and collect those tiles and if you have the majority of those tiles you can either use them for claiming a spot in the museum which will get you points based on the next tiles you collect or all the tiles you collect at the end of the game or you can actually take them for the tiles themselves which are going to be worth points and give you bonus powers to navigate that area control part of the game a bit more swiftly and a bit more efficiently um this one i thought was remarkably elegant so easy to teach but has some good some good back and forth player interactions you're trying to block people from jumping in spots the scarcity of getting those museum spots to amp up your scoring was um was really compelling and i liked the way all the different player powers worked as well um very pleasant surprise i think this game um kind of exceeds the way it looks i think the the visuals of this game is going to put some people off but to be honest this game isn't widely
available so this was kind of more of a you know just just more content for people to enjoy and just to see what i'm playing really but um if you do want if you if the game does appeal to you i know it's been kind of re-implemented by a game called rome r-o-a-m if you want to check that one out which of course is more widely available so that is mikarinos at number eight now at number seven i have garum so garum is by pythagoras games this is another um i suppose as an area control every majority style game as you are placing tiles on the this is this is another abstract game by the way you're placing tiles on this big board made up of all these different bowls um and then you're you're trying to line up as many symbols of your color as you can in any row or column and then ideally try and claim those rows or columns to score kind of set collection bonuses all these kind of multipliers because the more symbols you get the more points you get and if you don't hit a certain mark then you can actually end up losing points so i like the way you have to pace yourself on this one you know are you gonna claim this spot before another player does um are you gonna claim it too early and other people are gonna kind of sabotage you by placing tiles of their color or other people's colors to try and you know nullify your points um very elegant another game that played in 40 minutes or so regardless of the player count um very simple easy to explain but still had some good decisions here and a lot of these games actually this month seem to fit really well in the category of being pretty rich games but being fast to play get on
and off the table so garum secured a place in my collection for now and i'm really happy with that one next up i have juicy fruits at number six so this one is um because the component opposite of a game so like garum and mickarinos this one is bright vibrant colorful welcoming this is a contract fulfillment and resource management style game as you're collecting this bunch of fruit and in um cashing them in to fill these contracts to get victory points you're trying to buy new tiles in order to get get points as well and to increase your ability to gain resources but i love the way you get resources in the first place in this game as on your individual player board you are shifting these um pieces around of these individual fruits and depending on how many spots you move that and piece or slide it you are going to gain the corresponding amount of resources and from the supply and that's a really puzzling part of the game as you're moving things around trying to make the move as fast as you can and as far as you can and try not to block other pieces in and as you're doing that and gaining more and more resources you're unlocking other spaces to make your uh your actions more flexible and give you more scope to move things around really fun it's so so simple but it still did have that efficiency puzzle and it did have enough to grip more experienced gamers again as well as being so accessible for people who've not so interest not so involved in the gaming hobby to um to wrap their head around so happy this one i think this one fits a really good niche of being a versatile game and um still got
many pays in this one for me that is juicy fruit at number six at number five uh perhaps my biggest surprise of the month at least pleasant surprise this one is startups so startups is actually a gameboy by oink games so oink games of course known for their tiny little boxes um you know this size box i've normally known for their party games they've got a lot of kind of a big scoping actually in terms of the games they put out but this one is actually a thinky filler game it's a set collection style game but one with a bit of a difference as you want to be careful not to compete with sets that you're not going to win because if at the end of the game you have any shares in these companies which which is the theme of the game you are and an opponent has more than you you're gonna have to end up forking out your points and giving them victory points um so it's one of those games that i tend to really enjoy where no matter what you do it feels uncomfortable it feels it feels like no matter what you do has um great great weight and a great um a great kind of uh repercussions for each of your actions and you can find yourself making mistakes and investing in things you just didn't want to i'm also has some great incentive building here as if you don't take cars from the market you have to put tokens on them which makes it more inviting for other people to get to get in on the party and try to invest in these companies um this really is a game i think you have to pay play for yourself to see how it works very simple but the scoring and the way it works just feels a little bit different and a little bit out there um
keep an eye out for my review for this one because i think this one is really flying under the radar and perhaps i think a lot of you guys would appreciate a design like this so that is startups at number five uh at number four and i should say my last game a startup was the first game that got my shield of quality so at number four i have my second game with my shield of quality this is my farm shop so on the shelf here my farm shop another family weight game that is still um still has enough going on to be to be enjoyed enjoyed by more experienced gamers so this actually uses the machi coro space-based mechanism as your rolling dice and basically triggering different things on your board to collect resources depending on what you've rolled and then cashing those resources in for points and this one you are rolling three dice and two of them are going to do what i just said and the other one is going to buy a new card which have to replace one of your board existing ones on your board and i love the way you can really tailor your engine in this one you can build towards certain specific strategies this one was a drastic drastic improvement on the uh space base and matching horror games um those games really did fall flat for me but i always felt that there was something there and something that could be built upon and i'm so glad that rudiger dawn was the man who discovered that i should have had faith in the really good one because i thought is this one it's just going to be a slight tweak on those games um and in a way it is but in a way all those tweaks made the game drastically
better this is when you have so much more mitigation with what you can do you can really build a bit of an engineer on investing in certain spots and i love the fact that when other players take their turns and um you they select the dice to activate their board you get the full power of the activation on your board as well and not just some um kind of reactionary reward like getting a coin or two this one you get to do your full-blown action which is so much more satisfying great pacing really does ramp up as the game goes on and i just thought this was an absolute delight and i enjoyed it thoroughly so that is my farm shop at number four so let's get into the top three so this is the best of the best games of the month the third being vice roy uh so you should talk about underrated gems this one was actually one of the i think it's one of the initial kickstarter campaigns this one is another bidding style game as you're building these um these tokens these different currencies of different colors in order to acquire these characters and then you when you build these characters in your big pyramid of cards you're getting rewards depending on how high up the pyramid you're getting you're trying to match these symbols to get a free income your cards these these kind of law cards they can score you points in different ways this one is so easy to teach again great decisions here great is all these characters do different things one of the best examples of a point salad style game is there are so many different ways you can gather points you know are you gonna collect these scrolls and score these boosters to boost the value of your scrolls are you gonna be trying to just get pure points um are you gonna be trying to get these swords and shield symbols to try
and you know even force other people to lose points by not being able to defend themselves uh what a delight this game is uh i love the simplicity of the bidding here you can only have a bid one token at a time but if you bid the same color as somebody else to claim the same character then they cancel each other out and you have to go again which can potentially cost you a lot of money works really well ultra smooth ultra fun that is viceroy a high high recommendation from me at number two i have spirit island so finally managed to get spirit island to the table i played this one uh three times now so still kind of formulating my opinions on this one because it is a pretty rich a pretty involved and heavy game as we are taking controls of the spirits we all have these unique powers and we're trying to work together try and fight off these invaders and kind of coming onto our island um i love the the scope and kind of variety of the characters here they're all so so different all have their own strengths and weaknesses you know are you going to be really defensive and stop people from pillaging the land are you going to be an all-out attack kind of guy just blast these people into oblivion or are you going to kind of work together and try to boost each other and fill each other's weaknesses and get a whole well-rounded package by you know communicating with your teammates um so much to explore here i love the elegance of the system you know it's very simple despite being so heavy and so involved and having massively paralyzing decisions this one because it is not the easiest game to map out turns in your head because timing is everything in this game
but when you break it down into what you're physically doing it is actually very digestible um but still i have a lot of room to um to grow with this one still finding my feet but so far so good i think the more i spill this one this one does have potential to get my elite shield and number one talking of elite shields i have tinners trails so tennis trail definitely my favorite game of the month so this is a martin wallace design um set in cornwall so this one you are trying to buy these different mines um sometimes you know what you're buying sometimes you don't know what you're buying because these tiles are face down and the idea is that when you reveal these tiles after buying them you are going to be trying to extract the minerals from them so you've got your tin and your iron however you can't just go and go in the gung-ho and mine all this um metal from that and sell it because you've got to be careful about how much water is in those mines because the more water the more expensive it is to extract so you've got to buy pumps you've got to buy these boats all to try and get this water out and mine it at the most efficient time being careful that the market might not be as strong in future terms so i love this speculation with this one there is now the right time to sell it because this game you're actually selling um you're sending your money and converting that purely into points so the the way that the money and the points go hand in hand and this one is great you have attention because you get broadened you get compensated more in the early round so are you going to take a gamble and sell sell sell now and not carry too much money to the next round or are you going
to play a bit safer keep hold of your money but get diminishing returns in terms of points as the game goes on and it does fit that nice weight of being a medium weight euro but having more complicated decisions than you'd probably expect i'm absolutely hit for me and i'm definitely up there with wallace's best and you know i'm not massively experienced in wallace games but really keeps putting out games like this and i'm getting games like brass and anno 1800 and tennis trail to the table this guy is quickly becoming one of my favorite designers so um definitely a unanimous um 100 guaranteed best game of the month with tina's trail so hopefully you've enjoyed this video i hope you have i really enjoyed putting this video every month and i look forward to kind of ranking these games definitely my favorite video to put out and hopefully you've enjoyed this one too i apologize if it's gone a bit long and apologies the lighting and setup is a bit different but um you know we work for what we've got but thanks for joining me and i'll see you all next time on chairman of the board bye