4 Signs It’s Time to GET RID of a Game – Board Games & Coffee Ep. 2
Transcript
hi welcome to board games and coffee today we're going to talk about signs it's time to get rid of a board game I'm going to open with a survey that I asked my subscribers earlier this week I'll pull that up so I asked which of the following is most likely the reason you remove a board game from your collection and the number one answer was it was probably never a great purchase decision to begin with now as a reviewer this really struck me I I I almost feel responsible for this that people are buying games that they think aren't a good purchase but I'm going to talk about that at the end of this episode um what I've done today is I've organized this discussion into uh four signs and this is interactive if you'd like to ask questions you can go ahead and ask them in the comments and I will address them at the end of this video but for some people who maybe don't have games that you would even think about getting rid of maybe you have three games on your shelf or six games or something and you're like get rid of games why would I get rid of games I love my six games and for those of you who are in that position I envy you cuz I remember what it was like when I got started and every game was exciting it was so cool that I got to
have 10 I remember when I had 10 board games I was like wow my collection is big but the uh reality is that this hobby is much like collecting CDs in the '90s but the difference is there are no MP3 players that will save you where you can just discard that entire collection because the hobby is in its nature physical tax and takes place in meat space you can't I mean yes you can play board games on live online and I play board games online but that's no replacement to the experience of sitting down with people at a table and playing board games so as it is my collection grows and grows I think right now in my house I probably have about 250 uh so what are the signs that it may be time to get rid of some board games I'm going to kind of outline what these signs are and then I'll describe in detail some of the board games I have as examples and also what it is that will rescue these games from from being donated or given away or discarded so the first sign is time passes second sign is it gets demoted from its position on the Shelf the third sign is analysis and the fourth sign is identification of an
exit so the first sign time passes this can happen almost without knowing it one day you realize that it's been a really long time since you last played a game and you don't know when you're going to play it next so I looked at all my board games I think the game that I haven't played in the longest amount of time time may be five tribes now why why have I not played five tribes I'll talk about that when I get to analysis but the thing that rescues a game from this stage this sign and its process is those people who love the game who keep requesting that you bring it out so for me that game is quacks of quinber I don't like quacks of quinber at all I have it out of the way where no one can see it and yet my kids love quacks of quinber they ask me Dad can we play that game with the potions so that's how that goes the next sign though is demoted position now this is where the sign that the games go from the favored position on the Shelf down below out of sight or up in a cabinet where you won't notice it at all but there's a really interesting aspect that influences our connection that influences our organization and can rescue a game from this stage and that
is uh either its look the look of the box or how it appears how it fits on the Shelf I give you an example another game that I don't play a lot is marry Posas and this is a game with about butterflies it's got this gorgeous box the whole the whole game the board is beautiful butterflies and flowers and uh quite frankly we don't get rid of it because my wife loves it it's in our living room it's like absolutely on display front and center and I've told her several times I'm ready to get rid of Mary posis and she's like no no no no not that one that one that that one's so pretty so pretty the other ones though like for me in terms of where it fits on the Shelf I've got uh alicat games up here my I can't see alycat games I've got crino games down here I've Got Game Brewer games over there the the logo it just looks so nice they're all lined up there Chocolate Factory I haven't played Chocolate Factory in a long time but it looks so nice next to uh Eternal Palace so this can rescue it from its demoted position the next sign or stage is analysis this is where it's been such a long time since you last played the game
that you're now asking uh why why like why do I not want to play this game oo thanks for the warning someone's like you might hit your coffee elbow all right so for this I went through my Purgatory shelf the games that I'm haven't decided whether to keep them or get rid of them I wrote down all of them and then I described them in categories and I think the categories are different for everyone I'm not saying that like you're going to have the same categories too but for me I've got six categories and they are one game that lack a rising action two games that are too drawn out three games that aren't worth the teach uh four games that are replaced by another game with similar rules five games that require either a special person or a special group to play with and six uh games that I just don't like so some examples now by the way I'm not going to be able to go through all of these games and like describe why I don't like them and and many of these games I do like I like them a lot I have
there are design elements that I admire some of these games I have given a positive review for now when I review games I try to give like the caveat like oh this is a great game as long as blah or you know so just because they're on my list here doesn't mean that I would necessarily retract something I've said about it in in the past but uh nevertheless I haven't been played in a long time so first games that lack rising action what I mean by that is these are just games that are a flat experience it's the same thing turn after turn there's not the exciting like climb of of working toward something and actually if you if you watch the previous episode I talked about what makes a game addicting these are games that do not have those factors so um School of sorcery holotype insecta marry Posas Luxor Chocolate Factory her story Picture Perfect Yak I don't know if you're going to know all those games many of them are family games by the way and I think that's one of the risks with family board games family board games in order to be accessible to people of all ages they're often very easy and then they they lack a rising action the thing that rescues any of these games though is that some of them have a very unique mechanic or aesthetic so unique mechanic for example I'm just going to talk about Luxor just as an example Luxor is a game where
you're moving around a pyramid you're finding Treasures in this pyramid and to move you play cards cards from your hand so you have five cards and the thing is you can only ever play the card on the left or the EXT right you can't Shuffle the cards around in your hand so let's say you play the card on your left when you draw a new card you put that one between in the middle of the four cards that are remaining so you always have five cards there's always two on each side and every new card gets added to the middle so as you pull from left side or right side you have to plan what do you want to play next like it's it's such a cool mechanic it's such a cool decision-making space but it's sort of a it's sort of a slow playthrough maybe you know and the other thing is I got to say I do play these games with my kids I I bought them to play as family games there's a difference between playing with a you know children who can kind of drag a game out more and then adults who can kind of get the right pacing but anyway I digress next category is games that are too drawn out I could have grouped these first two categories together but the thing is these definitely have a rising action and then the end is like kind of agonizing for me I just wish it would be over so I wrote down two and there's more that I'm going to talk about when I get to Stage for the identification of an exit but because I've already gotten rid of the other
games two games everell and flamecraft now those games you probably know about I've given the worst review I've ever given for any game when I reviewed flamecraft and everdell I'm always comparing to everdale it's like old news now so next category games that aren't worth the teach these are games hold on I get excited and I go too fast all right games that aren't worth the teach so these are games that I like I like them a lot well maybe not a lot I don't like them enough to teach people to play them and maybe that's because the rules are finicky maybe there cuz there's too many things to do like there are games that I don't like teaching but the games are so good that I'm like I don't care I'm going to teach it anyway because once we play this game it's going to be awesome one such example is Oak which oh by the way Oak is from game Brewer game Brew is uh shutting its doors and they're doing everything on sale so Oak is going on sale uh trolls and princesses all that stuff you might want to check that out anyway um stroganov which which is also by game Brewer too complicated too complicated and five tribes I mentioned that earlier I like five tribes I like everything about the mechanic which is kind of this Malala movement based
mechanic but the problem with five tribes is the cards once you get to the cards I hate the cards you've got bidding you've got movement you got you've got like special spaces and how they all score and then on top of oh and then you've got purchase thing that you do and then and then and then and then you've got cards and by the time I'm teaching the cards I'm like just bear with me gu like it's too much it's too much I used to play this game with my child but we just didn't play with the cards oh and we didn't I don't think we played with bidding either we just like stripped it down to its core mechanic which I actually love um now if you're like if you're wondering there is there is a replacement you know I think Crusaders gets the same sort of mechanic but isn't a pain to teach all right next category games that are uh forward particular group so these are games that I haven't played in a in a long time if if if I was like doing this on a gradient I would say that at the beginning of my list when I was talking about games that lack a rising action earlier I was talking about games that I sort of if I say dislike the most and as I accelerate I'm going or towards the end these are games that I like even more I like these games even more and yet I still don't play them because it's just hard to get a group around the table so oh man Albin vard him with his small City and Clinic I love these games
I haven't played clinic in like a year and a half a I got the kickstarter for the deluxe version of small City because I think this game is so cool and I've never played it because the rules are too much of a pain and I don't have the time to teach it and the group to get around the table not yet at least I'm I'm still growing my group here in okanawa um small City Clinic bizaar of ubar I reviewed that game recently I said I liked it and I also said I was the person at the table who liked it most and no one liked it as much as me it's like a trading game and then another game that I love I love this game I love on Mars but I haven't played on Mars for like 2 years cuz it's so it's it's so many rules it's so many rules and and the turns that you take in that game are long you've got to be with a group of people that just love technical technical games I could probably think of more but I wrote down four uh and actually I got some more that I already got rid of which I will talk about then there's games with similar rules these are games that are probably great games but I there are better games to play like I'm Goro Goro is an Italian game I would rather play mind management everdell I already mentioned everdell but I won't play everell again because wondrous creatures is just so much better wingspan okay like I actually think wingspan is really cool wingspan doesn't go on forever and ever but I'm not going to play it
because I would rather play or Earth Earth is much better quest for El Dorado again solid mechanic would rather play Life of Amazonia and Skull King I bought Skull King cuz I thought it was cool and I've never played it because I would rather just play wizard the extra rules in Skull King aren't worth it it's like to add a little bit more chaos I would rather just play play wizard which has been around since what the 70s the 80s anyway uh lastly so those are the games now games I don't like just don't like it I quacks of quinber I do not like quacks of quinber and I also always lose quacks of Quin Linberg Okay so step or sign for the identification of an exit all right this this is like how you know like the other ones are like leading up to leading up to here is the sign you know it's time to get rid of a game all right if this happens to you you get rid of the game you're like what what could it be right it's awesome check this out it's when you find the right person or group to give the game too here what I'm saying my best friend's kids are in high school now his oldest son wants to start a board game club at school I happily gave him like five games I can't think of a
better reason to get rid of games than because you are passing on the hobby to someone else and you know they'll like it I was overjoyed to give away these games and there were cool games so these are the games I said I wasn't going to talk about until the end I gave away dominant species I gave away ter uh terysa those are big games now my criticism of those games reason I don't play them anymore is because those games get drawn out I think that they're too long but they're awesome games they were thrilling when I first played them I gave them to a high school kid to start a board game club at school I got rid of a cactus town and dice Throne which they the I I could talk about I just don't like them okay I'm just going to say I don't like them dice Throne cactus town and then I got rid of evolution which is an another awesome awesome game evolution is why Evolution because I think it takes a special group evolution is very competitive right it's you're you're literally destroying each other on purpose um for a guy with three sons to be able to like fight through Evolution I think that's awesome I don't really want to play Evolution anymore okay so hope you get your your questions ready this is the last section of that I've prepared want to go back to that survey uh so the survey again was let's put that back on here the number one reason that people wanted to get rid of games was because it was probably never
a great purchase to begin with and I followed that one up with okay if it's not a great purchase to begin with then why why why did you buy it so I asked why do you buy games which factor has the biggest influence on buying a game and the number one answer I watch or read a reviewer's opinion wow it's like a big responsibility so here's the way that I'm connecting that if you are watching reviewers to get their opinion and then you're going out and buying games no and then you find out that the games when never that great of a purchase to begin with then that means that something's wrong with the reviewers now listen these are two different surveys it's not one doesn't cause the other right it could be that every one of the games that reviewers recommend is awesome and it's only the games that you don't can seek a reviewer's opinion that you feel like was never a great purchase to begin with that could be the fact I don't know but that's like I mean still look at how many people that was this was like 49 % of people there were four answers there almost half of them said it was because reviewers opinion that they buy game and then 68% of people think it's never a great purchase to begin with so that makes me wonder what are we going to do in episode 3 next week where we'll talk at the same time I
almost feel like talking about do do board game reviewers suck I don't know it the way that that works is though we do a poll we do a poll uh every week to see what the next episode is about so stay tuned for that I'm now going to move to questions and uh to set up my screen way over there I don't know some of you don't even realize I wear glasses okay best reason to get rid of games and not feel about it giving it to others to help them discover the hobby or different game genres all right that was not a question let me go over to the Discord
too okay here's a question uh what about collector's edition or big box games Kickstarter exclusives Etc do you have games that you've invested to that to to to serve as a feature in your collection do I want to get rid of those okay Collector's Editions Kickstarter exclusives so truth be told I've got two I've got two Kickstarter games that I haven't played since they have arrived I played them before I had the kickstarter and then I didn't play them afterwards one of those was small city which I told you about the other one was Hamlet which I've I have got to play Hamlet that's not on the Purgatory shelf that's on the Shelf of shame it has a it has a pickup and deliver mechanic which I really enjoyed and then I played a different pickup and deliver game I played uh Acro TI with a friend and I was like oh this was lame I really didn't like this and then because I didn't like enjoy playing Acro tiia which I think it was the friend I played with not so much the game itself I was like well I don't want to I want to play something else for now and then Hamlet arrived in the mail and it was pick up and deliver and and I was like oh I don't want to play that cuz I don't want to play pickup and deliver games that's a that's the stupidest this is this is how things end up on the Shelf of shame maybe I could do an episode about that no good reason no good reason I am
so far off on addressing this question it's okay because there not a lot of questions so do I let that influence yeah I do because you know what I don't think I want to get rid of wingspan or everdo I mean I don't even have Kickstarter or big box editions but they're just incredible like landmarks in the board game hobby it would be like getting rid of like Smells Like Teen Spirit or something like if you were collecting CDs and you know the the cover art for that Nirvana album like it's like too iconic to get rid of so I would say I don't but I don't have a lot of Collector's Editions I don't have a lot of big boxes I do have a big box of dominion which I I also don't want to ever get rid of because Dominion was like this pivotal moment where I got my family into board games my wife plays board games today because we started by playing Dominion so that's special and as long as I have so many games I may as well keep games like that around um so yeah I that is a factor and I do I do think that it's worth keeping games around for
Nostalgia ooh I like this question do you have a game that breaks your rules but you still decide to keep and why I think the answer is yes I wish I had I wish I had that's a good one I wish I had time to prepare for that one
okay okay so there I don't know I think I kind of went over all of the things that save a game so here's an example of one that I've thought about getting rid of and I still haven't gotten rid of it it's it's a I don't know if this is the best example ooh photosynthesis photosynthesis doesn't have a rise or fall I should get rid of photosynthesis I think I tried to sell it on Board Game Geek okay let's think what about a game I was going to say prag caplet rainy um prag caplet rainy is is such a pain to explain it's it seems so dry um it's actually it's another game that really cool to play on board game arena because the maintenance of the game is done automatically for you and the visibility of like things that will cost and the results of doing different things things are more clear in online implementations and there are some like oh man I like playing wingspan on board game arena I complain about it sometimes but like it's such a swift game when maintenance is done for you and and that's a factor that I didn't think about but I keep Prague kep it rainy around because I see it as like a love letter to the city of Prague I think the game is just such a beautiful piece of art but I also kind of feel like I said that already like games I keep them around for their aesthetic I got another question uh it is do you have times where you've gotten rid of a game and regretted it oh what
games were they I have not gotten rid of enough games there is okay there is a game that I've kind of got rid of so my story is I think I've said this before uh we're a military family and so we're always moving around before this we lived in Bethesda Maryland before that we were in Japan again now I'm in Japan again but I do have a house I do have a house in San Diego and so what I did when we moved from San Diego we rent it on Airbnb and I thought it would be cool to leave a bit of a board game collection in San Diego so that when people saw the photographs of the house and they like oh look at this photograph of their living room they have board games on their shows oh look at I know that game and that game that's so cool this guy's a board game player like let's go stay at that house like I don't know if that's ever been a factor on someone's decision but I I I wanted to leave that piece of me behind in San Diego so I left Agricola behind in San Diego and I regret that I left it behind because it was so recognizable it was like number one or number two on board game keep for a long time I thought it would like have an impact there's no way the people in Airbnb in my Airbnb are are getting agria out reading the rules like learning the game and playing it
and being like Oh I love it I'm so glad that agria is here in this Airbnb there's no way that's happening especially in a place like San Diego they' be going to SeaWorld they could be going to the beach they're not playing Agricola it was stupid to leave it behind I just need to get it and bring it back it's like gosh I bought it in like 2010 I've had it for years it's like a special cool edition of the game I want agrica back but I at least I didn't actually get rid of it okay and I think that's it for questions yes so thank you again for watching uh I would like you to know that this is now a podcast so if you like listening in and you don't necessarily want to watch the video watch My Mad facial expressions as I lose my cool over some board game that I've freaking out about uh you can get the podcast on all the different podcasts things uh it's called board games and coffee no surprise there and if you're sub subscriber your subscriber you'll probably see the polls as they go out this week about the next episode thanks again for watching and I'll see you next time