Board Of It's Top 10 Board Games (Updated 2024)
Transcript
hi everyone I'm tally this is Farrell and we are bard of it and welcome to Bard ofit's top 20 games and today we're going to be going through numbers 10 to number one ooh exciting times so this is our top 10 list updated for 2024 last year was the first time we did it the just the top 10 this time we've done top 20 and that video came out last week so if you are only looking at this go back and check that out first so you can see 2211 but this is very exciting because honestly we talked about whether we should do it or not because we're like would would the games even change and actually there's been massive swings and massive changes to the list a number probably like half of our top 10 from last year were in the 11 to 20 so it's very interesting even for us cuz we reveal live to each other so we don't know what the others picked and we're going to get into it basically but first is going to read our top 10 from last year yeah let's just do a quick recap so starting with your list at number 10 you had code names number nine Cascadia number eight cap Europe number seven the undaunted system number six Great Western Trail all of them we're counting all of them uh number five is brot number four
barrage number three PX Premier second edition number two brass birmingam and number one was Scythe moving on to my list at number 10 I had undaunted system number nine cap Europe number eight oon number seven qu of quedlinburg number six was articulate SL root long story won't get into it now you're going to have to go back to the first video number 20 to1 number five Great Western Trail number four bitter culture number three Canan EV number 2.5 again long story barrage number two brass Birmingham and number one was Scythe so both our number one and number two were the same okay so let's go to the number 10 and what's exciting about this video in particular is that we will actually be married just as this comes out oh yeah because of the magic of the fure future so because of how time works so that makes it even more exciting so we can look back and say oh look that was uh the old us before we were had legal documents joining us forever yeah so let's go to my number 10 mine is something that was on your list in the last video and that is June Uprising specifically I think it's much Superior to June Imperium okay you're going to cheat like me and say both no I'm just going to stick straight with June Uprising fair enough cuz I think that
was the game that really got us into June really yeah loving it because we've had June Imperium since the start we actually played it a surprising amount even though I don't really remember playing that much and we weren't super enam with it but we did and we got June Uprising because we wanted to do june the BIOS guide thought it would be a good thing and we just started playing it and it's I think particularly the Imperium cards are so much impr proved that I just really found myself enjoying it and then we introduced it to some friends and we had these kind of crunchy meaty four player games which was brilliant that's how it should be played before that would mainly play two-player and you know we have the expansions the expansions are brilliant you throw that all in and it's such a great time it's a mashup of of deck building work placement very brutal you're racing to 10 points and there's all different ways you can get them but combat's always important and just such a tight tense game is going to make you sweat you're going to have to be reactive it's going to be very interactive so there's a reason it's it's so popular and obviously I've bought into the hype because now it's in my top 10 of all time yeah I think I when we first played Uprising I think that I thought I liked Imperium better but then when we played up Rising a few times then we went back to Imperium I was like then oh yeah actually I think
Uprising probably is slightly better so that was quite interesting to kind of go back to it yeah and we have a buyers guide for everything June expansions the difference between the two games if you want to check that out cool okay my number 10 is something that's was on also your uh 2211 and that is Caper Europe not surprising so a two-player head-to-head game go too much into the details we already kind of talked about it but over and over and over every video even just on the number 20 to 11 we talk about it all the time because it is really good but reason why it's in my top 10 is great production very fun with a little bit of added humor in there which I always like as well you can play a game in maybe 15 to 25 minutes depending and it's just very smart it's quite simple but the push pull is very tense so it's yeah a kind of simple rule set simple actions but the game comes from the tension of the head-to head and I just think it's super well done and we got super addicted to it when we first got it we played maybe 25 times in the first couple of months we had it I think we just were playing it over and over because we just thought it was so amazing so yeah that's why it's in my top 10 I think it's dropped a few positions if I remember correctly yeah I
think so yeah but just through not playing it and no reason really why we haven't been playing we just play so many other games that sometimes other stuff takes takes the priority uh but if you said do you want to play a game of Caper Europe I don't think I would ever ever turn it down it's just yeah the desire to play is still there we just have to play other things sometimes my number nine is quite interesting because it's a game we've had for a long time and it wasn't on my list before and it's shot in you know past 20 to 11 straight to number nine that's interesting and that is Eclipse second Dawn for the Galaxy but it was always something that I had a real sweet spot for I think just when we made the list last year I hadn't played it a lot I think what really cemented it is we recently is had a full six player game of it and I won so there you go straight to number nine your rating is like Shard and freuder meanness whether you win or not yeah top so it was it was eclipse is your general generic 4X space kind of game where you're you're flipping over tiles and you're building up your ships and you're attacking other plays and discovering new terrain and Building Technology upgrading things but it does it all so well and so interesting there's all these different ship parts and every player can modify their ship how they want each faction has its own
unique element that you can lean into so there's bit tiny bit of asymmetry I think the way that the map is revealed is quite interesting because it's not preset players decide what they want where relatively you still draw random tiles there's just so many cool things that it does and almost every element of it it is just really interesting and vibrant and bombastic and I just it's but it's also at its heart a Euro so that I also like it's just something that despite it going up to six is also fairly good at two players and I've really enjoyed it for a long time we are very positive on it in our initial review years and years ago and just that I think that six player game really cemented it for me you know getting to play it with that many people everyone knew how to play it it was just those experiences that made me realize how much I do love Eclipse second dor from the Galaxy yeah that was really fun evening yeah my number nine is cracks of quedlinburg wow falling oh only by flying out of the top 10 next year it won't even be in the 20 I'm sure it's only dropped by around two I'm really surprised cuz we've played a lot of it recently yeah I thought I would make it go up I thought it was going to be like your number five I mean now you're making me question my own list psychology I I I think we just played a
lot of great games yeah recently that that's all it is fair enough that maybe just deserve to be a little bit higher um yeah so cracks of quedlinburg is another bag building game so I talked about o on in the last video CRA of quinber a little bit different here but it is bag building is the main mechanism and you are a quack in Yi times making some potions and basically it's push your luck as well so you have these little chips that have um values on them and they represent different ingredients that go ingredients sorry they're going into your pot but all of the different color chips have different powers when you either when you pull them out or the end of the round or whatever it might be but the values on them correspond to how far along in your pot you can put them because the further you can go around the more points you'll get and the better chips that you can buy for the next round because there's also an ingredient called cherry bombs the white chips and the push your luck come part comes in because if you have more than seven values of cherry bombs in your pot then you're going to explode and then you have to choose either the points or to buy new chips at the end of the round so it's it's all about knowing or remembering like what's in your bag what's already come out risking do you pull one more chip out if you're maybe
on six value of cherry bombs and you know that the three is still in there but you've still got quite a lot of other chips do you want to risk it and pull it out but a lot of replayability also with this one because we have some of the expansions which makes it you know more different every time because you can throw them in or out the different is modular right and I just love the fun of looking around and seeing where everyone is and are they sweating are they going to push their luck saying go on pull out one more chip because you hope that they might explode I think the key word here for me is just it's just a fun fun game silly fun uh but it has it does have enough little decisions to keep it interesting as well so yeah should you push you like what chips should you buy trying to combo the different chips from each other as well cuz some of them combo quite nicely as well yeah I just I just love it yeah I mean it it's obviously a very good game very good kind of Almost Family weight game maybe a little bit more to it yeah but it's something that always brings a lot of joy and a lot of fun moving on to number eight mine this has been updated as of yesterday I think because we played it yesterday day before yeah yeah and that is barrage cuz I think it actually it kind of fell a bit out maybe
even to the 11 to 20 and then we played two games of it the other night because we got all the new expansion stuff and that's just pushed it straight back in WoW fickle fickle just remembering how good it was um so barrage is a very say with me mean game mean work placement uh very brutal very interactive uh very fun if you like that type of thing if you don't fun yeah it's is heavy so you're essentially building Dam and Power Systems to make hydroelectric power on River streams coming down a mountain but there's very limited water to use to generate the power so players are constantly fighting each other for it you can build dams above someone and take that water away from them it's it's really a brutal game but there's a lot of interesting decisions and a lot of fun I think some of the reason it has fallen at least a bit and was going to fall even more is just because it is a game that is very much best three four players and all of our group that we did use to play with has now left and it's a bit harder game to introduce bit tricky it's something you want to play a few times so now we if we play it's going to be two player for the foreseeable future and I think that just yeah it's not how I want to play it so yeah obviously if I'm going
to struggle to play it if it has caveats then it's going to drop a bit it's just not the type of game that you teach people with one time and and then yeah that you'll get the most out of it you have to have a group that can play more than once and almost like play it regularly yeah yeah um otherwise yeah I think it probably doesn't give the best impression as the first game because it is so mean yeah but it's in terms of work placement and and meanness and kind of a Euro with interactivity very few things are going to beat it can't recommend it enough cool so my number eight is something that you've already had on your list that is undaunted uh oh well you've contradicted yourself now why CU you had cap Europe as your number one of your best two-play games of all time but now you've put it behind undaunted how do you Rectify that I told you I go on feeling is that your only answer because because this is of all time and that's specific to like the two player experience but they're both two folks yeah I know that I know that but this is ranking in a context of of like all the other games that we have okay I think you've impeached yourself but sure I made sure to put them in the correct order I checked that so I didn't do that no well qu okay continue and know I
stand by it though I absolutely stand by it continue we we rank them at different times so my my I'm very emotional about these sorts of things go on man so yeah you've already talked about undaunted so not too much not in this video but no but if you watch the 20 to the 11 it's a series of games based on World War II conflicts it's hand management your hand represents soldiers which are on the field essentially and you play them and they will have certain actions that you can take with that particular uh unit let's say so Gunners or Riflemen or whatever it might be but you only have four in your hand at any one time basically so it's all about knowing what's coming potentially and playing the strategy of what you're trying to do in the battle to the best that you can using the units that you have available to complete the objective but yeah for me I was so surprised I liked it when you first got it I saw the art on the cover I was going to say it's funny that you me because of this I heavily judge games based on the cover and I just thought oh no this is not going to be for me but really enjoyed it stress fun very tense game and I just think the yeah the Simplicity of you just playing cards and moving some tokens on the board but how it lifts off the page that
you really feel like you're directing the battle because you can go about it in different ways be more offensive or defensive and at the end you always regroup and I do and think I should have held back a bit there and tried to pick you off or I should have just gone on the offensive so yeah very but like very um fun maybe not the word but considering how simple it is I think the fun and like the atmosphere is the word I'm looking for of it is really top-notch yeah uh so obviously already had it on my previous list can't agree enough it's brilliant and that initiative system I think is one of the best game design elements that I've seen where you have that hand of full cards you say but you always have to discard one so bid for who goes first and that can have a big impact because if I go first I could attack one of T's soldiers and then if I hit them and tally has the soldier in her hand then it goes and then she doesn't have that card to play anymore so that's such a brutal decision of do you give up your best card with a high number do you give up a card with a low number that does nothing so many interesting choices is in undaunted yeah moving on to my number seven and this is going to blow your mind okay it's going to be the biggest shock of the entire series interesting my number seven I'm
scared to say it is Scythe okay it's fallen from number one wow of ever for the last half long we've been playing board games since we first played scythe and I think that's just because again a bit like I was saying with barrage we've kind of lost our group yeah we had a very close-nit group of Scythe players we all were crazy about it absolutely loved it had such good times playing it and now they've moved away and it's just us and we don't particularly like stythe at two players so much so we just never really get the chance to get it out it's not something we rushing to play even though we have a deep affection for it and Scythe is a efficiency engine building game where you play different factions in a kind of alternate history World War I with big giant hulking mechs and you're kind of doing area control and you're fighting over territory you're upgrading your actions you're racing to a finish Point collect achievements by doing certain things and yeah it's it we have so much Nostalgia for it and a lot of love but it's just not something you know yeah I want to play these other games to play it has dwindled I want to play these other games more that are coming up
interesting okay my number seven is Scythe no I'm joking it's not Scythe it is love wild John company John company wow well I'm impressed it's in your top 10 yeah brilliant game second edition should say John company second edition I'm I'm surprised sh was shocking number seven really okay I thought you'd be shocked that maybe it wasn't higher maybe I didn't think it' be in your top 10 okay I feel like you need to explain the game okay so you play kind of families who are working within the East India Trading Company set back 1700s 1800s and you're all have different roles in the company it's a weird semi Cooperative competitive because you you're basically trying to go for victory points which you get a number of different ways but you all have different jobs in the company and the company is obviously an entity all trying to do the same thing basically trying to make a profit and survive because then it's generally better for everyone but there are instances where it might be more profitable for you to tank the company and work against it you you might be selfish because you have a way to get money that maybe isn't the best for the company you have to negotiate is a really big negotiation game because there's a lot of different ways where because you're split amongst all these
different roles you can't usually get to where you want to go without the help of another player yeah so it's just a very interactive it is heavy but it's also a game that you can play like a role playing game where you have kind of GM who runs you through it and in that it's actually quite simple in some ways because any given action a player will do is quite simple it's knowing ramifications true but it's such a Sandbox yeah exactly well explained thank you I think it has to go in my top 10 just because of the pure fun factor that we have when we play this game it's always a great time I think out of those sorts of games where it is very it is very complex although what you do round to around again it's one of those ones where if you just explain what you need to do okay it doesn't sound that bad but it's the implications of of the actions and decisions that you make on the company and other people and how your own standing is where the complexity comes in but we've just had so much fun playing it I think we've been pretty lucky to play this with um some good groups we actually a couple of groups that we have uh got into playing it and I think everyone has always enjoyed it as well we do throw in a little bit of the role playing like you said like you're fired manager of shipping yeah um which elevates the fun for us at least so yeah again I've said this a lot in this list but like amazing amazing
production like be like beautiful art very thematic in that way so yeah it goes up there because of the fun and the laughs I think leading on from that nicely my number six is same designer different game and that is root okay and six six yep some other games have have pushed it back a little bit but root is a game that we really enjoy I wouldn't be surprised if it's coming up on your list uh it's one of our most played games and this is the asymmetric game where your different Woodland factions and you're basically fighting to get to 30 victory points and each faction kind of plays its own little game but it's very interactive very warlike uh with a cute veneer of paint on it yeah Woodland Critters that want to murder each other and there's a lot of content for it we've done a bias guide for it and it's just something quite special in in the way all the game ties together it's a lot of fun it's always very interesting to play the different factions it's a game that's never boring and now we have found a nice group who they enjoy playing route so we've actually got a fair few games in across the last year that aren't just at two player which is usually how we used to play so that's also quite nice uh it's just I think it's just something quite unique I I really like CO's designs you know he was my number 11 it's number six
now you're number seven so you obviously like him I just think there's something always quite special and unique there and it is just a very very technically interesting game to play yep it's a very tense and just something I really enjoy okay so my number six is root hey complete crossover first one yeah of this list yeah had close but yeah for all the reasons that you just said really I think the the time maybe that solidified it for me that I really really loved it was I think we by had some spare holidays so we just took a week of work because we had nothing to use it on and we just sat around and played games and we played a couple of games of Route even at two players we were just like at one point this is such a great game yeah we were we finished it you know one of those games where you both finish within a point of each other and you just like what what a great game like when you finish playing yeah and you know we've had it for a while now we've played it quite a number of times but I still haven't been actually some of the factions so I think that is also a really great Testament to the replayability of it because it is so dependent on what other people are doing and there is a lot of factions and you can play it in different ways you know maybe uh you can go offensive like I'm just thinking about being like the Woodland Alliance
you know crawling in and putting the little tokens down which don't get you immediate points but then you can like blow it up later or you can try to run and get more points like in slow increment yeah um so just a different ways to play it so that's I think ties into what you said it's never boring because there's always a new challenge to think about I think yeah exactly so rout B of it joint number six moving to number five mine is another game that has shockingly fallen away from placing in the the top three and that is brass Bingham and so this is number five now number two and that is because there's been some sight shifting around uh so I think the next game was reversed last year kind of more or less like give it well maybe not anyway so BR Birmingham terrific terrific game currently ranked number one board game Geeks board game Geeks alltime ranking uh by player votes and you know it's it's got such a dry theme which something we love Ling Euros your your kind of um Industrial magnetes in in the industrial revolution building factories building canals AB Rail and it's just such a clean wonderful system game it's a joy to play it's a joy to introduce to people it's
just such it's is probably next pack Premiere one of the best designed games in my opinion I've ever played uh if you're looking at purely a design standpoint it's just a terrific Euro and it's it's very very hard to beat but it will be beat by my number four that's how numbers work yeah okay I'm struggling a little bit actually now she wants to flip-flop yeah so indecisive okay yeah okay my number five did you flipflop yeah oh last up to the minute flip-flops up to the minute flip flops my number five is Scythe ooh blown down the list as well I I just I just dropped it a little bit because of reasons which will become clear but yeah same same thing as you still love it would never turn a game down but it does to just sort of sit on the Shelf here and neither of us is clamoring to there's no desire that's a problem um and I guess that is just because there's two of us and even when we have people around we we just choosing other things I think it's hard to like replicate The Nostalgia that we had with it I don't even think it's that I think the biggest problem we have going back to when I was talking about it with the group is that if we introduce it to new people it's an efficiency puzzle yeah and we will
destroy them so it's not really fun for us to introduce someone because it's like we're going to show you our favorite game but we're going to completely wipe the floor with you and you'll probably have like a relatively miserable time yeah that's what I think is so hard to introduce people for me that's why I don't do it because I know they will you know it takes a few games and like will they enjoy it though if like we just I I think you just have to preface it with you know this probably will be a tough game but we can go again like right after and maybe just sit with the person and like almost do the actions for them in the first game they can understand but yeah we we just have so many other things which maybe we're enjoying more at the moment but it still for sure holds a special place in my heart so uh yeah it deserves to be there because of all the fun we've had with it in the past as I alled to my number four is another Euro it's a heavier Euro and well that we both love very much and it is Great Western Trail number four okay so this is obviously a game about her and cattle it's got got all kinds of elements you have deck building you have kind of worker placement worker movement uh you have all kinds of actions you're comboing things together playing things off each other you're yeah building up your deck of cows or sheep if you're playing Rail and Trail New Zealand there's a lot of decisions there's a lot of different paths you can take to Victory and to get points you could kind of go on the trains and work with them
you could go and try and buy a lot of cows you can build houses and little action spaces for yourself so there's a lot of different ways and I think we actually played it a lot recently we started playing it on BGA game arena with a friend and so we've actually had like a fair few games of it in the last couple of months and I think that's what just pushed it up for me have a real love for it we did the buyers guide and we covered all three I think it's almost cheating a bit because we saying gry wasn't Trail as a series so there is actually a selection of games to pick from as well as not just one yeah and I think would probably agree our favorite is Argentina just who's got a bit more going on if you're already used to Great Western Trail but it's really fun theme even though it's slightly dry but that's what we love I think the theme is great uh I think the different routes you can go is always really interesting each game feels a little bit different and I love that now there are different games in that series to play around with different mechanisms if if if that's what we want yeah agree let's see what's coming up in a few moments then my number four is campani V so this is a again another heavy Euro um it's a vatel Lera game about making electronic Vehicles Factory yeah talk about dry themes but to be
fair it is way more interesting than it sounds so it's worker placement and you basically have to go to different departments in the car factory in order to like get designs test the cars get the parts for the cars it is complex as with all V tell cus games there a lot of interlinking things or like um cascading bonuses and actions and things that come off doing certain things so you have to be very on it and the most optimal ways that you can do things the worker placement you know is quite harsh because there's only one person that can go right in each space but what we really love about it is there's this mechanic called uh the mean boss Sandra and Sandra moves around the different departments and marks how well you're doing in that department so you have to also think about doing training in each department as well as doing the action like getting parts or test the designs and if if you don't meet Sandra's standards then you're going to get punished basically and you lose points it's a really good mechanism so we like we've said we like these mean games that have a little element of toughness so for us I think that just adds a Twist on a big heavy well produced euro is the Sandra mechanic where it's slightly mean as well so you have to be considering so many things
and then that gets thrown in as well I mean as always with those types of games like amazing production I think it looks really beautiful it makes the theme of a car factory look really cool and minimalistic and the pieces are amazing like little wooden cars in different colors and I think it just has great table presence yeah I mean I'm glad there's a valal soda game on the list and is a great Euro so moving on to my number three and this is going to be the point in the video that is going to absolutely blow your mind oh my God there's no way you're going to think I'm crazy oh my God okay I'm excited I went with my heart on this one and that's not like you this went straight like when I was thinking about it it went straight in the top 10 and it flew all the way to number three and it's not even a new game we've had it years and years and years but I've just played it a lot last couple of months and it's just I got to accept where it is and my number three is res Arana okay okay yeah you see that coming I did not see that coming all I love resar that is quite shocking to me but not really cuz you beat me every time and as discussed your lists are meanness and and winning so yeah okay that must weight it upwards quite a lot so rokana is the theme is like a little whatever it's kind of your your Wizards or Mages or something and you're competing to make spells and magical stuff but what
you're really trying to do is it's a race for uh a certain amount of points and it depends if you have the expansions not but it's 10 or 13 so it's kind of a race and it's an efficiency puzzle and it's really cool because you you start by drafting uh I can't remember the cards but cards basically that do different things so you kind of draft them with all the other plays you build up your deck which is very small it's only six or seven cards you have kind of a starting Mage card in play already then you draw and you play them and the cards cost Essences to play little resources and they generally help you generate more resources or or kind of gain things or whatever and it's all about playing the cards or discarding the cards for resource to build a tableau in front of you and then you can use that Tableau for actions and everything this game is really quick and snappy which is one thing I really love about it so you know your turn will just be I turn this get three essences then next turn will be I spend these three Essences to get these three Essences and turn this card and you're just kind of yeah working your way through a chain and building a chain to then be able to either buy these monuments or places of power which give you ways to gain victory points and it's just like a flat out race it's competitive yeah it's a wonderful Little card-based Euro game comes in a small box and is one of our close friend's favorite games and I went
skiing with him and we played it a few times and had some really sweaty games we were racing to these points and the expansions make it even better uh ROK I absolutely I just a solid little game personal obviously favorite for me yeah I do really like it as well wouldn't be in my top 20 I'm not super good at it I never win you always win but I do I do enjoy always playing it and I don't think I would turn down a game of that yeah ever well you can't not allowed okay my number three is barrage that's High Praise so it was a little bit further down actually not so much but this was my part of my flip-flopping a few moments ago when I Rel looked at the list just because we have got it out again this week like you said and yeah I just I just love it it's so crazy though that I really love these mean heavy Euros because again I'm not very good at them but I just love to play them even though I get frustrated in the middle of the game and think what's the point I can never win and it's so tough but I just think they're so cool and it is satisfying to figure out how you're supposed to do something right cuz sometimes the situation seems impossible and you don't have enough resources and having to sit there and really think how you can optimize everything and then come up with a solution I think it's
just very satisfying and I just think barrage is a really cool theme as well dry Euro theme hydroelectric power I love the art I love the components I love the art deco style I love the theme it's really good I would really want to play it now actually well we just had two games like two days ago barrage and one game was two points or one point difference and the other was like five points difference so it also has close yeah but yeah I think it's brilliant and happy for it to be my number three down to the final two I would ask you to guess but that might spell number one if you guess wrong so uh I don't think you'll be surprised by my number two and it is again Cult of the new but I think it is one of the most brilliant Euros I think I know what it's going to be ever played and what is it is your you're number two void fall yes it is void fall a big heavy Euro about space and and fighting off a kind of alien infection parasite type thing the flood Bor um voidborn voidborn I yeah flood born's from Lana uh yeah the voidborn and it just does so many kind of classic Euro tropes in really new or at least semi novel interesting ways I think a lot of the systems are really
interesting it's almost infinitely replayable with all the different maps and scenarios it has so it's like semi scenario based so and you can set it up if you want more interaction or less interaction or more complexity and it's just such a rich fulfilling rewarding experience and absolutely love playing it there's nothing else quite like it in our collection it was a big surprise for me last year uh it was my number two game of last year uh brilliant and if you want a big heavy space Euro I can't recommend it enough I think it's the the kind of action selection system the way that you do that is very cool as well because you only have a certain amount of actions that you can do every round which changes actually every round so they can be now I've only got four this round or five and yeah it's you play it by cards right you get to pick two of the actions out of three on the card say which ones do you do and a lot of the game is unpicking how to do stuff so what do I have to play in what order to get to where I want to be at the end of the round to meet the scoring conditions should I do this first so that I can get that and then do that and yeah so many cool things like check out our review of it because there's too much to go into there a lot but it's such a good game no I do really like it spoiler alert is not like my number number uh 2011 I can't believe it's not your top 20 yeah I I I
feel a bit bad about that but get rling Le out there I think I don't think that I would ever choose to play it I would obviously play it no I would play it when you said let's play uh void fall I don't think I would ever pick it and I don't know why that is I think I find it almost like a bit intimidating in a way yeah I think I I completely get it has a horrible setup yeah yeah but the thing is what's actually quite interesting because you do this round structure once you start playing it again all the rules do SN back in it comes like in quite quickly I think and you find it quite like easy to get back into I just think the barrier for in my mind is maybe higher than it it is in reality because every time you get it out is no problem but it's it's a lot yeah but no I do really really like it and yeah can I give it an honorable mention honorable mention my number two is something that has retained its spot actually it's brass Birmingham mhm fair enough yes so yeah I love this game because we like these sort of industrial themed Euro games I love it because that's like the almost the opposite for void fall I you can remember the rules so easily there's so many games that we have which are heavier and you don't play it for a while and then you have to remind yourself about how things work and what are these rules but with brass
Birmingham I feel like we just remembered the rules it took a little while like it takes a game or two to really understand it and how to play it but for me at least once you do it it's so ingrained in your mind that you can just easily get this sort of you know heavier game out um and always very satisfying it's interactive with the way that other people can place their buildings and use use theu optimizing what the cards you have in your hand and how to use them and yeah I just think the theming is really cool the production is really cool and I think it's one heavier game that we have which we have actually managed to teach other people no problem um we've played it with like a few people that we don't necessarily play heavier games with and they've enjoyed it as well so I think it has to go up there for the fact that you can get it out with a wi audience even though it's one of a those heavier games for me yeah so it's a great game and obviously I already had it my top 10 but it's it's just such a great design and there's a reason it's so popular and it's a good pick thanks moving to my number one I actually can't the big reveal oh I do know what it is you will know what it is I haven't mentioned it so I was thinking I can't think what you haven't said but I just remembered yeah okay so my number one which is not a surprise to tell is John company second edition W number one gay
G straight to number one and obviously my number one and number two are my number two and number one of 2023 So Co new you heard it here first all old games suck only the new games are good so AP from agrica which is 20 years old yeah that's true so oh you called me there so yeah Jun already explained it when tally had her it on her list and for me it is just the the table talk the negotiation the role playing the the sandbox it provides the difference you have different scenarios and even within the same scenario each game feels so different you know the company can fail and the game can end early it can go the distance in the last three to four hours it's such a variable experience it's so rich it's some of the best if not the best experiences I've had in board gaming which we said in our review of it you can check that out uh there's just nothing quite like it and I can't remember except for the early days of Scythe having so much enjoyment playing a game yeah and that is why it's my number one just the pure enjoyment every second of playing it's fascinating to me the design it's brilliant John company second edition wow that is yeah strong I'm not I'm not super Uris I may be a bit surprised it's you're number one but I knew it would be up it's just it's for the for the experience the
experience the whole package yeah the experience can you think what my number one is no cuz you everything I would have said you've gone out it must be something is it something new no I can't think it will just be boring content my number one is Great Western Trail of course yeah haven't mentioned that yet course yeah so you already talked about it but it's my number one I think it's the game that I just have the most fun playing even though I barely ever win you do always say This Not That Winning is Everything of course most games I don't really win so I wouldn't have a top 20 if it was uh down to winning there'd be like two games on there qua of quinber would be on there if it was down to that but I think just the whole way the game works with going around in a Loop starting at the front of the trail ending at the at the end selling the cows or sending them off on holiday as I like to think about it it means that regardless of what everyone else is doing you are just trying to do better and better for yourself each round and then for me it's just a bonus if you can actually win I just have so much fun trying to figure out where to stop on the trail what to do what direction to go in and I could come dead last in a game of you know four players and still think I had a great time I don't remember ever having a bad time playing Great Western Trail like really
uh there there's no like frustration about it some other games which are mean maybe barrage you can get a bit frustrated in game but that doesn't exist in Great Western Trail because no one's blocking you no one's stopping you doing anything really it's just all about how you are optimizing going around so just love it same as you if I had to pick one from the series it would be um Argentina but equally you know I think the other two are brilliant as well would never turn a game down I just just love it yeah so gr and shell is brilliant I think you're right that it's always enjoyable to play it's one of the few games that just the act of playing well I mean most games been not one of the few but where it is just the act of playing is so enjoyable and worthy experience that the winning is almost secondary yeah usually that's not the case but I think void fall as well for me is also that the playing with the mechanisms the decisions you make uh the act of it is really great I think how you said about John company the experience but a lot of that comes from it is all off the table let's say and it's between the people and how the game facilitates that but this is all on the table actually it's not interactive at all but it's still there's still an experience there for me so yeah love it and I think it's a worthy number one
game nice well two absolutely terrific lists if you have any questions about the games just ask them please let us know what you think whose list was better who you agree with more let share what your favorite games are we'd love to hear it we're always looking for new ones I only discovered a gria this year yeah that's true I'm surprised actually the one thing cuz we talked about this off camera I'm surprised that you didn't have grand Austria Hotel anywhere tell discovered Grand Austria hotel and I thought it would be like in your top 11 to 20 I I did actually put it as number 20 on on my list I wrote down for myself it says Grand Austria Hotel slm my Island SL my city and I I just think my city and my Island pipped it because I was very and I'm when we first played it but then I almost forgot about it a little bit after I would happily get it out now play right now but I think I like they stand more the test of time maybe if we get it out and play it a little bit more but I think it was too new for me okay whereas you didn't care about that you were like C in the new get it in there the okay so if you found this enjoyable please consider subscribing it would really help us grow the channel and if that is enough you can subscribe as a wedding present for us uh we'd really appreciate it yeah it helps us gr the channel you know get games make buyers guides we don't have a patreon or anything so that's kind of
all we ask so that we are more attractive to Publishers the more subscribers and the more views we have but we really enjoyed doing this we really hope that you enjoyed it and we'll see you next time for more content so see you bye all right let's get married