Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 17:01

brought to you by boardgame Atlas ,com the fastest-growing boardgame community in the world kia ora and welcome to 14 games i got rid of in 2019 now these aren't the only games that got rid of this year i actually did another list halfway through the year with another ten games so these are really the ones i got rid of in the second half of the year and there are many many reasons to get rid of the game it's not just because i think they're crap in fact i quite liked some of these games but i've only got a limited amount of space and of all the new games coming in to review i simply have to move some on that's it some of these games i just didn't enjoy that much or i just know that they're not gonna get played again and frankly there's no point keeping a game if i'm not gonna play it so let's quickly move to the list with the first game tigris and euphrates now this is a tricky one because I appreciate tigris and euphrates I admire its design that I don't really enjoy playing it that much and neither do any of the people in my main groups that I play with so intellectually I can kind of go oh yes this is a very fine game with fine decisions to be made but I don't find it fun and I don't really see the point in holding on to a game even one with a really good reputation like tigris and euphrates if no one you play with is gonna want to play the game with you it's just occupying shelf space at that point and I think it's because it's a dry abstract highly competitive game that you really need to play a lot to get comfortable with and to really know what you're doing and every time I played this of a group they were like yeah that's fine I enjoyed that that was okay what are we gonna play next never got anyone say oh

let's play that again immediately afterwards so yeah that went on the trade table and it's gone to someone else who will appreciate it a lot more one of the problems of Kickstarter and there are many problems with Kickstarter is that it creates games that are more flash than substance and one of those games for me was vengeance vengeance is fine it's fun it's a lightweight Yahtzee elder sign type dice rolling game where you are the aggrieved party in a revenge movie like Kill Bill or death wish the problem is it's got relatively light and simple gameplay combined with a colossal set-up time and a truckload of miniatures that really add very little to the gameplay they're static they're just markers that go on the board and you end up with dozens of these miniatures just display it across the board for no real reason gameplay-wise other than to make the game look impressive now I like miniatures I'm a big fan of miniatures games but this one just seemed like work to set up and the miniatures were so static there wasn't any movement there was no dynamism so you note with these bags of nearly a hundred three-dimensional markers that you have to set up and then pack away and sort into their different groups and it was just a barrier to what's a very simple straightforward game now this came in a small box and was completely streamlined production-wise so it was just the mechanics and you can set up little boards put markers down and do the fights and all that kind of stuff I probably still have this game but the boxes about the same size as Star Wars rebellion and there's a hell of a lot more game in rebellion this one was sold to someone who didn't care for

the game at all and just wanted to paint the minis next up is the game that wins an award for most air in a box and that is splendor no no spin is a really popular game with a lot of people and actually don't mind splendor it's okay but I really prefer century golem and I found when the opportunity to play splendor has come up century golems been presented as an alternative and we always pick sentry golem so splendors been sitting on the shelves since I reviewed it untouched in fact I mostly did the review so I could cover the game and in on sell it to clear the space on the shelves and it brings me to an idea which is game space that's a term I used to describe games that occupy a similar play space where if you're in the mood for a set collection game it takes about 30 minutes century and splendour occupy a very similar game space and I've been trying to get to the point where I don't have lots of games occupying the same space because when you're in the mood to play one and you've got like nine options that just means those games don't get play unless you're a big fan of that particular genre so yeah it came down to a decision splendor or century golem then I pick sentry go on next up is Lancaster which is a very popular euro game and when I feels alright but i got lancaster in a math trade not understanding I was getting the Lancaster big box now i was quite keen to get a copy of lancaster and play it but the big box is freaking big and I don't like the game enough to have all the expansions all the add-ons in this colossal box so

it ended up sitting on the shelf occupying lots of space and you'll see that's a recurring theme a lot of these games have big big boxes so we ended up playing Lancaster twice and it's okay but these days okay isn't good enough to stay in my collection the game has to be like wow this is great for me to keep it around and the hilarious thing is apparently this Lancaster big box is quite tricky to get New Zealand because when I put it up for trade I had no less than three parties come to me and engage in a bidding war over it at least one person who missed out is still salty to this day number five there's another game I got in a math trade and that is Agricola and I make this really short and simple I got rid of this because one of my close friends has agricola and not only that he has a newer version of it so if I ever go round to reviewing it I probably reviewing the later Edition than this earlier one well though I've heard from a lot of people that the earlier Edition is somewhat better to play there's a few gameplay differences between that and the new one and several people have told me that I was an idiot to get rid of the older edition because it's a superior game but this is just a case of do I need to own a game that my close friend has and that I can borrow it at any time clearly the answer that is no you don't need to own games that people you play with every week have the next games tiny epic zombies and this for me was really disappointing game I got this one secondhand very very cheap off shem and I was really looking forward to it it looked neat ooh look dinky I love the meeples with the chainsaws and the little axes and stuff on them and machine guns that's really cute and then I sat down to actually

play the thing and it's just a mess of a game it was one of the harder games I've ever tried to sit up and learn to play with just seemed counterintuitive I played through a lot of games I learn a lot of games so it's not like I'm dense when it comes to reading rule books and picking things up but Tiny epic zombies just bounced off me really hard I guess I was expecting something a bit lighter and a bit more fun and it just seemed awkward I really do like the board layout either it was just really Messy and muddled so we've played a couple of games of it and it was just underwhelming even though it's a small box game I really didn't feel the need to keep it in speaking of disappointing games the next one up is the Walking Dead no sanctuary a game that seems like it has a really cool concept until you actually play it and one of the core concepts in the game is that each of your characters has three different types of actions they can do cautious ones middle level ones and aggressive ones and the leader of the group will go okay we're going to be cautious this round so everyone else has to play a cautious card otherwise that causes friction within the group and that sounded interesting theoretically but in practice it makes absolutely no freaking sense we got to be cautious we're going to do stuff and you're like wow I can't do that because I've only got angry cards in my hand so I have to be angry which creates tension within the group mechanically now for me cooperative games that have tension within them that should come from the player actions not from an arbitrary I didn't draw enough things to fit in with what you're doing therefore I'm going to cause problems for the group that sort of mechanic just

takes the agency away from the players and it's the mechanics of the game telling you that your group isn't working and for me that just sunk this game just sunk it hard okay everyone we need to be quiet we need to be real quiet out I'm only angry I can only do things loud I don't care that this zombies right beside us I'm gonna be loud now that's Walking Dead no sanctuary now you might have heard me mentioned my love for legendary aliens and occasionally my bafflement at legendary Marvel I really like the legendary encounters system for aliens I think it works really well and I've had a lot of fun playing it solo with groups and to play with death but I never really enjoyed legendary Marvel and I always thought that was because the legendary encounter system was different to the legendary system so we picked up another legendary encounters game legendary encounters x-files and it wasn't particularly good because they used the same core system it was very similar to legendary encounters aliens but the changes just made the game worse and virtually every respect so instead of having three chapters which had like a structured story to them you go through three seasons and there's like a random thing you have to solve in order to unlock bonuses for the final fight but the problem is these things you get to solve were completely and utterly arbitrary so you turn over one and it says defeat an enemy in "the bureau" in order to advance this if you don't see any enemies in the bureau this is impossible you just can't do it and there's several

times they popped up and we were like we can't do that that's that's impossible so we're gonna go into the final fight failing to complete the objectives because they were just completely arbitrary and I get that card games have randomness and that's part of the challenge and fun but compared to alien legendary where each of the chapters was structured so there were specific things you have to do but you knew, but you were given the tools you needed to do those and X Files you weren't also unlike aliens with its strong chapter structure where characters were connected and it presented to a three-act structure for a story The X Files just spat references at you oh look it's tombs he was in this season he's gonna turn up and there's also a werewolf because you know remember the werewolf from that episode he was also in that same season so you're approaching a full season of mostly episodic television and trying to present a cohesive story of that in about a dozen cards and in doing that three times for a game it was just here's a reference here's a reference here's another reference remember the guy hey remember these people that's not theme. theme is not just references and x-files is just references and to calm things down we'll go into Chocolate Factory which I thought was a pretty good game I thought it was fine but it's also quite similar to a game I really like called pay dirt and paid it was on my hidden gems list and it's a game about gold mining so with one you've got a factory producing chocolate and the other you've got an assembly line processing dirt to collect gold one has auctions and one has drafting but I felt the game space

thing came into it and I thought the games occupied such a similar space that I didn't need to have both of them and while I enjoyed Chocolate Factory it didn't do quite enough to a usurp pay dirt on the Shelf next follows a game I had a lot to like about it but almost as much to dislike about it and that's ex libres the books were great the different meeples the different factions this is actually there's a lot of good in this game but there's also some puzzling choices made in it as well the fact that locations go away each turn aside from one so you having to relearn the whole board is just a bizarre choice to me the second one is that the location boards were almost impossible to read and I play games of a few people with pretty poor eyesight so legibility is something I try to keep an eye on no pun intended and I know I could probably have House ruled this game or done something to it to make it work for me but I just can't be bothered doing that these days so for all its cute books and cute meeples and cool concept it really didn't work for us and it really didn't work for my play groups so off it went next up is a game that got panned by a lot of people a lot of reviewers said this was trash and I really enjoyed the hell out of it and that's gen7 .gen7 for us was a hilarious experience of four people playing bureaucratic middle managers arguing and bickering while their colony ship started to burst into flames around them I had some of the best table talk and banter of any game I've ever played playing gen 7 where people like I need

help fixing my things like yeah it's not on my work schedule we greed the work schedule at the team meeting and fixing the engines before they blew up was not part of my responsibility I'm afraid that's on you and that was a tone we played through the whole campaign of these pity bitter bureaucrats squabbling over their fiefdoms occasionally uniting to make sure that the whole ship doesn't explode and it was a riot it was a really good time and one of my favorite co-op will see me co-op game experiences of all time the problem is that gen 7 says it's replayable and it probably is and you can experience a different story but the mysteries gone the Magic's gone it's for all intents and purposes a legacy game that you can off sell and someone else can replay but personally I don't think a second play could top the really good experience I had I don't think it would replicate the discovery that we had in the game and I'm pretty sure any follow-on would just be a pale imitation to the first campaign we played so instead of holding this big box that I really enjoyed playing and had a lot of fun worth I thought I'd push it on to someone else and they can have a lot of fun with it as well or hate it like everyone else the third-to-last games another one of those okay games it's saloon tycoon there's actually some really innovative stuff and saloon tycoon about how you build up your saloon and the different buildings and the different character play but it's a western and I'm just not really into Western themes and none of the people I play with her into Western themes so we played a bunch of games around the time I did the review of it a year and a bit ago and since then it's

just sat and it's never been picked by anyone to play since and if the games gonna sit there for eighteen months with no interest probably time to move it on to someone else who will appreciate it the second to last game is a really wonderful story about a game I gave away to a group who I know will get a hell of a lot more enjoyment out of it than I will and that's Gridopolis us now Gridopolis is like a 3d version of Lego combined with checkers and I thought it was pretty interesting but it's also a really good game for kids and I had one of my friends test it with their kids and they really enjoyed it and they also run a games Club at a primary school which is a New Zealand equivalent of an elementary school and we donated it to that club so instead of me holding it and maybe occasionally playing again with it it's now being played by kids at school and I think that's a really good place for games to go if they're child-friendly and suitable and you know a club let's just donate them to the club it's almost certainly got a hell of a lot more plays that a would off if it had stayed with me and last and possibly least is the game that set the new record for arriving into my house being played five times reviewed and then got rid of and that is tapestry I really didn't like tapestry I really didn't enjoyed it all and it's not because I wasn't good at it I knew how the game worked I could get big scores I just saw that those scores were so dependent on the faction you picked and the tapestry cards you got and I did some tests and I played through the same

faction only taking the default 15 point trap cards through a solo game and also playing another game where I got to choose from a tableau of open cards for the most optimal one for my tapestry choices and the difference was colossal 200 points gap between game a and game b playing the same faction and with the same player expertise and there's the other thing I really didn't like about tapestry which is how the game keeps punching losers in the face and invariably the person who gets the most actions will likely win and that means they'll be playing for a while at the end of the game after the person who's come last as well and truly finished so you finish up your score up and go yeah I've got a hundred eighty points and you've still got about thirty resources to spend and that person will sit there playing through their game racking up points on you just repeatedly punching you over and over again going yep I'm ahead I'm more ahead I'm more ahead I'm more hit and a more ahead and that's our fun for anyone unless you're one of those people who really likes rubbing people's faces and when you win winning that way is kind of miserable you sitting there going through your process as everyone is sitting at the table just sort of staring twiddling their thumbs waiting for you to rack up your score and for me that's miserable game play I couldn't wait to see the back of it so that's my list of 14 games I got rid of what games did you get rid of this year let me know in the comments and you enjoyed this video like it subscribe to the channel

and support us on patreon

Progress saved