Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Best Board Games For Two Players...That Aren't Specifically Two Player! (Episode 4)

Transcript 37:40

hi everyone tali ann farrell here from board of it and we're back and we're ready to do it all over again and what we mean by that is we're back with another installment of our series best board games for two players that are not specifically designed for two players and if you have seen the series before then thank you for returning and you know what's happening we've time stamped all the games so you can jump to the ones that you want to look at and also this time we've ordered them generally from lightest and complexity to highest and we're going to section it so you can also kind of watch through the section of games that fits you if you are new thank you for joining and what this is is these days a lot of people will primarily play board games at the two play account for a variety of reasons but while it's easy to find lists of the best board games for two players because it's kind of a niche genre in gaming or board games that are specifically designed for two players people have other interests you know it's not like the genre is not fun but you're also gonna have other games you want to get and if that game says two to seven and you're mainly going to play it too you are going to wonder is that game actually any good at two or as designers just slap that on the box to sell more are you gonna be playing a variant does that game miss something that you get when you play with more so it's tough to work out if it's a good game to spend your money on or not and this video is an attempt where we're

going to go through some games that are designed for more than two players but that we really enjoy playing at two players or maybe they're even better at two players than higher player accounts and we're going to go through these games and what we're going to do is we're going to give you a blurb on them maybe describe how they work a little bit then we're going to tell you why is it good at two players and how does it differ if you play with more lastly we're going to tell you why we generally like it what's special about that game because these games are going to be the kind of highlights that we've been playing over the last six months but there's a big mix of popular games new games old classics and just maybe weird more obscure ones so uh we appreciate you all joining yeah if this is helpful we'd love it if you could subscribe and we will now get on to the games themselves so first up we have cascadia and this is a puzzly tile laying game from the same publishers as calico and on your turn all you'll be doing is taking a landscape tile and a corresponding animal token and you can place these anywhere in your own personal landscape each of the animals will score in a different way so this is going to be driving where you place them in your landscape but the trick is to combine all five animal types in the most optimal way for scoring we also need to be thinking about how you can score for

contiguous terrain types so why is it good at two players well honestly some games even though you can play with more and this is one four players are just better at two players and this is definitely one of them and this is because firstly the game has no interaction so it doesn't matter how many players there are you're still gonna have the same great experience but when you have more players you get more downtime without getting anything extra from the experience so it is preferable to play with less so you can have more game and the other part is that because you take the tiles and the tokens from the middle with four players there's going to be a lot more influx and the people going to be taking them so there's no point thinking about what you want before it's your turn because it likely won't be there anymore whereas that too you have kind of a three hour four chance it will still be there which means you can strategize and the game moves a bit quicker in that respect but yeah so this is the game to get if you like games that are low complexity but still have a bit of crunch and brainwork it's also really relaxing to play i think that's been a comment from a lot of people that we have played with very relaxing very calming very peaceful it was actually farrell's number two game from games that came out of the 2021 yeah and it was also in my top 10 list as well big hit for us yes one of our most played i think yes yes so that is cascadia

here we have the quest for el dorado which is for two to four players and this is a deck building race game from master designer rhino rhinocenicia and the goal of the game is to be the first person to get to el dorado that's why it's a race but how you do this is through playing cards and deck building and what's interesting is that to move you play a card and then that will allow you potentially to move on certain types of hexes so a machete to move through the jungle spaces for example and the deck building comes in because you can buy better cards that might let you move further or give you special powers to do kind of you know edit your deck let's say or draw extra cards that turn that so why is it good at two well because it is a race game it could be argued that it is better the more players you have because obviously races create excitement and tension but we personally think it too you do still get that same experience and thrill but just with a small twist so when you play it two each player has two explorers that they control and you only win by getting both explorers to el dorado so what you might miss in table talk and kind of excitement you get back with skill and strategy it also makes the game a bit smoother because you're less likely to get stuck each round with not drawing the right cards as you do in three to four player version sometimes your explorer just gets stuck you don't have the right cards whereas here because you have two explorers you can just divert those cars

to your other explorer yeah and it should work out so who's this for well this is kind of perfect if you're looking for something that you can play at two-player that if you like race games if you like the tension of race games if you like deck builders there's another great one and in particular it's great that if you if it's if you want to play a game at two players here and there but you also want to have a two-player game that is good that you can introduce to family members and friends who maybe aren't into board games or mildly into board games this has been a really big hit actually with my family in particular my mother and one of her friends came and stayed with us and they absolutely loved it so it's kind of a generational crosser as well uh but yeah so the quest for el dorado great at two great at four so our next game is galaxy trucker and this is a real-time tile laying game in which there's a central pool of tiles and everyone will be taking the tiles in order to build a spaceship that's adaptable to a variety of situations and then once everyone has built their ship you'll go on a space flight by drawing cards which might give you opportunities give you money or maybe a more dangerous event such as a meteor shower and the goal of the game is to make it to the end of the flight with your ship still intact and whoever has the most money is going to be the winner so why play that two well we've actually mostly we've played this a lot since we

got it and we've mostly played that two and had an absolute blast and what was interesting is when we finally played with four and this is two to four that i thought the gameplay would change a little bit in terms of the tightness of taking these tiles from the middle and it just didn't really it didn't feel any different at all and in part this is because it's quite solitaire because for the first half of a game you play you're going to be focusing on your own shipboard and taking tiles and like looking in central and the other players don't affect that too much i imagine if you played with the kind of level three ship for example that takes a lot more tiles maybe things will get much tighter with four players but generally if you're playing with a level one or two ship there's not really a difference in feel it's not like you can't get things you need still yep and i think the other thing that i would say is also it's kind of maybe a little bit better playing it too because if you're the person to flip the last timer signaling that you only have like 60 seconds left and no one else is ready the more players the more people are going to get pissed off with you so if there's only one other player you get less anger directed at you you don't mind if you annoy me no well not that you mind annoying anyone but yeah anyway uh we do think this is a slightly more complex game than your average sort of family weight gain but like farrow was saying there are a variety of levels to play in terms of how big the ship is so that's really great and what's really

cool is you can combine all of these levels together to make one game but for new players you can just play with the level one ship have a game done in 10 minutes so they can get to get to good with it see how it goes and then you just go again this is a great game for people that want something humorous and zany and where you're going to be laughing a lot are other people's misfortune and what we will say is it is fairly luck based that's just something to be aware of but in any case at two three four players pretty much the same experience and you're going to have a lot of fun with it now we have the beautiful reprint of tinder's trail a game by martin wallace and this is an economic auction resource management game and it's all about tin mining and cornwall big up and obviously very exciting theme and what you're going to be doing is you're going to be auctioning on mines and a lot of the time you won't know what's in them so you kind of have this funny thing where you flip over and it's either really good or everyone else laughs at you because there's nothing but water and most of these mines will come flooded with a bit of water water makes it more expensive to get the metal out and so you can use action points to get machinery to get rid of the water and it's about kind of managing your money to extract metal but also to spend it for victory points and you essentially you want to get the metal out and then you sell it all at the end of every round and the price is randomized so there's a

bit of when you take the metal out when you sell it as well yeah so why do we enjoy it at two players well usually with auction mechanics they completely fall apart if you don't have at least three players but sometimes games find a way to make it work and this is definitely one of them so when you start a bid there's a minimum price as dictated by a card in the two player variant so because you're at least paying a fair price for the mine it doesn't allow other players to cut in later on and be able to buy a bunch of mines for nothing so that works really well the map the size of the map and the availability of the machinery is also scaled according to the player account so you still get that crunch and and fight for the machinery which makes it just as cutlery at two players as it is with a higher player accounts so beside those two points of interaction the game is mostly spent working on your own mind extracting your own metal so for that part you don't really lose anything out to players yeah and while yeah you could say that it's something better played with more just because the auction mechanics pop it's definitely not something you have to not get because you'll only play it two players as we said the auction mechanics translate very well down to two players and just it is a very it's a very nice game it's a bit lighter than most economic games and there's a lot of kind of randomness in here that makes it quite spicy for a euro makes it feel different

even though it's an older game and i think this is for you if you like martin wallace games or economic games or you just kind of want something a bit lighter and pretty looking to have a bit of fun or you're really into mining here and pasties and pasties yes so that is timmy's trail by martin waltz and we do have a full review of this which we'll put down in the description box below yep so our next game is and i hope my pronunciation of that was was okay uh it's a bag building euro which we've become super fond of because quite frankly it's just really fun to draw the stuff out of the bag and it also has some really smart mechanisms for negating luck we would talk about the theme but really what theme you are medieval people doing medieval things and if you look at it hard enough it all falls apart yeah so why is it good at two players well so this game is for so some versions of two four capstone games have kind of got the rights at least in america and have a new version out that's two to five uh so obviously you can play with a lot of people and generally you know it's a classic euro there isn't too much change if you're playing at two or if you're playing at five the only thing we would say is this could depend on what you like your games to be

because being classic euro there's not so much interaction but there is kind of actually a little more interaction than most in terms of you have a central board where you're moving your people around and building houses and this stays the same size in terms of space availability though there's some extra goods to pick up with more people but but so you'd be bumping into people more at higher play accounts there's a lot of tracks where if you're the first person to this space or to be in first position you get something and with more people obviously becomes much tighter and there's more chance it's not going to be you so if you want your games to be a bit tighter you might prefer that four or five but if you like them to be a bit lighter and more friendly and to explore the mechanisms you're going to prefer it at two but either way it is really brilliant at any play account to be honest and the general feel of the game doesn't change too much yeah yeah so like farrell says if you like your games to be a little bit looser in terms of direct competition then you're going to prefer online at two players at two it allows you to really explore the systems and to be point maximizing without having to worry about doing very specific things just to beat your other players to it so we really love olian and would highly recommend it modern classic modern classic modern beige trader classic now we have intrepid which is a cooperative game and i think it's the

only one on the list and that is because we hate co-ops no not really it's just that we're both savages and we've direct competition so we tend to prefer competitive games i just want to beat you yeah and also generally competitive games there's more of a question about the play account because co-operatives scale quite well but in this one you are an astronaut aboard the international space station and some sort of disaster has occurred maybe a meteorite has hit the space station and you kind of have to run around repairing stuff to survive so it's kind of grim if you die because everyone aboard the iss has just died but this is uh kind of a dice manipulation puzzle game where you're going to play as an astronaut and they all have a unique way of manipulating dice and they have to put these dice on tiles showing specific faces to activate that tile produce resources you kind of use the powers on these tiles and your own powers to manipulate the dice yeah so why play it two players well as farrell mentioned it's a cooperative and they are generally scaling pretty well so the experience is going to be you know pretty similar at two to four players however we personally actually think that the two player count is is the best for intrepid yeah because we do think that playing solo it would be kind of too many balls for one person to manage comfortably and it's a bit too much and at four players it's much tougher to keep track of what everyone else is doing and to know how and when to collaborate best

particularly because each player is playing quite differently so we do think two really is the sweet spot here in terms of the titles that you have to work with versus the puzzle that you get back out of it yeah so i mean we prefer to play it too but it's going to be equally as great at four i just think or one or whatever three it's just more comfortable i think it too and this is actually maybe my favorite cooperative of the moment uh i just really like the theme i think it's quite a nice theme i think it's an interesting puzzle and this is perfect for people who want cooperative games and want to completely avoid quarterbacking yeah because you cannot do that in this game because much in the way of how spirit island handles it because players are doing these asymmetric astronauts and manipulating dice in different ways you really have no concept of what they're doing or how they're doing it so it's you can't dictate to them to do their own stuff because you're on your own tiles over here so that's quite nice but yeah if you like dice rolling if you like puzzles if you like cooperative games this is a lovely big box cooperative it's gonna say lovely but nearly did ruin our relationship so oh yeah that's true because be careful of that yeah if if you've failed because the other person can't do simple addition it's the lack of quarterbacking means that you might actually get shouted out yeah that's true that's true but maybe that's just you told me you could make 13 energy we're savages yeah

that is intrepid so next up we have mind management which is a hidden movement game for one to five players which will be head to head if you play with two players or one versus many if you play out more and you either take the role of the agency or the rogue agents and the goal of the agency is to move around the board recruiting new agents secretly passing through certain spaces on the player board which have certain icons on them which match a set of cards that are behind a hidden screen and the role of the rogue agents is to hunt them down and stop them you also have the game expanding out as you can add in different content the more games you play which might give one side a crazy power so you'll be having some really good cat and mouse battles so why player set two why not player two honestly this is the kind of game that this list was made for because i feel like this is a kind of game that people will look at and go it's one to five players it's seems to be uh one verse many ah it's only two of us you know are we going gonna get the same experience as having a bunch of people no this game is better at two player two and like two only honestly no no not really but so what it is is that when you have two this game is a tense head-to-head battle of the wits you have the rogue agent who controls all of them and you have the agency and i'm just

pointing like this because basically who me and talia are every single time yeah and it's head-to-head and it's very tight and everyone's in control of everything but the more players you get you add them all to the rogue agents team which means that you're diluting down your kind of gameplay experience five more because if you have four or five players four of them will be rogue agents one will have a rogue agent each but that means that you're now getting 0.5 turns to every two of the agencies turns because you move your one character someone else moves their character agency turn the other two players do their stuff comes back to you and it's just it's not as fun as being you know directly in control of everything and playing alternate turns and the other thing is that the more people you have obviously you have you're kind of cooperating and this game is primed for quarterbacking i think particularly if you have one player that's more experienced and the reason for this is that it really demands intense cooperation and you will have to agree on the best path and what you're doing so if you get people that don't and people stop going i want to do this like you're going to lose and on top of that you get people quarterbacking because they don't want to lose and be like no you've got to go here yeah and overriding people so yeah yeah i mean honestly we are absolutely in love with this game and it's almost certainly

going to be going to be on our top 10 best games of 2022 lists and we are only in january so make that what you will um it is amazing at any player count it's just that we do think it's better out too it's more of a tense tactical battle for all of the reasons floral mentioned above um it also oozes theme the production quality is amazing the art direction is just fantastic and it also has a lot of variability because of the different contact content packs that you can add in so definitely a recommendation i'll say that i think on board game geek they agree with us because the recommended player count is two or two or three i think so yeah so yeah but do not sleep on this one here we have hadrian's wool a heavy flipping right that's based around building hadrian's wall and the kind of surrounding cities populating with people and giving them theater and stuff like that but also defending against attacks from pits and how this works is at the beginning of a round you're going to flip a card it's going to give you a bunch of resources which are actually physical tokens in this game and then you're going to spend them to tick out like boxes on big sheets of paper and as you take out these boxes you know you can do all kinds of different tracks and they all do different things and give you different stuff or with score points or whatever

but sometimes you'll fill in a box and you'll have an image of a resource and then you get that resource so the game kind of is to spin out these resources for as long as possible by smartly filling boxes that give you some investing them and so on yep so why play it too well quite honestly this is something that we would only ever play it to or solo i guess because it's one of the most solitaire gaming experiences we've ever had even more so than the usual something and rights yeah if we had people coming over for a gaming night we would never put this down in front of them because it's like you're all just sitting around having quiet time almost like doing a school test and so we definitely think this is something to play with someone that you live with for instance where you can both just be comfortable sitting down having some quiet time and gaming together yeah i think what's funny is this game plays one to six players that's a lot of players right but the uh best player count on bgg i just looked is one which i think just is a testament to how solo this game is yeah this is for you know if you i don't know play as a couple or housemates or family this is what that game's for it's nice to sit down and it's competitive but you're kind of doing your own thing it's a nice quiet time maybe with some tea or something but if you like heavier games if you like uh rolling rights and if you like resource management and crossing out boxes then it's for you and what we

really like is this is kind of the first roll and write or flip and write we've played that feels like a big tabletop experience because it comes with these physical resources it's quite tactile and it just has a bit of crunch but it still plays in under an hour so it's quite nice but yeah that is hadrian's wall so now we're getting to the games that a little more complex a little more mean and nothing is meaner than nemesis and nemesis lockdown and this here is nemesis lockdown which is the new standalone expansion two nemesis and this series is essentially alien support game it's a survival horror board game replicating the experience of the alien movies essentially with the names and locations changed and this is great for generating stories amongst your group it's very random but the randomness kind of combines to create unique experiences every time you play and it can be hit or miss you could have bad games but you're going to have really wonderful games as well it's going to be really exciting and really fun and in this what you're trying to do is you're trying to escape a facility on mars night stalkers have got out they're killing people and you'll have a secret objective might be kill another player might be find this rim and send a signal and then get out of there but you're going to try and do that you might work with other players you might not but it's really good fun it's a great experience and it's for one two five players yep but why play two players

well honestly we have mostly played this at two players uh in a semi-co-op way and we've really enjoyed it when we have had more players in the mix whilst it's been really great to have them there for kind of the interaction and the table talk we kind of found that the moment-to-moment gameplay is not that much different we do think you might get a bit of a different sort of overall experience at two players versus higher player accounts because you're going to have more movement more secret missions more possible betrayal yeah but in terms of the actual nemesis experience you're going to get that at any player count and if anything the bonus of playing at 2 is it can be a much quicker game which is sometimes nice in a game that can run for more than three hours yeah now i'm sure this is one that people might disagree with they might say oh i've never played it too it's much better with more but i think the thing for us is that like we said the experience didn't change so much besides the niceness of just having another player and interaction and stuff but this just isn't a game that we would go uh i'd like to play it this weekend but we only have us two i just get out honestly and that's the point here and the point of this series i guess you could say is that you will have a great time doing it at two players and you know so this is for people who maybe you're a fan of like the arkham games you like the the difficulty a bit of randomness you like generating stories and making up narratives and that no game arguably does it better than this and that's why it's rated so highly uh or at least the

original nemesis is yeah so yeah nemesis lockdown good fun at two planets yep and we do have a couple of other videos um about nemesis lockdown the first one is a bit of a buyer's guide where we talk a bit about the differences between the original nemesis analysis lockdown what to look out for who each version might be for and then we also have a full review of nemesis lockdown so we'll again link them in the description box below so next up we have coffee traders now this is probably the most controversial pick on this list because we're quite sure there's a lot of people out there that would say they would never play this with two players because the two-player variant is rubbish and they're wrong we would say they are right wrong no i'm joking but they are wrong no it's a fair opinion however i strongly disagree because this was my number two game of 2021 and we have mostly played out two players yeah and we think the two player variant is perfectly fine in any case coffee traders is a big heavy crunchy euro about bringing fair trade cooperatives to the different coffee growing regions around the world you have a bit of worker placement area control and resource management so why play it too and to be honest more than any other game on this list this is probably well it is best if you play with three to five i think we can agree um because it is a highly interactive euro like if you think of barrage or

something like that but barrage is actually surprisingly good at two players we were surprised about that i think when we played it um but yeah this is better but the two player variant is actually quite good and you have kind of an automated third player and it works really well and honestly it feels pretty similar to just playing three players which have also played out a fair amount and what i particularly like that this kind of automated player does is that they have predictable actions or sorry they have actions you kind of maybe predict or that you know they will do which then lends the game an element of strategy because you go ah they're gonna do this which means i'm gonna do this now and i don't have to worry about doing that and you can kind of use that to plan out better because usually when you're playing with more players the game's almost purely tactical in some aspects because you don't know what the other player is going to do whereas because you can predict this it makes the strategic element in the game which i think we really like yeah and yeah like i said i mean it's not that much different than playing three players to be honest and this is a really good heavy euro games excellent designs really nice mechanics i think it's fairly different to kind of what's out there at the moment yeah essentially i mean it's not the best game on this list for two players but if you mostly play it two players and you like the sound of the game either because the theme appeals to you or you like big heavy crunchy euros we personally don't think we you should let

that kind of put you off yeah you won't be disappointed if you do play it two players according to our own experience uh is a terrifically designed euro that we do feel like maybe he didn't get the attention it deserves but that could be due to the fact it's a very expensive game yeah i think that's kind of an issue as well with the two-player aspect is that because it would be nicer to occasionally play with like four if you only ever will play it too it is fairly expensive so that's maybe the biggest issue yeah value for money is something to to consider for you but yeah as i said it was my number two game of 2021 which i think is a very prestigious award so that was coffee traders and we also do have a full review of this one last but not least although probably heaviest we have imperial steam and this is a railway building game uh and although the box says austria you're going to kind of build railways in countries surrounding austria as well and you're going to be building railways and making industries and building train stations and the point of the game is to make the most money by the end of it uh yeah you can classically complete objectives you can manipulate stock in your company and it's very brutally difficult hard game where you never have enough money to pay for things and you always want to do more than you can you're very limited in what you can kind

of do like you could only buy one resource every time you go to the market but if you go to the market again you have to pay like lose reputation so yeah so this is a tricky one yeah definitely very brutal but why play at two players well firstly it's a surprisingly quick game at two players despite the complexity and it's always kind of nice to have these games in your collection where you get that big heavy experience but you don't have to always be spending two hours on the game secondly the game has special tiles and boards for each of the player counts and these do successfully elicit some of the same crunch so kind of scales well in that way the main differences are going to be on the main board because it doesn't change size according to the player counts so you're going to get a bit more crunch when you're trying to build out your railways particularly because all of the players begin in vienna and you're going to be racing to try and get to the cities that allow you to deliver the goods generally players can't have more than two tracks coming off of a single city and to build a track where a player already is requires you to pay them money which as farrell said is an extremely tight resource so it's gonna be a bit more brutal in terms of the the fight for space in four players than it is at two but at two you are gonna still be coming together and fighting over the tracks but probably just a bit less often yeah so i think it depends obviously how you

like your games but honestly it's actually maybe preferable too just to have that bit of breathing room with building the railways because the rest of the game is so tough and brutal but i think no matter what play account you played as it's going to be much the same experience because as i said this more than many other games has excellently designed the feel to be the same at each player count because of these different tiles and boards that it incorporates and who is this for well people i love really brutal games but games that the more you play the more you can work out the mechanisms and you know you'll play the first game and maybe you'll get 200 and then you'll play the fifth game and you'll get like a thousand and you're like i would never believe that possible for my first play yeah so it's good if you want a game that you can keep you know especially if you're only going to play a two player kind of have this matter of practicing it and getting better and getting more competitive but yeah that is the final game on this list imperial steam and just to round off our video it's going to give a bit of a shout out to some honorable mentions of some games that are specifically designed for two players that we have been really enjoying yeah and they are mantis fools summon awards second edition and caper europe which if you're a regular viewer of our channel you know probably that we are absolutely obsessed with yeah uh uh so this is almost certainly gone in like caper our top ten for this

year maybe our top ten of all time wouldn't surprise me and it made me laugh because the dice tower i've just done their top 100 and it was in z garcia's number 15 i think yeah and straight in there so yeah so we've been loving that that is the ultimate two-player head-to-head game for us i think yeah mantis falls is really cool because it's is actually two to three players yes so it's a bit of a cheap but we didn't include in this video just because i mean it's for two to three players like it's basically specifically for two players right and it's probably better at two players we think as well and this is a little social kind of deception deduction game that might be cooperative when you play or might not and that's kind of where this deduction comes from because you won't know if you can trust the other player and it's really good fun and it kind of evolves as you play and then when you talk about summoner wars which was on both of our top ten lists of last year yeah so it's a kind of head-to-head game where you each play as a different faction i'll kind of describe it as a bit chest-like so you're you're behind your cards and you're drawing them out and you place them on certain places on your board and you're kind of moving moving them around um you go through a series of actions which is always the same every every round so summon move attack and you've really got to think about where you're moving your cars to eliminate the other players um units so you have to really see yeah spatial puzzle and you have limited amount that you can do so you can only attack three times only move two times

so you have to be very careful with what you're doing and optimize all the time but also be anticipating what the other player might do to you and for me that was a big surprise because i kind of judged it by the cover looked like not really my thing uh but actually it's really fun really tense the games usually go on for a lot longer than we think they're they're going to because uh it's such a tense battle so we really enjoy that and for caper europe we have both a play-through video and a full review which you can check out and we also have a review for mantis falls if you want to know more about and generally although i've said it sometimes a lot of these games not all of them we have content for and we're going to link that down below reviews of a lot of them uh or play throughs for like the quest for el dorado and yeah we'll link that down below and essentially uh we really just hope this was helpful to you and if it was again we'd really appreciate it if you subscribed if you have any questions please let us know yeah and please tell us your favorite games that fit into this category yeah but most importantly thank you for watching

Progress saved