Skip to main content
Loading video...

15 Games I Was Wrong On - with Tom Vasel

Transcript 25:34

Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassos, and today we're talking about 15 games that I was wrong about. Now, as we get into this, this is kind of a tricky thing because when I go back and look at this and I've looked through hundreds and hundreds of games that I reviewed over the years and tried to pick games where there was a considerable difference to how I think about them now to my initial rating/review of the game. Now, it's almost egotistical to say it was hard to find games, but that's really the case of it because if you really hate a game, you're not going to go back and play it more often. If you really love a game, it would be weird for it to suddenly be one that you suddenly hate. But there are reasons that these things can change, and that's what I want to talk about in this video. Now, that being said, I know the vast majority of comments below will be, well, here's one game you were definitely wrong about, Tom. You love this game and you're crazy, it's wrong.

Or you hated this game and ruined everyone who was part of this game's lives with your review, which is not really true. Um but yeah, you can't really be wrong about a game with an opinion because that's what they are. They're subjective opinions. Anyone who always says the Dice Tower doesn't do objective reviews, you are 100% correct. We do not do objective reviews. Our things are all subjective. They're just our thoughts on the games. And there's always going to be the you didn't play it right, you didn't play it with the right group, did you even play it at all? And the answer to that is yes. Um you you messed this up, you don't know how to play this, why did you even play this type of game, blah blah blah. Um but we do change and we do you know, things will change as time goes by. On my list today, the 15 games I'm talking about, about half are have gone up and half have gone down. I did not include games from my childhood, because we all dramatically changed from things that we liked or didn't like from a childhood. I have one game from my childhood, but I'll talk about that.

It's a little bit different. But for the most part, these are games that time has changed my thoughts patterns on them. So I thought I would share those with you today and tell you what's changed about them. And also I want to point out that these are in no particular order at all. They're actually Yeah, they're really kind of in a random order here. So let's get started. First we have Devine. So this is a game and I I remember when Devine came out and it's part of the GIPF series, an abstract strategy game in which you are trying to essentially form a stack of your pieces whilst remaining connected to these red pieces on the board. They're like lifelines of sorts. When this game came out, the Games magazine, which is really they don't do the top 100 games, but they did a top 100 games every year. And the year that Devine came out, they said this was the best game of the year. And I was kind of huffy about it. I'm like, no way is an abstract game the best game of the year.

And then I played Devine and I was like, this isn't really that good. I was very chill on Devine for a while. But as the years went by, I tended to play the GIPF series over and over again. And the more I played Devine, the more I really liked it. The more it continued to rise rise. It's not as as high for me as YINSH, which is my favorite in the series, but Devine is a classic game. Is it the best game that came out that year? I don't know. I don't know that I would always agree on that, but I definitely like a lot more than I used to. And this is one where just more plays helped me like a game more. Now, before I jump to the next one, I will say that this video is not for that. This is not Tom, you need to play this more, you'll like it more, because I really don't I think in my life there are many bad games that I played and many games I didn't like. Why should I go back and play them over and over again hoping that I will like them rather than just play games I know I like already or a game that I don't if I like or not, but it might be good. So, don't think you're going to come grab me at a convention and be like, Tom, we're going to play this game and now you'll like it. But it did happen with The Van Detective. I remember the first play of Detective. We played it at a convention and this was a game that I was very very excited about. We we got into it. We we like searching for researching notes, looking on the internet. This was such a fascinating idea. The whole escape room genre has been like such a high for me

when it first came out. I was excited about all of it. But as the years went by, Detective became a chore. And you have to like really get into that stuff. I I get that some people get into it, but I want a more specific smaller streamlined thing. So, I was really excited about Detective, but this one kind of just faded for me as time went by to the point where now I'd be like, it feels like all out of work. So, I went from liking it a lot to not enjoying it as much nowadays or even there's other escape room games I put on I thought about putting on here. I thought about Time Stories, for example, but Time Stories while my final ranking of it is so much worse than me loving it giving it a 10 at the beginning, that's the result of bad expansions and not a fault of the base game itself.

Although you could argue that the promise was false, what have you. And exit games, even though I'm kind of fading on them a bit, it's not necessarily that the first ones were bad. It's just that the the the newer ones are not as as as as I just feel like I've seen a lot of the stuff before. But with Detective, it's the methodology of it that I find to be a little bit more tiresome and why this one has gone down for me. Next we have another game from the same company here Portal Games and that's Robinson Crusoe. Robinson Crusoe was one of the first cooperative games I played and I played a lot of cooperative games over the years, but it came it became a tsunami as time went by. And Robinson Crusoe I played a lot. We played it several times live on our channel. We played it with the designer. Me and Zee played it with the designer talking to us. We've done it a lot.

And every single time I played Robinson Crusoe, I liked it less. Why is that? I think on one hand, it's because every time I play Robinson Crusoe, I feel like I need to relearn the rules. Every time I play Robinson Crusoe, I feel this crushing overwhelming Are we going to survive? And I finally did beat it. I finally beat Robinson Crusoe once. I beat this game. And that was me playing with somebody online. We were playing on Board Game Arena or something like that. And we finally won. And yet I look at it now and it's with this feeling of dread. So this one has dropped for me tremendously. I used to really like it. But there are other cooperative games that I think I'd rather play more now.

Next we have Photosynthesis. Photosynthesis is the game where a player and an expansion killed the game for me. So Photosynthesis is a game about growing these trees and it's a mean game and we talked about this meanness of this game and back and forth the sun going around and stuff. And I got into that. We played the expansion one time and it was such a bad expansion, I think. I didn't think the expansion was very good. But I played with a player who utilized the game and did things like putting a tree in the middle and then not growing that tree, but just basically just putting it there to stop other people from doing it and just constantly And the game just felt like I was being slapped in the face the whole time. Now, you can say, and I agree, that a bad player does not a bad game make for sure. But then the next time I went back to Photosynthesis, it felt like it happened again. Not in nearly as dramatic as as a way, but I was like, wow, I just don't like this game nearly as much as before. I remember I originally gave it I think a nine. Really loved it.

I think it was in my top 100 at one point. But now when I look at it, I think I don't know. I I I don't mind being mean to other people in games, but Photosynthesis felt like someone stuck a knife and just was twisting it the whole game. And that wasn't as fun for me, which is why photosynthesis has dropped. Next we have Age of Steam. So Age of Steam is a classic game. And while there's a lot of things I I I loved Age of Steam when it first came out. I was so fascinated by the system that Martin Wallace had created. Age of Steam has dropped for me tremendously for many different reasons. Um one, I think better versions have come out as time has gone by. You know, we have the Railroad Tycoon, we have Steam itself. And those games were all more forgiving than Age of Steam was.

And that's what I as the more time I played, the more I disliked how tight the auction was in Age of Steam, how just unforgiving it was. Also, as a side note, I found that the Age of Steam community when I even hesitated and said I like Railroad Tycoon better, they came in and just screamed at me so much I thought I don't need to play Age of Steam anymore. Y'all don't seem particularly fun to play with. I do know there's a lot of people who love the game and they still make maps every year, but I think this this day of me liking a game and I like I mean, I look at Age of Steam and I can admire it. And many of the mechanisms that I admire from it are now done in games where I feel a little bit less. There's still things I can cut people off. I can still, you know, still tight games, but Age of Steam felt so tight, miserly in the enjoyment that it gave. So it's dropped for me as time went by.

All right. Well, we've talked about some negative games going down. Let's talk about a game going up and that would be Camel Up. Once again, and I'll tell you what, as a as a reviewer, it's always kind of silly sometimes the things that affect us. I mentioned before Games Magazine, you know, affected me because they said this game was great. Uh Camel Up beat Splendor for the Spiel des Jahres. And when that happened, I was like, that is not possible. Splendor is a fantastic game. And I remember the first time I played Camel Up, I thought this is just okay. Now, I then played the second edition and loved it. But I've gone back and looked at the first edition. And the fact of the matter is, it's not so bad. I like it. But when it came out, I said, it's okay at best.

I was I was annoyed at it, but I think part of my annoyance is were why is everyone raving about a game? And which is a tricky thing because sometimes you do think that you're like, this game can't be as good as everyone says. And you have to kind of look behind that. We really try to do that on the Dice Tower, we do. But sometimes, as a matter of course, it might not happen. And I think that's what happened with uh Camel Up. Now, Camel Up itself has been displaced, I think, by a lot of other, you know, Ready Set Bet and and Hot Streak and things like that. But that doesn't mean it's still not a very very good game and one that I like more now. Conan. Man, folks. So, this is a game I remember the first time I heard about this game, I was very excited. I saw it for Conan fighting a lion and there's monsters and this was so exciting. And we played it and I was kind of enthralled. I liked this river system of moving these tiles. I liked the game.

I think I think I like the game. Because as time went by, each successive time that I played Conan, every time I got infuriated at that horrible horrible rule book, which they really doubled down on when they made the Batman version of the game because it was just as bad back then than the new one. But I That rule book's bad. But then also other things like Conan being Superman and everyone else being uh you know, just Jimmy Olsen running around next to them. It was it was There was a lot of issues I saw as time goes by to the point where I just don't want to play it. And the way the scenarios are written were like you can use people in this scenario. Who do I use in what scenario? Now, I know people will tell me that they probably cleaned things up in recent years and maybe they have.

But it really as I mean, I I went and looked at my review. I was very excited. I'm excited to see stuff in the future. And I'm not excited at all now, unfortunately. Villainous is a tough one to put on the list here, um because I like Villainous, and I think there's a lot of good things about Villainous, but there's one major thing about Villainous that has changed as time has gone by. And that is the fact that when I first played Villainous, I was very much like, wow, this is really cool. They have unique Disney illustrations to this. You have your own deck. They're taking these different uh villains from Disney and they're doing new things with them, and you do this. And I pushed it because they sell it at Target, they sell it everywhere as a family-style game. But every time in the last several years that I've introduced this to people who don't play a lot of board games, it has bombed.

It is complicated and it keeps getting more complicated with each successive set, but when you go to the store, you don't know which one. They can't tell me to buy the original one. And so it's really dropped for me because of that, because the complexity to Fun Ranking isn't quite there. There's a lot of stuff going on in this game. There's a lot of moving pieces, but the game itself is really, really simple and basic. And so for that end, it has dropped for me over time because it used to be like, hey, go to Target and get Villainous. Now I'm like, go to Target and yeah, get one of the better games, you know, a simpler game because Villainous just has failed me so many times. Saint Petersburg. Now you all, if you watch our channel at all, you know I'm a huge fan of Saint Petersburg. It is one of my favorite games. Uh we'll be doing our top 100 games next year, and there's a very good chance that Saint Petersburg will land in that top 100. Why is that?

Uh you know, why's it on this list though? Because when I first played it, I just I couldn't get it. I kept playing and saying, I don't understand it. It's fine at best, at best, maybe with two. For the longest time I was like, two player only. To the point where I wrote a review series with other people where I was trying to start a new thing back in the day, and we were talking 20 years ago, where I wrote the anti-Saint Petersburg section of it because I just wasn' that impressed with it. But as time went by, I played it more and more. The new version came out. They just came out with a new version this year. Um but it is an ugly game. But it is definitely a particularly fun one. There's something about it. Every time I play it, I go, wow, I just have such a great time with this game. And this is one of the highest ones that has raised for me over the years, St.

Petersburg. Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico is another one and maybe I have a type here where I look at it and everyone was like, this game's amazing. Number one Puerto Rico magazines. And I played it when I first got into the Euro game hobby around 2001, 25 years ago or so. This was one of the first games I bought cuz everyone was raving about it. And I played it and I was like, oh. Well, that's fine. Then I played it with other people and I definitely ran into some of the problems that Puerto Rico has where if you don't pick the right action on your turn, the person next to you can get irritated because you mess things up and everything like that. And I was like, oh man. And so I kind of was getting ready to write Puerto Rico off. I remember I did my top 100 games of all time, the very initial list of my top 100 games of all time. And number 100 was Puerto Rico.

At the time, I'd played like 300 games, you know? And the crowd was like, what? So low? And I was like, yeah, and it's going to drop off. And it did. But it came back on my list. There's two reasons for that. One, somehow, I think it was Eagle Griffin at the time or just Eagle Games made a computer game version of Puerto Rico. And I was in my classrooms in between classes bored and I started playing it and holy moly, it was fun. I played it a ton. I got pretty good at Puerto Rico. And then secondly, I started playing with people more often, not necessarily the die hards. And I found myself to enjoy it more and more and more and more and more. And of course, that new version from Awaken Realms last year was fantastic, but I had loved it before that point. I think Puerto Rico is just an absolutely phenomenal game that has really stood the test of time and I like it way more than when I first played it.

Myth. All right. So you know how people get on my case a lot of times because they point out that I've made errors and I've done things. And there are several games throughout my reviewing career that I've made major mistakes in which when we catch a major mistake, we pull the review down right away, you know, correct and put it up. Usually though, I'm going to say you draw seven cards and was like, no, it's really six and you would have enjoyed the game more. That's very minor stuff. But Myth was something that actually caused me to put a policy in the place because with Myth was like a miniatures type game where you're fighting bad guys, a cooperative game. Came with this giant rule book. And I remembered asking a couple other people, uh content creators at the time I was like, are you making heads or tails of this?

And I mentioned that to the publisher and they said, we'll fly someone down. And that person flew down and taught us how to play Myth. And we enjoyed it. It was fun. And we played it and we did our review and we said how good it was and everyone said, why did you not mention the bad rule book? Well, because we were taught the game. And this taught me a big lesson here because I almost never allow designers publishers to teach me their games. It happens sometimes. We do it, you know, I play through and things like that. But for the most part, I insist on reading the rule book and even if you've taught me the game, I want to read the rule book. This just happened to me recently where a game that I was taught earlier this year, I loved the game. When I played it from the rule book, I was like, wow, this rule book's really bad. So I definitely look at that. And so I was wrong to not mention that rule book back then.

Um and it's something to to keep in mind for the future. The Myth taught me that. And the game itself wasn't really that strong of a game. We had a good experience uh playing through several games there, but um didn't really pan out in the end. So that's Myth. Zolkin. So I know why initially bounced off Zolkin because Zolkin they showed all these gears and turning these gears and I was like, oh my word, that's exactly I want turn this gear, this gear moves like this. And then they're like, do that big gear in the middle? It spins around once. And I was like, wait, wait, what? Cuz Zolkin really isn't about gears. It's more about delayed actions. But I did not care for it. Now, earlier in this video, I said, if you think I would like a game more than I should and you offer to play me, I won't.

But I didn't always have that policy. And so one time, uh a person from uh Vegas named Chris emailed me and said, hey, you're coming to a con here. Uh I would like to play Zolkin with you with the expansion. I think you would like it, you know, given a second look at it. I would I will not do that today. But back then I was like, yeah, why not? And you know what? He was right. Um it was a lot more fun to play Zolkin this way. I had a better look at it. I looked at the whole thing. In fact, when I was going through my list, there were several of those old CGE games. Um I Dungeon Lords is another one where like my thinking and my thoughts have changed in some of these heavier Euro games to where I think that Zolkin is pretty decent and good, but I really didn't like it my first times playing it. Um so that was that one time. So thank you to Chris. Well, you can thank him yourself.

He works here at the Dice Tower now, but he didn't then. Um but again, I want to reiterate that this is not something I think we should do in general. If I meet someone who doesn't like a game, I don't grab them and be like, you must play it with me, you'll like it. Nah. I'll just play something with them that they do like. But in this case, it worked. So here's the game from my childhood, Yahtzee. But it's not that I It's not what you might think. It's not like, oh, I love Yahtzee as a kid and now I don't like it. It's that I love Yahtzee as a kid. And as I got older and I started discovering new games, I was like, oh, Yahtzee's not very good. Yahtzee was put on the the rungs of Monopoly and Risk and and Sorry and games that I just didn't really enjoy. And then there was like, oh, here's new games, a new genre called Roll and Write, and I like it, I like it. And I keep going back and looking at Yahtzee going, Yahtzee's pretty good, particularly Triple Yahtzee in which you and in which you could just play a regular Yahtzee, you just fill out three columns at the time, but Yahtzee is a pretty solid roll and write style game that I honestly think is better than at least 40% of all the roll and writes that have been made out there, honestly. It's that simple and good. I think it's a bad rap and it definitely got a bad rap for me in my young adult years, but now as I'm older, I enjoy it a lot more.

Flash Point Fire Rescue is a game in which, you know, when the the early cooperative games came out, I really fell in love with this one. Everyone was like loving on Pandemic and I was like, nah, Flash Point Fire Rescue is where it's at cuz it was so exciting. The fires came out and the bursting and the theme of it to run in and rescue people. And then this past year I played Flash Point Legacy, which was the legacy version of this game. And as we went through, there was random fires and we couldn't get through and the legacy experience was kind of ruined by just a lot of random negative events happening to us. And I don't think the legacy game is great. I think there's there's several problems with it unfortunately, the Flash Point Legacy. But what really got me thinking was what about Flash Point? So I tried it, regular Flash Point, and wow have my taste changed.

That random stuff that that can just happen anywhere, that's fun once in a while, but the game consistently just has random fires starting everywhere and you can win or lose a game based on rolls of dice, which is in stark contrast to say Pandemic where there's still that randomness, but you have an idea of where the outbreaks are going to happen with the cards coming out. And so this one for me dropped quite a bit. Finally, we have Vegas Showdown. The first time I played Vegas Showdown, I was very excited. It was coming out from Avalon Hill. It was about casinos. What an exciting thing to do and I played it and I scored miserably and I played it again and didn't like it and I said this game is not particularly good. It's okay at best. Avalon Hill has lost their way, all their great games that they've made. And in fact, Avalon Hill then proceeded to make several games that weren't very good.

And then for some reason someone I played it again at some point because I really did like that theme. And each time I played Vegas Showdown, I liked it more and more. Each time I was like, oh wow, this is how the casino fits together. Oh, the auction works this way. It's such a cool game. Still, we don't have a nice deluxe version of it. Um, it's still just okay quality as the years have gone by. But it's a fun game that just has continually improved itself for me as time has gone by, and I like it a lot more. Well folks, that is it. That is all the different games here, 15 games that I'm wrong about. I know many of you were expecting bombshells to be thrown here, but I don't think that's really good for me as a person. Like I said, you got to get introspective about this.

I'm not going to suddenly come out here and say, Cosmic Encounter, I hate it now. I used to love it. And like I said, there's a lot of growth that you have. I've been now reviewing games for 24 years. Um, um, and I've been playing games for, well, 45, 46 years. And really been enjoying myself, having a great time. My I I I am not so egotistical to say that I can be wrong. But at the same time, I have opinions on games. And I am constantly told all the time, my opinions on games, whether positive or negative, are completely incorrect or wrong. And I think that's good. That's the whole reason I build a team here at The Dice Tower. I build a team so that we would have different opinions and viewpoints. And when we agree on games, then we should agree on games sometimes. I always find it humorous when people are like, oh, you guys agreed on that game.

Well, did you? I don't want someone to hate a game just for the sake of hating it, but I do like having that diverse opinions. I was just listening to Z and Mike before I recorded this talk about a game that I loved, and they were like, it's not that good. And I was like, they are wrong. But we're friends because they're just games. It doesn't matter if they're how much we liked them or not liked them. So have at it. Like I said, I know in the comments you're going to tell me um, about games that I was definitely wrong on that I didn't mention in this video. But what I would prefer, what I prefer from you in the comments is this. Why don't you tell me a game that you've changed on dramatically? What's a game that you loved and or hated or some of both and have changed a lot and why? Because I love reading that sort of stuff and I do read all the comments. Anyway, thanks much for watching. I'm Tom Vassel. We'll see you next time.

Hey, thanks for watching another video here on The Dice Tower. We really appreciate you stopped by and checking our things out. Thanks so much for joining us today. And hey, if you really like what we're doing here at The Dice Tower, then there are different ways to support The Dice Tower. One of those ways is through Patreon. We have links in the description to this video. We have links to lots of other things we do down there, so definitely check it out. But either way, we're glad you watched us. Tell your friends about The Dice Tower. Until next time though, I'm Tom Vassel and I hope you enjoyed this video. First we have so I made you a mixtape. Well, I used to like this, but it's a piece of trash now. Just kidding, Mike.

Progress saved