Skip to main content
Loading video...

Our 20 Favorite Board Games on Your Shelves - Lost In The Shuffle

Transcript 18:07

Today your shelf o game will that lead to a claim as we look through games to name. Which one would get lost in the shuffle? Well, that's not what we're doing.

That's okay cuz I ran out of ideas today.

Grant.

Yes. Chaz, something just occurred to me.

What?

Do you know what all board game collections have in common?

They're made of board games. That is correct, sir.

And where there are board games, there are shelfies or pictures of people's board game collections.

Yeah. You know, my real um life hack if you want it is if you want to sort of keep up in the shelfie race, just go to your local game store, just take shelfies in your pajamas in front of their games. Yeah. Nobody will know. How come you have seven copies of Wingspan? Yeah, cuz I want to know uh how much money I've put in this when I could have put a kid through college.

Oh, good point. Fair. Well, we put out the call on the Game Night Pics Blue Sky account asking for viewers to send in pictures of their shelfies and viewers, they did.

Yeah, you guys have amazing collections and we're excited to talk about them. We're going to look at the photos of your board game collection and pick out our favorite game in your collection and the game we think is the most underrated in your collection. The hidden gem. The game that you have that not enough people have that not enough people talk about.

Absolutely. And we got three collections here that we're going to go through. Starting with a submission from Ted Scholler. And so we're going to dive into this awesome game closet right here.

Yeah. Look at that game closet. You got you squeezed a lot of great games into that closet for sure. I like so many of the games that you guys have. I I mean, honorable mention for me here, uh, Wavelength is one of my favorite party games of all time. Uh, White Castle is one of the like, I love a game that is thinky and has a lot of strategy, but plays in a fairly short time. And White Castle accomplishes so much strategy in like a 60 to 90 minute game. And there's just so much depth to it. But personally, if I'm picking now, I haven't played this new version, but Ted has the new Quacks on the shelf, and Quacks of Gwedlinburgg is still in my collection, and it's one of my favorite games of all time. I have mentioned before on Lost in the Shuffle and just in life and at conventions how much I love push your luck games. You can build your bag as much as you want, but at some point there's just a ah let's reach in and see what happens, you know? And I love I love that those moments in that game and and they're full of elation and disappointment. And you know, you you leave a game of Quax like remembering moments from it. And you know, to me, a game a great game is about creating those memorable moments and Quax does that really well. Was Quax an honorable mention or

No, no, that was my honorable mentions were Wavelength and White Castle. So, Quax is my favorite game off of this shelf.

Okay. Well, you mentioned White Castle, which is actually the game I was going to mention as the one in this photo that I have been enjoying the most recently.

It's so good.

It is.

I love the dice drafting system where you're pulling diceg stuff. Yeah, it is like just a solidly medium weight game. And there is a lot of strategy, but it's not like a break your brain level.

Yeah. Now, it does have its expansion. It does add another rounds worth of turns to the game.

Okay.

And I'm actually torn. I don't know whether I prefer it base game or expansion. And that's rare for me.

Sure.

That's just a testament to how strong the base game of White Castle is.

Awesome. I do love that game.

All right. For my hidden gem, I am going with the game Oros right here. Oros is a game I wish more people talked about because there are tiles out on the board and you are shifting tiles and making them slam together to form bigger tiles like as if they're creating mountains out in the ocean. You're slamming a two and a one together and it makes a three and you're trying to make these fours so that you can build temples on the fours and get your guys up on the temples and can move up the temple track. But there's also an engine building aspect to it. You can't ever do everything. So, you're deciding what actions you want to make stronger, what stuff you want to level up throughout the game. And it's just that, you know, you get to do more and more things with your actions by the end of the game as you raise your knowledge.

That is fascinating.

I will say uh it is a game that is better at three or four than it is at two players. If you play it at two, you have to play a dummy player. And I don't love that. I would choose not to play it at two players, but at three and four, it's fine.

Okay. Okay. I think I'm going to go with Daybreak because

Sure.

Because Daybreak is a game that if left to my own devices, I never would have selected to have hit the table.

Sure. Sure.

But I went to a game night and they had it. They've brought it out and it was so brutally fun.

This is a game. It's cooperative, right?

Yeah. And you need that because you got the CO2 levels rising. You got problems to take care of. You got to coordinate to do this. You got to have, you know, let lend me some of those resources. Let me do this to try and protect the planet. And it's one of those games that it doesn't care if you win me or not. I'm here for you to figure out and win.

And I let myself be kind of intimidated by it and overlook it. Uh I think others might do the same.

Fair. Yeah. I've never played it. It's It's a little heftier, but it's all not overwhelming. This week's episodes were made possible in part by the game Wondrous Creatures, not unlike this wondrous creature right here. What are you? Bad Comet brings us a strategic board game for one to four players. Combining an innovative approach to worker placement with tentalizing tableau building tactics. Discover over a hundred fantastical creatures. creatures like this goofy looking dog here, which I'm I'm pretty sure is actually just a pile of sticks that somehow came to life. Regardless, as you place your workers across two hex map spaces, you'll also capture resources, activate various special effects. And as the game progresses, new powerful special effects become available, allowing you to get creative and use these abilities to unleash your own powerful combos, calling on the unique talents of your creatures to build your very own magnificent managerie. The quirky, puzzle-like fun of Wondrous Creatures is truly a unique worker placement experience. And believe you me, I know a thing or two about unique. You can discover Wondrous Creatures by following the link in this video's description to find it in stores, online, and directly on Bad Comt's website.

All right, now we are jumping over to Captain Gert's collection.

Yes, this is very intriguing because there's so many games on here. I cannot decide.

Yeah. Yeah. A lot of big box games here for sure.

Yeah.

Lot of lot of beefy fellas.

Oh, so much beef.

I can see ones that I'm like I've I've wanted to play Septima so much for so long and I've never had a chance to play Septima.

Okay. My favorite game in this collection I think could also be considered the most underrated game on this list or in this collection and that is the game Starship Captains. Ah, Starship Captains is sort of like loosely Star Trek themed. There is a fun engine building aspect to it. This worker placement action selection aspect to it. And you are going to be flying your spaceship around the board doing things, but you're also going to be getting these technologies that you're adding to your board. And that's the engine building aspect of it. One of the most interesting things about it though is you will get more workers as the game go on and as you use them you slide them into this little slot.

Okay,

but not all of them come back up later. So there is a a timing aspect where you're like, I need to be conscious of what order I'm doing these actions in because maybe later I can get a worker back, but if it's not the color that I need to do the action that I need to do at that point. So that slotting in of workers and potentially getting some workers back is really cool and interesting.

That is a neat approach.

Yeah,

I'm going to have to take a little bit of a different approach here.

Okay,

just look at this first picture. We got war story in the upper left corner here. We got Sniper Elite, fantastic hidden movement game. We have Ghostbusters, the board game, which I'm jealous and would love to find out more about and play.

I'm a fan of Mansions of Madness and stuff, too.

Yep. Absolutely. Yeah. We got Escape from New York, which again is in this pile just waiting to be played. Arrivals. We got Star Wars Rebellion with when I'm in the mood for a big Star Wars game is the one I always turn to. I love that one. We got so many on here. And of course, we have one of my all-time favorite games here. We have Nemesis, which

I can see you have all of it over on your shelf there. You have so many Nemesis boxes.

Yeah. So, that one's kind of a gimme. So, I'm not going to pick that as my favorite,

but Okay. And then we got the whole other shelf here, which I think is just as potent and powerful. Waste Knights in the upper corner.

Yeah.

And also Last Aurora.

Okay. I have been wanting to play both of them for so long, but since I learned about them at the same time, I can never remember which one.

Which one is which?

That's funny.

Which leads to making no decision at all.

I believe to me Starship Captains is both my favorite game and I think the most underrated. I do think Expeditions is underrated. Okay. Oh, you know, Expeditions was sort of the mediumweight version of Scythe, and Scythe remains the more popular game. I think Expeditions is the better game.

Oh,

I would rather play Expeditions.

Okay. But looking at Starship Captains, there's that new guy right there below it.

We actually just played this game last night.

Moon Colony Blood Bath. Yeah.

Yeah. And uh would you recommend that as a game that's on the shelf?

Yes. I had a great play. I've only played Moon Blood Bath one time. We played it last night. As long as you don't mind a game that kind of punches you in the mouth a little bit, it's really fun to try to like sort of survive as long as you can.

Yeah, this is definitely one of those games. Why you hitting yourself? Why you hitting yourself? Why you hitting yourself?

Yeah, for sure.

Dude, there's two more in here I got to talk about. Dark Moon is on here.

Okay. Would you like the mini light version of Battlestar Galactica? Yeah.

Lower down on the shelf there is City of the Great Machine.

Uh, you know, that's always one that I've been interested about. That's one I've wanted to try and never have. You talked about Oros, how the tiles move and smash together. Well, City of the Great Machine, the tiles move around and relocate on the board as this big steampunk city reconfigures itself.

Okay,

definitely definitely worth trying at least once to try it out.

Awesome.

It has some really great ideas in it.

That brings us next to our our last uh shelfie of uh the episode. Uh Missag, there's a ton of games here for sure. Oh man, how in the world can

I know this is really hard to pick. I mean, there are a lot of games in this collection that have made multiple of my like top 10 games of the year lists, right? Like I see Fromage right there was on my top 10 of this last year. I've talked about how much I like RAW before. Planet Unknown, one of my favorite games of all time. We were wondering if we might have the same pick for our favorite game out of this collection, though. I wonder if we do.

We were talking about how, oh boy, out of all those these great games, it would feel a little funny to pick like a light party game as the favorite pick.

Yeah, there are some times where I'm like, is that like I'm a gamer. Is it okay that my favorite game is like a silly fun time?

Yeah. So, is the one that you had in mind So Clover?

No. But that is a great game.

Okay. Tucked right down there in the corner almost.

I love So Clover.

So Clover is a great party game. It is one of those has never failed when I introduce it to any group.

Yeah, that is a great game. No, mine was Camel Up.

Really? Yeah. At the end of the day, how much fun am I having playing a game? And there are different ways to have fun. I love White Castle. I think chaining stuff together in White Castle and figuring out how to have an epic turn is fun, but I also think Camel Up is just silly fun, right? Every time I play it, there is laughter. It's unpredictable, right? You never know what's going to happen.

You are never able to pin that thing down. Even Even at the last turn, you still don't know.

Yeah. And it's a game I don't mind losing because I always have fun along the way.

It just the experience of it is Yeah. Absolutely. So, out of all these games, there's a bunch of great strategy games here. And Camel Up, I still think is my favorite game.

Man, you know what? I still think that's fair. This is a collection that if I had to replace my board game collection one, I would be perfectly happy with

I I I feel the same.

Mhm.

We got El Dorado.

I do like

fantastic building racing game. Love El Dorado.

I do too.

We got Witness, which

I don't know that game.

Oh, Witness is a logic puzzle in game form.

Okay. You have a booklet of all these basically these logic puzzles. You know the old deduction. You can only talk to certain people at certain times like four players. You're only going to talk to actually one of those four players. One other player is going to talk to you and then you got to put all the pieces together and figure out what's going on. Oh yeah.

Oh that that I I feel like now that you mentioned that I feel like I've heard of it but I haven't played it myself.

It's it's a combination between a logic puzzle and the game telephone.

Okay. That's fun. That's cool. But right there next to it I think is going to be my pick as my favorite on here

is Zia or Shaw depending on how you want to pronounce it. But Zia Legends of a Drift system. It is a sandbox game. So you give the tools how to build a ship and things you can do to earn points and how to build a solar system and then you're like, "Okay, everybody go off, do whatever you want. Earn points however you want and just do stuff."

Oh, okay.

Love that game.

Do you have a pick for the underrated the hidden gem out of this whole collection?

Oh no. Can I go with Zia and Witness?

Yeah. Yeah, that's fair. Cuz I've been thinking about it of which one. Again, so hard to pick just one. I think Everdellore is an underrated game. I love Everdell.

Uh-huh. I think Everdellore is a better game than Everddale. Farhore is 90% the same as Everddale, but those 10% differences do make the game better. Yeah. And so, you know, that's one I think of as like a hidden gem here, an underrated game. I got one way down here, the bottom left corner, right next to So, Clover, we got Sobeck two-player.

Oh, yeah. I've never played it. It's always been one I've been interested about.

Yeah. I really dig this little tile set collection game. It's

Sure.

It knows what it wants to be. Okay.

And it does that super well.

Wow. That's great. Yeah. I'll tell you another game I would pick as a hidden gem here. Juicy Fruits. A super fun family game where you're moving tiles around and as you slide them around, you get resources. But if I had to pick one underrated game, if you made me pick between all of these games of which one I think is a hidden gem,

and I am

Yeah,

I am forcing you to do that.

So, if that is fair, it is the Art Project.

Oh, okay. I love a good cooperative game,

right? I want it to be somewhat of a challenge and I also want it to force actual cooperation. The art project you really do have to cooperate. You have to keep talking. You have to make a plan who's doing what. I love a heisty type theme and the art project is that. Soy. Yeah, it's a really really great cooperative game that I think is underrated.

Okay, speaking of underrated thing that's deserving of an honorable mention.

Okay,

I just realized something about Massage Collection here.

Okay. Do you realize that this collection

what

is in alphabetical order?

Is it really? Oh my god. Oh, you're right.

Yeah.

Camelup, canvas, captain [clears throat] flip. Oh.

Uh-huh.

What a way. Oh man, I can't imagine when you get a new game.

You have to shift everything.

I know, right?

That's wild.

Wow. So, yeah. No, I

that is very true.

Mad respect.

That is a lot of respect for sure. Yeah,

that is something I like aspire to do that will absolutely never happen. My collection will never be that organized.

True that. But I boy am I jealous. That's awesome. So yeah, that's just one more layer of appreciation that you can add here to the massages collection.

Yeah, for sure.

Thank you again for sending in your selfies

to everyone who has sent in selfies both in this episode and previous ones that we've done.

Yeah. Yeah. This is really fun for us to do. We like talking about games. We like seeing the games you have in your collection. Yeah. So, if you would like to maybe get in on a future episode, well, down in the comments, you'll find a pinned comment over to a Blue Sky post that has information on what you can do to submit your Shelfie photos, and we would love to uh look for hidden gems and favorites in those as well.

Yeah. So, yeah, you're welcome to do that. You're welcome to subscribe. You're welcome to I'm not your dad. Do whatever you want.

Yeah, but do it. Subscribe. I'm your dad.

Oh my goodness. Good cop, bad cop going on here.

Yeah.

All right. Well, on that concerning note, watch the next videos.

Progress saved