Games That Dropped Out of Our Top 50s (2026)
Transcript
Hey, I'm Brian. This is my brother Daniel. And this is Rolls in the Family. And today we are here to come clean, to be authentic with our viewers,
you know, because we just did our top 50 board games of all time. We counted it down. We picked winners for a giveaway. It was an exciting time.
Blissful time.
Blissful. Um, but you know, it would be easy for us to just slide under the rug, games that we raved about last year that maybe didn't, you know, make the top 50 this year. And this video is where we we don't allow ourselves to do that.
Accountability is a key value into the channel that we are forced to come on camera and talk about every game from the last year's top 50 that did not appear on this year's top 50. and why
we have a really toxic relationship with this channel. It's uh
yeah,
you know, it's good to put systems in place to encourage the behavior you want in your life.
Good, Ryan. It's good.
Um really, this is just a way to try to get Daniel to stop calling his favorite games. And
Ryan's like, "We're not letting Daniel get away with this again. We're making a video about it."
Yeah. This is an annual one now. Uh so we are going to start we're going to be counting through these starting with the ones that were ranked the lowest last year. So we might have, you know, some things in the 40s moving up the list. So the further we get up the list, the bigger the drop.
We will have links to all these games below. I think many of them many
we would say every single one on here is I mean obviously we at one point thought top 50.
So
yeah, so these are good games and a lot of them are still in our collection and maybe just fell outside the top 50. We'll talk about that, but they are linked below if you'd like to check them out.
Um
maybe leave in the comments below. I didn't think about this, but uh a game that you once really loved,
but it's dropped
but ended up, you know, dropping for maybe dropping out of your collection,
right?
Um all right, let's get this moving. Daniel, it looks like
Yeah, it
was that was a top five transition there. I was well I was going to say Ryan you know it you know part of the challenge of making videos online is like we immortalize our opinions but they sh but they shift over time like you know you can
well and they can shift like within a week like we talk about that with like our top it's like if you pulled me the next week it would be a completely different
things would shift around
but but I think this
shows what happens in
this reflects that and so it's good to be able to talk about it to come clean and uh the first game uh that uh I'm going to uh that moved moved out of my top 50. This one, you know, it was at 49 the previous year, so really, you know,
it never deserved deserved to be there in the first place. Um, but a game that I will be honest, uh, maybe has dropped a little bit, uh, in my heart for me. Uh, dropping now to 61. This goes to Wingspan. And I believe Ryan, did you coal Wingspan?
I once owned and decided to coal.
You called Wingspan. I like
probably have some video,
honestly. So, I like Wingspan. Um, I I think it's I mean
it kind of sits in a weird spot if I'm being honest of it's kind of feels like it's in the ticket to ride kind of a very like almost gateway game type of thing.
It's kind of a gateway plus,
but that's what I was going to say. It's a little heavier and maybe that's why it still is in my collection is I feel like it is kind of my like if I was going to have a step up kind of game. Uh it feels like it hits that spot really well. Honestly, I love the presentation of it as well. It's just it's a game that is just it's beautiful on the shelf. It's beautiful to pull out. It's just aesthetically pleasing and that there's a lot a lot going for for that. So, it's not one that like I'm choosing like, oh man, I really want to play a game. I enjoy a game of Wingspan, but not one of like my personal all-time favorites, but it does feel like it still has that that spot where it could it could get played um with a group that maybe I'm introducing to board games and they're wanting to kind of like take a you know, step up. This could could be a good option, but down to 61, Ryan. So,
yeah. Nice. Yeah, it's definitely for me in this category that I'm I enjoy Wingspan. I would have a fun I'd you know, enjoy playing it again. It just wasn't one that I felt like I wanted to hold on to.
We'll see.
Uh I'm next up a game that we actually have raved about a lot on the channel over the years. Um it
similarly for to Wingsban last year was my 49. So it had been slowly slipping. I think largely just cuz I play I've played it a lot. Um this is the Quax of Quedlinberg or Quax if you're into the the new
Yeah. brand new.
It's a little surprising, I'll be honest.
It is is maybe a little surprising. Um I haven't been playing it quite as much and it only dropped to 59. It's still a game I really enjoy. Um but I think I'm like over 50 plays of it now.
Um and so I I can't deny there is some of the novelty factor that is has worn off a little bit, but not to the point that I'm it's like cuz there's some games where like the novelty factor wears off and there's like nothing. you're like, "Okay, I'm kind of done with this game." I don't feel that way about Quax, but it is like, you know, we were really, really, really high on this when we were first playing it and stuff.
Um, I actually just introduced this to my son for the first time.
Um, so, who knows? Maybe it'll revive a little bit. Well, in playing with him, it's very possible we could get more into, you know, on repeat plays, using some of the cuz a lot of times if I'm I'm introducing to a new group, we're you I'm trying to use pretty straightforward stuff, not getting really exotic ingredients or use the herb witches or any of this expansion stuff. So, it could be fun to kind of explore some of that. Again, um a game
I still very very much enjoy, but not a top 50 one anymore.
You know what's the challenge I have with this game, Ryan, is I love like Herb Witches. Those expansions are, I think, really fun,
but you never get to play.
I was going to say expansions are hard with a game that is often times a kind of gateway game
because you're often times playing it with people that you're not looking to add heavier. So, it is a little challenge. I've I've just had a lot of uh difficulty getting those expansions played um with this one. Um
yeah, there's a few things from the expansion like just some of the extra ingredients that actually are still pretty good. So, like there's some of it that's nice to have or like the loco weed, but yeah, a lot of it a lot of it's just been sitting in the box lately.
My next one, Ryan, it's 48. It's dropping to 57. And this is honestly still in my heart one of like my most underrated games in the sense of I every time I play this one, I have so much fun. But it's just it's we've played it a ton. It doesn't get chosen almost ever. Although I will say in the I think it was maybe a year or two ago, we did have an opportunity of like six or seven people who wanted a more strategic experience and this one hit it perfectly. This goes to Seven Wonders and man, we I mean our box this is our original OG Seven Wonders box here.
Yeah, I think it we got that within months of it releasing.
Has taken a beating. It is it is in rough shape. But this this is, you know, it's obviously kind of the origin of uh this kind of card drafting mechanism that has now become super popular in a lot of different games. I still think Seven Wonders does it in just such a clean and fun way. I love the way that it has who you're sitting next to at the table, especially when you're playing like a seven player game has just this fun dynamic of even the personalities of the people next to you. Um, Kofkov, our sister, is, you know, has a certain Seven Wonders personality.
More aggressive.
It's like everyone, why is everyone trying to sit on the opposite side of the table as Kaitlin? It's weird.
No, but it's uh it's a it's one that I still really really enjoy playing. I just don't get it played
almost ever, you know, anymore. And so naturally, a game's going to drop in that. But
I still have got a soft spot in my heart for Seven Wonders, Ryan.
Yep. Yeah. I and I've played it even fewer times than you in recent years since you have the copy. Um but yeah, I I have just fond memories of all
that much fewer. I mean
yeah twice in the last 10 years
I think I played a BGA game once and it took like six minutes.
Hey, there you go.
You can really fly power through one there. Yep.
Uh my next one was my 48 last year. This is one that very similar story I think to Quax in terms of a little bit of the novelty settles, you know, settles in. Um, and that maybe is part of why though we're talking about a 10point drop here, which isn't that crazy. Uh, this is Thunder Road Vendetta, which the first few times you play Thunder Road Vendetta, I mean, it is just like a like what's going to h you you haven't seen all these crazy things happen yet of people running into something and smashing and it causing a chain reaction and then this person lights on fire and you know, all these things that can happen and
it's so fun to watch that unfold and just like I don't know it it's I don't think it um like I don't want to say that the novelty like completely wore off um because I still really enjoy this game, but it is it's like a different experience with now and it's actually a very fun game to like introduce to people.
Like there are certain games in that category where it's like I like introducing that novelty factor to somebody else. But even novelty factor aside, uh this is just a fun game when you want to just be rolling dice, having crazy things happen, attacking each other. This race, it's it's so like unabashedly aggressive and you know, heavy metal like just
uh and with some of the expansion content and stuff, it's just fun all the different things that can come up. Um, and so I've had great sessions of this just laughing. Um, but but like it's one of those games that finds that balance between the laughing funny moments, but like
also some strategic tactics within it of how do I position myself and kind of do this? Um, so it's one I love having in my collection cuz it it is really pretty unique of games I have. And there's certain people that like when you're looking for a game to introduce you go, "Oh, you're going to love this game cuz if you if you can tell that there's somebody that maybe is going to get into that theme a little bit more, kind of this Mad Max
racing theme, um I'm always glad to have this one on hand. My son likes this one, too.
I like this one. That was I had a good good first impression of it." Yeah.
Um
my uh my next one, Ryan, is a game that dropped quite a bit from 44 all the way down to 77. Although, here's what I'll say, Ryan. I think this has less to do with this game and more something that I'm discovering just even about my uh tastes in gaming. And this goes to Yinch.
Uh and Yinch is a uh fantastic abstract 1v one game. you know, you're having these rings that you're I don't even know how to describe this. Move your ring in a straight line. You and you drop a piece. You're ultimately trying to create uh uh five in a row and do that three times. Although, one of the things I love about it is the whole kind of little bit of a catch-up mechanism that when you score one, you have to take one of your rings off and so you're at a disadvantage whenever you're in the lead. Um I think that's really cool and I think it's a great design. I've had a lot of fun plays with it. just my personality. I don't gravitate towards the one v one all open information like we're out we're outsmarting each other.
Maybe that's uh you know insecurities on my part of my uh u not not feeling like I'm good.
You don't want to realize how much better your wife is at these games. There's the little bit of like when you get when you lose at the end of a game like this. Um, and you know, if you want to hear all of our stories of me growing up and Ryan and I head to head videos, I think we've got a video talking about me getting angry in board games. I've gotten better,
but there still is that like it's like it hits that like similar part in me of this feeling like I lost because
I got outsmarted.
Yeah. For no other reason.
Like there's I can't point to anything else. You know, other games it's like, oh, you know, the Those are the, you know,
a game you do really enjoy that has some of these traits as well is Santorini. True. Um, but that one it does have the added layer of the god powers that I think gives you a little bit of an out of like,
oh, it was a bad matchup or it sounds terrible. It sounds like I'm just making excuses. No, I'm just I'm saying just generally for anybody playing it, it gives you but but also with Santorini like um you know besides the fact that you could blame it blame it on the powers.
Um
you can also I'm completely losing my train of thought. I had I had a really
I'm going to jump off of what you're saying it. Uh and you can tell me if if I'm completing it. the god power gives you like a direction to try to work towards whereas like in this
there's no open I mean you just you from the very start I mean it's just like chess right like from the very beginning you need to decide what you're going to do um now one thing that is really cool about this game is the way the board state can change like I it makes me think of even like a game like yellow and yangy of where like someone takes their ring and flips it flips all the chips and suddenly you're like,
"Oh my gosh, like I this totally so you there's some I mean people who are good at this game, there's an opportunity for some really clever moves and uh interesting things to happen. So I think it's a great game. I'm I haven't I don't know. Maybe it's on the fringe in my collection. Um I I
I got it.
It's in my collection. And honestly, I I think it's fairly safe in my collection, but I I do like having a few
Yeah. games that I like in this category, and this is one of my favorites. Yeah. Of this style.
Um, and I think part of that is when I do find somebody that likes these types of games, it's fun to introduce
like a really novel one that they haven't heard of,
right?
Um, Yenshi is also a little long, honestly. like it takes usually like a half hour or longer, which is for this style of game
is maybe a little bit longer than getting up to 45 minutes, but
so yeah, a lot of self-discovery in the
Yes, it's good.
This channel's been really good for this.
This is very therapeutic.
I feel so much more in touch with my inner being.
Oh my.
Uh, it's you again, Daniel. It is me again.
You're Cuz you're 43 also.
My 43. Yeah, 44 dropped and 43. Not quite as far. just out of the top 50. And this is going to go to Far Away. And I really like Far Away, actually, Ryan. I uh
You don't have it, do you?
Yes, I do.
Oh, you do? Okay. I forget. Okay. I always forget what some of these games I get first if you end up with them.
No, I have this one. And a very unique game in terms of it. What I think what I love about it is it it just like it the way your brain normally works in a board game, it like makes you have to think the opposite of that. So, a game where, you know, normally in a board game, you're uh building up, you're playing things in order to ultimately get towards like a
you get the resources first
first and then to get the get the thing. Whereas this, you're getting like the scoring
thing first and then you need to build after the fact, you know, because at basically at the you're playing these cards out, but at the end you're going to flip them all over and then you're going to reveal them in reverse and you only score based off what's visible. And it it's just a really really clever interesting uh mechanism on it. Um it does maybe why it dropped. I'm trying to I'm trying to process that. Um I I really enjoy it. It's maybe a tad it's not it's not the most accessible game
because because some like it definitely takes a like if someone doesn't click with that way of thinking. I could definitely see it flopping. like you kind of get to the end, you're like, "Oh, wow. I scored really
on that final reveal." You go card by card and it's very possible you go, "Oh, and I didn't I guess I didn't do that one either." Like, you might just have to watch your strategy crumble in front of you.
Yeah. So, there's there's possibility for it flopping, but the game it is just a fascinating game, fascinating design, and one I I really really enjoy having. I don't see this one uh I don't see this one leaving cuz it just feels so different from other ones that I that I have. So
yeah,
out of the top 50. Can
I tell you that that kind of gamers filler category of games that don't take long but appeal like there's just situations where that comes up at at the end of a game night or you just have like a little bit of time. So it's nice to have good ones in that category. Speaking of games that are not at all in that category, uh this is one that's bound to
you need to talk about this one.
Steady Slide because year after year I don't play it. And that's just any game you're not playing is bound.
It's a sign
to slide. It's a sign. Uh this is Twilight Imperium fourth edition specifically. Um I haven't played this in I think seven years.
Was I in the last game you played? I don't think so. Or is
it someone else?
It's been a long time since Have we even played the fourth edition together or did we only play the third edition?
We played it once together.
Maybe once.
Yeah.
Um, so this is such a big epic game. It's one that you just got to you have to plan a day. And I can't be the victim here because I could plan a day. Like it's I've done it before. I've done it for other things. I think there's a part of me that whenever I think about it, I mean, here's here's the reality. I don't get as many full big gaming days in a year as I used to. Like significantly fewer, right? And so I think there's the part of me that goes,
"Oh, I could plan a Twilight Imperium day or I could plan a day and play multiple other
three of your favorite games
and it's a really hard trade right now."
But I still look at it and go, man, I do want to do that sometime. And there's really just nothing like it. and the fact that you get to do it with six people. I mean, you get this big group shared experience around this epic game. Um, so it even though it's been sliding, I don't think anything's changed for me in terms of like it getting closer to me getting rid of it. Every year I guess is like a poke that's like, "Ryan, you going to actually schedule a game sometime?"
But, you know, it's uh
Well, honestly,
I've got three kids now. We can almost, you know, give it a little time.
You're getting there.
We'll round out a full, you know, throw. She'll do fine.
Yeah, I'm sure she'll be fine.
Um, yeah. You know, it's interesting, Ryan. Yes. You know, you can there's the tension of like, okay, I could be playing like three of my favorite heavy board games or this.
Mhm.
But six players like the heavy, you know, you think about it, you know, outside of your crazy agricola game you played, um, your most don't support that number of players. And so it really it's not only unique obviously in the 8 hour length of it, but six players engaging in something like that is is also um a pretty unique thing.
It also makes it harder to schedule because many of my friends in the season of life also, you know,
that is true. It's just
Yeah, it is. It is challenging. So you don't have the expansion
that lets you like, you know, hyperlink so you can it makes it work better if you don't have a full six. But honestly, again, it's like if you're going to do it, just get the six, you know? So,
y
it's back to you, Ryan.
Oh, look at that. It's still named
a game that
uh Yeah, this one's kind of interesting.
This one was my number
40 last year. It dropped 14. So, it's just outside of the top here.
Uh but this is Wonderland's War, actually.
Wow.
And Wonderland's War has kind of been calibrating ever since I got it. And and it's an interesting one because it's so has so many pieces.
Yeah.
That I really like in games because it's got the bag building that we talk about in Quax Quadlinburg which who knows maybe some of the novelty of just the bag building thing. We saw Quax unique mechanic when you were coming into this. Yeah.
Um but it's got a fun bag building thing in a more strategic game. It's got this really big presentation and this fun area control. It's got a really fun card drafting thing as you go around the tea party and can go to whatever card you want and you're doing all that.
I think uh there's been a few things that have kept this from getting into kind of the upper echelon of games for me. I think one is it feels like it it feels like there's so much going on, but sometimes it doesn't feel quite as like cohesive in my strategy or I mean I guess you like maybe it's just me playing poorly.
But sometimes that never be the reason, Ryan. It sometimes feels like you're kind of just getting a lot of, you know, everything and getting into things and like it's all fun, but like it doesn't have that same like strategic throughine I maybe get with other games of [clears throat] like feeling like I'm and I guess to be fair it is a little bit of a different genre of game than some of my favorite games. Like it's this isn't like a resource management strategy game. Um it's a bag building push your luck area control um game. But I think the other thing that's kind of interesting is the bag building in the context of quacks is a shorter game. And something that is inherent with bag building is bad luck, right?
Specifically push your luck back building which this has like Quacks where you do the battles, you're pushing your luck of how far do you want to go,
right? Um, and the thing is in a game like Quax that's less than an hour and you get to do that those, you know, draws like you do nine rounds very quickly in succession.
In Wonderland's War you, it's a much bigger, more epic game. And so you feel like if you have a bad counting
Yeah. like you could have done this whole plan and got my Wonderlandians into this area and I'm all set up and you could have the, you know, the bad luck rear its head and it just stings more in this game, right?
And so I think that is a little bit a part of it. And it's not even just like from my own experience like sometimes, yes, that's me, but sometimes even it's
seeing it happen to somebody else
makes the game less enjoyable for me cuz I can tell they're a little frustrated with it. So, I think there's a little bit of that in the DNA here. Um, it obviously helps if you set expectations right and everybody's in the right mindset. Um, but it is kind of an interesting thing as you kind of expand some of these like push your luck mechanisms into a bigger game.
Yeah.
Um, it can be hard to like have it to to avoid those negative feelings [clears throat] kind of coming up.
Yeah. I'll be honest, Ryan, I didn't love this one.
Yeah. Like I that was my vibe. was good, but it it it felt like this is the type of game that is in the lane that needs to like
knock it out of the park.
And yeah, I don't know. Maybe I kind of agree with you a little bit of and and again, first game, so I it'd be good to play it again and kind of okay, you know, although I'll probably forget all the rules before then, but
yeah, like the odds aren't probably good at playing it again.
So, I don't know. I mean, I
Is it on a Is it on Cole alert? Is that
I don't know. I don't think so. At least not yet. Um, you know, it is a game that's better after you've played it more than once, just cuz it's got a lot going on. So, the more you can feel like you're kind of comfortable and kind of know what's going on with everything.
Um, you know, it helps as far as it getting played that our sister loves this game.
That is true. She does. I've had really good games, you know, with the group that knows it. Um,
yeah.
Yeah. But it is it is a little bit of a it's it's one of those games is is the juice worth the squeeze a little bit because it's got a lot going on. It's there's so much with the player factions that like it's hard to remember what otherilities
because you're choosing to play this is I think the true the hardest thing. So
um we'll see. Time will tell.
Time will tell. A game that uh time did tell and it is now gone um from my collection. Uh Ryan probably disagrees with with my conclusion of this of this game or maybe is surprised that I uh that I landed here. Uh but a game that was 39 last year and is now gone from the collection.
I think I was just surprised at how you went way positive on this game for a stretch. Like you it was great.
Like you swung way past me and how much I enjoy it and now you swung way.
I mean Ryan that's that's right in line with how we always do things.
Rain is wet. The Pope is Catholic. [gasps]
my uh game that game that left my collection is Cascadia and uh again Cascadia uh really really great game. Um I think what you know I loved so much about it was um one the simplicity of it. It is a really easy game to teach and get like for people to understand what's going on. Um, but I love like optimizing. Like that's what I loved about Cascadia was the optimizing of my layout. Um, I think there were two things that are why it left. One, I think as I played it more, the optimiz the joy of the optimization I don't know if it just uh wore out a little bit. like I just got kind of used to the it was there weren't as much like sad like moments where I'm like oh that was a you know there still there still is that but it maybe just wasn't quite as high and then
the second part of it was when I played your copy of harmonies and again different games you could I think you own similar lane you own both but similar lane in that like optimization and I'll be honest the high of what harmonies gives me in terms of that like puzzle It just it was far exceeded Cascadia for me. Um
I'm in the exact same boat. Like like Harmonies for me personally blows Cascadia out of the water in my personal enjoyment of it.
But for now, Cascadia has hung around because it has feels like a different enough category. I mean what the one of the most clear data points I have is my wife enjoys Cascadia and doesn't enjoy harmonies. And so it's like okay, there is a segment here in my collection. I mean, you're keeping it. That's like you could hate a game. She said she likes it.
It's staying. So, um yeah, that's honestly I mean, it's really that it's a good game. It's one that uh I mean, I think we had it in our uh you know, like whenever we did a video about kind of uh staples that people with starting a collection, I want to say this one was was in there.
And I'm not even It's interesting. I'm not even sure if I would have harmonies replace that because it is a different it is a different way and I the accessibility of Cascadia is great and like that would be my you know for an entry game like still be one that I would point to. Um but just for me personally I think uh the excitement of it kind of kind of wore off a little bit. So um
it's gone now.
It's gone. Yeah. Yeah, we get to hear a lot from Dag here. I'm looking and we got the next four
entries. I'll keep moving here. So, next one um is a game that I think I think it was more it was uh I rated it very high the first year and Ryan was surprised by that and now maybe it's settling where it
Yeah.
Uh should land. This goes to Seven Wonders Architects. Uh which went
I was very surprised the first year that or last year that this jumped ahead of Seven Wonders for a year.
It did. Um Yeah. which which it is now back below seven wonders which I think I had gotten a play of seven wonders after that and you know it's always you're always trying to kind of recalibrate
I remember when I first was introduced to this one I was oh my goodness blown away by the fact of how accessible this game was like it is so simple this game um and you know your son
a year ago was playing this game with us and we were having a and we were having a blast And so for a game to be so simple, but I tell you what, I just that left, right, middle,
it just is so fun. It's it's it just this I don't know like the whole game I was like, man, for how simple this is, I am having so much fun here. And so I think like the initial just accessibility to my personal enjoyment is why it like launched up. Now, I think having played it a lot more, it's like, okay, the
the peak enjoyment out of the simplicity is there's definitely a cap to that. Um, so it's definitely settling settling down. And I think if I was to say just, hey, Daniel, which Seven Wonders, Seven Wonders Architects, which one do you want to play? I would choose Seven Wonders just given the a little more meat to what's uh what's going on. But I've got the expansion to this one now, Ryan, which uh you know, with the medals and that is so great. And it's it is a I mean, talk about a staple in a a collection to go to that many players and be that accessible and play that quick. And
it's great.
Yeah. No, it's a it's a good one to have. like there's just it it it's a great one to introduce people to like especially if they haven't played a lot of modern board games because it's simple enough but it's got a lot of these like modern mechanisms that to somebody that hasn't been playing modern games it feels really novel um
right
yeah plays fast fun get a drinking sorry I was supposed to keep talking
I forget that it's me again so
I'm not used to this
done with my time here
another game that dropped from 34 just out of the top 50, 51. Um, you know, I think party games just always are going to never be quite as high as obviously our
always going to track.
Um, they're never going to be as high as some of the, you know, strategic board games in terms of our personal enjoyment, but this party game is my favorite party game. I believe that's still the case. Um, despite just being out of the top 50. Um, and this goes to Times Up title recall. And I haven't gotten to play this one uh here uh uh recently. I'm actually brainstorming. We've got kind of a our at at work like a staff little there's like a staff kind of retreat thing coming up.
Um and and
and whatnot of a team of people and I'm thinking this one
could be cuz we're you know you're looking for like laughing fun and this one could be an absolute hit. Um, so I mean, and and we have so many great memories of this this one of, you know, just I love when games the mechanisms naturally produce fun and funny moments. Like I don't like party games where it's like I have to try to make it funny. You know what I mean? But like I but I like it where it's like just by playing well
this one, you know, there's just so many great things, especially the way the rounds build, you know, use the same deck each round, but it gets more constricted what you can do. And so you're building on past clues and which that's just like that is a universal human thing that people enjoy is like referencing something funny that's happened and like in a new way and and it just, you know, being even more funny. So, I feel like this game does that does that so well, but it's out of my top 50 now, which is
it has been so long since I've played this
that I'm it's it's one of those games is similar to when you were talking about Cosmic Encounter that it's like I don't even really know what my opinion like my current opinion is. I have all these amazing memories,
but I mean we're talking memories largely from over a decade ago or like around there. Um, so yeah, it's one that we
Do you own it?
I do own I have our actual original.
Oh, you have the original. Okay.
Very cool.
Yeah.
Um, yeah. I I would love to play it again because I know I know what it can do.
Yeah. Yeah.
They they like have they played it so much that they
they hyper played it during quarantine and now
and now have cut out every other person from playing.
Like we can't play it with all of you people anymore. [snorts]
You peasants. Yeah, there are circumstances in our life that's made this one harder to get played, unfortunately.
Okay, Ryan, this one I think is my biggest drop. Well, I guess if you I guess I guess I guess going into cold is probably the biggest drop
out to the streets.
Um, this is not a game I own. Game you own. Game you've already talked about and uh I would agree with um a lot of what you said, but maybe even take it a little bit further. uh dropping from 32, which maybe was a premature ranking, who knows, but all the way down to 71. This goes to Thunder Road Vendetta. And
again, this was one Ryan where we first play of it,
first couple plays of it. I mean, I'm just like this is so cool. The way it simulates cra like they're just the crazy things that can happen. It was like this is this is incredible. So much fun. Um, I think the dropping of it, um, is I think the last time I played it, I want to say we had maybe not as fun of a play of it.
It was a pretty suboptimal. I'll remind you. Was this our brother's house? We at our older brother's house. We were playing with my son and our nephew. So, it already is like wrangling to play a game. You know, there's a lot going on. But then we were also playing in a room where other things were going on. TV was everywhere.
So, it was not an ideal,
which that affects a game, right? That it affects your like you you rank off your last last feelings. Um, and yeah, maybe just uh I think I have concerns of just that kind of what you were saying like for personal enjoyment, will the novelty of it wear off a little bit over time? Um, and so I don't know, this almost feels like too extreme the other way because I think I think this game is really fun, but I am coming off a not amazing play of it, which um, which definitely affects it. So
yeah, I mean I think I see it as settling into a place in my collection where it isn't like there's certain games in my collection. Harmonies for example, which we just talked about that just feels like this evergreen go-to that I can just keep going to that well and it's going to keep giving me exactly what I'm looking for.
Then there's games like Thunder Road that I feel like it serves the purpose really really well, but I don't know that I want to be playing it constantly, right? like you almost want a little bit of a break from it so that when you come back to it, you're excited for that unique experience again. And I totally love having games in my collection that are in that category.
But it does, I think, hurt it on these lists.
Um cuz when we're our favorite games on these lists tend to be the ones that we're like, I just always
am wanting to play this game.
Right.
Okay, Ryan, my last one before you get a you get a jump in here. This one's kind of weird. Um because I ranked it
last year.
Last year, but then didn't rank it this year, which yeah, maybe there's
I don't think you played it.
I didn't play it. I haven't played it since. And so I maybe I just this year felt like I didn't you know what an un not ranking game is usually just me saying like I don't feel like I have the uh plays to be able to land. Now obviously the first year I thought I did. I don't know what happened here, but a game that went from 30 to unranked uh is Arcs. And um I I actually really enjoy Arcs. Um the times I played it, it is the most tense board game I've ever played, I think. Um
yeah,
one of the most like I I can I remember playing when we were playing out in your wife's uh art studio.
Yeah, that four player game.
And I'm just like I mean this game is hard. the you know you have you get your hand of cards and I think every single person at the table is like how do I do what I want to try to do and what's the best way to do I do I seize you know uh control or or what's the
uh yeah
is that what it's called initiative or like just this game is so tense and
well and when things go like if something goes wrong it isn't just like oh it went a little wrong it's like I went from scoring points to getting absolutely nothing. Like it's really brutal in like the consequences of things.
So, this one wouldn't ever be like, you know, I think in my like all-time favorites just because I tend to not gravitate towards games where I'm like sweating the entire time,
but like it is a brilliant design for that lane, you know, of game. So, like it feels like it's, you know, I don't know where it would rank
now. now. It just it was so long ago, so it was hard for me to like even think about it. But it feels like it's like one of the best games I've played in that like really interactive, tense, board state games. That's just never going to like enter into my top echelon because uh just that's that's more of a personality thing. But you think about someone like our like our sister who likes those kind of games and I think this is her favorite game. Um, and so, you know, it's u
it's a great game. Um, I would love to play it again. Um, I would love to play the uh
I know I would so love to have the blind uh you know, and it probably won't happen. Um, but for this year, ARCs is uh unranked
for now.
For now.
Unranked.
Yeah.
Cool. My last one on the list is definitely the biggest
like headline news, I guess, in this um
This is true confession time.
We talk about how games are in different categories. Well, let I I'll get to that after I introduce it. So, this was my 19 last year.
Uh so, way up there in my top 20. And not only did it drop out of the top 50, but I actually am getting rid of it. And this is Underwater Cities. You might be thinking, Underwater Cities say it ain't. So, didn't you guys do a review and give it a nine out of 10? And you would be correct.
But here's the thing. We we talk about categories of games. And when we're in our collection,
in each category of game, and when I say categories, I mean like situations or weights and complexities, like all these different things that kind of make games compete with each other. Mhm.
Um, we want the best games in each category. So, we talk about like there's not a lot of party games and making our top 50, but my top party games in my collection are some of the safest
games in my collection. I'm not getting rid of them because they do so well in that. Well, Underwater Cities has the, I guess, displeasure of being in the most competitive category of all, which is the longer strategic,
you know, games that tend to be my favorite games. Like, these are my favorite games of all time are in this category. And there's a lot of them out there. There's a lot we haven't played
and a lot of good ones. And especially it's it's magnified even more now in the season of life we're in where we're not playing each of the these games that many times in a year. Like I in a year will get maybe not even all the ones in my collection played once or or twice.
And so that so shifts the kind of weight of keeping because if I'm going to keep a game like this in my collection, I'm keeping it in rotation. like I actively try to get played that I haven't played in a while.
And so that means when I'm making Underwater Cities the game that we're playing that day, it's not playing any of those other games
that I love so much. And so even though it was number 19 of all my games in my enjoyment, it was probably like number eight in that category or something, right? like and so I finally just
and I I played it quite a few times and I feel like I really really enjoyed all my plays with it. It was just like okay I think it was time. It was also I think how I could kind of justify my mind bringing in STI. Yeah, I was going to say
um and when I bought STI, it was kind of like even before I played it, it was like if this ends up being a hit for me, that might that might be the writing on the wall for Underwater Cities because it's just adding to the same category. And spoiler alert, said he ended up being a hit for me in my
I think it was up almost into the top 10. It didn't quite make the top 10, but way up there.
Yeah. Basically replaced. Yeah. And even with a little bit higher.
Yeah. And it's and so it's one of those things like had I kept Underwater Cities and ranked it this year, it's probably in my top 25
still,
but in the context of my collection and what makes sense to hold on to, I just uh I'd rather be playing some of these other games.
Well, that's the question we always ask oursel when we're getting games. It's not just would we enjoy playing this game. There's a million games out there we'd enjoy playing, right? We have limited time and and limited like in certain gaming situations and like we've said on this channel, we love playing our favorites
over and over.
A lot.
Yeah. And that's something that that maybe differentiates because there are people that love just trying lots of different games and they can be now those people should probably think a little bit of like how much do I need to own games because there's a point where it's like okay if you're not going to be replaying them. Um, but yeah, we are very much in the lane of I do want to play my favorite games over and over and over and explore. And I love coming back to a game that feels familiar and there's not that friction with the rules.
So, it's it's hard though, man, with how many good games that get put out now. You really have to,
you know, hold your ground with that approach to not get
such a sirens call to want to try all these games.
True. But I'd argue, Ryan, even though I'm going to bring us home here, I'd argue that's the most uh shocking one. Uh
yes, that's that's the big news.
That's the big news. Um so don't don't come at me anymore about being the volatile one. Jeez, Ryan. Um I am going to wrap things up here if you're what?
So let me So I called my number five game of all time. Let's just end the video right there. Um, but there is a very there's there's a very clear reason for it. Um, my number five game of all time was Nemesis,
but I then have now gotten Nemesis Retaliation, a different game. A lot of differences in it.
And so, thus, it's uh we view it as cold, that one, this one was new. Um, and I believe Nemesis Retaliation was my number three of all time this year. And I tell you what, Nemesis is a
it it first time I played it, I just had not experienced a board game like it. I had not experienced a game that had gave me just the thematic feel, the the uh literal like fear of like going around. And actually, that's something original Nemesis has even more than Retaliation. Um this semi-ooperative nature. I mean, that's something we've always we've always been interested in semi-ooperative games, but I think it's just never really landed. It feels like in Nemesis they finally kind of found the formula that we really like. But getting Nemesis Retaliation and just them injecting so many things that it for our tastes I think elevate it. Um a variable map um things that I I think while the fear of you could die at any moment is fun in Original Nemesis with a game that's going to you know be a 3 to four hour game again we don't get a plays all the time. It's kind of nice to have a little bit more of a beefiness coming in that it's less likely you're going to die, you know, immediately. I love the change of the mission cards where now instead of it used to be just first alien comes out and you have to commit and you're like, I don't even I haven't even nothing's even happened yet and I have to decide. Whereas now it's you're you're incentivized to commit earlier because you get a benefit. But but you could hold on and that just keeps the tension throughout the game.
Yeah. which I realized a very nice side effect of that rule is it's like also an insurance to help prevent you from dying cuz what can end up happening
is you're like oh no I've gotten myself into a really bad situation you know something happened
I need to discard an objective to get three cards or two cards or whatever the current reward is and I can use those to help me handle this situation and so it's a nice kind of like fall back
instead of just dying,
right? And I so I just think all of it took a game that that I I mean obviously absolutely love top five game and they managed to improve it kind of significantly for me. I know it only went up two spots, but like my love of Nemesis Retaliation is very very high. Um and so Nemesis uh left. I uh I got rid of it. This is crazy, Ryan. I got rid of it before I even tried retaliation. That's
Yeah, that's gay.
But I He's like, I know if I get rid of it, then I for sure. No, I uh I will say I watched I dug into like what were the changes and it was one of those things that's just like
I this seemed like I can so see how this is going to be better. Um I could have been wrong, but I was not. And uh to me,
doesn't that feel nice?
It does feel good, right? It doesn't happen all the time, but when it does, it feels good. Um, so that is uh Nemesis comes in all the way up at number five and now out of the collection. Well, there you have it. If you missed our top 50 games of all time, we have the full playlist linked here. You can go check out uh which games beat all these games out in both sticking around and ascending the ranks. We've got another video here you can check out as well. But we will see you in the next