Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 31:59

hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this episode I go through some plays and a smatter of games that I was able to play during the month of June I was able to get to 71 games by the end of the month and so it was a pretty good month for me and as you can see there are a wide array of games that I played of course I've been playing a lot of Apple Jack and glass Road a lot of Seven Wonders with some friends before they moved away and some other games that are easily done on board game arena of note I did finish the crew I've been playing for years a match or a campaign on board game arena with some friends and my wife of the crew and we finally finished all the missions and so I think we're going to start the Deep SE sequel to that so that'll be interesting some of these games you may have noticed I've already covered and some of these games I will probably cover on in more detail in a future episode if there is a game here that I cover in this quick style uh kind of highlevel overview reviews of of some of these games if you want to hear more about them let me know in the comments down below and I will happily oblige if I can so with that intro out of the way let's start with cat in the Box many people know about cat in the box but if you haven't heard about this game it's a trick-taking game where the cards you play don't have a suit assigned to them when they're in your hand but are assigned when they are played thus Mimi King Schrodinger's cat thought experiment and in addition you predict

how many tricks you will win in the a certain round and while you keep track of Tricks made on a research board you gain more points if some of these tricks and these cards with their certain suit of color are all lined up together and adjacent to each other with your own suit then you gain extra points in addition to correctly predicting your bid and and achieving that this was a fun trick-taking game that wasn't too hard to uh learn as I thought it would be you know I thought the concept of these cards not having a suit until they until they are played was more daunting to me before I actually started playing it and I I like the predictive puzzle of not only guessing how much you will win with the bid but also where to play certain numbers during the game making some tactical decisions along the way to hopefully get some points out of that but also to not play a paradox where is you know you you play a number from your hand and that color is already taken or all the color spots are already taken for that certain remember you have to play somewhere else on the board and you can't play in that certain color again so a lot of negative consequences for not being able to do so so you have to plan ahead and make sure you are playing the correct number and colors that you have available but also trying to push your way in and make that puzzle uh work for you as well as the bidding so it's pretty simple but a and elegant you know with enough replayability I think to uh create a puzzle each time you play it and perhaps a puzzle within a puzzle as you play with the same group and try to

predict where everyone may be able to play so I think I get the hype behind this game and it was a lot of fun to play and hope to play it in in person to see how it plays on the table I thought it was just fine on board game arena playing asynchronously so it probably is a better experience when it is live so those are my thoughts on Cat in the box next is Trio so this is a quick lightweight game that has you playing trios of cards from both your hand and a Central Market of cards but the caveat is is that these cards in the middle are face down you flip these cards over but if you fail in creating a trio of cards three of a kind you have to flip these middle cards down on the table and so it requires an element of memory to remember where these cards are this is fine for some and memory though for a lot of people I think is a limiting factor to how enjoyable modern games are and this was especially true playing it asynchronously on board game arena I could write down some notes in the corner and you know make sure I kept track of where certain cards are but this was very tedious to do and I couldn't remember what the cards were from turn to turn let alone if someone else had taken a card and made a trio from the middle and used a card from there it would often be you know it would jumble up what I thought I remembered about where those cards were and so the memory element suffered even more because of that the redeeming aspect is that you can play this game as a team so I think that alleviates things

if you're playing this live you can perhaps communicate in a limited fashion to telling your partner where certain cards might be if they are having trouble uh memorizing where these cards are in the middle of the board but you don't want to communicate that directly to your opponents who may be able to create a trio from that as well and so I like that aspect but unfortunately the game itself was not very fun for me because I couldn't remember anything from an asynchronous play so perhaps this game deserves another chance in a live play but I am doubtful that for me at least it would be any more fun than it was uh which was not very fun at all Middle Ages is a game that is contains light Drafting and Tableau building where as a general overview you are drafting buildings of different types hoping to have a majority over your opponents as you place them into your tablet they each have special abilities which earn you points in different ways when in comparison to others once again if you have a majority of those types of buildings in addition to some buildings allow you to reserve buildings in the sequence of drafting and so the the thing about this game too is that the tiles that you draft are onlined in a way that you can see a couple of turns ahead and so you can one you know reserve some of these buildings to be able to play on a later turn but also you can kind of forecast what you might be able to play and what your opponent

might be able to try to play to their board as well and it's pretty easy to kind of guess what they might want to do based off the number of buildings they have already played onto their Tableau I like this game it was reminiscent of other drafting games of a lighter nature such as Sushi go but also contain a little bit of complexity that for me felt akin to It's a Wonderful World when I think about the complexity of Middle Ages I think it falls in between those two games I think it's a wonderful world is a little bit more complex of a game than Sushi go or Middle Ages but Middle Ages has a little bit more of a tense decision- making uh compared to Sushi go with the interesting you know unique feature that you can see some of these tiles ahead of time and not have to rely on the memory of passing cards and hands of cards from opponent to opponent around in a circle so I think this game is really fun if you do enjoy some of those games I think it's worth a shot to try Middle Ages out on board game arena it's I think it was fun next let's talk about a heavier game in PAX Renaissance second edition to be specific but this is a big game in the Pax line of games similar to Pax Premiere I Believe by a different designer in which you are Merchants Vine for control over Europe in the renissance period you do so by buying cards from a market that is both spe has specific cards to the the Western and Eastern portions of Europe at the time containing events and character or not characters but historical figures from

that that time frame taking control of these figures into and placing them into your own Tableau and activating a variety of different types of actions that they are able to do usually you can activate one card uh or one action per card and as many cards as you can on a certain side of your Tableau whether it's the western or the Eastern portion and I'm not going to get into any more rules because this game is quite complex but these actions mostly have to do with the interaction of the board placing units onto a a map of Europe um both more combatant style units to engage in combat and take control over certain regions and to gain certain cards onto your Tableau like the uh the Kings and the queens and the vassals uh that pertain to each region uh you can also Play Down Merchants to uh set off a trading route to gain coins and and ultimately this game is decided or the winner is decided by you having to buy a certain victory card that is shuffled into both decks and they if you buy this card or activate this card then you are eligible to win the game if you meet that certain condition there are I think four different conditions that you can meet and all of them consists of having like a certain number of units on the board or having a certain number of Kings in your tableau more so than your opponents Etc and so there's a lot of flexibility to how you pursue and win this game and for that reason this game plays fairly quick for such a high level

and complex game this is a really intriguing game I had a lot of fun playing this and learning how to play this it was daunting for sure and I am not I am still a little fuzzy on some of these rules I'm not totally comfortable with it and it has that factor that there is a high skill level and high uh ceiling of play for this game there are podcasts and YouTube channels solely dedicated to this game and others in the PS line and so I know a game that has the capacity to Garner a following of of dedicated players is something that I'm always intrigued in uh very similar to games that I really love and enjoy it's probably a little bit farther down the line of me wanting to really get into and play uh for whatever reason I I I think I have a lot of games that I really want to say master before this game but I had a lot of fun playing it I would play it again if someone else brought it out I would have to refresh myself even after having played it just you know a few weeks ago but it was you know it was still a lot of fun and I think there's a lot of potential for this game if you do like highly interactive and high you know highly skillful games um this game might be right for you and you can check it out on board game arena of course next I Revisited brass Birmingham now it's been months since my last play of brass and and back when I had experienced it first it was through an online implementation called game parlor I don't think this implementation is viable anymore at the time of this

recording if so I apologize but in any case I do have a physical copy of it now due to my birthday and so I finally had a chance to bring it out and play it again and really refresh myself to the rules to the differences from this compared to uh the original brass and what kind of new options this game had to offer and I thought I still think this game is really fun I think it's well-deserving of its high rank on Board Game Geek it's an elegant game that is you know easy enough to to teach it's more in the medium weight I would say medium to heavy uh complexity for for teaching but once you understand the actions that you can take what the cards do and most of the card all of the cards are basically uh symbolized and have iconography for what you can do there's not a lot of te uh text that you have to memorize or anything like that but you know as soon as you understand the way that the game plays you can really see I for me at least I can really see the depth that this game provides there is so much strategy to how you implement your cards as you as soon as you be you know you begin play there's probably some general you know strategy that works really well unless you have a certain combination of cards and at certain player counts of course to um coupled with the flexibility of the setup variability of the markets that you deliver to and sell products to it really affects how you play your cards

from your hand and in addition to that flexibility you can scout for cards or in other words discard cards for wild cards to let you play anywhere in any type of building and so I really like the added flexibility that that this game has even at the sacrifice of some of the uh tried and true set and stone strategies that you have in brass laner or the original brass you know giving up the opportunity to build you know really uh High Point bearing cards in the shipyards and things like that trading that out for having to rely on a new type of building with that produces beer as well as all of the different types of buildings that you can sell markets to or sell to markets in addition to the core buildings of coal and Iron Works things like that so I really enjoyed my play of brass Binum it was a breath of fresh air to come back to it again I really hope to continue playing this game hopefully one day this gets a a better digital implementation if you haven't heard there is an implementation on Steam it's not very good I don't think even playing against the AI is a good experience there might be a lot of bugs or it's not very hard or something like that and the online player versus player experience is lackluster and so unfortunately that hasn't panned out hopefully this does get a better implementation I know it's number one on the not only on Board Game Geek but also it's number one on the Most Wanted game list on board game arena everyone has

upvoted that game so much that it's taken the number one spot after not being in the top five for a long time and so hopefully that pressures in a good way uh this game for to to be developed and and implemented in a way that a lot of people could play it and really master it and hopefully that happens sooner rather than later next let's talk about Dune Imperium and I the these are my thoughts on Dune after 10 plays I probably could have done an episode solely based on this but due to time and work and everything I think I'm going to have to squeeze it in here but if you do want to hear more thoughts on Dune Imperium let me know but this month I did reach 10 plays of Dune Imperium this was mostly done on the efforts of the new digital app that is available for purchase and I've played this a ton with my father-in-law both just him and myself playing the game but also against some AIS I will say that the app is really well functioning it's easy to play against uh opponents online and the AI uh uh opponents are pretty well uh programmed I think they are pretty tough at least we've had a difficult time overcoming them on a consistent Basin basis and it's not even uh set to their highest level of capacity and difficulty and so I think this game is is fun uh especially at four players this game offers a really tight experience really limited uh spots with work rep placement

if you take a game like Agricola or a lot of the games in the Rosenberg line the way the amount of spaces that you can play with uh scales according to the player count it does not in D an Imperium at first I was playing this two playay and it felt really easy to kind of do what you wanted to do that definitely changes that four players and it creates an experience where you really have to think about what cards should I play as worker placement uh options first where should I prioritize to be able to uh make my Headway in in different ways to get points right I still think at my first impressions with Dune um and this included Dune Uprising as well were that going really heavy on Military and being able to win as many battles as you can especially the ones in the latter half which usually award you two points which is a fifth of the points that you need to win the game if you are able to build up your military or your troops and place them consistently onto the board or onto the uh combat area you will probably get to Victory a lot quicker than your opponents will the Faction board and advancing up that is pretty good as well I think it really relies on the cards that you acquire during the game allowing you to go there with a little bit of luck in the draw involved in that probably having to trash other cards to be able to make those cards work and perhaps your player asymmetric player Powers play a part in that as well but I

I still want to think that combat is the number one priority to go for and the players or the characters that you can play as that emphasize this this combat strategy I feel like tend to do a lot better but this is based off of a very small sample size I know people have really dedicated a lot of time to the strategy of this game and may contradict what I have just said but these are my Impressions just after 10 plays and I think this game definitely warrants and has gained my interest to play this game much more than 10 times I think there is a lot to unpack once again it's a really tight game and so I'm really intrigued in the sequence of of a lot of these worker placement events it's it feels very similar to the tightness of agria at a high player count which really intrigues me uh the deck building is is great as well I like the choices that are offered in either playing a card to use its worker placement ability or to save it to purchase other cards that may serve you better in the game I've had really good experiences and results with some of those cards in the deck such as the opulence card being able to save up a lot of money to gain points along the way uh there were one or two games that I was able to win or at least get really close to winning based off of that strategy and on that note too I I love how tight this game is when it comes to the race to get to 10 points as well for the there have been some outling games where there is a runaway leader but for the most part I think everyone has played in a way that we or at least we

all you know playing at the same skill level made the game really close to to where we were all within one or two points of 10 points and winning the game pretty much at the last round or second to last round and so I really like the timing of this game and it it doesn't necessarily create a short game per se but you can kind of see where the game is going to end and and it really shows and tells an arc of a story that is told thematically as well with the characters in The Planet you know the the premise that is is told by the the Dune story and so I think this game really knocks it out of the park thematically as well as strategically and so it it once again like how I feel about brass B Birmingham I feel about Dune Imperium I think it does deserve its high rank in the upper echelons of board games of all time and I can't wait to explore this game a little bit more let's continue on to something a little bit lighter in confusing lands this is a short 18 card game that features layering uh of cards on top of each other very similar to games like nalia or Trailblazers both games I have covered on the channel uh previously various objectives are depicted on these these cards and in the rule book uh all these cards and these objectives are explained and so each turn you choose between two of these cards that are dealt to you you choose one to play onto your board either side and basically on top of a card that has already been placed onto

your Tableau making sure that the placement rules are met but then you also give the card that you did not choose to your opponent who has to play it onto their board as well so it creates an opportunity to focus not only on your Tableau but also to consider your opponent's tableau to make sure that everyone or that you maximize the uh opportunities that you have to score more points than them this game features the chase of objective cards you know with the tantalizing options of well I started off with this card and this objective should I continue to pursue this or should I chase this new objective that I have been handed in a new round in a new draw and so I like games that offer those tantilizing decisions from turn to turn it plays very quickly and I think this game is is a really fun one and you can play it on board game arena and try it out for yourself it's not going to be as complex as some of the games that I've covered before but if you are wanting to play a good puzzly game in a short amount of time as a filler or just asymmetrically on board game arena this game might be interesting to you next is roll Through the Ages uh the Iron Age this is an older roll and right game that was originally designed by Matt Leon in the form of roll Through the Ages the Bronze Age but this is a a newer version made I think about 10 years ago by Tom Leman you roll dice you gain resources turn those resources into buildings like ports and provinces gaining Tech benefits along the way and building monuments for points like you typically would in any other civilization game uh

there is interaction in like fight fighting barbarians building up troops and uh attacking other opponents as well gaining tribute from them and I think it has all the makings of a solid role and right in a quicker format relative to other civilization themed games I know that the physical version is not a looker if you looked at uh pictures and images of this game on Board Game Geek you can see that it really is a very Bland looking like statistical uh roll and right type of booklet with a wooden uh board and Peg similar to like an old version of Cribbage that you might find in your grandparents closet and so this game doesn't look very good and it's probably why it did not catch The public's eye as say pandemic did but I think if you like roll and right games with a civilization type of theme I recently covered discordia I think if you like discordia you might like this game I think if you do like really involved in complex Ro and right games then Hadrian's Wall is probably up your alley it kind of had the same you know similar Vibes compared to Hadrian's Wall not as complex though I think hren wall is definitely a more uh thinky type of a game but if you want to try this uh game out it is available on board game arena and even though it might not look great it's well implemented on board game arena and maybe the strategies and the things that you're doing or abstracted here are something of interest to you so you can check it out next is sale this

is a Cooperative trick-taking game for two-player once again I played this on board game arena and you play in this game you play tricks to move your ship the the ship that is carrying both players around the sea and around obstacles hoping not to run into or awaken the Kraken if you do so you lose the game you can awaken the Kraken by naturally playing tricks uh as soon as one player out of the two plays enough tricks according to the round rules and scenario for example if you win four tricks then you flip over a few cards from the deck uh you advance the Kraken uh track and soon it kind of gets to a point where it awakens and you lose it kind of felt similar to like Clank where you move along a dragon track and you know the closer that you get to the dragon Awakening or or you know pulling out more cubes out of the bag uh the more dangerous the situation is and so you're you're racing to get your ship and and you move your ship by playing tricks and comparing those tricks not only to who wins but also to the suits of the uh cards that you play they allow you to do certain actions such as move your uh boat forward in a certain direction or it may have a negative impact to Awakening the Kraken even faster and I've only played the learning scenario and so there are probably some cards or modules that are added to this game uh things that you can do to set up the board to make it harder as well very similar to games like the crew and so if you like the crew which is also a

Cooperative trick-taking game I think you would like this game if you do prefer more of a board presence in addition to the trick taking mechanism it was it was a fun game uh unfortunately I think I do like the crew a little bit more because you can play with more than two players but if you are having a game night with another person and you want to try a cool little trick taking game I think sale is worth trying next let's talk about River of gold so this is a pickup in deliver game that kind of a pickup in deliver game that I played on board game arena where you build out markets along a river uh you're spending resources to play these uh these buildings onto the the side of this River increasing your influence in certain guilds and types of markets as well for points this is all set in the fantasy world of ragon as well uh we my wife and I played The Legend of the Five Rings card game from Fantasy Flight that was uh made I think like 10 years ago or so and so I think it is set in that similar world but anyway the pickup and deliver type of uh portion of this game is that you collect in your hand uh certain contracts of of people of cards that you need to fulfill fill with resources you can trade these resources in for for each other and and hopefully build up the right amount of resources to pay for some of these deliveries but the the caveat is that you have to roll dice at the beginning of the round and you can only deliver to folks who match that symbol that you had rolled in your hand for your the cards in your hand and

so there is a little bit of luck of the draw or lck of the dice roll when it comes to who who you can deliver to and this is mitigated not only by the fact that you can change the dice roles according to certain text and abilities on cards or otherwise but also you can gain points by solely focusing on building out markets and saving up money to do so and so in my personal experience and anecdotally the points of this game I think a lot of the points in this game came from delivering to those folks in your hand and so I think having you know trying to mitigate that and and roll the right dice at the right time to get those deliveries made made a really big difference in who won who didn't but it would be interesting to see how viable these alternate strategies that are a little bit more deterministic and not reliant on the dice roll end up being at the end of the game and over time so this was a fun game if you do enjoy the more pickup and delivery style of game uh moving around a map and delivering these Resources with a little bit of luck in dice rolling then you can try this game out finally to wrap things up I want to talk about my my experience with Cascadia landmarks I finally had the chance to play this expansion after talking about it a lot in comparing uh this expansion and Cascadia to other games that I have played recently I had a chance to play this physically with two other players and unfortunately my experience had not changed dramatically from How I Feel

originally about uh Cascadia in general and my thoughts on the additions from this expansion so here's why first the I I didn't play with the six player or the version of speeding up this game I think I would have enjoyed the trying out how fast this game could play with the quicker variant even at a shorter player count I know it's meant for higher player counts and I think with that it would still end up feeling like a longer game that in my opinion shouldn't be so for Cascadia I think Cascadia would be fine in like a turn-based a synchronous type of experience but uh for the weight that this game provides in rules complexity I felt like it took a little bit too long for what it is but The Landmark tiles and I think this is in the perspective of a lower player count half of what is a potential you know for this game The Landmark uh bonuses and as a quick overview when you are playing habitat or you know habitat tiles onto your uh Tableau and you place the fifth tile that that matches a certain Corridor you know environment type you have the option to uh place an animal elsewhere I believe but also to gain a landmark tile to place on that tile that you just played and to gain one of the available cards that has opportunities for endgame points the thing that was kind of disappointing was that these cards and the points that were offered by these cards were very minimal uh in the range

of say you know two to five points on average and once again this is at a lower player count but I I wonder and I do suspect that it might be a little different because I know you do scale the amount of tiles that you play with in each game to having the same amount of tiles played and then the same number of rounds playing played every time which I think is 20 and so it might not change at all but the fact the matter is is that those cards did not offer as much of an incentive for me to try to play some EX for the exception of cards that allow owed you to combine the uh largest Corridor of environment uh spaces that you had on your Tableau with the second largest to hopefully gain the majority and to gain more points than your opponents in that regard but other than that a lot of those cards just didn't offer enough bang for me to want to collect them to the point where I would rather play a fifth tile down onto a you know a corridor and take that animal that I had just drafted as well and play it onto that tile or save that tile for another animal in the the future rather than taking the optional Landmark tile and so I I was kind of disappointed in how um I guess menial the amount of points were available in that in those landmark cards and so it wasn't the best experience for me I I have cooled a little bit more on Cascadia as I've played it I think if I had the chance to play this more regularly which I probably would because I am surrounded by people in my life who

do really enjoy Cascadia and so I think if I do get to play this game a little bit more say on a digital format I think I would enjoy it you know I I think I would enjoy it more as an asynchronous game rather than in person I would rather play a game that plays a little bit more complex at the same in the same time frame as it does with Cascadia and the complexity that is added with the landmarks expansion is not enough to make it as satisfying as I would like it to be and I I was kind of disappointed in how low the incentive was to play some of those landmarks onto my own Tableau but tinkering around with different player accounts might change my opinion on that and it would be interesting to hear from you or and from anyone else what you might think about that expansion if you have played with it and so those are my thoughts on a lot of these new games that I have played mostly digitally some on the table in the month of June once again it felt like a pretty pretty good month to try out new games and have uh you know revisiting experiences as well in the form of uh bringing out an old game or playing with a new expansion so hopefully some more opportunities to come we'll see how it goes this month and once again let me know in the comments if you would like me to talk more about some of these games or if you have thoughts uh whether you agree or uh disagree with my thoughts on some of these um opinions that I have i' would love to hear it either way thank you for listening or viewing and hope that you schedule an appointment with us real soon take care

Progress saved