Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 100 Board Games of All Time (2023) 50-41

Transcript 37:25

welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and this is our top 100 favorite board games of all time and today we are counting down the 50s and we have broken through to the top half so let's get right to it with your number 50. my number 50 is Isle of cats and I love cats is a game that I kind of forgot about for a while I feel like we hadn't played it and we moved over to playing Isle of cats explore and draw a lot and then we went back and played regular Isle of cats and I'd convince myself I liked explore and draw better but now that I played the regular one again and remembered it is my favorite one still I love cats it's just great it's it's such an interesting mix of card Drafting and tile placement and I I can't think of another game that does that well if it does that at all and certainly that does that as well and it's got the cool scoring thing where you're scoring from the cards that you draft and those become for some reason they're called lessons lessons and I don't understand that but for some reason they're called lessons but they're just kind of ongoing scoring so you're drafting those instead of drafting baskets to put your cats in there's a lot of quirky fun bits to this and the expansions that we got the asymmetric boats um the monsters or

beasts make it interesting too and the kittens the kittens are the best part of the expansion because I love getting that one or two tile little cats and they look adorable as well but you're right the scoring condition is interesting because you still have to like pay fish for those cards so is it worth your while but that is how you can get a lot of points I love board games where you still have to pay fish for those cards and you got to get your baskets to catch your cats it's such an absurd world and that is my number 50. my number 50 is tillotum which came out last year and it surprised me it's by board and dice and we generally like board and dice games but it's the name of a European city and I haven't been too Blown Away by other games that are just named after cities and I think what makes this one Stand Out is how many combos you can pull off because of how interconnected everything is because it seems like you're doing quite separate actions of either like moving around or building something or putting people into your homes but then the bonuses that you can get for each of those actions often will tie into the other actions so even though one turn might be like just move a couple of places you're then allowed to pick up a tile and that tile gives you a new action and you can kind of almost go combo to combo to combo yeah it's it's a really clever game I was surprised too because it's so it's like aggressively beige but then

it's really fun and it is that that whole combo thing and also just how you choose your actions as well there's this wheel of numbers like one to six or whatever it is and then you roll all the dice and then the dice go out there but the cool thing is leave the dice is the number of resources that you get in the color of the dice and the place is the number of actions you you can take and then it leads to all these other things that happen it was super super surprising it blew me out of the water yeah and the color dice matching the resources is a huge factor of I actually don't want this resource but I want this action so what am I gonna do and that is my number 50. my number 49 is hegemony and hegemony is this quite heavy quite asymmetrical socioeconomic game where different players are all different classes within the economic system so there's the working class the middle class the capitalists and the and and the state but in this case the state is like altruistic and trying to help everybody out it's like a reverse 1984 kind of state that actually wants the best for everybody um and it's it's just really interesting and you can tell as well that there are actual economists that help to work on this game so you can see all of those bits in there and I feel like I'm learning about finance and economy and all of these things and the the asymmetry is fascinating the asymmetric factions are really interesting because

you're do very different things so it is pretty important that everyone understands what their faction does and a little bit of what the other factions need to do as well because sometimes you're doing the best thing for you and sometimes you're trying to kind of just do something that gets in the way of the other players as well well the interesting thing about it is you kind of have to help everybody out because it's there it's such like a symbiotic system that if you're the working class you have to work somewhere and that's going to help the capitalists in the middle class but if you don't do it then you can't build your unions and have your strikes and everything else you want to do as the working class so you have to help them out and if you're the capitalist you have to employ the working class and you have to pay them and even though they I hate to do it and so it's really interesting that it's like I need to give you enough but I want to make sure I get a bit more out of it and that's fascinating it is it's tough and you really got to think you got to study before you show up for this game but I think that it's worth it and it is my 49. my number 49 is Ganymede and we were first attracted to playing Ganymede because you love the moons of Jupiter so the title just already got us playing but it seemed really simple when we were explained it because all you have to do on your turn is take one of the cards and perform the action on that

card but there's still enough strategy because if you can chain the cards together then you can do the bonus actions for how many cards you have and which type of cards you end up for the scoring conditions can really change what you're doing as well so it's each turn goes so quickly but it still is really satisfying and I feel like still feels like there's enough strategy in yeah it's it's cool because really you're just you're putting dudes down on Earth or you're moving them into Mars you're moving them to Ganymede and that's pretty much it like that's pretty much all that the cards do but it's so much more interesting than that because you've gotta kind of time it because all of the cards have different colors of people so you've got to make sure that there is like a red and a yellow on Mars but then somehow that there's going to be a blue and a yellow so that you can move those over to Ganymede and there's little powers that let you switch colors or let you add people let you do these different things so you are thinking ahead but it's like these bite-sized choices that are just really interesting and engaging and we play this a lot yeah it's become I think our go-to game for when we're not too sure what to play and that is my number 49. my number 48 is Clank Acquisitions Incorporated and this could pretty much be any of the Clank games they are all fairly similar but I like the campaign one the best the Legacy game it's it's just it does

Legacy so well it's super super quick with it it's got little bits of text but they're actually like legitimately funny and fun and you build up the board and a pretty fulfilling way and it's the only Legacy game I have ever played that we actually legitimately still play we still use the boards and I think it's probably the best Clank board that you that we have after we're done the game and what is nice is the cards translate to using other boards as well so we just bought the Legacy version but then we were able to buy just the map packs that have the different sided boards which is nice because those add slightly different ways of playing Clank and then we didn't need to buy the original to be able to play those yeah we could buy like three more boards for like 15 there's just a few little tiny tweaks you gotta make and then you can do the like the ape temple one and there's one with spiders and there's like an underwater one and they all do add some cool different stuff some cool different meeples and clank's just it's just a fun game you can teach to anyone that's a fun Pusher luck thing and that is my 48.

my number 48 is Imperial settlers empires of the north and this is a game that has grown on me the more and more we play it you are asymmetric Viking factions and you are building out your houses and you're going on missions but the asymmetry really stands out and it's so it seems so minor because so many of the cards look so similar on the surface like you are collecting similar types of resources and some of the actions seem so so similar but how you interplay all of the cards and the type of things you're doing is so different and in the base game there's a good chunk of factions included and then all of the expansions and we've picked up a number of them as well so it's been just a lot of fun to explore all of the different factions yeah this game the it is so interesting what they do with such a like small system because you're just playing on a tableau of cards and then you're sailing ships to kind of get more cards but some of them like Bank their money and then they save up all this money and some of them build like a million cards and some of them have all these like Play Once cards and some of them are mean and they trade things but not in a way that you would like things to be traded it's like a forced trade and it is super interesting how each one of them plays and how they play against each other and the art is deceptively simple for the depth of the game because it's quite cartoony which I appreciate and that is my number 48. my number 47

is Euphoria and I feel like Euphoria is kind of like the underdog of the stonemeyer catalog it's such like a big publisher and this is the one that kind of flies under the radar a little bit but I think it is a lot better than it gets credit for especially if you add the expansion which makes it a lot more playable for two and for solo and just a more interesting game I think but this is all about a dystopian society and it's a it's a dice game you're putting dice out and you're getting these different resources and then you also have these four kind of Warring civilizations within this Society a little bit this is all very abstracted but it's super dystopian and so the clever thing and I feel like we always talk about this but it's such a clever mechanic is that every time you use a dice it gets a little bit smarter and a little bit smarter until it just runs away because it realizes it lives in like Brave New World and it's tired of eating Soma all the time so it gets out of there but the theme is really is what brings me in but then the gameplay is really interesting and it's cool how well it ties to that theme which I think is always great when the two things knit together yeah and I think part of that too is you get a secondary faction that's hidden and so you do have these four different factions that you're trying to push your main one along but you might have one that somebody else is also pushing on so it can be really nice when that person has been pushing that one along and you get to reveal it and

get that extra like bonus and you're like yes I was part of this faction too yeah it's interesting because I don't usually like hit and roll but it's like a positive hidden role kind of where you're like secretly helping somebody instead of secretly a traitor which is really interesting but that is my 47. my number 47 is Rez arkana and what blows me away about rezar Kana is you start with a hand of eight cards and that is it those are the cards you have to work with so you do get to see what all of your cards are but then you shuffle them and you don't know what order they're gonna come out and you just have to try and make do with the combinations of those cards for which ones you're going to pay to play out and which ones you'll you'll spend to be able to play other cards based on the different locations that you're going for or what you're gearing towards and what your like magician or with your Mage power is as well so you're really trying to find the Symmetry between all of these cards and because everything every card is unique and does things in different ways I've never had a game play remotely similarly even though it's just using those eight cards yeah this game is it's so smart how those cards have been have like how the cards have been made that they can all kind of work together that I've never played this game and thought oh well I can't do anything like I always

see those eight cards to think oh I think this is gonna be great like every time I look at that and think I killed it I got such a good hand this time and yeah it's just a fascinating game that you can do that much with eight cards and it still can change throughout the game as you get different stations that give different bonuses as well and that is my number 47. my number 46 is azul and I'm not usually that into abstracts but Azul just grabs me it's such an interesting game and I'm I am going with the original I think for a while I was really won over by summer Pavilions but I think I've gone back now to the original I've been playing it a lot lately on BGA and we've been playing it a little bit this is one that I like fine playing online but it's so satisfying to play in person the Clack of the things in the bag and they feel so nice and smooth and I love putting them out and just making the patterns yeah in person is definitely better and one of the key things is the drafting of the tiles because that is what you're doing all of the tiles go on these little market circles and then you have to take everything that is the same tile on one of those circles leave the rest and move them into the center what that means is you can really try and make your opponent fail by drafting things so that you know by the time it gets to their turn they're going to be stuck with like seven that they just can't use

and that will all go to just the negative points at the bottom yeah it's a little bit like Carcassonne where it starts off as like this friendly like your first few games or you're just worried about your thing and it's all friendly and nice and then as soon as someone realizes oh wait I can really I can really screw someone over then it gets real mean and Azul gets real mean with its Drafting and that is part of the fun of it though I think it's like a fun kind of mean where it's like a clever meme because you've thought it out like three turns ahead and then you see your plan happen and the other person gets so sad but in like the greatest way and that is my 46. my number 46 is Village and I'm specifically going to talk about the big box because that's the one we own and it includes all of the expansions and some new stuff for the big box but Village is pretty genius in how you do your actions because your actions are dictated by wherever there is a cube and at the beginning of each round all of the cubes get randomly distributed at the different locations and so you're trying to decide what Cube which represents a resource you want but also what action you want to do and what action you'll want to race your opponent towards as well because some of them don't have a lot of actions available so you'll want to get in quite quickly and then you are also and I love the theme because this is the key part try you have to often

spend time to do your actions and when that passes The Hourglass it means somebody has died and your hope they die doing something that gets them put into the chronicle but managing where your people are and how fast time is going is such an integral part of the game yeah it all of the parts are fascinating because like when you say some of them you don't have a lot of Cubes there's one this Market action only has one Cube so you really like it really matters when you go to that but you need to have the stuff to sell at the market to go to that so both people are kind of racing to get stuff and then also going there or maybe that's not your focus and it's cool because you can have different focuses as well where you want to travel a bit more or you just want to focus on like killing off your people quick and getting them all put in the book and making sure my next person's a farmer who's going to die farming because there's a space open for like a legendary farmer but all of the shopkeepers are filled so I don't want anyone to die over there now um and it's it really is interesting and just seeing like the generations it's not quite as thematic as I thought that would be but mechanically it's genius it is when we first started playing we were really conscious of time and not wanting to kill people and we since realized the value quickly and getting them into the chronicle and that is my number 46. my number 45 is one we've already talked about tilletum

which was higher up on your list and um to all the things that we said about teletime remain true 10 minutes later but tillotum is it really is so smart how comboy all of it is and how it takes those you know what looks like such a dry Euro game and a lot of very dry uromechanics like you're building Cathedrals you're just moving around town to town putting out houses and you're fulfilling contracts and all these euroe things but they feel just like more kinetic because of how they combo and how they all work together and it really is just from having the actions that tie together because it does seem so separate but just being able to pick up a tile that lets you do something else and all of a sudden those things become connected yeah it just really so strong mechanically that everything else kind of Falls away and that is my 45. my number 45 is camel up which is a racing betting game involving camels and you are moving these camels along and you're trying to place bats for who's going to end up first at the end of the round as well as at the end of the game but because the camels stack then that can really shift things around because like one camel can move a lot by just being on top of another camel or they might end up on the camels that bring them backwards so I love that you will have like you never know what is going to happen you I don't think you

can be good at Camelot because I don't think there's like a winning strategy you can use the information you have available and you can try and be strategic and do the odds of who might win but then all of that goes out the window if if that winning camel starts going backwards yeah they're just there are too many like anything to do with camels there are just too many factors involved any drama neologist will tell you this and it is it it's so fun and I think it's because of all of that chaos and because you can bring in new players and they got almost as good of a chance as anyone else because even if they make terrible choices those terrible choices could end up being really smart choices if just if a backwards camel decides to pick a bunch of camels up and rush them back to the start and the board in the second edition looks great yeah it does look really great it's a wonderful Gateway game and I just love like the chunkiness of the camels that you're moving and that is my number 45. my number 44 is flam Rouge and even though the team who made this made heat and I think Heat's terrific flumridge is still my favorite racing game I just I love how incredibly tight it is because Flom Rouge is about bicycle racing and you've got two Racers but in bicycle racing unlike car racing no one's zipping ahead you've got to save your energy so you got to stay in this pack and be right behind and just come out at the right time and the whole

thing is just a game of inches because like the cards you have in your hand will just barely get you to the Finish Line if everything goes right so you really have to think about how to get a little bit over the finish line so you can only play all of those cards once so you're already at best barely going to succeed and so you got to make sure you really succeed by using your drafting the best or using your downhill well so it's just a really smart game but it's also super fast so it's like it's smart but it doesn't take you a lot of time to think out the smart choices and I'm really interested in The Grand Tour expansion because that will let you play multiple races and he already has that in the main box included as a campaign and you add different cards between each of the races and flam Rouge already has a version but it's an app based version so it's just a little bit clunky and I'm intrigued to see what this Grand Tour box is going to be for the campaign version and we do already use the app quite a bit to do those campaigns and we'll just spend a whole night doing like four or five races of Flom Rouge and having the whole world cup but it's going to be interesting to see when they have that like tightened up version in the box and just what do they steal from heat but already that is my 44. my number 44 is azul which was so almost a

crossover two away that's two now that have been so close on this list we're gonna have a crossover sometime soon they're getting closer and closer and just like you I am going with the original version but I do really like summer Pavilion it adds some complexity to the original one so I like that we have both options but because Azul is a game that we just tend to pull out maybe like as a warm-up game or at the kind of end of the night I do appreciate the Simplicity of the original one yeah but both of them are really good though and they are my two favorites of the four um but I the thing I like about summer Pavilion well there's a few things I like that it has the attic complexity but I also like and this is not a gameplay thing but that the shapes are more fun to make shapes with so when it's not your turn you just see everyone around the table like lining up the ones that they have to make little animal faces and stuff and I just enjoy that part of it it's like this weird thing that just seems to happen yeah the tiles in summer Pavilion are great and I really really like when you just pour them in as well they make them such like a good clanky noise and that is my number 44. my number 43 is a Hadrian's well and Hadrian's Wall is this very heavy stinky rolling right game and it's interesting because it's like it's a rolling right because it has to be

because it would just take up so much space to have all of the boards to do all of these things usually Roland rights or rolling rights are flipping rights because they want to give you that quick experience that like you're camping and it's like a thing to do quick around the fire kind of game this is not that this is you're taking an hour with your head down really thinking out all of the parts of what you're doing and oh if I cross off this box is it going to lead to this box and how am I going to use my resources and then you've got people that are kind of resources and they're really important which ones you have and where you put them when and there's so many many interesting paths to Victory there are things I still have not really figured out the Gladiators I still have not really figured out the temples there's so many little Avenues you can go down in this and like explore things for something that's just two sheets of paper and it's so good solo too I think it does work really well at two as well and I think one of the trickies if you play with lots of people is some people's turns might last a lot longer because they real they are really thinking about what to do and maybe manage to trade in a few more things and do a few more actions whereas at two I do feel like we tend to have the same pace and still finish at the same time and just doing that puzzle is so satisfying yeah and it is it is multiplayer Solitaire there is no doubt whatsoever we don't have a problem with that like I I like just sitting down and

doing the things and then we're basically just kind of pacing each other with like can I beat your score it's just it's so inherently satisfying and this is like the comboist of comboe flipping rights that is out there part 43 is carcazon and this is a classic it has sold millions of copies and rightly so even though it's a game that a lot of people play Early when they get into the hobby it's still like a top 50 game for me I love that we're both building this Village out together and the compete competition that goes along with we're building it together but very much not together very much not together but I feel like we're really well matched because you definitely try and take my castles as much as I try and take yours as well and so it becomes this really fun challenge of can I steal this Castle away from you or or this farmer in this field and when you notice that there's been this person lying there that connects just right to get all of the points that belongs to the other players like no I thought I had that field and so still after so many plays Carcassonne is so satisfying and we got the missed over Carcassonne recently and I really liked playing The Cooperative version of it and we introduced the way to play it with regular Carcassonne which I enjoyed as well yeah I actually like it more as an expansion to regular Carcassonne which I

don't think a lot of people use it that way but it works really well and every everything that you said like you usually don't like meme games but in this game's so mean but it's like joyfully mean and this was one of the first games that brought me into the hobby this might be the first real hobby game that I played and I've played it I must have played it hundreds of times by now and I still will play it like we still play this game at least once a month and I'm still interested in it every time we switch in and out the different expansions um and it feels a little bit different depending on what's in there sometimes we'll just play the regular base game but I I just continue to enjoy this game it's staying power for me is unmatched yeah it definitely is and and missed did give it a boost for me because it has ghosts and we love Halloween and anything that has ghost or Halloween themed uh is wonderful and that is my number 43.

my 42 is Ganymede and Ganymede is like like you were saying it's just such a great like Comfort game it's really become one of our ultimate Comfort games it's like this between two castles gingerbread house there's a few of them but I think they're really interesting thing about Ganymede is it kind of feels like a larger Euro game that's just been somehow like squashed down like it's been put into some sort of like mechanics compressor that have shrunk it so that you still feel like you're kind of getting that experience but in like 30 minutes and with less rules but you're still making interesting choices you're chaining things together you can make an engine you can set up these really cool Combos and just like now every time I play a white card I'm gonna do like five times of whatever this bonus is and it's satisfying and when it ends you're like oh is that it maybe let's play another one and I love that feeling yeah I think part of that it's a bit of a race to who can get the most scoring cards but having more of those won't necessarily win you the game either so the end can come suddenly and that is really nice that you're like I just wish I could pull off this one other turn yeah I almost always feel like if I have one more turn I would have won that I would have won that handily but I feel like we both feel like that if I had one more turn it was gonna be like another 10 points and they've just timed it so that it ends

right before that and it just really leaves you wanting more my number 42 is Great Western Trail and I'm gonna pick the original with the expansion over Argentina even though I still really like Argentina and in both of them I love that you're a cowboy and you're hurting cows and collecting different types of cows but one of the interesting things is you can really set the pace Alexander Fister has a few games like this where where you have a range of movement you can go and some of it is really dictated by what the other players are doing because you can maybe stop at each building and do lots of actions or jump ahead only do a few and then get to the end and sell your cows and and start again and if you are going quickly I'm gonna go quickly or if I'm going quickly which is all right you're always going quickly then that does push you a little bit because you do want to make as many trips to Kansas as possible so I always do find that interesting of do I really try and do as many things as I can or hope that I have what I need at the end to be able to to sell enough cows so I think the theme really wins me over which is why the New Zealand Edition that is brand new I think is going to be my favorite because I Like Cows but I really like sheep yeah the New Zealand one I'm I'm fascinated because we lived there for a little while we loved it there and it's got

like an island board and it looks like it's it's like it's got more differences maybe than Argentina did I really like Argentina too and I'm not sure which one I like more actually the original one or Argentina um the original plus the expansion or Argentina but yeah New Zealand looks really cool and it's cool that they're all I don't know about New Zealand yet but I assume that they're all like different experiences that use that same engine because certainly the first two um I feel like it's really worth owning both of them because they bring enough that is different even though that engine is so similar and the movement's so similar I think just because the base of the game is so strong and it's interesting to see that kind of played with in new ways it is but we're having a hard time justifying owning a third version of a sheep but sheep and New Zealand so I bet I I bet you know I have the New Zealand version as well and and that is my number 42. my number 41 is dwarf romantic and speaking of cozy games they do not get Cozier than this this is a game where some people's criticism of dwarf romantic is there's not really a like winner or loser but it's so it's lovely for that dwarf romantic is like the knitting of board games you're just kind of doing a thing and it's gentle and it's lovely and you make something at the end and you're just kind of casually working together

as you put out like your pieces there's not really a wrong way there's a right or way to do it but there's not really a wrong way to do it and it's it's just really satisfying putting everything out seeing it line up you're you know finishing your goals and you've always got three of those to to go and as you do the campaign you're picking up these other things that make it more interesting but they're they kind of drip in exist exactly the right time so it's interesting every time and even the second time through The Campaign which we're almost finished now it's still just as interesting having those just drip in in different ways and that's changed our strategy again but yeah we you would play this every single night if I would agree to it I I absolutely would play this every single night and I think this is when a lot of people probably like solo and I do think it works really well two players because we play it like one player we have a big discussion about where the tile should go who in the words of the Spice Girls two becomes one yes exactly so even if it's my turn and I'm holding the tile it's we have a conversation about where it goes it really doesn't matter whose turn it is and I really like that collaboration and that discussion and because you can't lose there isn't a wrong way but it can work out you could still feel really satisfied if you manage to like line up the tiles just right to do lots of tasks in a row and there are still those uh sense of that

sense of accomplishment yeah because if we finish all of our tasks we're high-fiving like crazy but this is really a game of like this high five we high five like gentle dogs um but this this is really a game where there can't really even be in like I can't imagine there being an alpha gamer in this game just because it is so gentle and just like naturally Cooperative that it just you want to work together and it's it's just it's like a lovely way to spend a night drinking some tea playing some dwarf romantic and it is my 41. my number 41 is Marvel Champions and in Marvel Champions you are cooperatively trying to take down Marvel bad guys and I'm gonna pick the X-Men version and I think that's mainly because of your love of X-Men oh yeah there's no point even in having the older ones now we only since the first mutant Genesis one came out um it is now X-Men Champions yeah and never card playing game that you really do have to work together and maximize each other's strengths a lot because often one character might be better at like thwarting and the other one fighting or you're gonna have to heal each other so I do really feel like there's a lot you have to decide on your turn and so you can't be really be an alpha gamer but you also have to consider the other person and make sure they're doing all right and you're

supporting them we just played this yesterday and I was thinking I might have this too low but when I made this list we hadn't played for a while and that's where it ended up when I made the list yeah we played it last night and it was it's it's always so fun but we're doing one of the X-Men campaigns right now not surprisingly and I've I really like the campaign boxes there are certainly bits and especially the X-Men Sabertooth is too hard for a starting one and other ones Ronin is too hard for anything so there are bits that just feel like a tiny bit unbalanced but for the most part the campaigns are really interesting yeah I think when I made this list we had just played so many of sabertooth and lost and lost and lost and then finally had a win that I needed a bit of a break so I won't be surprised if this is higher again next year and that is my number 41. and that is it that is the end of the first part of the second half of the 10 part series of our hundred favorite games yes it is and we have not seen each other's list so the further down we're going the more Curious I am because there's some games you haven't said yet that I don't know if they're going to be really high for you or just not make the list yeah I definitely have a few that I was like oh it's got to be in this section and now I'm like does she just not like it now or does she love it have I won her over yeah I'm fascinated each

time we do one of these but as usual thank you so much for the games if you like the ones we talked about and subscribe and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game

Progress saved