Top 100 Board Games Of All-Time 2025 (10 - 1)
Transcript
Welcome to Allies Arene Enemies. I'm Jess.
And I am Sean. And today we are continuing to count down our top 100 favorite board games of all time.
Yeah. And it is the final countdown where we are counting down from number 10 all the way to number one. D. That's right. This is the final countdown. It's also the final week of our Kickstarter. So, if you don't know our game, it's set in 1986. It's got modular locations and I think really terrific cassette tokens. So, if any of that sounds cool to you, check out the link right at the top of the description to check out that Kickstarter. It finishes September 20th, which is fittingly the last day of summer, but this is also the last part of our list. So, let's go to number 10 right now.
My number 10 is Orlon. And one of my favorite mechanics is bag building. And there just there are not enough games. There's this, there's Wonderlands War, there's Quacks. I really like all of those, but Orlon by far my favorite one. And I think the reason is that it ties building with really thinky Eurog gaming. and you're you're you're getting these dudes out of your bag. You're using them to get more guys, which also makes you move up all these different tracks and you're trying to place them strategically so you can do all this other stuff. You're sending them to town hall. You're walking around this map. You're building cities on that map. And this game just gets more and more interesting with the other stuff from the uh invasion expansion as well cuz that brings in all sorts of different ways to play it where you can play co-op or solo or headto head which honestly the regular game works well that way too. But the co-op mode we also really like and there's so much good in this game and it is my number 10.
My number 10 is Gaia Project and this is Terrammystica 2.0. First of all, it's a space theme, which I really like, and it uses a modular map, and that makes it work much better for two players because it pushes you together, which is important because you're like racing to put out buildings on these different planets. But it is tough to put out buildings cuz it costs a lot of resources. And it has this interesting economy where when you put out buildings, your income then is what's already revealed. But as you upgrade buildings, you got to bring other buildings back and that covers up those resources and reveals new ones. So you're constantly trying to balance your amount of resources. But what I like in Gaia Project is unlike in Terrammystica, I feel like there are a few more options and a big part of that is there is this tech track and so you're able to kind of upgrade in different ways. Maybe you're making it cheaper to go to a further planet or getting more resources or getting more income. So, it gives you more flexibility, but it's definitely a lot thinkier. But I really like it and it's my number 10.
My number nine is Everdell. And I think a big reason that I like this is just that Jess loves it so much. And I think that definitely rubs off on me. I also like it because of all of the different animals. And we've got the giant collector's box and that comes with tons of animals. And we spent like 3 hours stickering all of them so they look even cuter now. But even without all of those expansions or even the new ones and I do like them. Silver Frost I think is great. Farshore I think simplifies things and is interesting. But still original Everdell plus New Leaf and probably Belfare I think is my favorite way to play this. And really what you're doing you're just making a little animal village. You're putting out buildings. You're putting animals into those buildings. I really like that mechanic as well. My only real problem with that with the base game is just those goals, but Belfare and Newly fix those goals.
They add extra little stuff and I think they just tighten it up that little bit and kind of really nail it. But Jess will play this all the time and so I play this quite a lot of the time and it is my number nine.
My number nine is Planet Unknown. And this is a game I love introducing to people. First of all, I think it's just not as widely available, so people are less likely to have played it. But secondly, it has a great mechanic of using a lazy Susan. And why it uses that is it means everyone can play at once, which is great. So there's no downtime. On your turn, you get to pick which of those two tiles you want. On other people's turn, you still like pick and put tiles out, but you have to choose out of what's in front of you. And then you're choosing tiles based on the shape of the tile, but also the terrain type. And then the terrain type ties into this whole other part where you're these different corporations. And so you're bumping up these tracks and you want to do a little bit of everything. And so it's just an interesting puzzle of trying to like fill your planet and get up tracks. And I love how there's so many different planets that you can play and different corporations that you can try. And it's my number nine.
My number eight is A Feast for Odin. And A Feast for Odin famously is the game with a million worker placement spaces. But they're not just there for show. There's a few interesting things that they do. First of all, there are all these different paths because you can hunt. You can get these really cool items. They're on this special board. You can sail to different islands. You can just trade stuff for stuff. You can have animals. All sorts of different stuff. But the other interesting thing that they do is it's kind of the speed that you're playing because you've got these weak ones and stronger ones and really strong ones, but you don't have that many Vikings. So to take a really strong action is like a big commitment. But what I really like is Norwegians because it makes those like three and four Viking actions a lot more viable because it ties more to this card play that is in the in the original game. And you're smart if you know how to use that. And I didn't know how to use that.
And these other boards are really fun. It adds a few more of those. It adds a few more islands. It kind of adds all the stuff it wanted you to do in the base game, but maybe you weren't doing enough. And it's like here's a like it pushes you in the right direction. And then you're like, "Oh, that's where the fun is." And this is a really fun game. And it is my number eight.
My number eight is Tapestry. And this is an abstract civilization game. And it's because of this game that I started recording scores. This was even before we had an app. I had a notebook and I would keep track of what factions we were and what scores we had. And I think a part of that was the factions may not necessarily be even, but I liked being able to see when I was a faction if I at least beat you when you were that faction. But even without all of the factions, which are super interesting, it's just a really clever game because you're going up these different tracks that represent the different parts of civilization like military, science, technology, exploration, and you're trading stuff for stuff. And so you're really trying to manage your resources, go up all the different tracks, and one of the things you get are these buildings. And so these buildings go on your city board. And the city board is a whole another like interesting part of the puzzle because you can put income buildings out on there. There's also these like big landmark buildings that you can put out that help you fill the space. And it looks really cool, too, because they're all like these like clay looking models. And I think we have played this like over 60 times. And I still always want to keep playing it.
And it is my number eight. My number seven is Sea Salt and Paper. And this is my favorite card game. It's just it's such a beautiful game with these photos of origami art on it, but it's also such a clever game. On your turn, you're just taking one card. You're either taken from the two that are face up that everyone sees or one from the top of the deck. And then there's all these fun little ways that the cards combine. And there's actually not that many. It's like take a card from the top of the deck, do another turn, take a card from one of the piles, just make a little set collection with the cards. Or you get mermaids, which are scoring for points, but four mermaids just wins you the game. Or you get anchor guys or whatever they are, and there's only two of those in the deck, but they can get a ton of points if they go with that five or penguins.
And so there's all these just like little things, and you like learn more about them the more that you play. And it just feels like magical. I feel like how poker players must feel like those real intense poker players. Like I'm running the odds on everything of like what is the chance that that Jess got one of the anchor boys or what's the chance? Does she still have that penguin? Did that go back? Does she have a shark? How many sharks have we seen? I'm doing all that stuff in my head all the time except I'm doing it with adorable origami cards which I think is a lot more fun. And this is my number seven. My number seven is Cascadia. And I one of the reasons I think I really like this game is because it reminds me of home. I grew up in Vancouver. So really I am building where I grew up. And it's this interesting puzzle tile placement game where you've got bundled choices because on your turn you've got to take a landscape token and an animal to token and you've got to make that work for what you're building.
But you're usually not going to get both things that you really want. So, you've got to make it work. And the landscapes, you're trying to group those all together into different sections, which is harder than it sounds. And the animal tokens, you're putting out, and they all score in different ways. And I enjoy games where you're building something that at the end you can see what you've built, and it's this lovely landscape with interesting decisions. And the animals also can score in different ways. And it is my number seven.
My number six is Western Legends. And I do this a lot with movies where there's a movie I can see all of its obvious flaws, but I just love it anyway. Or I even love it because of that. I'm looking at you, Tank Girl. But Western Legends is very much that kind of game for me where I recognize that there's a lot of clunky bits in here. There's a lot of super random things. There's a lot of things that are kind of out of your hands sometimes and there's ways to play that are a lot stronger than other ways to play but maybe not as fun. But you know what else? There is cowboys. And boy is this ever a cowboy game. You got a whole bunch of real life cowboys. They've all got different powers. You're doing so many fun cowboy things. You're getting horses. You're riding around town. You're fighting bandits. You can rob trains. You can rob banks. You can be a good guy or a bad guy. You can switch back and forth. If other people are bad guys, you can be a marshall. Go arrest them and then send them to jail.
Make them lose half their stuff. Or you can be a bad guy trying to sneak away from those marshals. You can take cows, trade them back and forth to other ranches. There's expansions that just add more stuff. Although we almost never go to them. We just have them taking up table space. But I still love that they're there. It is such a like huge story. I just want to be a cowboy. I don't care that much even if I win. I'm not even trying to get points. I'm just trying to do fun stuff. And I think that is a really good sign for an engaging game. Boy, I love this game. And it is my number six.
My number six is Terraforming Mars. And I love how sciency this game is. I would love to be able to terraform and live on Mars. And even though we don't have the technology for that, I do feel like the designers like researched how it would actually work because there are a whole stack of cards and throughout the game you're building your card tableau and your engine and you're trying to get plants, you're trying to get heat, you're trying to do a whole bunch of stuff to turn the red planet into a green living space. But all of those cards have certain things that they'll do that I feel like kind of make sense because like an asteroid will come down and that gives you a whole bunch of heat. You can play this animal card, but you can only play it if there's enough oxygen. So, I do appreciate what feels like scientific plausibility. And I like the kind of semicooperiveness that you're both trying to terraform the planet. And terraforming Mars is my number six. And we'll be right back after this important message.
Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat.
My number five is Great Western Trail, New Zealand. And Jess last time said she likes the sheep cuz they're cuter. I do not agree. I love the cows, especially the belted Galloways. They're the best ones cuz they're so fuzzy. But I still like this one the best out of any of the Great Western Trails, and there's a few reasons for that. One is that this one really does lean into the deck building elements with those special cards that change your deck quite a bit. But I also like that it kind of brings in that first expansion but like tightens it up a little bit with all the different islands or whatever it is at the top of the board that you're going to as well. And that does feel interesting. Argentina kind of tried to do that as well, but I think New Zealand does it a little bit better. There's also really interesting buildings in this one.
There's just there's just a little bit more. It kind of feels like they took the original, they added like two or three little expansions that just that just brought a little bit more out of it and they kind of perfected it here. So, Great Western Trail New Zealand. This is probably the only Great Western Trail I need. And this is my number five.
My number five is anacrony. And I love the theme of anacrony where this you're living in this postapocalyptic world that's going to get even worse and you've got to evacuate. So you're like between apocalypses and so you're these different factions and in order to be able to do most of the actions that are on the main board, you've got to put your people into suits. And so we actually bought the upgraded one, which is one of the few upgraded components we got, which I highly recommend because I love that you slot your people into suits, but you usually can't afford to always send your suits out. So, you've got to carefully weigh which workers are going out onto the planet, but throughout the game, you're buying these tiles and you're adding it to your own city board. And I like that you have access to just your own personal tiles. And it's a really thinky tough game, but there are opportunities to be able to get more stuff because you can borrow things and try and pay them back by going back in time to pay them back. And there is a lot that you're trying to do before you evacuate. And you definitely want to try and make sure you evacuate before the game ends. And it is my number five.
So close to a top 10 crossover, but in the immortal words of Hollandote, so far away, my number four is Anacriny. And Anacrony is a former number one for me. And I still do really, really love this game. I feel like we just played it an awful lot. But anacrony, like you said, I love that it happens between apocalypses that you're just like you're right in the center of two apocaly maybe and in like this little sweet spot. Although it does seem like an awful sweet spot. I love those those um the things that you're putting your guy into, the suits that you're sending out. I also love that you like start to lose spaces in the end of this game and it really feels like it rushes as well because once you get past that cataclysm which means there's only a few rounds left at most. Every time you go to a space it disappears and so you're losing spaces every round and you lose those spaces very fast. But you have hopefully built up all those spaces on the board.
And I like that too that this game kind of transitions from everyone rushing for spaces in the middle. You're still always kind of doing that to building up to being able to have that own little engine and all that cool stuff that you've made. And those buildings can be super different. Do really interesting different stuff. And the expansions as well. Although I kind of like this better without the expansions for the most part, but it is nice because they're so modular. So you can bring those in each game and just change something. And those really make a big difference as well. Although don't use them all. We did it once. I feel like my brain is still recovering. It was way too much. One or two is plenty, but anacrony is my number four.
My number four is Ark Nova. And in Arkn Nova, you are running a conservation zoo, and I've got a zoology background, so I really connect with the theme. It is a bit tricky, though, because I've got such a soft spot for primates that whenever primates are available, I am always going to take them, even if they're not part of any goal. But just mechanically as well, it kind of like mashes a whole bunch of mechanics together. It does feel a little bit like terraforming Mars with the tableau of cards and the engineer building and there are a ton of different cards. It also is like Rajas of the Ganes with the two different types of scoring tracks which I really like because you can really push up one track or the other or just try and get them to meet in the middle. And I like that it has the action selection mechanic where the cards get stronger the more you leave them. So you really want to try and play them when they're in the last slot, but you also have a whole bunch of different stuff to do. And it just intertwines all of those mechanics so seamlessly. And it's my number four.
My number three is Dune Imperium. And you heard that right, not Uprising. It is Imperium. And if we're going base game versus base game, I do think Uprising is the better game. But Dune Imperium, when you add Rise of Vixs and you add immortality, I think is the perfect way to play Dune. It's just it's so good. It's just all the right amount of stuff, but not too much stuff. And Dune, I love that you're clutching and clawing for those 10 points and that you've got those different ways to get those 10 points and you're on that politics track and you're fighting the wars and you're trying to get those nine cost cards that are so hard to get and then worthless once you have them in your deck. And I do like kind of mixing it up and trying to go down those other tracks. Doing that science track that's in immortality is a really fun way to play as well. or getting a ton of those tiles and then you feel like you're like a superstar that stuff from Rise of Vicks and that really makes the board a lot more interesting as well with some of like with the overlays on it and the other like all the different cards and the way those interact. But whether it's Uprising or it's Imperium or best yet if it's Imperium with all the expansions, Dune is such a terrific game and it is my number three. My number three is Lost Ruins of Arnac. And I think this combines two of my favorite mechanics so well. Worker placement and deck building. And it's a game where you can
get a surprising amount done because you start the game with only two workers and there's five rounds. So you're only putting your workers out 10 times, which doesn't feel like a lot. But throughout the game, you're also buying cards, and that will make a huge difference because some of those are very powerful. And as you're going throughout the game, you're able to open up more stuff because you're discovering these campsites and you're defeating guardians. And then those spaces are more powerful worker placement spots that will let you get more. But it is amazing like how much you can figure out what you need to do because I never think I'm gonna make it to the top of that research track yet almost like every time I do. And I like this even more when we started playing cooperatively because it takes like one of my favorite games with yet another mechanic that I like which is a co-op game and it's my number three.
My number two is Gaia Project. And this has been my number one for the last couple of years, but I've got a new number one this year. But let's talk about that in a second. Right now, I do want to talk about Gaia Project because they had a new expansion come out last year and it's really good. I enjoy the stuff that it adds. It adds these extra little weird planets, but they do give you different ways to settle planets. It feels like you can kind of get a few more things done. You can visit different spaceships. I love that those spaceships are named after other games. There's like an Eclipse and a Twilight Imperium one. That's really cool. And I just I've always loved Gaia Project. It is such a difficult like you were saying at the start of this video, it is a really difficult engine. It every single thing that you do feels like even if you're not usually AP, you are in this game because boy do you have a lot of things to analyze here. and just squeezing that one more. It feels like every single turn I need one more white thing or I need one more blue thing. I don't know what they represent. Or I need one more yellow is money, but I need one more of those things. And but there's all these ways to get it. So I'm trying to math that out. Oh, if I do this, then I do this, then I feel so so clever. The interaction's great. How you're building on the middle of that board. All those different factions. And now they've added the new ones as well with that expansion there. And the solo game's terrific in this as well. There's so much to love in Gaia Project and I
still really love it and it is my number two.
My number two is Everdell. And you already had this on the list. I think you gave a bit of a spoiler alert that I really liked it. And it's true. I do. And I think part of my love for it comes from the fact that this was the game that made me really start a collection because we played this at a board game cafe and I fell in love with it. And before that, I'd loved playing games. But playing this made me want to not only get this game, but go and seek out all kinds of other games because I just realized what a big interesting world there was with games that you could have such a beautiful game and such an interesting game. I really like the pacing in this game because you start with only two workers, but by the end you have six workers. you've you're getting a whole bunch of stuff and it's just continually rewarding what you're doing because more cards will let you put out more cards, more workers lets you do more. And so it's I just feel like it's such a positive game and it is my number two.
My number one and my new number one is Ultimate Railroads. And this has been kind of steadily moving up my list for the last few years. But this is a game that the first time I played it, I loved it. I played it once, I immediately bought it. I made I think you were in Canada. I made a friend come over and play it with me like the next day. I just could not stop playing this game. And I think a big thing I love about this game is the progression in it. Cuz that first round, you're lucky if you get like eight points. Like that feels really good. by the end you're getting like a hundred points just like five or six rounds later. And I really like that that you've built up this engine. You built up an engine of engines and you're like you've got these different tracks that all the tracks do different things.
You've got in the Ultimate Edition four different boards. Each one of those has a little quirk. You've got other like little bits and pieces you can mix in too. So even at the start of the game, there's all the different variables that you can mix in. But even if you just use the one board, you would never do the same thing twice because you use those different bonuses. You go down different tracks. And part of that is because that worker placement is so competitive. You've really got to rush to those different spaces. You've also got the different bonus tiles. There's just so much variability, so many different paths. And and Ultimate Railroads is such a terrifically simple but incredibly deep system with so much replayability. I love it and it is my number one.
My number one of all time is Dwarf Romantic the board game. Well, I'm actually going to go with the latest version, Dwarf Romantic Sakura. And this is such a cozy, delightful, cooperative game. I think it probably works really well solo, but we've exclusively played it at two, and I think it works great for two people who like playing together. It's very chill. You are putting out these different tiles to build out your village, build out your roads, build out your rivers, but there's still some challenges along the way because throughout the game, you're completing all of these different goals and it's also a campaign game that unlocks stuff as you go. So, you're also trying to achieve those goals. So I think for me this is the right mix of it having just such a relaxed kind of atmosphere but still with enough challenges that it feels rewarding when you're able to accomplish those. And it is my number one.
And that is it. Those are our number ones. And that is the top 100 all wrapped up for 2025. These are always fun to do. It's always interesting both to look back at what my list is and I really like seeing what your list is cuz we don't show each other our lists at all. So, it's always a surprise what gets left out, what gets added, what do you really like this year. It's it's just super fun to do. I hope you guys enjoy watching it.
Yeah. And thank you so much for watching it. And just a reminder that our Kickstarter, the last week of summer, is finishing on the 20th of September, which is the last day of summer. So, please check it out. The link is at the top of the description. And as usual, please like, subscribe, and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game.