Skip to main content
Loading video...

BGG Top 100 Analysis - Featuring Ben from 'Back of the Shelf'

Transcript 2:22:02

hey everybody and welcome to a rather short notice live stream here today i thought i'd do something a little bit different and go through the board game geek top 100 and give some passing thoughts as we go along and as you can see i'm not by myself here i have somebody joining me uh ben do you want to introduce yourself oh hi i'm ben you want more than that um what do you do with the board game space uh from back of the shelf podcast we've had you on several times dan it's always been a pleasure so i thought i'd return the favor oh thank you so much yeah i've been trying to get ben and some of the other guys from um from the back of the shelf podcast onto the um onto onto a stream or onto my channel but for one reason or other another it's never worked out but finally we managed to get bet on um i said that their podcast is absolutely fantastic it's one of the only uh one of the only kind of board game media that i actually consume and listen to because they take a whole different approach to a lot of the other stuff out there and really focus on kind of old forgotten gems and stuff that you know isn't really talked about nowadays so i think that's a great a great kind of niche that they have and they do a great job great kind of chemistry so if you do like your podcasts definitely give their uh give their show a look really good stuff so let's talk about while we're here today then so as i said we're going to go through the um the board game geek top 100 um give our thoughts about them um you know do we like them have we played them did we do we want to play them and all that kind of thing um i suppose before before we get started i wanted to kind of give a brief overview of thinking you know what what are your thoughts on the uh ranking system as a whole you know do you put much credence

on the bgg top 100 uh no almost none um because i used to a few years ago you know number one that was super important to me have a look at those top tens but uh as time's gone i've realized it's got less and less to do with the quality of the game and more and more to do with popularity word of mouth and kickstarter i think warps it significantly because if you've if you've paid too much money for a kickstarter you're going to be inclined to to to give it a higher score and then also if it's a very limited run only those people who have paid big money for it will have it that's gonna you're not gonna get many negative reviews there so i tend not to pay too much attention to it these days i still quite enjoy it it's nice to see what goes on there yeah absolutely i mean i think that's that's a really good point and if you do you know really analyze why these games are going up there then again reasons that ben are saying that kind of consumer bias buying it rating it accordingly um because you don't want to kind of kid yourself that you've wasted money on the game but i will say that um kind of looking at my favorite games like say my top ten i think eight of them are in the top 100 um and for me that kind of gave me a bit of reality check that maybe there is some some weight behind this list um because i i don't think i get sucked up too much in that kind of thing i i don't think any of those games were kickstarter games um so i don't know maybe there was something to it and i think if a game does get to that popularity or um to that level of success then they've got some kind of winning formula that's you

know are they the best games i don't know but i think this they've got to have something extra i think but we'll talk we'll talk about that as we go along so let's get into the list you ready ben i'm ready okay so let's get started and i'm going to say the first game is an absolute bang and one of the only games that i rate a 10 out of 10 this is trade yet so trader number 100 um so yeah as you can see here this is one of my favorite games of all time and one of one of only three games i think that i rate you turn out um love it stefan feldman carla game point salad ben do you like spelt do you like trojan i've never actually played this i know gerald absolutely loves this game uh so it's definitely on my list of things i want to play uh but yeah i don't know much there was something about i can't remember he's a specific thing he said this is you don't see it that much in these games so yeah really really want to play this one yeah it's one of those games i got many years ago and it just kind of every time i played it my rating went up and up and up and up and now it's just like plateaued at a 10. i said i very rarely give tens away you know rate hundreds and hundreds and hundreds games and only three of them have ten kitchen is one of them so i love it that much and it's definitely my my favorite failed game but do you like any of the failed games or or have you not tried any all right man i'm drawing a blank here step and fail games we'll come across some i thought we will come across a few more okay um definitely a deserved well obviously i think it's deserved to be at the top five but okay okay next up the crypto

at number 99 so for me this was a game that completely destroyed code names for me as soon as i got to crypto i never played code names again i think this one fix it in every way a team versus team word based game as you're trying to give clues but not be too obvious so your opponents can intercept on the words you you secretly have um have you played this one ben i've owned it for a long time and i could never get it to the table i could never quite find that right time i need it's not an entry level game so you need you need then you need seven or eight and i can never get that group going that's that's a good point actually because i i did compare it to codenames i think codenames is a game that gets compared to this one a lot and i will say this is that notch higher um which does add a slight obstacle and kind of gives you that slight hindrance thinking you know am i going to pull this now am i going to lean to a you know to a trusted one that we've played again and again but and for me i think that extra bit of effort is is worth it because of the payoff um i think it's just a bit more a bit more clever but as ben said this one is a bit more um it's not as intuitive as a game like code names but again i think that pays off in the actual gameplay itself but a great party game and i'm not actually surprised it's this high i didn't realize it was um so highly ranked i'm quite surprised it gets a serious buzz yeah yeah i've never really seen that around but i know it pops up everywhere yeah it's kind of like a yeah like a party plus style game okay so something completely different now number eight 98 tigers and euphrates so an absolute

classic rhino canisius game um a game that i would say is massively unique there's nothing else really out there that compares to um turkish new faces apart from yellow and yankee of course um have you played this one band i know this is a bit of a classic um i know i think i think jerry likes this one as well oh he loves this one i have never been able to find this at any sort of reasonable price so no yeah sadly this one has um has gone out of print semi-recently but i'm sure it will work out for it come back um pretty soon i have pretty strict rules about how much i'll pay on games this is one of those that if i see it at anything below my blood giving blood levels and then i'll take it yeah but this is if you want something that's completely different very confrontational um pretty abstract um you know you can map things out quite carefully but there is some decent randomness put into it like just the right amount by drawing tiles and things but again it's a game you really have to play for yourself to understand the nuances and stuff about it but very weird but i think to be unique for that many years i think is great you know 997 release are fantastic okay 97 i love cats now this is a game i haven't tried despite this one being immensely popular probably the last two years or so does this one appeal to you ben or not uh it's um i have tried this but on board game arena it came out it's an alpha i think at the moment so it's not complete it's not polished um i couldn't quite get degrees it's just polynomials fitting them into the into the ship i i put it aside wait for it to be fully released okay didn't grab me

right okay and do you generally like polyominos as a mechanism in general is there any kind of stand up polymer game that you go to uh i should point out i have not looked at the top 100 in quite some time so i'm not sure what's going to come up or not i'd say yes i quite like them uh yeah i don't know yeah let's say yes i do like them okay yeah i know this has kind of been a real influx of these games over the last couple of years and this was one of the ones that really did take off um i've not really looked because i always thought a lot of them were so similar to each other and um yeah none of them hooked me massively but i want to try this one but i probably won't won't pick it up okay 96 russian railroads uh this is a game i haven't tried i don't really know much about it but i will be checking out the ultimate railroads which is coming out this year which is a kind of this one and i think all the expansions in one big box um i think it's a relatively involved euro other than that i don't really know much about it do you know anything about the mechanisms in this one ben or or not uh yeah it's building tracks and moving the trains i've had to go at this um it's really euro really euro uh and not really my cup of tea okay that's interesting um because everything you said you know saying it's really euro that's just um pick my interest it's uh yeah i i can't think of there's any luck in it at all okay it's been a while now but yeah i don't remember it was just very take things put things it was yeah very mechanical

okay cool well that's um to me so um yeah that's my up my optimism for russian railroad so yeah looking forward to the ultimate rail where it's being uh released this year okay no 95 lorenzo ill magnifico so this one another one of my absolute favorite games this has been a top three game of me i think since i've owned it um i think it's got pushed out the top three to number four this year this is a worker placement game an engine building workplace in game where you are essentially taking different cards but based on these workers associated to different colors which are associated to different dice so the strength of those dies changes from round around but everybody's playing with the same strength which i think is a really cool mechanism um does this one appeal to you this this is very euro um but i think it's got that slightly lighter more fun factor to it as well but what do you this does can i talk about other uh um podcasts on here a absolutely too called board game snobs they absolutely love this game and so i have been all again looking for this for a long time this is really hard to find oh okay i didn't realize that actually because i had it such a long time i didn't realize it was hard to get hold of yeah this one yeah this one for me out of all these games by these italian designers this one seems to be one of the ones that's most polarizing so some people really love that dice mechanism which determines the strength of your workers and some people really oversell the randomness of it and for me because everybody's hit with that same randomness it doesn't really feel random if that makes sense um so it's not like

i get shafted and you don't so it's kind of like another contingency you have to overcome but i think it's an amazing game the end of building is so satisfying enjoyable and it's it does that perfect thing where um it really peaks and then the game just ends and i love that that's what makes you come back to our engine builders for me um okay speaking of um polio games 94 patchwork again i'm surprised to see this one's so high because it is that's this is where i think a lot of people have bought it because it's cheap and easy and very accessible and therefore have and have like uh skewed that slightly that's it's okay i played it me and my wife played it ten times and then i said yeah we've seen everything really we can possibly see in this game yeah yeah i get that i think for me actually this this is my highest rated uh rosenberg game i think i generally don't get on with these games too well but this one i think is great in this and uh i haven't played it really much in the last couple of years but before that this was one of my go-to games with with me and my partner as well um very lightweight i love the extra layer of the economy where not only trying to fill in the board but also get that constant income of your of the buttons as well which just just enough gaming us but not too much to turn people off it did lead us on to uh i think it's him if it's not him they're very similar games but there's three that came out um indian summer yeah and the cottage got we we moved on to those and we do quite enjoy those okay what better than patchwork yes yeah oh interesting okay uh much heavier or same kind of level a little

bit more let's say a step up uh there's a little bit more going on but same feel to it it was they're really nice games yeah yeah it's kind of one of those things there's such a saturated um area of gaming there's all those hard placement games that i really didn't know which ones to kind of you know how to swim through and which ones to pick but still patchwork has always stayed in my collection and um yeah didn't really consider getting rid of that one okay 93 rising sun very grandiose eric lang area control game um loads of different things going on um massive production kind of the most spiritual successor to uh blood rage and i suppose prequel to ankh so um ben have you really done a deep dive into eric lang's area control games no he is masculine but at the risk is very controversial i have not heard great things about him i know he's really popular but then the people who i enjoy as reviewers are massive fans of of his games they think there's a lot of the same thing that's it yeah so um rising sun is one if i had any choice of any of them that's probably the last one i would pick there's a couple i would be interested in okay i've only tried this one and blood rage and which also we'll talk about later because i'm pretty sure that's higher up um i actually when this game first came out i was enamored with it i thought it was so great this was maybe three well three years ago now um and there was just kind of like a switch on my head where suddenly i went full euro and i couldn't really play games anymore um but i still really appreciate what it

does it does that cool puerto rico system where you're drafting the ability that you get and everybody else gets a kind of slight worse version of it this one does that quite well especially for like an area control style game um so yeah i think one of my main issues with it was that there's so much kind of added in content that it started to get a bit jarring there were exceptions it started to get a bit bloated and convoluted but i think it's i think it's decent but i certainly have soured on it wow 92 raiders of the north sea so i've not played this one but i think am i right in thinking that the raiders of scythia is exactly the same game and near enough the same game from my understand yeah i i do own this game um again played it three three times and think yeah that was about it really um it's fine it was it was it was an interesting uh we played a fair amount you know work placement used to be ubiquitous this is a slightly different um spin on it it was fun yeah played it played a few times really light it's not not massively uh engaging i'm completely with you there ben um so i've only played the radius of scythia version which again i think is 90 the same and for me it was a bit of a flat line these kind of medium light work replacement games are a bit of an area that i struggle with because i think they're all so similar with one very slightly different thing that differentiates them um and i kind of like the being you know this is the game that does this not this is the

game that's the same thing as everything else but slightly different but it was fine as ben said just quite generic in my opinion yeah painless i was just you know i'm saying yeah okay we played it that great well done so yeah i'm with you i'm with you okay 91 uh this is not really my kind of games i play i'm despite loving lord of the rings this is journeys in middle earth this is the lord of the rings um kind of adventure game that uses app integration i think this is a kind of a sister game to the manchester madness system um have you played manchester madness or this one so my my wife does not like these games so the chances of me playing these are slim um i i would be interested if i could find the right group but no i haven't tried this one now yeah i'm with you so i generally don't play um kind of campaign driven games because i'm very much uh you know pull this one off depend off the off the uh shelf depending on what mood i'm in and i don't really like the commitment that these games kind of demand um so one i'd happily try somebody else's version of but i certainly won't be adding it to to my collection um and the same goes for the next one really um eldritch horror that whole kind of cthulhu um area of gaming it's nothing i've really dived into never really appealed to me um have you dived into the arkham horror eldritch horror kind of umbrella of games uh no i do i don't think i've ever played a cthulhu game which it seems odd now i'm trying to think i don't ever have no

no no i'd strange i think of many i can't think of many that i've played i know there's so many out there um but i know the end these are massively popular obviously being in the top 100 but um and i think this is the i think this is the newer one out of the two i know there's arkham horror and elder torreira i think it's the the kind of newer edition but i could be wrong on that okay 89 alexander fister's first game on the top 100 this is at mombasa so mombasa very fista in his mechanisms kind of hand management playing cards to do different abilities climbing tracks getting shares um kind of expanding your kind of coverage of the main board and investing in these in these companies to multiply your points um i think this game is some of fistus greatest work in my opinion i think this is probably my second favorite game of his um i think it's brilliant um very hard to get hold of now uh have you played this one or or no because i exactly it's really hard to get a hold of uh yeah i passed you by first time never found it god this my whole world's come crashing in here for any of these games i feel terrible i think it's okay because i mean obviously you're aware of them and um you know is fister a kind of designer that you generally like his games um i know no not really no i'm not no that's i can get that i mean despite i generally i generally enjoy his games there's again a few that i like way more than others but he's one of those designers that are generally the medium heavy weight euro and i could see why

people wouldn't like them so they despite me personally like them i i can see why they're not for everybody but for me mombasa is brilliant um dominion uh particularly intrigue um this is kind of one of my gaming gaming confessions actually so this is number 88 i've never played dominion uh one of these games that completely evaded me um just one reason or another when i got into the hobby i i think the game that got me into the hobby was legendary which is the kind of marvel deck builder this one obviously just passed me because i didn't really want two deck builders in my collection so um have you played minion ben or most people so i i played to me right back when it first came out uh i don't know why but i only ever played the start setup i think i'd play with different people and obviously it's their first game i said it was what would play the start so the first the suggested setup and in preparation and i i got really bored of it and i never carried on preparation for dune imperium got out dominion someone brought it we got it out we played this setup as we have standard i remember all this stuff and then we we played a different setup absolutely brilliant like absolutely fantastic the way the different ways to control the cards because the initial one you're just buying cars to make better cards in this second setup you have to sacrifice cars to do ah it was it was fantastic so it's gone right back up my uh estimation this game yeah this is quite an interesting one because obviously it's had so much support over over the years got it i

think so over like 15 expansions or something um and that pure level of variety is kind of like a almost like a hook for me but also a bit of a deterrent because i think my biggest problem with these deck building games is that they get so bloated and then they become cumbersome and then you know what's the optimum way to play them and i suppose that's been the biggest obstacle for me but i actually quite like the idea that this is a pure deck builder because most deck builders now are hybrids have a bit of deck building a bit of something else and i think the more and more i kind of get or play more games i start to appreciate kind of more simplicity or you know more more simple things and so dominion is still one of those nagging itches i want to go and explore and get on with it i massively recommend it that that second setup when it you know you you're playing a game then suddenly things click yeah oh okay everything shifted around uh it was a great moment that was it's great game interesting okay thanks for that 87 trois so tour this is another kind of a polarizing game uh this is as mechanical and dry as it comes you know if you don't like your dry euros then you're probably not going to like 12 but if you do i'm pretty sure that you'll love it so this is a dice driven a game where you're you're kind of using your dice but you can also take other people's dice without their permission but you have to pay them for it and then you're kind of dividing those pips into different actions you can take and you're kind of communally fighting

against these threats as well and for area control bonuses it gets so dry you can almost see the gears turning in this game but a bit like you know we'll talk about dominion this one has so much variability each game is massively different from the others because the different cards to come out um i think this is a brilliant game uh have you dabbled with this one ben or does it appeal i'm guessing not i have dabbled with this online and i i this is one of those games that made me realize that the actual rolling of the dice is quite an important part of some of these games uh and so obviously we didn't do that online so i didn't really click with me but i know gerald absolutely loves it like just raves about this game and i wonder if it's that clinking sound of dice going down waiting for them to come up that plays a large part in him that's that's yeah i think that's a fair point you know that tactility of a game is is massive um and when it's taken away you don't realize how big it is um but what did you feel about the um you know the stealing or say stealing but taking other people's diets without without their consent because i know that rubs a lot of people the wrong way um for me i don't really consider them my dice i see them you have to pay me for them they're not mine to own so i kind of accept that but i know that's kind of one of the sticking points for people uh i like i like interactive so that's things like that i'm awful uh making someone sort of sit up and then i have a little bit yeah i like that stuff so yeah i can see why i would annoy your euro gamer absolutely yeah so normally that kind of thing would would annoy me but for this it just works for me because you do get compensated for it

and i think it's a a great game that stood the test of time you know 11 years old now or 12 years old and i still think it's fantastic 86 big one um in fact this is this is one of the reasons i don't like the btg top 100 is duplicates so this is the third edition of twilight imperium um i'm sure if you're watching this you probably know that the fourth edition is ranked higher um so i think should we should we talk about twilight appearing with with the first one sure yeah but the new suggestion let's move on then uh battlestar galactica so this is one of the we're talking about grail games this one was one of the games that people would search high and low to get a copy of spending hundreds of pounds um a kind of a more involved longer social deduction game um never played this one not really interested in playing a longer social deduction game and especially one themed on battlestar galactica which i don't give a damn about so they just played this one no never never played it no oh there because they knew they they really rethink differently yeah yeah i'm like you putting in an hour two to two hours to suddenly just have it all pulled out from under you i'd find that tricky yeah and i think i think maybe been woven under selling it thanks i think it might be you know three hours or so to play i think i could be wrong on that i've not played it but um yeah if you can't get hold of this one and you didn't know there is a a new cthulhu themed one called um unfathomable i think it's called um if you want to play that one so but it's still interesting to see again with an ip being so i'm

highly revered um okay uh 84 pandemic legacy uh season zero um i've only ever played base game pandemic never played a legacy version kind of one of the reasons for or kind of i mentioned earlier about the journeys of middle earth game i generally don't play campaign games or ones that require longer commitment um have you had much experience or what are your thoughts on legacy games in general and of course pandemic none um the i know that the boys tried playing season one and got through to three or four months i think you have to really really like pandemic to to carry on the whole the whole the season uh i did have some people who did like it but again one of those things that can i ask you to play then 12 games in the foreseeable that's a tricky tricky sound absolutely yeah um yeah that's that'll be near enough impossible to arrange you know for me personally um and to be honest pandemic a game that i could really i would happily never play it again to be honest i've had my time oh yeah i think it's good i think it's objectively a good game but i kind of you know been there done that seen it and not really interested in anything else okay moving on then number 83 kayla's so this is another one of those games this is um i think one of the first worker placement games um that is one of the old dry dusty cutthroat euros and

you know watching this channel you probably know that that's my that's kind of my forte never played kayla's never played the uh newest version either but certainly want to do so um have you had much experience with kayla's ben i have i really like this game uh gerald was really interested i bought it for him um for his birthday i'm not sure if he's playing it yeah or not i this this is um when you look at board games there's a definite era where games were ruthless and you had to play them you also had to play them five six seven eight times before you really thought oh yeah okay i'm getting this down this is probably the prime example of this there are so many things to do um he said cut throat is absolutely cutthroat it's it's extraordinary how mean you can be in this game yeah just devastating yeah we uh really really like this game it's really uh it's you say it's euro i would i would hesitate i think today's definition of euro is quite different to to what this game this game is was quite quite take that ish okay game yeah it's really good okay yeah i definitely want to want to pick the snap in the future um so i don't know why i haven't explained why i haven't because it's normally the kind of games i like from that era especially oh and speaking of a very cutthroat games 82 el grande so el grande another

pretty um in your face every control star game ones that you can you know really again kind of become quite cutthroat your quintessential area majority style game um wolfgang kramer um this is my my favorite game of all time i haven't ranked it on here um because i think i've ranked the big box version but just go to 11 doesn't go up to 11 yeah exactly this game is amazing uh i've never played this uh i tried once online just it wasn't i again it's one of those things that you need to be around the table playing with your friend doing the little castle thing i know that gerald has it we it's one of those games as soon as we see each other if i ever find this at a reasonable price it's gonna be insta buy uh because this this is very top of my wish list yeah again if you i think if you like that kind of cutthroatness um very clever but simple mechanisms um ones that you might not think are so significant at the start like things such as being able only being able to deploy where the king is or around the areas that is like so so important in the game and it's just so dynamic it's kind of tactical with a kind of small thread of strategy it's it's as good as it gets i think for a game that's you know from 1995 is quite fascinating really so i think one of the best games what my favorite game ever made uh 81 talking about midway or mid to lightweight one games architects of the west kingdom so another massively massively um successful and

popular game series um shem phillips design again six here i think that's six just kind of for me just completely just classifies the game it's so it's okay it's just what it is it's fine it has that one different one or two different things that make it different from all the other worker placement games at the same weight weight value um again that's what i think really i know that's pretty unpopular decision or opinion i i i don't understand why they're so popular like raiders was fine and it's like it's just fine it didn't really excite me very much i'm looking at this one i haven't actually played this one because i the radius one was just fine i look at this thing okay fine nothing about it really gets my juices going and yet they're wildly popular yeah i know like scary popular and i think if you if you did take that that kind of impression away from the raiders game that we talked about earlier um then i'm pretty sure that you'll feel the same way about this one um this one just had that different mechanism where if you keep putting the same workers down then you get more resources each time you do it so it kind of has that compounding resource gathering and then you can like arrest workers and send them to jail and stuff so i had that little extra of um you know of interactivity but for me that wasn't enough to take it away from the genericness of the rest of it just like kind of gathering resources buying buildings all that kind of stuff we've seen a thousand times it sounds like he took the idea of working placement put a guide down do a thing and he thought right how can i do this differently oh there's three different ways i can do this there's three different games right there and

let's let's now try and make him you know okay if that's where you want to go and do it i i couldn't sometimes that's that's exactly what's in my opinion what's happened but we'll talk about work replacement games that are key flower um play this one ben because i'll let you take the lead in this one if you have by that reaction i love and i hate this game i i i've never crossed anything like it it's crazy uh it's so tight it's so mean and it's so it's so finely balanced and yet if one foot wrong you're done you're finished there's no there's no coming back from it and being able to put workers down on other people's um little oh man that this i absolutely love this game but if it's going wrong usually you can tell by the by the middle of autumn whether it's gonna it's gonna happen or not and you know i'll play the rest this game and watch you just thrash me yeah i love when it goes well i love this game uh yeah but it goes badly this is an incredible um kind of bidding and working placement game and she said you're crying these towels but then you can bid on the tiles that people are requiring and they get all the meeples on them and the meeples are the currencies so there's constant flow back and forth of all the different meeples and makes people stronger in certain categories oh it's just as good as it gets this is a fantastic game it's extraordinary i can't think of any game like it no no that's a good point i think maybe some of the um kind of again partner games the other richard breese games that kind of yeah change some of the mechanisms but the rest of

it are the same but yeah you're right nothing else has used that hybrid of the bidding and the work placement so seamlessly together it's just and your work is being used for both of those using them to bid but also because you don't want to bid too many because you want those workers to produce resources so clever great yeah and even not being a certain color yourself you know you've got all the colors and they're not yours they're just one of the currencies fantastic yeah um okay number 79 tainted grail full of avalon these games some games like this generally i just won't even take a second look at massive campaign-driven games loads of purple basking things and maybe i'm underselling it i don't know um because i know obviously they're very popular have you dabbled in these style games or not no no i'm like you i look at this there's no way i'm playing this game uh just just the groups i'm in this wouldn't wouldn't want to play them i am genuinely generally fascinated to know who plays them because i just i've never met anyone who owns anything like this well i'd be curious yeah i think from a personal level i i actually like my personal life i think i'm with you but you see a lot of the you know the the content big content makers these these are the kind of games yeah okay in the spotlight these are always the ones you know what's the next 100 hour campaign game with a hundred you know 100 miniatures 500 hours of gameplay or i i don't understand how they're finding the time to get these to the table get them completed um because to me they all look the same at a glance but you know maybe that's just being ignorant but i don't know

not for me 78 a game that certainly isn't me grand austria hotel so another great dice driven euro with a really cool theme actually this is probably one of my one of the only uh games where i think theme helps massively and i'm not i'm not a thematic gamer i don't really care i'm very much a mechanisms man but i think for me the theme of this game really does sell it to people and whoever i've played it with um even if they don't really like euros they normally think you know granddaughter hotel is one exception to that and this is one that i would certainly think could extend that drawbridge out to people who are turned off euros into into enjoying them um any thoughts on this one ben you've played it i know gerald loves it he sends me photos of the board the little cubes on and i'm like you know that's that it's not it's not this is this is like the modern type of euro which i'm not i don't really enjoy that much okay fair enough uh yeah i mean i never played this game with somebody who hasn't enjoyed it but i don't know i'd recommend giving it a go because it's not terribly long you know it's going to be it's a two-player game which is actually the optimal play account in it's definitely my radar it looks like that meaty meaty game um yeah if it pops up if you know if it was put in front of me i'd play it but i wouldn't i don't know if i'd actively seek it out okay fair enough i think it's brilliant that is uh granddaughter 78.

so dominant species um okay this is uh another very cutthroat area control star game that i absolutely detested so this is have you played this one no the boys have and they have very funny thoughts about it they said it was fascinating but not really a game right okay so yeah this this is a weird game and it's one of those games that i can kind of appreciate what they're trying to do because you have this kind of work placement part and that will get activated in like chronological order so you can kind of you know almost program all the actions that are going to happen but that creates so many variables where all the housekeeping is just painful because basically all these different hexes that consist of the map you're always kind of um kind of manipulating to suit your species and hurt other people's species and any kind of action you you can do can kind of cascade um out and affect everything else and it's constant housekeeping constant bookkeeping and for me it was just all work no fun at all um and i'm surprised so many people love this one because i i really couldn't find the fun in it um but you know i suppose each one's you know everyone's got their own taste but would you try it or oh not interested i i don't know if i would they said it was in it was like i don't know if they would play it again um i'd have to ask them they said it was interesting it was very interesting maybe not not so much fun yeah i can't

think of anything else that really does that same mechanism um but yeah it felt like work and i would i wouldn't play again three hours as well not great okay 76 another massive pop-up game i suppose that's a bit of a mute point but this is uh loads of water deep dungeons and dragons medium light worker placement game um i'm assuming you played spend this seems to be a lot of people's kind of first year in gaming are getting this one to the table is that the case uh this was not my first game uh i played this a few years after it's uh when was it yeah a fuse after it did not did not hit the spot for me it's just i guess i guess i went into it a little um because i spoke when we said to people they said you can't call them purple cubes and orange cubes you gotta call them the robes and the wizards i don't even know what those things are you know which one's the purple key what's what is this the wizard okay i'll have five so yeah i just didn't really float it's just moving cubes around to buy cards just didn't didn't vote for me yeah this one um again as a generic worker placement game as it gets but it does what it does quite well i think and i do like the fact that you can build buildings own them and then other people can use them and you get a benefit from that i think that's a cool mechanism that's been used great in other things particularly um key flower does it does it better but this one was for me this was a great kind of drawbridge into bridging that gap into the more heavier um worker placement game so i will say as a true gateway you know welcoming game

this one did do a good job but this one over there has fallen for me quite drastically and again i've got no real reason to go back to it because there are so many better ones out there now um 75 agriculture um agricola game i haven't played um and to be honest out of all the uber rusev games again i've mentioned earlier i've never found one that's really hit the spot for me and so that's really made apprehensive to try anymore to be honest um any experience with this one or cover another um no no way um i know david hates this game i absolutely hates this game uh yeah so when he says that yeah i know that's not for me at all did he say why or i just said it was work it was just work just yeah that's yeah that's that's a lot of the impression i get from a lot of his games best um i just really struggle to extract the fun out of them and it's pretty weird because you think on paper they sound really great but in practice no certainly four five tribes now this this is this is a weird one actually because i think objectively this is a good design um bruno cafala design another designer actually who um who i've really struggled to to find his gem or this game for me this is like a man carla style game you have this big grid of tiles and meeples on those tiles then you're moving them kind of picking up a whole cluster of these meatballs dropping them off one at a time and then taking the action where you land um depending on the meeple color quite an interesting mechanism i

do have some quite distinct problems with it um any thoughts on this one ben uh no i i i have i was interested because it was the raging hotness you know when it came out yeah but it's i heard at least two or three people say this is quite prone this is quite susceptible to analysis paralysis and i've always been cursed with not curious i shouldn't say curse i've always been blessed with um gaming groups who have at least one who who struggles with that and i can't stand i can't stand analysis promises so they when they say this is no that's just don't even look at it so that that is my experience i've played this a few times um that's semi-true so my problem with this game is that it could be a so ap prone if you want to play to that level but for me it's always really obvious about the obvious move to take you know there's one good move on the table so player order is so so important and that obvious move you're always going to take it because i suppose people would argue that you don't always take the obvious move because you could be leaving opportunities to other players but that from that it creates so many variables you know variables within variables within variables thousands of different combinations that there is no way you're going to go through that thought process and work things out and it just ended up feeling work and then you just take up take the uh take the obvious move and go from there but i probably haven't explained that well but um one thing i did like about this game was the fact that you actually did full turn order that was my favorite thing about it but the rest of it i could certainly um you know certainly take it or leave

it okay 73 seven wonders um another another kind of gateway plus level drafting game this was one that really kind of put drafting on the map um supports big play accounts you're building these wonders you know increasing your military science all that kind of thing so a very again gateway plus level almost like a sieve building game based on drafting cards works really well for what it is um see i've rated it fairly low here um i did play this many years ago i haven't paid it probably in about five years um maybe i'd appreciate it more nowadays if i played it and maybe that 5.5 is a bit a bit harsh um but it's okay i wasn't really blown away really like really like this game really like this game um uh this was this was one of those games you know i was there when this was this came out and this changed everything right this just i was blown away by it it was it was incredible so yeah i really really love this game yeah i know i'm certainly in the minority um of this and i said i think i think if i played it now i might appreciate it more because at the time i was kind of um i think i'm starting to get into more heavy games and that maybe some of the again more streamlined games um started to the beauty of them start to get a bit lost on me um but i would certainly try again um and there is another version which may come up a bit later

uh okay number 72. uh this is voyages of marco polo so another game from the italian designers um another dice driven worker placement game um i think this game is great i think out of all of of all of them um this kind of midway worker placement games this is one that's really distinct um love the way they use the dice in this one love the fact you get these unique player powers that are pretty game breaking um i actually prefer the second version of this one um for me it kind of merged together it was a bit more harmonious in its design but i think it's a great game um played this from ben or interested yeah i did i don't it didn't i don't know why i didn't like it so much i think mainly because we absolutely i don't know if it's going to come up further up the thing we absolutely love uh alien frontiers which is the same idea right warner dies put them down somewhere and i don't know why this didn't click so well with me but yeah i i think we tried it once once or twice yeah not my thing really okay fair enough yeah i say this is probably maybe a level higher than alien frontiers um oh you wound me sir you wound me no i don't mean i don't mean like um i mean you know i mean it is weight kind of category um but hey i think it's really good but again i i rate this one i think i wrote the second one on eight and a half i think they're really good design so very well-rounded games 71 okay i've ever diced driven euro so if you don't know dice driven euros are really kind of my my jam i love those

style games um and this is another one by the by the same designer or co-designer marco polo i'm daniel tashini at this one tayto khan city of gods big rondelle game um massive cascading um cascading kind of combos and things um you get this which triggers this which is this climbing tracks all that good stuff um from from other other games you've said ben um or opinions on the other games that have similarities this does this one people i people i like really like this game and listen to what they say i think you have to have a very specific group if i could find that group i'd be really interested in trying this yeah yeah i think it is certainly um on the heavier end of the medium category um i think maybe most people would even consider it heavy um it's one of those games it's one of those games i feel like you have to play two or three different games with different mechanisms to get you ready for this this sort of game yeah i think that's yeah i think that's fair yeah and it's some of the um some of the bookkeeping as well is is a bit it's a bit clunky or like just the the way that the turns play out so you do this and then that will kind of upgrade your dice which let you climb a track which let you do this and you reset this and sometimes you can get a bit lost in that and forget what you've done what you haven't done um but i think the overall payoff warrants it because the game play itself is that good as you're building this big kind of almost like

it's pyramid really like a like a well a south american pyramid are you trying to match up symbols and things i think it's a really good game and um well one of my favorites really uh 70 uh clank a deck building adventure so this is the fantasy version of clank um which is kind of a pushy like deck builder i played the space one um which i think is pretty much comparable i felt very flatlined for me didn't really interest me um wasn't well i hated the artwork hated everything about it really um not interested at all and um yeah completely flat-lined any experience with these ones uh it was mildly on my radar i knew that some people had enjoyed it and then i played julie imperium his his latest one suddenly it's very interesting this if i ever see this because okay yeah we'll talk about that later on but i'm very interested in trying to find this okay cool um is it the same designer as i didn't realize it was the same design yes i think so yes i'm pretty sure yeah okay interesting um just go through a couple of comments um ashley thanks for joining us ashley um glad to have you here and i'm sure you've been with marco polo um what about the second one yeah i think um you might have joined just just as i said the second one i think is even better than the first one so maybe a matter of time before it starts overtaking it but if you like it a little bit looser and a bit more synergize with each other i think the second's better the first one's a bit tighter um but i think a bit more jarring in terms of the two parts of the game

um and she's also said that you need to have the right people for a game of clank yeah so maybe i'm not one of those right people okay let's crack on then at number 69 okay so this is robinson crusoe adventures on the cursed island so this is um co-op pretty heavy co-op almost survival game that when i first got into hobby i was massively um this appealed to me massively and as time gone on um i've just lost all interest in this one no real desire to play this from the tour to be honest uh any thoughts like what have you heard about this one ben i do remember this this has always been you know i might have been in gaming as long as you have and this was always there as the one just yeah people say how difficult it is to beat and you never win and yeah it sounds that sounds miserable so yeah i i find is this i can't think of the designer is this this is not vlada fatal is it i don't know i don't i don't think so no okay maybe i've got that wrong um okay so yeah one that just didn't really isn't really my cup of tea at 68 race for the galaxy uh this is a a kind of a hand management tableau building game um with probably some of the worst iconography um initial initial rules dump that i've ever played in my life one of the hardest games to uh understand um have you played this one bear now or does it appeal yeah yeah i like this

game this is this is my this is my stuff i do like it um people revere this as maybe one of the best examples of this game i don't know if i've got that phone but i do really like this game yeah this is but i've never had to explain the rules and i think i wonder if that would change uh my perception yeah yeah so this yeah this is a weird one because i think maybe objectively the the um the rating deserves more um because i really do appreciate the design um loads of combos some clever card play again uses that puerto rico system where you pick a role everybody gets to follow it one of my favorite mechanisms um but some of the symbology all the contrasting things really did put me off and i thought because i played games so kind of big gaps in between them that relearning this after playing it after a while was just a big turn off for me so yeah that's one of the reasons why it's a six and not not any higher um and actually yeah thank you for reminding me it's ignacy trevor sheck yeah thank you um okay let's crack on then weird another uve rosenberg game um i haven't played this one fields of all i think this is a i think this is a two player only one um do you know what difference just differentiates this one from the others no i don't i have i have been i've been trying to keep an eye out for it uh really hard to find this one okay

there was something about it i again someone who who i like i can't remember who was i i tend to you know watch lots of reviews and if i think if i hear someone say this is good when i put on a list somewhere this has been on the list for a while people quite like this one yeah yeah i know it is popular amongst those who who enjoy his games um it's considered one of his one of his better ones um okay talking about the west kingdom number 67 paladins of the west kingdom and i will say out of all of them this one is the one that i think potentially could um could be more for my tastes um one of the one of the things i really took away from this one was that it looked or instantly reminded me of early on um about this kind of placing workers on the board and triggering things um i think it's the heaviest of the three um i could be wrong on that as well but um still yet to find my the shen phillip games that i really enjoy but does this one appeal any more or less than the others to you ben or no no i i did they look they look cool right they're super super popular but yeah since no i'm not really interested in those okay fair enough um 65 aeons and i will say i don't really know anything about this game at all do you know anything about it neither do i how is that what is this game um i don't know why maybe it's the name so may just defend humanity's last city harnessing alien powers to destroy monstrosities yeah that doesn't sound like my cup of tea so i think moving i've actually never heard of this game how is it

that's weird okay moving swiftly on then uh 64 as well um another one of the pioneering deck building games or no i think small rope battling card game is it um android netrunner no knowledge of this game whatsoever did this one capture you at all when it was big at the time i think it's out i did it did i bought it i tried reading the rule i tried getting people into it it's just dense

i know for a fact that people got really really into it became it became almost a way of life game uh and so i was i was quite interested in that you know get quite quite excited uh but yeah i just couldn't couldn't get in there couldn't get much that's the impression i got as well was that this is again a really lifestyle game people who love it it's pretty much the only game they play so yeah android netrunner um ashley um i think she's um spread some light on or shed some light on aeon's end so it's a co-op deck builder but you don't shuffle your deck okay interesting i kind of like that mechanism a lot of games use that when you've got to play things in certain order um okay interesting um okay something completely different crocodile dexterity game um i think it's kind of like a is it like a bowls mechanism trying to get things closer to the middle i don't know how it plays uh yeah there's a there's a hole in the middle and the the um bullseye is getting in the middle but yeah it's it's about getting it close and yeah it's great this great game it's a huge huge table presence it's massive yeah yeah they are obviously quite luxury items for the look at these these boards very much so yeah um but i'd have to try it but normally these kind of things are i've won and done for me like i play them happy i played them and then no real incentive to go back to play again i'd say it's great it's um i've never seen them or haven't seen

many in britain i've seen loads in north america where they have one lots of space so they can have it set up or have it somewhere and they have cabins and this is this is very much a cabin they'll have those out the woods somewhere so you know quiet saturday afternoon they're banging this around it's great for that yeah interesting what your thoughts on this from being on the you know board game top 100 do you think it's fitting that's a great question i don't know it depends it's a great game i really enjoy it it's fantastic it's massively accessible uh you know anyone can play it age no barrier it's a it's a great game uh is it a board game yeah it just seems funny that we go through all these games and all of a sudden there's there's this it just doesn't seem to fit but i suppose i haven't played it and i suppose we you know we talk about all other things that are you know little little dexterity games so i suppose this one fits the same category um and mackenzie from side game thanks for joining us mckenzie um says it reminds him of classical or classic parlor games like billiards yeah it kind of gives off that in my impression yeah yeah exactly um and silver age um silva saw a silver coin age of monster hunters um thanks for joining us i'm glad to have you here okay and oh here we go as well from um from side games saying the majority of negative reviews for crocodile are people saying it's not really a board game but i

suppose again why why would this not be a board game when something like um what's called like ice cores is it's just that's true that's true yeah yeah i don't know okay 62. um i think we'll move on because there is a newer version of it further up that's um through the ages the first i'm having a philosophical exponential crisis here is it bulgaria is like paul is poker a board game i suppose i think it would be yeah okay uh 61 liz boa so vital asserta very heavy euros game designer extremely involved complex mechanism with a mechanism style games i haven't tried this one i've only ever played one of his that's not true kind of one and a half of his games um so i played the gallerist and i'm not sure that's higher up or not and and um mercado de las boer which is kind of one mechanism from this boa um so i can't really testify if this is good or not i know this is one of his most popular ones have you played any vitality games i have uh not this one okay so again popular amongst his his fans so i can't really comment because i don't really know how the game works functionally uh 60 quacks of querdlenberg so this one's kind of shot up in the last couple of years what this is 60.

i hated this game this was so i did not like this game why was that okay well gerald gerald thinks it's because the guy who was explaining we played it in um the uk games expo and gerald is is adamant it was because the guy didn't really explain it properly i just sat there and just pulled thing put things in bag putting it it's just i was i did not enjoy it at all it just it was poor really boy i did not i was really interested in this game because you know it's one it's an award winner really popular no never straight off the wishlist bend it so funny if i have a complete polar opposite reaction to you so this one was i got some this one to the table way after a lot of people did it already got that kind of massive peak of popularity everyone talking about it everyone playing it i had still yet to do so um we went to a games night got some to the table had it taught me and i had an absolute blast it was an instant hit for me and i kind of haven't looked back since so i don't know i really like it but i tend to like these kind of pushy like style games anyway but there we go um just go to a few comments um so silver coin saying uh fun fact that android netrunner is the most expensive game in this car i know i think that one's again completely not being supported anymore and uh i don't know is it like a is it like a collectible game or is it like a like a preset deck thing i think you you can buy um expansion packs for it yeah to change things up what like um like more like a living card game it's

i think one of his strengths was that the decks were so unique and they played with each other so in such unique ways that each expansion pack was basically a different style of playing as you could buy a thing to to change the way you're going to play uh i know the initial ones were interesting themselves that the first two in the box which were genuinely odd you could you could mess with each other's decks and it was really like an aggressive deck building sort of two-player thing uh and that's why i could never get it going uh but yeah they they released quite a few things for it yeah okay and i think this is obviously talking about um liz bower i'm actually saying it's his sec her second favorite um vital lucerda game so interesting to see if your favorite will um come up okay let's move on then so that was 60 quacks of credible very light game doing obviously doing extremely well and being a big hit for uh wolfgang wash uh number 59 eclipse um normally sci-fi games are an instant turn off me i don't really have many of them in my collection at all um and this is another example of that i don't know what it is i assume it's a 4x style game um i haven't played it i played this one i know the boy on um i come with his name he loved twilight imperium on the dice tower and he absolutely despised this game sam the skinhead guy uh he absolutely hated this game so that put me off

but now eclipse two's come out and it's just raving reviews now i'm very interested again okay no problem oh yeah so nothing's right on that one azul okay that's all another one 5.5 yeah this one was this one really fell flat for me and that that done every bad one i've seen so far has come up in september 2020 was it just a bad month so yeah maybe maybe i think that was when i regraded all my um all my ratings but this one i think it's fine i think it's fine and generally as a rule i love um michael keising i think he's a brilliant designer this one i think was a victim of hype so this one was so built up i played this one way after everybody else did and it couldn't live up to that hype um i think it's fine no real interest in it i haven't played any of the sequels but obviously you feel different than i do oh i i um yeah i really like this game really like this game um even when you go past the sort of yeah obviously this easy game might take the tiles but when you've played a few more games together and started getting a bit more uh juicy with each other yeah it's still good if you get the right level of player really good yeah okay fair enough um just got a couple of comments here um richard thank you for joining us richard he said he wonder wonder for a while uh whether the the server games have been on my top

list um you think you've hit well for me um if i try a few more um and mercado is this moment it's not a real destroyer game yeah i completely agree with that last comment um yeah for some reason i've played one of his games which i think is higher up in the list and that was um really not a hit for me at all um i think it might be in a big part because the teach just didn't land and uh yeah it was a bit too much for me at the time and oh talking about that game number 57 the gallerist um another vitality game about running an art gallery um is this one of the ones you played then or not no no i think i may have made a misspoke here a second i've got the designer wrong i wonder if i've ever played actually one of his games okay so this one yeah this is a game where you are basically running an art gallery you're trying to kind of increase the popularity of some artists and um i kind of forget everything but this this is i probably played this about five five six years ago um i had a terrible teacher this one um it went on for far too long i think the teacher didn't really have a clue what they were doing and that rubbed off on on us as well um but i think this was the kind of traumatic event that really disturbed me off uh the title of soda games so yeah unfortunately i've rated it at five but i would try this one again to see if it did it would change but i just remember not enjoying that experience at all um number 56 another time yeah which um i haven't tried so i can't comment on that one uh 55 okay lahave um this is um i think

one of the better ubi rosenbergs that i play uh played a game that really does shower you in resources um but this one i have really struggled with the whole feeding your worker thing it felt like most of the game i was just feeding feeding feeding feeding and it just didn't land um have you played this one ben or is this one of the frozen bugs you like no i haven't i'm sick this is one of those that comes and goes into my consciousness uh this was tom vassell's number one that's right a couple years ago um yeah i don't know it's sometimes i'm interested sometimes i'm not if if i'm leaning more towards a sort of euro we style this climbs onto my onto my radar it's not at the moment i'll be honest yeah i i did i do recall thinking it was a good design but yeah it just felt like i'd never really had enough opportunity to do what i wanted to do and was forced to do the whole feeding thing which seems to be one of the kind of talking points of a lot of his games um a couple of comments here um voiter i don't sorry for pronounce your name wrong i'm saying uh for his all he thinks summer pavilion the third one is uh more gamey of the three um have you dived into any of the others ben or just just the original we we have the second one the um stained glass window yes it's not it's not great i think i like my wife quite likes it but it's not the first one was super simple that's its magic and the nice little pieces the stained glass window they look like boiled sweets it's not that's not the same uh so we're

sort of yeah we're thinking about the third one whether to go for it or not now we are thanks very much peter um star trek thanks for joining us i'm saying everyone and that he likes us all as well so this is awesome okay let's crack on them so that was uh 55 la have um 54 star wars imperial assault i think this is a miniatures skirmish game um i think you can probably think what the rules are like for the game like that am i right are you a star wars fan bear no i'm not playing i love i love i could talk about star wars we could scrap this like it's two hours to where star wars this game uh i did not like this game um we bought it it was four of us all star wars fanatics uh and it's not a cheap game that's why the four was brought together and started with trying to do the app we use the app it's an app you can use the app as this sort of i guess you call the gm garbage just the worst we spent a good half of the time trying to decide what the uh ai was trying to make us do like this stormtrooper moves there and he doesn't move there so bad and then another guy said why be interested in playing so i went to become gm uh and so i was laying out and i i'm very much balls to the wall this is star wars it's gonna be super exciting i'm just gonna throw stuff let's be really quick uh and again fifty percent of time was spent working out can you know does this line of sight work here does that work there

this guy's gonna move three spaces and then he's gonna go poop it was so bad i really really didn't like it um and this as just probably the only the only time since then that i have considered looking at a sort of dungeon crawlery game uh is gloomhaven because it's it gets as far as it can work out gets away from all of that uh i'd be really interested in that but yeah this game no no no sad to hear as well when when you say you're such a big fan of the ip you probably really wanted to like this game and that's the most deflating experience when when it's not that good i'm very much a sort of slow gradual builder but um yes gm i had darth vader on the table in the second mission so what what and they were and then and the heroes were only 20 feet away well so darth vader is going to force chalky wall because he's the best jedi ever you know they run away as this is what is going on here okay it wasn't for 53 mechs and minions so pretty big programming style game um don't know how this one plays never really took my fancy um know much about this one ben or not david loves it absolutely loves it uh it goes crazy for it uh i've never tried it and i'm not i'm not a really it's like a tunnel fighter thing isn't it you're sending sending minions down the tunnel right now yeah i know it's um really applauded for its

production to production value to cost ratio um i think it's like a like a multi-billion dollar company who published it um okay 52 clans of caledonia um this one was a bit of a disappointment for me um very kind of a farming style game that uses a lot of the mechanisms made famous in terra mystica um i really want it's like this one um as you put some stuff on the on the table and you can get kind of upgrades and things um this one another example of just flatlining for me it really didn't have its peaks and lulls it was just very very boring i thought but despite that it was a well designed game but i just didn't really find it terribly fun um this is this is one of those this is one of those if you like this sort of game this is your jam like terra mystica that's your jam this is not my jam at all not at all yeah if you don't like that those games yeah you would you would not um okay 51 this is a game that consistently i hear people rave about pax premier second edition so this is kind of a historical area control style game but quite a minimum have you played the pax games not played a single one i i've played perfurian that's my that's the one i've played quite a lot of uh i would if these are gay i would hesitate to call them games they are they are more like

role-playing experiences they're extraordinary pad for freewriting extraordinary game the the level of detail on you know phil eklund has some issues uh i think is um widely publicized but what he does with just a deck of cards and cubes is ridiculous i i don't know how his brain works because the the packs games are astonishing there's this one and um pax renaissance i really want to try those games but i'd be really cautious about trying to get people to play them because i they are very heavy very unique should we say right interesting i think i think this is another example of me wanting to try this one but probably not picking up myself um 50 seventh continent this was really the hot game about again five years ago when this came out um massively massively um expansive game where you're exploring into new tiles and things um kind of uh almost like a point-and-click adventure style game that's got hundreds of hours of gameplay um i think we've said before ben these kind of longer commitment games aren't normally our jam um is this one an exception to that or is it is it the same i know no i actually had a bit of a argument with someone on on facebook around about the time this came out i think they were spending a thousand dollars on this game that is crazy yeah yeah that's nuts but back when that was you

know that's when you could spend 25 or 30 on a full game thousand dollars was a lot of money yeah that's that's mad okay so yeah i mean really ambitious design and one that i kind of give give credit to because i love it when people try new things and kind of uh unbounded by their kind of imagination but not my style of game um kingdom death monster um another game i know nothing about it's kind of fits that other category i can't remember the game that came up earlier that we said we kind of these games come up we look the other way i think this is another example of that um i think more of a lifestyle game i think people who love this one of the only games they play i know um mckenzie from side games is a fan of this one um is this one any different from all the others for you then or is it just another one you know you're talking about these ones at the seventh the one was um tainted grail and i think of all of them this one if someone if we had a few beers and you know down somewhere and um someone slapped us on the table and said right we're gonna i'll be yeah okay yeah i'll give it a swing i wouldn't own it it's not something i would try and teach and bring to the table oh okay i was always got the impression that king of death monster was a massively heavy game but i could be wrong on that i think i i think i think it's involved i think it's important yeah okay um ashley's saying that she's never played that but she's got townsfolk tussle in the mail the other day um and supposedly they're quite similar i don't i don't know if they are or not i know i know mckenzie oh this is

this is actually i know ashley actually has a lot of games actually as well again so yeah okay that's uh yeah that's probably true okay cool all right 48 power grid one of the old classic euros we're talking about earlier with the game like kayla's this one is another very mathematical economical cutthroat style game about auctioning for these kind of power stations and increasing your presence on the board but almost mapping things out to the to the nth degree um i think this game is so different and one that really does hold up well um very dry very you know not gonna really draw a lot of people in if this isn't your your forte but i don't know i think i think people could have a lot of fun with this one um even if they didn't think they could but any interest uh this was one of the this is this is seared into my mind this game uh because after katan you know you play katana oh my god what's going on here uh i went and did a bit of research and found this one uh and so bought this and tried to read the rules and just bounced off so hard it just could not get my head around what was going on uh and i just sold it on so yeah it was not uh didn't go down with me and i've never tried it since okay i would recommend that you do so um i think it's it does hold up really well for a game that came out again 16 17 years ago i think it's a brilliant game so uh that's that power grid still regarded as one of if not the best freedom and freeze game who a designer i really like actually

um another game from the italian design is simone luciani and danielle cheney this is salkin the mayan calendar believe it or not this was actually the first ever worker placement game that i played and it's still probably my favorite of that genre um what a game this is brilliant pretty simple game on the face of it collecting resources building buildings i'm getting points different ways climbing tracks but this gear mechanism where the longer you leave things on the board the bigger rewards you get and bigger payouts you get fantastic unexplored mechanism i think this game is fantastic i think gerald has this and he's saving it saving it for a special day okay i think you'll like it because um yeah mechanically literally mechanically with gears in this game um it's as good as it gets just brilliant um a whole new element of time and the worker placement is just it's just epic uh 46 an acronym um don't know much about this one other than what mackenzie's told me um david turtle game is i think it's his highest rated game um minecraft design um pretty full on i think uses this kind of lone system that's supposed to replicate this time travel um yeah i'd be really interested i know the ballgame snobs love this game uh i'd be really interested and understand how the time travel thing works but yeah i can't you can't find this game this is insanely rare yeah well i think um i think they might be able to get a hold of it on a kind of a kickstarter pledge manager ah okay yeah um but i

didn't realize it was that hard to get hold of either um but i want to try it want to try it um and hopefully in the near future i will i'm actually saying that she loves the gear um mechanic insulting as well yeah it's absolutely brilliant and completely uh unreplicated so yeah love it uh number 45 underwater cities um engine building galore building a building a city underwater um constantly getting cars to increase your engine make yourself more efficient get abilities that nobody else has cards galore everything all over your table this is a very sprawling game but ultra satisfying game this one really was a home run for me um again more more worker placement but this new idea of mixing worker placement with hand management is when you go to a certain spot you could pair that with a card and then get both benefits that for me was really fascinating and um thoughts uh his games i've never played this one i'm actually i'm actually looking through his list of games right now all of the games that he's done i'm really interested in and yeah i haven't tried any of them uh the last will that's what i've been trying for a long time uh and there was pulsar 2849 yeah i i really would like to try this game so never have got around to it yeah funny you say that actually um then so this year was when i first well actually prager was the first game i tried of his which was actually his most recent one um and well apart from messina which came out this year or last year now um the um that really did was the catalyst for

me to go back and try his back catalogue so i tried pulsar i tried underwater cities and they're all like not in eight and a half nines out of ten she's that brilliant so i think um if you like this style of games they're kind of i don't know they're kind of like quite dynamic euro games i think i think you bound to like it but hey uh richard says he don't like david turtle games as a rule but anachrony was like actually great interesting um interesting comment there because again i'm somewhat hot and cold on uh on taxi designs as well okay 44 barrage um yeah this game was utterly blew me away this is absolutely outstanding um nothing else like this do you know much about this one oh yes i know this game the the snobs love this game and i think gerald has also just got this game davido jack remember so yeah uh i'm really excited to try this as well yeah this this is kind of a throwback to those older euros um i think what i love about this game is the fact that all despite being relatively heavy heavy um all the actual mechanisms aren't really what takes your or what kind of takes you away from the game you really are focusing on that current board state and reacting to it and the mechanisms just kind of facilitate that so it really is about again building dams and collecting these water to harvest it into into power but then building higher up the mounting and spending more to cut people off and trapping the water before it gets to the other players just such an innovative design and um

just what as good as it gets me perfect 10. um adore it um amy said oh my god after ashley oh my god of ten yeah so one of the only three um but she says it is too mean for her yeah it is pretty mean but i suppose if you get in the mindset before the game starts you know this is going to get nasty let's just accept it then uh you can enjoy barrage uh ah so because barrage was selling at esther next to their stand so yeah great and hopefully yeah you had a successful uh mention let's crack on then so uh at number 43 the crew quest for planet nine um this one blew up a couple years ago uh have you tried this one and are you a fan of trick taking or not i absolutely love trick taking games i've bought this but again i want to i want to get the right group together because we want to sit through and do i've read the rules i want to i want to get them i want to generally hate trick taking games and i don't like people didn't like it i thought people just electric taking games uh so i need to find the right little group of people i think i might have but they they like heavier games and i just try and edge this in slightly so i'm i'm trying to plan out when to get this going but yeah i'm i am very much looking forward to this game i'm shocked by the five yeah um for me this is a game i appreciate but in practice i don't really enjoy it that much it's quite to be honest

trick taking is a whole kind of category games i don't doesn't really gel with me i don't really quite understand it or understand the nuances of it um maybe i'm just too stupid for it i don't know but i don't i don't think it's all it's made out to be again another game i appreciate but not quite for me i know my brother absolutely adores this game um but i think everybody else kind of struggles to to appreciate it but maybe it's just not a right fit for our group um 42 pandemic legacy season two so we already talked about season zero um again i think we've said that we've not tried any of the legacy games and i'm lukewarm at best on pandemic um so haven't tried this one um manchester madness second edition um we talked about journeys of middle east not my cup of tea again and i was streaming the same for you ben you said another thing if i had a group that said oh i want to i want to try role-playing games all i've played so far is board games this is probably the one i would pick up and say right let's just try this first and see how we go with that sort of more interactive narrative sort of going along so it's always been on my sort of radar but i've never had that group yet yeah that's a good point actually um i know the app's supposed to be absolutely fantastic and i think that's what some of the um puzzles are supposed to be good as well so maybe a good hybrid of again that storytelling and some puzzliness as well uh 40 eclipse second dawn for the galaxy

oh okay this is i assume is the the sequel to eclipse again i didn't realize this one shot up so quickly 2020 game already at number 40. um impressive to say the least but don't think about it shut up and sit down glowing about it so i think that has a has an effect okay okay yeah yeah seems to be the case um 39 too many bones this is kind of a more involved dice driven game i think this is quite rules hey one that i'd like to try actually again i know mckenzie likes this one um but i can't really see it fitting in my shelf very well and i know if i got this i'd never really bring it off but you do you tend to like more involved games using dice as a mechanism is that kind of randomized uh no no i don't um nothing like this really if i was gonna i think this is like it's like a a miniatures game um i i thought it was just pure dust like tons and tons of dice but i don't know it might be miniatures i'm not sure i'm sure someone in the chat will know maybe i think of rum and bones i can't remember oh yeah that's the yeah that's that's more of a miniature pirate fighting one yeah ah okay okay yeah uh 38 maracaibo this is by far my favorite sister game this one for me is a real kind of kitchen sink of mechanisms and kind of takes all the it's almost like a frankenstein's monster of all those other games it takes a bit of this from um a bit of this from mombasa a bit of this from great western trail and so on

um and i think it just works together brilliantly um what a brilliant game climbing tracks as you expect multi multi-use cards so you know you've got manage your hand am i going to use it for the ability am i going to use it to cash into the quests um almost like a rondelle system as well you're traveling from port to port which dictates the speed of the game this one again is a kitchen sink style game that i can never really see myself getting bored of i like it that much um brilliant game uh this is on my radar slightly because of all the controversy that it attracted so i i never really went for it okay i don't know what the controversy was oh really uh there was a strong um colonial imperialism miasma around it so i never really took much notice oh there's plenty of other games that use that but uh okay number 37 marvel champions at the card game so this is the living card game um well kind of like the next in this series of living card games there there's the arkham one there's the lord of the rings one i think there's even a game of thrones one have you tried any of those systems or or not no no this is this is not my sort of thing yeah um funny enough these these are actually games that um that i think are really good so i've only ever played the lord of the rings one kind of and i think mechanically again fantastic game but the problem

with it is that you need to constantly start increasing your collection keep buying new missions and buying new characters and stuff and for me that is a big turn off now but objectively i think the design is fantastic just not quite right for my for my collection because i won't play with the same people or get invested in it but i think if you like solo games these are really good options um because they're pretty deep loads of variability and just generally well well well-designed games um 36 we already talked about agricola i think i talked about a different edition of it or something um it's there again yeah i don't know i don't even know what the difference is between this one and the other one we talked about uh okay 35 wow i'm very surprised to see this one this high um 2020 release lost ruins of our knack now this one is a strange one because i know we we talked about a lot of these almost mid weight worker placement games feeling you know falling flat for me this one is pretty much in that category um however it did merge the deck building part of the party as well quite well with that worker placement and um this one was surprisingly good and it plays very succinctly has a great kind of forward momentum where i think it's only like four rounds or something first round you feel like you're not doing much at all fourth round you're getting a ton of things done um so i thought it's actually a pretty good game and i can see why this is popular 35 best game of all time popular i don't think so but obviously um obviously i'm in the minority but any interest in this one or have you

played it uh i have because i bought it for my friend for his birthday uh because there is um he's just getting into games and i i i mean literally within a last since i've known him i don't think he really played before so i'm sort of experimenting with lots of things uh he really likes the mechanisms in some other games so i go on this one and we've we're gonna we're gonna get it to the table i'm sure i'll be ahead i can't really see people disliking this one because it's just a pleasant game certainly doesn't outstate it's welcome um some uranus with climbing tracks and things um the multi-use car thing works well again the deck building's just enough i think it's a very well-rounded game and i can see why it's been popular uh just going to some comments so silver coin's saying that the um the too many bones uses chips so i think it's a chip furry game okay rob yeah okay and he also said that maracaibo uses already proven mechanisms um and similar well constructed as arnak yeah

yeah so um yeah exactly taking things that already have proven to work um and ashley is talking about agricola saying in the minority here that really dislikes agricola and he found it quite boring she found it quite boring yeah um i'm not paid it but that's generally how i feel about most uber rosenberg games unfortunately uh number 34 blood rage oh massively popular in your face area majority style game with a viking theme um sixes might sound bad but for me these sixes are just above average so um i'm quite harsh on my rating so don't take that as a negative i think this is a good game i had a good fun with it um i think the thing i didn't like about it was the the combat resolution where you're just playing cards from your hand kind of high number wins thing that feels a bit abrupt to me but the rest i liked the idea of maps being destroyed and different strategies you can take upgrading your clan but the rest of it was just okay um did you say you tried this one or not no i haven't i have not tried to know and it this would be you know if someone said which games you want to try of eric lang's it's actually godfather the ones that i really want to try okay this is this would be i'll give a go this but no godfather is what i really want to go at yeah godfather was okay i actually that's quite a bit um better than i thought it would be actually uh okay so that's some blood rage massively popular game um again i'm in the minority there uh 33 caverna the k farmers so this is

basically almost like a companion game to agricola um however this is widely considered as being a bit more forgiving and being able to achieve more than you can in agriculture so i think out of the both of them this is certainly the one that i would pick up when i when i eventually do because i do want to try them because i think they they've reached that level of kind of critical acclaim where i need to at least give it the benefit of that and give it a go to make my own opinion of it and this is the one that i'd rather try um out of the two would you rather lean towards this one or would you want the really hard version of agricola no no this this is if they forced me to place another yeah this would be the one i've heard yeah i've heard decently good things about this one whereas not not so much about a curriculum yeah okay yeah i'm the same um and silver coin saying he actually prefers rising sun to um to blood rage i'm completely with you i love the combat system in uh in rising sun um oh ashley's also saying that she preferred rising sun so maybe rising sun is more popular than we realize but there we go okay so cracking on then to number 32 or food chain magnate okay oh this is a this is a game that really did um not impress me and not not because of the game design so the game design is actually pretty good it's actually very good this is as cutthroat as it gets you know we've talked about cutthroat games i've never played the game more cutthroat than this um before i go any further have you played this one man or do you know how no no i've never i've never been part of a group that would

that we've built up to this though right okay so this one um if you if you can ever get shocked on a game this is it you know you need to have the right teacher so we we had somebody teach us the game um and then all of a sudden within the first turn they've taken a strategy that's shut everybody else off and you've got no way of recovering um you can you know you can be out this game in the first ten percent of the game and have no way of catching up um and this is the teacher the teacher did that yeah yeah dad dan you don't play with those people you take those they're not like regular they cut out of your life yeah i don't i can't remember who it was it was from some random convention or something oh they're the worst yeah and that really did make me salty on this one you need to be on a loving level playing field with who you're playing this with um if you've got a bunch of mates just chilling out exploring the game together then it's going to be great but if you have that disparity in somebody who's inexperienced playing with someone who is experienced then you've got zero chance of winning this game um some really cool mechanisms in it um as you are kind of getting these milestones if you're the first to do something you can get something unique to you that nobody else can have and they've only got like a very short time frame to get that i really did like that graphic design and stuff is i really don't like and again this one did leave a bad taste in my heart because of my actual experience of it but hey i'll probably give this another go you know with the right group maybe it would increase a bit but it was just a bad bad experience

31 more clank this is clank legacy acquisitions incorporated incorporated i had no idea that this was um i didn't know it was a legacy version of it yeah i knew this was this was out there but i thought this was just lingering somewhere in the i know 3000 or something i didn't realize it was i saw i saw the word quiet i got really excited for a second now so yeah yeah um i don't know or maybe obviously does the whole legacy thing quite well um and obviously crank is popular so they've got a winning formula there that's a coin that says uh food chain magnate gets a four because they are right down not quite um silver coin um yeah i did i didn't like the um the ability that your game could be over in the first 10 of it okay number 30 um absolutely brilliant game i think one of the highest ranked games over the the eons of um of board game geek this is puerto rico um this is for me one of the one of the definitive euro games one of the classics great interactive um games you're picking roles um getting a better version of that role but everybody else gets a follow-up action um that's not quite as good but they still can get use out of that uh have you managed to get this onto the table ben yes thoughts that's all that's all i'll say well uh this is this is i do believe you can separate the gaming world into people who like this game and people who don't like this game and that will tell you

quite a lot about the sort of game that that person's gonna like from from then on sort of thing if you like this euro games are going to be your your thing uh if you don't like this there are a whole world of euro games you probably just shouldn't even look at uh yeah it's just i i played it it was fine i can't say i particularly enjoyed it i mean i played a few times and each time you know okay i'm not i you know you you say highly interactive i would consider this not very interactive it's not you just sort of choose a role okay you're fine and it's very much um sort of totaled along didn't really okay not my game not my game okay but i say interactive because this game although isn't such direct interaction i think the it's got a slightly different layer of interaction than a lot of other games do you know where you've got to really consider about the position that other people are in to know when's the right time to pick a certain role um so that's that's why i say it's interactive that you've got to consider about what where the current player's current situation is um i i think it's a wonderful game um i i get a bit miffed at times or a bit confused at times when people really put a massive emphasis on the kind of puerto rico sharks saying that if they'll deliberately sit next to certain people so that they can take advantage of them and stuff like that um i i just saw that as a part of the game and not a negative but that was just my impressions of it oh no this is this is the sort of game where i

would have random seating like you are gonna be assigned we're gonna we're gonna roll dice or do something to to organize seating because yeah it's too easy to if you've got the if you have the correct people in your right and your left your game to be very different to if it was some other way you know yeah that's a it's just a little bit too much for me yeah i get it that's absolutely true but yeah fair enough uh 29 everdale another medium light kind of work placement engine builder little tableau building game very gorgeous to look at i mean this is one of the standout looking games absolutely beautiful um i thought it was fine family weight generic decent nothing really else to say thoughts like this one not like it um i know david absolutely loved this game uh but as time's gone on i think yeah like you i think maybe my interest wouldn't be you know initially i'm really interested in it but then it's it seems like one of those again one of those medium to lightweight um my daughter's just getting into gateway games i told you before she's getting into gateway games so this this would be maybe in a year or two maybe think about that sort of thing um but yeah at the moment yeah it's just it's very light looks yeah this one this one took off massively yeah major knights um gain no interest in whatsoever i am interested in this because this was this was it it is a dungeon crawler but as far as

i can work out it's extremely unique in the way it does things uh and i am very interested in it i've never had a chance to to find it it's just it's i've never really seen it yeah um i've heard that the rules minutiae in this game is paralyzed massively um yeah very hard rules to get in your head constant exceptions always referring back to the rule book and that's normally a bit of a bit of a turn off for me now 27 a game without much um exceptions this is um early on um a bag building style game which kind of mixed with worker placement as you're adding these tokens to your bag drawing them out randomly i suppose and then allocate them to your board and then choosing when to trigger them to climb tracks to increase your ability to do things make things more cheaper more efficient build buildings for yourself um this game is brilliant i've had this in my collection for many years um still love it um i would say if there's ever anything that needs an expansion to make it great like a good takes a good game to make it absolutely brilliant um then it's early on with the trade and intrigue expansion um i know you say you're not a massive fan of these kind of dry euros but this one i think has that extra layer of fun or fun that it can offer and i've never really had a bad game of this one um have you played it or does it appeal to you you know it's been on my list for a long long long time and it never comes up i tend to sorry i should point out i say it again again i tend not to buy games

brand new i buy them second hand so i'm usually at the whim of the second hand market this guy never comes up which is a sure saying that it's uh pretty popular yeah that's a good yeah good observation yeah i never really see this game coming up second hand um but yeah it's a fantastic one and a bit like i mentioned earlier grand austria hotel there's a few games that i would use as um kind of you know if you don't like euros or you you've had a previous bad experience for euros give this one a go because i think you could like it 26 root um a game i'm fascinated by never played it certainly one that i really do want to try but probably again not not one that's right from my collection but if i if i knew somebody who had this one i would be more than more than keen to try it um experience this one ben so gerald was okay with it david absolutely despises this game oh okay uh and i i bought it on a steam cell because i was gonna play online with a few few of the guys uh and as soon as i started playing it this is the war game this is this is a it's one of those card sort of card driven um just a little war game thing and i think if you go in thinking it's gonna be something else yeah that would drive you nuts i think that's what happened with david uh yeah as soon as i started this is this is just war game uh it looked really cool uh but i think there are if this is your jam there are loads of war games out there which do the same thing yeah um yeah specifically does a bit of a good job of disarming you and misleading

you what the game is about i suppose but yeah oh yeah well it looks it doesn't look like a war game really does it but as soon as you start oh yeah this is easy but yeah one that i really i'd love to try it but the idea of teaching everyone a different game before you get played yeah that's that's a massive turn off you'd have to have you'd have to have four people who have read the rules and not required to teach it yeah yeah um just comment there from silver coins and it's a war game dressed up so people have the wrong idea yeah exactly um it it is a it's good if people are overrated exactly what you said yeah because otherwise there's too much going on yeah fair enough okay viticulture another one of my guilty confessions really never played viticulture never really had the urge to because i've heard that the there's some significant randomness in some of these event cards or stuff that come out and that was just a bit of a death mail for me never really interested in playing it i love love this game absolutely love this game uh that card thing is true but that's where i am i like having a little bit of randomness in my game i'm not arguing about the cards i mean i'm at the point now i've played the game enough that i could i would probably take out cards i think that's too overpowered uh and just i'm just putting them away um and if and if you want more cards then then build the buildings to get more cards and get more you know there is a way to do it it's like um i would say it's not quite han you know

deckability hand management because there isn't there is it is a bit more random lucky than that but it's yeah it's in the same sort of realm i absolutely love this game this is i consider one of one of the best okay interesting that's that's kind of yeah people interest a bit more because we have the exact same opinion on some of those other again mid or midweight worker placements whereas this one again i generally hear people love it and maybe my concerns are not warranted so yeah viticulture number 25 24 arkham korra just paused we just could just pause a second uh peter just points out that the viticulture based game is great it is great but with a tuskegee expansion it is outstanding and he's absolutely correct tuscany the funny thing about viticulture it's been through three or four editions and each one is significantly different uh and i would say now finally if you were to take if you would consider viticulture as with the tuskegee expansion oh yeah absolutely brilliant game yeah i've heard that one is an essential expansion so yeah i'd obviously try it with with that um yeah i want to try it i want to try it but again maybe someone else's copy okay 24 arkham horror the card game so this is basically another version or another themed of the marvel champions game um i believe it's the same designers same company everything um so we kind of covered that we haven't played them or i've paid a lot of the rings one and good for what they are but not quite my

jam now 23 wingspan um ben you want to take the lead on this one have you i've never played it uh but it's definitely approaching because uh again like everdell i think this is gonna be perfect for um she's eight she's just getting into things you know she can play ticket to ride this will be the next step up from from from those games so yeah it's definitely my radar yeah it's it's good for what it is um certainly hyped to to the nth degree now you know massively uh maybe blown out proportion i definitely don't think it's the 23rd best game of all time um but we were talking at the start of the show about winning formulas beautiful production um you know lovely theme that's going to be welcoming to a lot of people um it just seemed to again get that recipe just right for it for a big hit and that's kind of really led the let the fold for a lot of other these nature style games to come out and follow and try capitalize on the success but for a for a mid to lightweight engine building game it does what it does pretty well and um i enjoyed my plays a bit but didn't really see it sticking around i think i think for us withered souls dan this is yeah but i am genuinely shocked how many people this game has got into into the hobby more than i've ever seen ticket to ride and the i people you know people that i used to you know your facebook friends whatever will suddenly take photos and it's wingspan i'm like my god

when when did this happen you know are you bored yeah this is this is a huge um this is responsible for a massive number of my friends getting into board games yeah brilliant that's really good to know that this is a good game as well so it's again they've got that perfect recipe of being a good game and not gonna do the hobby of the service and still be um you know still be massively popular so brilliant for you know full props 22 moreuve a feast for odin so this one is a strange game so one that is massively sprawling um options galore almost the complete polar opposite of what you'd think a worker placement game would be because there's so many options at all times um for me that was the kind of problem with it i did like it it was never going to be my one of my favorites because i think this game could have benefited from a good edit a good portion of the game being taken out of it um i know a lot of people like that kind of sandboxing nature of it for me it wasn't really a positive for the game um i thought it was fine but yeah i was never going to be amongst my favorites um out of the uvs is this one that appeals or or not uh no i i have seen this it looks borderline overwhelming like i think about trying to teach this game it's just right i i can imagine it's sitting if i bought it would sit in my shelf and then oh yeah one day i'll get down and i'll have the spare you know 90 minutes to go

through all this stuff so yeah i just i don't know if i have that space in my life yeah that's that's fair i mean it is certainly an intimidating game lows you know massive table hog tons of resources um tons of worker placement spots but despite that i it's actually not that bad to teach but because the game is so wide but i don't think it's terribly deep i really don't think the um you know the the synergies and the all the way through different parts of the game did it merge with each other as well as what they would have liked it's more just kind of like a a buffet of options rather than having a really you know well synergized game but you know again that's probably controversial people love that one uh number 21 june imperium so you mentioned this one earlier ben so i don't know much about it so take the lead i love this game i i cannot i i was lucky enough uh dave and trevor bought it for my birthday got delivered here in the czech republic uh it was that it was quite difficult to get it absolutely love this game i am just enthralled uh it's just extraordinary i love i love the june universe you know i was reading them i've read it i'm one of those fools who've read the entire series two or three times uh so i was ready i'm already buying but when we're playing and i'm getting all the people all this there's guinea harlock and there's the overlook of this princess ireland no one no one cares i just absolutely love it and the systems that play it's them putting the workers down trying to

explain the game isn't too difficult because you only start with two workers i'm like don't worry they they will they will you'll get it as you go on because you're gonna we're gonna put two down and we're working explain this i've explained it to new players uh two or three times now and just for a game that has that sort of interactivity depth the the the pleasant systems everything's working nicely it is quite easy to teach uh i i this is hands down one of my favorite games of all time a brilliant level high praise um i've heard it's rather nasty quite take that ish is that the case or not now no because and and i know i am cautious about conflict games because i'm one of those i'm one of those people that dislikes the games where if a fights b then c is gonna wipe the floor because they've exhausted themselves yeah dune handles it differently in that you can always see what what troops you can add troops to your barracks but you you can add troops slowly there's an area where you have the fight it's a battlefield i would guess you can add troops you can take them you can take them away and you'll always have troops in your barracks we might not have them and you're gonna do this ten times so it's not it's not devastating if you lose it's not the end of the world you still can get back in it next game no this is one of the best ways i've ever seen uh that sort of conflicts it's exciting as

well that the conflict is super exciting just this is the i love this game it's absolutely brilliant well there you go can't get better praise than that yeah no no uh 20 brass lancashire um not played this edition of brass i've only played birmingham which spoiler i think is higher on the list um so i'll say my thoughts to that one any any experience with the brass series i've never played these games now okay we'll move on then we'll talk about brass a bit later concordia okay so this may i always say that this is um i think from a design standpoint objectively one of the best games i've made i don't know any improvement that could be made on this game i think it's marvellous um yeah this is a kind of a card driven game if you're taking actions by playing them um but having to once you play those cards they're discarded but you have to pay another card to pick them all back up and you incentivize to play through all your other cards love the interaction in this game where getting somewhere faster it's going to be more profitable because it's going to cost other people more money for doing so and also getting resources can help other people as well so i like this positive layer or level of interaction in this game i think i think it's fantastic one of my favorite games ever concordia i'm judging by that side then ben is this one that's not for you i suspect i had the same experience as you did with um uh what was it the food chain magnet right because this is one of the first games we we'd all moved i moved abroad we all

moved to the same building and we're just getting to know each other and that's all board games and this guy brought this and we went around and played it with him and he did the same thing kind of showed the rules and then just hammered us i just i had this and since he he turned around and said over a few weeks he got much better at understanding you know what's acceptable and these sorts of things uh but yeah since that first experience i just did just didn't i was like ah this is not uh not my thing it was okay it was fine i i feel like i should like it because that that card thing of having to spend a two and three because i really like that that yeah that's such a such a tension in your in your decision making uh but yeah this yeah i've never played it since and um yeah it's hard to come back it was yeah okay so we briefly touched this earlier number 18 terra mystica very euro um upgrade style gamers you have your you know your player board with all your pieces on them and you're putting them on the board and when you put them on the board you're kind of unlocking abilities more income for yourself as the game goes on climbing tracks um terraforming the land so that you can inhabit it and build your buildings on and all that kind of euro goodness i played this one for the first time this year i thought it was fantastic i'm really looking forward to playing more of it um tons of kind of asymmetrical powers depending on which faction you are um but hey i can this is one that can see is not for everybody we talked about clans of caledonia earlier um

i think again if you like one you'll probably like the other but weirdly enough i really like this one but i wasn't so keen on caledonia but did you play this one or uh yeah and not not at all not for me gerald absolutely loves it and he's tried so hard to get us to play it you know now yeah a man actually said yeah gaia project is better for teremiska for me and i think i think the masses that's coming up yeah i think it's coming up um so we'll touch on that a little bit later um okay so that's that's uh terra mystica uh number 17 nemesis so this is kind of like the unofficial alien game i think it's got the hidden traitor thing that was kind of made popular by games such as dead of winter another game of massive miniatures um other than that don't know too much about it um not normally the kind of games to play very you know more american style mechanisms um does this one appeal to you ben you know more kind of no if if i was going to play aliens on a spaceship uh maybe space hulk not okay cool um yeah 17th best game of all time uh people go wild for it though so i don't know if it's uh yeah this is this this is one of those i think kickstarter has a has a undue effect on it because this was huge wasn't it yeah this is probably the quintessential example of that kickstarter um bias i suppose before yeah that's nemesis yeah can't really comment on that one number 16 though and we

talked about seven wonders earlier seven wonders duel this is the two player version of it um still similar mechanisms but you're drafting from a common supply from this kind of like pyramid system where you're picking things up and potentially revealing cards underneath it which means there's more options to draft um i think this game is great um been one of the big hits for me this last year surprisingly enough actually because i wasn't such a massive fan of the original but i love the different options this game has a lot of game in a you know 30 to 45 minute experience and i'm constantly enjoying it so any any preference of this one other than the the original one or not oh a number of players you come in i'd be happy to play i consider someone just borderline genius that that tension of two like take that card so he turns over uh and the so the um the follow-on turns for the wonders become essential because if you if you cannot risk turning that card over in case you know if something bad is on the other side yeah such that i i think that's one of the one of the most most genius experiences i came out of nowhere as well i've never really think something like it yeah i absolutely love this game yeah utterly to be honest and i can see this from climbing even more um at least in my personal rankings stefan feld i think this is the here we go i think this is the second stefan feld game since yeah it's trajan at number 100. so this is the castle of burgundy by far his most popular game at

least in terms of you know popularity near sales etc um another dice driven euro tar placement game um combos galore all that kind of stuff i love this game i think it's brilliant um not not looker and that's coming from me who likes that kind of style of look but um like this game is fantastic strikes a great balance between being fun but still being euro and um i think it's great do you enjoy that one or not ben i uh i consider this this comes from a time when games were play tested to the nth degree because like you say it strikes that like if you were to explain the game you roll some dice then you get to pick some chips and then you can move them from here to here then sounds so dull they're so boring but in in effect it's so perfectly balanced that that constant decision make do i do i spend the dice on this or that or just fabulous and it could have been it could have been too much and it ended up been a disaster or it could have been too little and just been a sort of it's absolutely perfect so you can clearly see it's been designed and designed gone through iteration after iteration operation to get it just like this yeah that's a really good point actually because it does such a great job at using those dice to keep you on a little bit of a of a track but with the option to divert a bit with those mitigation tokens but if you don't have them then you're doing what the game tells you what to do and that just

keeps the game ticking along so nicely but even if you get shafted by that luck you feel like it's your fault because you haven't got those workers in your supply brilliant game absolutely love it even if you describe it you think all the things uh it must be overwhelming number of things what they call a point silence oh you won't keep track of but it's so easy it's just such a there are so many things going on but it's such a narrow like i say keep it like a narrow trap yeah this is yeah fantastic game and just comment there about seven wonders joel saying it's better with the pantheon expansion because you can actually pause and not take cards which is a really beautiful option to take at the time yeah um i really like that expansion i don't think it's essential but i think it's a welcome addition um okay then so we're getting up to two hours i was trying to speed up the last uh last view here um so we got we got psi this was a game that was the this was the talking point you know 2016 this was the game on everybody's lips and i played this one way after everybody else and i thought it was pretty damn good great game with fast turns engine building um hybrid american euro mechanisms um i liked it and i didn't think i would um enjoy that one or not ben no i intensely dislike this game i don't know why i do know why i remember i had such a visceral reaction to it and everyone being so so very positive about it and i and i went i said i can understand what's good first of all i remember this was the

this was the um this set the tone for how to build hyperbaric game because i remember when the cover came up for this i was blown away like i was just i cannot wait for this game to come out this is everything a board game should be giant stonkey you know it looks absolutely brilliant and they drip fed out as this was this was when was it 2016 just the this was the birth of the hype train as far as i can remember this is this is the one uh and i played it i was like what the hell is this like there's no you go what i want so the mech's gonna fight and then no they're not gonna fight they're not gonna fight okay all right so we're not fighting okay it was um so bizarre i think i went in with very different expectations um and then and i came out and i tried again the second time and the second time and i don't know you know this is a while ago five years ago but i came out and i read something about how people react to luck and how if luck is imposed on you like in at the start of the second game aside one of the guys got the perfect combination of starting position and faction is that doesn't make sense yes um and so that was luck that i couldn't do anything about it there's got that where as opposed to like you say burgundy you roll the dice and then you can try and do something with it right which makes both well i could say supreme that look i could do nothing about what

he what he got there and he just steamrolled us and he he said this is this is all like this is what i'm going to do i remember i remember him also looking around at everyone's board saying well next thing you have to do that because that's what you can do what is this i absolutely hated that game and i will never play that game again there you go i think i think if i ever got to play at that level i would instantly get turned off like you said but i've always played this game with people who um at the same level as me don't really have a clue what we're doing we just wing it so i didn't really know enough detail to know who was at the advantage so it would have been you know it would have gone over my head i suppose uh okay number 13 twilight struggle um this was actually i think a former number one on on board game geek um it was yeah i never played this one one i'd love to try um but again i think it's this is one way you want to have the same person to play again and again with to get the most out of it and i don't think i hit the same game to the table enough times to get the most out of it so that's probably why i've held back on that one the mechanism where you play a card so the mechanism you you have actions on top of the card and then an effect at the bottom of the card and you can use the actions but your opponent might be able to use the effect that's my favorite mechanism hands down i absolutely love it that constant uh i really want the actions but then this thing is going to be really good for you ah i absolutely love that that is so i i absolutely adore this game brilliant do you think people get can get a lot out of it from um you know the first couple of plays or does it really reward those repeat plays together you know to get the peek out of

it i think it's there's enough there that you would recognize things so you would recognize the vietnam war you would recognize the space race you would recognize uh these various things from history and when they turn up on cars that's quite a happy feeling uh and then you try and play them and you see how history sort of and it moves from ear to ear just like the cold war so initially was in europe then it was in southeast asia then it was south america and it was in africa and it moves around the board uh it's just it's such an enjoyable ride to go along with it um i don't know if i ever played a win you know it's it's i really just enjoyed that that playing against each other you know seeing what happens uh yeah this is a fabulous game interesting yeah i'd love to try it but i haven't done uh 12. great western trail um definitely fister's most popular game i'm gonna rate this from seven i think it's good um i think it definitely lives in the shadow of of maracaibo i prefer maracaibo so much more than this one um so maybe that was the order i played it in because i did play maracaibo first and then when i got great western trail to the table i thought well this is just not as good as maracaibo and i also think mumbas is better so for that reason i i get it at seven um i didn't really have the instead to go back and explore it more because i like these other games that much more but this is one of the most popular euro games out there um did you try this one ben or not no no no no no not yet okay um 11 spirit island uh this one was probably one of the

hardest games i've ever had to rate because the game design itself is so unbelievably clever and good as you have these asymmetrical spirits trying to fight off these kind of invaders and use these powers but you're working together and things trigger in different times and stuff um i am so bad at this game um the whole the whole timing thing just completely melts my brain um maybe that part of my brain doesn't get exercise very often but really appreciate it generally i don't love co-op games um ironically for a cop game this one i prefer to play solo which i'm not a solo gamer at all um but it's a brilliant design but i do worry that it's not for me um if that makes sense um but any interest in this one um oh yeah yeah this has been on my radar for a long time and you never find this game okay well i might have a copy coming up for sale soon if you want it oh hello hello i'll make a special offer mates if you like co-op games um or even like solo it's as good as it gets really i cannot criticize the design it's so so clever you're pushing things around and manipulating the board's state some are really defensive spirits some are really aggressive as you're blasting these people away it's so dynamic and really puzzly but that whole time thing slow powers and fast powers is mind-blowing um but yeah great game uh moving on then so i think we are getting into the top ten

ten more of the ring second edition um this isn't really just a sign of me changing my mind over time i also love this game now i read it at six i think it's a probably the best lord of the rings game um but just not my style of kind of dice rolling combat and that kind of thing it's really cool ideas i think there's a lot of rules bloat in this game it could have been streamlined more some of it isn't very intuitive but the overall epicness of the game really does shine through um any interest to get that out absolutely um but i think i think you have to have a very specific opponent who's happy to go and i yeah i don't really play many two-player games that's the issue uh yeah so yeah i would i would love to do it you know just never never got around to it yeah if you have that kind of big event game you know you've got somebody who's equally as passionate you know wants to get it played you're both enthusiastic you've got the time no time restraints sink your teeth into it and enjoy yourself um how's that really cool system where you got cards with events on them and cards that you can use in battle but in order to use it you're going to have to sacrifice the other power which is really cool kind of suggests that um you know twilight imperium yeah um so yeah has some really cool ideas but i thought a lot of these kind of cards event cards were so circumstantial that they never really pulled off but a really ambitious design okay number nine through the ages a new

story of civilization so this is the second edition of through the ages another massively ambitious game civilization style game as you are going through again the angles of time increasing your technology your culture getting new leaders going into new lands and increasing your kind of capacity to do things loads going on in this game very heavy very involved but again another game if you've got the right group this is a really good one but i always found this one just sat on my shelf because we never had that right group um a guy explained this to me we sat down at about midday on a saturday and by hop us one we were ready to get started uh what is going on uh so i went away we played them we then played for about an hour and i think one of us had to leave so we only got halfway maybe through the first round um but we enjoyed the feel of it so much and he said oh we'll do it again so i went i went away and read the rules and we never go to the table again and it's because it's a beast as well and massive so i started playing it on uh board game arena hands down this is the game i've played the most on that thing i absolutely love this game it is mesmerizing i'm terrible at it i i don't understand how people can can play it and get the just and yeah i still go back because because i absolutely love this game it's such a bizarre this it's so funny to try and now i've played a few times it looks so easy

you're trying to explain to someone yeah yeah quite dense game yeah yeah i love this game definitely great the latter plays it feels like completely different than your first game for that massive intake of rules it's a lot to overcome but worth it i think definitely um definitely worth it okay number eight um star wars rebellion played this game a long long time ago um again i'm not massive star wars by myself um as a star wars fan yourself have you tried this one because this is considered the you know yeah i know i have only played many to play games this is no this is a no i would love to though yeah i i mean if you like the ip i'm sure you'll like it this is a big kind of cat and mouse style game obviously one person's the the rebels one's the empire you're trying to go on this big kind of campaign and find out where they are lots of back and forth um another epic game in scope it's almost like the the war of the ring bit in the star wars universe and that kind of that kind of feel and magnitude but not my style of game um but i did appreciate it despite not you know not being my tastes uh number seven gaia project so this is we talked about terra mystica this is the sci-fi version of it i know there's supposed to be a lot of improved mechanisms i don't know what they are um i've had them explain to me but not knowing it is is different so can't really comment i like terroristica i assume if you like one you like the other um but there we go would you try this one despite not liking terror mystica ben it would take some serious persuasion

okay no worries uh number six gloomhaven jewels of the lion okay so this is a game i really wanted to try for a long time because i've heard it was obviously a dungeon crawler um and it has some surprising euro twist on it um first off have you tried any of the green havens yet no i'm i am i'm saving myself like this i am usually i'll have a little look i want this to be full on no spoilers for these games at all not even the systems so i'm trying to avoid everything everything about them so it's fresh i will leave it at that then i think everybody knows how good of haven plays i won't go into any details and spell it for you um so there we go moving on five twilight imperium fourth edition so the second twilight imperium on the top 100 this is i suppose one of the grandest scope games out there a massive kind of space um well everything to do with space you've got battles you've got setting up planets um increasing tech trees all this kind of stuff this game has it really again another kitchen sink style game er kind of got some combat dice rolling and stuff um have you played this one or not no i i am this is when me joel and dave get together next time this is the one i think we may even be organizing a weekend in a cabin somewhere just to play this game this is gerald's number

one of all time interesting so yeah this one for me is uh weirdly enough you know this is like the polar opposite of games i normally go for space sci-fi normally i know um you know dice chucking mechanisms generally a no but despite that this is one i'm really glad i've got to play and certainly one of those games i think everybody should try at least once because it is a hell of an experience to take it away um my the thing i really like most about this game is the kind of politics side of it so you can kind of like pass laws and stuff and like vote against things and some of them are really fun and dynamic and change the game a lot um loads going on here again more like kind of a mirror thrashy style game which is it's not like i say but if you like those style games you like sci-fi games then you're gonna absolutely love twilight imperium okay number four terraforming mars another confession never played it um have you played this one or also or not because i thought would be better if you take the lead if that if you have played it i have played this game that's not not for me yes it was um i think an engine first of all the way it's been produced is an absolute disgrace this is the worst uh uh i know that people say they love this game so much they prepared to pay to upgrade components i wouldn't know where you'd stop you would have to upgrade everything it's just i've never seen a game so bad and this was 2016 this is when things were being

pumped out supremely high quality yeah it was so bad um the game itself it was okay i it was again i just felt like move a cube here move a cube there i i've generally baffled i've played this three or four times i i think if you're a euro gamer this is fabulous okay um because i know that there are obviously it's number four right and i know my friends the people i was playing with thought it was the bee's knees but i was like yeah yeah that's not it's not really not my thing i kind of think that i probably would like it but i worry that i've got games in my collection well particularly underwater cities which is often compared to this one i don't think there'll be room for both um so definitely what i want to try to see i hear the um is it aries i'm not sure if it's like a mini standard expansion or a reprint it's supposed to be significantly better um yeah from top from from start to finish just just better yeah fair enough um yeah i would like to type because there's not many people all generally people i trust as well say this game is absolutely brilliant but yeah just for some reason i haven't really had that massive incentive to try it it's it's one that i think what am i doing wrong i i just you just have to accept that it's just not for you it's that this this exactly it's like the marvel cinema yes like just not for me it's just not my thing and i i'm happy that you're happy

but i'm just out yeah fair enough that's terrifying mars number four number three birmingham so yeah brass birmingham a game that i got to tape with the first time in 2020 um this game is is magnificent um totally lived up to the hype for me um these kind of economic style games have really kind of come to the to the forefront of my tastes um this year uh this is it's surprisingly light in its in its rules as you are basically trying to just upgrade buildings by shifting resources off them and you do that through some quite clever route building as you are kind of have this supply and demand thing as you're trying to connect your different i think it's like coal and stuff to the to the market um you can use other people's resources so this is kind of um passive interaction i've got some interesting card plays you use these cards for the locations and for the type of buildings you're putting down as well um a lot going on here some a lot a lot of depth that maybe isn't first apparent it definitely does take a few games to wrap your head around the again the the sophistication of the game but it's a wonderful game certainly a game that's going to stand the test of time but again and again and again it's always going to feel different because some good route building gorgeous production and i think this game is definitely um one of the best and um again i've really scratched the surface with it i've i don't know i don't consider myself a good player of it but when i know i'm kind of hooked and want to get better at it that's normally a good sign of a good game but

do you want it's martin wallace yeah i would i really like martin wallace i always find him he was hurt he always has i always feel like he's one small step away from the perfect game and i'm i suspect that this might be the one i'm looking for uh so yeah i'd really really like to play this one it's it's is am i correct in saying brass lancashire was the original and then this is the kind of updated slightly improved version that's right yeah so i think okay i think one of the changes were that it has this other resource called beer in it or beer and you put it on out certain ports and yeah i i never played the original so i can't compare them but from what i've heard that's the uh that's the difference but i think i think it's minimal um but the game's great again it was it's hyped up to the masses and uh and it's still when a game lives up to hype it's normally a good sign so i would recommend it uh number two pandemic legacy season one so all three of the legacy games are in the top 100 suppose the same comments apply to this one than the other ones so um yeah no real interest to try this one as time's gone on my interest has gone down and down and down not willing to commit to that many games especially not of pandemic so um this is the game i'd love to understand how the algorithm works behind it's like how does it get this high does that have that many people played it like for example terraforming mars i imagine a great many more people

have played terraform mars than pandemic season one because season one such a difficult sell right you got to sit down for 12 games of this before you can say if you can really you know experience it whereas one or two games terraform miles you've done so how does that how does that work yeah this is one of those i'm like this is a yeah but to be honest everybody i've ever heard like unanimously whoever's played pandemic legacy season one says it's outstanding um yeah but i suppose if you like pandemic you're gonna you're gonna love it but yeah i'm just not willing to play it that many times well there we go pandemic legacy season one but no longer the number one it was number one for a couple of years i think but now number one everybody knows gloomhaven that's the the main one there so i've talked about jaws of the lion which is kind of like a way to hold your hands through the rules i suppose the rules explanation and gloomhaven is the is the kind of main course really um loads of content in there a dungeon crawler i don't want to go into details because um i'm looking forward to playing it without any spoilers or any even a you know mechanical spoiler um so well i can i could i i think because of so i look at this top 100 i i hadn't looked at before and i'm going through this thing it is it is heavy in the euros so clearly uh if you are a euro style person you're probably more inclined to come on to board game geek and and and fill these things in right and i suspect the glue haven has hit that sweet spot

between it's a euro at its heart it's a euro game but it has all kinds of theme splashed all over it so you sort of feel a little bit rock and roll if you're a euro gamer you're going for this sort of thing i i suspect it's hit that that little sweet spot there i'm really excited to try it because i don't like dungeon crawlers a descent an imperial assault but i like the idea that you're going to try and they try a mix of these things i'd be i'd be really interested to try it i'm very excited yeah and so that the rankings are massively skewed to the starter games as you said because you know i think even like wingspan is um well ranked quite highly uh i think there was the number of ranks um on boardgamegeek like i don't know 100 000 something like maybe not even that uh let's have a look uh i don't know what rec it was there we go okay 55 000. i think i think maybe a few months ago it hit a million sales so it goes to show the kind of portion of people ranking it to the people playing it is massively off the game like wingspan whereas i imagine with a game like um like group haven that percentage or ratio is going to be much higher to people ranking it than actual sales overall if that makes sense so there we go you got to take it for what it is though but there we go that kind of concludes uh the list really um hopefully you've enjoyed it is there any kind of glaringly obvious game that you think would have been on this list or should be on this list then that that isn't oh don't ask me that now um

ticket to ride i'm surprised it's not there oh yeah uh i it obviously is the gateway game and obviously it's old but i i bring that out you know my giving group with you know four or five 40 year old men and that's still one of the most requested games because it's just so easy so good to to teach and yeah i'm surprised it's not there i didn't realize it's gone yeah i'm pretty sure i'm pretty sure the euro one is must be in the top 150 so maybe it narrowly missed out um but but yeah i mean i'm trying to think about some other ones nothing jumps out massively um maybe games like for sale or biblios they seem to be generally quite popular i thought they would be up there um again maybe probably not top 100 maybe top sorry um yeah that's it really oh i do know yeah ethnos i a surprise because that's always quite well received people like that game yeah i guess it's not it's not as widely available uh and chinatown i thought chinatown for the top 100 somewhere probably the top 400 or so um oh okay it should be the top 100 yeah that's funny it's funny it's not yeah okay so this is so that's where i think that's why i think things like the call for the new and kickstarter have skewed things slightly and made things a little imbalanced for whatever it's worth just the way it is nowadays um yeah but you see that's games from like you know tigers and euphrates are

still in the top 100 um yeah it'd be interesting i know raj is considered one of the best yeah there's a few glaring emissions i think ra is in the top i think it's pretty i'm pretty sure it's in the top 150. i think it slipped out in the recent in recent months really um but yeah that's an absolute classic from the late 90s and so it'd be interesting to see those stats and see you know what the year breakdown is um and but there we go just a couple of um final comments then before before we um part ways um max thanks for joining us max i'm saying that he doesn't like legacy games um and we've got one here saying um after 17 plays of pandemic legacy they don't want to touch another legacy uh again um but because how are you playing 17 times up they're 12 there are 12 months on it i think something might get broken down into further oh i didn't know that 17 i think that um and barca says uh what games do you feel uh at risk of dropping out the ones at the bottom i suppose um games i always think new ones anything published 20 20 20 21 i think that's that's the hotness you have to have serious staying power to to stay there uh because as much as we complain about to 100 it is a decent measure of of what's popular and what's not at the time yeah well there we go then so um thanks

everyone for joining us for this pretty short notice i'm streaming thanks for ben for joining us again at very short notice so um i didn't give him the most a time to prepare for this but he's been great a great guest great having you on i'm ben so thanks so much for joining us and hopefully we'll we'll have you on for something else in the future as well um it's flown by dance so i know it's two hours and 20 minutes just thrown back brilliant so sorry sorry make it go so long i had no intention of just going over two hours but it has done but hopefully you guys have enjoyed it um we've really enjoyed talking about these games um and everyone else we'll see you next time on chairman of the board and of course be sure to check out ben's um podcast uh back of the shelf brilliant podcast talk about games of old some stuff that's been forgotten about that they um want to get back to the table and talk about and shed a bit of light upon so um anything else you want to add then before we leave no thanks help me it's been an absolute pleasure brilliant so thanks again guys and i'll speak to you all soon bye

Progress saved