Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 50 Board Games of All Time | 40-31

Transcript 24:41

jeffrey jeffrey jeffrey fancy seeing you here again hey anything else oh good all clear are you ready yep am i ready hello everyone and welcome back to foster the meeple a channel all about board games and gaming things yes we're here with our second episode of our top 50 board game of all time our favorite our favorite we are here today to do our numbers 40 to 31 yep i can't for some reason that always confuses me i have no idea why i agree it is i agree i don't know what it is about it but it is weird complicated you just inherently think 31 to 40 is nine but it's not right so we've already done our 50 to 41 that was our last video so you probably want to go check out starts there i mean whatever if you want to start here you do you do you boo boo that's true okay you do you boo boo we're gonna start off jeffrey with our number what is it again 40 40 to 31 do you want to start this time sure i'll start this time let's do it that way oh good this is the perfect time for the cat to catch starting to play with a toy baby it's got a little jingle ball in it no no no all day she doesn't play with this toy if you hear a little jingle in the background just know that the cat is having the time of her life and the other cat is trying to lick every last morsel of food out of the dish my number 40 is micro macro crime city okay another new to us game

this year this is it's board game adjacent let's just say it's kind of like an activity where you've got a big map on the table and you're trying to solve crimes and find dead bodies and with this very cute cartoony art i love it but not for kids oh no no no no no honey honey not for kids art's cute the art is cute the theme is very murdery there have been a lot of murders and macro when they say crime city emphasis on the crime yeah and the city we've only we've played through probably like five or six cases so we've got a long ways to go i'm sure it would probably be up higher if we played it a little bit more much as a story with a lot of these games but yes that is my number 40. not on my list at all that's a weirdo okay this one i struggled with for the same reasons you just mentioned it's a board game don't get me wrong but like it's more experience for me my number 40 from stonemeyer games is tapestry really i really really like tapestry and i know a lot of people really really don't like tapestry but i love it i know that there can be a runaway winner and there's some balance issues but everything about this game i loved it's beautiful production the little resin buildings that you can put out on the board are incredible you know there's kind of multiple paths to doing certain things scoring points i i've heard the newest expansion to this art and architecture improves the game so it might sneak up i'm not sure once i can play the expansion button i have not no i have played this many times but i

this did not make my list that's fair baby she's now taking it up the stairs and dropping it down the stairs good choice jeffrey we haven't played that one in a while it's been a hot minute my number 39 is king domino zone on your what is on your list i feel like i just don't know anyways king domino is a staple in our house we play this all the time less so in person now more so on bga but this is one of those games that we're we like to introduce to new people we played it with jeff's mom we played it when we played it with some of our other friends who are new to the hobby we've introduced it to people on bga and we just love it i it's simple but fun i think i'm relatively good at it so that's probably also why i like it quite a lot but that is my number 39. you got to be kidding me you're gonna have to go take it if it unless you want to keep doing this for i do not have it back later that's the jingle ball don't look you can't be looking while i look i'm not looking all right my number 39 game from final final frontier games merchants cove really why are you shocked it's not higher yeah really merchant's cove is a very asymmetrical i guess what's the mechanic in it oh many many mechanics you know each asymmetrical character plays a little bit different it might be dice rolling and dice placement it could be like a little plinko board yeah we're talking base game here everything is based on

action selection and each asymmetrical character's action selection functions with a different mechanic yeah 100 i love the artwork in merchants cove i really love asymmetry in games i haven't played merchants cove enough to push this up the list further and i haven't played with any of the expansion uh characters which i think pulled this back a little bit on my list i think it will go up the more i play it i love this game it's so good and i'm looking forward to playing it more with some of the new player what do they call characters i guess i guess some of the new characters but that is merchant's cove number 39 favorite game i'm very surprised it wasn't up higher on your list it's tough competition top competition is top 15. my number 38 is one that was on my top 10 last year in the number eight spot it has dropped 30 spots and that is imperial settlers empires of the north we did play this this past year but it was it was at like the very beginning of the year and we just recently got some of the new factions roman and japanese yes which we haven't played with yet so i think with more plays once again this is one of those games that i could see falling anywhere in my top 50 depending on the year but i love this game it's so cute there's like so much going on she's very good at it too yeah well i only ever play as like one faction plays as the penguin faction yeah it's just cute and i just love it so it's a good game i like it a lot too not on my list though don't look i'm not i if you think that i can see that you're

crazy my number 38 favorite game of all time from aeg john declare kubitos what number is this 38 are you kidding me no first over boss and now this are you trying to hurt my feelings is a pusher luck dice rolling racing game where that's pretty much it so where this game shines for me is the variability there's so much variability in this game in terms of what those dice represent there's different like abilities that those dice can mean and each track can be a bit different in terms of how you get from a to b but ultimately that's what you're trying to do you're trying to be the fastest to get from a to b on the track while rolling dice you can bust by rolling the dice i know i do it every time i'm talking about rolling dice now you'll always notice it one cool thing i think about this game that i love so much is the fan track so if you are falling behind the game will keep you in the mix it will give you certain abilities off of this fan track in order to keep you relevant you can actually be super competitive by being strategic on when you don't want to push forward when to push forward it's great i love kubitos we need to play it more mm-hmm i love qb i know it's going to be much much much higher much much much higher much much higher much higher okay what number are we on 38 7 7 my number 37 is a new 2s game this year another there's going to be a lot of new to us games this year and that is land versus c from good games

publishing all right this game now we've only gotten to play it twice and i have thoroughly enjoyed each time that we have played it it is a tile placement game where you're trying to build out like a land mass one person is land one person is c try and close it off score points et cetera et cetera et cetera it is fun it is thinky yet simple there's no setup involved which i kind of love like all you need to do is put a tile in the middle and start two stacks and that's it it's so much fun and i know this is a game that we are going to play a lot more this year and i can very easily see this creeping up my list very quickly and i assume by the look on jeff's face it has already creeped up his list it's not on your list at all what is on your list like i actually don't know it's going to be like 20 versions of root root root and all the expansions one to ten root clockwork underworld yeah anyways that is my number i've already forgotten 37 land versus c i struggle with this one why because you're not good i haven't played it enough but i do know that i'm going to love that game more and more my number 37 game is black angel black angel is an incredible game it's worker placement with dice essentially and the whole premise of the game is the is it the black angel of the ship yeah you're trying to get the black angel to planet spezz s-p-e-s don't ask me why they

named it that and you are going along this really cool board that keeps kind of shifting with the black angel as you go along into space and you can send little robot characters out from the black angel in in these little like these little spaceships to collect resources and fight like monsters and stuff it's so so so good spiritual uh successor i think trois if you've played same designer we love black angel i think we both love black angel i don't know if it's on your list or not but i think it fell just outside of my top 50 but i did really enjoy it and this is another one that i didn't think i was going to like and i think you were surprised that i liked it i was very surprised it's beautiful it's yeah it's the board is bright and blue

my number 36 i know is going to be much higher on jeff smith that might be the first yeah and that is lord of the rings the confrontation i am offended deeply so we only played it once this is one that i know for as a matter of fact it is fact that if we played it more it would be higher but it's so good we've only played it once i thoroughly enjoyed our play we do now own this game which means it is a game that we will be playing again this year and with more plays it is going to skyrocket for sure this game is just a bundle of fun just a bundle of fun so that's mine and i know it's going to be i have no idea where it's going to land on jeff's list but i know it's going to be quite high my number 36 game favorite game of all time is ghost stories getting so much judgment here okay ghost stories is a i'm going to say tower defense-esque mechanism with a fugal japanese theme attached to it in ghost stories you are trying to protect a village and villagers from ongoing onslaught of spirits or ghosts whatever you want to call them haunts and they are continuously moving towards this village and you need to fight them off with player abilities that you have village powers and etcetera etcetera it's incredibly difficult it is basically a badge of honor if you beat this game we've never beat it we've never beaten we have no badges my goodness every time i play this game i have an absolute

blast it's punishing but it's so good so good and i'm looking forward to this is a staple this is one that i think jamie and i will be like do you want to try ghost stores again see if we can do it we'll pull it out it's so good it has so much replayability in my opinion because it is so difficult okay jeffrey that seems to be awfully low which means i might i'm very surprised like i i feel like you don't know anything on my list i don't i literally i have no idea i like i said i think it's just root i mean we rank the same games i know that's why it's shocking my number 35 is one jeff's already talked about in this video and that is merchant's cove once we weren't that far off then no i think once again i i just thought it was going to be way higher on your list i do love it it's just i want more of the players do you know what bumps this game down for me is the setup and the tear down yeah that's very very fair which i don't do jamie jamie does it actually i was part of the tear down i was like this is terrible yeah and you almost like rage quit putting the game away there's just so much in this box and it's so hard to yeah anyways it comes with a like instruction instruction manual but i yeah i think the more we play this i love it more i am very excited to get the other factions because one of them i believe it's the oracle her mechanism is roland right yeah that's cool and i just think that's amazing so i'm just very excited to continue playing this i love the artwork i love the game play a lot of people do complain that it seems like it's kind of like more of a solitary game and there's not a lot of interaction but i think that's fine i

don't have an issue with that this one's gonna shock you my number 35 favorite game of all time is terraforming mars okay so that last year top five was your number three yeah so so from three to thirty five we have not played terraforming mars once thank god am i right i have only played bass terraforming mars jamie does not love terraforming mars very ugly and i don't have a play group to play terraforming mars hence why it is 35 on my list i still love it i still want to play it it just doesn't inherently get played here i definitely want to pick up the prelude expansion because apparently that changes everything and i'm going to try this year to convince jamie the terraforming mars is a good game because i do love it terraforming mars was one of my favorite gaming experiences when i was first getting into this hobby and i still have that nostalgia for it it's a fantastic game i just haven't played it enough and that's why it lands where it lands not on my list are you shocked you shouldn't be my number oh my god this one i don't know we're gonna get a divorce i don't know where this is gonna land on your list this one was on my top ten last number three four i don't think you said it number 34. this one was on my top ten last year as my number six and it was jeff's number one and that is gloomhaven jaws of the lion at my number 34.

when i first saw the rankings uh from pubmed and this was actually even lower i was like not a chance it's got to be higher originally it came in at like 40 and i was like no that can't be right i love jaws of the lion i love it but i think it's almost the recency bias thing because we finished it at the beginning of 2021 it's fair point and we haven't played it and then now we've played all these other amazing games and i love it i still love it i guess not as much as i used to i will mention this is on my list obviously uh tell you where gloomhaven is not no gloomhaven didn't make my top 50. we have played both but my preference is jaws of lion i agree with your sentiment idea i think if we had just finished it would be way higher because we had just finished it i think we did this last time my number 34 game it's a card game small box card game one we've only played one time but we had an incredible experience with it and definitely want to play more of it that is innovation oh okay yeah innovation is a another civilization-esque game where you are building out uh building types and doing all kinds of crazy combinations and splaying out cards and then there's a bunch of different eras you're going to work through which give you new technologies new buildings to do even crazier combinations crazy this is a game that's so swingy and you never know what's going to happen in my opinion some people might like might not like that which is understandable but for me like i love that uncertainty where and i remember when we played it like i was

running away with this game and i was super confident i had all of the things i needed and jamie had this one card come out just blew everything up and i was just like and normally that would anger me like normally i'd be like oh my god like what the heck but i was like wow that was so cool and i i love innovation so much i think more people need to try it great card game and don't be put off by the beigeness of the game my number 33 game is calico i love calico another one i know the more i would play the more i would love it it is a incredibly brain melty brain burny puzzly cat game where cats just want to lay on the quilt and then you're getting buttons the theme adorable the gameplay very very difficult not hard to learn hard to master very i love i love this game like i love this game it's very puzzling every time we're playing it i'm like i love this it's very you it's very mean i love those types of calico is a jamie gamer yeah like to a t like if you want to design a game for jamie calico is the type of game that you need to be designing and like i said i can 100 see this being higher up on my list as the year goes here's an interesting question now that we're talking about calico yeah we should get another cat i agree no what about cascadia oof at this point i think i prefer calico i really liked casper i really like so we just played cascadia last night for the first time i really really liked it but it was also

digital i won't know for sure until i play it in person i'm really nervous for my number 30. my number three is a very new to us game that we've only played somewhat recently and it is from roxley and that is a fantastic two-player card dueling lane fighter called radlands radlands is very similar mechanically to a game that i absolutely adore called netrunner it's a two-player only game and you're basically attacking the other person in sectioned lanes in order to defeat their base their bases in each lane it is incredibly beautiful i absolutely adore this game and i can absolutely guarantee you this time next year if we do this again this will be much much much much higher yes this just where jamie is stating you know where calico is a game designed for her i wouldn't inherently say this one is gay this isn't a game designed for me but it's pretty freaking close this is a game designed for us like this game this is a perfect type of game for us that we love with take that it's two player primary well i shouldn't even say that it is two player game it's two player only yeah i can't say enough good things about it okay people my number 32 is a game that i love with all of my heart every little last inch of it and i know people are going to expect this to be much higher spoiler alert it didn't even land on jeff's list how do you know and that is our most played game of all time and that is silver bullet i love silver bullet we play silver bullet

number one not only just because we love it but because it is so accessible because it is the perfect kind of game for us so i know it's going to be coming to a shock that is not in my top 10 or top 20. it is coming in at number 32 but i do love this game jeff didn't even put on his list because he keeps losing i think is maybe the reason why i love silver bullet everyone knows my love for silver bullet yeah but again when i think about this stuff in these games in terms of if i had primary player group yeah would i pick silver bullet like if i was given the option to play my goodness terraforming mars with a group of people that love to play terraform mars at four player or three player or whatever i'm gonna pick that over silver bullet but i still love it number 32. it is on my list but i just wanted to say because i know people are gonna be shocked and we still love it and i will fight to the death for it it's an amazing it's just that when jeff was doing his rankings it was like silver bullet versus root silver bullet versus root underworld silver bullet versus root uh river folk yeah yeah yeah yeah it's going to be shocking to you when root's not even on my list no i don't even yes it's on your list i just don't know where it falls i think it's number one i have no idea we don't know okay that's my number 32 silver bullet one of the loves of my life my number 32 from thunder works games is a game we like to call role play role player i knew it role player is a game where you aren't i guess building out a character more so than you're building up the stats for a character so you'll be given a class and a type and then you're rolling dice and placing them in your character sheet f placing them in your character board

to give them scores for constitution and strength and vitality and all of these things it's a beautiful game the dice are incredible i don't know why this game works so well i have no idea we love role player we just got role player adventures which let me tell you excellent choice jeffrey it's a great freaking game all right my number 31 i'm interested to know where and if this lands on your list but my number 31 is the initiative 31. so i guess it's higher than huh holy sh yeah my number 31 is the initiative which is a game that i love i think for me the initiative was such a fun experience but it was a little bit of a roller coaster for me stay got it like the highs were really high but then there were some plays of it that we were kind of like we figured that out almost immediately it was almost very very very fair yes but i still loved the experience it was so much fun and i think like i needed jeff in that game if you hadn't been playing with me i wouldn't have got i wouldn't have won any of them because i don't know how to do code breaking and for some reason you're really good at it and i think maybe that increased your enjoyment of it possibly i don't know i still love it i mean summer 31 yeah i mean i'm sure it did but for me like that might be my favorite gaming experience of last year yeah so 31 rude don't look okay i can't see anyway my number 31 game favorite game of all time which i think is going to shock

jamie a little bit and maybe not a little bit i think it's going to shock to me a lot my 31 game from awaken realms lords of helles ah i'm not that surprised this is a tough one for me because i want to explain kind of what happened with lords of helles lords of helles isn't great at two-player a scandal which is what we played it at words of helles is a area controlled dudes on a map esque game cyborg greek gods there are other conditions that can be meant like you can take your hero and go on a quest and the quest can resolve and do certain things for you can go off and hunt go on a hunt and fight mythical beasts and do certain things that way there's a lot going on in this game it's not your stereotypical area control where it's basically you fighting another army and you win this would be much higher on my list if i played it at a three or four player guaranteed i love area control dudes on a map games i just haven't got an opportunity to play this at the primary player count but absolutely love this game oh that's it that's it that's it for this list so those are our next 10 games i am shocked at some of them jeff is shocked at some of mine mainly just one which one confrontation really i thought you were shocked by something else the initiative you were shocked oh yeah jaws of the lion you oh yeah yeah yeah you're right yeah never mind jeff has been very shocked anyways those are our next ten we will be back again with our number oh god 30 our number 30 to 21 next tuesday so we'll take a break for

board games and brew we'll be back next tuesday with our number 30 to 21. if you guys are interested in buying board games like any of the ones we mentioned today don't forget to check your friendly local gaming store and for us here in halifax that is the boardroom game cafe yeah no kidding obviously that's all we have for you guys today thank you so much for watching if you like what you see please subscribe we hope to see you again soon and now we say goodbye goodbye later days i wasn't sure if you were going to pass it off to me again i always like to keep you on your toes unbelievable i'm sure it's fine it's fine uh does that have one of our eyes it has mine okay baby no literally like as soon as we started filming she's believable okay we've played it with jeff's mom good call that did it get out of here with your cds why would you do skates what like like you could die yeah so easily you could die and i don't know any other idea it's got you me i take it off yeah oh sorry i can't i never thought uh not abilities what's the word i'm looking for assets strengths stats stat artifacts that oh wait what do i usually say

Progress saved