TCbH Podcast - Gateway Games
Transcript
hello and welcome to the cardboard Herald podcast I am Eric joined as always by my lovely co-host Jack I was trying to think of another adjective and I got lost I got lost there yeah I I actually thought there was like some lag or something I was like did I drop off the call or what's happening you know is Eric right at the moment yeah I like it well I was I my gut really wanted to go back to a reverent but we've already used it and and then I couldn't think of a backup one I don't I don't know why I don't think of these things when I start saying them where I'm like my lovely and other adjective co-host Jack I don't usually think of them beforehand it's just whatever feels right in that moment and I was going to say Reverend again which you know the audience already that' be a repeat yeah I think you got to work on your adjective game there uh but you know Christina and I call that vocal turbulence where like your brain is operating at a different rate than your mouth is and so you're doing a lot of lip flapping and then either you conjoin words there's actually a term for that where you like switch the beginning of one word with the next word and it just kind of like tumbles out um or that kind of lag there just a weird sort of you know mechanical androides glitch in The Matrix situation vocal turbulence oh yeah we'll take
we'll take the back then and joined by my lovely T Tumblin co-host Jack yeah call me the Tumblin dice that that's me what's up Eric not much I am back in DC I just spent a lovely weekend at a friend of mine's uh wedding in Puerto Rico uh which was G gorgeous and I got so sunburnt which is why I'm fully covered at the moment because I am peeling as all get out I just I should have known I I sunburn at the at the slightest inconvenience of sun that's funny because you're originally from Florida so I would think that you're like prepped for that you're just like biologically you've been immersed in the sun you're ready for that and now you burn huh yeah I so I used to not like I played I played tennis every day in in high school for the most part I was out in the Florida Sun every single day and did not get sunburn I did have like when I was a kid I got sunburn a lot but I moved out of Florida I moved up North and then my sunburnt uh my sunburnt Tendencies kicked back in so yeah I am peeling as as like a like I'm an orange or a banana yeah I I was born in the tropics uh I was born in the Philippines and then lived a few years in New Delhi
India and once we moved to Alaska I just adjusted because I am pasty and peeling uh when it comes to the Sun but did you bring any board games with you did you bring anything yeah yeah I brought things um I brought harmonies uh just cuz it's it is my amazing at this point my it is if my sister my mom and I are getting together I'm bringing harmonies like that's the point where we're at uh it's kind of been I was not really anticipating them to latch on to it like I kind of brought it cuz I was just like oh I like playing it and my sister is roughly getting into board games my mom isn't particularly but she'll do whatever the family is like down to do like she's down my mom is down to like try any weird thing that just somebody said this is fun we're all going to do it my mom will like she has done a throwing which is very out of character for my mom but some friends of hers from work went and did it and she's really happy about that great I love it yep so the old Tomahawk moot um so you went to Puerto Rico and you brought harmonies with you uh did you get any other gaming in not in Puerto Rico I did play um El Paso ended up on board game Arena today so I gave that another play um that's
the slimmed down version of Great Western Trail uh that asade day is putting out um it's it's solid it is a solid rendition of Great Western Trail um so i i s some Jersey cows like what what happened in this uh did you did you meet your objectives did you go around the trail many no I did not play very well no I I the the other person who I played against I I think like almost doubled the amount of points my God I'm not I I don't I I do not claim to be good at El Paso at the moment but that was like for my first time playing I was like oh this this is cool I'm getting how everything works here like there's it it's a real Snappy game I'm really happy that I got to try that out um sweet yeah and then I've been playing more witchcraft I'm probably going to throw a review together of it um here shortly uh though I do have some some other games that are arriving in the next week or so that are going to have a little bit of a timeline to review them so that one I'll do I'll figure it out um but yeah I think it'll be it'll be a positive review on witchcraft I'm I'm liking it quite a bit I think that I wish there was a little bit more variety but overall super super solid
solo game and it just it gets to the table so quick I think that's kind of my favorite thing about it I wish that I could say the same for super squad High which is a game that I've played recently which has some really interesting ideas is it's uh by Nerdy pup games um I really enjoyed their first game even though it was a little limited uh that was dungeon date uh which this as well has so much Vibrance and so much personality it's a Cooperative worker placement um does some really cool things with the uh superhero genre but it has this social element uh and like memory element to it that completely derails to me derails the flow of the Strategic element of the game um and even apart from that the worker placement and like the the things that you're reacting to unlike say I don't know um anything from Spirit Island to pandemic where you make smart decisions but you kind of you know when to take risks when to not take risks you see what the problems are and you're making choices about which problems that you're actually going to be able to uh deal with and the ones that you let Slide the uh latitude with which you can let anything slide in here is is very
little uh and so it becomes overly prescriptive in like what you have to do um which is a bummer because you know like if I'm playing Cooperative game I want to make those cool creative decisions and there are hints at those cool creative decisions that you could do but in the couple of games that I've played so far it just for me uh it's just a little too limited and in conjunction with that social system I I it didn't it didn't fly for me but I'll have a review to kind of elaborate uh some of that here soon uh I played some seti uh recently uh shout out to uh Steve who um you know like uh you met uh before uh moving down um he's someone who's relatively new to the board game hobby uh and coincidentally our our uh topic today is uh Gateway games um but he took to heavy games right away he wants the heavier the better the first time that I met him was at a public game night and uh the the host of it introduced him to me as someone who might be interested in the type of games that he uh typically likes he's like yeah you know when I'm at these places I'm happy to play these things but for me the heavier the better
I'm not necessarily good at them but I'm always interested in the systems which I found really fascinating because he's only been playing for like two years or so he he's new to the hobby compared to certainly you and I um and so the other night he was like Hey on Tuesday you want to play seti I was like do you want to play seti like that that's a big chunker for Tuesday night and he's like yeah like sweet I I just love that there's someone who's enthusiastic about getting a a beast like that to the table even if seti was a game that uh I was not fully positive on um and some of the uh things the the issues that I have with it being kind of um that's the opposite spectrum of something like uh super squad High where you're you have so much you can do and it's hard to really tell if what you're doing is Meaningful in the grand scheme of things um but well I still had fun I had fun playing with him um so that was kind of a notable play and the the other thing that I didn't mention the other day uh last time we recorded but I started playing sleeping Gods uh have you played sleeping Gods I have not I I I roughly know about I mean I've seen the box art and I think from from
everything I can tell the game looks gorgeous but uh I have not dived into that system I think that's a game that I I I keep an eye on whenever I I'm like looking at sales so I'm like I I think for me that's the biggest barrier to entry is just I know that it is in in my mind a pricier game that I just you know I'll keep an eye on a sale and if if something comes up all I wouldn't mind having it it seems like a fun game that would be up my alley but I'm not like dying to go get it um but I'm happy to hear your thoughts on it what are what are your well this is uh distant Skies which is the sequel game um I played the original sleeping Gods uh with uh my buddy Mike and my wife uh who was the frost Haven crew uh and then uh he had sleeping Gods I think he kickstarted it and then we got frost Haven and played through that campaign in the midst of that sleeping Gods distance Skies was uh put on I guess it wasn't Kickstarter I think it was game found uh but I I ended up backing that because I was like you know what I want this game I want to support uh this company uh and I liked the first one and this will be cool to do once we wrap up Frost Haven not realizing that it was going to sit unplayed on my shelf
for many months as we continued Frost Haven uh but we finally did broke out distance Skies uh I like it better uh it's uh what I loved about the first game which is a really smart open world game that uh combines strategic elements of Adventure Gaming with the narrative elements of Adventure Gaming which are often at odds with one another and integrates it um very well here uh to make just a compelling expansive system with so many levers going on behind the scenes um the typical Red Raven games artwork is unbelievable um just lovely story beats uh narrative uh and the the few things that I felt were kind of lame about the original sleeping Gods um like the huge cast of characters that you had to uh manage um regardless of your player count uh and the combat system uh we're both overhauled here you still have a mandatory five characters that you have to play one always rotates that's the the kind of like protagonist the leader of the group um and then there's four uh characters besides them so if you're playing a four-player game everyone gets one character and then rotates the
captain um in our case we have one person playing two which is Mike and then Christina and I have uh alternate duties um she's like the notetaker mat maker type of person and then I'm the setting up game boards and manipulating components and you know always on hand uh Mike is uh managing one bonus character that works beautifully um but yeah you know um earthborn Rangers and uh and sleeping Gods really have to me proven how open world games um that have conclusions but you can save at any point uh that that makes sense in a comparison to some sort of video game but you can come back and have different experiences or retread some of the same ground um can really work in ways that I think seventh continent tried uh and and had a lot of promise on what what that could be but didn't fully execute on would you recommend sleeping Gods disguise to like somebody who's new to the Hobby you know I would not and for a few reasons um because that's our topic today uh as I spoiled earlier but good
transition there getting your transitions going thank you I'm working on it um yeah so I think sleeping gods disgu or the original is a good example of something that while my fundamental role in Gateway Games is if you're transparent about what the game's going to be and uh you explain the the intensity of the game if it's something that really appeals to someone even after that full transparent explanation then sure give it a try but the reasons why I think this wouldn't necessarily be a good starting point is uh it is very systems heavy which there are a lot of touchstones that people who have played board games for a while could see how those relate to other types of games that are out there uh I think it would be very good as an introduction to tabletop games if someone came from the RPG field still tabletop games but wanted to go into board games specifically I think this could be a fantastic translation if they had no interest in Euro games or you know like typical strategy games but they wanted to see how uh uh Adventure could be Consolidated into a box then I I think that the the touchstones of RPGs would
be familiar enough that uh this could be a good translation but other wi um I don't think it's necessarily the strategy that's a barrier in a lot of games I think it's the uh interconnectivity of systems and the Reliance on you know like touchstones to build someone up I don't know what what do you think do you throw someone in the deep end uh do you try to go for something small I I think if I'm trying to get a person into the hobby or if I'm just like trying to get a person who I've played some smaller games with before but more like want to get them more into the hobby um I think you you mentioned it as touchstones I kind of think of it as like humans like patterns in so so if I introduce them with something small I can then use that pattern later on to teach them something bigger so like with I don't know if I would necessarily go straight and this is this is a lighter game that I think some people might consider a Gateway game but I don't know if I would go straight to Seven Wonders when Sushi go is right there yeah so I I think for me when I
think of Gateway games at this point um I think of these games that are either distillations of really frequently seen Game mechanics and honestly I think a lot of a lot of game right games are are great examples of this cuz like Abandon All AR of chokes is a deck builder and and people then have that reference point or Touchstone uh when we when I want to introduce them to another deck builder that's maybe a bit heavier um or like and this is Dominion I think is also a great one for that because Dominion is really like a pretty pure deck builder that you can then teach people other deck builders and I think the U deck builder yes the The Herald of them all the prophecy spoke of deck builders and it said Dominion this here that that is interesting about game right um because you're totally on the money with that the Forbidden Island Forbidden Desert um are great introductions particularly Forbidden Island I think MH yeah well that entire series I feel like is a really good learn the mechanics get introduced to other mechanics that now interact with that which I is just how I feel like a lot of
in my mind how I would introduce someone to board games in a vacuum is Right teach them games that are super fun but are primarily focused on one single mechanic and then you can start adding in other mechanics into that so like with uh um something like something like Dominion or aandal artichokes those are deck builders the goal of that is to build your deck and Abandon All chokes it's to destroy your deck I'm I'm still going to call it a deck builder for this exercise but like going from something like that to then like clink is a really easy segue where they're like oh I understand how deck building works and I understand how adding cards to my deck improves my deck in in some ways and makes me specialize in some ways versus others um and now I also have to figure out if I have a character on the board and I need need to move my way down so I think that there's in a vacuum that is how I would like to get someone into board gamings and that would kind of be the flow of the Gateway that I would like but it it all kind of depends on the person but that's that's roughly what when I think of Gateway Games it's games that are primarily focused on one mechanic for
the most part this is an example of us kind of putting the cart before the horse I I think we should actually Define Gateway Games right because you know that that's one of the point of gate Gateway Games is to like introduce people to the Hobby um so like for those who aren't familiar with Gateway games uh or the terminology uh you know we're talking about uh what is a game that presents itself in a way that is an introduction to this uh and this is a common thing for gamers to discuss primarily because our hobby unless you're intending on predominantly being a solo gamer is contingent Upon Us introducing more people to the Hobby and often times that's someone that we really care about being interested in the hobby you know the spouse family me members friends whatever you want to make a good impression and so there are certain games that don't necessarily sell the best impression of um uh of the board gaming hobby either because uh they're very Den or Niche or the themes aren't going to be appealing and Gateway games are the ones that are you frequently used as kind of that ambassador to to bring people in now there is another connotation for Gateway
games that we're not using it as here that's more of like a pejorative you know like people will sometimes be dismissive that these are not meaningful games is kind of in the same way that people will sometimes talk about like app based games for phones as like well there are video games and then there's you know mobile games as if someone who plays these doesn't count as a real gamer um and that's I don't think Super prevalent within our hobby but you see it in online spaces for sure um and uh by any means uh we're we're not saying that you know these games are intended to be exclusively used by people who are unsophisticated or not as knowledgeable about this hobby you know these are games that are make good introductions but if that's as far as you want to go and you don't want to build beyond that if your favorite game is Sushi go or Dominion or forbidden island or whatever that's great I love playing a lot of those games too uh even if my happy zone is in a complexity level higher than that I'm always down to play that stuff and that that's not us saying like we have graduated Beyond this and we would never demean ourselves to play these uh also
there is a weird element to Gateway game so this is like third element is the term is like a cute way of saying you know this is what's going to get you hooked um but it is a comparison to like drugs and addiction right like that that's what we're saying with Gateway probably you know because we grew up uh us us you know I I guess I'm like Elder Millennial here um grew up uh hearing about gateway drugs uh and so Gateway Games I've always thought of as like oh yeah you know it's your gateway into the hobby that you're going to be spending all your money and time uh on and you're going to be obsessing over these games and buying all kinds of things I'm seeing no conclusions from Google of the origin of like the phrase like gway something but I thinkology yeah I think that's also Fair where it's in my in my mind the way that I'm thinking of it is Gateway as in this is your introduction to the Hobby and these are games that can just introduce you to the parts of the hobby that are fun and also the parts of the hobby you might not like but I guess it is also like this is how you get hooked and start spending all your money that is also that that is also true for me uh where those games
did get me into the Hobby and I have spent a lot of my money on games so with modern games I I think it the Undisputed king of uh Gateway Games is Katan right you know that's the one that's broken through into the mainstream I'm not saying it's the best for everyone to use but obviously it has been used time and time again as something to introduce people to there's a whole world Beyond uh the the board games that you grew up playing that are not chess that adults want to play and you're going to have a great time with it whole clubs have been built around this um so you know like what do you think about the the prevalence and success of Katan and do you still think of that as a a good Gateway game um or do you reach to Alternatives um I mean I think that it has such a massive prevalence as a Gateway game I mean I I consider that in carcassone as my two Gateway games like those are the two games that I played initially like very no other board game experience and a friend of mine was like oh do you guys want to play this game and I was like oh sure sure totally or by no other board game experience I mean just like modern non- Monopoly games um and I think it does a reasonably good
job and honestly at this point it's because it's become such a cultural reference point for board games like people are much more willing to try Katon than like if I said oh let's play Sushi go some of them people don't necessarily know what that is whereas they can at least fathom oh Katana is a popular game I know that that is a game let's play the new thing that I let's play the thing that I know about um so I think in terms of that it's it's a solid Gateway game it'll get people to at least I think be willing to try it um I think it's not necessarily the best Gateway game in terms of it is such a highly social game that it becomes I think Katon frequently can create P bad experiences yeah I I think that for me that's the biggest thing of it it is more in my mind it's more likely that I play a game of Katon and be frustrated at the end then like really enjoy it right at the end of it but during the middle I probably having fun moments I think that is probably the
um the inner board game circles uh the Gateway game that is most frequently turned on right you know like people who immerse themselves in this hobby who love learning all kinds of new games Katan is just one that people step away from and reflect on and go like there's been a lot of progress in this hobby since this released in 1995 and uh I don't even own a copy anymore I have Katon Jr my kid likes playing that but uh you know like beyond that I I don't have it and I played it again for the first time in a long time during Co in an online session that I did with some friends local here in Judo you know with our video cameras and everything set up had multiple boards you know I had my board that was here and they had their board there and one other board I was like man you know I enjoy that I'm doing this activity with my friends and I enjoy that they are getting a lot out of it but I just I don't I don't love a lot about this game there there's a lot that I would change if I were remaking this but I also think there are some really key features that make it uh a really good um hook for the hobby you know like uh first off it the
theme is uh historical in the vaguest sort of way um that it can kind of appeal to like the George R Martin reading fantasy nerd who's like ah I want to look at some people's struggle to raise some crops in the you know in some vaguely European land but it's also not fantasy in a way that it you know isn't going to make someone feel silly uh when they're playing and there are a lot of people who are new to this hobby especially adults who don't want to look silly like that that is their biggest fear in playing a higher pressure strategic game um adults have been conditioned that it is bad to look silly in front of other adults and that's a problem as a society that we need to overcome uh but um you know having a a indistinct uh but suitable theme that works generically for most people and then the the thing that you do in the game is you trade resources that pulls on some familiarity from Monopoly that a lot of people have as kids it makes sense you can understand this like agricultural bartering that's going on and then you're building infrastructure there are very few things
that you can do on your turn I can get my resources that turn into this this this or this and that's all I can do the only text that I really have to contend with are on these development cards and they are very simple very straightforward they do exactly what they do yeah probabilities all that other stuff that's that's strategy but if I just focus on how do I get what I need to build a road and then once I built a road how do I get what I need to build a settlement and can I upgrade that to a city it's very good at directing someone at smaller objectives that end up expanding upon themselves and you can very quickly see the ramifications of what you're doing uh and you can very quickly see when something was a good or bad idea now dice probabilities are going to mess everything up in Kanan but which I think I'm going back and forth on calling Katan and Katon uh you infected me with your Katon um but I I think that those are the things uh when I was spending some time thinking about this topic that are the most key uh for Gateway Games to me when I'm making introductions it's not about having a few number of me mechanics or systems it's not about having a a level of depth
that's either super shallow or you know is super strategic I think it's about having few but impactful decisions where you can quickly see what the consequences of your actions are uh where a game like seti and not only is it Buck Wild in the amount of things that you can do but it's very difficult to see if what you're doing is a smart thing a game like say Abyss by Bruno catala or many of Bruno catala games uh fit into this category um but uh Abyss or King Domino you can see immediately what the impact of what you did is going to be and how you can build upon that and the opportunity cost for what you did is leaving something to someone else um yeah I think those are what really makes the best Gateway Games yeah and I'll I'll say this for I I'll say this for Katon for for one I fully agree with you where there's the there's not a huge amount of player choices you can make in a good way like there is you can build a road you can build a settlement you can upgrade a settlement into a city you can buy a development card and that's that's kind of that's kind of it and so it it really funnels
you into how do I do these actions that I'm hoping to do and the other thing that I think makes Katon a pretty solid Gateway game is it's so social that you are talking to the people at the table which I think is such a great aspect of board gaming and it kind of forces you into that and it forces you to like think about what's going on in the game and like how how are you interacting with the board right now what is what's Jim doing over there what's he got going on I and I think that can also create really fun moments in a game that is going poorly for you I like I have so many stories of I had a game where I had a city on a a a a thing that had a six an eight and a four and I didn't get anything from that City all game and isn't that silly and isn't that unlucky and then I had a game I had a game right afterwards where I just they I had a settlement on the number three and we just kept rolling threes the entire game and so I just ended up with the surplus of this thing and isn't this silly and I have all this wheat to give you guys and I think that it because it is such a social game in that aspect it is really good at introducing people to the fun parts of the hobby as well where you're engaging with the other
people at the table well Eric let me ask you this pretend I'm a a new person that you've met you're like oh this guy is super cool and extraordinarily handsome uh but he's never played a board game since childhood and you are trying to get him introduced to board games what do you want to know about me like what what are you going to ask me to kind of help you one mhm you know get me get me interested in a game uh but also select what game that you're going to kind of make your debut with um I think theme is really important I think that's that's a thing that it we're we're at a point in modern board gaming where there are so many games at so many different difficulty level like just how how difficult is this game to understand um that we we have so many different things of is your like do you enjoy history you got Katon you have Splender you can make Splender into like a history game do you like fantasy well then you got Clank you have small world small world like there are so many games that can do this animals we got harmonies we got Cascadia we got like we
got options what's your like there are so many different games that can be Gateway Games CU there's just a lot of games that are coming out I feel like in this at this time in this like difficulty range where it can be really in-depth or it can just be something that you're teaching to somebody who's never played board games before and because there's so many options I want it to be a game that the person is going to engage with and for me that that means means theme is the question that I probably would start off with uh yeah yeah well I I just had the occasion to uh put all of this into practice uh recently because Christina uh has grown close with a uh fellow student in her um course that she's taking at the University here uh they were somewhat recent to Juno uh she and her husband um were looking to Branch out into other activities they don't really have any familiarity with board games and Christina invited them to come to the local Meetup and let's hang out we'll play some games there and they really weren't sure what this was going to entail you know they they play some video games together as a couple like they like to play fortnite and they played some other things uh the the husband has played League of Legends in the past and these are just things that
we discover through picking them up and chatting with them on the way down um which kind of helped me understand contextually like what some of their interests were this was my first time meeting them as well um and she had uh you know only spent time with uh them through the aspect of uh going to class together but um I brought some games in the bag there's also some games uh over uh at the Meetup that we could use from their Library uh but we get to devil's club and uh when I'm uh bringing games out I was uh thinking all right well I kind of know uh what some of their interests are I've asked about Hobbies uh so I'm not too worried about theme uh but I also don't want to like overwhelm them with too many choices uh and so I started with um asking about like some some history uh because we asked do you ever play any like board games together or anything and they were talking about like uh we play like 10,000 I was like dice rolling perfect okay um so do you know do you guys have you played yatsi or do you at least kind of know what yatsi is uh they're like yeah yeah we know YSI I was like okay so perfect we're going to you know get King
of Tokyo a shot here not using powered up just using the vanilla Heroes and everything I was like okay so you played fortnite you know you call know combat colorful these people that are destroying Tokyo you call them Heroes just is weird yeah just an interesting thing I noted it's going in your file yep uh and so I I I was like okay well we're going play this uh it uses a yatsi mechanism to either get points or destroy all other monsters does that make sense also are you familiar with King of the Hill you know the game that kids play you know who can be standing up or on top of the hill or whatever and whoever is on top of the hill is the King of the Hill that's the central concept of this one person is going to try to get into and then maintain hold on Tokyo and they're either going to try to wait out until they get enough points or make sure that no one else is able to take them down and we're going to just do an exchange here they picked it up immediately and loved it from there uh they played some drop hter uh and they played uh because uh this was actually to me a more obtuse game that I wouldn't normally uh go to as a as a Gateway game
uh but because the theme was really attractive to them and the description was attractive to them they played some tonoko um with the bamboo stacking and the panda moving everywhere uh and they took to that really well again and that's where I started thinking about yeah tonoko there there are a lot of options on the board but you're driven by simple objectives and on your turn you only have a couple actions that you can take and you just select what are the two actions that you're going to do limited choices immediate ramifications and kind of smaller guided objectives that take you to um uh completing those um and so it communicates a lot about what you're supposed to do taking away that kind of nebulous oh am I looking like an idiot for choosing to do what I'm doing type of thing and also takes away the feeling of being overwhelmed if you don't grasp a 100% of the rules yeah totally and I think that I mean all those sound that sounds like it was a great experience introducing them to board games uh and that was I think probably a good call to pick up on things that they are familiar with and just just continue to use those reference points or touchstones as a way of helping people recognize p patterns people humans at a base level enjoy recognizing patterns
they enjoy recognizing oh this thing is just like this thing that is a Bas level human trait when it comes to like just existing in this modern world people like understanding things and it's easier for them to understand things if they have a reference point of oh I know yatsi I know King of the Hill this is like those two things combined that's why that is like in so many advertisements for or maybe not even advertisements but reviews of board games or movies or TV shows or just anything it's there's a lot of it's like if this thing and this thing had a baby that is that is a way for us to say these are two reference points that are connected in this thing um so yeah I think it sounds like King of Tokyo was a great hit for them that would be a great that's that's a great game to like introduce going going back to our BGG Hall of Fame discussion I still think King of Tokyo should be on there as like a pivotal and notable moment in game history agree well Richfield already had his yeah well I mean it's hard to argue that magic is one of the most important but if you were to take your collection down to 20 games I know you already trimmed it down but if you were to take
it down to 20 games that are the games that you want to keep forever are what of those games do you think would still work well as Gateway Games I'd probably keep Splender which I think that's a that's a really easy Gateway game um harmonies I I it would probably be in that list and I think I think that that's a Gateway game that I find very there's so there's so many great things about that game as a Gateway game of people like the cute art it is a very beautiful looking game which I think that can get people into it um but it also is both limited actions but a lot of there still feels like there's a lot of space for people to make big plays in that game and I think in in that manner it's a good Gateway game because people I feel like at the end of it feel like they know so much more than they did at the beginning and because it's a short enough game that's absolutely a game that people would go oh I want to play that again right now um
mhm one that I think furnace I think would also work one that I was going to say that I think I would probably keep my collection and I feel like is frequently referenced as a Gateway game that I think I would in a vacuum steer people away from would be wingspan yeah to me that's a game that just it's I I mean I love wingspan but at the same time it feels like one step too many things to explain that I have you seen that video of Manny penin uh just dunking on wingspan because his kid was trying to teach him wingspan and he's like him and his wife are like this is the most complicated game on the planet and Elizabeth Hargrave was so excited because enigo Montoya was dunking on her game um yeah I have not seen this this sounds awesome you can look up Manny paten and wingspan it's probably still on the internet somewhere um you know I kind of had the same feeling with Sky Team like on the one hand I think Sky team is perfect for this because it's it's got a great theme everyone understands and can relate to planes uh and also you can make it
really excit you know like if you have your friend who's like ah flying a plane that sounds exciting you could be like no we're crashing a plane like this is desperate and crazy and we're doing all these things you can make that a little bit more intense um but there's a lot of pressure going on um in every single turn of Sky Team um which you would want to make sure that someone is going to be able to feel comfortable learning learning a whole new skill not just learning a game but like learning board games as a whole um part of what makes sky team so great is it's so simple yet every single decision matters and every decision that you make could be the wrong decision if you don't play it well that leads to your defeat like it's not so high pressure that you couldn't cooperatively work together and communicate what are some good moves and that kind of stuff but uh you know like that's a game that I think works amazingly well as long as it's someone that you know has the confidence to have a good time even if they fail miserably yeah yeah and I think that co-op games are really can be a good game to introduce
people to board games for the sake of we're all on the same team so either we all fail together or we all succeed together in a way that makes it kind of less competitive which is an aspect of board game some people are turned off by at the same time I think that you have to just be really careful that you're not quarterbacking to the point that people can't play the game that you're there to play with them um but like I think pandemic especially if the person who's teaching it is uh just aware that that is a thing that they need to not do pandemic can be a really great Gateway game where you're introducing people like oh yeah there's disease diseases outbreak we have to do these things to stop it it might be maybe a bit too cutthroat for people who haven't played board games before like I feel like if this is most the table's first time playing a modern board game the disease is probably going to win almost certainly it's because you just don't necessarily have the skills yet to take in the data you're receiving from the board and output that into a good formal plan but that Forbidden Island could be another one where it's like you know we're working together as a team these are games that we
can you know play together and we're going to sort our problems together and that's a non competitive way to introduce someone to board games well I think no matter what uh it it's important to know your audience um to help people feel comfortable uh and to help give guidance you know like whatever game that you're playing and even if it's not someone's first game offering suggestions on just like hey if you want some suggestions on some things that you could do your first couple of turns um that is perfectly helpful uh and you know can help with that sort of discomfort and feeling lost um some people really want this sense of Discovery uh so not being overly prescriptive about what someone has to do uh in order to succeed you know like that's that's quarterbacking um you know you generally want to steer away from that but some people do kind of want that as a guiding hand so as with pretty much anything social uh which teaching board games to other people and introducing board games to other people um is you know don't be a jerk and try to know your audience and have a degree of understanding of what someone else is going through and and play to play to
the room you know like see where they're at see what they need don't be overly guiding but don't be so hands off that you can see that glaze look over their eyes were like I have no idea what's going on yeah you know you got to adjust yourself what do you what do you consider your like one of your gateway games like that got you into the hobby that got me into the hobby yeah um absolutely would be hero Quest um as a kid and yes it was four kids um but that introduced me to dungeon crawling that introduced me to um systems of you know persistent gameplay and that made me understand that games could be so much more now that was 1993 or something uh shortly after I played magic which got me into like tabletop gaming systems more in-depth stuff uh some other other dungeon crawls uh like um uh dragon strike I played a bunch of um and then before playing Katan um I played some board games um when uh before I moved to Juno here um I had some friends that were starting to get into early stuff uh and they were playing a lot of Steve Jackson games uh
so Illuminati and uh munchkin but I think after that I was kind of researching board games and that's when someone was like oh you should play Katan and I was like I know of it you know like I've seen it I've sold it because I worked in you know games uh stores uh but I hadn't played it um because that didn't necessarily kind of look like my jam um but then I ended up buying a copy uh and I was like oh okay I can see this uh but I remember the exact moment when as an adult uh I was like not just games not just tabletop games in general but box board games are my jam is when I played Small World um I remember who I played it with I remember the occasion of me uh playing it uh and um I had already played some other games up until that point so I had some familiarity but when that game hit the table it looked like the most complicated thing I'd ever seen But the illustrations were so inviting the mechanical implications of what you were doing were
so smart to me at the time you know like oh to to win a battle I just need to have two more tokens you know the I just need to be able to do that when you when you die the repercussions you know like if you're defeated you only lose one token no matter how many you had there you only lose one token and then the conjunction of power worked so well and it just sparked my imagination I could see what things could be possible within that play Space um and it had so many cool tokens and pieces and things and yet my turns were relatively simple MH and the objective wasn't like Risk I didn't need to wipe everyone off the board my objective was to get as many points as I could by the end of the game game um that was awesome uh so small world was the game that really convinced me like I want to be a part of this Hobby and I want to explore all the games because if this is what we can do then sky the limit there's all kinds of things this is so cool totally yeah and I think that that's a that's a little bit of an interesting Journey with starting with heroquest I feel like that's a really that's a that's a heavier game to start out with have an older brother man you just you just got to and you know be be in
that like divorce dad Zone where you're spending a lot of time as latch key kids you know hanging out by ourselves in the sticks of Alaska and you know you're well playing a lot of hero quests together I think it also goes back to you know you're down for the theme I I think the theme can do a lot of heavy lifting to get people more into a game that that might be maybe a bit more complicated but they they'll give it more Runway to get going and like snag them um but you know like anything can be a Gateway game for somebody like Steve's favorite games are really heavy games those are the games that he has interest in playing so like if I don't know what his game way game was or is um but somebody who's that dedicated be like oh no I'm I can learn systems and how they interact like th I want that level of play Maybe Dune Imperium could maybe be a Gateway game like that can it that's one of I would say that's one of the more complicated board games that I like really really enjoy and if you like like Dune and dune you want to experience all Dune content that there is in the world Dune Imperium can be a Gateway game CU that can also
be a thing where you you have the touch point the Touchstone of this is how the different houses are this is vaguely what they do so oh it makes sense that the uh mining Guild gives you right fold space I I think one of the cardinal sins uh that I committed in my early content creation uh Journey as I was talking about Gateway Games in another I don't know was it a video was it an essay I publish or or something but I listed War of the ring as a game that I think could be a great uh showcase for the hobby because it so badly wants to emulate Concepts from The Lord of the Rings and so many people are incredibly emotionally invested in The Lord of the Rings that you know like as long as someone understands and this is really what codified that that concept that I was talking about at the beginning of the podcast some as long as someone understands oh yeah this is this is like a beasty long game where there's Dice and people killing each other and they see that and they're like oh that looks awesome the Thematic connotations of the things that you're going to do I think are going to springboard them into really diving deep into that game
um and I I think even though it is such a giant game there are systems it still has those elements of you know like it's clear there are things that you need to do here are smaller objectives that lead you towards bigger objectives and uh you know like the the ramifications of your decisions are pretty uh apparent uh as you do them um and that again thematic foothold is going to be a lot in getting someone past that it's also a game that doesn't I guess you know mince words with what it's going to be right you know like if you have that on the table it is not pretending to be a lighter game than it is uh so if someone sees that and is still like oh hell yeah this is going to be awesome give him a shot give him a shot yeah um we have a few listener comments that I want to bring up just CU I think that they they will add more to the discussion uh and I think that they're just you know I I think that they have similar sentiments but they phrase them in a little bit different ways that might just uh provoke some other thoughts so first off from rabbit Victor uh the comment is I tend to
introduce new players with carcassone Cascadia or some type of card game like Trio Rebel princess and recently Skull King coup is a good choice but personally it is a game I don't enjoy playing anymore I'm sure theme can make a beginner enjoy a more complex game but in my experience it did not matter too much if the players are heavy video game players I feel confident trying more complex games and that has worked out well in the past depends on the background of the people involved I I agree with all of that with the exception of coup uh unless someone had a long history of say poker and really like felt comfortable with bluffing mechanics so again it's understanding contextually what uh people may be comfortable with or more familiar with uh but coup has such a dependence on someone just confidently saying well I take three with my duke um and they have no Duke in sight they've never even seen a Duke you know like it's a game that relies on that um which I think is easily picked up but I I'm always trying to be cognizant of the person who um doesn't want to look like an idiot in front of everyone else um and I don't know I I don't know that I would reach toou um but I I I think the
for the most part that listener is spawn on um I kind of agree with cou I think my issue with it is it relies on players being a similar knowledge of the game levels like I think a person who has not played coup before is going to be at such a massive disadvantage in that game from some compared to somebody who has played for a while or like just played a hand they're throwing off The Meta you know if you have an existing group suddenly this is a wild card that's in there they don't even know what they're doing who knows what they're what they're introducing um yeah you know like I I think if someone's not afraid of losing um and they're like yeah you know like if they understand that they're probably going to lose uh then I think that that's fine uh because within three games of coup which you could knock out in half an hour uh then they're going to have the majority of what they need to have a Fighting Chance you know yeah in a similar way and this is a game that I do think makes for a good Gateway game just because of how in my mind like the cards tell you what they do uh would be love letter I think that's another game that rabid Victor didn't necessarily mention but I do think that would be a a one that fits
fits the general uh Vibe of games that he recommended which is just you know this is a lighter game the cards themselves you you there's less bluffing involved so people might be more confident in uh you know just being being a little bit more like oh how does this card work like I just don't know what does this do it and that is another game that I feel like definitely rewards a person who has played at least once or twice before but be because the game the rounds are so quick and then the game is Just like a handful of rounds it you can easily go like oh okay I I understand how this all works now same thing's true with skull or any number of those games but I I think that same disadvantage would be there for anyone who is playing it for the first time even if they've played hundreds of games in the past you're picking up what is the unique Cadence and and leeway that you have uh to kind of bluff your way around that game um hit me with your next one with what what's the next comment the second comment is from gigas news and it it says love it depends so much on the person SLG group I love figuring out a great game for a group of casual gamers some aspects I'll think about great art it will often make people like the game before we've even started I also think
it contributes greatly to the experience and it's often so much nicer than what people are used to from the old classics they know theme obviously what kind of stuff will this group like uh analysis paralysis potential some new players are surprisingly prone to it and too many people it doesn't even Cur to think about what to do before it's their turn and I don't like to be the person that constantly tells them to start thinking about their turn early complexity is this group already familiar with for example turn-based video games is it a group people who work in Tech and might be into something a bit more crunchy um I think this brings up a lot of great points I think art is a really good selling point like people are I think much more forgiving if they're like oh this looks really cool this is fun to look at even if I don't quite get the rules just yet um and then analysis paralysis potential uh that is that is very true I think because people are and I again I think this Loops back to what you've said previously which is people are scared to look silly and look like they've made a mistake people who are new to the Hobby who aren't as used to losing or like you know I'm going to test this out I'm going to I'm going to mess around and find out uh are very
prone to not being able to make a decision in a in a short time span mhm and I think that again comes back to a a good Gateway game is something that you can see the ramifications of your actions fairly quickly um and there's a limited number of choices I'm not saying it has to be three it's it doesn't have to be Abyss even though I use that as a a solid example um but you know like where the the impact of your decision is the opportunity cost is a great example because you know you want to do all the things in your turn there's only four or five different things that you can do and by taking something you're giving up access to another because someone else is going to hop on to that that gives you a good understanding of consequences um and then you know like someone doesn't have to know rules for 15 different things they just need to know what the the handful of things that they can do on this turn uh are going to be and you know like our our listeners are really hitting on it um as we've talked about know your audience learn a little bit more about them try to get a little bit of context before you say well this is the game for you yeah totally um and
then this is not a listener question but this is my final question for you that uh just to kind of wrap it up if you had to choose in a vacuum one game that would serve as the Gateway game for all people joining the hobby for for forever what game would you choose oh my god oh boy has to be as universal as possible Gateway game I mean right off the top of my head I'm thinking harmonies uh because it has such vibrant beautiful illustrations it has a a simpler mode a slightly more complex uh more difficult mode in the water side and then the additive ability to add the um uh the the Spirit uh to it uh it has really TCT tactile components uh and again you're making very small choices but they are impactful and consequential um though my instinct as you were saying the question uh was Century spice Road uh because that is so distilled like even more than Splendor in my mind um like the number
of things that you can do is so small uh and the the thing that you can accuse centry of is being like overly polished you know overly Bland you know like it is maybe too uh distilled um but it works so well at showing exchange um the the expansion of capabilities uh and uh wordlessly guiding you towards objectives um that I think it anyone could learn it but it has a significant amount of things going on under the hood that make it a satisfying game I I mean I think both those would be great choices Harmony is definitely I think at this exact moment I would be hesitant just because there's I I just have I feel like a ton of recency bias with it but like my exactly that's is is super into and she's like a person who I don't necessarily think of as a person who is very into board games but like I think that's a great entry point for her it is it's a game that also I think rewards playing more which I feel like can then get people into the hobby if they are now like oh I play this game oh I can try another game but you know I know how this works I but yeah I guess my one concern with it is
just it's so recent I don't know how it's going to hold up up like I I think that it clearly is a very solid game especially in this realm of uh like this specific space in board games um I think I think the the go ahead go ahead no you go you no no I okay sir um to stick with the Bruno catala thing uh I think King Domino is an incredible design uh it relies on the kind of cultural connotations of dominoes um you're building an expansive Empire you can quickly see what the complications are and like when you start making bad decisions you could see the Noose kind of uh pulling um it's vibrant the illustrations have a lot of nuance on them you be like oh this one has a cool dragon Shadow on it um and uh the choices are very simple but very meaningful um and there's a reason why it was such a hit uh it it is something that I only break out with more casual gamers or newer Gamers at this point you know like if that is the level of complexity that people don't want to go beyond then I love playing it
um admittedly I don't break it out all the time when I'm playing with my wife or other friends who are coming over but I do keep it in my collection um because I like that game quite a bit and I I think that it's an incredible uh Ambassador for the hobby yeah I think I'm torn between Sushi go which we've talked about I think that that just is a game that is easy easy to understand it's easy to like teach and pick up and play but it also teaches so many fundamental board game concepts of like Tableau building set collection uh the picking one card that this is going to be your card and you have to you have to make a choice between these seven cards to start out with um and it also just is it's really cute the artwork is there and I think that because it is simultaneous play it just is like a really fast game to play through a few different rounds and the I'm between sushigo and uh flam Rouge I think flam Rouge the reason that I think it's a really Universal game is it is so visually clear what's happening where it's oh this person's really far ahead we're catching up to them they're
getting exhaustion cards cards I think that it teaches a lot of Concepts in board games like deck management um it makes you really interact with the players around you where you're like oh how far do I think Eric's going to go this round because he's I'm drafting behind him and I don't want to get ahead of him um I think that that's a game that I feel is just it has amazing table presence where you you know you build out the you build out your track and bikes are a pretty solid like bikes and racing are pretty solid uh reference point for people where I feel like it's a theme that isn't off-putting well at the same time being like pretty pretty captivating for people who are just vaguely aware of what's going on it's both elegant and has kind of a toy element out the track and as much as I love heat um which is essentially the the same system and uh an evolution of the concept um heat is exactly what you don't want uh in uh onboarding someone I think because that sequence of play uh requires you to do things that can easily be forgotten um
and when someone is feeling vulnerable and learning a brand new thing and you as an experienced player forget something and go like oh right I forgot to do that blah blah that makes their confidence drop even further yeah um and uh that's not always the best I have seen so many experienced Gamers Play Heat and then go like oh right uh forgot that okay so back up just a little bit and do this it is a fabulous game I love heat but I I totally agree that I think flam Rouge would be the better introduction to the hot yeah I think that there's a ton of games that can be great Gateway Games and I think that there's we're we're at a time where it's it's the Golden Age of Gateway Games I think there are a lot of people who are looking to make games that are in this ballpark in terms of difficulty but also so kind of fun and approachable in a way that I think now is a great time to be getting figuring out what Gateway Games you want to make sure are in your collection yeah and I I shouted out Bruno catala but Phil Walker Harding who did Sushi go uh has really explored this realm um fantastically uh with um uh emot is a great example exle or emot
duel and then uh gizmos is another fantastic uh example of games with few options really meaningful decisions and still feels good like as an experienced gamer you're still like yeah I'm doing cool things in this game totally yeah and I think that there's there are so many games that we didn't necessarily touch on and I think that you and I would both love to hear what people people think of as their like Gateway game uh like when you think about it what's the game that comes to mind feel free to comment on whatever platform you are on if you have any questions related to Gateway games or uh whatever our topic is going to be next week we'll post about that on our YouTube channel so keep an eye out for that um but any comments you have post them on the platform you are consuming this podcast or feel free to email us at cardboard Herald gmail.com um as always thank you so much for tuning in thank you for being an awesome Community uh I am Eric with a cardboard Herold along here with Jack that's me later um