Top 10 House Rules in Board Games - My Personal Fixes
Transcript
thank you hi folks welcome to the show I'm Luke Hector and I'm the broken meeple this is a show devoted to board games where I get reviews top tens and always give my honest opinion regardless of the consequences that might befall me we'll get on with the top 10 in just a second but first I want to say a quick word from the sponsor of this channel as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.co.uk Candor stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on audio is over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded bacteria's points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kinder and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so today I'm taking a look at top 10 house rules now I don't mind house rules as much as some people there are those that will pathologically not touch the rules to any game they'll say no no it's perfect as it is the designer wanted it this way this is how it should be played Purity no this is how the designer wanted it played might not be the best way to play it everything can be improved there is no such thing as a flawless game so I don't like toss out house rules willy-nilly but occasionally I will decide you know what I think we could just tweak one or two aspects here and it won't be too bad
typically that tends to happen in maybe a solo game in which case nobody around the table needs to care that I've done a house rule but some of these ones on the list are multiplayer games and I don't always get my way to introduce it as a house rule unless I'm teaching it of course I don't like to say to other people like look I do it with a house rule you should use it no no no that's not the way I'm talking here but if someone else is teaching the game I'll suggest it and then the group can decide but if I'm teaching it and I want to throw it in we're throwing it in deal with it that's just the way it is but you know these ones aren't huge rule tweaks I mean some of them are a little bigger than others but these are just little minor things that you know what that they come to mind these are ones I want to throw in and I'll be interested to know in the comments what house rules use for your games or maybe the games I've mentioned because there could be an extensive list of like compendium of house rules that everybody's used and I don't tend to have too many I mean trying to come up with 10 that I could remember for this list was a little tricky because there may be some really obscure house rules I use elsewhere that I come up so rarely that I don't actually recall them but these ten definitely recall them definitely have used them in the past and a couple are a little bit like ah whatever but you know certainly you know when we get higher up no these are a really interesting little house rules and I dare say that there's one or two from this list that you'll want to take for your own so without further Ado it's time to get on with it foreign is not a massive tweak for one game
where it features for the other game it's a bit more major and I still think that you should do this in that game because I just don't get the point otherwise but I don't own either game and I don't even like one of them so it's like ah whatever that's why it's my number 10. but this one caters for Shadows of a Camelot and gloomhaven both of them use this run they're fundamentally different game so what on Earth do they have in common they have something with involving hidden information and it kind of makes sense in gluven but even then I just think it's not worth the while you know Game Haven I already I'm not a fan of mainly because it's a Euro game disguised as a Dungeon Crawl so anything that makes me want to love it for a Dungeon Crawl I don't like because it's not done well enough and then you get the Euro side of it which some aspects are just saying okay now you're just turning it into a puzzle when it really shouldn't be you know out of that Mage night but with this one the hidden information is the idea that you have cards in your hand and in some in glenhaven's case there are initiative values and in Shadows of a camelot's case you just simply can't say what number from one to five is and so you have to basically come up with some stupid way to sort of say to other players you know you know you know oh I can go in let's see let's take Shadows of a Camelot right I need to somebody says right I could really do with a five at this point you know and you have to basically go I can really help you with this point and uh you know I you know what I can I'm not someone you should rely on I'm not useless I'm just a little bit more than useless and it's
just God's sake just tell me you got two or four or five or something it's stupid stupid and stupid it's this artificial way to try and introduce humor into a game that's not how you do humor okay it doesn't work in gloomhaven it's not meant to be humorous but you initially values to dictate what order you can go in and so you might play a card to want to do something and then you know just buy a sheer dumb luck somebody might be going before you and it screws you over particularly with picking up loot yo I want to pick up this loop from the floor oh you happen to go first oh well you get all the cool stuff all right um I guess I just wasted my time playing that card then why can't you just simply say that I got a 25 I got a 49 I got an 84. because technically if you know the game well enough to have played it so that you memorized half the cards you could technically just play gloomhaven with a cheat sheet and get around this problem so this is only for people who are so new to the game that they don't know these cards I just don't get why it's a thing so I just house rule just tell you what the card is I have a five this is the 25 get that stupidity out of the way and just move on foreign number nine I need to grab a little party game down here here we go have not got this out in a long time but Sheriff of 99 still a really cool party game really still like it however there is one aspect to the game that really fundamentally needs a house rule change because there is no point for the actual rule that's in there when you are taking
cards you have the ability to take cards and then when you discard them you have two discard piles that you can decide where to go because when I it has been a while since I've played it but basically you can kind of see what cards are there and you can draw from them and that and but you have two discard piles house roll just have one nobody cares about your stupid two discard power rule it's ridiculous this is a game where you are lying to each other about whether you've got free chickens in your bag or four loaves of bread do you really think I need this weird gamery mechanic where you're drawing or discarding to specific discard piles it's just a weird fiddly rule it just makes for a more mess on the table just have a single discard path I don't care what someone discarded down to it I don't care what someone drew from it because at the end of the day I'm relying on whether the person is lying to me by just you know General Bluff tactics then I care about trying to press my luck as to whether they drew certain cards probably whatever it's not like somebody's gonna go right well I'm gonna draw three cards from here they're all red and then say right I got five chickens it's like they're not stupid enough to do that so I'm not exactly gleaming much information there and it's it's one of those things it's stupid it's fiddly and I just don't see the point in it you know just have one discard pile one deck nice and simple and like I say keep it that way this game should not be made fiddly or complex it's a light party game it is great fun it's just meant to be for laughs stop taking it so seriously why
it's so serious foreign number eight this is a house rule that I've only really just started using like this month I've started using it so it can really go too high on the list but this is a rule I'm going to incorporate in pretty much every game I play of this multiplayer despite really loving the game it's a 9 out of 10 for me and I really adore it and that is Wayfarers of the South Tigress I actually just played this at handycon recently actually big long four player game but still enjoyable however we didn't use this house rule then because I figured well people are still learning it again and I didn't want to you know add in extra bits but then we got discussing it and then I discussed it with a couple of people on the Instagram and YouTube and that when I was talking when I showed off the game photos and I thought yeah maybe I should have thrown it in the idea with Wayfarers of the South Tigers is that you have all these different card rows and you know you're collecting cards they've got tags and icons on them and you're using that to get points and progress on the journal track oh cool there is a rule where you can look at the top three cards of a deck when you're drawing a new card but it requires you to have a carrier pigeon or another provisional to do so and I do stress that people need to use that ability more often in this game when they complain about swingy luck okay they're just not doing that often enough however that's not to say they're entirely wrong the luck factor of the cards coming out and not being the ones that you're looking for can be a bit of a hindrance because they don't cycle unless people take cards so you do
sometimes end up with situations even on a four player game where a bunch of cards remain stagnant and there's not a lot you can do about it but with this house rule you can very simply you might need to use a token for this as well though if you can't remember it there is a period in the game when each of you will rest and when you rest you get your dice back and you do stuff you know it's basically an admin thing for yourself but what I want to also do at rest time is that you flip a token or you know or indicate that you have rested okay let's say the first time you've rested okay and then when each person around the table has rested once you look at all the card rows and discard the innermost card the one that's been there for longest all of them Scrat gone refresh the row it just keeps the game cycling a little bit more and you just reset and go again so the next time everybody re does a rest action once you spin off that card it keeps it moving adds a little bit of tension a little bit of that speed Factor because it's like right when's the next time somebody's resting ah free people have rested uh if somebody if you if you decide to rest that card's gone I maybe should think about buying that soon you know it adds that cool little bit but it keeps the cards rolling and now you might be thinking well hang on a minute what about the meeples because they stay stuck on the cards where do they go just move it to the next card along that's all it is you know just you know if they're on that card that's getting discarded they shift to the next one nice and easy it creates some little tactical points where you might think well you know those meeples are going to shift to that card I kind of fancy you know what I'll wait for that person to rest and then they'll go buy that card it just adds another cool little decision to make in the game it's pretty
easy to include you could even not even mention it's a house rule frankly because if you describe it with the rest of the game you think it was built in already but if you're having a problem with the fact the cards don't cycle enough maybe throw this one in foreign is a little bit of a boring one because I use this in a lot of different games and frankly a lot of other people do too it's kind of one of those Universal house rules that you can Chuck into any game where you think that the card draw luck is too much the poster chart I'm using for this one though is vidiculture because viticulture people complain about the visitor cards they say that those visitors are too swinging too you know too insane well if you use the advanced ones from the Tuscany expansion or one of the expansion ones that is mitigated because they tend to have multi-choice and I usually find that they're okay but if you want to try and mitigate that Sweeney like a little bit then simply just do the universal house rule draw two keep one you know nice and easy any time that you have to draw cards from that deck you draw two choose one that way you just get more cards to look at and this works in pretty much any game that requires you to draw cards from a deck if you feel that there is just like oh you know what but there's like only so many of these and I kind of am looking for it draw two choose one because then at least you just get to see more and maybe you still won't find it whatever card draw like has that effect in games but this just mitigates it to a bit and in viticulture it's not often you have to draw more than one card of a type so it's usually fairly
easy to do draw two keep one without getting too confused if you have to draw multiple cards then just draw two choose one draw two choose one or you could say all right just make it one more than the number you drew so if I've got to draw two cards I simply draw three cards and choose two you know whichever way you want to do it but this works in a lot of games and it's one of the easiest ways to mitigate card draw luck for the culture definitely makes a difference though in fact I use this every time I'm teaching video culture I will put this house rule in just to Stave off the inevitable complaint that some people will have over it I mean Stone Mario games are not known for their balance at the best of times oh come on I feel that when you throw this one into video culture it does a decent enough job
my number six is for a very old classic game but not the rule that you might be thinking this one is carcassarian and you're probably thinking all right okay it's the whole draw at the end of your turn thing it's not granted that is a house rule that I use but frankly who the hell doesn't use that in every game of carcasso to make the whole idea that in all the iterations they've done they have still to this day in the basic rule book not put in the rule draw a tile at the end of your turret it mitigates downtime what is wrong with you z-man games get the point stupid it's stupid but what I'm talking about though is actually a rule that gives you a little bit more decision space and a little bit more in the way of options and some people already do this and I'm in favor of it as well which is to have to handle three tiles so you only draw one tile at the end of your turn as normal again always draw at the end of your term but instead of just having one tile in your hand that could be just useless for you you can instead have a hand of three and you choose is one of the free to do your term with so at least if you do have a tile that's not going to work for you at this point you might have another tile that will and for the most part are just different shapes than that but again it's useful to not have to rely solely on tile draw luck this is one mainly for gamers because if you're teaching this to brand new people you really shouldn't over complicate it or give them too many options to think about on their turn just one Tower will be enough but if you're gonna throw like millions and like you know like die hard Gamers into a game of carcassone I'd probably want to throw in the free tile rule because
it's not that hard to decide between three tiles and it just adds more options more decision space rather than letting the game dictate whether I get a tile that's useful or not I can't you know I can't stress how much I hate in carcassone if I'm like right I could just do with anything that's got a city on it and I draw like some stupid little singular Road and that's it oh great well that literally does nothing for me at least if I had three tiles wouldn't necessarily have that problem
for my number five we are going to what has been one of my favorite games of all time like I said no game is Flawless every game can be improved in some way and this is of course one of my old times Sentinels of the Multiverse and it's like you're thinking wait a minute Luke this used to be your number one and could very well still go but back to number one who knows but this is a 10 out of 10 game for you how can you possibly have a house rule for this it's actually a more gamery house rule it's not one that I throw when I'm teaching new new players this game but if I'm teaching experience sorry I remember with experienced players or if I'm playing this solo I love to throw this one in the idea and sent knows is that you have your Heroes that say three Heroes go up against the villain and there's an environment each one with their own deck the villain takes the turn then the three Heroes and then the environment and then rinse repeat it goes in a cyclical man the cyclical Cool Whip Cool Whip Cool Whip Cool Whip I can't pronounce that word but it basically goes in a circle okay villain hero hero hero environment and Prince repeat feet the heroes have to go in a set order for the whole game so Legacy followed by tachyon versus by The Wraith why why can't they select the turn order that's the house rule I throw in particularly for a solo game if I've got the villain they take their turn I have three heroes in front of me why must It Go in order why can't I decide you know what this round I want tachyon to go first and then the Brave and then Legacy I like your plan except it sucks so let me do the plan and that way it might be
really good this leads to more tactical play it leads to more cooperation with the players because you can openly discuss who should go first and sometimes you might find it doesn't make a difference but when you've got power effects like legacies plus one damage you know you typically want that to go first in the round but then there could be something where you know if The Wraith could just get off this little device ability now then others would benefit from this or you know if it's a case of right there's an ongoing card there it's really doing my heading all right well hang on if The Wraith takes the hit and does and gets rid of it first then the other two yes you won't necessarily have the damage boost on your turn but at least you won't be hampered by that thing and this just I think just makes for a more tactical gamery version of Sentinels because I just don't get why it has to go in sequence I get maybe they just did that for simplicity's sake but I think zeon's end did something similar with three players where you could dictate what order they went into I got problems with zeon's end but you know I still think that was a good little rule even though elongated the game a lot in Sentinels yeah this could potentially elongate the game but again teacher with experienced players in that fashion or for me I'll just use it solo I got three Heroes and you know what I wanted to decide what order they go in not the game are you on my team just represent Paul all right let's go foreign number four this one is mostly for three and four players it can work with two but two players not too bad with this in terms of its length this is a length like mitigator because the game in
question Meadow which sits down there very lovely little game it replaced quadropolis for me beautiful lovely little card Tableau game that really outstays its welcome if you're not careful with three or four players particularly at four it is a grind at four and it's just a mess on the table this is a table hold like crazy and the expansion Downstream as much as I love the cover is a great expansion but man does it do nothing to mitigate the time length because you have these action tiles that you use to select the cards around that grid and then in the downstream expansion it adds another one so it doesn't mitigate the timeline if it adds to it that's not what you should do in a game so what's my house rule two players you just stake it you just have all the tiles because two player go goes back and forth back and forth back and forth and it doesn't take too long but you could maybe put this one in for two player but with three and four my house rule is you remove a tile every round and people might think well this will mess up by comparison of BGG stats I don't care because I don't put my stats on bgd of games I've won in their coins it's not interesting it's not fun for me it's not a competition but with this you've got to curb that timeline if you've got to mitigate the downstream expansion and frankly even without the downstream expansion I'm throwing this into the base game of meta with three or four players every single time I teach it you normally have a one two three and four tile to use I think that there's a question mark wild Tower but I think you only get that in two players I could be wrong it's been a while since I've
played it too but with the expansion you then get the one two three four and that River tile I say each round one of those tiles you can't use you get to pick which one you don't use it's not random it's not Sweeney luck but you let's say you've got the one two three 34 in the river tile one round you might say I don't want to take anything from the river section okay fine you might say well you know I'm going to use the free now I need the one I could really use that River and then you gotta decide oh hang on am I using the two or the four ah okay go make a decision here it's another decision to make but it cuts the length one less action around it makes a difference particularly in three and four players I don't care if it makes the points a little bit weird it it was not noticeable to anybody playing it but when you sit down with the downstream expansion you play a four player game of this and it takes nine on two hours you want to kill everybody that escalated quickly you do it hurts it's not something I want to repeat ever again so I will always throw this in and certainly it means that I don't want to play anybody else's copy of meadow with three or four players unless they're gonna put some mitigation in because it really does take too long at those player accounts remove a tile every round
three we're talking about a nice little card game very cute little card game which surprised me actually I didn't think for a game that cost me six pound on Amazon to get like a German version even though it's multilingual you know that people were suggesting to me I should play after I think I did my top 10 tiny games list or whatever it was before that I don't know you surprised me how much I liked Ohana me now Ohana me is a really cool little filler game you're trying to collect cards and you you place them in three columns but you can't go in between the numbers so if I put a 55 down and then I put a 60 down I can't put a 56 7 whatever you know I can't go in between that bit and you're trying to collect the different types of colored cards and it scores you points in different ways throughout the game it's a really clever little game tight scoring that you wouldn't expect honestly give it a shot but there is one rule that you must ignore in fact I think everybody ignores this rule I I would be curious to know if there's anybody out there who plays with this rule because it is just dumb when you draft the cards you draft the cards each time there is a rule in this where the turn order for when you place down a card is dictated I believe it's been so long since I've played it but it's essentially based on who chose the cards first or who played a card first I mean that's essentially it it's this weird thing you're supposed to keep an eye on there's the witch player around the table did something first and then the turn order is done from then well that was pointless it makes subtle difference frankly I don't care what the turn order is I'm not going to base my decision as
to whether I keep a card or not on whether you played a particular number because there's 120 odd numbers in the deck and we're not going to use most of it so what difference does it make that you've done that just ignore that rule in the house rule I use is that it's simultaneous you just do it simultaneous it is so much simpler if you do it that way you draft the two cards you then go right ready flip and then you do what you're gonna do if you're not if you're gonna Bing it you simply don't flip it you know simultaneous nice and quick the game goes a much quicker Pace that whole fiddliness is gone I honestly cannot fathom why you would prefer to do it with the rules as written then these simultaneous rules and I if you are one of these people who disagrees with me on this please please put a comment in and tell me why because at the moment I can't fathom why you need to tell me it's just such a weird rule simultaneous quick flip nice little drafting game it's a filler it's not meant to be stupid strategic or anything you're kind of semi-pressing your luck whilst also trying to hate draft the other player because you know he doesn't like these particular numbers they're not my favorite but I can work with them I'll take these two and leave you with a couple of hundreds that you hate haha you know it's that's the sort of game it is why they thought this whole turnover thing would work I mean why couldn't they have just fought simultaneous what was what I'd rather be able to fly on the wall in that like game design room that made them think that was a good thing I don't know I could ran on for ages as I say ignore that rule simultaneous card flip Ohana me works
wonders stupid it's stupid my number two is I wouldn't say it's a cheat but this one has kind of been fixed with the upgrade settings for this game and what's coming out in 2.0 of this game but for ages I was using this house Rule and so were a lot of people and the fact that people complained about this enough in the game despite as much as I enjoy it meant that they had to come up with a better way of doing it in 2.0 of Tainted Grail tainted Grail is probably my go-to campaign game as much as I Rave about this war of mine in that free act campaign that's probably the best campaign when you consider the length Factor but if we're going to talk about one of these long drawn out campaigns that takes multiple games multiple chapters and everything tinted Grail is the one that I have downstairs and put my stock behind because the setting and the writing and the gameplay are just for me you know it just works and others have come alone and tried the Isis Vanguard and that and oh swan in their decent games but I can only play so many Campaign games and tainted growl works for me I've even played the 2.0 version on the preview video I did last year check out that video and I'm looking forward to see you know more of that setting and possibly even see how the 2.0 rules influence the old rules because you can get basically an upgrade kit but the problem was these men years awakened Realms does not really understand the concept of grinding in their games as much as I like their
games they really need to understand that padding out the content by ways of grinding is annoying we don't like it in video games we sure as hell don't like it in board games get a clue hello hello anybody home so basically there were these men here and the men hears were how you traveled across the map you had to activate them with resources and it got intensive at times these were a grinding pain because you constantly had to keep them on a timer which meant that they whittled down then you had to get them back up and then they Whittle down you had to keep getting back up and if you just got unlucky with a particular you know like Excursion you were doing you just basically write the mercy of these things and you could waste hours of the game just trying to grind for the stuff you need to activate the things they are a pain 2.0 does it a lot better and I'm glad to say they have but in the original you basically I say you had to have free Max and they were indefinite no timer at all the time camera is gone once you've lit it it will stay there until you manually get rid of it and by manually get rid of it I mean that you can only have three men years up at a time so they will never go away but as soon as you decide you want another one later you've already got free you've got to decide which one goes poof and goes out of the way for a bit this enables you to get across the map as normal but it also means that if you just want to hang out in a small area and have fun with the uh the journal exploration or do a little bit of resource Gathering and stuff you haven't got to think oh God things ticking down ah what am I gonna do around and two hours later you've had to grind more resources that
you've just spent the time collecting for something else it's a pain I'm glad they fixed this for 2.0 I mean it's not entirely fixed but it's done more better and it's more better it's done better and there is a way to get around it and the sort of immediate other cost you can pay to get them up if need be so definitely 2.010 degrees and Improvement but man did I have to house rule this constantly in my solo games because it just got ridiculous found anything yet we ain't
fine finally the Universal house rule that I will now throw into as many games as I can because this rule is just such a clever design choice that I'm surprised no one came up with it before this is now the poster child I'm using is wingspan I love wingspan but this house will work perfectly for it but it's not so much a house rule that I've come up with I wish I could take credit no I have to give credit to one of my other favorites art Nova because art Nova came up with this idea and I think it's so good that if I have a chance to throw it into a game I will that's why it's my number one this is a house rule that basically is so good it needs to be in more games and this is the objective discourage rule in Arc Nova you are given two objectives at the start of the game but I hate it when you get given two objectives and you have to pick one because it's the start of the game nothing's happened how the hell do I know what's going to happen I've got no idea what's gonna happen all right Leo will I draw these cards will I get reds this game will I have to find animals with a title with a color in the name I don't know I don't know what's gonna happen and you might think well okay it gives you something to aim for aim for it doesn't come out of the decks you're screwed all right nowhere has a really clever thing that when you get to a certain point on the track the points track which typically doesn't happen till at least halfway through the game if not later you at that point discard one of the objectives you started with so you've got half a game to dip side whether one of these objectives is
better for you or not have I got I've got to collect water icons or I've got to get uh what's another good example or I've got to build my entire Zoo all right fine as I get to that point I'm realizing that I'm not doing too well on the water icons but I have flipped my build card and I could try and finish my map you know what boom we'll bend that and I'll stick with this that just works wonders why is wingspan the poster child because the bonus cards the bonus cards are woefully underpowered in wingspan I know people talk about the eggs being more powerful but the Oceano expansion kind of fits that fixes that with the board but the bonus cards are still a bit of a hit and miss affair because you might start off with one that is fantastic for you or you might just start off with one that whiffs entirely and I'm not worth that many points unless you really do well with it and then again you have to get two of them at the start and decide which one to bin how the hell do I know what I'm supposed to been here's the house rule Incorporated in the wingspan though it's four rounds Long when you get to the end well first off when you start the game you're dealt two bonus cards keep both of them right keep both and then at the end of round two specifically round two which is the halfway point from rounds perspective discard a bonus card doesn't even have to be one of the ones you started with because there are birds that you can play with that you draw more bonus cards you just discard one this does wonders that bring the bonus cards back to a power level where they are things that you should actually start thinking about and they're not just throw away points because you might start off with two cards and then as you
get more birds you realize you're actually doing well with both of them but you played a bird that you let you drew another bonus card you're like hmm that didn't exactly work out for me you know what I'll discard that one and keep the original too but even if you don't play any of those birds you don't get any more bonus cards just being able to wait until halfway through the game after you've got some birds seeing what's going on what other people have got before you decide hmm do I want to check out this one that wants me to get loads of baskets with eggs in them or this one that requires me to get birds that have all got people's names in the title well I found quite a lot of Tom Dick and Harry Birds during the game so I'll get rid of that one and keep this one my God is at work wonders here and I will yeah I I don't just want to do it in my games of wingspan I will actively take measures to try and convince the person teaching wingspan that it should be in the game that's how much I think this rule works and I say wingspan but honestly any game any game that says draw two or multiple objectives at the start of the game and pick one where you have no idea what you're choosing if there is a way that I can think of to incorporate the art Nova role in those games I will do it hence this is my number one this needs to be in more designs of games I'm staggered that it's not been fought up before I'm staggered that since I've not seen this used but I'm certainly gonna throw it in and I hope a lot of you do as well so there we go top 10 house rules and maybe I've played others or not even realized there were house rules but
these 10 came to mind and I had to talk about them like these were definitely ones that I use or want to use maybe there's another house rule there that I've used as well but if it's not that important or I can't remember it then it clearly wasn't a top 10 wordy one but I do have some other ones on my honorable mention so first off hive mind hide mine great little party game you've got to answer questions like you know things you would keep in name four things you keep in your pocket or something and then people write down the answers and you're trying to come up with answers that everybody else has also come up with great party game love it but the amount of times that you know the amount of people that go down the slots because you're trying to stay in the hive not get kicked out the amount of time amount of people that do that is only one for most of the while until you get to this point around the board where it starts being two or three you roll a die at the start of the turn and you move the queen bee alone and eventually it gets to that Loop and starts going round well house rule keep start at the Loop because it takes multiple turns to get to that Loop and all that while only one person is going down the level it just elongates the game too much to start at the Loop and make things a bit more chaotic it's just more fun and it curbs the time length down that way but like I say it's purely the hive mind uh King of Tokyo I hate the idea that you've got to start in Tokyo when you roll a claw because people are hesitant to roll Claws and King of Tokyo is not a game where you should be hesitant to roll claws you know I should be loving the fact that I roll claws because I get to damage people but the first person to go into Tokyo usually gets on by a lot of
other people by the time they go in there and so can't we just randomize who's in Tokyo from the get-go like maybe roll all the dice and whoever gets the most claw starts in Tokyo it just makes for a weird first term but it goes away pretty quickly so it's not a big deal but you'll just feel that maybe it could have been changed somewhat oh man dollar Stones oh my God you remember that abstract game from board and dies I cannot believe somebody came up with this dumb rule in the rule book but the idea is is that when you put this pillar down you take these Stones around the edge of the pillar and you use it and you put in stacks on your board the rule book makes this stupid elongated way of saying that you've got to pick them up in a particular like clockwise Direction and then flip it over or like invert yeah you gotta do all this fiddly stuff with it and it's like yeah but you tell me to turn it go clockwise and then flip it in all this lot going anti-clockwise would achieve the exact same effect and I don't have to do any weird flippery nonsense it's just who
detail about how to do this Rule and it's so dumb that nobody uses it house rule just do it randomly or go anti-clockwise whatever it makes more Sensei uh let's see stroganoff her don't replenish the The Furs that you get from the market don't replenish them until the end of a turn normally you replenish as you go for your turn but all this does is that as soon as another one comes out the person has to reevaluate their options and then you get AP and it elongates the turn just don't replenish the fur Market until they're done with their turn and then you don't get that problem and see and finally planted planted I actually finally got to play planted actually uh uh when did I uh was it in April yeah it wasn't April damn I should have put that on my uh eight pool was that April I felt like it was maybe it was in March I can't remember but basically I did get to play it recently and I think the game is fine it does the job it's nice and simple but I do not think that you need to rush out and get a copy because it's like so hard to find outside of the US target market it's a fine game but in two players the display of cards that you choose from does not cycle anywhere near quick enough so a little house rules at the end of every round two of them scrap you scrap every you scrap a couple of cards every round because otherwise in two player that market just gets really stagnant and that's not good in any game that has card tableaus three and four player they cycle a bit more often you just need to
throw that little bit extra in to make the two player game a little bit more shall we say fluid rather than static if that makes sense so that's it for me this episode of the broken meeple if you like what you see please thumb it up on YouTube and share the video on social media if you can let's get some discussion topics going on on Facebook and that but also let me know in the comments what your house rules are what house rules do you use in games often and which ones have really fixed problems with the game do you agree with the house rules I've come up with do you have alternate versions are you one of these people that plays on anime by the bass rules seriously why but still get your comment down below and let me know why if you are one of them and you know this could be an interesting little compendium of house rules on this video I think it's quite an interesting little topic because it's not like people will think like oh you know you're using a house rule let's add disrespecting a designer no the designer still did a lot of great stuff for something like wingspan or you know or other games I've mentioned it's not like I'm saying Your Design sucks I'm just saying that I think your design is great because I love your game but maybe just this one little tweak it's just a tiny little bit of constructive criticism that maybe if we were debating it they would probably still go nah I still kind of like it the way it is that's cool I'm just going to tweak it when I play it whoopee I still love the game I still recommend the game to other people there's no none of these house rules I think are deal breakers well maybe I'll Hannah me but let's face it that's not a massive deal it's not a massive Game Changer but for example if we wanted to play Wayfarers of the South
tigers and nobody wanted to use that discard cycling rule big whoop if somebody wants to play Sentinels and they say nah can we just go in an order whatever big whoop it's not a big deal even in Shadows of a Camelot people want to do the whole humorous thing about not saying what they got in their hand fine it doesn't kill the experience for me I just think these little tweaks make it better but that's a personal thing it's always subjective when it comes to house rules it's just the nature of the beast but anyway I'm waffling on so take care and be sure to check out more content on the channel including new the two new series I've done for best of the month and the new keeper cold series I'm doing I mean you've asked me to do some of that stuff and now it's there for you so hopefully you'll enjoy it the views are certainly saying so so thank you very much for that until next time remember regardless of whether you're a fan of house rules or not it's still only a game so take care and enjoy and bye for now
thank you