Nick Ruins Engine Building - Friendly Ties Podcast
Transcript
hey there welcome to friendly ties this is a podcast about board games and normally we talk about one game a lot in these episodes or at least that's what we've done in the past but today we actually want to be a little bit more broad and specifically we want to talk about engine building as an idea in board games uh this actually came up organically when we were recording a different episode about furnace uh just what's an engine build or what isn't and it turns out that nick is pretty opinionated nick has some strong feelings engine builders slightly finicky about engine filters and they were so strong that we're like we should have a real conversation about this i know let's record an episode so that is um why we're here essentially today um it it might seem a little pedantic uh to to to delve into this but i love engine building games or at least what i consider to be engine building yeah what you thought what you thought was an engine building do you are you sure i've got a list nick i'm ready for the debate so yeah nick take it away yeah i mean i think what's interesting is that bgg does not have engine building listed as a mechanism uh it really is yeah it's not it's not on bgg and i i looked for it because i was like um doing research for this episode and i think broadly people struggle to identify what engine building means and i think that's part of the reason why i have this pet peeve about people calling games engine building games that to me don't
feel like engine building games so in some ways i would argue that engine building is a lot more of a feeling than a mechanism and like what constitutes his engine building has like a pretty broad definition that kind of like dances uh from person to person and what works okay so we can all agree then for example furnace furnace that's an engine builder right like that that's that whole game is an engine builder it's i agree that it's an engine builder and and i and i think it's close like i i do yeah the dance that i'll go into here you'll see the engine all you do is take cards and build in it what am i doing i'm building an engine and churning little things through it and making points yeah so so the reason that furnace hits the my definition of an engine builder is because one card allows you to do another card which allows you to do another card which allows you to do another card uh but somewhere where i could argue that it's not really an engine builder it doesn't feel like engine building is if you play a version of that game where you buy all of your resources using your like losing losing the auction essentially and then using those to just convert to victory points that doesn't feel very engine building to me so most of the time you don't do that in that game the majority of the time you do this like card chain uh and so let me like let me lay out these like two
different categories like super categories that i would say like engine building falls into and for me like one that i think is a very obvious definition this is like clearly an engine builder and i i would struggle to find folks that disagree with it is combo chains this leads to this leads to this if while you're describing your action sequence you say and because of that and then this like if you use those like like addendums or prepositions that just like connect all the parts of your game plan that's an engine builder the two games that really popped out to me as being these things are steamworks and gizmos those games are like pure engine builders it's like you take an action it does this ting ting tick tick tick tick like fires off all this other stuff uh that is designed to make this combo to me those are like explicit engine building games it's really funny because i'm looking at my list right now of games that i you know when i was i brought i went through my collection and i pulled out like my top engine builders i don't think any of them do that i'm like oh boy yeah yeah so so let's talk into the let's talk about the second category which is where i really think the like core of our discussion is going to be and it's about building a system and this is where like quibbles come into play and like what does building a system even mean it usually means some private ownership that you have i don't think i've ever seen like a public engine building game but now my design brain is just like what could that look like uh you know
it's usually something that you own so a lot of like tabloid type games tend to like dance into this category one thing that i really firmly don't agree with is that income is not an engine and that is really where i disagree with other folks about what things are underwater cities being the example uh anastasia that that came up for us in the past where you were like oh underwater city's an engine builder i was like no it's not because it's just income so if it's income to me that doesn't count as like a chain and then also it depends on what other mechanisms are present in the game so uh something like a lot of deck builders have the potential to be engine building games but that deck building mechanism is so essentially fundamental to the game that it just overrides the sense of like oh i'm playing an engine builder right now and so that those tend to get into the wishy-washy category and so this like building a system building your like tableau what is your like home your home planet your your home terrain looking like uh is where stuff starts to get really gray i realized i didn't put a good definition in there and that's because i struggled to do so it seems like a key part at least as far as you're talking about it is the uh inputs and outputs that like that something is made and then you immediately use the thing that's made as an input like inputs outputs become
inputs which makes out outputs and inputs et cetera is that kind of where you're at super good framing of using inputs and outputs yeah i wish i thought of that um yeah and it's it's it's also specifically that the outputs become inputs for other outputs right it is inputs to outputs to inputs to outputs um that is the distinction for income for me that it is just like you have your in your input which is like you bought these cards and then you have your output your income and then you just like repeat that cycle which happens in a lot of games one of my favorite games the sidereal confluence which is a trading and negotiation game there's an economy phase and you have your inputs and your outputs and i would definitely not say that's an engine building game like absolutely not i think i'll wear my brain often goes with engine building or really focuses on is the building part of that phrase like engine building like you know two key words and when i think of engine builders because i up to this point and maybe maybe still i don't know maybe you'll convince me but i up to this point would have considered underwater cities to be an engine building game um at a high level um you're gonna go through these income phases where you make income but you construct buildings that make you that income and to me it's always felt like building those constructing those buildings felt like the engine like you spend resources to make buildings that then make you income for the rest of the game um you know as an ongoing thing so it's like investing in that essentially and uh they all kind of activate at the same time just spewing stuff out at the right moment in the
game giving you a whole bunch of stuff to then use to do your work replacement which you know realistically underwater cities is primarily a work replacement game but i think it's an interesting distinction between those two um having things feed in and out uh i was thinking about this a decent amount before we recorded this and one thing that popped into my head was a rube goldberg machine um you know the idea of you know the the tennis ball falls off the table and hits the racket which falls on a computer hits the space bar starts playing music and the speakers gyrate etc etc like a long series of of of systems um that you could just keep tacking on and tacking on and when i think of engine building in that way which i guess is a series of inputs and outputs becoming inputs um i'm hard pressed to find that many examples of games actually yeah i mean that's why i think i take a little bit of issue nick with this idea that income can't count right because like also what do you define as income right like so you're saying like there's an input and an output but like in underwater cities right which is the example we're using currently sure you make income but you also make like a bunch of other things so are we saying income is just money and points like that's what i hear when you say income but income's not like it's money points resources to a certain extent you could say anything where you're gaining certain things based on what you have is qualifies as income and then i'm sort of like okay then what what are you so you're you're basically
saying that it's only if i put something in and it converts something out that you considered an engine is that kind of am i understanding that correctly well there has to be a sequence there and so like underwater cities has an explicit production phase right like that is that is income right uh and i like i'm hard-pressed to say why underwater cities is an engine like what what is the thing that becomes the thing that then generates the other thing so under that same guys how do you feel about farming games that right like i've never really actually thought of farming games as engine builders i think my definition engine builder yeah but in a way in a way one might argue that they do fit your definition right like i've always thought of engine builders as i in the scope in this in the scheme of a game i have created something that is going to pay me back something so in a way i guess i've always thought of it as income production right like i've done x y and z and as i continue to go to other parts of this game this is going to continue producing for me right like i'm just going to keep getting wood or i'm going to keep getting this thing because i've done this great little setup and i can go over here now and i can use my wood to go do this other thing that's that's that's what i've considered me building an engine within a game right so that has just been my definition up to this point so in a way it actually sort of meets both of our definitions if you will you could say a farming game is a perfect example of
that right like it it i plant things and then they grow and then they do other things like so what's coming to mind for me right now is actually like haul or tau right like so you you need to you plant goods you harvest those goods and then you use those goods to move your house along this little track do you consider that to be some sort of input output no no i don't i i mean it is input and output but it's not an engine builder so that's you know again back into this place where it's fuzzy for me it sort of needs to have this chaining effect um in holler tau like you collect your crops you collect your resources and then you pay them into your house to advance or pay them into your cards or whatever it is that you're doing and then they go away um you haven't built something that sort of self-sustains or has this you know i like john you brought up the rube goldberg like that doesn't give me that like rube goldberg feeling i want my when i play an engine building game i want the feeling that i have to be at least a little bit mad scientist-y and i don't i don't feel that in the farming games and yet and yet you move your your house forward and then that gives you more workers so it does give you something else that continues i think that you are stretching the definition of what the inputs and outputs are here yeah all right guys help me out in the comments someone someone help me out here i mean i i fully acknowledge that my definition is is more esoteric and a lot more stringent than i think uh other folks are so that it's totally cool i'm just
i'm just defending what what engine building means to me and it's and it again it is that emotion that feeling because it's not a mechanism uh it's that it's that feeling of chaining that feeling of rube goldberg the mad scientist and and that doesn't happen in hotel you get you know you move your house to get more workers just makes you slightly more efficient like these little edges don't count to me interesting thinking back historically to what i've considered to be engine builders and i think i still do because let's be real this whole conversation is fun but it's also is there a point to it i don't know we're just you know kind of digging into it because it's fun to get into this there there is a point here there's there's nick tearing down the fundamental terminology of engine building and now combining it with chaining because i'm like that's a whole different mechanic nick chaining are you gonna sit here and tell me darwin's journey is an engine builder you're gonna tell me grand austria hotel is an engine builder because they chain no they're definitely they're not injured oh i'm losing it over here okay i gotta go i'm gonna regroup i'm regrouping so i thinking back more uh you know like the rube goldberg is kind of like maybe what nick's talking about but where my the basis for my thoughts on engine building is starting with not much or nothing and ending with a complicated system that that's custom to what you did over the course of the game like i have tended to think of terraforming mars as being like a quintessential
engine building game to me especially when you play with the uh without um with the advanced rules essentially where your incomes and i know okay yes incomes your incomes all start at zero like you make nothing you do nothing at the beginning of that game and at the end of the game uh and at the end of one game maybe you have you're making just monstrous amounts of plants uh or uh in the next game you're a metal baron and you just have tons of titanium and you've got asteroids crashing into the planet and you just you obviously the asteroids aren't engine but like you build a tableau and it really is a tableau builder and i do see a lot of correlations there and that's kind of what i was getting to earlier like my emphasis is on the building part of the engine building statement where you're building up like kind of stacking things on top of each other almost like little modules that maybe don't input an output into each other but they work collectively as a cohesive thing like in terraforming wars if you have a big plant strategy and then you put down a card that consumes plants and does something unexpected with them and then that unexpected output unlocks the ability to get some more points or something like that and i feel like i've made an engine in front of myself but that's just my personal definition i think anastasia's gonna strangle me when i respond to this but uh terraforming mars and pulsar with the four digits after it i'd actually done 2849 or whatever suburbia uh those those three games were ones that i put on my borderline list uh and let's so let's talk about terraforming mars right where it's like
why is it borderline an engine for me when it's definitively an engine for you first of all i i don't think that it matches the definition that we just talked about right like we just i just said no to underwater cities and you could argue that terraforming mars is exactly the same construction right you like play out cards and then there's a production phase and you get those produced resources and like that's that right there's not much like chaining that goes on there i think the thing with terraforming mars that to me feels more borderline than underwater cities is the vast quantities of things that you do in that game so to your point about building john that's what pushes terraforming mars into the borderline is this uh engine building game or not for me okay okay so folks at home i told you she'd be mad at me this is this is what we're gonna do right now we're gonna pull up my bgg collection right now and nick is gonna go through it and he's going to tell me what games are engine builders based on his definition because i i'm looking at the list of ones i pulled out and they've all been nixed at this moment so we're gonna do that so i'm looking at this okay dominion is are deck builders engine builders okay great question i put three games on my list that are games where you can build engines but are not engine builders and dominion is one of them because i can play if you play if you play big money in dominion right just to like buy gold buy victory points i would argue that you're not building an engine uh you're just playing a deck builder there's nothing
like cheney about that but like i've played a game of dominion where i built a deck that was 40 cards and it drew the entire deck every time and then it had six dollars that like made me purchase one thing or whatever um and that was very engine mad scientist feeling for sure so dominion for me sits in that place where it can do both uh because you can play the game not have built an engine and still be totally successful but it does allow you to build an engine particularly with certain cards and i've only played two or three dominion expansions of the like 70 million that there are right the other two that i put on that list by the way are wingspan and race for the galaxy games in which i think you can build an engine but don't need to to to play the game successfully but i wouldn't you say that like the very act of like for example in dominion the very active plane a big money strategy if you will does require you to put together some sort of engine i guess it's an income engine to be able to have the level you would say that but i wouldn't say that oh my goodness oh my goodness okay all right let's keep going um i'm scrolling through this separately and and i'm having a hard time finding much yeah i'm not i'm having a hard time finding anything in my collection i thought they were all engine builders you mean because i'm picky or because you're not you're you're getting convinced by my uh well i was about to say i think nick is infecting my definition so i'm
questioning everything it's also very true as we go through my collection that it's embarrassing how many of the games in my collection haven't played so some of them i'm having to skip over because i don't know them well enough let's see well i've looked through my collection as well and i had a couple pop-up that i thought would be interesting for discussion one of them being space base um that's a game where it's a dice game i mean you're rolling dice it's kind of a settler of katan style where one person rolls dice and everybody makes stuff but as you go through the game you upgrade the amount of stuff that you make on various die rolls and i know nick has played this because this was the first game you and i ever played together yeah good memories good memories uh space base machi quoro um kingdom's card kingdoms of valeria no those are tableau games not engine builders okay okay okay okay so concordia let's let's pause at that would you say so concordia is not a deck builder because you but in a way you are buying more cards would you say that your hand is somewhat of an engine builder because absolutely absolutely not oh my god concordia is is on my are you kidding me list of that people call it an engine builder and i it's not i i am like concordia is one of the ones that i'll die that i die on yeah you you have you i mean i consider i actually do
consider it personally i think you could make a stronger argument that it's a deck builder to a certain extent which you know i know it's it's not quite but the way you're collecting cards for your action selection but but you are essentially your hand in and of itself is an engine that you are you are building towards and it's doing different things i guess i honestly you're getting into my head yeah yeah yeah getting into my head it's like now i'm like every game could be an engine builder by my definition so it's like like the act of gaming yeah it's it's it's an action selection game and it doesn't do anything that that fires this off because i have this i can do this because of this i enabled this it's just like oh i'm just a little bit better at building houses or copying your thing or buying cards off the board like that's those don't have these like crazy sequences to to my mind so yeah concordia now so dissecting the the phrase engine building a little bit in order to run an engine you need gas right you need something to fire the engine and make it happen and because of that i would definitely land pretty solidly in nick's camp when it comes to concordia a game that i i love but you know that that hand of cards that you're strengthening as the game goes on like there's no gas there really you're just you're getting more tools in your uh in your toolbox it's like a toolbox game i want to fully admit that i actually think nick is right here on this one i'm just as they're going scrolling through my collection i am like desperately
searching to find one game that like it will count so um yeah i think you guys are right but i will say going back to the gas thing i personally don't feel like the engine needs to make gas for other engines for my definition like for me even just like one flow-through of you know stuff comes in and then the engine crunches and then better stuff comes out even once feels good enough to me what's like what's a gas game for you john i know i've talked about terraforming mars already but i kind of see that as being there you know the main resources in the game like plants baked into the game one of the actions that you can do is just crunch plants down and turn them into a forest tile that you put onto the board and i see the plant as kind of being the gas and i guess you know that action by itself is very lame but there's lots of fancy cards that you can put down that let you do that more efficiently or maybe just differently you know crunch those plants up and do something else with it um so i that's why i see those cards in that tableau as being you know strapping on new modules to an engine i guess that's the way i see to it like i don't think the the rube goldberg machine needs to run in a sequence i think it could just be a frankenstein of modules slapped together and you pick and choose uh when the time is right you know pouring different gases into different modules i guess i guess my thing is like from your guys's definition now now now i'm looping the two of you together we're not the same
but it feels like he's agreeing with you so okay i hear you john like yes put gas in the engine and i want to say like fundamentally i i do agree with that i think this is more like the loss of engine building as a term for me is is is hard to wrap my mind around because i i am starting to be like no genuinely like i use that term all the time and and you're right like i i'm not sure what it applies to anymore uh in a lot of ways because i have seen it more like probably my definition has been much more closely related to the income portion of it right like like i explained that the things i i set something up i kind of knock it over i guess mine's more like a metronome right like i hit the metronome and it just keeps clicking over here in the corner and then i go off and do something else and i add in another beat and another layer of music and whatever and that that's how i see it and so but the way you guys are describing it is overlapping so much for me with chaining that or what i describe as chaining that like i i do want to ask you the question nick like what what makes like a game darwin's journey comes to mind um but we could even say like golem or grand austria hotel like these games where like thing after thing feeds into thing after thing i know i never really considered any of those engine builders but since you guys are overlapping with chaining like no i don't either and i see i see what you're saying there and i do think i have a hopefully satisfying response to that in this goes back to what john said about the building part in darwin's journey or in golem you take an action that can
create a chain it might even be something that you have set up that allows that chain to occur but uh generally once you do that you can't just immediately do that again on your next turn something excludes you from doing that you've take you've selected an action or in darwin's journey is a great example because it's like you've walked somewhere on the island like you can't even take the space again you have to keep going along the island at this point and uh golem is one of the ones that kind of dances because the uh the book mechanism in that game the top of the board in golem does get close to what i would call an engine that's where you stack the cards and then you keep reactivating them and you know you get one card right now yeah yeah and another thing that you said earlier in their anastasia that i want to mention is you know you're like oh i call these things engine builders and i'll be honest with you i sometimes do too you are absolutely gonna catch me in games that we play where i say like oh yeah i'm gonna run my engine and you're like that's not an engine though i'm like you're right like you will catch me using that because it's like such a common phrase that we like tackle in board gaming it was actually part of the reason why i was so excited to do this episode to say like yes we all do say like engine building here but like that i i like i don't like the term because i feel that i'm using it incorrectly interesting so you would say based on that because i think another place where this sort of came up is in our last episode we talked about messina 1347 and and and there's a lot
of things going on in that game but we did talk about the sort of like central board and i've referred to that right like player board as like running my engine you know running my overseers around this track but under based on what you just said about golem and darwin's journey and that you know like i was thinking i was imagining like dominoes right like you can't just pick up the pieces and run it again yeah that's kind of the same thing that that same thing is kind of true in messina right like you your overseer's continuing to move so even though you're using the same spaces i guess you're reusing them do you consider that an engine builder it's a great question that one is a little bit harder for me for sure uh you're and you hit all my points for me right like which is basically that the fact that you're advancing that there's like a limited kind of usage to it but because in messina it's that that adjacency lasts for so long it is kind of enginey um i think the perks are just a little bit too small and staticky to like create that cascade effect that i'm i'm going for as you were just talking about that game though i thought about another game that i really super consider to be an engine builder and that's steampunk rally i've been trying to find a way to to bring that in yes 100 i've been sitting here being like i want to mention the steampunk rally i want to mention the steampunk rally have you played steampunk rally anastasia i haven't actually no and i'm not even that familiar with it i've i've seen i can imagine i can conjure the front of the box yeah so it's it's a
racing game uh and actually i'll tell you right now the thing that i like most about steampunk rally is that it plays like seven or eight players and they play simultaneously like you can play seven or eight players in an hour and i think that's really cool but it has this like drafting thing at the beginning that's like okay but at the end of the day what you're doing is you're like you get a bunch of cards that you can build your car and you then use some dice to run your car and it is pretty hard though i guess theoretically possible in that game to not build an engine and still race mostly what you're doing though is building a crazy engine where it's like i put this into this machine which gives me these color dice and then these colored ice i put into this machine which allows me to move this many spaces but because i move so many spaces i'm creating wear and tear so i need to use these other dice to stop the wear and tear or my whole machine is going to fall apart and the part that's really neat about this game both thematically and from the idea of either expendable or non-expendable engines is that your engine can collapse in the game you take like damage from generating wear running along the track and so your engine can fall apart or you can like build a tank that's like very reliable and is like a smaller more puttering engine but will like continue to ramp up over the course of the game so that one for me fits the definition and it has that you know that mad scientist that rube goldberg training effect that i'm looking for in an engine building game yeah there's a lot of furnace in there now that i think about it i mean obviously steampunk rally is a
lot older but it's the kind of game where it's like okay everybody run your engines and everybody simultaneously looks down and just plays with your stuff moving dice around and you know cards are flying off and all that kind of stuff yeah i think it also one of the reasons i like it is because it it matches your definition and it also kind of matches mine in that it is you're making this frankenstein's monster of a racing machine and sometimes you use these parts and sometimes use those other parts it really changes because uh as part of that game one of the things that you do is spend effort in order to get gas like literally dice that you then you know roll to add in there it's interesting because like i i feel like we've played a lot of games where that feeling has occurred like everybody go run your engines and and yeah i'm sitting here and i'm still and as we're talking you know you know we're looking through my collection i'm still struggling to come up with another game that i'm like huh yeah that one that's a game that i have or that i played a lot that really meets this definition for for for how often you know what we've already talked about i've referred to you know engine builders i think i've got one for you anastasia i know that you know and maybe own lorenzo magnifico it's so funny that you say that i do know that i do own that and i almost listed that on that list when i said gollum grand austria hotel and then i was like no lorenzo's not one
are you familiar with that one nick uh yeah i've played it with you actually i'm a little rusty yeah i mean that one is it's a work replacement game a very tight work replacement game but what you were doing in large part is setting up a chain of actions and then hoping to be able to activate the worker placement spot to then actually use this chain of actions and uh and that's where a lot of the game is like just putting cards down in a line and they are you know the first card you take goes in the first spot the second card goes in the second spot you can't rearrange them and they do things like turn coins into wood and the next card will turn wood into bricks and the next card will turn bricks into coins again you know like that that kind of thing yeah and i can i actually do think nick that one meets i hope if i understand it correctly i think that is actually meeting your definition in that it is a long chain of things that is happening it's something you activate it adds gas you you i guess the essence activating it is what but you you're feeding things into it and then you know stuff is coming out along the way and it is true that actually my biggest complaint about lorenzo which is actually on my trade list is because it can be so hard to activate your engine usually there's only one work replacement spot to do this or you know depending on the player account and it can be very frustrating because you could put all this work into building that thing out and then you know get
blocked from running it it's an entry building game but not necessarily an engine running game yeah and i think it's interesting to note too that the ones that we've or at least that i've landed on is like definitively engine builders are all games that tend to be on the the shorter to medium side i think that's almost a necessity in something like this because engines just get so run away they get so snowbally that you can't have them go on for too long or they get totally insane so i'm struggling to think of anything that takes more than two hours that i would be like yeah that's a pure engine builder and i think lorenzo might be like the longest game that like gets on that list yeah although you mentioned wingspan which is not a not longer than two hours but you mentioned wingspan and i i do see that i mean obviously there's an income element but there is you know the way you put your cards down when you put them down the roads that you activate so that's obviously at play and i can definitely see that and then i don't think we've talked about this but another stonewire viticulture would you say viticulture is an engine builder the way you work your wine board i've only played viticulture a couple times and it was like digitally so i don't have a good emotional feel for that game my instinct is no because the worker placement component is is too overwhelming emotionally for me right so it doesn't give me that like feeling of running a chain so much i guess it's a little slower and this kind of maybe tweaks or brings up an interesting question about the definition right it's like you
yes you make grapes but there's this aging process right as you're moving between the seasons everything is aging and as they age then you can move you know then yes you can harvest them and they get older but uh again i guess it means my definition which is to say that i put things in somewhere and then i go away and i come back and my grapes are older and look they they functioned without my oversight right or my wine is older and that i'm assuming does not meet your definition at all yeah i i don't think so um it's it's it doesn't quite get there because i guess that really what i'm like landing on as we've gone through this conversation you're like helping me realize is basically i just don't i don't agree that income and i don't agree that tableaus are engines and that's that that might be as simple as that i uh we're talking about long ones and i know that this won't meet your definition but that's fine because obviously honestly i think this conversation is really interesting because i think we're gonna end it all three of us having a much better idea of what we personally think an engine building game is and i think we're all gonna have different definitions and uh at this point in a stage i'm curious what your definition of engine building is or where you're circling around because i feel like everything apparently games i'm circling around games being engine builders thanks i actually think that anastasia is in the majority like i think that i'm the weird one
i think you're definitely the most uh niche uh one of us but i mean this car honestly i think i have a better idea of what i think an engine builder is now than i did you know 30 minutes ago or so and i'm just curious if if anastasia has had a similar feeling because i think i don't think nick's changed his mind at all i don't think so either i i do enjoy that um we've made it to the end of my collection and i don't think we found a single one after furnace so i think that's interesting yeah i mean i i i think nick makes some excellent points um i think that you make some good points john i think i probably am going to lean if i need if i were to narrow my definition of engine builders i would lean towards john's expanded version of nick's definition slightly wider uh choices but i think i actually go back to especially since we're saying okay engine building's not a mechanic right i think i'll go back to what how i feel as a player in a game and i think for me i go back to that idea of what is building my engine and you could say that's that doesn't necessarily make like that every game could have an engine that you're building so you know in terms of am i going to delineate a game as a pure engine builder i think i need to feel like the engine that i'm building is maybe 70 to 80 of that game right so i can see to a certain extent what nick is saying where it's like sure some of the games i listed it's
just a portion of it you know or it's a part or it's just an income phase right like you underwater sees i can see what you're saying nick it's just like one part of the game and yet i feel like that's on the line for me because so much of what you are trying to do is improve that production phase to then do other things so don't make stuff in your production phase of underwater cities you're not going to do a whole lot with the rest of you exactly so so that's so that's hard for me but i you know and i'm gonna have to step back and reflect a little bit i mean i i think that my definition has come down to what for me feels like building an engine and i probably am gonna lean more towards any games that nick would probably call tableau builders or farming games or something else where essentially uh like i've been saying you know i set something up to do something and i can keep i do agree with you nick to a certain extent like i can keep activating it over and over again or it keeps producing for me over and over again and i have created an action path a series of things that i'm doing that is working for me or that is building up or giving or amassing me more points and i know that's super vague and i'm struggling to come up with some games that fit that for me because nick has infected my mind and i'm doubting all of my choices to just reflect something back at you
that i heard you say earlier that i'd love to hear you expand on you talked a couple times about like creating something and then putting it away and it generates things for you right the wines and viticulture or the grapes and viticulture and it came up a few other times where does that fall for you like is that engine building you know i was thinking about that after i said that because i was thinking about village i don't know if you guys have played village or john i don't think you have i played my village but not not the original neither of you have so one of the components of that is that you essentially put workers out on the board and they like they improve i don't know how to describe it like you put them out on the board and then you come back and get them later and they're better at they like they went to train i guess is what it is thematically is that they like trained in a skill and then they make it better for you to do that skill and you know the main mechanic of village being that all of your workers age and eventually die and all of that so i was thinking about that when we were talking about viticulture because i was sitting there being like okay is do i think i actually wrote village down on my initial list i'm like is this an engine builder like i i put people out here and they do various things for me and then they get better at those things and then i have you know you know is is is that what my thing is and i'm struggling with that you know after this conversation because i have i have considered that for a very long time to be my engine i'm creating something and i'm
gonna go back and check on it in a few turns and it's it's it's doing something for me but i gotta be honest guys and this is terrible for this podcast but you know nick you nick you're messing with my mind and i i'm gonna i'm gonna have to like post a revision later and be like what's my strategy in games what do i notice everything i thought i i can feel them on the fringes of my brain where i'm like freaking out i'm like what am i thinking of is a game that like that game like where you i'm trying to actually think of when do i use the term engine builder like like are building my engine i know what you mean nick it's that feeling of where like i press this button and then all these little things happen and it like feels really good and i'm like genuinely sitting here being like what is a game that does that that's essentially the core of my argument right like you and i will both use the word engine when we're playing the game maracaibo but i don't really think i'm building an engine it's just this like gamer habit that i've built up so it's like this like i don't know ludological rejection no i mean you're right like i can't really think of a game that that that like just does that i just know that there are moments in games that do that so i guess john to answer your question what is my definition of an engine builder engine builders don't exist that is my definition we've got nihilism we're gonna re-brand the term it's just engine building now and it's in all games and i'm very happy with it
that's kind of what nick said at the very beginning right he was saying it's it's not a mechanism on board game geek it's a feeling and uh and maybe maybe that's where we all come together because i i think there's a that's a pretty persuasive argument well if you guys disagree with us or you have comments or you want to debate the games or you want to remind me what games i'm thinking of that i can't think of at this moment please please leave us some comments we'd love to see that kind of feedback and we'd love to engage on that the other thing is we'll also put links in the description of any games that we discussed that have an associated junkets games playthrough can check that out in case you want to actually see some of these games in action and then yeah let us know what you think yeah um once again if you're listening to the podcast uh there's a link to the youtube version of this uh where uh you know go nuts with your comments i i'm sure a lot of people have their own definitions and i would love to see where everybody else is on this stuff yeah until next time everyone