Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 (11) Board Games of All Time | Jeff & Jamie

Transcript 38:16

just make 10 louder and make 10 be the top number and make that a little louder these go to 11. hello everyone welcome back to foster the meatball my name is jamie and i'm jeff and we are here today to do our top 11 favorite games of all time as of 2021 curveball top 11. top heard that right yeah going against the grave exactly just like in spinal tap which jeff has never seen freaking weirdo yeah we haven't seen each other's lists so we don't know what's on them i mean i have an idea jamies are going to be all cute games 100 cute games like animal guaranteed i know one game on there for sure i won't say it no spoilers no spoilers if you say it i'll tell you that's the one that i knew cool beans let's go get a drink no what ew get your spit off of it what do you mean ew it's my drink you don't get to judge my drink it's sharp who wants to go first ladies ladies first top 11.

my number 11 is oh my goodness do you have any guesses honestly no i know i just don't know the order i think i could guess majority i don't think you'd be able to guess this one i've only played it one time well that's fair actually some on my list have only played once okay jeff also had one on his list that he'd never played but he took it off anticipatory play okay my number 11 is by counts of the west kingdom really yeah and that's by garfield games and it is a worker placement game it's a third in the west kingdom trilogy or series i don't know if they're doing anymore we've only played this once and i friggin loved it yeah you did really good too yeah i didn't know i tied for first i did not do well no i have a tendency to not like games that i didn't do well in yeah i didn't think you would pick that one i know i never would have guessed that it's my number 11. i literally started this video by saying everything will be cute and animal related and the first one is murder war five counts this counts yeah so this game like i said third in the trilogy series uh there's architects of the west kingdom paladins of the west kingdom and then by counts of the west kingdom and they all play slightly differently apparently you can put all three of them together and play like one massive game which just sounds insane i never knew that it's crazy it's crazy that's crazy i didn't feel that what do you like about it i like there's so many ones i like that

i almost i like there's so many different things that you can do like there's so many different ways you can get points and win like there's that thing in the middle that you can climb up and then is it a castle i guess and then there's like pathways and plus i really love the artwork like yeah that's very cute it's ugly cute neat yeah good choice my number 11. all right my number 11. do you think you guess it no you can't no i can't okay my number 11 is a game called western legends really yeah wait what do you mean wait okay i forgot which one that was western legends is made published by colossal games and it's basically a wild west themed kind of like what's the style western it's not really hand management it's not really there's work or place well there's like yeah there's work replacement area movement there's cards there's like different things yeah bunch there's a whole bunch of different things going on in this game but what i like most about it is that you can kind of win in multiple different ways so you can score points by like playing poker or you could score points by wrangling cattle or score points by mining and finding gold like there's multiple ways to to win so you can kind of cater the game to how you want to play it um and on top of that you can kind of choose to be good or bad um so like not at the game but like moral yeah so you can either be like law

abiding citizen or non-law abiding citizen and that kind of changes or whatever banned it yeah or something like that which means you can do certain different tasks in the game and um score points differently really really like the theme really like the um old west theme as well as the ability to kind of just play it how you want to yeah we haven't played this one in a while i'd like to it's hard to play at two players my number 11 is western legends moving on to number 10.

my number 10 is tiny towns really yeah by aeg i don't remember this we played it all the time before with the little houses and then there's like certain oh yeah yeah i love tiny towns it's that's right up my alley you're also very good at that game exactly you'll notice a trend typically i like games that i'm really good at and i think you probably feel the same i don't know i'm not really great at western legends yeah that's true i think i won a couple but but yeah so basically tiny towns you have these little buildings and you're trying to create patterns to cover up your little town or your grid i love it it's you know it's cute it's colorful cute cute counter it's cute it's colorful it's easy it's quick to play i love this i'll play this pretty much anytime we do have one of the expansions tiny towns fortune fortune 14 tinytown's fourteen we haven't played that one yet technically it's not even ours it's my brothers but whatever i think you're good at like those little like puzzly games yeah where you like only like santorini and that yeah you have to like you are better at santorini than me that is undeniable my number 10 insert drum music great western trail yeah love that game oh my god it's weird that both of these games have a cow feel

cowboy there's cows in them yeah jeff grew up on a fern checks out great western trail is by i don't know how to pronounce it what is it spiel great western trail i keep getting it mixed up with western legends like that is really great western trail is one with all the cats and no i just mean in terms of like saying it anyway so in great western trail you're basically looking to load up trains um and move product livestock a bunch of other things it's really just like a movement based game i think there are some card elements to it um you know you get cows and you have to match certain cattle together in order to kind of move them around and the cows are so cute there's fluffy cows in there there are fluffy cows i've only played this game a couple times it is heavy it takes a very long time to play like three hours i think we played last time with three players yeah we were playing with one person who took a long time for their turn so who's that matt a game i'd like to play more i love it cows cows cow team i love cats it's weird because literally i'm looking over this and like there's multiple cow games those are the only two okay i was like what other are you playing calgary cowboys

it's like i grew up on a farm and i don't know what that really oh we used to do the set of desires basically you'd have a cow and where it would like you put it in a field and where it would poop on a number you would win that is actually ridiculous number nine number nine number nine for me is one of the games that really got us into the hobby and that is clank exclamation how did you know clan's on my list it is you said we have an overlap no i have overlays oh my number nine is clank a deck building adventure game oh it's by renegade games and it's like yeah it's a deck building adventure i guess it's kind of like an explorer and deck building and not really work replacement because you're moving but is this your number nine no i don't want to know this game got us into the hobby what's one of the first boardwalks one of them yeah first board games that we played a lot and i still love it and i love all of the like different versions and we've played a little bit of plank legacy we started it with my brothers before you went back to egypt my brothers have to pick that back up flank is a great game to me it's like a classic i freaking love it and i love deck builders i really do like i like that mechanism a whole lot with clank basically you're like trying to is it it's not going through a dungeon but you're trying not to make noise clanks to disturb the dragon you don't want to wake up the dragon it's kind of a dungeon

i think any time that you like make a noise you get these little clank cubes and then you have to draw clank cues and like some of them will make the dragon mad and will move up and like there's all these different things but essentially like that's why it's called clank that's the sound you're making you're friggin around it's like shut up you're waking up the dragon all them coins in your pocket getting that dragon fired up stealing his treasure you're basically bilbo baggins trying to steal smiles treasures my number nine are you ready this is gonna blow your freaking mind plank is it my number nine is clank what what not only did we have um whatever you want to call it what's it called when we like a crossover yeah it's crossover it's a crossover but it's all the same number yeah that's like a true crossover that's a true crossover you're just repeating everything nailed it everything jamie just said i will also say but not say one of the first that we kind of got into love deck builders it's kind of push your luck too i mean there's a bit of that element where you know like you're drawing tokens out of a bag for a dragon attack and it's like should i get out now with the treasures i have or should i go a little bit deeper and get that bigger point value treasure that might be a little bit further down are you gonna get out because you gotta get back out too it's crazy man and you've got coins clanking around

you might say you know they got necklaces over your freaking self clanking around you're making all this noise and trying to get over here man get over here get over here and then he wasn't breathing my number nine also clank so now we're on to number eight eight my number eight is imperial settlers empires of the north okay the only reason why i'm sorry to butt in here but the only reason why this game is on your list is because you always win it's so fun she always wins and she'll only pick the same facts i pick the little girl because she knows how to play it so well that she'll win no i picked that one because it's literally the cutest one okay essentially there's like factions and everybody gets to be a different faction and each faction plays differently i didn't say this is from portal games but each faction plays differently and they're all just it's such a cute little art and then you can go sailing and like for the faction that i like to play with which is the little girl with the penguin she's adorable we don't know what it's called but basically like she's able to lay down a bunch of cards and that's kind of like my real big engine going on big engine building type of game and it's so cute it's so fun and we've taught this now to both of my brothers separately and they both really enjoyed it as well yeah yeah it is a good game even though i never win i really want to there's

some expansion factions that i would really like to get there's like japan and rome and i can't remember what else but yeah great game great game great little engine builder my number eight is a game called seasons oh i almost put i didn't put seasons on so i almost did seasons is published by lebanon liberalite what live a lot live we're probably pronouncing it wrong this is like bizarre and bezier all over again seasons is a phenomenal game card drafting uh dice roller you kind of draft cards at the beginning of the game depending on you know which round you're in you'll get access to those cards as you go so you set three aside you have three in your hand and then set three more aside for each year four seasons and then years and then each year you'll get access to your other three cards to play so you have to be a bit strategic on what you take to start versus what you leave for later and so basically you're you're rolling dice everyone gets to take a dice depending on your turn order and those dice give you certain abilities i really really like seasons i would always play it when possible i do play it on okay marina board game arena if i'm just sitting on the couch and feel like playing something i'll hop on and play game seasons never win ever those people are crazy i know i think i feel like i've won it a few times like in our little group yeah great cranking okay cool okay cool okay cool next next please

moving on to number seven okay this is also a game we've played this game numerous times but only at the same time in one day and i it was an instant love for me i have no idea what this is really okay mysterium oh yeah yeah yeah yeah okay and this is by this also by liable it's also by libelo they're crushing it live a lot mysterium is a like a cooperative deduction type of game so essentially one person has been murdered bro so there is dead and they are acting as the ghost and they're trying to give you different clues as to who killed them so there's cards in front of you of all of the potential suspects and i think you're like an investigator or something and uh the ghost is giving you cards with pictures on them to try and because they can't talk they're not allowed to talk and then so like the first round is you're trying to figure out which one of the people killed you or something or who the suspects are second round is like where and then there's like what weapon and then the final round is you have to put it all together yeah you have to put it all together and it is so fun i i loved it i knew yeah i did once we started playing jamie really likes that like production type of stuff and the art is like it's it's perfect yeah it reminds me of the haunted mansion like that

it's got that kind of like creepy feel but it's like beautiful and weird and yeah i love it it's a good game just as long as jeff doesn't play the ghost yeah there's literally a card full of buttons and then he finds a card with buttons on it and gives it to someone and it's not there is balloons or something i think and then there's also mysterium park which i would also really like to try yeah i'd like to play that game more that was fun great for all ages because you played with my d since you were like 12 and eight or nine nine oh jason's gonna they grow so fast it's hard to tell we don't care about age yeah age is just a number it's basically like a twist on clue yeah kind of it's like clue but cooler and more dynamic it's like picture glue no picture of being cooler and that's what it is yeah my number seven is a game i've only played once but when i when i first played it i was like i know exactly i don't i don't know if i like this which was a shock which was very shocking but then i started thinking about it more and i was like i want to play that game again real bad so my number seven is gaia projects by z man games you're basically trying to take over planets and kind of like terraform these planets you're establishing a planet for like growth and all of these things and it's basically this whole big gaia project yeah this would be defined as a euro

game but we are still confused yeah we're sweating yeah like when i watch explanation videos and i'm like i don't get it when it comes to like understanding what a game is i feel like it's just like everyone's kind of just it's a crap shoot really love space theme games um so i i love space in general so any space related games i'm in love with and i feel like the more i play that game the more i'm gonna want to play that game my number six i wonder if this is going to be a surprise to you i don't i don't know i there's some i'm very surprised that haven't come up on your list we might have one more crossover i'm fairly certain we will i just don't know where it's going to lie my number six is gloomhaven jaws with the lion six yeah oh my god do you think it'd be higher way higher six six not mad i'm just disappointed i really okay it's still number six like i love this game so we actually we started off playing regular gloom haven we had one group that we were playing with and they kind of fell off the face of the earth and then we had another friend that we were playing with and then he kind of decided that he wasn't super into it and it's so much effort to play regular gloom haven with just two people so we got jaws in the lion and it is such a great experience we just finished it last week how do you explain it it's hand management um exploration campaign based it's a campaign based exploration game

card management card management story it's just legacy yes it's an epic game like it really is so so good and we really threw a lot of things out there that's my number six i love gloomhaven jaws line you can't really say too much about it so you don't want to spoil anything i guess but yeah we can't tell you too much about it you play too much wow six six i mean my response kind of tells you though i think it's probably that it's probably my number six i think this might come to us as a surprise to jamie um mine is gloomy but no and i was like what was it right my number six is dinosaur island love me some dinosaur island me too i freaking love that game i love the retro look of it yeah the colors it is a decent hefty cute little chunky game like it's it's got a lot to it you're basically like building up your dna so that you can it's jurassic park yeah you can you can make dinosaurs with this dna to put in your park and you know you've got to manage your security so that dinosaurs don't eat people like it's just there's so much going on like i love it so much i love the theme love the colors the only gripe i have with the game is that i wish the meeples were a little bit more dynamic yeah but you could buy them yeah like we've we just have the basic like there's just one standard dinosaur for regardless of which type of dinosaur

you build it is by pandasaurus games but um didn't make it on my list only because there's so much setup it is a big game i don't mind setup of games i really don't because i'm usually the one that says exactly i really don't mind setup because i never do it yeah it's perfect i am excited for dinosaur world oh yeah that's not this list though james that's not the thing on to number five my number five is quacks of coiling i knew this was my north star games i love this game quacks of quailenburg first this is a push your luck game that i love mainly because i am a very lucky person it is uncanny how lucky jamie is yes this game's not about ducks so don't get your hopes up because i thought quacks as in the crazy doctors doctor wish which doctors that person's a quack i can't remember if you're like is it building a potion or something yeah you're putting ingredients and then there's like a bag and you gotta stick your hand in the bag and then pull out these ingredients and you place them and then you could potentially is it explode or bust yeah explode and that's why jeff doesn't like it because he generally always pulls out the bad yeah i could have i could have a hundred good tokens in my bag and five bad ones and i will pull

out that was five hour time my number five which i think you're gonna be like i didn't think of that maybe you have i don't know my number five is dice throne i did think of it i didn't put it on my line really yeah so i really like dice throne i'll tell you why i'll tell you why oh sorry i should mention dice thrown is by roxley canadian company broxley games medium public keep rocks in it get it rocking it oh good one dice throne is a great two-player game and that's why i love it the most you basically can pick a different type of character and that character comes with a different set of cards and abilities and you're basically throwing dice down it's kind of like yahtzee like trying to get certain dice faces to face up to do certain abilities on your board against the other person so i'm a competitive person 1v1 all day give me that this game is just something i will always love we travel with it we take it when we go we went to disney and we took it with us we take it when we travel you know it's a quick game it doesn't take that long like under half an hour it's just it's awesome to pick up and play and beat jamie in i mean that's all there is to it that's why else am i here if it's not to be jb and games barely number four we're getting up there right yeah we're getting up there my number four

is well i know i think i know do you know what is it i don't know it's good there's ga there's i think there's only a few left there's like three games that i'm like she hasn't said it yet and i know they're up there my number four is viticulture okay yeah all right and this is a work replacement game that you also you get cards so there's a bit of hand management in there and basically this whole game is just about making wine you're going through different seasons you're plowing your fields you're planting the grapes you're making the wine you're selling the wine like all of these things which like when i hear that i'm like okay that doesn't sound that exciting but it is really a fun game and we've played this many times we've played it two player three player four player yeah we've also played the tuscany version yep yep and i feel like a lot of people like this game it's very popular it's a freaking classic it's just fun and it's like a relaxing game it is a little competitive enough of a competitive element to keep it interesting exactly well i mean it's obviously competitive i mean you're trying to score more points than everyone else yeah but it's still kind of like chill it is very chill going through the video yeah you're kind of just chilling making wine you get mama and papa cards and they do stuff i'm here for it cool all right my number four is a game by stone mayor games stone

i could easily put anywhere in the top four i think when we first played that game that i was all in i was all in on that game like i loved the movie so i love the mechs i love everything about that game like you know worker placement movement type you know to get resources battling to spend you can battle but it's not even a battle game like that it's like area like area control yeah it's it's interesting because i think a lot of people think it's a battle game but like it isn't it's not at all a battle game you can um and that's a component you need to do but um yeah just the theme like i really like that dystopian theme a caveat to all of this is like the rise of fenris campaign you can play was unbelievable yeah it was like so good if you've played sites but haven't played the rise of fenris expansion campaign you need to do it it is so good definitely a bit of a gateway game for us as well for me especially really love that heavy strategy stuff so scythe number four yeah we played the hell out of that game we haven't played it in a long time yeah we were talking about it the other day we played it probably too much and then we kind of let it go for a bit but i would love to play it again for sure moving on now to number three now we're in our top three do you know what my top three are i could probably guess okay don't give it away with your face you don't have a terrible poker face i

want to give it away it's going to be villainous mansions of madness i don't know the third though okay well let's just get into it it's definitely those two are definitely in it oh maybe the haunted mansion game but i feel like that's too new that's too new yeah and it's not that amazing i just like the theme i did my number three game is the haunted nominees i was like ready to be like is mansions nailed it by fantasy flight games i love it i love this game i love like creepy spooky horror type of love crafty love crafty i'm sure well it's in

but basically this game has an app component with it there's a whole story and it's like you're you're moving through these different rooms you don't know what's going to be coming up next and it's cooperative so like we play together you play the scenarios sometimes you win sometimes you lose and there's one that we've lost wow a lot it can be difficult but this game is so good like i love it the detective element yeah the detective element yeah you go in and you're like i'm going to investigate this thing and then jeff might be doing something whatever he's doing fighting a monster or something yeah and then you might get separated which happened yeah yes one of you might die should be caught in a fire or one person might become like i can't remember what it's called but like your brain goes yeah so that's a really cool component like each character that you get has like so many hearts and so many brains and the brains are like the insanity factor and the heart is like your life so you can go insane in the game and then play against a group potentially yeah well you get like a card that tells you what your new your win condition is and sometimes it's you know just play the game as normal or sometimes you're trying to mess everything yeah and the other people don't the other people the other people don't know what your win condition is yeah so then you'll make an action they'll be like why's why why why did you do that why why do that yeah yeah so it was great manchester madness i love it i love life my number three

is by a publisher called frix games terraforming mars is my number three jeff loves mars love engine build there and love the card drafting like card deck building kind of element to that you're basically terraforming mars it's a pretty simple concept you're on mars and you're trying to make it habitable for different actions so taking over certain hexes the more you do the temperatures rising on the planet you know to make it hospitable and all of these things just a really really great game i don't remember this game at all i know that i played it once so that's sad i just i don't know sad to me now we're on to number two oh it's takanoko on there too oh my god it might be attacking alcohol and vilnius it might be i don't know number two and the fact that you forgot about this game is hilarious to me but my number two is wingspan okay yeah okay wingspan from stonemeyer games everybody knows what this game is it's insanely popular but basically you're just trying to get like resources in order to make a bird and you lay that bird you're not making the bird you're putting it together like a little robot bird putting the bird in a environment yeah you got these little eggies it's really cute and it's fun and it's beautiful and

i love wingspan the eggs look like uh cadbury mini eggs they do we won every time i i look at them i'm like i want to eat that we once played this game with cadbury mini eggs on the table risky business so that was remember when i said earlier like there was a game that i probably should have included and i didn't was it wingspan it's wingspan i also love that game my dad's a big bird watcher so he's big bird he loves birds i in so fact i love birds yeah yeah great game good choice number two mind number two is a game by stonewire games it is wingspan viticulture ah crossover so jamie's already kind of spoken a little bit of culture but yeah just really kind of like it's got a homey feel you're just kind of playing and building wine and or making wine and and harvesting grapes and smelling wine selling and and doing tours of your vineyard like it's just nice it's just a nice game and it mechanically it's perfect like i just love everything about it i do think i prefer the tuscany version over the one we have i think we have the essential version yeah um i do prefer tuscany because it adds a season and i think the map looks or the board looks cooler but both are great i mean you're not gonna go wrong either way um yeah number two viticulture much love we're on to our number new one

number one what my number one you ready baby hi honey my number one is villainous knew it ravensburger ravensburger raven raven's burgers another one that is super popular i am a huge disney fan like i have disney tattoos all over my arms i i love everything about disney and so these games were like almost an automatic love for me but the fact that they play so well we have all of the expansions except for the newest one that literally just came out with gaston are they expansions though they're not really not really they're like new characters yeah they're all standalone yeah so i love this game basically you're playing as one of the disney villains and you're trying to like you have a specific goal that you have to reach by playing different cards and like moving your your icon or your token or whatever and then you're trying to fade out or screw over basically uh your your opponent so there's a bit of that take that kind of element and i love it it's so fun and how we typically play is like we mix up all of the characters and we choose them blindly and i find that that keeps it interesting and fresh so that you're not always playing with the same person anytime that they put out a new new characters i'll buy it like every single time i will buy it the only one we haven't i haven't thought about buying the marvel one but i actually probably will

because it does look really cool you also love marvel i do love marvel well i guess marvel's now disney marvel is disney um yeah i mean i think thematically for you that that sense my favorite uh for how much you love disney i also love disney but not as much as you and my favorite one to play with is esma yeah great game i also love that game my number one has already been on this list my number one is a game by cephalo cephalo affair cephalo faire affair games jaws of the line gloom haven jaws of the lion i love fantasy i love fantasy i love fantasy books i love magic the gathering i love d and d like i love all of those things and you've basically put them into a board game i'm all there jaws of line was a great kind of compromise where blue maven is super heavy um jaws the line is really good at introducing you to the game having the storybook kind of deal where you can open the book and there's your map and a bunch of different information that you need so that's why it's kind of on my list and normal gloomhaven isn't even though i also love that and didn't get to play through it which sucks but yeah that dungeon crawler upgrading your character collecting gold collecting experience battling monsters battling monsters like i cannot express enough how much i love this genre of game and i'm really excited for

um frost haven to come out number one jaws of the lion no question undebatable undebatable put it on the board that's it that's our top those are top 11. because we're going against the favorite board games of all time so far yeah this will change yeah i mean let's be fair like in terms of other people and what they've played like our depth of games is pretty decent but their goal to play but yeah there's a lot of really great games we have not played like so this will change i mean it's just it's going to change part and parcel with the territory you know top 11. cool with some spinal tap reference that i don't understand this one goes up to 11. that is all that we have for you guys today let us know down below what your some of your top games are we would love to know if you have any recommendations for us please throw them out there we are happy to try those out yeah expand the collection expand the collection we've got some new games coming to us this weekend so we're pretty excited about that we do yeah i forgot about them i do indeed thank you guys so much for watching if you like what you see please subscribe to foster the maple follow us on social media on instagram it's at foster dot the dot meatball still waiting for a license plate guy to give up it's not gonna happen but that's not it so feel free to follow us on there and leave us a comment like subscribe

share and press the bell notification and do all that fun stuff thanks for joining us today and we hope to see you again soon say goodbye jack later days bye bye there makeup quick and makeup in here it's not gonna help the situation people come for the laughs not for the video quality yeah well people don't come

it's who i am except me makeup is it gone no ew i got it maybe wait wait i didn't get it call makeup it is it's on your shirt devin devin get makeup do you know what the shadow on your face is it's my big head it's not that big you don't have a big head do you think you have a big head yeah really it's bigger than yours maybe i have a little bit you do rude children's hats that is true i never thought yeah okay chill they're not children's hats young young adult hats why yeah my brother-in-law my brother my brother owns it we have an overlap yeah i made one you don't pay attention to any of the group chats did you look at all of those i saw some oh my god okay probably comes from my love for magic the gathering um jamie never will fist bump me she's got this weird thing where she just ew i feel like um i have a good radio voice you've er literally already said that like i feel like i could be on radio okay i can't mine's too whiny hear that all the pieces falling is that a drum that someone could draw

hello you

Progress saved