Skip to main content
Loading video...

Tabletop Power Rankings (April 2026)

Transcript 8:03

Hey, I'm Jamey with Stonemaier Games, and today I'm here to present to you the very first edition of the tabletop power rankings. This is as of April 2026. These were selected by you, or people like you if you chose to vote in the power rankings. The way this worked is that I presented people who uh who follow along Stonemaier Games stuff, I presented them with the chance to vote on three games that they have already played, that they highly anticipate, that they're super excited to play again. So, unlike other rankings that that I know and love, like on BoardGameGeek, the hotness, um the hotness is kind of dominated by games that are coming out in the future, rather than games that are already that people are actively already playing. I wanted a power ranking hotness-style list about games that we've already played, and now that we've played them, we want to play them again. I think that's that's the type of anticipation that I am the most excited for.

And so, that is what this ranking is. I asked people to vote on on a a Stonemaier game, or one to I think they can do up to three Stonemaier games. Um and then in a separate category, a a non-specifically a non-Stonemaier game, or three different non-Stonemaier games that they have played that they are very excited to play again. Without further ado, let's jump into the list. And I will share a a little Well, this isn't based on my opinions, these rankings are based on your votes, and you can vote again for next month. There's a link in the description below, so you can vote on the next month's power rankings. Um uh even though this isn't based on my opinions, I will share something about a few of the games. Uh I'll share my opinions about those games, or maybe my favorite thing about a few of them. Um and I will have a question at the end as well. So, in addition to filling out the survey for next month's power rankings, so that you can influence how these games shift around within these rankings, there is also a question that I have for you at the end.

Let's jump right in. I will share my other screen here. On the Stonemaier top five list, we have Tapestry at number five. We have Vantage at number four. Wingspan at number three. Scythe at number two. And the number one Stonemaier game that people have played and are most excited right now to play again is Wingspan. One of my favorite things about Wingspan is that every card that you play, every bird card that you play, not only does that bird card potentially have an ability that makes you better at that action over time, um but it also just inherently makes the action better, that action category. So, if you have put a bird in the forest habitat, you are now better at getting food in addition to whatever power is on the bird, if it is a when activated ability. So, I really really love that about Wingspan.

Now, let's get to the overall top 10. So, these are specifically not Stonemaier games. And we'll start with the bottom three. And based on the what I how I've designed these power rankings, the bottom three will drop off this list, and they will be replaced by three nominations. So, in the in the poll below, the survey below, you can nominate a game that will potentially be on next month's top 10 list. So, the ones dropping off are Speakeasy at number 10. Luthier at number nine. And Moon Colony Bloodbath, a recent favorite of mine, at number eight. I was a little bit remiss to see this on the the cut list. This is a little bit like relegation soccer in Europe, the bottom three get knocked off, and next month they will be replaced by Terraforming Mars, Sanctuary, and Dune Imperium. And by next month, I mean in the survey below.

So, among the top among the 10 games that you can vote for in the survey below, are Terraforming Mars, Sanctuary, Dune Imperium, and the following seven games. There is at number seven, Andromeda's Edge. Number six, Slay the Spire. Number five, Bomb Busters. Number four, Galactic Cruise. And then for the top three, I'm going to say one thing about each of these games, if I have actually played them. I have played Scythe. I played Scythe once. And the thing I really really like about Scythe is the discovery of the aliens each game. There are two different aliens in each game, and that there's this paired asymmetry between those two aliens, uh and that that creates this really unique type of asymmetry in the game. Like, usually in in game most games the asymmetry it is related to your starting abilities, or something that you do during setup. And you do put out the aliens during setup, but you don't discover them until during the game. I think that is really really clever. I kind of want to see more games with this discovered asymmetry that impacts all players during the game.

At number two, we have Lost Ruins of Arnak. This is the number two game that people have played that they want to play again. And wow, this game is just such an achievement. Um what's one thing that I really love about the game? I love how the temple tracks work. This is something that it took me a while to figure out how important the temple tracks were to Lost Ruins of Arnak, but now I I I found the temple track has made my number one go-to place to try to eke out one more turn in the game, to move up the temple track a little bit, and get a bonus, maybe an instant bonus, maybe an not an ongoing bonus, but something that instead of one of the little tiles or the tokens on there, just something that I get when I move up to the next level of the temple. And uh yeah, just makes the the game feel good when you can eke out one more turn. And last, at number one, we have The Castles of Burgundy. Like, a real classic game here that has been given a little bit of new life thanks to I think the special edition, which is really stunning. It's a really stunning version of the game.

Uh this is a game that I've grown into loving, and I think one of my favorite uh lots of favorite things. Like, this might show up on a future list. I'm trying to pick one thing that I won't say in in the future. But, one thing I really like about the game is the satisfaction of filling in and completing one of the areas of your player mat. I think that is really satisfying to complete them. Whether it's a big area or small area, it's it feels good to complete those areas in the in your little hex grid. So, I really like that about The Castles of Burgundy, the number one game in April that people have played, that they highly anticipate, that they're very excited to play again in April. Um so, yeah, thank you for joining me for the first edition of the tabletop power rankings. Go ahead and vote for next month. Vote and nominate if you'd like. So, you're voting for Stonemaier game or games, you're voting for among the top 10 games that are eligible, and you're getting to nominate a game that you are really excited to play again. And here, related to the nominations, is my question for you.

So, I've noticed that most of the games on this list, other than maybe Bomb Busters, are pretty heavy-weighty games that people have decided to dive deep into, which I think is wonderful. But, I'm wondering if based on the current setup of the list, that uh other games that people love to play, but just don't think of for this type of list, just won't ever get on the list. And if I should have some designated slot for specifically a light game, and maybe a cooperative game, cuz every game on this list is uh competitive except for Bomb Busters. Bomb Busters is the one exception in terms of lightness and cooperation. So, do you think that in a future version of these power rankings, that I should add a designated slot among the top 10, or maybe outside the top 10, um for a light game and a cooperative game, just so we have a greater variety of games to talk about here?

I think these are games that people play. Like, people aren't I don't think everyone is playing Galactic Cruise every night. And even if you are, you're probably mixing in a lighter game every now and then. And those games I think are relevant are are relevant, too. So, what do you think about that? And what do you think those if if you like that idea, what do you think the subcategories should be um for people to select from? Let me know your thoughts on that in the comments below, and I hope you go vote for May 2026's tabletop power rankings. Thanks.

Progress saved