Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 50 BEST Board Games of All-Time | 2022 Edition | 50-41

Transcript 45:42

foreign hey how's it going everyone Carlo and Dylan here from all you can board doing our 2022 edition of our top 50 games of all time so we did this last year in 2021 for the first time ever and this is our updated list I think things have changed a decent amount for both of us so um yeah so uh actually I was going to ask you how many games uh are new to your list in this year's top 50 that weren't on last year's so I have 16 games in this one that were not in the top 50 last year okay all right which I guess means 16 came off yeah exactly so yeah yeah I'm at 11 for mine too which uh I thought was pretty high at 16th yeah yeah that's good though that's good that's a lot of a lot of exciting new games to uh to talk about so yeah um yeah and I will also mention that we both have uh Bailey's and our coffees here so we're gonna get nice and drunk credit to Dylan he's got the espresso flavored Baileys on hand yeah so surprised me with that but it's only the finest yes absolutely absolutely um so yeah I don't really think there's anything else to go over I'm just going to kick it off to you uh to start off with number 50 here all right number 50 is tied with one other game for my biggest fall of uh last year yeah that's about 51. no no no no like there's two games on top 50 that fell the same amount oh I see but this one ended up at 50. the end was the the other one I consider my biggest Faller that we'll get to because that one was way higher up um like a higher ranked number okay so this one was 22 last year and is now 50

and that is my city 28 28 spots so my city and you was going to fall because we're done it we're not playing it anymore I have my memories of it I really enjoy that game I still think it's an awesome polygon as it evolves and everything but I played the version of it that is left over after you've done the campaign and like it's not bad but it's also not competing with so many other great polyamino games that are out there it is the Legacy portion that is so memorable and just like other Legacy games other Campaign games it's hard for them to hold their spot when I'm not going to revisit them most likely and I'm basically riding on this Nostalgia and I've cast myself in general in my life with video games with books with with board games just try to like identify when I'm letting Nostalgia control my my feelings on something like I won't get into the examples but regardless my city is one of those things I have such great memories now of us playing Las Vegas like that the all the campaign sessions that we did yeah the chapters and everything but when I think about just like the game that's left in my city and how it's competing with the other games I can't really rank it much higher so this will let this will almost definitely be my City's last time in the top 50 but we have my Island coming out so maybe that one will end up replace it it'll jump on there so cool yeah honestly Legacy games are by far the toughest ones to rank in these lists because you're going off of how you felt when you played through it right last year I had gloomhaven in the number 50 spot and again like that's never going to make it back onto here either yeah um and I think I had my city just outside of the top 50 last year so yeah amazing game and one we would recommend to anyone who hasn't played it but yeah I understand not to go back to it once you've played through it yeah my city

number 50. this week's on all right my number 50 is also a game that fell quite a bit uh and is also one that does have quite a bit of nostalgia for me and this will definitely be the last year on the top 50 for me so this was number 34 last year it has fallen 16 spots and that is merchants and Marauders ah yeah so and honestly if I had just trusted my initial Pub meeple rankings it might have fallen into like 51 or 52 but I I felt like it had to be on year one last time uh just the memories of this game are too fond it's right it obviously is a very long game um I don't think I've ever played a game if it took less than maybe two and a half to three hours is probably the quickest um usually in that three to four hour range but um just sailing around the Caribbean being either a pirate or a merchant and you're either as a merchant trying to like avoid other pirates that are coming after you or as a pirate trying to mess with other players or attacking other ships at Sea like it was just such a fun game there was a lot of things you know the rules were too heavy it's something I probably won't come back to again um unless I find someone else with a copy because I got rid of mine but uh yeah I've had some just some really really memorable times with merchants and Marauders some of my fondest board game memories ever so um yeah this will definitely be the last year on the list Unless somehow I get to play it again but yeah yeah merchants and Marauders yeah I want to play at the one time and it was interesting and fun but not for me well I shouldn't say not for me I'm gonna play it once and it's it's hard on the first time you play a game that's like three to four hours long yeah you have to get it to the you almost have to keep playing until you get it to refined so you can actually truly experience like the proper length of the game and like just the experience it's just well and I think you were the only new person playing and it can be a

pretty punishing game like you could lose your cap and you get killed you lose all your stuff you have to start over kind of things so but it was interesting yeah yeah great game if you haven't tried it and you're into these kind of like bigger experiences I highly recommend you check out merchants and routers cool uh my number 49 is the first game on the list that wasn't on last year and it is from the doctor himself Ryan kanitzia and it has witch Stone oh nice Stone squeaks on uh I actually thought originally when I was making this list and I was doing my rankings and stuff um I thought Wichita was gonna actually make it higher because I really do like whitchstone um but there is a lot of competition I haven't played it uh in a little bit now I think the last time I played was at your place a while ago now a few months ago a few months ago um but I really do like Wichita if I keep playing it uh more and more I I mean it's possible I could sled maybe I realize that I've seen all there is to see but I just I like how much is going on which song I like that everything you're doing is like to chain into like getting other actions and this action gets you this action because like I just like games like that and kanitza's design is solid every area of the board has kind of a distinct feel and a distinct way to tackle it and approach it and and managing your your you know matching of the Domino tiles to get actions is so much fun to see how efficient you could be in because I've never felt like I've left to give a witch Stone being as efficient as I could be right I still want to go back and be like okay how can I hit the fact that the rulebook tells you this is the maximum of actions you could possibly get it's like can I get have a game where I hit that how close can I get right so there's more to explore there I really do like which Stone I don't know if it'll climb in in future years or whether this will be the highest we'll see it and it'll slip off but as of right now it is really good and I can't wait to play that some more

nice yeah no one that's in my top 50 but a really fun game one that I will I don't think I'll ever turn down a game of this like I definitely want to play it again soon maybe we'll play for the holidays or something we should yeah it's really good great king um and okay also new my number 49 is also new to the list first time ever here and it's one I've played two or three times so far but has made a pretty big impression I know it won't be on your top 50. that is gintopolis oh yeah I mean maybe one day but yeah maybe yeah maybe one day I just know the one play you had it wasn't ideal we played it super late at night and I didn't I botched the rules explanation pretty hard but um so yeah this is just a fascinating game because I've never seen a game combine these mechanisms in this way before and also play in a relatively short game and have like the rules are hard to wrap your head around it's one of those games similar to something like Equinox or or curious cargo when like the rules seem simple but then you start playing and it's actually pretty confusing yeah um but yeah there's you're building a city with other players it's a tile Lane game but you're able to add tiles to expand the city outwards or to place tiles over other players tiles to change what color tiles are in the city there's different colored tiles to create different districts and then there's like yeah area majority over the districts and you're doing this by drafting cards and passing them throughout the game so like everything you do is a shared interactive like the map the cards the tile everything you do you have to be aware of the other players around you uh very interesting game very thinky I could see this one potentially getting a lot higher on my list but it's like I haven't really wrapped my head around it fully yet so it could also be one like similar with you with which Stone it could be one that falls off the list if

over time you know the the strategy doesn't become any more clear and I don't have like the the great plays with other people yeah I don't know where it's going to get to in my playing group no one has seemed to like it anywhere near as my just me yet so right uh yeah if it doesn't get played enough it might slip off but kinkopolis is a really interesting game I'm excited to play it uh not under the influence of alcohol and not only two in the morning yeah of course because it does like I do remember finding parts of it just saying I just remember my brain being like you can't do this right now yeah yeah you do this I'm like you can't do it you're like oh okay so wait what how does this work together half an hour into the game that was my fault uh that was gamecopolis all right my number 48 uh is a different version of a game that was on my list last year and that version is no longer on my list so the other version last year was the 35. um this is I think I know this is 48 and it's code names duet oh never mind yeah so code names was 35 last year code names is actually not on my list this year because I haven't played it at all in this last year but I've played a bunch of code names duet and it's very much the same experience of the actual game it's just it's in a two-player package it's now Cooperative so it's changed but what the actual actions of how you're giving Clues and everything has stayed the same so I feel like you're still getting the code names experience out of it it's just in a two-player package I love codenames duet I think it's such a great two-player game it's situational for me personally in the sense that like I usually now just play code names duet with like dates like for some reason that's just like it's just a really good couple or date game uh because you're

working together because it's that Cooperative game sort of naturally is more approachable yeah we can help you get to know someone too yeah totally and given the way you give Clues and like it's just yeah it's it's you can try to find things that you have in common with how you're going to link up Clues so you're kind of learning about each other in the same way so I played a bunch of it I really love coding music I think it is a really really good version of code names and I think it's also one where like people could play this version never having played the original code names and it's not like you're losing part out on the experience or that's like not where you should start or whatever so yeah so codenames duet 48 was on the list last year but it kind of replaces code names right and there's less downtime in this version right yeah and especially per player because it's not like one person coming up the clue while everyone else sits around there's a mini campaign in there too like everyone you have a map and you go to like different cities and they have harder requirements and stuff so you can actually get some longevity yeah yeah I have a copy I really need to try this with Anna yeah I think he doesn't like it yeah cool nice pick all right number 48 on my list is a game that dropped seven spots from number 41 last year and that is monstrosity ah yeah um the it's hard to say why it dropped I mean part of it is just that there are new games on the list right and some new games that have made it are ahead of it so it kind of got bumped a little bit but it's still a really really fun game we had an awesome another awesome play of this uh during our charity live stream that we did back in May for mental health um and basically yeah for anyone who doesn't know that long and short of it is you're playing together uh with uh it's not cooperatively but one per you take turns one player is the uh eyewitness we saw some sort of monster

commit a crime and the other players all are sketch artists with a little dry erase board marker and you have two minutes to or you have a 20 seconds to look at this card that has a drawing of a monster and memorize it put it face down and then you have a two minute timer to describe the monster as everyone else draws it and then at the end you're gonna be kind of revealing and seeing who is closest and that sort of thing really fun game tons of laughs I think I've cooled on it just a little bit and I found that after the original four five six times I played and I was like just absolutely loved it the novelty wore off just a little bit it's still a game that I'm never I don't think I'm gonna get rid of any time soon but I'm finding that in those environments I'm tending to default to a couple other party games that are just a little higher on the list so uh fully deserves this place on the list still excellent game I think everyone should try it um yeah monstrosity monstrosity uh is actually not on my list this year was last year but it I think it was like 53 54. it was just it just missed yeah and I played a couple times I ordered from you to play with my co-workers and stuff it is really fun I still really really enjoy it I would agree I think I've cooled on just a little bit in the sense that like not that it's gotten worse but for this one specifically it is just kind of group dependent like yeah that's not only on drawing ability and stuff but also just like how engaged people are with drawing games how much how much laughs and fun they get out of it when you have the right group for it I feel like this is like 10 to 15 spots higher on my list yes but because that inconsistency it's hard to to rank it that's exactly it all of my most memorable plays of it aside from the one on the live stream were before we did last year's top 50 and then most of the plays this year were like oh it's still really good but not quite as good as I remember kind of thing yeah but anyway

monstrosity number 47 for me was 46 last year it's dropped one spot uh and that is drive four drive four I couldn't take off the list even with other games I I don't think I've even played Jaipur this year but I couldn't bump do I pour off because I played it so much that I still have I still know how much I enjoy this game I still know it's a Premiere two-player experience out of the the ones I I have on my shelf and then I play regularly um and it's just great it's an easy one that I can always go to and teach and not worry about their are being a bunch of like rules complications or people understanding stuff and we can have fun out of it even though I've seen so much of dry poor and I've actually played it on board game read it now too um I never feel like it's like boring because like oh I've played this a bunch or I know the strategy or whatever there is at there are aspects of it that I just find so much fun to come back to and like and knowing like when to like you know invest in camels and and then how many camels kind of give up to still claim the most camels token but still be able to use my camels efficiently or even just selling like two uh of a gem type rather than waiting for the third when you know you're not getting the bonuses yeah and for the hand management to free up space like the game has really it's right and we love cities we love hand management games yeah you see everything there is to see in Lost Cities but the game is still highly replayable because the decisions are super tough right yeah yeah so it still it still hangs on to my top 50. I thought there was a chance it might slip off but uh because it was 46 last year but it only drops one spot so 46. not quite in my top 50 but yeah excellent two-player games still in my collection as well I'll happily played any day I don't know why that just reminded me when you said knock what my top if they have Whiplash JK Simmons then not quite

my temper not quite my temple not quite all right number 47 for me is one that has fallen quite a bit and this is Again The Nostalgia Factor at play a little bit trying to divorce myself from that is this your biggest fall no I know okay uh no I don't I don't think so okay look at it yeah maybe it might be though yeah it's pretty high so this one has dropped 17 spots okay down to number 47 from number 30 last year and that is evolution climate so there's a couple of reasons well first of all I'll describe the game briefly uh I the essential what you're doing in this game is you are um creating species and adding trait cards then like you have a blank species at the start sort of a blank canvas one population and one body size and you're playing cards throughout the game uh adding either three or four traits to each of your species in front of you you can gain additional ones throughout the game um and basically you're adding traits to make them more adaptable into the environment you're gonna have to collect food the points in this game are food so everyone was going to be like a watering hole where a certain number of food gets generated depending on what cards you place there's like multi-use cards Tableau building it's very interactive you can have carnivores that eat other people's animals and all kinds of stuff so it can be a very punishing unforgiving game if you fall behind really early it is tough to come back in this game it does have a bit of the runaway leader thing unless like it's kind of on the players to attack The Runaway leader if everyone like doesn't

go after the leader like the game isn't gonna just kind of have that Mario Kart effect on its own right so um the last I've played it I think twice in the past year and both times I just think that um there was a long time where I didn't play it maybe year or two and we played so many other games in the meantime that when I came back to it I think I just realized that I've cooled on it a little bit and the plays that I had of it were like I think we played once and someone was like oh now that I understand can we play again and I remember thinking like I don't really want to play it again right now like we just played it and in the past when I used to like love love love this game more I think I would have been down to play it over and over all night kind of thing so still a very good game but um The more I've played it I've cooled on it a little bit I don't think it's something I'm gonna suggest I also don't think it's gonna like leave my collection yet yeah um but yeah Evolution climate that's it yeah this is one that never resonated with me the same way that it did with you and also I just wanted one of those like unlucky experiences too where like one time when we were playing at the cabin I just happened to get really sick and I had to stop halfway through the game or something that's what my memories of evolution climate is it being one of the games where I felt like I was gonna throw up while playing yeah and we just packed it away and whatever yeah so uh yeah so it's never hit resume quite the same way with me but I don't think it's a bad game it's just something about it never you know jumped out yeah but that's fair yeah so I can understand the drop cool yeah that was evolution client that was my number 47. and yeah it dropped 17 spots that might actually be the biggest fall yeah oh no because I had one in the 20s that's off the list completely oh okay and so if you don't get to that game it was Isle of Skye oh damn anyways um number 46 for me is a game that

wasn't on my list last year uh I thought this one could be higher but it ended up not being and that is mandala nice great two-player game this one honestly if I continue to play it a lot in the same way that I play other two player games that we've talked about a lot on the channel I could see this one climbing like this probably won't be the the highest it ever reaches um if I continue to play it a lot because I really really enjoy mandala it's just a really interesting uh game but it constantly makes you think about like not only the move you're gonna do but what your opponent's gonna do and you're managing two different areas so it feels like you're playing two different games in some way like yeah there's two men dollars and you're restricted to which color you can play in your area in the joint area um of each one and so having to look and say okay a mandala gets finished in one of every color is present it so how close are we on that one how close are we on that one when do I want to trigger this one or when do I hope they don't trigger it and they aren't managing both and managing which cards are going to come back to you and what they're going to score when they go into your kind of little area there like not just managing your hands yeah like there's so much to think about you're using cars so that you like to play to gain points but you're also using them to be able to win a mandala so it's just like Arboretum a little bit with that what are you using your card for kind of thing totally it's a great game like I said I think this one will continue to climb it the more I play it because I I played it a bunch now but uh but I feel like not enough Rich have like you know reached some of the other two-player games in this list yeah and I think it eventually could it's a great game although it was a little bit late to the party on it because I thought I've said this before I thought it was Mancala um which is a very different game and I was like I played man College before like why is everyone talking about this ancient game yeah exactly like 2019

release who does this company think they are just refactor and everyone's talking about it yeah so mandala is great I can't wait to play it some more yeah I only tried it once with you had a really good first first play of it and it's one that I actually initially had on my short list but after I looked at it and thought I've only played it once it won't make it this year but uh yeah I could see it maybe making my top 50 in the future really good two player game nice all right my number 46 is new to the list first time on here uh that is Lord of the Rings the confrontation I thought this was gonna sneak on yours yeah yeah uh and big shout out to Jeff and Jamie from Foster The meeple Who uh found out that this was one of my Grail games a while back and they tracked down a copy and sent me one uh so thank you so much to you guys uh yeah this game has been a blast to kind of discover I know there's another one relate to the party on because this game came out in like the early 2000s I think yeah it was like 2003 or something Reiner kinesia it's basically a Lord of the Rings themed version of Stratego you have a pretty small um uh I guess like diamond shaped map and you start in your little uh I guess while you're playing obviously the like Frodo and the Gang I I always people in the comments are getting a hard time I'm always bad about like what are they is it frozen like what's their like group of like I guess the hobbits like they're not all Hobbits because what are you asking me the good versus the evil like in Lord of the Rings like it's oh yes the fellowship there you go there you go yeah the first movie is called The Fellowship of the Ring I know I'm telling you I was blank on this because I always go like years and years without watching what are they called Frodo in the game yeah I know

so yeah it's basically the fellowship against uh I'm not even what's what's this yeah but what are the other ones like what are they all lumped in as together well it's in the gate I hate in the instructions it says the good player versus the dark place so I'm like this is not the right lights yeah I don't know anyways good versus evil asymmetric Powers each of your little characters uh you know you have Frodo and Sam and Gandalf whenever each of them has a unique ability and you're moving into once you get into a space where an opponent is you get to turn your pieces around and reveal one of theirs and kind of see who wins the combat you each have a kind of unique set of cards in your hand and you know what the other player has or hasn't played and you're always playing a card every time there's an encounter so very cool game uh the good players just trying to get Frodo to the other end and the evil player is trying to either I think kill a certain amount of the good guys or get a certain amount of their guys to the Shire fascinating game uh really really fun and one that we'll definitely cover in the channel in one of our upcoming retro reviews uh once we've played it a little more yeah this is one that I think I had it on my rankings that I did and didn't make it but it's only because I played it once um I think if I play this one more this could end up climbing a bunch and actually make it on uh because it's a really really good game yeah sure that is Lord of the Rings the confrontations it's really tough to find us if you find a copy somewhere at a reasonable price yeah snatch it up number 45 for me was 29 last year Falls 16 spots but not because I don't like it honestly it's just it's I actually like this a lot I almost have had some better plays of it

this year than ever have but it's just a lot of competition talked about it a lot this year in different ways and that's the mind I really like the mind it's just it's it's just one of those games that for as much as I like it and as much as it's always going to make different lists of mine I'm always gonna rank it high and talk about it it had when I compare it to other games directly it's hard because other games give me a little bit more out of it I'm more impressed by the mind that I am like saying is a better game than this or this or whatever because in many ways it's sometimes yeah sometimes they can I feel like it's not even quite a game it's more of an activity or something like that like I mean it is a game but it's just it's hard in competition with some of the other games in the list so that's the only reason it's Fallen I really really do like them I think it's so unique I think they're I haven't played quite anything like it where it's like the rule set almost it's not the rules you're teaching to everyone it's it's the personalities of the table that you're teaching to people you have to like be like get used to what everyone's personalized are because the first time we play it we're gonna that's gonna be it's gonna be a learning experience to basically set us up for the next time we play it or the second game in a row where now we know this person plays fast this person plays Reserve this person is just like you know never gonna play a card if they think that they're within this and many numbers of it or whatever like yeah that's the funnest part of the mind and so every time I take it with a new group I'm excited to like see how is it going to play with this group so great game super inexpensive super small I mean it's just an easy one to throw in we told our we brought it up at our conference uh that we did a speech uh yeah speech out at in October and one of our teacher friends uh immediately went

and bought five copies of the mind and has been using it in his classroom and he said it's been a huge hit nice that was awesome it's awesome it's great yeah it'd be great for getting kids to open up and talk at least after obviously the game has limited communication but I mean between rounds and stuff but to learn about each other yeah it's you know like it's a situational game so when you're like trying to get together with friends for game night a lot of the time it doesn't come to mind but when you're actually sitting down playing it on come to mind I understand but when you're actually sitting down playing it it's always a great time right totally that is the Mind 45. cool my number 45 is a game that dropped nine spots so last year it was at number 36. uh that is Dune Imperium oh it dropped so yeah and I I think I even from when I first uh played it and talked about it in my top 10 games of 2020 which I believe it was at number five when I did that um I knew at the time that it wasn't one of my absolute favorite work replacement games you're gonna see a few at least three or four more maybe more that ahead on the list um and it's I don't even know if it's that I've cooled on it it's that you know again with 11 new games on the list that weren't on here last year it's just you know over time has fallen a little bit but um we had a really good play of it again on our our live stream that we didn't make um this is work replacement with deck building I'm sure I don't need to really get into I think most people probably have heard of the game before or know some something about it um what is me to drop mostly is that it always still feels a little bit longer than I would like I think the only time I've been able to get it completed in under two hours is when I played at solo a couple times right and so yeah it just it always feels like just a little bit longer I think the time we played on the live stream too I thought we were about to hit that perfect length and then

something happened that like where someone was able to get the conflict then it got pushed and we had to play another full round so sometimes like doing another full round with the conflict does extend it very very fun game and I will say right now I haven't tried either the expansions uh the immortality one just came out I have rise of X but I haven't played it yet so I have a feeling basically if rizovics improves my opinion of it quite a bit I could see this bumping up um if rizovics doesn't do much for it or if I like it less I don't know if this will stay on my top 50 for a long time but it's still a very very good game uh just yeah a little longer than I'd like yeah this one this one's like a newer one to me this year because like when we did our their last list last year I hadn't played it yet um or either I hadn't played it yet or I don't play but I don't think you had yeah and so I was just taking your word for stuff I didn't know anything about it um and I really really like doing Imperium I think it's it's I mean I I like deck building mixed with um like placement yeah workplace or I was just gonna say deck building mixed with like another activity in general going on the same way like Clank has its own thing yeah um and work replacement games yeah I love workplace videos so mixing those two genres together was just like a a beautiful match and even as someone who's not a fan or not a fan I just I've never got was a dune personally I never read the book and and right right it just wasn't something that was you know I understood even without that knowledge I can still somehow see the integration of the theme just from what I put from you and from Braden and and just like the way things are done in the game like it's just it's really really good I like doing a barrel yeah yeah very good so is it well maybe I shouldn't ask this question then feel free to not answer it says it not in your top 50. I'm not telling you okay

uh okay number 44 for me I was 37 last year so it's dropped seven spots and that is terraforming Mars uh so terrified Mars I still really really like I just haven't I think I mean I think I did play it this year but I can only played at the one time it's a game that I think will likely not climb even if I meet someone who wants to play a whole bunch I played a bunch in in a year or something like that I think I've seen everything I I I'm gonna see in terraforming Mars but the amount of times I've played it now I really really like it I just don't think it's gonna grow on me or it's gonna beat out other games that I think are doing some of the mechanics better or just be I'm finding more interesting or whatever the case may be like I still really enjoy the fight on the main board for you know like putting your tiles down and claiming them with your cubes and um and and how certain cards have like special tiles that you can interact on the board with and like when you would wear ocean tiles get places I like the main board thing and the fact that that's all um affected by what we're doing with the cards in our hand like there's something about that I just find really satisfying when I play terrifying Mars as well as the way the game ramps up it's like my favorite thing is how it starts off being like man this game is going to take forever and because like we have to hit this and then all of a sudden as you start to get stuff and you get different cards like they're having new abilities and stuff all of a sudden and you have more money coming in and our credits you suddenly just like are like oh my God like the game's gonna end in two rounds like when you think it's halfway in you're actually like 75 to 80 into the game but it's due to realize it too late every time that always I always like that feeling borgas because it

makes them end and I'm like I could have wish we had two more turns so it leaves me with a good impression of them so yeah it fell but it's I still really like it I just don't know if it'll climb again maybe if I try it with some of the other expansions although I have I do play with Prelude every time now and really enjoy Prelude so yeah terrifying Mars 44. cool all right yeah not on my list uh I did expect it to still be on your top 50 but I did expect it to slip this one right around where I expected yeah yeah you need to get on race for the Galaxy man I'm just kidding I mean I've been on the bracelet Galaxy it's sad but have you really truly not in the way you wanted to all right number 44 on my list is a game that has dropped quite a few spots again uh this has dropped 15 spots from number 29 last year and that's because full disclosure and I think I said this last year when I made my list when I put it on my list at 29 last year I had only played it once and I haven't played it again since then so it's still just on one play and that's why it has dropped that much so at number 44 is Cosmic frog so I it felt kind of odd dropping it so much without having like obviously if you don't play a game at all and it is going to probably drop in most cases but also like my opinion hasn't lessened it's not like it's not getting played because I've thought about it like oh I don't like the game as much it's mostly the barrier of the rulebook isn't laid out in the best way I don't think so coming back to it if you haven't played for a while and relearning it is a little tricky yeah um and the other thing is that setup takes so long that I'm only gonna like the next time I play this game it has to be that people agree in advance like we are going to play Cosmic frog so that I

can refresh on the rules and have it set up but if people come over and see it on the shelf and oh what's that game I'm not just going to be ready to play it again so that's the barrier keeping from playing this game again very very quick rundown of the game I won't get into the usual uh detail that I love about this game but the longest shorter is that you are a frog in space harvesting shards of the planet into your gullet and then jumping into The Ether to store them into your Intergalactic Vault players can steal shards of planet from either players other gullets or from their vaults it's the game is pure chaos there's dice rolling for combat you have powers that change throughout the game a totally random turn order where you never know if your turns next or if you have to wait six turns till you go again there's like meteors that land and crash on the planet throughout the game just absolutely wild stuff but unlike anything I've played amazing artwork really cool theme I can't wait to get it back to the table but um you know if another year goes by and they don't plant we do our top 15 next year it'll have to slip off again but I'm hoping that won't happen because I just have it set up on your table and invite us over well I don't but for the first time I did that and people go out there they were kind of disappointed and then I remember someone didn't have the greatest experience with the game and I felt bad and I was like because because of the like it is gonna take like a good probably hour and a half to two hours and if you're not ready for that Randomness I don't want to put anyone in that situation if they don't want to play the game well I promise you if you have it set up and we play and if I have a bad experience I'll pretend I have a good one thing yeah honestly you just can't hold it against me you just say like it's my own fault at a bad time got it you got it so yeah number 44 Cosmic frog hope to play it again soon nice number 43 for me is

another game that wasn't on the list last year and it's a really simple light little party game that I just bought my own copy of and that is just one uh so just one I played actually a bunch this year and I think I had I think I'd played it last time we did 250 but I just I think it was either once or twice or I just I hadn't hadn't had that like really great experience to kind of like should have it Shine for me yeah and I have played it with I played it I played it a lot now and including with like different groups of people at like work functions and like it's a testament the fact that like normally we don't we don't often buy games that the other person has or we do it sometimes but we don't have a lot of them no there's not tons and this one is one where I would just like after boring it from the last time I was like I just need my own copy like I play this enough it's a go-to enough with the groups it plays up to seven um and you can easily uh you know get more people into it as well um it's yeah it's really simple and yeah sometimes like it's hard for me to be like wow so I think just one's a better game than this or whatever because I'm like that's the hardest thing about this simple thing but like it's it's it it's very reliant on the on the people you play with and the sessions you have and The more I've ever thought about it like the last time I played it at like our work Retreat um that was like everyone still talks about like how much fun that game was and even though it's so simple it is something that can just easily bring people together and to me that is what board games are supposed to be doing if this one can do that really really well and better than a lot of other games then yeah it deserves the spot in my opinion yeah so just one squeaks onto this list it might go if I play more it might go higher it's hard to say but I'm glad that it did make my top 50 because I think it deserves it now that I've

played it a bunch yeah I'll have more to say about it uh higher on the list for sure but yeah it was on my list last year it was higher than you have it but yeah yeah amazing game and I think what makes me I think that the key went like you said these games are tough to say like is it really better than this other like way more complex heavier game but I always think what was my least enjoyable play of it and that's probably still at least an eight or nine out of ten game night that we played it like it's just always very very good never a bad play yeah although I don't think I'll ever forgive you that now that I think about it the fact that you think just one's a better game than Gloom Heaven games are better than glutenant I look back on last year's list okay coming in at number 43 for me is a game that I reviewed on the channel the past year we've actually spoken about it quite a bit in the past year and a half on or I would say uh or so on the channel so last year it was at number 35 it has dropped eight spots that is Cascadia oh wow so still a very very good game I just uh like last year you know it was one of my most anticipated games for 20 or 2021 as it was I played it I love the game very good Thailand game and it's one of the probably higher ones on my entire list that like I found a lot of what happened over this past year is and I think especially because of like again we're not post-pandemic but the pandemic's in a slightly different you know situation than before obviously yeah and I've gravitated more and more towards more interactive games and I found that

Cascadia just there have been a lot of game nights we've gotten together and I've seen it on the shelf and I just keep finding that I'm picking a lot of other games maybe not a lot I don't want to be careful again because like we're talking about we have played like 400-ish 400 plus games over this list like to have a game at uh 43 is still very high it's still one of the best games I've played right um but I've I've cooled on it a little bit and there's just some like all-time great games that I've had the privilege of trying in the last year or so that have snuck ahead of it so uh I don't see it like leaving the top 50 anytime soon or anything like that um and it could even climb if I play maybe a bunch of the solo mode more this year or anything like that really good game and one I would highly recommend to a lot of people um there's really not a lot of like negatives or bad things to point out about it uh yeah amazing game Cascadia this I would have bet was gonna climb on your list I'm very surprised it dropped I thought I thought for sure this was gonna be one that like had a spot last year because it was still a relatively newer game and now it was gonna like climb and continue and maybe maybe not continue to climb but like climb from where you had something little surprises I think part of also why it hasn't climbed is because other people like I've shown it to other people but no one has like a lot of the people I've shown to hasn't really requested to Play It Again like they've been open to it but it doesn't seem to be like the crowd pleaser of like oh that's an amazing game and maybe I just haven't played it with the right people I haven't played it with Anna yet and some other friends who like these kind of lighter Thailand games so yeah anyway Cascadia cool uh number whatever 42 42 is a big drop uh from 23 last year 19 spots and this is mostly because I own I think I've only

played it once in the past year and like I think that's honestly the main reason it's dropped because it is really your game it doesn't use Fjord um so New York it's a great game um I still would never turn down a game of it uh I have fun with every single time play it's not my favorite movie Rosenberg game by any means uh obviously there's a few that I like better but um it is just like a really solid like classic it feels like a very classic Ube experience like when you play it like it's kind of what you would expect from new Bay game I'm glad I have it it could honestly be one that is gonna slingshot a bit and like it's dropped now and then it could climb again because I think it's going to be one that is very dependent on how many times I've played at that year my list in general I think it's gonna be fluid that way because we play so many great games and so many games in general because we have a YouTube channel that even just like if I played a different uvae game more that year or whatever and I've liked them both it's naturally gonna probably push it ahead because I'm like I have these you know more recent great memories of it so and I don't have Nostalgia or anything when you skirt so it's it's a great game um it's dropped this year but I again I wouldn't I would say for this one the 19 spots is not because it's like 19 spots worse so much as it is that like yeah like you said 16 games on mine join the list uh there's a lot of other ones I played more than moved around so it's just kind of like you know it's just that it it's the Natural Evolution of me not having Planet fair enough you're gonna have to give your copy to me then because I've been dying to play this game again and you're the only one and I can't find a copy online like it's out of stock everywhere and like it's one of those games I'm gonna end up buying my own copy of but if you if you think

about getting rid of it speaking of which I'm very curious to see it over time because I think you have I think that's the most uh like Scrappy punishing tight UV Rosenberg bigger game in your collection I'm curious to see as we play more of the ones like La Habra and or yeah and stuff I'm curious to see um yeah where that continues keeps getting pushed further in your list of Ube games maybe we'll do like an Ube swap at some point like you give me one of yours yeah glass Road for new sea orders yeah there you go well I'm not like not getting rid of them I'm not getting like this all right that is 42 news here yep all right number 42 for me is a game that's new to my list this year but it's a game I've spoken about many times on the channel and is one that I specifically remember was like 52 or 53 last year and just had missed out oh so it was like I thought you were I thought it was in like a game you just played this year no no new to the list it's something that I was very close last year and what propelled it into number 42 this year is just it's probably one of my most played games of the last year especially in bigger groups and it continues to deliver every single time we play it wavelength yeah yeah so wavelength was one I think last year I was hesitant to put on the list it kind of like what you're saying about just one I was like it's party game is it just is it the gimmick that I'm like the whole thing with the wheel that you turn to give the clues and stuff um I I kind of wondered about it but the more we've played it like every single group and it's what I like a lot about it is that it works really well obviously with groups who know each other very well because you're trying to give Clues and guess what people would be hinting at and the better you know someone the better idea you're gonna have of where they're trying to point

you with the clue they're giving um but it also works very well with people who don't know each other very well because you're getting to know each other and sussing out and it kind of makes people come out of their shells and the game doesn't work if people aren't talking so no one's gonna say yeah let's play the game and then sit around quietly so um it tends to be just a really good time every single time you're giving someone a clue from one Spectrum to the one end of a wavelength to the other and then basically you can play in teams or you can play cooperatively and the other players are trying to guess where your kind of clue is hinting on this kind of wavelength and uh yeah just a really good game and the fact that it goes up to 12 players really works in its favor and that is part of what helps it stand out about a lot of those party games that cap out at like six or eight or whatever so yeah wavelength I don't know if it'll stick on my top 50 like long term but I think it has a pretty good shot it's a really good party game one of my favorite ones for sure sweet yeah this one was in my 50 to 60 range like it was really close to making on because I played it a bunch more this year as well yeah and same thing love it it's a great it's a great game I think I consider getting my own copy of this one really it's just the cost that is kind of uh

um but yeah I I might still eventually but yeah great game I also played I also board this one from you to bring to what they say that same word function everyone loved it it is a solid party game yeah yeah cool sounds number 42 yeah wavelength last one for this list 41 this is gonna be the this is gonna be the big one so this one is the biggest fall the biggest fall of the entire list tied with the um my city but this one is a bigger deal this is falling 28 swaps from 13 last year so 13 on my list last year 41. I don't even remember this year um and it is the classic Lindbergh oh wow yeah so wow I only played classified Limburg one time this year and so wait did you re-watch are we disagree on video and you're like yeah Carla made some good points yeah Carla was right no see I still I still really like Wax Coit Limburg I think it's just starting to settle in to where like into it like and I still it's a game I'll never get rid of in my collection I don't think or I shouldn't say never because that is one thing I could see beautiful on camera or something yeah I shouldn't have said it uh but in general it's one I will still go to a lot I really enjoyed it I love introducing people the one play I had of it it just wasn't a good session this year and I just find that like I ranked a very highly last year because I had so many good plays of it and the people I was playing with really really loved quacks and requesting it more and stuff like that whereas this year was it was a little bit different so I feel like as I compared it this year to other games on

my list I just realized that as much as I do really love quacks and and that kind of fun experience how the randomness in it I appreciate but it's hard for me to compare it to other games with uh with that level of Randomness because I don't always I'm not always in the mood for it like it's not always something I want it's always what I'm looking for so it doesn't hit the table quite as much I always have fun with quacks that's something I'll never that will probably won't change like there's always a fun factor that I can guarantee on having with quacks but I just find that like more and more I am gravitating to games where like that are that level of Simplicity but with um a more strategic package or like a little bit more tactical or whatever or a shorter game if it's gonna be that exactly and it's just it's a hard it's a hard game to take all the components out for I I can upgrade it and stuff but getting that whole thing set up on a table takes way longer than I than I wanted to and so that's always every time I play it I'm like did any of this uh have to do with the fact that we also tried Orlean for the first time as another bag Builder no did you think I know they're very different games in terms of the way they play but was that like oh man bag building I I don't think so like I mean if anything reminded me that like I do like bag buildings a lot and there are other options out there so maybe a little bit but I wouldn't say that was the main influencer okay if I played more of it if I played more volume maybe it would have been like okay this is like I could see this just replacing and the itch I'm wanting to scratch the backs but yeah ultimately I think this is more a case of it probably being too high last year but I just had a really good plays of it and stuff and

so this now it's settling more into where it actually is makes sense yeah so the biggest drop the biggest ball quacks of weidenberg from 13 to 41. okay so we still disagree on it but nowhere near as much as we did a few months ago all right and the last one on my list for this video here at number 41 up six spots from number 47 last year I think you'll be pleased I think maybe you're probably hoping that it would have climbed even more uh but that is azul like just original yeah that should have quite more I I know this is one that even even last year when I put it at 47 I felt weird because there was a point where it was like a top 10 or top 20 game for me for a while and then I kind of cooled on it and then I think since I cooled on it I may be over cooled on it if that's possible and then when I went back after a while and played it I was yeah I froze on it yeah I guess yeah and then I came back and was like okay no this is better than I remember why did I cool on it and I think I just overplayed it right at one point for a while and then I just needed a break and then coming back to it reminded me like no this is a damn good game yeah we've talked before about what are the things that prevent it from being like you know what's or maybe I wouldn't say top your game for us because I I believe you still have it higher than me perhaps based on last year's list um but yeah it's a really really good game other than the kind of like scoring thing being a little tough for new people to pick up on and that kind of thing it's a really solid game one that I will never turn down a play of I'll never get rid of my copy plays well at all player counts it's just one that I no longer I think it's pretty rare that I'm going to be the one to suggest it off of the Shelf unless it's been one of like every few months like hey it's been

a few months let's play Azul again but if I've played it recently I'm not gonna have that burning desire to get get it to the table again right away there's just too many other games I currently prefer um but yeah it's just a classic game a staple it could be a staple in pretty much anyone's collection and one will never get tired of playing and I feel a bit bad that I had it at 47 last year so I mean I had to give it a bump this year I still think you should feel pretty bad that you have it for in your 40 to 50 range but you know that well but you don't know what games are ahead of it yet it doesn't matter because I know Greek loves Adam and that's already a problem uh depends how you define the word problem yeah I will have more to say about this later and that's that's probably not a spoiler a surprise because I think I had it in my top 10 last year it was cool number nine for you if I remember correctly so uh we'll see where it falls this year but yeah very cool I I love it I'll I'll say more about it later all right that's uh that's it that's 50 to 41 uh we didn't say at the beginning but um I think last year we we had like one of these videos coming out every two days this one will probably be every three days um but it could fluctuate depending if like the third day would fall on a day that's like uh you know on Christmas day or on you know Christmas Eve or boxing day or something we're like let's just delay at one it'll be roughly around three days between videos so you can always count on just kind of checking back on the channel and you'll see when the next video comes out yeah and obviously 10 per video all the way up to one yeah so the series should be done within about a couple weeks so stick around for that and uh let us know if you're enjoying this um otherwise I think that's pretty much it yeah I'll give you a quick little tease and and just just to get people's appetite wet in that there is a game in my top 10 that wasn't on my list at all last year damn okay so we look forward

to that try to try to try to guess what it is go in the comments and try to guess what game was on my list at all last year and now it's a top 10 game okay I'm not gonna say anything about that but yeah I'm very intrigued now I think I might know what it is because I think you mentioned last year that you regretted leaving it off the list so I think I know what it is but I'm gonna be wrong anyways all right thank you so much for watching and we'll see you in uh ranking number 40 or 31 soon

Progress saved