Skip to main content
Loading video...

18 Board Games Ranked - Episode 10

Transcript 28:33

hey everybody and welcome to february's installment of month in review so this is a series where i talk about all the new to me ball games i played during the previous month and i rank them from my least favorite to my most favorite so i've got 18 new titles this month ranging from some pretty simple fillers all the way up to heavy involved euros and everything in between and as usual these games are often based on just a play or two so there are some pretty initial thoughts but some of them are a bit more concrete maybe i'll talk about those as i go through so let's get started at number 18. so my least favorite game of the month is cosmic encounter now i should say up front that i pretty much knew what i was getting into when i played this this is like the opposite of what i look for in board gaming this is a very asymmetrical very imbalanced kind of confrontational style game as you're trying to attack the other players you can rope in other people to help you the defender can as well you're playing massively imbalanced cards against each other to try and um you know trump each other in terms of playing the highest numbers and um this game also has a bunch of interrupts where you know if you have a certain card in your hand you think you've mapped everything out you think you've worked out and you can you know deterministically decide to win a fight and then all of a sudden here comes the card you had no idea about to stop that attack and i i detest that style of gameplay and that's pretty much what this game is all about um so yeah as expected i hated it um and yeah i mean but massive caveat again i'm a eurogamer i like i like um kind of more mechanically balanced games ones that work well and smoothly this one is the pillar opposite of that so yeah

unfortunately um cosmic encounter lived up to its expectations in my head but i know there's a massive mark out there who enjoy this style of game so that is cosmic encounter at number 18. at number 17 i have coo which is a small box card game a a bluffing style game which you can choose to um kind of adopt the power of these different roles to kind of collect money or steal money for other players and then try to eliminate the other players when you have a certain amount of currency and it's kind of a last man standing style of game um this one i i got to the table and i wanted to play it because i always heard that this was kind of the hell of a genre always considered quite a good bluffing game and i will say this one did disappoint me quite a bit um because sometimes when you've got this currency and you're just picking someone pretty much at random just saying that i'm eliminating you or maybe you're basing on who's got the most lives and then once everybody's got the same lives again you're just picking someone just for the sake of it so i don't again i don't like that style of gameplay just that player elimination aspect stuff that you can't really do anything about and um yeah it just was a bit too abrupt and not again not my style of gameplay and funnily enough i got this game to replace an older game in my collection called operation faust which was like this um game where you're cut bluffing collecting currency but that one you're buying artwork to try and get to a certain value um so it wasn't so in your face and this one um kind of got rid of the part i liked about that style of game and um i thought made it worse so that is cool at number 17.

at number 16 i have eratis cartis so this is the card game version of the board game rattus this is a a push your luck style game and i suppose maybe a hand management style game as at the start of the game there's going to be a bunch of these cars placed face down with this limit of rats on them and if you ever go above those rats will at the end of the game if you have above those rats then you're going to be eliminated but the objective is that you're trying to use these cards to climb these number of different tracks and depending on your position on the track so you're going to get victory points but every every round a couple of cards come out that you have to kind of tribute cards to and if you contribute the matching cards then you're absolutely fine and you'll just move up the track that many spaces but if you decide to tribute cards that don't match then you'll take a rat token which we again will try which will bring you closer to that rat limit um i don't mind the concept of this game and i like that idea of that as the game goes on you start to learn how what that threshold is of those rats but what i really didn't like about this game was just how swinging it was and how lucky it was so um i ended up getting loads and loads of cards of a certain type and then that building i needed to tribute those cards towards never came up and it did work for the other players so it's like pure luck um there's not really much you can do about it um if you know that rat limit you know what you've got to play with anyway so it just didn't work for me and it was just way too lucky and um yeah nothing you can do about it so it's a shame really because i think it could be a bit of an easy fix but it didn't work for me

for that reason so that is rattus cartis at number 16. at number 15 i have dominoes or ominous i don't quite know how you pronounce this one and this one i have only played once so this is very initial thoughts and this one is an abstract dice rolling game where you have this grid and you are rolling uh running a die in your turn and that's going to have a number of different faces on it kind of related to the different players in the game one of them does something a bit different is like kind of a wild and you are basically trying to bring a cluster of your your faces together to try and score them as points but whenever you put one of your or whenever you put a die onto the board then you can move another die up to three spaces so you can use that to kind of bring your die closer to your cluster or maybe move your opponents away from their bigger clusters just to slow them down a bit that's pretty much the gist of the game i didn't really see the strategies here and it felt a bit too random for an abstract because sometimes you just don't roll the faces that you need and therefore you don't really have the opportunity to score points in the first place so yeah i wasn't too keen on it but it did feel quite nice to play it was um it has quite a nice kind of throwback design to it it feels like an old-fashioned toy which kind of feels quite charming um but still the jury is out on this one maybe some levels of strategy will start to unravel the more i play it so that is ominos at number 15.

at number 14 i have shanghainen which is a two-player of the filler game um a kind of set collection style game is you have this row of cards i'm depicting these different pirates then you're rolling a pair of dice and then you are basically depending on the pit value you are placing them next to these certain cards of the matching spot on the row and then the idea is that you're trying to have the majority of those cards or have the majority of dice or the dice neighboring that can kind of boost your power to collect those cards for end game scoring so that's very simple stuff but the thing i did like about this game is the actual scoring mechanism itself where you would score in relation to what your opponent had of the same suit so say i had a total value of five yellow cards my opponent had a value of three then i would end up scoring three because that's what my opponent scored but if you have all the cards i get a monopoly on those cards then you score all those points and you could use that in quite clever ways so if you know that your opponent had say eight of a certain type and you had none and they're about to score all those points you could maybe claim a one card of that type to make sure they only score one points because they only score what you have in front of you so that was quite a cool mechanism i think the gameplay is a little bit too straightforward and you don't really have much kind of mitigation of the dice rolls but despite that i think it doesn't work against the game because it is so simple and it's pretty fast and very accessible but a good game um and i enjoyed it and i'll probably play a few times more that is shanghainen at number 14.

at number 13 i've had a game that i've been after for quite a while now because it came out last year this one is the game 10 so 10 is a pushy luck and bidding style game as you were trying to collect sets of numbers of different colors so you're trying to create say one to one to ten basically um as your maximum score and you're doing that in this kind of drawing cards pushy like mechanism where you are placing cards out trying not to go above 10 when you're drawing these numbers out but whenever you draw these other cards which have these different kind of um tokens on them then you're bringing that value back down so it has that back and forth momentum where you know i'm up to nine but then i draw one of these cards down to bring it back down to four so you can get more mileage out of your turn that way and then once you've decided to stop because you don't think you can you know draw any more cards in the fear of getting going bust then you can either choose to take all the numbers and add them to your scoring pile or you can take those um those tokens in order to bid for cards in the market which have gone their pre on previous turns that have been either busted or um neglected when they chose the tokens instead so that was quite cool i thought the auction mechanism when you choose to bid for these different cards was a bit tacked on because these wild cards would come out and you'd have to stop and do an auction i didn't think that worked for the game and it felt like a mechanism too many or just one too much and i think that's probably one of the lasting things this game so i generally love pushing up games and this one works well but i think it's got two or you know one too few one too many things just bolted on for the sake of it but despite that i did like the game that is

10 at number 13. at number 12 i have another very simple dice game this is pasha by stefan dora this is a kind of a yahtzee variation as you're rolling um i think it's five dice and then you are um i think you've got like two rerolls as you would with the artsy and you're trying to build up the best kind of bunch of dice that you can so you know are you gonna get a pair are you gonna get the three of a kind or maybe even a full house and you're basically trying to get as far as i can to get the best possible role you can but what i did like about this game is that prior to taking your your action or your roles you choose to play one of your scoring cards which determines the the points that the winner the second place third place fourth place are gonna get at the end so if you're really confident that you can beat the people who played before you can maybe play a higher card but if you go earlier then you're kind of more um unable to make an informed decision so that was quite cool um and yeah that was probably one of the the best things i took away from this game but despite that this is a game that's very accessible anybody can really enjoy this one just pure dice rolling fun and i can see this game hitting the table quite regularly because it is so straightforward so that is pasha at number 12.

at number 11 i have a very popular game with viticulture by stone maya games so this one is a kind of a a light to medium weight euro worker placement game based on a vineyard so you are gathering grapes these grape vines you are turning those wine grapes into a wine and you're bottling it up to sell and it's a pretty straightforward game but one that works well i like these upgrades you have on your board as you would constantly kind of upgrade your little your little vineyard increase your storage capacity your capacity to make more kind of vintage wines um getting certain upgrades so you can make other um other kind of um orders and things i did feel that this game was a bit too like dependent on some card drawers because a lot of these work replacement spots would be just draw from the order ordered x for a new order to fulfill um and maybe you didn't have the vines in order to fulfill that order or you know you're trying to draw a certain type of grape and it never comes out i mean that happened to me personally and one other thing i really didn't like about the game was the swinginess of some of these yellow cards in the game so you go to this um spot which let you draw a yellow card or play a yellow card i can't remember and it would some of these cars would be absolutely fantastically powered um once it would just do a bunch of things as a single action and some of them would be like very circumstantial and not too interesting and for me that really did dictate the the feel of the game and it kind of when there was a big move to make it didn't really feel like you made

it it felt like the game made it by drawing or by playing a certain card and that just felt a bit unsatisfying for me but um despite all that i did really like this um this efficiency puzzle of getting the grapes in trying to mature them to sell nothing more profits and not to waste that maturity because you know every every round all your grapes will slide up to the next level making them more and more mature which is quite thematic so a nice game one that i thought was quite forgettable which might be quite insulting to some people but um it didn't really do it for me despite being well-rounded but you know a good game but not one for me that's for sure that is viticulture at number 11. at number 10 i have the isle of cats which has been quite popular over the last couple of years this one is a drafting and kind of polyamino style game as you're drafting these cards which will let you kind of get more get these cats or currency to get cats they'll give you these scoring opportunities which is quite cool so you'd actually build up what you're going to score throughout the game in order to which will kind of synergize with the puzzle you're making with the with the polymers you're placing on this boat um so you're placing all these tiles you know maybe you're trying to match colors to colors you're trying to maybe fill the parameter of the boat all these different criteria develop that skin goes on to get you victory points so it's quite a satisfying game and i thought those two distinct mechanisms did synergize with each other very well and there's quite a lot to consider here so i thought this was probably one of the best polyamino games i've played in recent memory and i can see why it's popular so that is isle of cats at number 10.

at number nine i have king domino origins so this is actually my first experience playing any king domino game i never played the original or queen domino this one is kind of set in that prehistoric theme so um slightly different skin there but this one is a very simple domino star games you're placing these domino shaped tiles onto a little onto your little tableau i suppose trying to build up i think it's like a 5x5 grid it might be bigger i can't quite remember try to match terrain to terrain and trying to get these different symbols um to increase your multipliers and which will get you points at the end of the game so and that was quite cool i did think there were some things that were quite unnecessary like these characters would come out which you could buy to score your points in other ways i thought that was a bit tacked on and took away from some of the purity of the game but i did really like this volcano mechanism where you take these some of these tiles would have volcanoes on them which were pretty much dud spacers but they would spit out these um bits of lava which would land on other tiles and they could increase your multiplier so that was a really cool mechanism so yeah other than that very simple fun very family friendly but it works well and there's still quite a satisfying puzzle so that is king domino origins a very nice family game at number eight i have a mafia zoo by rudiger dawn and this one is a re-implementation of an older game of his called louis xiv um an area control style game that uses the istanbul kind of merchant mechanism where you would take a bunch of tokens and start there and then you can drop them off one on a row kind of going down a route and this

one uses that mechanism but on uh you know an area control style game but this one has this kind of anthropomorphic mafia theme to it as you're trying to influence all these different mobsters to get you these resource tokens and then you use those resource tokens to claim buildings on a separate part of the board which will get you victory points and engine building benefits so i thought this one flowed really well um i had a good amount of kind of deterministic strategy but balanced quite well with drafting or drawing cards in the first place to show your starting points on this on this drop-off mechanism so that was quite cool it kind of struck a good balance between strategic but still tactical and didn't make it too um ap prone but i like the game um i do think that it has um definitely has has um a limit on how many times you can play this one yeah i've played a few times now i think i'm done with it i still would say you know check it out if you can but i don't think it has that massive potential for replayability and because everything is static on the board you know there's no modularity you can't mix all these um mod bosses around you can't mix the buildings around so it pretty much feels like you're saying that's playing the same thing game and time and time again but i've already reviewed by this one um it's not been released yet so you know keep an eye out for that one but i'd recommend checking it out because it might appeal to you and it's a good area control style game that is mafiosu at number eight okay so starting with seven here this is where my shields of quality start so these are games that have reached at least a seven out of ten

and ones i would quite confidently recommend um so at number seven uh gaining my first shield of quality is last will um by vladimir suki so this is an older design of his another relatively simple worker placement game but something i always say again and again if you're gonna make a an entry-level gateway worker placement style game do something different because there are so many out there they're all copy and paste and you'll feel exactly the same this one feels different because purely of the premise of the game is that you start with your points which is money in this game and you're trying to waste it as quickly as you can um you're going to be doing that by doing this lavish spending sure by buying houses for high prices and selling them for low prices maybe you'll just wait for ages to let the price depreciate and then sell it and you can hire all these helpers that will waste your money for you um lots of cool things here a really thematic game one that you know i thought was really enjoyable and the theme came through strongly um and i really like this mechanism of you could choose your kind of actions you take throughout the game so are you gonna draw this many cards are you gonna get this many workers to place um and that will also determine the initiative on which you're gonna play your pieces as well so that was a really cool mechanism um and i like the game a lot i'm not quite sure how it will hold up again time after time um but i'm keeping a hold of it for now because i do want to place a few more explore what that has to offer and it plays in a very succinct amount of time as well so um this one might even fit or stay in my collection to fit that get that entry-level worker placement um

kind of bracket in my in my collection so really nice game i enjoyed it a lot that is last will at number seven at number six i have a uh orion kinicia game called celtus which is i think it's actually a former spilled jars winner from a few years back this one is basically considered lost cities the board game and this one you are trying to acquire these cars or you always have a hand of cards and you're playing them in order are they starting high and burdening to low or going low and building to high and you've got i think it's five or six different suits and you're basically when you play these cards you are climbing up the relative track and when you climb up these tracks you are starting at negative points and then trying to work your way towards positive points so you can kind of do a bit of a gamble and say you know what i'm going to guess i'm going to get to this point but sometimes you won't even reach and get out of those negative points which is quite a cool tension but this grain has some really cool domino effects where we where you reach certain points on the tracks where you get these tokens which will again screen more victory points or you can score straight up victory points or you can even get these kind of clover spaces which will as soon as you reach that spot it will knock up another one your tokens on another track and that can create some really cool cascading effects where this will take up this track this take up this track and so on and it's really satisfying when that happens um a nice game that that cannot tension really shines through um you're really gonna have to pace yourself quite well because you you don't have so much time to do get these things done and starting on tracks late can be a massive gamble and can you end you up in the negative so pretty much it's lost cities but the but

the board game and the k is from two to four players which is very nice but really good game that is celtic number six at number five i have hadrian's wall which is a very grandiose uh roll and write style game or a flip and write style game in this example as there's so much going on here this is pretty much a massive spreadsheet um you are drawing a card at the start of the term which will show the resources that you have and then you are going to be using all these meeples because you actually have physical resources in this game in meeples and these resources to do a bunch of different actions so you're basically trying to fortify this this roman fought to stop these picks invading because every at the end of every round a certain amount of picks will come and attack and if you can fortify it and protect yourself then you'll score valor points which is get victory points or if they slip through your barricade then you'll end up scoring negative points but there are other roll and right tracks so it'll unlock so you can use to convert them into positive points or you can kind of do lots of things to kind of um again mitigate that risk you've got this kind of polyamino star part of the game you've got lots of upgrades you can get there's a ton going on here definitely the most involved roll and right game i've ever played and two is probably probably the best rolling rider game i've ever played i will say i went into this game with expectations being sky high because i've heard so much good things about this one and i do think it's a brilliant game i will say that it doesn't necessarily feel as deep as i would have expected um it kind of feels more more wide and it's got a big breadth to

it but the way the things synergize aren't quite to the level i would have hoped but despite that i do think it's a it's a really good game i mean it feels like you're playing three roller mic games at once some of the combos and things you get out are massive you know you get go up this box or tick this box which get you this resource you spend this resource to get this resource this resource and you can really string out these long epic terms we can get a hell of a lot done um and you're spinning a lot of plates here so i thought it was a very good game i've played this a couple of times already really enjoyed it and um i think this one's going to be it might be a grower or it could go the other way so this one is kind of on that effect to me but it's never going to go below a shield of quality because it is that good but um it'd be interesting to see if it's going to reach higher points or or slip a bit but that is hadrian's wall um very good roland right game now at number four i have a small game with sub astral so subastral is a game i really enjoy at the moment so this is by matt riddle and ben pinchback who i recently been gushing about because they made a game called stella which i really loved this one is kind of another game in that line i suppose by renegade as you are basically trying to collect cards to build sets a very simple set collection style game but this one does some things very differently that make me really dissatisfied i find this game very intriguing so you have a hand of cards you're playing them on this communal row of cards and depending on the number you play it will have a number of cards to the left of it to the right of it so if you've got you should play four you've got the three two and one to the left

and the five and six to the right and if you take any cards to the left you're going to add them into your hand for kind of future plays and if you play anything to the right you're going to add them in front of you for scoring and the more cards you collect of different types the more points you're going to get but that starts on numerous rows so if you start again from scratch from the first card you collected you can create more sets and on top of that your two most numerous columns of cards or the you know the most numerous suits you have score points in relation to how far they are on that track so if it's a six card along and you have three cards of it then you're going to score 18 points because the six times six times three so i really love the scoring mechanism here it works so well it feels breezy it feels stinky and it's probably one of the best for the games i've played in modern memory so that is sub astral check out my review i love this game at number three i have an older game with peloponnese uh peloponnese is a weird mix of uh pretty a pretty accessible beige euro but one with some really cool ongoing tension some cool auction going on here or bidding um as you are taking control of this derivation you're managing the population the resources and you're using those resources and currency in order to buy new tiles and those tiles will give you more population they'll give you sometimes powers and things um but every so often there will be a tiles that come out which will negatively affect you so it'll be things such as um lose a third of your population or lose a third of your

resources and all these things you've got to try and mitigate um and prepare for when they come out so it's a really cool tension where at the end of each round you'll flip a number of these tokens around which will start kind of edging towards these um catastrophes being triggered so i love that punishing nature of it and trying to overcome those difficulties it really reminds me of a game like um like in the year of the dragon you know where the game works against you but that the bidding works well too um it's got some really good things going on here pleaser has a really good balance of being pretty thinky quite strategic i'm tactical but only taking around 45 minutes to play strikes a really good balance that way and i i'm really enjoying this one and i think it's a fantastic game that should be talked about more but it's kind of faded into obscurity over the years but very good classic euro that is poloponies so let's go into the top two now and these are two games with my uh elite shield so this is the best of the best for me games that have ranked at least an eight and a half out of ten so the best the best uh at number two i have boone lake which is the latest game by alexander fister this is uh almost fits to spin on the terra mystica system as you are putting buildings out onto this communal board unlocking income as you do so as you know you're removing things from your player board and it will reveal currency or victory points and you are basically trying to build up these um these settlers and these houses and then these these settlements um which will generate points in different ways um you have

this really cool action selection system where you're basically drafting this action strip which will determine the actions you can take in the game you know it could be create a new space on the board to go to it could be upgraded when your piece is already on the board it can be put one of these cows down in order to score points but i love the fact that when you take one of these action strips everybody else gets like a follow-up action which they can take so everyone is engaged at all times in this game and then you'll remove the action strip and play it to the bottom of this um this table basically which will really decrease the incentive for other people to use the action again because they can potentially lose victory points so it has that really cool um back and forth of waiting for actions to build up strength again because the higher they are you can go further down this river which will get you more flexibility which will get you bigger bonuses and then you've got all the traditional alexander fister card play on top of it where you're building up an engine throughout the game um lots going on here but surprisingly easy to learn and play and this one really did go down well for me and i think it's a very pleasant experience and probably my favorite or second favorite vista game and definitely my favorite vista game since maracaibo so that is boon lake at number two fantastic vista and finally at number one to no surprise my favorite game of the month is arc nova so arcanova definitely the hotness at the moment this is a pretty involved heavy strategic euro game about building a zoo from scratch so you're building the enclosures you're getting animals in from all over the world of different types you've got your primates you've got your big cats your you've got your

your um kind of reptiles and you can put them in a reptile house you're getting points in different ways all these cards are unique you know there's no duplicates at all um it has that really cool scoring system where you have to balance your appeal of your zoo by getting the coolest animals in but also with your conservation points where you do think you'll get points such as looking after certain types of animals or you can even send them back up into the wild and you're trying to get these two different points um to cross over each other much like in the game like rajas of the ganges and which is a really cool mechanism it has a cool tension to it and this one does that very well um i don't think this game does tremendously anything or any anything tremendously new or unique but what it does it does very well you know it manages to embed uh a lot of um strategy and a lot of gameplay into a very core simple system as you're basically choosing an action out of these five actions you're removing that card and putting it back to back to the start of the row which again will increase the power of it the longer you neglect it and you can upgrade those to make your actions more strong um so much to talk about here just go check out my review um i was gushing about this game i think it's fantastic has a brilliant solo mode which is quite rare for me to say um and um yeah it's fantastic believe the hype on this one i think is great and definitely worth your attention at least especially if you like games like um like terrifying mars or underwater cities this is very much in that vein and has all those cool card combos so yeah my favorite game of the month is arc nova so that concludes uh this monthly review

i hope you've enjoyed it and something on here has caught your attention um as always um thank you for watching and um you know be sure to check out my my different platforms and patreon um subscribe if you haven't leave comment and like all that good stuff and for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved