Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 17:26

hi I'm Adam Porter and this is my board gaming Vlog and I know I've had a bit of a break for a few months unfortunately uh I haven't had the time to make these videos it's been because I've been devoting so much time to designing games um as you'll know over the last few years I've been designing games I've been regularly going to play test UK meetups which are meetups of um designers trying to make inroads into the industry uh I meet weekly with a group group in Cardiff and then I also meet with a group in Bristol and uh Oxford and occasionally up to London and Birmingham uh and I've been doing this for years now I've got to the point where I've got a few games five games uh waiting to be published so they should be out over the coming months um and so I'm starting to get a bit of a feel for the sort of problems people hit when they're designing games and I thought that's what I'd talk about in this video and hopefully over a few videos um coming up over the next few weeks or months um so in this particular video I wanted talk about the pitfalls that people hit when they're first time designers and uh specifically I want to talk about Dice and Randomness in firsttime designs okay so to get it out there straight away I designed dice games two of my games which are coming out soon will be dice games but they are specifically dice games they are games entirely based around dice around rolling dice mitigating their luck manipulating those dice um push your luck sort of gambling sort of elements to them they are not large games that

use dice for a degree of Randomness within those games and that's what I'm talking about here when I say to you Dice are not the answer in a first time design frequently when prototypes come to our group we'll find that there will be roll and move mechanisms so that basically is the old style uh Monopoly Style game where you roll the dice and you move that many spaces you have no choice about where you end up or maybe you have the choice of going left or right as in a game like Talisman again an old game now we're looking back to the 1980s here this is not modern stuff um but basically your move is dictated by the dice roll the other thing I see frequently is roll for combat now this is much more present in the modern board gaming hobby it's still used in a lot of American style games particularly um so when we're fighting battling Fantasy games Sci-Fi games rolling the dice in order to resolve combat and then the other thing is just Randomness all over the place and to me this is really uh characterized by the event deck frequently I see this in a firsttime designer game um an event deck a deck of cards and on at the beginning of a round or at the beginning of a player's turn they draw an event and something random happens now it might might wipe out one entire portion of the board and all the pieces on it it might take away all of a players's resources or all of all players resources it may reset the work

that has been carried out over half an hour or an hour of gameplay and that can be deeply frustrating so the first thing I'm going to do is just go through this collection of games here and let's have a look and see how many of these games feature roll and move mechanisms so if we take a look at my collection and starting at the top and moving down how many of these games that you can see here feature roll and move well the answer is none of them even these adventure games where we're moving around a map they don't tend to feature roll and move not even in something like Super Dungeon explore which is your classic Dungeon Crawler or Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles which is a Miniatures battle game not even in Imperial assault we don't see roller move in there as we come down here there is one game which does and this is maret this is a children's game with a big chunky dice where you can move about on the board that has a bit of roller move in it and further down as we get to some of the older games well heroquest that certainly features roll and move none of the games on the next shelf none of these at all feature roll and move in them and then as we go along the top there's no roll and move in here and in fact until you come down to this shelf here which has three racing games this is where we see some roll and move starting to happen so formula D this is a straightforward racing game rolling dice moving around the track um but it has an ingenious mechanism uh to to to

deal with that and then these two racing games here both have roll and move in and actually there's a similar game a little further along which is the game Manila this is similar in field to camel up uh again you're rolling Dice and moving things aside from that none of the games in my collection here have roll and move in them at all so Monopoly is a bit of a classic example here because it has roll and move and then it also has event decks it has two of them Community chest and chance so when I land on a chance space or a community chest space which is through no strategy through no fault of my own I haven't decided to go there just the dice roll has taken me there I draw a card and something bad might happen to me or something good might happen to me now that is chaotic it's unskillful it's sort of entertaining momentarily I've got 20 quid you know it's not fun to lose the 20 quid although it may be fun for the other players to laugh at me in a mean spirited way um but ultimately it leads to a frustrating gameplay experience um so Monopoly has a bit of both heroquest was a favorite game of mine as a child the old MB Games Games Workshop game um so let's have a little look at a bit of of uh hero quest in action so here we have an elf he's in a room with two Orcs he wants to get away from the Orcs but the only way he can do it is by rolling

the dice he rolls them he gets two wands so he can only move two spaces of a possible 12 he moves two spaces away from the Orcs he now well he can't fight so he decides he's going to search so he draws a treasure from the treasure deck but it's not a treasure it's a wanding monster an event from the event deck so a chaos Warrior is placed on the board and if we have a look at the chaos Warrior card here we can see he rolls three attack dice so now we have combat by dice he rolls three skulls that's three hits on the elf now the elf only has two defense dice so he can only counter one of those two of those hit points at most so he rolls two of them he's looking for Shields doesn't get them three hit points elf is dead okay through no fault with his own now the dwarf has a turn two sixes brilliant he's he's running away from an ogre and a gargoyle he's got a 12 he's miles away okay now what did he do differently to the elf nothing and yet the elf is on the floor and the dwarf gets away okay so hopefully you're starting to get the point once we introduce this degree of Randomness into a game then all strategic decisions and tactical decisions cease to matter doesn't matter how interesting and and and ingenious your game design is it's going to be completely undermined by the luck and chance in the game unless it's a very very short game I'm not saying you can't

use uh roll and move or roll for combat in games but I think they should be reserved for experienced game designers they're no longer useful mechanisms for somebody learning um you know introducing themselves into game design in fact I would say they're toxic I would say they destroy destroy your first designs they can be used ingeniously as in um formula d uh where a player can select which type of dice they want to use in fact let's look at all the alternate mechanisms for moving around the board what else could we do so here are a bunch of games where you move around the board throughout the game how many of these use roll and move not that many there are a few there are a few in here so specifically there's formula D which uses its clever sort of dice system where you choose which type of dice you want to use what size of dice and you work your way up through the gears so you might be using a big chunky 30-sided dice that comes with additional risks or you might use the nice and safe little four-sided or six-sided dice um so that is how formula D gets around the problem camel up this one uses dice roll R in but here we're gambling on where the playing pieces are going to end up so the playing pieces in camel up and in Winner's Circle and in Manila the playing pieces don't belong to any particular player uh so when we

roll the dice and move those pieces it it's a case of we're we're betting on which ones we think are going to get there first so that is roll and move but not in the sense that we've seen it in oldfashioned games now if the game's over here so this is Super Dungeon explore forgotten King te Ninja Turtles Star Wars Imperial assault if these had come out uh 15 20 years ago they would have definitely had roll and move in them but they don't in here we tend to have asymmetric um player Powers so the the different characters in the game can move different amounts um orbe it in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles there is a dice roll but there's plenty of opportunities to mitigate those dice then we have a whole load of games which have action selection so in Forbidden Desert in flasho fire rescue in Raptor the players have a number of action points in Raptor that's generated by some card play in flasho is kind of set in stone and those action points can be used either to move or to carry out various other actions like attacking or putting out fires things like this we have a couple of games down here where we literally flick the pieces across the playing space so flick them up on catacombs steampunk rally is an interesting one because here we actually build an engine you know we we put resources into this engine and we put together cards that that generate movement points and allow us to move around the track in a race so that's an interesting combination of Euro game mechanisms and movement uh and then we

get onto games like tonoko and Ricochet robots where you can basically move as far as you like but in a straight line and when you hit a barrier you have to stop maresh is true roll and move old style roll and move very simple children's game and so perhaps it feels a little bit more appropriate in that one now role for combat I know I'm going to have a harder time convincing you of this that it's not worth using um because it's used so frequently in so many games and also I'm well aware that my collection leans well away from the sort of games that use combat at all let alone roll for combat so I may not be the best person to speak on this that said I think rooll for combat is so generic now that it's very hard to make your system of rolling to fight interesting and different and and and make your game unique and and if even if you have all sorts of other unique stuff going on in your game that role for combat just overwhelms it and and and undermines everything else that you're doing there so find other interesting ways of of of doing combat whether it's to do with card play or um you know there are other randomizers or maybe it doesn't need to be random at all and finally the dreaded event deck so uh what what exactly is this all about well I think players are introducing designers are introducing event decks because they want their game to have a narrative Drive they want

story elements in their game they become so immersed in the world of their game they think this this this world would have earthquakes and volcano and tornadoes or dinosaur attacks or whatever and so therefore the only way they can Factor those into the game is to have a card draw which says dinosaur attacks lose a turn or dinosaur attacks move back three spaces and and it can be devastating to your design it can completely make everything else meaningless because it it can throw you back so many Paces everything you've been building up wiped out or you lose the game just on a card draw so how do games introduce those narrative elements without the randomness of this card draw well if we look at games that have events in them so games like Evolution climate or twah or dominant species what tends to happen is that a series of events are laid out at the start of a round or several turns ahead and then players have a chance to react to this maybe to deal with the event by putting some resources into it to make that event go away or maybe by taking control of that event to ensure that it doesn't happen to them but they can drive that event towards another player now that is not uh total chaos that is not total luck because the other players have seen that event is there too and if they wanted to they could take it and drive it in that direction this is how it works in a massive strategic Euro game like dominant species without making the whole thing chance based the worst type of event decks are

the ones where you have random events sort of interspersed with useful cards so when I draw a card from a certain deck I think oh this could be really something useful a useful resource for me or a card I could play to advance myself in the game but then when I draw it actually no it's just set me back several turns or in fact it may have destroyed my total game experience let's have a look at the event decks in agrica agrica has two decks which uh two decks of cards which you can add into the game as little expansions which are event decks that's exactly what they are in fact I've got them on the table over here so I'll show you um so these are sort of almost promo items really there's the legendary Forest deck and the X deck and what this means is when you go and gather wood in Agricola which is agric is very strategic game you gather wood to build fences to house animals you cook the animals to make food to provide for your family a lot of the game is is about building up to Gathering new family members having this family Growth Action you'll spend the first half of the game trying to make your house big enough make sure you've got enough food to have that extra family member now in the legendary Forest deck every time you go and gather wood you draw a card off the top of the deck or in the X deck every time you go to the to gather Stone in the Quarry you might encounter aliens so you turn over a card off the deck so let's have a look at the top deck of the X deck Earth Girls Are Easy immediately carry out the family growth

even without room in your home action so I've already said the first half of the game for most games of agrica is spent trying trying to get yourself ready to have a new family member and make it possible with the single draw of a card from the event deck this is giving one player that um ability that player now is is most likely going to win certainly they're at a huge advantage through no skill whatsoever so these are classic examples of event decks fortunately in agrica they're kind of treated like a joke nobody really plays with them they're quite humorous and so you can sort of flick through them and enjoy thinking about what that game might be like without actually having to suffer an actual game of AG gria with an event deck a board game design is only as good as the decisions that a player makes on their turn how many decisions are there in your uh in your prototype how many decisions can a player make on their own term what dilemmas do they have do they have choices are those choices interesting are they equally as exciting whichever way they go are they overwhelming choices or are they at the right sort of level does it matter whether they go that way or that way or will the result turn out the same anyway this is what we're looking for Meaningful interesting decisions unless you're making a game like um Villa petti or Bandu or junk up where you're stacking pieces or something where

you're flicking or a Speed game in which case decisions don't really come into it in a strategy game we want choices and those choices have to mean something and they have to be fun and and sort of delicious little puzzles for us to solve anyway thank you very much for watching this first in my little design series hope well hopefully it'll become a series uh I'm Adam Porter if you want to watch the other view videos on my channel then please do it's Adams board game Wales and if you want to follow me on Twitter I'm boardgame Wales thank you very much for watching all the best

Progress saved