Top 5 Train Games w/ Amabel Holland
Transcript
hey gamers this is liz davidson beyond solitaire and i'm here with emma bell holland she is the lead designer boss designer of holland spiel yeah which is a fantastic small quirky games press is that how you describe it yeah that works we like to say that we publish uh weird games and war games so that about covers that yes all of which i'm very much here for but uh what we're actually here for today is uh to talk about train games about which i know nothing uh and about which you know at least something because you've designed some ideas yeah so tell us about your train game designs uh so i've designed seven train games five were published through a company called the winsome games and some of those were licensed to other publishers like rio grande which did north and pacific and trans-siberian railroad and capstone which did irish gauge and iberian gauge and uh those probably i mean probably the two gauges are my most popular best-selling games uh through holland spiel we've also published uh the zoo line which is really weird i wouldn't recommend it as anyone's first train game or even their set maybe the third third train game maybe uh and then dual gauge which is hang on that yeah i have to engage dual gauge which um is like a train game
system with multiple maps uh and the reason why that exists is that uh mary told me i need to do a train game every year for holland spiel i thought well if i do a system i can just do new maps every year and then i don't need to do a new game every year and she said no now you have to do a new game every year and new maps every year so i you know i made more work for myself genius i love it and so the other thing i want to ask is what okay first of all this is this is beyond solitaire but most of these all of these games some of mine are so lowable but yours are not and we're just going to make that really clear of friends yeah yeah no because most of what i would i don't i don't get too upset about you know what is a train game it's kind of like what is a war game what isn't the word you know i stopped being nerds um but most of what i look for in a train game uh is about uh emergent alliances um and you really need three plus people to do that because you need people to play off of each other the more players the better i feel i i always feel like a lot of there are a lot of games people want points one play at three or four i'm playing at five or six because the more people you get in there the more entangled it gets and that's what's really exciting for me about train games that and just you know making choo-choo noises and building across the map fair enough so yes i am i'm glad also
however that you said you're not once quibble about the definition of training games because i do not play what i would consider to be trained games i literally could only come up with five games that i have played that have trains in them that seem like you could label it as a trade game so my list is going to be absurd your list is going to be brilliant you know what i almost put on the list what i almost put on the list was power grid because you're you're building this network there are auctions which you get a lot of options in during games you don't really have the emergent alliances that i look for but i didn't get on the list but i mean there aren't trains but i would still call that a train game because really for train games the theme doesn't really matter now for me most games i'm really looking for games that engage meaningfully with the history and with the theme train games i don't care about that i probably should you know because certainly the history of making these railroads especially in america that is some dark stuff i almost said it's weird and um with a huge cost in human cost environmental cost and it's not really grappled with effort in these games and i have a hard time with like things about colonialism that don't grapple with that stuff i don't have that problem with train games maybe that's a blind spot for me i don't know but um the theme doesn't really matter for train games because it's really just about this network building and then this
investment stock alliance stuff nice i thought that's actually super interesting this is already more interesting conversation i knew how to have about trains which is why i invited you on here i got what would it even look like to make a deeply historically ensconced train game and would that truly just rain on the parade so i would be interested to see that actually i i know there's someone who's working on a game about um i want to say about the pullman strike uh which at least gets a little closer to that but i don't know if you know i don't remember who's doing that or how far along they are but yeah it's uh i don't know interesting well uh so okay normally i would have used the gas to go first but you're gonna have legitimate suggestions and i am not so i think i'll go first and start my list at number five okay so this is a this is the only game list that i don't actually love that much it's just i was trying to think of train games is okay it's a roll and write called railroad inc so basically in railroad inc everybody has their own little grid you roll dice and you basically just connect the dive faces into little train routes on your grid and you know there are little expansions that offer different stuff so there's a red version of the game in a blue you can end up with craters that you have to work around you know it's definitely a nice puzzly little game but i don't think it really
captures that kind of networking spirit of trains it's just the fifth game i could think of that had trains in it oh have you ever played this one i had played a role in writing about trains so that's probably it but unless there's more than one but i don't remember it that well so um yeah that's i think that's kind of the problem but um now i i i will say with so are are we alternating is that how it works okay yes uh i will say that my list isn't ranked i just have okay so this isn't like my fifth favorite or anything i'm actually i'm trying i tried to pick games that were different kinds of train games to help people who are new learn about it and the very first one i have is the game i will pull out if i'm playing with people who haven't played the train game before or people who don't really play a lot of modern games because it's very simple like my grandmother uh who passed away uh last year she loved this game and that that was it was hard to find games that she liked and that is uh trans-europa it's also a trans uh american i think a trans japan you already know what's cool because we're trans in the title it already makes it better right um but this is a game where uh you have a hand of cards at the beginning with different cities on the map and you're trying to connect these cities on the map but um you are building shared tracks so
everyone you don't know what everyone else has for the cities and you are putting track down as one big network of tracks so you might be building towards your city you're also building towards my city but i don't want you to know that and then i'm gonna branch off and uh it's very quick uh it's not a money-related game the way a lot of training games are uh you get the whole networking thing and um you still have uh in a way kind of emergent alliances but with this bluffing aspect and uh i like it bunches it's good i'd recommend it oh that sounds awesome yeah and i also i love that you actually look for different types of training games because i don't know much about train games i invited you on so that i could selfishly steal your knowledge so i will take this i'll take the suggestion hand um it actually sounds like a i don't know uh maybe a more gamers gamer version of what i'm bringing up which is ticket to ride you know what i know that uh i i feel like ticket to ride as well as ones that some people kind of feel stale but you know what it's god's staying power i would consider it still a classic game uh the app is actually really good too so i can even play it by myself occasionally if i want to but you know ticket to ride has a special place in my heart because when i was first getting back into board gaming in grad school uh i played magic the gathering i played katan and then the next game on top of that was ticket to ride and at the time that was the most exciting thing you know and
i i love that it's a game again right of trying to build roots you don't necessarily want people to know where you're trying to go so there's like a little bit of bluffing there's a little bit of risk because the more roots you take on you know if you don't manage to complete them you have a bit of a point deficit problem and you know it's it's a game that i think continues to work and continues to be fun and also i don't know i think what you were talking about with training themes kind of being feeling less fraught i think something like ticket to ride like who at a family gathering well i'm sure people have thrown hands over tickets to ride actually now i think about it but it started out innocent yeah it was all innocent until they completed my route but uh yeah i mean this goes to show you the lack of depth in my training of knowledge but you know what i also still think ticket to ride is a good game yeah it is i you know i played it for the first time 2019 i just just when there were game days that i could go to and uh you know i thought hey this is this is really good um and you know i will call it a train game because it will piss people off that's the so i i will call it a trade game so to piss off how to trade gamers uh next one on my list is chicago express now that's a nice cover yes now i have two versions of this i have this version and then i have the original printing wabash cannonball
now which one of these do you think costs more money you didn't wait this has to be a trick question which one do you think costs more money i'm gonna one of the clamshells i'm gonna say you had to pay more for the clamshell okay so actually i got this for free as a gift but but but um last time i checked secondary prices for this we're in triple digits and that's a very fancy claim show it's very yeah so there's a company called winsome games and they're the ones to publish my first five train games and they have a lot games are published it like this uh with components that are maybe less lavish than this and then they like get them licensed to these games and um it's uh they really pioneered a lot of training and kept train games alive as a genre uh for much of the last like 15 plus 20 years um and uh the big one for me is chicago express because this is the game that invented everything i rip off in my games so um it's uh you're building track with represented by cubes onto a hex grid um you're trying to make connections there are auctions for stock shares it's very focused on timing on correctly
predicting the when the game is going to end and manipulating the levers that lead there um and it is terrific and um you can get this i think you get this now like 20 bucks so you know grab it three digits for the claim show yeah you know which which they're they're they're only so they only publish like a couple hundred copies of each each of these games so they're very hard to come by um i would definitely recommend getting the the boxed edition instead so um before we move on to the list because my list is ridiculous but you're actually i'm like learning a lot from you you mentioned a lot of things about stocks like people not wanting to consider certain things trained games that looked like it had a hex map on it um so when people say train games i just think of games and trains in them because that's the extent of my actual knowledge which is why you're here but uh what is the difference between a train game and 18xx because when i hear stocks that's what i associate like i've never played an 18x game but i do associate them with people who like trains and people who like stock games so are those two separate categories are they together like how does this so i mean 18xx i would consider to be a subset of train games um just like um there are other subsets i can think of one anyway um and uh
you know there might be one of those on my list well we'll see but um plus something like chicago express or sometimes it's called a cube rails game which is like a different subset of train games so it's really just crane games is a broad category and then you get more specific like 18xx um and stuff like that and 18xx particularly i mean it's really a system or series of games um and that's become like its own kind of genre just like um you know like war games there are hex encounter war games or card driven games etc you know i got you i got you okay that makes a lot of sense all right so i have you know again i have zero experience in this area so uh you know for me i just think it's like ooh a train it must be a train game i i feel like you can have this conversation about war games too though like is there a war in it does that make it a war game oh yeah it's a complicated question uh yeah messy yeah oh yeah because so i mean definitions are useful when they highlight affinities and they cease to be useful when they're used to exclude yeah i think that that makes sense if you want a different definition look for a different affinity as opposed to an x because everything you know i had a friend um moving that because i was a movie nut
and he tried to categorize all his dvds might be vhs's a while ago um depending on the the genre the absolute genre is this a science fiction film is this a uh horror film is this a comedy is this a drama and like he could not stand when things were a little bit of both but everything's a little bit of everything everything is its own unique category yeah and again you're just what you're not trying to fit in a box you're trying to highlight what it shares with other things yeah yeah that makes sense so on that note my third one on the list is literally just called trains and it's a deck builder i love deck building games oh i actually i actually am so sad that trains does it solo because whenever i can get a chance to play with other people i love it it's about like building bullet trains in japan and you just build up your deck and you try to lay track and you try to build stations in big cities and uh the complication is that you end up with trash that you have to figure out how to dump and so you know it's actually a really nice deck builder that also plays out on a little map with trains and i thought it was delightful i mean i guess if you don't like the theme you might not enjoy it but every time i played trains i've had a really really good time and uh you know probably is because i like deck builders in general
but if anything was going to make me interested in how trainers work it would be deck building so i uh i i definitely like the game and we'll play it whenever offered an opportunity cool yeah yeah have you played it i mean i feel like i probably just my list is probably just very strange compared to like coin keyword no it's not it's not it's not strange i have not played that one though um i i used to play a lot of deck builders because when i first got into like the hobby and the euro part of the hobby deck builders were the thing i think the first modern game i played was some deck builder about i don't know vampires it was really hot for like a week um but uh you know but i mean i i play so many games of dominion uh eminent domain as well um so i i like deck builders just as i've moved more into like war games there aren't that many war game deck builders uh there are some but there aren't that many so i haven't played a tech builder in a long time but it it's fun to build decks i like i like thinning my deck so i have like a five card deck i just keep spamming that this is this great that's wonderful yeah the only you know the only war deck builders are gonna give okay i guess i'll count undaunted okay so that would be you know you're you have a deck building situation you're um using the cards that detective move
units on the map there's five four cards that clog it up i would call that a war game too definitely dictator and then uh time of crisis oh yeah i have time of crisis yeah i played it i like it it's good yeah this is the only war deck builders i can think of um except for um i know that there is liberation haiti that's in design from damon stone from the zenobia award so that's where you're building up for the haitian revolution and the first half of the game as a deck builder uh so i actually really really like to try that because that might be really really exciting yeah oh and it's my turn right okay i was like oh yeah um so the next game i have um it's a game in a series that has uh very strong uh devotees uh it's very it's long they're too long these games they take too long to play they're too fiddly um and like the second half really bonks down so of course the system i'm talking about is crayon rails and this is the only crayon rails game i own which is india rails uh which uh i enjoy so uh these are games where you are moving goods and the goods are represented by these little fiddly tiddlywinks and you are slowly moving them across the map with you with your train and you are drawing with crayons onto the map uh your your connections
and um i mean we play it says it takes three hours last time we played we're about four hours in and we weren't halfway through yet so they take a long time to play that might be also because i i don't live in india so i don't actually know where all these cities are so a lot of is looking at like okay you need to take specific goods generated by specific areas to specific other areas and if you don't know where they are it might you'll learn you'll learn the geography eventually but um you know maybe if you're interested in this find one that's set where you live and you might have an easier time of it but um but i will say for again you know it took too long but sometimes you want that sometimes you have like a a rainy sunday where you got nothing to do and you just can set it up and while you're you play some turns while you're also taking some time to make dinner or whatever and it's it's a good game for that i think um yeah so that's that's crayon rails there's another kind of train game that i don't think there's much now the the roland right you mentioned i mean you're drawing the the map in that way but you don't really see that much anymore with the crayons i wish that would come back because it's a neat component it's a neat feeling yeah maybe this this year is a hollandsfield train game oh oh lord no
uh because emma bell is a purple crayon i'm kidding i do like purple crayons oh there you just reminded me of something uh it was completely irrelevant but um so crockett johnson who did hair on the purple crayon and also the carrot seed which is a wonderful book no one talks about the carrot seed it's great um he also did a comic strip called barnaby i think um and there's a book of it i'm supposed to buy it for myself and i forgot so you've reminded me to divide that thank you i knew i'd be good for something on this video damn it oh you're great all right so um my number two is actually a game i genuinely really love it is so low-able and it's hard to get the united states because it's only printed in germany and i had to print the rules in english off of board game geek but it's by our mutual friend david thompson and it's switch and signal i love switch's signal it is a cooperative game where you basically have these trains of different speeds and you were trying to manipulate them to deliver goods and then make it back to like the main station and it's really challenging because you have very limited like switches and signals that you can use to open up and adjust routes so the trains take the right pathways to where they're supposed to go so if you are not timing things correctly or if you roll a die and a
train like moves more than you expected to or like you just don't have good logistics then it is a mess and so trying to figure out together how you are going to make these trains work in concert enough to get everything done is actually super challenging and really really fun and there's like a europe map and then you turn over and there's like an america map and that one's really difficult and so basically it's honestly i i know the ticket to ride is a traditional like introduce people to games game but if i had people over who'd never played games and it was like my grandpa who loves trains by the way he's got an entire lionel train engine like train room in his house i would love to play switch and signal with my grandfather and actually david thompson designed switch and signal to play with his parents who also like trains uh so i would actually like to see switches to go get in american printing because it's delightful it's a really nice cooperative challenging like frustrating the right kind of ways game that isn't that hard to teach it's not that hard to learn and it's just really fun like it's so wholesome i'm a fan it it sounds really lovely and clever that that really sounds exciting oh i try it i want to try that one now yeah somebody publish that sorry i can give it a shot yeah like we've had last week reached the part of my list where i genuinely loved the games it only took all this but i clearly just need to play more train games right like as game nights
start up like people gotta play some train games with me so i can learn them okay that's so the next one i have is it's probably the the most obvious one uh this is 1830 this is the well second but really the first 18x game of people no 18xx um the these are games that are not nearly as complicated as people think they are like the rules are really very simple they're just they just take a long time to play because they're games that were designed to take a long time to play when you wanted to spend most of the day playing the game um this is probably my favorite 18xx um 1889 is really good i i like it probably a little bit more but i don't own it so i'm i'm using this one and this is also uh i think has more more variety than 1889 does but um if you want to try an 18x game you know try them they're fun for the first two or three hours and then like the last hours like but you're there with people that you whose company you enjoy you know i have friends who all they want to play is 18xx and so i played a lot of team xx with them and um you know it's not like i was like really excited about playing 18xx i thought about playing it with them and there's a really great community of people who just love these games and love to teach people to play these games and help them out and and they're also
people who are jerks stay away from them but um you know uh yeah so if that's another kind of game and i think most of the reputation of train games is being nerdy as being all about math is as being you know really heavy and complicated comes from 18xx which again the rules overload isn't really that complicated it's more of the impact of your decisions and the butterfly effects that uh you know make it feel heavier right like it's not that hard to learn how to play but it's hard to learn how to play yeah like actually make smart choices you know what's interesting is i did not ever imagine there would be a solo 18xx game but there is one edward from heavy cardboard said that it's great i think it's 1862 is that the one i don't know how i remember its numbers but i think it's 1862. um but apparently it has a separate solo mode within the game box that's like not quite like it's like the designer went off on his own to make a different kind of game with the components it's not you know oh you're bidding with a ai player or something from what i understand but apparently it has a very interesting compelling solo mode inside the box and i'm now very curious to try it because it was edward's like number one on a top 10 solo list that we did recently and i talked to ricky royal the other day and he was liking it too huh so apparently solo play is entering
the world of 18xx maybe i need to like board this train myself so yeah um and and not to derail this video but um i'll be really interested in talking to you sometime about your thoughts on how people approach solo modes of you know multiplayer games because i'm i'm a curmudgeon about it you know generally and um i think you could probably have a less curmudgeoning perspective and i really enjoyed having that conversation with that yes we should we should definitely do that at some point because i think the whole range of syllabus are available um you know i i if it's good i'll play it period so i'm open although i will say i do have a soft spot for games that are designed just for me as a solo player those are really the only ones i like you know um whereas like stuff with bots or i don't i don't i don't like bonding like flow charts see i enjoy bots and flow charts i actually like them partially as like they teach me game strategy i'm a better player for them um but i also am amazed by i think i like them because maybe in another life i would have studied ai or something if that makes sense i really enjoy automated opponents and seeing what they're capable of how much they have to cheat in order to get around you whether your human smarts are able to overcome them uh if it's a good bot i'm definitely interested i also think a lot of people play silver though the bot is just there
to give them a run for their money so they have to play hard themselves and it's less about that interactivity with another player i think more about um wanting to be able to push the game to its limits yourself and then have something to kind of hold you back a little bit so yeah that would be interesting like fuller chat but say my number one it's again not i mean it's not a train game in the traditional sense but it's about trains it's a great game it's snowdonia okay it's a lovely work replacement game uh where you have laborers that you assign um they do various actions so you're trying to like lay track and you know score points and then the first person to kind of to lay the last track on the way to the top of a mountain with a name in welsh that i'm not even going to pronounce because i will embarrass everyone will trigger the end game and i like it because it has lots of strategic decisions without being that complex of a game it does solo and i enjoy like a little bit of weird randomness in my games and so you have to deal with the weather on this one because it's about welsh train building and so that means that you're going to have welsh weather that will come and mess up your your adventure and so you know there's a deluxe box now there's lots of little modules and different you know scenarios that you can play and i just think it's such a nice solo experience it was one of those ones that was really hard to get for a while and then there was like a big deluxe kickstarter reprint and i
was on that like ready to go and i've had a good experience playing my game each time and my game group seems to like it too whenever it comes out so yep snowdonia for me i mean i think it's a train game because it's got trains in it but you know yeah no it it can't i it counts i like it um so the last thing on my list not last but not least um and so a couple disclaimers this is a game designed by a friend of mine and the game i have a financial stake in though right now is out of print so i'm not like here to to say buy this game okay but it is no western rails my friend travis d hill and uh i like this game a lot it's one of my favorite new train games uh and it feels very much like a train game that would have been designed like in 2010 and it's not me you know digging it at all it's because it has this kind of nostalgic feel to it it's looking at these kind of older train game mechanic with this point-to-point kind of map um and you know kicking the tires and and and sprucing it up and you know travis designed a number of train games and the reason why i published this one because it's my favorite of the ones he's done so um
yeah western rails is fun game um i like it a lot and that's why i put it on my list fantastic yeah i know you don't publish these you don't like so i think that's a fair mention yeah no i i absolutely i don't but hey you can put it in a claim shell and then put it on ebay for three figures you know it might work no that's awesome and travis is a really cool guy actually it leads me to ask maybe one more question before we kind of wrap up which is so you love historical games you also love train games i've noticed that edward from heavy cardboard likes his 18xx and he also likes his really heavy historicals and i feel like travis is also somebody who has a big interest in history and i know that he loves meltwater he likes he enjoys war games and he enjoys train games is there a connection is there some sort of crossover between these communities where as i continue my like war and historical game journey like trains will just become a thing because we'll all just evolve you know there is some overlap um i think because they're they're often a little bit to the side of of mainstream they have this kind of little niche um and um yeah i think that's probably just it uh i mean travis uh you know it in the pre-pandemic times uh he he and his his buddy marcus had a
little um like private small convention that was specifically themed around train games and war games you know and that's what we i got to go to the two of them and that's what we did we played training games and war games um there is one there is one train game that is also a war game public published by winston games it has not been reprinted so you're not gonna be able to find it i don't think this comes in the clam shell um it is called panzer zug and this is a game in which you are bomber pilots bombing german railways during world war ii and trying to damage the german war effort and is completely random it's not really a good game but if you play it with people who are drinking i don't i've never touched alcohol in my life you think it makes me easier for me to win but it doesn't but you're playing with people who are drinking you know and it's too long for what it is but it was shorter it wouldn't be fun it's just it's it's and it's a silly uh very dice rolly kind of experience but there are trains and it's published by winston i would call that a train game yes let's go for it i was kind of hoping that you meant it was going to be about like war trains could you see something like colliding along the river that could work too because why not we can do whatever we want um so uh emma i want to thank you so much for coming on here also um i
know you've just had your annual college feel sale but is there any announcements you want to make about your uh your publishing house before i let you go um i mean we have more games coming up next year we do every year um first game next year will probably be eyelet which is a game play with shoelaces i'm i'm pretty excited about that one it's it's i really i'm really excited about that and yeah that's that's what i have to say yeah there's a game coming out next year there'll be a new train game next year it should be a dinosaur cage what really yes really yes it's a real game cool mary's my co-designer and um it is about um building ray rays during the uh you know dinosaur era in uh north america you have the the western interior seaway and it starts on the map and then you place tiles and it shrinks and then you're building through territory as it shrinks and you're transitioning from shipping companies around by dinosaurs to transformed by dinosaurs it also might be air travel ran by dinosaurs and um it's a pick up a devourer game um with a stomp market and what else oh and because the dinosaurs are more
advanced than we are they have ubi so um yeah no it's just it's i'm i'm excited about that one that that is the that's a train game for next year and it's going to be fun and they're going to be dinosaurs so i mean now that you told me about this i'm excited too that sounds amazing that just sounds like a really good time as was this so if y'all want to go check out annabelle's blog she writes design notes very often uh if you want to go check out hollandsville it'll be in show notes and well thank you so much for coming on this is awesome thank you this is great always good to see you and it's always good to see everybody out there leave us a like comment tell us what your favorite training games are but most of all happy gaming
you