The Problem With Crowdfunding Board Games
Transcript
Hello and welcome to Board Stupid. My name's Way. I'm Matt.
And I'm being barged from all sides, from above, from below, from side to side by the amount of crowdfunding games in front of my eyes, from everywhere. And I'm wondering, Matt, if it's too much. Well, let's find out. But before that, hit the subscribe button. D it. All right, let's go.
Matt, with some 5,000 or so releases of different board games every single year, many of them are through crowdfunding platforms like Game Found and Kickstarter. And recently, I think you watched a show which inspired this conversation.
Yeah. Um, I was having like a nice day and uh there was the Game Found Summer Fest, I believe it's called. that is kind of like where where game fans present all their upcoming title to the platform. So it's an upcoming to the upcoming
upcoming to be upcoming. Okay. Okay.
Um um anyway and there was a plenty of like titles. Um some that sparked my interest more than than others. Uh there are a few cool things. I'm just say yes probably I'm going to put some money on top of that. But then I would just say wait a second. how many games have I backed already this year? And I just like went to to my spreadsheet because I do I do have a spreadsheet with all the all the stuff that I packed, but I just realized that I'm backing less and less and less and less. So, there's something there that it doesn't and there are there are so many games that I'm kind of like
probably more more than ever.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. There are games that I'm interested into, but do I want to still really put all this money now for something that might come like in two, three years time? I don't know. I'm just I'm feeling less of the hype. Definitely less of the FOMO because come on, all these games I'm I'm coming to to um to retail. They're all coming.
They're all going to come eventually. Yeah.
And while before it was just like, oh, might never come to retail. or I really want that gem that I saw it. I think it's going to be a great game or it just I I think I I think I lost it a little bit.
Is it like Okay, so let's talk about that's one thing which is crowdfunding fatigue. And I think this is obvious this is something to talk about crowdfunding fatigue. There is so much in the way of things that are being put on crowd funding platforms that as you say will be coming to retail anyway and are kind of burying down everything that you know would actually only be crowdfunding only like for something that we've already talked about a few times which is Neon hope which is not coming to retail that is a crowdfunding only.
Yes. Yeah. Exactly. So those are things like like oh yeah I want to put my money on it. But um a game that kind of like the first things like the the first game that they show one of the first games that they show was the um remastered version of Arkham Horror not a card game. They already did a remaster
of the of the cooperative. So the original Arkham Horror um now
so why does he need to come to to to to crowdfounding just like I just say I don't
wasn't that cuz isn't that a fantasy flight property which is owned by Asthma day?
Yes. It's kind of like I'm I'm just like I seriously so they that will become uh basically a pre-order. Yeah. Of course, you're going to get you're going to get it first. Not always because that we know it that is not that
a lot of time I received games that I could have actually picked up a UKG or spiel before they they've been delivered to me. But fair enough. Um you're going to get a couple of wounds kind of like a couple of cards or that mini expansion that between you and me
we're never going to play it. uh or the first play a mark made in uh platinum. I don't know stuff like that. Then again, it just like
who cares? Well, there are people that that cares, but it just became like a um like a big a big pre-order shop for something that is going to come out in uh 18 months time. And I just like I don't know. I just feel I'm not excited anymore when a new game when a crowdfunding games arrives. I remember before like a couple of years ago, I would be like jumping and uh putting straight straight away on the on the table and it just doesn't when now arrives it's probably going to go on the stack with the all the other that arrive in the queue.
Um and yes, we are lucky enough to to play a lot of games and we cover a lot of games. We're trying to to play a lot of games. Sometimes we get those games as a review copies, but trust me, we spend a lot of games here, a lot of money on board games.
Uh, but just I just say I'm I'm feeling that's
it's a Yeah, another great example is um is Brass Pittsburgh. It's one I have backed. I've got a list of games I backed in the last year and a half and uh that is one which we did a whole episode about it which you can go and see there about the issue with that campaign because that 100% could have been a retail release mate. And could you imagine the absolute carnage it would have caused if they did like a Stonem approach and just Essen one day went by the way Brass Pittsburgh's been released. Everyone be like boom would have exploded. I would have sold out immed
people but
Exactly. Exactly. made like a billion dollars. But here's the thing. That game did not need to be a crowdfunding game pushing down all of the other games that probably do need to be crowdfunding games. Of course, it's just a bloody pre-order.
Yeah, because then you're going to pre-order and on and once you're pre-ordering it or backing it, uh, and you spending those £200 at the end of the day, that's what you're going to spend because
oh, are you really backing just the the basic version of the game? And this is not just about uh Pittsburgh is is all the others. Of course, you're going to do the deluxe version that might have that token different from the other. Fair enough. That is those are sometimes like better quality
components. Well, that game specifically is an egregious example of that.
You're going to spend way more money. And then other games that might come up on the radar if you're lucky. Like they're just going to be overseen because you just say you already spend a lot of money. And
yeah, and what's even worse than that, let's let's just keep covering this specific thing about things going where they could have gone straight to retail. It's basically what looks like straight reprints or very simple reimplementations of games. These are also going onto the platform. And again, these could just be retail releases of games, right? Like you got was it Lorenzo or Magnico?
Yeah. Trust me now. Yeah.
Voyages of Marco Polo going out as well. Got lots of these other games.
I think it's new. Exactly. Yeah. 100%.
As he was Hanami, the new version of Samurai. The games aren't good. Like we're not saying that the game the games are great
and they went to retail.
So why is they well why are they being smashed onto this platform which is basically a pre-order pushing down I think uh all of those games that wouldn't necessarily get a retail release and need that uh need that money and need that funding and kind of almost bullying them out just through the amount of marketing money that goes into them. Right.
It's kind of annoying and upsetting at the same time.
It is. But I think for that I think we need to rewind and go back to the start. Let's go back in time.
So Kickstarter was launched as a platform all the way back in the yester year of 2009.
What were you doing in 2009?
Days being young like
being younger. Like
you don't want to know.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yes. No, you don't want to know. I had two working knees. It was brilliant. Uh and um yeah and from that was birth the idea of being able to bring your ideas to life.
Exactly. So that's when stuff like Zombie Side came out. that is 2015. That for many board game historian is the is the one that actually put the um the sign on the on the wall in terms of like of ball game because it was the first one that did so much money at the time. It was a project that
it would have not gone out on retail because it's not something that people at the time would have bought it. As soon as this went on Kickstarter, uh there was like just we're throwing out all these minis and uh the addon more minis. If you back in now, more minis and if you backing more,
and here's the thing, right? You can understand because the amount of money it takes to create those molds.
You need you need like a pre-injjection of money in order to to get those things built, right?
And that and that makes sense. It was a it was a at the time uh a a very small Simon. Yes. Uh kind of like had to invest a lot of of resources to do this kind of game and um and they've been successful and they open the the road to many other and the journey
back going back in time when Seimon was a very successful company profit making with a great headquarters had loads of money and was very liquid. Not like Seon today we're talking about on the past semon and then two years later basically after Zombie Side was Gloom Haven. Now Gloom Haven was an example of people saying there is no way people will buy this board game. It's too big. It's too crazy. It's too ambitious.
It's a 200 hours campaign.
It's going to cost people £150. There is no way people will buy this game. And that is basically what every publisher said to the folks at Sephare Games that it will never be made. Yeah.
And so guess what happened? became one of the biggest uh projects in history on Kickstarter and you know made millions of dollars
and one of the most beloved game and one of the best game
and franchises of games
if if it's not just in the genre it's just like one of the best game ever made that is widely renowned widely adored that genre and sorry that um IP
and now there continued frost haven and blah blah blah and with draws of the line etc etc So it opened the the door for people to come to crowdfunding with their insane ideas because they had if it if the vision was right
and it made sense, people would spend the money.
Yeah, exactly. And that things is uh is still there a little bit
uh cuz we see from from uh I don't know um games like um Fetching Feathers or like the the small um all of these like indie publisher that trying to like Neon hope and you can name a million of them
but they are getting like slower and slower smaller smaller and smaller because then if you if you go in a in a shop and all the windows and stuff is full of this stuff that of course is more flesh is more they can invest much more money. You're not going to notice that that little things that might be that might be your next favorite game. It could be like revolutionizing the the the industry for the new mechanics or or whatever it is. it just like it's I kind of feel like it's it's not there anymore. It's just like it's almost impossible for those people to to manage to do it unless they invest and we saw we spoke with a lot of them. They invest a lot of money in the market in trying to compete with with something like Bruss coming out or the new whatever.
Yeah. Or a re-implementation of an older project. But let's now flash back forward again and let's explore some of the reasons why this is happening. Let's go.
Well, you want to know all the reason why? Well, easy enough. It's money.
It's money, isn't it? And the obviously the publisher at the other end of the project doesn't want to spend their money. They want to you they want to spend your money. So what they are doing by putting them on this platform, putting games on this platform, which could quite happily be retail projects is they are divesting risk to the end consumer. By you as the consumer at home clicking on crowdfunding projects for a large game that will eventually go to retail anyway, you are absorbing the risk of that product. So there is much less risk for the publisher at the other end, right? They don't have to commit in advance any of their resources. They essentially get all of your resources and they kind of sit back, wait for the money to come in, and then they'll go buy the game. What's wrong with that, you might add? Well, let me tell you about games that fail on crowdfunding. Matt, I think you have some experience.
Yeah, indeed.
Through my cash out of the window a couple of times.
And me, too. And this is from like not just small names that big names
from some of them were big names at the time and then poof disappeared into thin air. So this is the issue with taking on risk unnecessarily which is basically weighted things away from the consumer. It is essentially anti-consumer practice which something I deeply annoy. I deeply adore. I do not like it at all.
Yeah. No I I know where you come from. Yeah. That is quite um it's quite a bad thing. Um but yeah this this been risk averse going back to that point like this company reimp this is why we seen so many reimplementation reimplementation a reimplementation a reimplementation a 10 year edition five years edition deluxe edition
one year edition sometimes basically
second edition third
it's just like you know that they're going to sell and uh that that's it but if I yeah you just I quite quite annoyed to say some of these games have been great. I'm not talking about like Hanami. It's been it's been great.
Great game,
but I just like
it is anti-consumer regardless of what you think about it. I think almost objectively and this is again it link it links to that reason the same exactly the same reason why we're seeing so many re reprints reimplementations and re reimplementations that are going on crowdfunding. It is a double risk aversion strategy. Right. We are we are taking an established game that we know people like and also we are not going to spend our money as publishers. We're going to spend your money in advance. So this is you taking risk. And here's the thing, we keep falling for it
time and time.
We we keep falling for it all the time.
Yeah.
We keep falling for it and I it it somewhat baffles me and like but at the same time Matt, we are getting to a point I think me and you personally uh where this is going to be slowing down. You've said yourself you've backed less games there. I'm backing less games and we only really back games at this point for the channel.
Yeah, exactly. And and you you saw it like probably uh in the last um 6 months, 7 months, we did a very very few uh coverage of upcoming game on uh on crowdfunding. Uh for for multiple reason uh first of all uh because most of the time these games are not complete. they are just like giving you a preview, an idea of what the game is going to be without
for us being totally able to say if this game is good or not cuz I
I don't know. It seems interesting, but the the design is unfinished. The production is completely prototype. There is no way that we could tell you with hands-on hearts that you should go and back something based on a partially complete product. Which is why me and Matt basically don't like doing prototypes. You'll see us very very very rarely do that.
There are very specific specific
because we are very interested about I don't know the designer or or the game
some history behind it or something
or we already managed to play a demo and we are really interested to see to unpack a little bit more about the games but it it just became like and we got requested at all times
every day
and and the answer is always same we don't really do it. You can send your prototype, but we know prototype are expensive. So, if you prefer to send it to someone that's going to take a nice photos and going to say, "Oh, this is really nice. Buy it." That's not really us. We don't want to do it. We can't do it.
And um yeah, just I feel unfair toward you guys and um yeah, just like that's that's very much what it what it is.
Yeah, 100%. So, you know, these games are always in a prototype phase. So even when you're doing your research and you're seeing videos on like, okay, you should go back XY Z game because this creator has said, oh, it's really, really good. They're saying it based on an unfinished product. Always. There is never a point where they can say with or very rarely is there a point where they can say hand on heart, I recommend that you go back to this game because it is going to be representative of the final thing. That is almost never the case.
But I got one one scenario that I want to point out to you. So let's say that um Brass Pittsburgh did not went on uh crowdfunding.
Went straight to retail. Yeah.
Went straight to retail. So crowdfunding they did what like 34 million something bajillion pounds. A bajillion pounds
um based on the hope that the game is going to be uh better than than uh
at least as good. Yes. Yes. Yes. Equivalent.
Slightly different in the mechanics. slightly adjustment the rules makes this smoother but overall it's basically this the the same game isn't it of course so if that game went on on re straight on to retail uh you got the game and you we play it and we say this is great is exactly as brush Birmingham
how many people would have bought the game probably not many so this leads into the industry relying on hype rather RA than
yeah and rather
and we and we are the first one falling for it. We're con look dude we make entertainment on board games right 100%. But this is kind of getting to the crux of the point of the video which is how the industry is more commonly and more regularly relying on the hype of a game more than the substance and the reality of a game
rather than the game itself.
More than the game itself. And we've had countless of examples back in games. Games come, they're perfectly fine, they go on the shelf, they get sold six months later,
and the cycle continues.
Yes. It's becoming rarer and rarer.
Yes.
Uh for for games to to arrive from one of the the game found things or Kickstarter, whatever, whatever it is, and being like, "Wow, this game is really, really good." We got a recent um white fly. Did you say white fly? Something like that. A white whale. Uh there was um um Realm of Reckoning uh that a game that I bet on the look and on the feelings that I had for the games we actually paid was an absolutely amazing game.
Oh, it's incredible. Yeah, Ro is amazing. But no one is interested in the game already because crowdfunded like two years ago whenever it was now is is you can buy it but people are not interested because they're interested in the new thing that is
and the new things that you're going to crowdfound and
two years later.
Yeah. It is a continuous cycle of hype which is yeah and FOMO of course I mean we know the industry at least the crowdfunding industry feeds off of FOMO right it is again anti-consumer it is feeding on people that you know uh preying on people that may be prone to to that kind of marketing right so and it is you
like me
yeah yeah and especially when offering things like split pay or you can you can have this £700 pledge all you need to do is pay x amount per month blah blah blah blah blah. Uh all of these things are problematic.
And you can have a a goldplated first player token token. Exactly. Um deeply problematic for me uh for all of the reasons that we've discussed.
But what do we do about it?
I really I really don't have an answer at this point. Uh because because I'm I'm part of the problem. But you part of the problem your part and and
I know yes what we always say is okay the side with your with your wallet and that's what I put myself like what I'm I'm trying to do at the moment and just like skip skip interesting I'll keep it there I'll have a look until the last day and there are very few games that now really pick my attention Um, and of course the the more you play, the more we again we're lucky enough to play so many different games that for something to really stand out is is more difficult. Yes.
Uh, but the hype is always there and it's always hard to not click that
pledge please submit let's let's go. I think that is the that is the only things is just like trying before hitting that pledge button that submit button just say sleep on it one night probably this a lot of time what they do
it's like even like games that I've backed in the last couple of months right let's take a look I've got a little list here of games I've taken a look at for example we've got Parks Europe uh which is not technically graphics it's a backer kit pre-order type thing but it's like
still it's still on that on that platform platform. Um, although this was last year, the Endeavor Deepc expansion probably could have gone to retail. Um, container went to retail. Didn't need to back that at all. In fact, I probably would have got a better deal if I just bought the retail edition. So, um, you know, that's I'm a sausage for falling. Yeah. Yeah.
Tigers Euphrates, another one. Brass Pittsburgh we talked about as well. All of these 100% could have gone to retail, mate. And I basically didn't need to spend my money and do it, but I did it anyway.
And it is.
But here's the thing, mate.
We know, don't spend your money, right? just just buy at retail most of the time. Play the games you already own because you know I'm sure that if you're watching our show, you've got a bunch of games that you can probably go and play, right? So that on your shelf that probably deserve a little bit of play time. But also, let's spin the question. We say, you know, what do you do about it?
Can you blame the publishers?
At all.
But like when what's what's
why wouldn't they? If you're the publisher, right? Why wouldn't you?
I I know. But it's going to it's going to create then like a crash of the market like it like like it happens with the banks doing all that. I'm not saying the same thing. But it's it's going to create that things where people started backing less and less and less until that is not a point anymore. But I don't know who's regulating this. Who was um like game found themselves? Do they regulate something like that? If I come with the a one year anniversary of the games that last year made me uh a million pound, why that is allowed to go again on crowdfunding. Oh yes, it's a second print. Well, just leave it on retail. You know, you you've made a million pounds. Well,
I know it's going to sell.
Yeah. Again, I don't think you can blame the publishers when there is no risk for them at all. So, or very limited risk. So, we're in this situation where we have complete market saturation. We have crowdfunding saturation. We're being bombarded left, right, and center with all of these different products, all these different projects that half of them could have been retail. It's pushing out indie smaller games that maybe need this uh specific funding or more innovative or interesting projects that we'll never get to see really. Uh and we are in this scenario right now. If we are heading for a fall, it may be soon. Uh but who knows?
You tell us. Do you know?
Do you know? Let us know in the comments below what you think of the current state of crowdfunding. And of course, it all sounds a bit doom and gloom. We've been talking about and criticizing it, but of course, as we said, there's plenty of good reasons for crowdfunding as well. Oh, yes. And hopefully continue that.
There are still some amazing games that that are coming out like the few that I bet lately like the eight dragons from from Wonder. Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely. That that is a uh one that looks super cool was So Shun from Flex. That is a classic game from uh from crowdfunding because it's just like it's big loads of plastic. Let's go for that. The awaken realm stuff you know that you you're buying into the minis you buy into the into the art of all that stuff. But stuff like should I buy back Cascade the new Cascadia Alpine?
Probably not.
Probably Coliseum Grass probably not.
Well, God knows when that one is going to come out. So, it's just what is it that we need to be doing as both hobbyists to maybe make better decisions? If it's just simple as keep your wallet in your pants, then easy as that. Is there something publishers could be doing differently? And can you blame them in such a uh volatile situation at the moment where you know where we've got volatile geopolitics and everything going on? Who knows when the prices of everything will will increase. Let us know in the comments below. But one things that you can do as well is checking the Patreon page.
Absolutely. If you do have money to spare and you manage to hold off on buy backing all of those, why not throw three quid away?
Three quid away for the price of a coffee. Helps support the channel like you have no idea. We got one extra set of lights. We're waiting on another one. Super good for us. Uh it helps us keep the lights on on the show. And in exchange, we get you a little bit of extra content. Get a monthly blog. You get a lovely uh uh video podcast uh giveaways just for patrons, all sorts of stuff.
That's the WhatsApp group. You're joining the WhatsApp group with to meet lovely people and uh otherwise simply hit the subscribe button.
Absolutely. For every single one of you that's watching and hasn't subscribed. I know. I see you cuz I do it myself. Just just subscribe. Yeah, it's nice and easy one. Exactly. We super appreciate it. Other than that, check out the rest of our videos and back us for the next one. Ch. What's the pink for you and me? What's