Skip to main content
Great Western Trail box art

Great Western Trail

Game Info
Year
2016
Players
2-4
Age
12+
Playtime
2 min
Publisher
eggertspiele
Collection
Ratings
Expansions & Family
Mechanic profile
Percentile rank vs. all games
Vibe profile
How this game feels to play
Description

America in the 19th century: You are a rancher and repeatedly herd your cattle from Texas to Kansas City, where you send them off by train. This earns you money and victory points. Needless to say, each time you arrive in Kansas City, you want to have your most valuable cattle in tow. However, the "Great Western Trail" not only requires that you keep your herd in good shape, but also that you wisely use the various buildings along the trail. Also, it might be a good idea to hire capable staff: cowboys to improve your herd, craftsmen to build your very own buildings, or engineers for the important railroad line.

If you cleverly manage your herd and navigate the opportunities and pitfalls of Great Western Trail, you surely will gain the most victory points and win the game.

—description from the publisher

Description

America in the 19th century: You are a rancher and repeatedly herd your cattle from Texas to Kansas City, where you send them off by train. This earns you money and victory points. Needless to say, each time you arrive in Kansas City, you want to have your most valuable cattle in tow. However, the "Great Western Trail" not only requires that you keep your herd in good shape, but also that you wisely use the various buildings along the trail. Also, it might be a good idea to hire capable staff: cowboys to improve your herd, craftsmen to build your very own buildings, or engineers for the important railroad line.

If you cleverly manage your herd and navigate the opportunities and pitfalls of Great Western Trail, you surely will gain the most victory points and win the game.

—description from the publisher

Ask a Rules Question
All mentions
Browse transcript mentions, sentiments, pros/cons, mechanics, topics, quotes, and references.
Total mentions: 371
This page: 50
Sentiment: pos 39 · mix 3 · neu 1 · neg 1
Mentions per page
Showing 101–150 of 371
Video 4okhLJqRsCk Nights Around a Table Analysis at 1:41 sentiment: positive
Nights Around a Table - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:41 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Visually appealing board
  • Includes a solo mode (in second edition)
  • Nicely integrated insert in second edition
  • Customizable cowboy meeples with hats in second edition
Cons
  • Artwork on the first edition box is considered poorly done.
  • Controversies surrounding themes of cultural appropriation and colonialism in its original design.
  • The original TP section representing trade with 'Indians' was problematic.
  • The first edition's artwork was described as 'horribly hauntingly bad'.
Thematic elements
  • driving cattle up the Great Western Trail
  • the American West
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deck Building — Players modify their deck of cow cards as they progress up the trail.
  • Rondel — The game features a rondel mechanic where players move their cowboy around a trail, visiting buildings.
  • Worker Placement — Implicitly, moving a 'cowboy' around the trail to visit buildings can be seen as a form of worker placement.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Possibly the worst board game I've ever made.
  • It's famous for being horribly hauntingly bad.
  • The issue with this one is that he has a section on the board this little TP section where you go and you trade with as the book says Indians.
  • It's a complete thematic reskin of Mombasa.
  • Little maple cowboys with interchangeable hats.
  • Blackout Hong Kong is algebra first semester and then Great Western Trail is the second half of the semester.
  • You bid on the tiles you want instead of randomly drawing.
  • This is an expansion that narrates a story over five chapters.
  • The cards look straight out of other game with extras.
  • It sounds like The Purge.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 4okhLJqRsCk Nights Around a Table Analysis at 16:40 sentiment: positive
Nights Around a Table - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 16:40 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive, with caveats
Pros
  • Improved components like the insert and unique meeples with hats.
  • Nice artwork on buildings.
  • Solo mode included.
  • The thematic update to 'outlaws' instead of 'Indians' is noted.
  • The game offers strategic depth and replayability.
Cons
  • Artwork on the original box is considered poor.
  • Involved in cultural appropriation controversies.
  • Can take many hours to play.
Thematic elements
  • Cattle Drive
  • American West
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — Players choose actions by moving their cowboy on the board and interacting with buildings.
  • Deck Building — Players modify their deck of cow cards as they move along the trail.
  • Rondel — The game is described as a rondelle where players move their cowboy along a trail, visiting buildings and potentially missing spaces if they move too far.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Possibly the worst board game I've ever made.
  • It's famous for being horribly hauntingly bad.
  • The issue with this one is that he has a section on the board this little TP section where you go and you trade with as the book says Indians.
  • It's a complete thematic reskin of Mombasa.
  • Little maple cowboys with interchangeable hats.
  • Blackout Hong Kong is algebra first semester and then Great Western Trail is the second half of the semester.
  • You bid on the tiles you want instead of randomly drawing.
  • This is an expansion that narrates a story over five chapters.
  • The cards look straight out of other game with extras.
  • It sounds like The Purge.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 4okhLJqRsCk Nights Around a Table Analysis at 21:51 sentiment: positive
Nights Around a Table - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 21:51 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Standalone game in a trilogy.
  • Includes a robust solo mode.
  • Expanded player boards with new sections and auxiliary actions.
  • Features a new resource to collect.
  • Includes a well-designed vacuum-formed insert with imprinted component shapes.
  • Upgraded player boards with indented sections.
  • New cow breeds are introduced.
  • The railway track is integrated differently on the board, allowing for more strategic movement.
  • Revised artwork and character designs (e.g., engineer, cow hands).
Cons
  • Box is substantially heavier than previous versions.
  • Learning the iconography and rules can be challenging.
  • The theme might not appeal to everyone.
  • The railway track's placement changes gameplay significantly.
Thematic elements
  • driving cattle
  • South America
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail
  • Great Western Trail New Zealand
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deck Building — Introduces a new type of card to manage in the deck.
  • deck management — Managing new types of cards in the deck for additional functions.
  • Modular Board — Features double-sided Port City tiles offering diverse bonuses.
  • Resource Management — Introduces a new resource to collect.
  • Rondel — Maintains the rondel mechanic from the base game.
  • Set Collection — Implied by collecting cows and managing decks/carts.
  • Worker Placement — The game adds a 'worker type' that is new to the series.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Possibly the worst board game I've ever made.
  • It's famous for being horribly hauntingly bad.
  • The issue with this one is that he has a section on the board this little TP section where you go and you trade with as the book says Indians.
  • It's a complete thematic reskin of Mombasa.
  • Little maple cowboys with interchangeable hats.
  • Blackout Hong Kong is algebra first semester and then Great Western Trail is the second half of the semester.
  • You bid on the tiles you want instead of randomly drawing.
  • This is an expansion that narrates a story over five chapters.
  • The cards look straight out of other game with extras.
  • It sounds like The Purge.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video racR6BLufIE Getting Games Discussion at 24:24 sentiment: positive
Getting Games - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 24:24 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it's not about like being the best
  • there are somewhere between 100 and 150 games nowadays it's nine days of gaming
  • the thing that's really cool about WBC is that it is very much couched in this tournament structure
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video ljFVhxc4tMU Allies or Enemies Top 10 List at 10:13 sentiment: positive
Allies or Enemies - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 10:13 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Balanced and extended rail-route dynamics
  • Adds new balance with cows and engineers
Cons
  • Second edition specifics may be subtle for some players
Thematic elements
  • Industrial
  • Strategy
  • Historical GUI of cattle and rail transport
  • Strategic with route optimization
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Route Building / Engine-Engraving — Engine grows by building routes and upgrading railroad capabilities.
  • Worker Placement — Manage workers to activate actions and advance on a rail network.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • the campaign has been kicking our butts
  • Storm adds these really interesting environmental effects
  • two-player mode as well and there's also a solo mode
  • it's fun to just get more different options of what cards come up and win
  • the artwork looks so much slicker and brighter
  • the personal goals are way better than the shared goals
  • the keepers in iron and the lord of the hundreds both work well for two players
  • we were worried that the whole crafting and building was going to overtake the main part of it and we're happy to say that it hasn't
  • two full dining room tables though or else you gotta take everything down and put everything out
  • I will retire that character
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video G-9EFFYj8y4 Meeple University Top 10 List at 0:10 sentiment: positive
Meeple University - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:10 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Hazards are now a way to gain money and an engine-building aspect.
  • The new setting in Argentina is cool.
  • The karaku cow provides a cheap and simple way to get victory points early and adds flexibility.
  • The Gran Jaro mechanism and strength add interlocking mechanics and engine building.
  • The game is shorter, making timing more critical.
  • The fourth farmer track interweaves directly with buildings, adding complexity to placement.
  • The grain mechanism provides new options and interweaves with other mechanics.
  • The railway mechanism allows for shortening the loop journey and adding action efficiency.
  • The port mechanism adds a competitive race element and precise timing.
  • The introduction of tokens for drawing and discarding cards is useful.
Cons
  • Randomness of new ships arriving can change things up unexpectedly.
  • Exhaustion cards (negative points) are gained when using cows to help farmers.
  • The shorter game makes it critical to get an extra delivery.
  • It can be expensive to get points from the port mechanism.
  • You can't substitute money for grain at the port mechanism.
  • Relying on train shortcuts means not using certain buildings.
  • The game can feel very tight.
Thematic elements
  • Cattle history
  • Argentina
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail (first edition)
  • Great Western Trail (second edition)
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Employees — Hiring employees can provide strength icons and is a new way to build strength.
  • Grain — A new currency. Grain is needed to place a disc on a ship; if grain cannot be paid, profits from the delivery must be paid. Grain replaces the railway mechanism's interaction with deliveries. Grain is obtained efficiently from farmers on employees or inefficiently through auxiliary actions. Grain is critical for the port mechanism and cannot be substituted with money there.
  • Gran Jaro mechanism — Replaces hazards and bandits. Gran Jaro fill hazard tracks, providing a benefit for building on them. A new mechanism called 'strength' is introduced. Strength can be built by clearing icons on the player board, hiring employees with strength icons, or discarding cards. Using cows to help farmers gains exhaustion cards (negative points). Strength can be spent by landing on a farmer requiring it, or at a building that allows recruiting farmers as employees.
  • hazards — Hazards have turned into Gran Jaro and fill the role of hazards from the original game. Money is paid onto spaces, waiting for someone to clear the hazard and get the money. This increases the amount of money received from hazard tracks, allowing players to time their movement to clear hazards or new recruits.
  • ports — When a delivery is made to a boat, it moves to a port. When the marker passes the correct color anchor, the boat sails away, depositing the disc on the matching port. Players can pay grain to move their disc and gain money or points. Ports are first come, first serve, adding a competitive race element. Some farmer bonuses and buildings allow discs to be placed on ports without great cattle or timing.
  • Railway — The railway is no longer related to deliveries. It now offers a way to shorten the loop journey, allowing players to jump onto a train and go to Buenos Aires early, potentially skipping farmers and buildings. This provides action efficiency rather than money efficiency.
  • Ships — Replaced the Trail of destinations. Ships have a number and players choose a ship to place a disc on, with exceptions for the cheapest or most expensive ones. Ships sail away and randomly new ships come in, which can change things up in a random way.
  • solo mode — The game now includes a solo mode.
  • Strength — A new mechanism that works with Gran Jaro. Strength can be built by clearing icons on the player board, hiring employees, or discarding cards. Strength can be spent on farmers or at buildings to recruit them as employees, which adds an engine-building aspect.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • We had to pick one of our orders so you may disagree with my uh with my order but that's all right we'll uh we'll get uh you'll hear them all one way or another yeah
  • I love that because then you can time your movement and in time where when you're going to clear clear up those hazards or those new recruits which we will talk about later
  • So it's sort of a continuation of what I know was a change between first and second edition Base Great Western Trail which was increasing the amount of money you get back from the band of tracks and Hazard tracks this one continues that even even further
  • I don't know if I love the fact that they come in randomly because you can you can get an unexpected shift in lots of expensive Ships coming at the start of the game or the cheapest Ships coming and that's going to change things up in a somewhat random way
  • This gives you new type of engine build
  • So it becomes this new it becomes this new thing you can do with high value cattle that's probably the first thing normally you would in the original game you'll just get high value cattle in hand and then just hang on to it until you reach the delivery point now there are other things you can do out here and you can spend that strength
  • You know the hazards and the the hazards and the bandits always felt like yeah now I've got excess money I can spend it and get this thing that's going to score me points but now there's an engine building side to it
  • Oh yes I really love that one because it links in with the way you build your deck it kind of adds these um little interlocking mechanism that wasn't there
  • I really like that I do I do like that as well give chance to have more these workers out
  • So I think that's a again that's it doesn't feel like that big of a change but it's a really clever way of using the rail to give you an action efficiency rather than a money efficiency and it's all all these things are about diversifying everything away from that single money currency
  • I do find that in the first and second edition I feel like I want to go to all buildings oh I need this one I need to get money I need to forward my try and so on but then I also need to go to Kansas City so at the start of the game you need to start the game I want to go to every building to kind of an engine build or get resources and then get kind of I thought okay next time next time I will shortcut I will just jump ahead three steps to Kansas City but the next time comes in more building a piece so that has not happened so this actually helps me to just jump straight ahead
  • For me this is the best thing that the new game adds and it it really makes the timing of things really precise I like it
  • So you can draw two and discard two especially when later on in the game you really need that really good stock or when you have really bad card you could still draw bad but you know you can just use that it's a good it's a good little lock hedge
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video o02rc90zQok Meeple University Top 10 List at 0:21 sentiment: positive
Meeple University - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:21 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • adds interesting variations to the original
  • timing and engine-building enhancements
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • variant of Great Western Trail with new elements (hazard tiles, ship, engine build)
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Engine Building — Engine-building components added to variant gameplay
  • engine-building — Engine-building components added to variant gameplay
  • Hazard tiles — Hazard tiles recruitable as engine-building tiles
  • timing/shortcuts — Option to shorten loops via train usage
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • this is a game called ecosphera rewilding the world
  • it's language independent
  • the transparent is not just a gimmick it's actually part of the mechanics
  • Great Western Trail Argentina compared to the previous versions
  • my number one for both of us was Great Western Trail
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video o02rc90zQok Meeple University Top 10 List at 15:13 sentiment: positive
Meeple University - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 15:13 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • new variations change the game experience positively
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • base game with new variations in Argentina version that alter gameplay
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Compound Scoring — Argentina variant includes new scoring/placement changes
  • Engine Building — Variant mentions engine-building elements (hazard tiles as engine tile)
  • engine-building — Variant mentions engine-building elements (hazard tiles as engine tile)
  • scenario-based variation — Argentina variant includes new scoring/placement changes
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • this is a game called ecosphera rewilding the world
  • it's language independent
  • the transparent is not just a gimmick it's actually part of the mechanics
  • Great Western Trail Argentina compared to the previous versions
  • my number one for both of us was Great Western Trail
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video PUC0PtG-vwc Tabletop Tolson Discussion at 0:30 sentiment: positive
Tabletop Tolson - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:30 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Iconic rondel mechanic with deep engine-building depth
  • Strong thematic flavor of railroad expansion and cattle management
Cons
  • Can be heavy and complex for new players
Thematic elements
  • Railroad logistics, cattle driving, and frontier development
  • American West during the 19th century with railroad expansion
  • Engine-building and hand-management with route optimization
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • deck_building — Develop and leverage a personal deck of worker cards to take actions
  • Engine Building — Create an engine through card and building upgrades
  • engine_building — Create an engine through card and building upgrades
  • Rondel — A giant rondel to select actions each turn with strategic blocking opportunities
  • rondel_action_selection — A giant rondel to select actions each turn with strategic blocking opportunities
  • Set Collection — Gather cattle cards and other resources to fulfill delivery and scoring
  • set_collection — Gather cattle cards and other resources to fulfill delivery and scoring
  • tile_building_upgrades — Build and upgrade buildings to improve efficiency and scoring
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • this is a lovely game with a fantastic action selection system that really encourages players to strategize with their hand
  • it's a fantastic strategy game
  • giant rondelle and you're building your buildings to hopefully block your opponents from going too fast too far
  • so that you can settle up a Kansas City and Advance all your markers so that you can be the best in the West
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video _N3jJMD072s Getting Games Discussion at 20:46 sentiment: positive
Getting Games - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 20:46 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • intriguing regional variant; curiosity about different mechanics
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • backbone of Great Western Trail with regional twist
  • New Zealand; sheep farming
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • backbone strategy with map differences — new regional map (NZ) with different dynamics; sheep focus; possible removal of trains in this variant
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I'm incredibly biased and I'm not going to sit here and tell you to back the Kickstarter campaign for this one
  • I wrote the rulebooks for all these four games
  • distilled two-hour 18nxx experience
  • I judge games by their cover; Katamino Tower looks cool
  • Clover really surprised me with how much I've enjoyed it
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video C_MUEgi0ohk Drive Thru Games Top List at 15:36 sentiment: positive
Drive Thru Games - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 15:36 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Thought the hobby 'shut down' after playing it
  • Takes everything enjoyed about the original and improves it
  • Delivery part is turned up
  • Train part integrates differently and works well
  • Every little thing is better now
  • Loved the game
  • Solo game is satisfying for a fix
  • Works well with 2, 3, or 4 players
  • Rewarding with 3 or 4 players due to more dynamic
Cons
  • Newness might be hurting it on the list currently
  • Solo game is not the favorite player count
  • Two players might be the weakest count
  • Solo game cheats, strategies feel artificial
  • The solo game built every single building in one instance, which is not typical play.
Thematic elements
  • Cattle driving and delivering goods
  • Argentina
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deck Building — Mentioned as a part of the original game that is tweaked and improved.
  • Delivery — The delivery part is a key mechanic that has been enhanced.
  • Set Collection — Implied by the theme of collecting and delivering goods.
  • Worker Placement — Implied by the movement around the board and delivery actions.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • urban sprawl is hands and above like there's nobody else in its class in terms of like a city building game
  • it is like SimCity the board game
  • the thing that I really liked about it and I think it's been really improved in the Third Edition is the whole narrative play thing
  • I do not play it to play it like a match with the Gathering player
  • this one I could see move up even higher just like Great Western Trail Argentina I can see League of legendaries get up there higher
  • just been blown away by this game
  • it's almost like he made a list and he said what are all the things Joel wants in a Dungeon Crawl and then he peeked into my head and said okay these are all the things he wants and so I'm gonna make a game with that
  • descent Legends of the dark is like kind of everything I don't want in a Dungeon Crawl but I still really enjoy it
  • my favorite version of all of those is the 1995 one and for a lot of the same reasons I like League dungeoneers
  • the absolute like brutality of it I really like
  • osworn is magical it is absolutely magical
  • every single scenario and story arc and that game has just been wow that's really cool this is really neat look at this little twist they did all this kind of stuff and everybody that I've talked to that is either much further than than us or finished I said yeah it just carries it up all the way through it's very very strong all the way through
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video iwmeAl0vcq0 Ryan and Bethany Board Game Reviews Discussion at 10:06
Ryan and Bethany Board Game Reviews - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 10:06 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Trading
  • Railroad
  • Cattle
  • American West / railroad shipping
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deck Building — Draft cattle cards and build routes to move cattle along the railway toward points.
  • Deck Building / Pattern Building — Draft cattle cards and build routes to move cattle along the railway toward points.
  • Point to Point Movement — Players move goods and workers along set routes with board-building elements.
  • point-to-point movement — Players move goods and workers along set routes with board-building elements.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • "this is a bigger game this is Alexander Pfister uh who's known for beer games"
  • "there’s different editions of things and whether they both deserve to be on the top 100 list"
  • "I love this game, uh very very cool"
  • "this is a game that I will never say no to"
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video DyeaCsl6P_g Meeple University Top 10 List at 5:33 sentiment: positive
Meeple University - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 5:33 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Intrigued by the small changes that add to the game, based on previous expansions.
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Sheep and ship herding.
  • New Zealand
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Small changes — The host is intrigued by what New Zealand brings, referencing how small changes in Argentina and Maracaibo added a lot to the game.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Welcome to our top anticipated Gen Con game 2023
  • please come and say hello I might be at die sour Booth I don't have schedule yet but I will put it in the description below
  • so please please please do let me know in the comments if you are going to be there if you're not going to be there that's okay too I will report
  • and we will mention those games in no particular order because it's too hot it's too hard to list it from one to ten
  • I can't do more than a standard three ball and a really clunky tennis I can't do more than more how bad my juggling even that it's just like I can't do more than one
  • it's all about building wind farms in Uruguay which is not a sentence I thought I'd say at any given point in time
  • if you liked Century this is a half step more complex but it's going to be a game for you
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video fsK9aCdubBw Ryan and Bethany Board Game Reviews Top 10 List at 7:10 sentiment: positive
Ryan and Bethany Board Game Reviews - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 7:10 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Rich depth with strategic tension
  • Performs well with players of varying experience when balanced with skill level
Cons
  • Complexity can be intimidating for new players
  • Optimal play benefits from familiarity with the rules and ecosystem
Thematic elements
  • Deck-building with logistical optimization on a moving track
  • American frontier, cattle drives and trains
  • Strategic, resource-driven planning with multiple routes to victory
Comparison games
  • Marco Polo II
  • Terraforming Mars (relative strategy depth)
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Compound Scoring — Sales and train movement affect revenue and victory points.
  • Deck Building — Cards drive actions and options, shaping long-term strategy.
  • deck-building — Cards drive actions and options, shaping long-term strategy.
  • Market/track-based scoring — Sales and train movement affect revenue and victory points.
  • Worker Placement — Locational actions influence income, cattle variety, and track advancement.
  • Worker placement / action economy — Locational actions influence income, cattle variety, and track advancement.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it's one of those classic uh you know Market train style games I think that everyone should play it's fantastic
  • the new Lincolnshire editions have you know really evocative art and that age of Industry style uh art and oh it's great
  • it's still the same idea you're still building your Tableau but it's different at the same time like this definitely deserves it's different enough for it to vote for both of these games to be honest they're completely different games in terms of the drafting of cards
  • it's basically aliens the board game without the IP
  • the alien is ultimately reproducing and moving around in the ship and you don't know exactly how it's getting around
  • this is one of those games that when you are just developing your collection this is this is one of the games that you want to own
  • it's a heavier one it's a pretty involved game
  • it's a space themed game as opposed to the more like fantasy themed themed game but they play pretty similarly
  • Through the Ages is the same dang game it's just got slightly different box art
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video hsy5ZQpz4hE Meeple University Playthrough at 0:46 sentiment: positive
Meeple University - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:46 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • deep deck-building element with many card options and new objective/action cards
  • dynamic board with shipping track and harbor masters adding variability
  • pathfinder track adds new strategic depth
Cons
  • potentially long and AP-prone play
  • very table-heavy setup with many components
Thematic elements
  • sheep farming and trading posts across a frontier
  • South Island of New Zealand
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail (base)
  • Great Western Trail Argentina
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • breeding_value_and_sheep_cards — sheep cards have breeding values that contribute to scoring when delivering to Wellington and at trading posts.
  • deck_building — players add and draw cards to form their own deck with sheep-related cards that influence actions.
  • hazards_and_turn_ordering — hazards appear on the board and affect play; the board ends when certain conditions are met.
  • path_and_sailing_actions — movement includes Pathfinder steps and sailing actions that advance along the map and grant bonuses.
  • pathfinder_track — there is a Pathfinder track with bonuses and points that players advance along during the game.
  • shipping_board — the shipping board replaces the traditional Railway path and introduces harbor masters and new shipping routes.
  • Track Advancement — there is a Pathfinder track with bonuses and points that players advance along during the game.
  • trading_posts_and_harbors — players place discs on trading posts and harbors to gain points and bonuses; storehouses unlock bonuses.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it's a huge table hog
  • we're streaming in 4K
  • it's a game of inches, it's a game of optimization
  • base Great Western Trail and Argentina
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video xJeP4MxxJ_I Meeple University Discussion at 14:37 sentiment: positive
Meeple University - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 14:37 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • New twist on a classic
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail Argentina
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Pantera that was Prototype so I'm able to be bought just taken or whatever a peaceful garden obviously the one that I showed and here is the um the wind farms in Argentina correct correct well not volcano I'd like to probably sorry if I was in Uruguay yes so for on a volcano we just feel like a Harding's game I like to try it still
  • nucleum this is also a prototype that I saw this is coming David Torchy's next one yes yes by um by ball and dice so this is one that the same day is actually nuclear but they make it in the alternative world because otherwise you'll probably too controversial for nuclear
  • and then the um Star Trek Discovery black alert team assistant yeah that'll be the first Star Trek game in the in the new discovery Universe yep I'll just be um Spore driving all over the place
  • and then there's a game called armelo now this there is a video game called amelo and they're making the board game so it'll be exciting I don't know if you play have you played our Melo I haven't actually played I'm a lawyer yet myself have you okay it seems like a good like artwork as well it wasn't on Sega Mega Drive I probably haven't played it
  • it seems like a good like artwork as well
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video zxTh9hJnEmc BoardGameBollocks Top List at 14:59 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 14:59 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive but tempered
Pros
  • Interesting twist on standard Euro mechanics
  • Enjoyable gameplay
Cons
  • Slightly overhyped
  • Not considered 'absolutely fantastic'
Thematic elements
  • Ranching, cattle herding, and trade
  • American West
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deck Building — Implied by 'cattle cards in your hand'.
  • Hand Management — Implied by the cattle cards in hand.
  • Movement programming — Players move ranchers around a map, choosing actions at different locations.
  • Resource Management — Managing cattle and actions on the trail.
  • Set Collection — Selling cattle cards to buyers.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • we'll be taking control of a plantation you'll be growing crops it'll be harvested in the crops sending them out to far off markets to get points
  • but they [__] the game up yeah the boards were all [__] up nothing fitted in the box or something or other and it was just a complete and utter [__] show
  • I'm sort of sick to death of Marvel six the death of [__] Star Wars and all that crap
  • Pax Premiere second edition can shove itself up its own [__] and consume itself before I even think about playing this Abomination pile of dog crap ever again
  • it looks like it's been penned by a three-year-old who's been given a king-size Crayola set for Christmas
  • sometimes I think spot or a trolling people you know they keep releasing these games that have got no artistic Merit but when you're actually playing you start to be convinced that they are actually worth their weight in gold
  • somebody's proudly displayed this phallic Tower of expansions that they're never ever going to use
  • this is a fantastic game can be a little bit complex but it's one of the rare occasions where a Euro game actually Blends well with its theme and its mechanics
  • it's just a fantastic game it's one of those sort of games that is quite leisurely it's not taxing or demanding in rules or mechanics and you could just sit back and just feel like you're pissed out your face sort of thing
  • this is our favorite solo game ever made
  • it's a bog standard Euro game with a little bit of a Twist which is why we find it a little bit more interesting than some of the others
  • a lot of people want to live out their sylvanian families incest fantasy
  • all the owns is a super fantastic game
  • number 31 is everdale this is a card driven game where you'll be placing your workers out of board to take actions playing cards it's going to give you actions as well building up your to blow with these cutesy little Woodland creatures and you get the bonus of owner big [ __ ] off cardboard tree in the middle of the [ __ ] table
  • it's okay I'm not going to masturbate over this game too much but yeah it's an average game
  • it's number 30 on this list is a game called all he owns
  • in all the owners you'll be doing right things you'll be moving your dudes around the map collecting cheese and stuff you'll be reaching into your bag to pull out your workers placing them on a map you might send them off permanently to sit in a chapel or something
  • this game uses the same artwork as Tua in it so like a medieval bio tapestry style it's a super duper bag building game
  • get the deluxifier components it makes the game easier to handle and all the owns is a super fantastic game
  • tell us what you think of our opinions of these games so far are you upset with my critique of everdale as my analysis of pax Premiere giving you a new set of hemorrhoids to deal with tell me in the comments below and I will gladly send you some anusol for your trouble
  • we're going to come back probably with the final bit I don't know I might do 20 more and then 10 because I am feeling a little bit knackered but if I could find some maybe we'll crack it all off in one go
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video CUIxUkSMsqA BoardGameBollocks Analysis at 9:14 sentiment: mixed
BoardGameBollocks - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 9:14 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • Fine game
Cons
  • Not as good as advertised
  • Overhyped
Thematic elements
  • Cattle herding and trading
  • American West
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deck Building — her cattle around this track when you stop you'll take the action
  • Route Building — flog your cattle to far markets through a railway system
  • Set Collection — take the action
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Castle burgundy is a dice game you're rolling a cut of dice you'll be using the result to take different actions to expand your Province to send Goods off to different markets and all that sort of stuff you know typical themeless affair that Stephen Feld will always always offer you but that doesn't mean anything it's still a fantastic experience I still love playing castles of Burg today and is still a fascinating romp even if you do want to push that gun out of the window
  • it's a game by Jamie stigmar stonar games it's side yeah this game changed the landscape with their Kickstarter campaign it created its own unique Universe with some fantastic artwork and it's wrongly regarded as a war game it's the threat of war that is the more concerning thing in this game
  • it's a fine game but it's just not as good as everybody tells you that it is
  • Love Twilight Struggle it's a great two player only game there's a lot of debt fear it's not perfect there's a few problems with the way that the cards come in and out of the game and it can be long if you take your time and you're going to have to do that if you want to win so yeah Twilight Struggle we don't play this all the time even though I love the maybe we should play a little bit more yeah
  • Vlad sh's Rule books turn my brain into soup
  • it's a space themed reimagining of Terror mystica
  • Spirit Island it's overrated piece of trash
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video -JFUmAbQwhU Meeple University Top 10 List at 13:13 sentiment: positive
Meeple University - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 13:13 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Adds more of a traditional Euro feel
  • More options than the original game
  • Less tight experience than the original
  • Deck building elements are very good
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • New Zealand
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail
  • Great Western Trail: Argentina
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deck Building — More traditional deck building as well.
  • Money management — I feel like you get a bit more money in this game as well.
  • Route Building — Rather than just having that single Railway track it's got some different paths you can go on.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Welcome to our top games of August 2023
  • Please also let us know what is your top game or games in this month
  • Inside job was I believe a Gen Con release
  • It's the fourth game in the Forbidden series
  • This one was definitely a Gen Con released
  • Forest Shuffle this was another Gen Con release
  • Great Western Trail New Zealand
  • Last Light by Royal Kennedy and Gray Fox Games
  • Rubber Paper Scissors
  • Sweet Mess Pastry Competition
  • My most favorite out of the Great Western Trail series ever being made ever ever
  • Hopefully you've been doing bread you have a great day great weekend and we'll see you next time bye
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video ZPPnC1QTQPQ Drive Thru Games Top List at 18:22 sentiment: positive
Drive Thru Games - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 18:22 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Jumped right in and knocked the original out
  • Keeps New Zealand out
  • Everything just sings and hums
  • Theme and mechanics gel together
  • Nice good crunchy Euro
  • Works so beautifully
  • Everything about a good Euro game
Cons
  • Might be a tricky proposition to jump right into if you haven't tried any of the games
Thematic elements
  • Cattle driving, frontier expansion
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail
  • Great Western Trail: New Zealand
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Hand Management — Implied by the deck building aspect of the original and likely carried over.
  • Route Building — Navigating the trail to deliver goods.
  • Set Collection — Collecting sets of cattle or resources.
  • Worker Placement — Likely present, similar to the original game.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I think it's my favorite coin game of all time now.
  • It's so Technical and crunchy and just immersive.
  • It comes with these really beautiful standies.
  • This is going to be part of the giveaway so just leave a comment below.
  • It feels like you're playing Skyrim or Fallout but in this Studio Ghibli style World post post apocalypse.
  • The way the mechanics and stuff which I'll talk about in the review which will be linked really lend itself to breathing life constantly through the course of the game.
  • And that to me is like such a new breath of fresh air.
  • So if you plucked me out of this universe somehow and you said you have a choice between you know Skyrim and Fallout no thanks and uh um you know this is like post postapocalyptic Earth I 100% I'm going to play in the world of the earthborne.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video an8WvpzzYlE Allies or Enemies Top 10 List at 12:58 sentiment: positive
Allies or Enemies - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 12:58 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • smoother gameplay and clearer interactions
  • new cards grant bonuses without card-slot cost
  • sheep dogs and wool-shearing add flavor and additional worker dynamics
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • cowherding, expansion of routes and systems
  • New Zealand-themed variant with island board
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deck Building — New cards provide bonuses without occupying hand slots.
  • deck-building — New cards provide bonuses without occupying hand slots.
  • Island board — An island board adds new paths and rails akin to the original game's rails.
  • modules — Optional modules allow further replayability and variability.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Great Western Trail New Zealand is phenomenal
  • this is by far the best version this takes everything I love about Great Western Trail and just it makes it smoother
  • the island board that feels a lot like the rails of the north from the original
  • the new cards you switch in it which lets you get a bonus without taking up a card slot in your hand
  • Village Big Box just takes everything from Village all the expansions and puts it all in one big box
  • Unmatched Adventures Tales to Amaze takes the original game and makes it cooperative
  • the stuff in the envelopes were more interesting as well
  • the aliens and The Thing are some of my favorite Final Girl variants
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video qMiu0llCopU Meeple University Top List at 1:10:53 sentiment: positive
Meeple University - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:10:53 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Highly Positive
Pros
  • Adds desired medium interaction
  • Enhances competitive timing
  • Strategic shortcuts add depth
  • More forgiving than base game
  • Best of the Great Western Trail trilogy
Cons
  • Released late 2022/early 2023, borderline for 2023 lists
Thematic elements
  • Cattle driving
  • Argentina
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • economic engine building — Players build an economic engine to generate income and points.
  • Hand Management — Players manage a hand of cards to perform actions or gain benefits.
  • Route Building — Players move along a route, similar to the base game, but with added strategic elements.
  • Set Collection — Players collect resources or complete sets for points.
  • Worker Placement — Players place workers to take actions.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Goblin vaults this year is not only that game but it's all the way up in my top five
  • the closest analog I haven't really seen anything exactly like it but the closest analog is Great Western Trail in terms of how the secondary scoring Market works
  • for me this takes classic Great Western Trail and adds that Medium interaction I'm looking for
  • I like Expeditions more than Scythe but I like Scythe
  • I really like a good two-player abstract and this is a really good two-player abstract
  • this has got this Euphoria bumping mechanics love it love it love it
  • this really hits the mark there is a lot of medium Euro interaction in this game
  • my number one game of 2023
  • this is my favorite of Great Western Trail well Great Western Trail Argentina is close second but I decided okay I can't really you know I just want to put one great won Trail as one game one entry
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video qMiu0llCopU Meeple University Top List at 1:25:34 sentiment: other
Meeple University - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:25:34 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Number One Game of the Year
Pros
  • Best Great Western Trail game for Stella
  • Most interesting deck building
  • Euro-style map movement
  • Satisfying engine building
  • Amplifies unique GWT elements
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Cattle driving
  • New Zealand
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail
  • Great Western Trail: Argentina
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deck Building — Enhanced deck building is a core focus, with mechanics for drawing more cards by playing specific cards.
  • Engine Building — Players can build an engine through card play and drawing mechanics.
  • Movement (Ship Board) — Utilizes a separate ship board for movement across the map, replacing the train track of the original game.
  • Set Collection — Players engage in set collection, potentially related to hunting or other benefits on the map.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Goblin vaults this year is not only that game but it's all the way up in my top five
  • the closest analog I haven't really seen anything exactly like it but the closest analog is Great Western Trail in terms of how the secondary scoring Market works
  • for me this takes classic Great Western Trail and adds that Medium interaction I'm looking for
  • I like Expeditions more than Scythe but I like Scythe
  • I really like a good two-player abstract and this is a really good two-player abstract
  • this has got this Euphoria bumping mechanics love it love it love it
  • this really hits the mark there is a lot of medium Euro interaction in this game
  • my number one game of 2023
  • this is my favorite of Great Western Trail well Great Western Trail Argentina is close second but I decided okay I can't really you know I just want to put one great won Trail as one game one entry
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video dAmFqGnzgIA Getting Games Analysis at 0:00 sentiment: positive
Getting Games - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:00 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • most ambitious of the three editions with many systems added
  • dynamic and highly variable; players can touch more systems and strategies
  • shipping/sailing offers flexible pacing and multiple viable paths
Cons
  • significant overhead and learning curve for new players
  • risky to teach New Zealand to a brand-new player due to its breadth
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail
  • Great Western Trail Argentina
  • Great Western Trail Second Edition
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • bonus tiles and wild workers — bonus tiles allow deck-building expansion; some bonus tiles grant wild workers or special cards
  • builder strategy — builder strategy is buffed, making it more viable than in the first edition
  • cows with strength and new sheep mechanics — cows have strength; cows used to obtain grain; some new elements around cows and other workers
  • customizable Rondell — central track with action spots that are randomized/tiles determine options and flow
  • Deck Building — deck-building remains core and is intensified with new cards that cycle more rapidly
  • deck building + continuous cycling — deck-building remains core and is intensified with new cards that cycle more rapidly
  • Delivery System — delivering along a track to cities with various payoffs and interactions
  • delivery to Port/Quay system — ship deliveries to ports, dock at a quay, then move to city for bonuses
  • Exhaustion cards — adding exhaustion to the deck when using strength that must be cycled out later
  • gold as a flexible resource — gold enables hiring wild workers and purchasing bonus tiles; adds strategic timing decisions
  • grain/wheat production — Grand Heroes produce grain and wheat; grain is used to ship goods
  • Hand Management — slow-motion hand management shaping the trail and future options
  • hazards reduced and managed via new systems — hazards are less punishing and can be mitigated through new pathways and bonuses
  • hazards replaced by Grand Heroes — hazards in the base game are replaced by Grand Heroes who tax/delay and can be hired
  • hiring via Grand Heroes — hire grand heroes to assist in production; leads to new deck interactions
  • money flow adjustments — money mechanics were adjusted; loans and money-to-points conversion altered
  • overall interlocking systems — improved tuning of how different systems interlock compared to the first edition
  • pathfinder track — a new Pathfinder track changes where/how you can build and score; diversifies routes
  • Pick-Up and Deliver — delivering along a track to cities with various payoffs and interactions
  • Rondel — central track with action spots that are randomized/tiles determine options and flow
  • sailing replaces trains — train system is replaced with sailing; branching paths and rewards along shipping routes
  • shearing remains with deck interactions — shearing sheep and deck interactions continue to provide depth and deck cycling opportunities
  • shipping system with multiple branches — sailing provides multiple delivery options; you can expand ships, bonuses, and house-building near shipping lanes
  • taxation buildings — buildings that tax other players and generate revenue for the owner
  • taxation dynamics — taxation system remains but is rebalanced relative to the first edition
  • timing track with bonus tokens — timing track is a major new element with bonus tokens and multiple ways to gain points
  • Track Advancement — a new Pathfinder track changes where/how you can build and score; diversifies routes
  • two-stage delivery loop — ship to quay, then to city to gain bonuses; timing and sequencing matter
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • two main mechanics it's got lots of mechanics but like it's a deck building game and it's got a customizable Rondell
  • it's a punishing game if you're new to it
  • the trains... they're quite boring
  • hazards replaced by Grand Heroes, which is a whole strategy
  • New Zealand is the most ambitious game why you say that oh I just think that they the most systems have been added
  • timing track is what pushes the game along; bonus tokens everywhere
  • you could hire them and they make you grain and they make you wheat
  • sailing replaces trains and offers branching paths that look intimidating but are straightforward
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video dAmFqGnzgIA Getting Games Analysis at 0:00 sentiment: mixed
Getting Games - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:00 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • two core mechanics (deck building and customizable Rondell)
  • high variability from setup tiles and tile shuffling
  • tension and system interlocking that rewards strategic play
Cons
  • iconography and rules require learning; beginners may find it challenging
  • initial plays can be long and punishing, especially with more players
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail Second Edition
  • Argentina
  • New Zealand
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • customizable Rondell — central track with action spots that are randomized/tiles determine options and flow
  • Deck Building — identified by speakers as one of the two main mechanics; players build a deck and cycle through cards
  • Delivery System — delivering along a track to cities with various payoffs and interactions
  • Exhaustion cards — adding exhaustion to the deck when using strength that must be cycled out later
  • Hand Management — slow-motion hand management shaping the trail and future options
  • Pick-Up and Deliver — delivering along a track to cities with various payoffs and interactions
  • Rondel — central track with action spots that are randomized/tiles determine options and flow
  • taxation buildings — buildings that tax other players and generate revenue for the owner
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • two main mechanics it's got lots of mechanics but like it's a deck building game and it's got a customizable Rondell
  • it's a punishing game if you're new to it
  • the trains... they're quite boring
  • hazards replaced by Grand Heroes, which is a whole strategy
  • New Zealand is the most ambitious game why you say that oh I just think that they the most systems have been added
  • timing track is what pushes the game along; bonus tokens everywhere
  • you could hire them and they make you grain and they make you wheat
  • sailing replaces trains and offers branching paths that look intimidating but are straightforward
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video dAmFqGnzgIA Getting Games Analysis at 0:00 sentiment: positive
Getting Games - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:00 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • better balance and more ways to generate money
  • Builder strategy is more viable and engaging
  • system interlocks are improved from the first edition
Cons
  • still harsh for new players; learning curve remains
  • initial plays can still feel lengthy if players are slow
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail
  • Argentina
  • New Zealand
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • builder strategy — builder strategy is buffed, making it more viable than in the first edition
  • Deck Building — continues to be a core mechanic; improved balance and money flow changes
  • money flow adjustments — money mechanics were adjusted; loans and money-to-points conversion altered
  • overall interlocking systems — improved tuning of how different systems interlock compared to the first edition
  • taxation dynamics — taxation system remains but is rebalanced relative to the first edition
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • two main mechanics it's got lots of mechanics but like it's a deck building game and it's got a customizable Rondell
  • it's a punishing game if you're new to it
  • the trains... they're quite boring
  • hazards replaced by Grand Heroes, which is a whole strategy
  • New Zealand is the most ambitious game why you say that oh I just think that they the most systems have been added
  • timing track is what pushes the game along; bonus tokens everywhere
  • you could hire them and they make you grain and they make you wheat
  • sailing replaces trains and offers branching paths that look intimidating but are straightforward
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video dAmFqGnzgIA Getting Games Analysis at 0:00 sentiment: positive
Getting Games - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:00 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • integrates Grand Heroes into a cohesive system with grain production
  • ships/ports and quay mechanics add depth and timing tension
  • new hiring system helps diversify options and avoid dead-ends
  • sheep/shearing adds a new deck-building dimension with meaningful choices
Cons
  • some players may find the rule complexity and timing loops confusing
  • some may feel it constitutes an expansion feel rather than a standalone rework
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail
  • Great Western Trail Second Edition
  • Great Western Trail New Zealand
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • bonus tiles and wild workers — bonus tiles allow deck-building expansion; some bonus tiles grant wild workers or special cards
  • cows with strength and new sheep mechanics — cows have strength; cows used to obtain grain; some new elements around cows and other workers
  • delivery to Port/Quay system — ship deliveries to ports, dock at a quay, then move to city for bonuses
  • grain/wheat production — Grand Heroes produce grain and wheat; grain is used to ship goods
  • hazards replaced by Grand Heroes — hazards in the base game are replaced by Grand Heroes who tax/delay and can be hired
  • hiring via Grand Heroes — hire grand heroes to assist in production; leads to new deck interactions
  • two-stage delivery loop — ship to quay, then to city to gain bonuses; timing and sequencing matter
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • two main mechanics it's got lots of mechanics but like it's a deck building game and it's got a customizable Rondell
  • it's a punishing game if you're new to it
  • the trains... they're quite boring
  • hazards replaced by Grand Heroes, which is a whole strategy
  • New Zealand is the most ambitious game why you say that oh I just think that they the most systems have been added
  • timing track is what pushes the game along; bonus tokens everywhere
  • you could hire them and they make you grain and they make you wheat
  • sailing replaces trains and offers branching paths that look intimidating but are straightforward
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video qgcRDiCzVeM Getting Games Analysis sentiment: positive
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • heavy, thematic, and deeply strategic
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • This has been such a fun thing I hope we keep doing it and get to episode 58
  • it's been two and a half years honestly
  • I love this game
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video SWIOMy0JBCI Meeple University Interview at 4:01 sentiment: positive
Meeple University - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 4:01 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I remember really enjoying trying to find all those new card types for Sushi Go Party
  • I really love the game it's it's a type of game I really enjoy
  • Forest Shuffle which I really liked
  • I would love to see Coimbra expansion
  • I would probably bring Race for the Galaxy because it's the game I've been playing for the longest
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video dUpNU-xvo1Y kovray Haul Video at 31:47 sentiment: positive
kovray - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 31:47 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
highly positive
Pros
  • More accessible than Great Western Trail
  • Faster to play
  • Clever worker/deck building integration
Cons
  • Great Western Trail can be complex and long, making it hit the table less often
Thematic elements
  • cattle herding, deck building
  • Wild West
  • Western
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deck Building — you were essentially deck building with your cows as you typically do
  • Hand Management — as soon as you draw them back up again you play them and they're immediately able to be used
  • Worker Placement — but you had workers as well and they would start on your board and once you use them to do various actions on the board they go in your discard pile
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • This game is literally you draw a card it's kind of like twister with your hands it is it's not kind of like twister with your hands it's twisted with your hands and sticks yeah
  • Combo is a good way to understand rankings of poker hands or of hands in general
  • The Gang was a game that came out and there are some really memorable hands and I feel like that game just always makes me filled with joy
  • it's important now that we're especially now that we're working in the hobby that we take some time to enjoy the hobby because we never want that fire to burn or the fire to continue to burn we don't want it to dim
  • Do you want to see me and Tyler go head-to-head in yellow house do you want a how to playay video of Cascadia Jr do you want to see a tether competition
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video jHxtpcmEA68 Board Game Sanctuary Top 50 List at 1:24 sentiment: positive
Board Game Sanctuary - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:24 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • tight engine with satisfying progression
  • tempo is fast upfront and scales with more board presence
  • strong thematic cohesion and strategic depth
Cons
  • can be heavy and lengthy for some players
  • learning curve can be steep for newcomers
Thematic elements
  • cattle trading and rail/track progression
  • American West, 19th century cattle drives
  • strategic, process-driven progression
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Engine Building — invest in builders, conductors, and cowboys to enhance actions and efficiency
  • Hand Management — build a hand of cattle cards to cash in for money and advancement
  • hand_management — build a hand of cattle cards to cash in for money and advancement
  • Route/track progression — move a train along a track around the board, stopping at key points for bonuses
  • Track Advancement — move a train along a track around the board, stopping at key points for bonuses
  • worker/developer/engine development — invest in builders, conductors, and cowboys to enhance actions and efficiency
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • the tempo of the game it feels fast at the beginning but then as more properties kind of plop out onto the field you're trying to navigate what are the best places to put your property
  • Barcelona is an absolute Gem of a board game
  • suburbia is a classic tile placement city-building game
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video VjF42rKP258 Board Game Buzzz Top 10 List at 27:34 sentiment: positive
Board Game Buzzz - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 27:34 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • familiar, well-regarded series with shorter playtime in this El Paso variant
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • cattle, buildings, and railroad expansion
  • Western cattle/rail era
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • area/engine building — classic Great Western Trail family with cattle and rail expansion mechanics (as described in context).
  • Engine Building — classic Great Western Trail family with cattle and rail expansion mechanics (as described in context).
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I'm so excited for this list
  • this is my channel so I can do what I want
  • I need this game so bad
  • the world is your sandbox that doesn't even make sense in my brain of how big they're hoping
  • the cover is so beautiful like Studio Ghibli vibes
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video nO7eX2GHmks slickerdrips Discussion at 22:38 sentiment: positive
slickerdrips - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 22:38 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • I really enjoy Great Western Trail.
  • I really like the different versions of it.
  • I'm all for it.
Cons
  • The hand stuff, putting down buildings with hands, putting these hazards down to make other people pay more stuff is not interesting.
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail: New Zealand
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deck Building — Players build their own decks.
  • Route Building — Players choose paths and construct their own routes.
  • Set Collection — Players construct parts of their own game elements.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it's a great big box uh like it's a campaign right well like not it goes over several sessions but I don't think like a completely ongoing thing.
  • I've heard it described as like a well I've actually heard a mix of people saying that it's like too many bones 2.0 and that it's like a mix of um too many bones and H Marcus I haven't played uh H Marcus but I've heard good things maybe I'll get stri at some point mixed together with the Elder Scrolls lured stuff I'm completely on board for this I cannot wait to play this.
  • it is completely like to to try and put you off if uh if you're not familiar and you're into Euro stuff it is completely dice chucking and there there is like there is Choice there is strategy and stuff into it but more than any of that there is Dice chucking there's rooll to move there's rooll to hit there's rooll to wound there's there's so much dice in this.
  • and so many things crop up in these um random cards that you're drawing whether it's the gear that you find whether it's those um events that um that come up or the the enemies that you tend to find that like you can you can see it happen even in like the the few episodes that I did of that playthrough like it's partly like just the human thing of wanting to recognize patterns but it comes up with these satisfying uh stories so often based on just a big pile of Randomness it is crazy that it can do that.
  • Shout out to bromstone is so good they had a big Kickstarter I think that was a couple of years ago now and it's projected for this year who knows if it will deliver.
  • if you get it and like it it is such a big rabbit hole that you can fall into like this game has been going for a long time like is like 2013 or something original Shadow to bromstone 2014 this game has been out for a long time and like 194 expansions.
  • Liz Boa is winning so I think we're going to be playing Liz boa next year next week.
  • is still getting disappointingly low votes that's my personal I'd like to give uh the the re revised uh Pathfinder ago uh and the reckon is actually
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video o3Pwu4xjc4c slickerdrips Discussion at 1:30:04
slickerdrips - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:30:04 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • the Restriction is supposed to be and when we moved which was a few years ago now it did get to these shelves are it get the games to fit on those shelves I think we did that and maybe had a bit of room to spare but since moving it's yeah there's a lot of extra shelves downstairs
  • 300 is the mark of too much and that includes like the shelves of tiny games of the game and the C crazy
  • it's size is driving it more than the numbers and as I said it's it's got a it's got to shrink down to mostly this room and there are big gaps but yeah it'll happen
  • Mansions is like a cube to itself Eldritch horror is a Quee to itself
  • Shadows of Brimstone that's probably the game that's it's probably tied from tied with Marvel United for a game that's taken up the most amount of space
  • box size is the issue and that's why like it's so one of them may be um like Imperial like Imperial was a cool idea and a a great train game but like one of the major things it's get it's got against it is that's one whole cax Cube for that game also box size is the issue
  • the game is always a favorite I think we've all got a copy of the game it never needs taken anywhere
  • My number one wish list for board game arena is more Cooperative games
  • I am continuously and constantly in gam castles of burgundy and I'm still no better at it
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video o3Pwu4xjc4c slickerdrips Discussion at 1:30:19
slickerdrips - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:30:19 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • the Restriction is supposed to be and when we moved which was a few years ago now it did get to these shelves are it get the games to fit on those shelves I think we did that and maybe had a bit of room to spare but since moving it's yeah there's a lot of extra shelves downstairs
  • 300 is the mark of too much and that includes like the shelves of tiny games of the game and the C crazy
  • it's size is driving it more than the numbers and as I said it's it's got a it's got to shrink down to mostly this room and there are big gaps but yeah it'll happen
  • Mansions is like a cube to itself Eldritch horror is a Quee to itself
  • Shadows of Brimstone that's probably the game that's it's probably tied from tied with Marvel United for a game that's taken up the most amount of space
  • box size is the issue and that's why like it's so one of them may be um like Imperial like Imperial was a cool idea and a a great train game but like one of the major things it's get it's got against it is that's one whole cax Cube for that game also box size is the issue
  • the game is always a favorite I think we've all got a copy of the game it never needs taken anywhere
  • My number one wish list for board game arena is more Cooperative games
  • I am continuously and constantly in gam castles of burgundy and I'm still no better at it
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 5HmGVuWUgsw The Cardboard Herald Discussion at 53:23
The Cardboard Herald - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 53:23 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • The best tends to be more of that strive for objectivity you know people going like well okay I guess chess is the best game ever or you know like uh but anytime where you get into that like real academic area there there's almost like a oh fine okay I'll admit that this one is probably the best or you know this or that.
  • I think that there is a lot more subjective in every sort of evaluation and I do think that those intangibles should be considered in what we try to evaluate as you know like meaningful best reviews.
  • I think that there is a lot more subjective in every
  • Island root and terraforming Mars were the top three
  • my tastes have changed over time I have kind of like shaped and refined my palette
  • critics have to watch so many effing movies that of course they're going to prioritize originality
  • Spirit Island is going to be in the top three
  • Aries Expedition representing terraforming Mars and root are probably going to be up there
  • maybe on the horizon that that is going to be our next guest possibly possibly our next guest could could in theory be Dwayne The Rock Johnson
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video rmYsAp57k5I Getting Games Review at 0:21 sentiment: positive
Getting Games - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:21 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • cohesive loop with tactical decisions
  • strong variety and player choice
  • accessible as a gateway to Great Western Trail
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail El Paso
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • deck management — cards representing workers are drawn, discarded, and reshuffled; deck cycles influence actions.
  • Deck Manipulation — cards representing workers are drawn, discarded, and reshuffled; deck cycles influence actions.
  • delivery/loop tempo — deliveries provide money and VP; players cycle around a loop to execute actions.
  • worker actions on board — workers (Cowboys, Builders, Engineers) implement corresponding actions on the board.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • El Paso is actually I think not even physically released but it is on beta on board game arena right now
  • it's a much faster streamlined game
  • the deck management and the way the workers come in and out is really cool
  • it's fun to see how you can pivot between cowboys, builders, and engineers
  • this game is just fun
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video rmYsAp57k5I Getting Games Review at 0:46 sentiment: positive
Getting Games - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:46 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • tight, focused loop with flexible worker abilities
  • hybrid strategies are viable and varied
  • increases interaction through tempo and timing rather than direct blocking
Cons
  • the Level 2 building (which lets you buy a bonus tile) is viewed as very strong and potentially game-warping
  • deck luck can be high; shuffles can heavily influence outcomes
  • some players may wish for fewer jumpy buildings to increase decision density
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • deck management — workers are cards that can be discarded for secondary effects; deck reshuffles reintroduce workers with their own abilities.
  • dual-use workers — each worker provides a base action on the board and a secondary discard-for-benefit option; they do not count toward the draw limit.
  • endgame tempo via deliveries — end condition is tied to deliveries; you must manage pace to avoid being late or too early.
  • progressive loop with buildings — buildings are limited and often jumpy; they influence tempo and provide various bonuses.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • El Paso is actually I think not even physically released but it is on beta on board game arena right now
  • it's a much faster streamlined game
  • the deck management and the way the workers come in and out is really cool
  • it's fun to see how you can pivot between cowboys, builders, and engineers
  • this game is just fun
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video rmYsAp57k5I Getting Games Review at 2:41 sentiment: positive
Getting Games - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 2:41 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • deck management — shares DNA with GWT but emphasizes deck-building and card cycling with a different emphasis.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • El Paso is actually I think not even physically released but it is on beta on board game arena right now
  • it's a much faster streamlined game
  • the deck management and the way the workers come in and out is really cool
  • it's fun to see how you can pivot between cowboys, builders, and engineers
  • this game is just fun
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video lsPxLU9hioc The Brothers Murph Discussion at 8:20
The Brothers Murph - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 8:20 · YouTube ↗
Pros
  • The original has three wolf haunting faces staring back at you.
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • If my score is higher than their cumulative score, then the studio, the channel, and the Murfs themselves belong to me.
  • How well do these brothers know each other? If they don't, their souls are mine.
  • I chose I play I chose my least favorite game on the planet, which is London.
  • The point is I want Squishy Fruits. But we all had the right idea.
  • I would say that he thinks C is the best letter for board games. The letter C.
  • It's between C and T. T.
  • Your souls belong to me.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video I9-bW8KUUGk Meeple University Top 10 List at 8:36 sentiment: positive
Meeple University - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 8:36 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • familiar core mechanics in a smaller footprint
  • potential as an accessible entry point for new players
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • deck-building and cattle handling in a smaller package
  • Western-themed, lighter version of Great Western Trail
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • building_track — buildings extend the track and influence delivery/travel
  • deck-building — draw and spend cards as in Great Western Trail NZ/other iterations
  • Tableau management — drawn cards can be spent or stored for later use
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it's very tactile so I'm really excited to see this one come out
  • the rules pretty simple and then there's some strategic thinking
  • there are not that many games out there that take the three dimensional rotational aspect of things into account
  • you are octopus with a cube like six-sided Cube
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 2Nt3qcS3goI Zilla Blitz Discussion at 0:07 sentiment: positive
Zilla Blitz - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:07 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • Huge strategic depth
  • Very satisfying to play
  • Lots of replayability
Cons
  • Can feel a bit thinky
Thematic elements
  • cattle driving
  • American West
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — Players choose actions from available options.
  • Deck Building — Players build and manage their deck of cards.
  • Movement — Players move their pieces across a board.
  • Set Collection — Players collect sets of cards or resources.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • It's really exciting to me. It's a card-driven racing game that's just incredibly fast-paced.
  • Ark Nova is a really complex game.
  • The Great Western Trail is a big euro-style game.
  • Pax Pamir is a political game.
  • Cascadia is an incredibly relaxing game.
  • Terraforming Mars is still a great game.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video H6LmbyTlrok Grant Lyon Top 10 List at 4:05 sentiment: mixed
Grant Lyon - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 4:05 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • simplified entry point for newcomers to the series
  • maintains core GWTr mechanics while reducing playtime
Cons
  • die-hard fans may feel it is too pared down from the original
Thematic elements
  • cattle cards, ranching logistics, and track-based action economy
  • American Southwest cattle ranching and trail system
  • analytical overview
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • streamlined, shorter playtime variant — El Paso reduces typical Great Western Trail length to 60–90 minutes.
  • track-based movement around a circular board — Players move along a loop to take actions and collect cattle cards.
  • worker deployment and resource management — Workers are spent to take various actions; cattle cards form your hand.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I am an optimistic person. So I think we will figure this out.
  • Happy gaming out there. Grant with GrantsGameres.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video T1Qxa7UtJPk The Brothers Murph Review at 33:19 sentiment: negative
The Brothers Murph - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 33:19 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
negative
Pros
  • Streamlined and simpler version of Great Western Trail
  • Very Great Western Trail-y
  • Cards cycling through discard pile makes sense and is enjoyable when played correctly
Cons
  • Played incorrectly, leading to a very unenjoyable experience
  • Rules for discarding employees were not clear
  • Rulebook needs to be more clear about card cycling
Thematic elements
  • Driving cattle to El Paso, building buildings, and managing employees
  • The American West
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail
  • Great Grz New Zealand
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Hand Management — Managing employee cards that are discarded and cycled back into the hand.
  • Set Collection — Collecting unique cattle to turn in at El Paso.
  • Trail building — Players move along a trail, similar to the original Great Western Trail.
  • Worker Placement — Hiring employees (cards) to perform actions.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I will try and solo it before we hang out on Tuesday to record this game is broken and we'll talk about it again.
  • I had a mental breakdown because I was just like, I can't I can't get it. I can't figure it out.
  • When did we decide to start making um paperbacks way bigger?
  • Paperback books are just the size of hard covers now.
  • I literally will only I will only actively seek out a place that sells it in the normal paperback size.
  • I do. I'm very mean to my books.
  • I dogge earring all day.
  • I hate reading series that aren't done. It drives me crazy.
  • The library in this is true for a lot of libraries around has so much more stuff than you think.
  • So free. So free. So incredibly free.
  • The Dresden Files has been the bane of my existence cuz it's just been for like a decade plus now.
  • I listen to more lecture series than probably anything else on Audible.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video T1Qxa7UtJPk The Brothers Murph Review at 1:40:21 sentiment: neutral
The Brothers Murph - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:40:21 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Neutral
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I will try and solo it before we hang out on Tuesday to record this game is broken and we'll talk about it again.
  • I had a mental breakdown because I was just like, I can't I can't get it. I can't figure it out.
  • When did we decide to start making um paperbacks way bigger?
  • Paperback books are just the size of hard covers now.
  • I literally will only I will only actively seek out a place that sells it in the normal paperback size.
  • I do. I'm very mean to my books.
  • I dogge earring all day.
  • I hate reading series that aren't done. It drives me crazy.
  • The library in this is true for a lot of libraries around has so much more stuff than you think.
  • So free. So free. So incredibly free.
  • The Dresden Files has been the bane of my existence cuz it's just been for like a decade plus now.
  • I listen to more lecture series than probably anything else on Audible.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 1rCWr8MJN0k Board Gaymes James Discussion at 5:31 sentiment: positive
Board Gaymes James - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 5:31 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • unknown
  • Western / travel theme
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • unknown — Not discussed in transcript
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it's time to log these all into BGG, and we will see you next time.
  • the trump changes based off of the phases of the moon
  • Has English rules, but it's in Japanese.
  • I won that by pulling a duck out of a hat.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video ah0ZN8SKrgU Hungry Gamer Discussion at 8:27 sentiment: positive
Hungry Gamer - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 8:27 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Distilled down, quick, and light.
  • Satisfying puzzle with set collection and engine building.
  • Clean and clever game mechanics.
  • Plays in under an hour.
Cons
  • Can be very, very long, especially when teaching new people.
Thematic elements
  • Distilled down version of Great Western Trail.
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deck Building — Building a deck of cow cards and trying to draw unique breeds.
  • Rondel — The game is described as a rondelle, moving around a trail and occasionally hitting the end.
  • Set Collection — Comes down to an odd set collection with cattle cards.
  • Worker Placement — You draw workers, and when you draw a worker, it goes into your tableau so you can spend it.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • It is disrespectful of me to do something with my evenings.
  • There is a special circle of hell for people who show up to a graduation with an air horn.
  • I really appreciate El Paso, you know, taking pretty much that same experience but distilling it down to the essential moves and it's a quick I don't know how long it took us. Less than an hour.
  • It's really hard and it can be really swingy.
  • You don't always have to teach a new game. Sometimes it's good to go back to something you know people like.
  • It is hard to teach because of the exact thing that I watched Don's face get confused about when you say you're in my garden. I'm in your garden.
  • It is chesslike in that you just try to optimize your moves over everybody else's moves.
  • It's a heavier game than I usually like, but I just think it's really clever the way it's put together.
  • The timer fits the theme in this game. You're driving 50 miles an hour in traffic trying to fight off bad guys.
  • Definite Spy Hunter vibes from this game.
  • The dice represent nature, which screws up your whole plan for that magic.
  • If you're going to play Twilight Imperium, you need to drink water, hydrate or not play.
  • And so Gunnet is a game that was sent us specifically reached out to me, asked me if we wanted to cover and they were interested in us covering it on this podcast, which is a first first time.
  • The core of the game is having the discussion of, okay, well, I'm going to give you this because you're going to act first and the first thing that's going to happen is we're going to drive the car to the left one space and then you're going to shoot.
  • I usually don't like a game with a timer, but you know, the timer fits the theme in this game. You're driving 50 miles an hour in traffic trying to fight off bad guys.
  • For a game that's seems like it's about making you feel stressed out for a brief moment and then that stress turns into moments of joy and glory. Like I think it accomplished that more often than it didn't.
  • The other game is Rollin One, uh, which is a golf game. Again, small footprint. It's a small box.
  • You take turns designing the course. So you take a number of cards that represent parts of the the you know the golf course and you put them together.
  • The golf clubs are represented by dice. So there's a d20, d12, d10 and so on.
  • And so there's actually some serious strategy to picking your club.
  • I thought it was very clever and I think both of the games are pretty darn thematic.
  • Make sure you are in the mood for the thing that you're going to partake.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video J16v0ExapQA Hungry Gamer Review at 0:09 sentiment: positive
Hungry Gamer - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:09 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Fast playtime (around an hour)
  • Cool, chunky components like meeples and storage boxes
  • Enjoyable basic rondelle system
  • Satisfying building and upgrading mechanic
  • Unique feel of only being able to use your own built buildings
  • Challenging decisions regarding high-risk, high-reward plays
  • Clever mechanic with worker and cow discard piles
Cons
  • Component quality contrast (cool boxes/meeples vs. standard cardboard tokens/cubes)
  • Can feel like you don't get to do what you wanted due to fast pace
  • High level of randomness in card draws can be frustrating
  • Lacks the 'meat' or depth of the original Great Western Trail
Thematic elements
  • Cattle driving, building an engine
Comparison games
  • Great Western Trail
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Engine Building — Players build and upgrade buildings on the board, which they can then activate for specific actions. The engine determines movement speed (1-3 or 1-4 spaces).
  • Hand Management — Players manage a hand of cards, balancing the need to build a good hand for scoring with the tendency to play cards quickly due to the game's pace.
  • Rondelle — The game features a rondelle movement system where players move clockwise around a small map, stopping at locations to perform actions.
  • Set Collection — Players collect cattle cards, and scoring is based on different breeds of cattle for a breeding score.
  • Tableau Building — Players can build and upgrade buildings which are added to their player area, and only they can activate their own buildings.
  • Worker Placement — Players hire workers, and the number of workers influences actions like acquiring cattle.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • It's just a really quick, fast game.
  • I kind of liked that only I could use my building.
  • So, all around it's just challenging to do to do the big things.
  • It really is clever. It really does work well.
  • So, with that said, what are my quibbles with the game?
  • Because the game is so fast, sometimes you do feel like, ah man, I couldn't do the things I wanted to do.
  • So, there is a high level of randomness to the game.
  • And the last thing I'm going to say is there's not a whole bunch of meat to this game.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video zUE33Qi-WwY Get into games Roundup at 18:15 sentiment: positive
Get into games - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 18:15 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • deep engine-building with meaningful choices
  • strong thematic presentation and components
  • excellent integration of multiple mechanics into a coherent flow
Cons
  • steep learning curve for newcomers
  • heavy for players seeking lightweight euro experiences
Thematic elements
  • industry, logistics, and route optimization
  • American West during the 19th century, cattle ranching and railroad expansion
Comparison games
  • Zulie
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • route building / rondel movement — move along a track to access actions and deliver goods, shaping efficiency and scoring avenues
  • Set Collection — collect cards and resources to fulfill objectives and earn points
  • Worker Placement — players place workers to take actions that advance their operations, hire staff, and move towards scoring opportunities
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it's just everyone's nice. Everyone's just one big happy family where you can talk to anyone, play games with anyone
  • The art on that game is top top tier, the artwork is really something special
  • I think there's going to be a lot of buzz around Time Troopers when it lands on GameFound in June
  • If you wear a Shirts and Merch t‑shirt, you won't be naked
  • The atmosphere at Aircon is just a really lovely thing in general
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video U11v8pu0gEo Board Gaming Ramblings Top List at 34:03 sentiment: positive
Board Gaming Ramblings - Great Western Trail video thumbnail
Click to watch at 34:03 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • It's a great game
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Cattle Drive
  • American West
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deck Building — Implied as a core mechanic.
  • Hand Management — Related to deck building and card play.
  • Route Building — Thematic to a cattle drive, moving from one point to another.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • For me, this is an S. This is one of the better games ever. I love it.
  • Um Tor Mars I've spoken about this many times. Hate love it. H I love to hate it and I hate to love it.
  • It's just like F plus for me. This is boring.
  • If this wasn't Marvel, if it was just called Champions, wouldn't be the same same wouldn't be a top 100.
  • We like lordas but like boa and kban ee is my favorite ones.
  • And then we're going to have Mara Kybo. Oh, Marbo is good. Uh I really like it still. Even though that Pirates of Marbo kind of did the same goodness in shorter amount of time.
  • I would place Marbo in B or C.
  • What? D.
  • And uh lastly for this part of the video, we're going to have come down EV S S. Yeah, that's an easy one to end on. We like lordas but like boa and kban ee is my favorite ones.
  • That was way more fun than I thought it would be.
  • I think this is fun because well we kind of have this thing in top 10 or especially in top uh when we make top 100 and top 50 because she's like oh you picked this so low or this is so high and we get like to kind of see our differences a little more clearly.
  • Also when we do the keep and we disagree we kind of I think that is fun and I thought that we we're going to agree more. So, but but it's nice that we don't.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Transcript Navigation
Showing 101–150 of 371
Game Deep Dive