Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 100 Board Games of All Time (2023) 10 - 1

Transcript 46:17

welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and this is our top 100 favorite board games of all time and this is it we are finally here we are counting down the top ten yes the final one and before we did this we each wrote down the 10 games we thought would be on the other person's list and the order so we'll check back at the end for how close we actually get to it but let's start off with your number 10.

my number 10 is Cascadia and Cascadia is just such a tight design this might be my favorite Gateway game that's out there and it's just all of the parts like I like everything about it it's like a simple tile placement game but also you've got these awesome little circular animal discs that feel really nice and clanky in a bag and I love pulling stuff out of a bag that you're putting on top of those spaces and then it's got this like the nice layer of the different scoring conditions and those are variable as well which adds a lot of replayability to the game and all of that stuff just makes it such a good Gateway game and we've played it so many times and even with like the Simplicity of it I've just I've never gotten at all tired of this game yeah the layers of scoring are interesting and I really like just trying to match up the landscape type files and trying to because whoever has the most gets a bonus so you are trying to group the different Landscapes and so just that little bit of an extra decision of what tile you take for the Landscapes with what animal does make it a bit tough because sometimes you won't necessarily be able to get what you want the nice thing though is it's super rare that we just can't use one or the other like it almost never happens that we have to just throw away an animal because there's nowhere to put it and I think it's nice too because that other layer of like the little pine cones that you get for the keystone species which Jess

has a little song about that she says every single time she gets a keystone species but that's a nice little addition as well that helps you that just helps you mess around with that market a little bit too but just all of those little things put together this is such a just terrifically tight package and that is my number 10. 10 is gloomhaven and we played through the gloomhaven campaign a few years back now and when we were playing it I probably would have said it was my favorite game we were playing it all the time we were staying up late because we thought oh one more and we might be able to retire our characters we had so much fun really getting a character stronger and figuring them out and then moving on to the next one and I think we got it at such a good time because we had just moved to the UK so we didn't have a lot of games and so having this one that we could play like for months really fit because we're like well what else are we gonna do well let's play gloomhaven and we were totally on board but because it's been a few years it's just naturally dropped down my list a little bit yeah I think it was really at the perfect time because I remember when we got this we were out in Bristol and we went into a board game store and we'd played games but we weren't anywhere near this into games and I was just like what is your biggest box of game what's like your biggest heaviest game that you have and they just got it in and I like I long for those days when we had space

for now we're like what's your smallest game that we can get the most play out of I would never say that now but it was great because we just had this huge boxing game we had room for it and we'd dove in with both feet and we really haven't been able to recreate that experience like we've tried with the expansion we tried with Joseline which is great with frost Haven which just has just a bit fiddly I think um but gloomhaven was just that like perfect experience of the perfect time and I'm so glad that we had it yeah and I was so excited for frost Haven I backed it as soon as it went up and then we got it and we have played it a fair number of times yeah I feel like I want to say we haven't played it then I look and we've got like 20 plays it's like 40 hours of frosting yeah so we've definitely put some time in but it's still like such a small percentage of the game and I had so many to find the time to play it but gloomhaven was just such an amazing experience that it is still my number 10. my number nine is lost ruins of arnock and when we started putting together the list when we started making these videos lost rhones was about 20-ish spots lower on my list but between then and now we got the latest expansion and oh boy has that ever moved it up I love when an expansion really changes the way that you can play a game and it really works well that way as a

co-op campaign game part of that is because Jess is just way better at the resource efficiency than I am so you usually win this because you can get way up that track and I'm like how is that even possible how did you do that but now I can use that magic to my benefits because she's on my team and we're working together to fight against the puzzle also all of the different sections of the campaign play like a little bit differently and have a new challenge and that's been really cool to to play with as well yeah for the expansion for the campaign mode each chapter has a challenge that drives you in a certain direction so you might be really pushed to do the research track and it makes that a whole lot harder or to explore a lot of sites or fight a lot of Guardians and it's been really interesting to try different different ways of playing like I never thought about really exploring lots of sites and not defeating those Guardians and now I'm like oh maybe I could do that and I found with the base game I was really stuck in a rut of playing a particular way of racing up the research track and defeating a couple of Guardians and then winning the game and then winning the game it did work for me it's different try those while you're kind of learning these different things about you know fighting the Guardians and doing this other stuff over here and maybe the research track isn't always the focus I'm learning maybe I should focus on the research track and maybe I shouldn't

just fight these Guardians and it also just it really puts into your head like how many different paths and different things there are in this game and the card play as well which we didn't even talk about how many things there are to explore and that's fitting because it's an exploration game and it is my number nine my number nine is tapestry which is an abstracted civilization game and I am always up for playing tapestry it helps that we have everything that you can possibly have for tapestry so that means we have a whole ton of different civilizations you can be and it's asymmetric civilizations so it makes a huge difference in how you play and then you also have these City boards that you're trying to fill with these buildings as well and some of the newer expansions have come with different versions of those too so the mix and match between the civilizations and the city boards really feels like every time you're presented with a new challenge and then on top of that it's the tapestry cards that you get each time might drive you in certain directions as well there are so many things that change how you shift your focus and especially with the arts and architecture expansion that added a whole fifth track too so with that additional track I find we're really trying different Avenues more so than when it was just the four tracks yeah and the great thing about this game is the like the bass system is so simple

like the original rule book was I think two pages long it was outrageous maybe four pages long that it was possible even to make a game that's like this big and it's fairly heavy to have it to be able to to condense the rules down that small says a lot about it because it really is just kind of you exchange a resource you move up a track but all of those points of variability the civilization and those City boards are really cool especially the new ones and the new the latest expansion added a lot more fun I think too because it's got all these little references to like horror movies or X-Men or a lot of stuff I personally really like but it's all of these fun little references and the city boards especially have that too yeah it's the fantasies and Futures and what is quite neat is because it's such an abstracted civilization game it means that they were able to add in these science fiction references and these fantasy ones because you aren't trying to recreate the path of humanity it does let those Auto references in in a way that works really well and that makes tapestry my number nine my number eight is kanban and I was just talking about how Cascadia is such a like beautifully simplified like tight package kanban does kind of the same thing but for a much much heavier game this is just for a heavy game this system is so so sleek and so smooth and that's why it's my

favorite of lacerta's games you've got every single part of it is so completely intertwined with every other part of it but the nice thing is you can start at any point within the system and it will work as long as you are also going to those other points before too long but it means that you can't get like fully blocked you can just be slightly less efficient yeah and it is good that you can visit the places out of order because even at a two-player game it feels really tight because Sandra moves along and you can never go where Sandra is and so far we've only played with nice Sandra because I've been too worried about playing with me and Sandra nice Sandra will reward the person who's doing best but me and Sandra will punish the person who's doing the worst and I don't know if I'm ready for that yet yeah I think it would be interesting to use though because niceandra feels mean because she's very judgmental but mean Sandra knowing that I'm gonna have to have at least this much of whatever the thing is uh really that that would be an interesting challenge I think we should probably we've played this enough now that we should probably take that on and another cool thing about this too is just how it uses time as a resource as well I don't know a lot of games that do that especially as well as this does that and so this is my number eight my number eight is horrified which is a gateway Cooperative game with an amazing

theme I'm going specifically with the univ reversal monsters one although I do like both but we watched all of the universal monster movies when we got the game which I had never seen before we'd love Halloween so anytime it's gearing up towards Halloween we play a whole lot of horrified and so this is a game we can play again and again it helps that there's slight asymmetric player Powers but also the monsters you can introduce a different number of monsters and they all Play Slightly differently and because it is so simple it's a good game to introduce to new players when we were up at aircon we had won the American monsters one that was the first time we put up a little like come play with us sign and we had strangers play with us and I think that's also part of why I like this game so much is just that memory of bringing strangers and playing with them for the first time well and that's scary the first time that you do it and it went really well and we ended up playing like the whole night with all different people and I like the American monster is because of the the 50s diner style of it the feel of it and then it's got just slightly like slightly more complex slightly different monsters and I'm really interested to see the new one but I definitely agree Universal monsters that has like my heart because I love I just I love those movies so much Bride of Frankenstein especially if you haven't seen that that is my favorite of the universal monster movies and they do such a great job of incorporating all of the worlds onto one board because they have each of the

different monsters locations but it still feels like one town and when you open up the box and you see the board with like oh watch out this would be scary so many great little details and it's those details that I love and that makes horrified my number eight my number seven is planet unknown and this is the newest game to make it into my top ten this one just came out last year and this is just this has everything that I like this has tile placement this has tracks and really interesting tracks that are like comboing and letting you bump things up and this has got just a whole bunch of asymmetry because it has the asymmetric corporations and it has asymmetric planets and those two things together combine in all sorts of interesting ways and we know because we've played with most of those combinations now we've played this game so so much this is broken into like our top 10 most played like of all time games and we've only owned it for like a year because this is also one that I just want to introduce to anyone that comes over part of that is because it looks so great on the table but also because everyone is always involved and I really like that and a lot of games have everyone always involved but on this it feels like it's always your turn and it's got a fun little like centerpiece as well that just adds to it even more yeah the lazy season really is the star of the show because of that choice when it's your your turn you can choose any option and then the other people they still get a choice too which

is nice because when your arrow is pointing at one of them you get to choose out of two options and one option is a bigger tile one's a smaller tile but you're often trying to decide which tracks you want to go up so that will influence your decision which makes it a bit tricky because the game ends when somebody can't play versatile so often you'll be choosing the bigger tiles just to try and fill up your planet more but sometimes those small little like two tiles might be just the things you need so it's that continual compromise of do I want to go up the right tracks or do I really want to make sure I'm filling up my Planet yeah and I think that's where a lot of the the kind of hidden interaction comes into because when we play a two players we both want to get like everything just perfect so both of us tend to take those smaller pieces and we have a lot more pieces and we take a little bit longer but when you play with a lot of players someone is always going to go for those big pieces and pushing and the more people you've got to mess with that pace kind of the more interesting this game is too and it is mine number seven my number seven is another game about terraforming planets that this one specifically is terraforming Mars and we got terraforming Mars again pretty early in our collection and it has stayed with me I love of the Tableau building you end up with so many different cards and all of that changes your engine and because it comes with like just an absurd amount of cards each game is going to be

totally different so you just have to play what you think is best depending on what you have you really can't plan towards certain things because you just may not get those cards and what keeps it interesting too is the asymmetry we like asymmetry a lot and this is another example of just those starting corporations trying to gear you in certain directions but you might end up going a completely different way based on the engine that you're building as well so I love the theme I love the Tableau building and I love just the actual transformation of the red planet into something that seems livable yeah I think having that that Central board where we're putting this stuff on especially because we got the fancy 3D tiles too is really fun but I 100 agree like there's been games where I've thought at the start oh yeah I'm gonna do this sort of thing and then I look at my starting cards and I think well okay I'll do that later but right now I'll use like these three like Greenery Focus cards and that just now I'm doing a Greenery thing I'm not doing whatever I thought I was gonna do you really do just need to use what you've got and then build with what you've already built and that's just gonna kind of take you down a path and and I think all of the different paths that are possible in this just make that so interesting yeah and at two players the other thing that's guiding you as well are the the awards and the Milestones because we do find that we achieve them all between the two of us but I'll stay away from the ones that I know you're gonna win so I can focus on the other ones so that's interesting as well in terms of that trying to decide which ones based on

what you have you think you can achieve and all of it together makes terraforming Mars my number seven my number six is a feast for Odin and talking about a game that has a lot of different paths this one has just the most different pads this feels like just an enormous sandbox of possibilities especially for a work replacement game although this does famously have like the most worker placement spots ever there are so many spaces and they're all interesting though and they're all usable and they're all useful in their different ways and and it's it's so neat to have a game that goes in so many paths and that we're learning how to play so much better all of the time because at first we were just I just got to fill this this this starting board is so hard how am I gonna fill this starting board and then I saw on another Channel someone was talking about and I wish I could remember who it was but someone was talking about the you got to get the islands first that that's so important and I thought how would you even ever do the islands and then I got them and I realized oh this is how you fill the other board is you get these things over here on the islands and the long houses and then you build an engine like oh that's really really interesting and then someone else was like oh you got to get the cards and then it was like oh and these cards give me bonuses well they're attached to other spaces and that gets me things and so it's these layers that I just keep finding even after so many plays and keep

learning how to play this game better and better so I just feel like myself progressing and getting smarter at this it's it really is a fascinating game and what really helped me as well was the Norwegian expansion and it did it for a few reasons one of the reasons is it really made you use those cards more because it had a few more spaces that let you pick up cards and play cards and I did find that playing those cards pushed me in other directions that I hadn't thought about trying before and the other thing it does is it really gives you a great option for when you only have your last one or two workers because sometimes before you'd be like oh I only have one worker left this feels a little bit like a wasted action to go here now those are actions feel almost the strongest which is really interesting that you're always left with something great to choose from at the very end of the round yeah and I think Norwegian expansions is great no matter what player count but it's like a must at two players because it just it tightens up that board just a little bit at two players and really it really changes the game and I think I've liked the game already but it has made it way better and that is my number six my number six is Baron Park which is by Phil Walker Harding and I think this was the first Phil Walker Harding game we played and we loved it and ever since then we play so many of his games and we really like them but this is still my favorite of his games like I love the

theme of building a Bear Park and you get to just cover your board and take different tiles depending on what you're covering but the whole thing involved as well is a race because it's a race towards the goals it's a race towards filling up a board to get the higher value bear statues and it's a race towards getting the different types of bears because their value decreases as they disappear there's something about this game that I just find so Charming I think maybe it's just that it just is like tile placement with more layers of tile placement this is like if exhibit found out that you liked a tile placement game that's what this is and it just does it so well and it's timed really well that most people almost get to finish their board or finish it which is great so even if you don't score well you're like oh look I've managed to fill my entire board then you count up your points and you realize you got a lot of low value things and that's where you try and do better next time but it is nice still to feel a sense of completion and that makes Baron Park my number six my number five is everdel and everdel first off is just beautiful and that's what originally Drew us to this and I think we've been talking a lot about like board game first but this was the first time the the two of us at least in the UK had gone to a Board Game Cafe and we went to one out in Bristol and we saw this game on the shelf and we were just like we got to play this later and and because of that it was the first time we watched out how to play video and Rodney

Smith taught us how to play that on the video because we just went back to the hotel we had like an hour to wait and learned the game and came back very excitedly and set it up with its big beautiful tree which now I hate so much and so in the way but we set up that tree and we played it and it just knocked our socks off we both just loved it and we that's never gone away we just we keep on being like enjoying this game being invested in this game and I think the the big box that came out this year the complete collection is why this has stayed at the same spot I think that it was last year even though there's all these other great games that have come out or that we've played because it just gives so many new ways to play it as well and I think New Leaf which just came in the big box was is maybe the best expansion yeah I I would agree it makes building higher value things easier which is nice too if you're struggling to build something that costs a whole lot of resources and it adds additional goals in terms of the passengers on the train which is great because we've played a lot of everdale that we have gotten to the point where we do have a lot of resources or things left over at the end so those passenger goals really tap into that and scare you towards being able to use those possibly to score points so new Leaf definitely introduced a few key things it didn't change the game like some of the other expansions that we've talked about but instead it enhanced the base game to make it even better and another thing that the complete collection did that

has just made me love this game even more is it gave us all of the critters and we had some of the expansions before but we didn't have the collector's edition so we were missing a bunch of this the really like the Platypus and the axolotls and some like specifically fantastic animals and now having all of them and having those stickers on them too which I wasn't sure I even wanted to use but I'm glad you talked me into it because it adds so much personality that it just makes a super Charming game even more charming and that is my number five my number five is lost ruins of arnak and unlike you this has stayed the same position I'd love the expansion but it was already ranked highly for me I think a huge reason why is the puzzle of just trying to do everything that you need to do with what feels like very limited opportunities because you only have two workers and there's only five rounds meaning you're only placing workers out 10 times but but you are able to get other resources through other avenues there's so many different combos you can do cards come into it a huge amount and when we realize that buying items was so important we started buying a whole lot more climbing up the research track you do have to spend resources but also gives you resources and exploring sites costume resources but gives you resources so it's such a great combination of having to spend things but get things at almost an equal rate

but it might not be quite the right things so just trying to figure out how you can turn one thing into another keeps that puzzle really interesting yeah this is a really really tight puzzle you always have to think kind of three moves ahead of if I move here then this will move me up the track but then this will do this and then if I play this card I can buy this other card and then that will do this and then when that plan comes together you just feels so so clever you do because it feels impossible at the beginning it feels impossible to explore lots of sites to feed lots of Guardians to go up the track but it does come together but in a way that leaves you with that feeling of like look at how I managed to do this and so the base game and the expansions that added the asymmetric player Powers definitely helped as well as and of course The Campaign which I really love makes lost ruins of arnac my number five my number four is an acronym anacrony is a fairly heavy game on BGG I know it's got quite a heavy rating it's like a four or something and I don't think it is as heavy as people think or at least it's not rules heavy because this is a game that we've played a bunch of times but we only play kind of every few months because it is a bit of a longer experience and we almost never have to look at the rule book again it's a fairly simple rule set but that heaviness comes from just a lot of fun interesting like chunky decisions that you're making all of the time because

you don't have nearly enough workers for anything and you certainly don't have enough mix and so you've got to be thinking about how do I get the things that charge up my Max because the max are the only way you can go to the shared planet and you go there by putting them really amazingly slotting them into the mix which is one of my favorite experiences in board games but you need enough enough that you can go out there but you also need enough water to actually wake up your your worker so you can use them the game just has these really great kind of checks and balances for all of the things that you need to do so you're kind of forced in a lot of games where there's like a feeding part there's all of these different kind of feeding barriers in this game but they're all more interesting I think and you are right I've never thought about anacrony the barriers being like the feeding mechanic but it definitely is and just like that you really have to set yourself up for the next turn because I found myself like being like Oh I can do so much this is amazing and then realizing oh no next time I can only put out one Mech because I forgot to get the stuff that I need to be able to put out more Macs and you do have to spend a lot to keep your workers awake but it does give you the option of forcing them away right yeah which is great if you're in a pickle and you're like oh no well I definitely need workers or else I'm hooped then you can force them awake and still get them you'll just end up with more negative points at the end yeah and another thing that has changed this a bit too is the expansion we've been talking a lot about

the expansions but in anacrony a lot of these expansions are really interesting but I almost feel like we have too many choices and we found ourselves just going back to the base game a lot more but just as a base game experience that's all you're going to need for this for at least like 20-ish plays and that is my number four my number four is dwarf romantic and this is the highest ranked newest game on my list it is a Cooperative tile placement game I love both of those mechanics and it smooshes them together so perfectly it's so chill we have this on our top 10 Comfort games for exactly that reason I think it's a little bit like if I were to do jigsaw puzzles which I never really got into but that same sense of like calmness as you're piecing it all together and I really like us playing it together because it's so collaborative every time we pick up a tile it's a discussion of where the tile can go and then you don't lose but you always try and get more and more points and I think that's one of the reasons why I don't like jigsaw puzzles is because you don't get any points so that you get this similar kind of feeling but with points and you're you're doing it together dark romantic is just a really cozy comfy puzzle and I think in her review of it I compared it to it's like the board game version of drinking hot chocolate on like a chilly day and that's a hundred percent what this is It's just so cozy it's like it's like

the mittens of board games and we've just we enjoy it every time we play it we enjoy it the whole time we play it and even if we're losing which you can't really do you just don't win as well but even if things aren't going well it's always joyful yeah it's a great game to play if I'm feeling really stressed or I just want something to feel a little bit better I remember it was one of my games of choice on my birthday because we have a rule that we can play whatever the other person wants on their birthday and I was like dwarf romantic because you're up for playing it but if it was up to me we would tell you it's all we would play it's all we would play we would play it every single day so you're quite good at playing it with me and I do understand we can't play it all the time but it is my number four my number three is Ultimate railroads and all three of my top three games have been my number one game at some point in the last week I have bounced back and forth on this so so much I almost switched them right now as well but I'm holding to it and ultimate rail of the roads is gonna be my number three but ultimate railroads is an absolutely fantastic game and this is basically this is a track game this is a track bumping worker placement game but the tracks in this this is we've had a few of these that we've talked about games where it looks like it's going to be impossible and then you can't believe how much you've done at the end and I think that is it's such a skill to be able to to make to have a game that has

that sort of Arc to it and this one is that like to the extreme because your first turn you get like 8 10 maybe 12 points if you really kill it on your last turn you're Maybe scoring like 120 points because of all the stuff that you've built up but as you get those bonuses and you get more workers and you unlock things and you put things on top of your board so so satisfying and it's so addictive and that there are four different kinds of railroads in this plus a bunch of modules and all of that stuff plays differently this is just like this box of board gaming joy to me yeah you're always debating which track to go down and often it's a debate of oh I can get five points now or I can get this bonus now or you can get a little like plus to each round scoring and those can pay off at the end so we've had games where one person has gone like way ahead in the first couple rounds but because the other person has worked towards getting all of those bonuses that will eventually build and build they've managed to like lap them by the end of the game this is one of those very few games that like I played it I think on BGA first and I was just like holy cow you've got to play this game like it just it blew me all the way away like I think I ordered this game before I'd even finished that first game on BGA and I got creamed in that first game I just got fully destroyed and I could not have loved it more and then when we got it I just love it even more on the table when

we're actually playing it and I can see all of the things this is It's if you haven't played it you got to play this it is my number three my number three is Arc Nova and Arc Nova is such a great mix of what a lot of games have done well so it is a Frankenstein of of mechanics or a Frankenstein monster if you will of mechanics yes because it has the civilization New Dawn uh action selection system it has the rajas of the Ganges of the two tracks Crossing to trigger the end of the game and then it feels a little bit like terraforming Mars in terms of the Tableau building and the icons that you're trying to mix and match as well and I love all three of those things so together it makes for a really interesting game I also really like the theme I have a background of zoology so doing a conservation zoo is is great and I really like that you're building out your zoo but a key part of what you're doing is then the conservation efforts of trying to release them the tricky is I love primate so I always anytime there's a primate I always want to get a primate even though it might not tie into anything else I'm doing so there is a draw of like just getting the cards I want that has to be mitigated a little bit with what cards will make me do better yeah I I really like that about this game too because I feel like I am usually the one who's guilty of that often in games Jess will see like the the solid path forward and kind of how

the math works for the game and I will be like building castles is fun I'm gonna build more castles and then I will lose because she's better at the math side and this is one where I am better at the actual math side of it and I can kind of take myself out of it a bit and you are just like oh my goodness Apes I gotta get them oh look it's perfect monkeys I gotta get them and it's like every kind of of primate she's just got a full primate Zoo every time and that really works to my benefit so I really do appreciate that but it's also fun just watching you like really loving every time you pull uh any sort of primate card you can tell when she does the card draw and which one she's got it's just like oh and it's like oh I see I see why it has happened here so I still I'm still playing it to the best of my ability but we have gotten better and better at this game because at first I think it surprised us when the end came when the two markers crossed so we only had like maybe a couple points but now we really set ourselves up for a really big last round and that makes Arc Nova my number three my number two is Dune Imperium Dune Imperium I really liked right out of the gate I thought it was just an absolutely terrific it just felt so Dune it's so tight in that only going up to 10 points and and like the war of attrition kind of that's going on in the middle and like knowing when to take back your troops and the the tight deck

building hard playing element all the politics all of that stuff I really like but with the expansions I feel like with both expansions that is kind of the full game of Dune it feels like that's how Dune was built and then they kind of started off with the simpler version which wasn't that simple but then have added these layers and all of the layers really really make this Shine the first one did a great job of just fixing a couple of the spaces that didn't feel that interesting and then adding a few different ways to play but then the second one I feel like with all of the extra cards and the extra card playing mechanics as well as another board that you're moving up with the research there's just there's so many paths and there's so much to explore in this game but to explore in this really like slow sloggy but like really terrifically sluggy doomful way and I think what again helps with this game is the asymmetric factions because there are so many different factions you can play and it's small little Powers but in a game that's so tight all of those little powers do make a difference in how the game feels and the different directions that you're playing as well and so we have played a lot because we always want to play all the characters that we can possibly play yeah and they're like 25 characters and there's some silly amount of different characters but I like that I like the like Rich World building and this is a world that I'm so interested

in too and that is my number two my number two is Cascadia and this was already mentioned on your list but I also love Cascadia obviously because it's my number two I think part of my love definitely comes from the fact that I grew up in the Pacific Northwest so I love that I'm building out that landscape with the animals that I'm so familiar with and there's so many games that we enjoy that you're left feeling rewarded by having built something that you can look down on at the end and Cascadia does that so well with all of the Landscapes and the getting it populated with the animals and so even if I don't win I still just really have enjoyed building my Pacific Northwest region yeah it it's just it's such a great game it's and that theme does help a lot lot because I wasn't quite in the Pacific Northwest but I was like just next door to it no one no one's making a prairies building up the Prairies you're just putting yellow or slightly off yellow so I really do appreciate like the theme and the familiarity of this game I think that makes it feel it just makes it feel like like a little bit of home but then you we just play this over and over and over you can play this like three times in a night and it still feels fresh and interesting yeah absolutely two I mean I'll be almost all my games on my top 10 I guess Gloom Haven not so much but the rest I do want to play anytime I'm always up for playing but

it's particularly true for Cascadia I do wonder if it would be so high if we still lived out there right if we could just look at oh look it's Cascadia right now yeah exactly I feel like maybe it is also High because it is a little part of where I grew up which is so different to here and it makes Cascadia my number two my number one is Gaia project and that is still holding tight from last year although last year it was like number one with the ball this year that was this was like a game time decision this was so tight between those top three but what it just holds on is I think it does a lot of the same things that I love about those all of the other games in my top five really it's the asymmetry the different paths to Victory the tightness of resources but there's something about this one that just does it just a little bit better where those different paths can feel so different especially with the tech tree and those different factions can feel so different where some of them you're really just focusing on that main board and building where you're building all of your your different houses and traveling to the different planets and sometimes it's really just that Tech Tree and that tightness is so unbelievably tight it's not that like I don't see where I'm gonna go at like the end of the game I don't see where I'm gonna go like my next action and every action I'm like oh how was that possible okay how am I gonna do the next thing oh I could do it

this way okay cool now how am I gonna do the next thing it's like a constant thing and I could see if you played this with someone with AP or even playing with this this with like a lot of players it may not be as as high on your list but at two players which is absolutely where this shines this is like two player Terror mystica really and at two players this is just oh it's just perfect I do agree about the possibility for analysis paralysis I don't really find that in our games because both of us are so focused all of the time that I have no idea how long you're taking on your channel I think we just both have AP all the time yeah because you're so in it you just don't like I'm never like oh I'm waiting for your turn exactly I'm almost glad when you take a while because it I'm taking just as long figuring out my turn and then same thing one that gets to me you're immediately trying to figure out what how what you're doing next that you don't notice how long I'm taking and so it is a full brain burner a hundred percent of my attention is focused on this game which is great it's a really interesting puzzle to solve yeah it's interesting because as you're saying I was thinking this sounds like a negative but it's not like and I 100 agree with you but it's in like the most positive way and I just find this game so completely engaging and that is why it is my number one my number one is everdale and I don't

think that comes as a surprise to you it's been my number one ever since we started doing these lists and it is held strong and I think there are a few reasons for it one reason is like you mentioned we played it pretty early in building our board game collection here in the UK and for me prior to playing this I was like yeah I love board games but I'd primarily played a lot of Gateway games so things like Ticket to Ride and the trail on house on the hill and Katan and carcazon and then when we played everdale everything about it was so pleasant it looked amazing the resources were so lovely but the gameplay as well we were getting in each other's way in terms of where we want to go but I wasn't like targeting you and it wasn't mean towards you and I was building something beautiful and lovely and you weren't really gonna mess with it and I think that was one of the first times that I thought this is what board games can be and it really made me want to explore more so I love everdel I love the mechanics and the build up like the first season you only get a few workers so each season you get stronger and stronger with more workers and more cards I it's just continually positively rewarding like it gets more rewarding the more in the game you go and the whole game overall was such a new experience for me that it what pushed me into exploring more board games yeah I wonder how I would feel about this if not for you because you are so delighted by it that I want to play it just

because then you're like oh you get to play Emmerdale I'm so happy about it and I do really love this game though and um and I think you're probably a big part of that but I think even outside of that I would still like this game because at its base it's just a really interesting Resource Management game it helps that all those resources are terrific and it's got squishy berries and nice sticks and smooth rocks and that does add to it but the resource management is interesting and then the card Tableau building is interesting yeah I love all the components the actual components and then the mechanics of building out my Tableau again it is something that afterwards I look down and I'm like oh look at my little village even if I don't win so I think it'll be really hard to displace this game because of what it did to bring me into the Hobby and the fondness that I I think I'll always feel for it but I hope I always feel for it and that makes everdale my number one and that is it thank you so much for doing this giant crazy Journey with us this was a lot of work every year we forget how much work it is but we really appreciate it because we see how many people actually watch this and share this and like this and everything else and that does mean a lot in all the comments and everything else and it is fun to do this whole giant countdown and kind of check back in with where it is and quite a bit has changed yeah I do feel like we do this primarily for

ourselves because we're just curious we're just being selfish we're yeah and it gives us a skirt to look back on year upon year and so at the beginning I said that we made a list of our top ten now we did it after our last video I feel like if we had made this list at the very we should do that next year yeah yeah that it would look quite a bit different because by then I knew basically what games would be in it but what order it was I wasn't too sure so how did you do with guessing mine I managed I got all all of the games but I managed only two correct and I feel like everdale was such a gimme so I really I only had one other one so two out of ten so between that and that I said we would have four direct Crossovers and we had none not one direct crossover in the whole thing I have failed a lot for yours I managed to get three in the correct position and again I did get the right games but only three were right and that was because I did like a last minute switch between two and I called it and I had guessed two direct crossovers we had none but I was closer than zero yep I won with that but thank you so much everybody for watching thank you for watching just this one if this is the only one you watched or thank you for watching some of the other ones if you watch those too as usual please let us know in the comments if you've played any of these games please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game thank you

Progress saved