Skip to main content
Loading video...

Guess the connections that link these board games together... - Lost In The Shuffle

Transcript 16:24

I would say there's a few things that tie us together, Chaz. We both have facial hair. We both wear glasses. We both like board games. So, we're going to try to figure out what ties all these different board games together. What is the common thread? Are we going to be able to do that or are we going to Oh, this is the intro. Lost the shuffle. I thought we

No, I was just trying. Today on this episode, Matthew has put together some games that are all tied together by a common thread, but we don't know what that thread is, and we're trying to figure out what do these games have in common. Why are these games on the same list together? We got to figure it out.

And you can help us.

Yes, please.

You can't really help us, but

you can play along at home.

You can play along at home. Maybe we can help you. So, I believe that Matthew has put together a little introduction of how this game is going to work. So, why don't we turn to the Matthew machine?

All right, Matthew.

Not unlike the name of a gritty detective drama set in a rural small English village where a a terrible crime is being committed by a knitting club. This episode is called Common Threads. Was that worth it? Was that worth all of the words? I have an amount of questions for you. Each of them is a list of five games. Your job, your task, dare I say your duty, is to tell me what the common thread linking all these five games are. Unfortunately, because of humans, you could technically get some type of weird answer where they're all in boxes, you know, but if you don't get the answer I give you, it doesn't count. All right, that's life. You'll be working together on this one. So, I wish you good luck and God's speed. And your first is thusly. Paleo, Legends of Andor, Challengers, Seven Wonders, and Broom Service. Well, I don't see any obvious connections. At first, I was thinking like, Challengers is an auto battler. Could it be that?

No.

My immediate thought was spills winners.

Oh, did Legends of Andor win a spills? Yeah. My question is if Challengers did. Oh my gosh. Challengers is a Ker Spiel winner.

Okay. So then yeah, that probably is the answer. They're Spiel nominees.

Well, let's dig a little deeper and find out. Seven Wonders has got to be a spiel to Jarus winner, right?

Kenner Spiel 2011.

Okay. I would just

Room service is Kenner Spiel 2015.

Challengers is 2023. Kenner Spiel.

Yeah.

And Paleo, did we check?

Was 2020, I think.

I think we lucked out. We got that right off the bat.

Yeah, I think you're right. All right. And I think they're all Kenner Spiel.

I think specifically Kenner Spiel.

Yes.

Yes. Are we logged in on that?

I think so.

Okay. Let's

I think we're good.

Let's find out.

I feel good about it.

Okay. Well, here we go.

We did that faster than we thought.

Oh, yeah.

The common thread here is that all of these games won the Kenna Spielus, the connoisseur/expert game of the year.

Yeah. Good job.

All right. Also then when I go back and I'm like challengers like I would say that's a family weight game.

Yeah.

So it won the game connoisseur of the year game.

Well that's the eternal debate about the Kenner versus Kinder Spiel is yours.

Yeah. Yeah. Sure. Yeah. Fair.

All right. Well yeah we are.

Yeah. Feeling good.

Rocking start here. Now we have Frost Haven, Alien Frontiers, Clans of Calonia, Brass Birmingham, and Final Girl.

What an eclectic mix.

He's not making these easy.

No,

Thomas.

My next thought is to go to designers and artists,

which I just looked and it's not there. It does not have a common thread and it's not player count because we got a solo game and then plenty of

nonsolo games here.

Next time we play this, we need Matthew to give us a clue.

Yeah.

Uh oh. Oh, nope. Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. Final girl reimplements hostage negotiator. Frost Haven re-implements gloom haven.

Okay.

Brass Birmingham is brash Lancasher. Alien Frontiers has multiple editions.

Okay.

Um, and Clans of Calonia.

I don't think that's from anything.

They were all at Gen Con at some point.

Oh, Clans of Calonia is having a reprint in 2023. Okay.

Which is two years ago.

Oh, it is, huh? Good to know that it'll be coming out.

So, new edition.

Maybe. Maybe new edition. Yeah. I don't see a lot of other things bringing them together.

Oh, wait. Brass Brinman just had like a new edition released, didn't it?

Well, they are going to be releasing a new version of Brass.

Okay. I know Final Girl has

has a bunch of editions. I mean, I guess you could say they all have or they all are or have sort of new additions. They're not based on video games or anything like that, right?

You don't remember the hot coin op from the 80s and brassing them. set up your trade route for your resources.

I feel like that's our best guess is like the new the new new version.

If it's something related to that, I give us the point.

All right. Well, that's very nice of you.

We are making the rules. So, you know,

I see what I can.

I think even even if it's not related at all, we get a point.

Old strategy.

Yeah.

Let's see if it paid off. The common thread here is that all of these games held crowdfunding campaigns.

Oh.

Oh, crowdfunding campaigns. Me saying they were all at Gen Con at some point is is is the same thing.

Now, hold on though. Now, you could go that direction. However, you could argue that Alien Frontiers was like the first Kickstarted board game.

Okay.

Frost Haven is like the highest grossing board game. Just wondering if I can somehow cheat us a point for that. I don't think so. I don't think

No, it's fair. But I don't think Matthew gets a point either for that one. I'm saying nobody gets a point.

No point. No points for anyone. Yeah.

Okay. We still have enough left on the list that we could come out getting more of them than not.

Yes, for sure. That's our goal.

That's my new goal.

Yeah. Yeah. Me, too.

Excellent.

It's always been it. I just never said it until now.

Oh, perfect.

Yeah. Yeah. Can you tell me the common thread between gizmos, cities, fjords, spellbook, and sushi go? They all involve like a little bit of engine building. Gizmos is a straight engine building game. Sushi Go based on like it's almost or maybe they all um they all like score only based on having certain things. Well, like a set collection thing where it's like if you have two of these, it's worth this amount of points, but if you have three of these, it's worth

fjords worth.

I don't know. I've never played fjords, so that's like the one I don't know.

Fjords is similar to not Castlevania, Carcassone.

Oh, okay.

Um, the similar type of tiles making little closed off areas.

They all have like a uh like a three-dimensional aspect. No, Sushi Go doesn't really.

No, Sushi Go doesn't. Yeah,

I know what it is though.

What is it?

I cracked the case.

Good. I'm We're This is cooperative. So, tell me.

Oh, are they all designed by Phil Walker Harding?

That's the one. Yep.

That's the common thread.

Okay.

You know what else he designed? Super Mega Lucky Box.

Oh, really? Yes.

He's everywhere.

Yeah, he designs a lot for sure.

There we go. And he's like to me one of my favorite designers because I think he's one of the best at strategy games that are easy to teach to non-gamers.

I see it right over there on your computer with a picture of him holding Im Hotep.

Yeah, I love that game.

Fantastic game. Yeah, Phil Walker Harding. Very designer.

Indeed.

And I also think our common thread.

I agree.

Right. All these gangs were of course designed by the wonderful Phil Walker Harding. Well,

yes,

we are on our way.

Two of three.

Two of three.

All right, that's a that is a not failing.

It's also two more than I thought we'd have at this point.

Now it's time for Concordia Nations, Hannah Makoji, Eldrich Horror, and Cavverna. Uh

oh. I think this one is the re-implementation of things,

right? Cuz Kaverna and Agricola.

Yeah.

Okay. You got Hannah Makoji, which I think is about um uh sud not sushi. Uh

you can keep doing that as much as you want. I don't know what you're doing. You know, the shark the shark game.

And then Concordius had a bunch of different editions.

They they these are games that were reimplemented by other games, too. Or do they reimplement other games? Because Eldritor is a relementation of Arkham Horror.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Cavern with a Gricola. Yeah,

Hannah Makoji is Oh, yeah. Uh, Gisha's Road.

Okay.

But what do you think that the Do you think the the thread would be reimplements and or re-implemented by? Seems a little broad.

Yeah, maybe.

Just

Well, because I don't Concordia was reimplemented by other stuff, but was it itself a reimplementation of other things? I don't think so.

I don't think so either.

Yeah,

I think we're close, but we don't quite have it nailed down. Oh, you know what else it could be? What's that? Oh, BGG did a Hall of Fame recently and they inducted like their first 25 games into the Hall of Fame or some I can't remember if it was like 20, but like Concordia would be on there.

While you're puzzling over

No, I don't think that's it because not everybody. Some of these are, but I don't think all of them are.

There is also Cavern Cave versus Cave.

Sure. Didn't Concordia get a two-player version of something?

Did it?

I don't know. Well, there's no Eldrich horror two-player game, is there? I guess Eldrich Horror Love Letter. No rats. I was thinking maybe that they had a two-player version that came out.

There was Concordia Venus, but that plays two to six players.

Does play two.

It does play two, but so does the original.

I don't think that we're going to be able to focus in any more than what we already have.

Okay, I'm okay with that. Let's see what Matthew says.

All right, Matthew. Ed McKilas.

The common thread here is that all of those games came out in 2013.

Oh, good. Oh, right in front of us.

Yeah, I didn't think about that at all.

Oh, we totally overthought that one.

You know, 2013, the year that everybody remembers.

We could have gotten there. We didn't.

We didn't.

So, we're two for two.

We're two for two. So, we have to win this last one.

Last one. This is

to be a positive score so the principal doesn't write home to our mom.

Yep. Is the fifth one. The last one. And it's Matthew.

So, he's going to make this hard.

All bets are off. Could be anything.

And can you tell me the common thread, if not elusive? This one's hard, basically, is what I'm saying. What's the thread between Twilight Imperium fourth edition, Blood on the Clock Tower, Dead of Winter, Hijgemony, and John's Company.

Boy, I was really hoping it was going to be something like Twilight Imperium fourth edition. Then this came fourth edition. Then this came fourth edition. I was like, I got it. Wasn't that simple. Darn it.

Those are a bunch of big old heavy games.

Yeah, they're like Beefy Boys. Beefy Boys with a Z. Even

a lot of them are over four on the complexity scale on BG. Is that what you think it is? But like Blood on the Clock Tower, I

was going to say Blood on the Clock Tower is a

it's a heavier game for its type of game, but

No, I

I think I got it.

Do you already?

I think.

You're not really carrying the torch for this game, so I'm glad this one was cooperative.

Okay. My thought was it's the first game published by that particular company.

Oh,

but uh Dead of Winter doesn't match because Dead of Winter did um

Well, it's the first Crossroads game.

True.

So, they have that line of games and that was the first one in that line.

And that is true. Hegemany definitely is Hijgemony Institute's first game.

Yeah. And Blood on the Clock Tower is definitely their first game. The Pandemonium Institute. Yeah, Twilight Imperium has got to be Fantasy Flight's flagship product. Pla Hat Games though put out um Summoner Wars.

No, Summoner Wars was done by Planet Hat,

right?

Yeah, that's what you just you said. Yes.

I don't know where I was going. It's done by Planet Hat.

Yes.

Yeah.

Summoner Wars. Yeah. We're talking 2009 and Dead of Winter's got to be at least 2012.

It was 2014.

2014. So, other than that, it seems like it fits.

Could you say it's the first in a line of games?

Twilight Imperium fourth edition.

Yeah, it's the first line.

Fair.

Darn it. So close again.

Could it just be like games that are considered heavyweight?

Yeah.

Yeah.

Like representative of their genre?

Maybe. There's some sense of negotiation in hegemony and in blood on the clock tower like

isn't John a really really hardcore euro?

I thought so but I'm grasping it straws here.

Okay. Economic negoti negotiation and political.

That's what it says about John company.

That's what it says about John company.

So maybe it all has negotiation in it.

That's the most consistent common thread.

Yeah. So what is how does debt of winter happen? You get the crossroads cards, you know, it's like, "Okay, do we let this person in but lose supplies?" No. Yes. No.

I think that might be what it is. Negotiation aspect of it.

Okay.

I'm open to other ideas, but

I got no better idea.

This is the best one I've got so far.

My only other idea, which I thought I was pretty proud of coming up with, was the first game published by a company, but it doesn't fit.

All right.

Okay. You know, I I think so. Some aspect of negotiation.

All right. We're going for it. This is it. Win or lose on negotiation, but if we lose, I will negotiate for a win.

Respect the theme.

Yeah.

All right. Well,

let's find out.

Yeah.

Of course, obviously, the common thread here is that all of these games feature voting as a key mechanism.

I think voting is kind of like negotiation. I feel like that that is so close. I think that that is the aspect of like, hey, you need to do this and then

we were right on the periphery of that. I don't

Let's take a vote.

Yeah.

All right. All in favor?

Yay.

All right.

We make the rules. We decide the winners.

You know what we should do? We'll give ourselves the point. Unless anyone in the comments tells us they actually scored better than we did.

Yeah. There you go.

Yeah. So, if you were able to get three, four, or all five of those common threads, let us know and we will deduct your point and give you the credit from

Wow. You could win this right now.

You could be a winner.

Yeah.

All right. So, the pressure's on you. Let us know down in the comments. And while you're down there, write a note for yourselves reminding you to join us for the next episode of Lost in the Shuffle.

Hey, these are fun to do. We like doing them for you.

Yeah. Well, we hope that you enjoy watching them.

Yeah. And if you're watching this far, well, hopefully that means that you do. So, until next time, thanks for joining us. I'll talk to you again soon.

Progress saved