TCbH Podcast - Board Game Components
Transcript
hello everybody and welcome back to the cardboard Herald podcast I am Eric joined by Jack as always hey I'm here I'm I'm available I'm on the podcast Eric thank you so much I know it it's really tough for you to clear your your very busy schedule to be on this we weekly podcast we film once a week thank you so thank thank you very much for that I had to talk to a few people to get it on the books but you know we man your child and your wife yes that's probably it um well hello how are you doing today Jack I'm good I'm eager to talk about board games this is a topic that I care very much about uh and uh it better be you you started a whole YouTube channel based on it so I I really hope you care about board games yes yes yeah well specifically we we've been talking about topics we've been talking about topics in general and uh you uh for those who don't know Eric has been taking over a lot of the the podcasty aspect of the cardboard Herald recently and I was like what's our topic today and he shot back to me components and I was like hell yeah I think that every board game has I feel like every board game has a component that at least at minimum can be commented upon as either a really good component or a bad component I feel like most games have something that you can point to and be like oh this is a
really solid component for what it's trying to be or why did they design this thing in this way um and I just thought it was like kind of a fun fun topic just because a lot of thought and design goes into them uh and they're a weird little thing about our hobby that we it's just a fun thing that I think sets games apart from a lot of other types of Medias that there are physical things that you're interacting with in in the design matters um but first off what have you been playing this week Jack uh I've been playing a bunch of stuff I mean we we've been hitting some oldies but goodies uh we played some five tribes last night Christina and I got that to the table after a game of harmonies and it was great you know we were commenting on how it kind of feels like of a time now we have enough distance from five tribes whether it's the place and time that we were when we got it or it was just the games that were coming out around the time that it uh came out it it definitely feels of about 10 years ago you know fitting in with the Lords of the water deeps the Kingdom Builders that kind of stuff um as far as new stuff I haven't I haven't played too much new stuff I I played word traveler um which is kind of an interesting Cooperative word game that uh has some like logistic pathing
based off of observational word association um it's office dogs first game does not does not hold up to where I think they go with uh River of gold and the uh Fellowship of the Ring trick-taking game uh but uh I me that that is the trajectory you hope a board game Studio takes is is better better and better games keep coming out as opposed to it'd be really sad if word traveler was like they this is like the thing they put the highest effort in I've never played it so I might love it I do love word games yeah I mean it's an interesting one because it's something that feels like it would fit really well in like a mass Market context uh you know like bring home to the family type of thing it's fully Cooperative low pressure it kind of I don't know if you remember uh from childhood those like uh quiz games or you know like trivia cards that were like long tarot card looking things on a single Loop it has that aesthetic like the the artwork looks born entirely out of that um with some intentionality so like the there is some craft uh involved in the game and I like that the other one that I was excited to at least touch on here but maybe talk about a little bit later um for those of you who are
listening you are missing out on license to Crill uh which is a board game where the Box uh is the whale uh and there are cards that come out of the plushy that is zippered on the front um it's bonkers uh as a concept the game is very meh um so this is a game where the component is doing the heavy lifting the component got it into the door the component is why I'm commenting on it right now um look at that though that's adorable again audio listeners you are missing out on a very adorable board game packaging right right and I I don't know if we have like a announcement section or anything but I guess we should mention uh this is up on like apple podcast and stuff and then we also figured out how to get it up on Spotify too yeah it is now on Spotify so it should be on pretty much any main major podcast streaming format you should be able to find and listen to this podcast uh yeah and I think that YouTube is the only place for posting the video uh just cuz that's the hosting site that we know best and it's where the rest of our content is so just kind of makes sense to keep the video version of the podcast there but yeah feel free if you're just looking for the Audio I know that we just gave a glowing review to watch it because you got to see a very cute whale um but if you uh are hoping
for a audio version uh we are now I think on all the major major platforms to my knowledge yeah uh I mean we got to talk to Jay-Z uh and Kanye about whatever their platform was from a few years ago but I as far as title yes there we go there a very popular music stream that's still that's still just as popular as ever right right right yeah um both of those figures are probably not uh those that we currently as of right now in 2025 want to do a lot of heavy association with our brand I'm okay if we if we keep the cardboard Herald separate from Kanye yeah don't that's a good plan that's a good plan about J but I I think for sure Kanye we I feel pretty confident in saying that we can avoid business associations with with him yeah well I mean as his uh as his um I guess stature goes down maybe we could get him as a guest at some point if nothing else that be kind crazy yeah you know that could be fun do you think he's a do you think Kanye is a big board gamer what do you think his favorite board gamer I think he'd tell us he's a big board gamer you got me there yep what have you been playing Eric um I've been playing Ark Nova on board game arena I've been trying out uh the Marine World expansion I own the physical copy but this is a game that I feel like benefits a lot
from being digital just for the sake of it is so easy to just press go whereas I feel like with the with the physical version it does take a little bit and if you're playing solo I can see board game arena being like the spot to do it are you doing Solo or are you doing multiplayer on both a little bit of both I've done I've done both uh I've been trying out just because I think that that's the thing that I would like to do a review on at some point the Marine World expansion uh because that is actually one of the First videos I said I would do for this show so I would like to that would be a good idea at some point or another it's been on the Google Sheets for quite a while yeah there are a couple things that are on there that like I fully need to do at some point or another Imperium Horizons is another one I put that one Empires rise and fall man but how you feeling about the expansion it's pretty fun I think that it opens up a lot of Pathways to pursue uh weirder strategies so like today in a Solo game I was like able to get a really nice Predator icon Loop which I just feel like I was able to do because you now in the expansion there's an option to purchase like any animal tag right like I can purchase a science icon and a predator tag which let me play like just helps you play Predators
more easily because they usually need you to have either predators in play already and they also benefit from having that already there but there were a couple others where it was like oh I need a primate icon to play this animal that I want to play are you playing with just the the standard solo mode I know that when when I first got Ark Nova I was still really hot for a lot of solo modes I made sure any game that I review more or less I still any game that I review I try to hit the solo mode if there is one but when I got that game I loved the multiplayer and I loved the solo mode and I was surprised that after my review because I I Tred to distance myself from reactions uh before I really get in the midst of a game like I might pay attention to buzz but as far as nuanced reaction and Analysis I try to divorce myself from that and I was surprised that there are a lot of people who criticized uh the solo mode of the game as feeling empty or too pressured or truncated like it was too fast of a version of the game to really mirror the experience of playing multiplayer um I can kind of understand that but I really like the solo mode as is yeah I mean I enjoy it is just the base solo mode I mean through board game arena that's what they have um yeah I can see that being the case just because there are a lot of times where I'm like well there's no churn in the card Market because
that's not really a factor in the game right like it only happens every seven turns and if there's just like the first five cards in the thing are all cards that I don't want and maybe there's a sixth card that I could get that I would want to get but I can't get it because of snapping rules so it's just like well these cards are all just going to stay exactly where they are and I'm just going to drop from the deck and then in three rounds after those cards have made their way down the aisle then I can get this card that I actually want so I can see it being that there's a little bit of frustration of it doesn't really mimic a multiplayer game in in quite the same way I feel like I can also see the comment that the pressure on it is really high just because it is like you have it starts feeling more like how few turns you have on like White Castle and Har where it's like oh I do have to like make I can't Dil D which you can kind of do in a multiplayer game a little bit easier at least um you can yeah I've I've been having a lovely time with this solo version I I mean I think that as far as like how big of the game this is this feels like a really complete solo mode right like I'm definitely
getting most of the experience I would get out of a multiplayer game like I'm probably there are definitely things that I'm missing out on uh like like the card churn and being like Oh I really need to get that card before somebody else's able to I don't know what that noise was um but that's uh I think that's that's a that's a sacrifice I'm willing to make to be able to actually mostly get the rest of arcova as a followup from last week do you find that the um like additive Reef stuff to increase the card turn the new universities that kind of stuff does it mitigate some of the I guess more luck based elements of the original Arc Nova um I think the universities definitely do I keep trying to interact with the new content and it just keeps being like so much out of the way for me to do that in terms of like I can't play the fish until I put the aquarium in play but I can't put the aquarium in play until I upgrade my build action and I understand that that's like a thing that is a something you can do reasonably early is upgrade a card but to interact with like any of the new fish that are in the game to be have to upgrade your build action makes it so that's it's a little bit is that is that true I I I'm I'm now
like if it's not true then I've been playing terribly wrong this whole time which is possible I think the aquarium can be built right off the bat uh with the the base uh build action because they specifically didn't want to make it so it was overly restrictive so that opens up a brand new world for you my man oh well I'm have to keep that bu oh w i could be wrong I mean let let let's you know like see the audience can bear out but uh I I think that we can in fact you you have I have it right here hold on you talk while I look at the rules what else have you been playing oh Vamp well um as far as playing or you know getting around to uh I talked about kire delve recently I got more plays of that in I'm working on the review for that uh and other projects going around here um just completed the harmonies uh review that we both worked on and should have that up as far as some uh announcement type of stuff for uh the cardboard Herald we've been doing more shorts um that we uh have been posting online um it was fun kind of experimenting with more short form comment uh or short form content that is on comment and I also learned what the millennial pause was and the Gen Z Shake uh as I consulted a friend on like hey what do you think about the short firm content and what do
you think about my big breath at the beginning of the video and she's like Ah that's just a millennial pause I was like what what are you talking about it's a whole thing you can look it up generational thing I guess Tik Tok YouTube shorts they they've already established it but anyway shorts are available we're working on those we're also working on some giveaways we're probably going to have an announcement soon about how patrons of a certain tier which hopefully is a pretty low tier are going to be automatically entered to win a game a month so stay tuned for that yeah anyway um I found out I was horribly wrong yeah you can build that immediately yeah hell yeah hell what I could tell so that'll be fun I guess I've just never I my assumption that's why you hadn't reviewed the game yet you that's why I needed this moment uh yeah for some reason I guess I just assumed that it needed that but that well all the other special buildings aside from the the uh you know the petting zoo require the upgraded build action so makes sense makes sense I get it um so I've been playing Arc Nova horribly wrong but I have been playing that and then the other thing that I've been playing that I've actually I've been getting onto the table is Sky Team but with solo rules I've heard of this interesting um and it seems from my looking over BGG and a couple other places there's essentially three paths you can go down for the solo mode which
is either roll all of your partner's dice mhm and then you just have both dice publicly available to you yeah which makes it I I feel like that would make it too easy oh yeah toally roll one dice at a time and just whatever you roll you have to place that turn no matter what the number is but you can't plan at all for it which I feel like does make it reasonably difficult like like that's a good level of difficult probably uh or what I did which I think I preferred better just because of how much what I want out of this game which is roll two die roll two dice use one keep the other and then just whenever it comes to the Bots turn make sure you have two dice available until so it's like you you're going to roll two dice but now you know what two of the dice the opponent or your partner has is so you know you have a one and a five and then you use the five and so you keep that one roll another dice to replenish it uh and that's worked pretty well nice I think there is like a there is enough planning that I felt like I could do what I needed to do like to be like a oh I got to like really figure
out how to best puzzle this out but because of you know you don't know all that your uh partner is going to roll uh which I felt mimicked the base game pretty well uh pretty good like I mean just in terms of it's not an official solo variant but to make this two-player only Co-op into a solo soloable mode mhm it was like really easy to implement that because there's not like any special rules tools or components you need it's just how do you how do you roll the dice and I think that worked reasonably well from what from when I tried I played for about uh 2 hours earlier and felt like I got a nice little uh experience out of it for anyone who hasn't really investigated this at all I and I've mentioned this a couple times and various videos uh where I have um l basted a publisher for not having a solo mode or I thought a solo mode was bad or whatever the most impressive group of Gamers that I know of is the BGG solo Community uh that they will they will solo anything you could give them a hamburger and they're like we made a solo game out of it um there there's just an unbelievable amount of design work that goes on beyond what is published by a company to iterate develop and flesh out solo
modes whether one existed or not it's really fascinating so chances are if there's ever a game where you're like H I'd love to play this I like solo but this doesn't have a solo mode go to BGG look at VAR you're probably going to find one yeah I still haven't tried there I am a little bit baffled by how many different solo modes there are of arcs yeah that's like a thing that I found where I'm like this is just I don't know which one to try I got to try the one that uh Travis said to try yeah um but yeah there there's like four or five different options and they all seem reasonably complicated but that makes sense with arcs I I feel like that there's not an easy solo mode option for that like I I can understand why that was not included in the base game totally well it's probably time huh probably time to talk about some pieces some toys pieces some toys some components yeah well I just think that first we can start off with why board game components matter that's a note that I think is a really important thing to explain why we might really like a component or why we might dislike a component but this is like how at least for me this is that is how you are Interac in with the world of the game is through components and while it might be like a
deck of cards that you're playing there's also like a lot of things that it matters that the component is shaped the exact way it's shaped there's a reason why a component that is really high quality stands out as something that if this is a thing that you're going to be interacting with a lot that the publisher or developer has like put a lot of thought and effort into how this component fits the game uh shows shows a lot of care that I think should be applauded in a lot of ways yeah well let let me get this out of the way upfront I think when people really think about it this is going to be true for most Gamers I'm certain that it's true for us um you know like good components can't save a bad game though a mediocre or good game is almost always improved by having better components now better is incredibly subjective right um and uh I I think that's really a case-by casee basis on what a game is specifically going for um you know like there's a lot of people who will talk online about like I never want to see Miniatures again or I never want to see this type of components again or I hate beige boards or whatever I I'm an omni gamer I like all sorts of things and I want to see all sorts of different things um and
it's hard for me to like specifically go like I this is something I always like in a game but when I do see a component that um that that really speaks to me it absolutely enriches the experience of playing the game now what you're talking about with the uh the way that you interact with the game you interact with the world of the game I think of it as like an interface right you know like you could have a crappy 480 TV and play video games on that and it will run those but you could also have you know like a 4k monitor or something and it makes everything else pop it could be the same game but there's definitely a tangible difference between those types of things um and then you can draw comparisons from like uh the visuals to uh usability you know like component uh usability is something that I think is getting more and more attention in the publishing side of things um in the last like five or six years with color blind uh uh accessibility options um making sure that things uh are um easily picked up and retrievable um slotted boards are kind of like a maybe not an accessibility thing but they're they're certainly something that can go beyond
just making a production look nice but actually having a a physical tangible difference that improves the quality of life in the game itself so there's a lot of things that I think make components important uh that provide function Beyond just visuals but the most intimate thing to me certainly is starts with the visuals um it it's the toy aspect of the game it's it's the game on the table that invites me to want to interact with it um it's the thing that hooks me it's going to be my first experience um and once I get to the table and I start interacting with it then that's going to be the function and that's where I'm caring much more about like what do these pieces facilitate but um the the most gut emotional reaction is almost always visual um whether that's art uh art assets throughout the game um that's could be UI assets or it could just be Association you know like this game evokes this other experience that I've had and how cool is that other experience so maybe these two games are very similar yeah and I think that there there's something to be said that sometimes board game components can build a like unspoken language of oh
whenever I see a component that looks like this it generally is going to do this thing like if I ever see a meele I know that that's going to represent my character somewhere on the board I think that that's that could be helpful getting people into the hobby I also think that there's a lot of components that bring a lot of table presence in a way that is really strong like I I can't imagine everell without the tree even though I I think it's a super nonfunctional board like there's there's no reason for the tree like right you could have the exact same game with it just being like some extra slots on the player on the board right and it would be totally fine like some wood ziggurat it stands uh in front of you and you're like whoa what is this thing and it brings it brings so much flare to the game that I don't think that it would have otherwise in a similar way like I played we're sinking recently I have a review coming out for that at some point or another and that has like a pirate ship component that is like an actual thing you have to interact with in the game unless you're really good and kill the monster before you sink at all which is highly unlikely right uh if you do that you don't have to interact with a pirate ship but yeah it's like a thing of I like that as a board game component because it's something that both has
table presence and like has a meaningful thing that happens in the game um the quality control on it is not very good uh cuz my pirate ship Wiggles in a way that I don't like but there's I think that there's a thing to be said of sometimes board game components are table presence and it just is like this dominates the table and brings Focus to it uh there there are a lot of games that I think have something similar to that um but then I think other times there are just components that there it's really a small but it is such a good it it's a sign of care that they put time and effort into making this component very good uh in Sky Team the slotted double board they don't they didn't need to make it a slot a double board they could have easily made it just one layer it kind of would sucked there's like things about it that I think the game would be worse off if it wasn't like this assembly required board in the middle but because it's there it just shows so much care went into making that as good as possible uh so I think that there are things like that where just the amount of care going into the piece shows that they they've thought about you as the player playing this game yeah you know
like I I think that components uh go a long way um in you know elevating the experience the the cute novelty you know Sky team has little switches with which are kind of fiddly switches and I loved that in the expansion they're like and we have more switches in case you lost some of your switches I'm like okay they're kind of acknowledging that the switches are kind of fiddly but they are cute and the double layered board is really nice the way the radial uh for the the uh tilt of the plane is rested in there works really well the way the dice go in there like you know it feels like it it elevates like experience um and the theme of the game um that feels like you know every kid's dream of being up at a cockpit dashboard and be able to hit the buttons and press the switches and interact with the things hopefully kids aren't dreaming about doing that as the plane is hurdling towards the ground but uh making a safe reasonable Landing if I have anything to say about it totally totally and one of the things about Sky team that makes it work really well in this context is that it is not exorbitantly expensive it is a very good production for the uh level of game the depth of game that they wanted to provide and it kind of hits the right
balance on all those regards whereas you know like you could have even nicer components that are twice as expensive but you know that that's not really that game that's not what it's going for you know you got to hit a nice equilibrium like the tilt of the plane to be able to land that just right and I I think that there there are some uh you know like other ways that components can uh enhance the theme uh and not just uh trying to portray the specific theme but the the Resonance of of the tone of the game uh Pax pamier is another great example of this with the beautiful canvas roll out and then these like totemic uh clay pieces that are the roads and soldiers that stand up um and the fact that they're pillars instead of shaped to look like individuals gives it kind of this more Antiquated Antiquated Antiquity uh based Antiquated Antiquated there we go there are you know where there we go Antiquated vibe to the game which I I think it's overall trying to evoke um and all of those things are what enhances the experience of a game I truly believe that if someone's like I don't care at all about the theme
or the components then they're they're to a degree lying because if that were the case you'd just be playing spreadsheets you know like yeah you you there are reasons most people don't play print and plays yeah yeah like I I do and I have a totally fine time with them but I I understand that I'm it's a print and play like the the reason I'm getting this game for free is because it's not we're not always free I do sometimes pay for my print and place depending on the Avenue but it's that the reason it's the price that it is is because the component components should have like a level of care put into them that make them enjoyable to fiddle about with well even print and plays you know like that that's another important aspect of uh components I definitely want to get to is like design limitations right yeah you know like sometimes A Game's design is restricted by the physicality of how you're interfacing with the game and I imagine that Publishers are all the time having to make practi IC decisions during development past the initial signing uh or idea of the game that impact some aspect of it because of the funding constraints to bring something to life like yeah this was a really cool idea until we found out how much it was going to cost to print these so we had
to go and do this other thing yeah and then some games like really lean into the Restriction like for an example and this is a game that I think actually for what I've been able to ascertain actually does not have the best board game components uh but Gloom Haven bugs and buttons is like all about how how much can we take away while keeping the Gloom Haven Essence right and from what I've seen I haven't actually played it I would like to uh but from your review and seeing the components in person like the cards are not the best quality and they Bend and warp way yeah that that's that's not ideal uh and my way around that uh is that you could have like um uh a top loader like a hard plastic top loader that you keep like a baseball card or you know like a rare Magic or Pokemon card or something in you know you could just put the current mission in that and that flattens it out that solves the problem but a top loader doesn't fit in that box but even that is a great idea of you know how do I wrap this whole experience into as few and as small components as possible and also what is stretching the limit of functionality not just the the design Essence but those are really tiny pieces any tinier and it would have been beyond
any sort of reason um and I I imagine that there are uh insignificant amount of people who find it too small to play on you know like buttons and bugs is fabulous I loved it I list as one of my favorite games of the year but if I were check out that video now in the top right corner if I figure out how to do that yes yes um but if if I were 20 years older uh which I hope I'm playing games in 20 years that may you know interact with my arthritis in a different way that may interact with my visual capabilities in a different way one of my main Frost Haven buddies you know like he he has to put on reading classes he's not that much older than me but you know like for certain things he's like all right well you know like let me look at this and that's not to disparage him but you know that's what the proper size thing components matter accessibility matters especially when what we're trying to do is to get people to the table um one thing that I I've thought long and hard about but I don't know that I've really talked to you about is to what extent do you define components because there's the the game board and the pieces you interact with but are components everything that's in the Box you know like I've long argued that the
rule book should be treated with the same level of importance as any other component thereby calling it a component but you know the rule book is the Box a component you know um I think it can be in my mind when I think of components I think of anything that's taken out of the box okay okay um I think the storage solution itself like if there's like little dividers I don't always think of those as a component unless like clearly car's been put into them um so but what if it facilitates ease of the game so for example I am working on the kfire delve review and it comes in three sets of boxes that are kind of like the the Cat my size a box uh and it has two decks of cards that lay down flat on their backs and it would be wonderful especially because the game is kind of designed with the modularity of pairing them all together if I could reasonably store them all in one box I can't do that and storing them in separate boxes is maddening and it is something that I'm talking about in the review as one of the things that I dislike about this game that I otherwise like quite a bit um and in that regard you know like the the Box the storage solution itself is making a poor experience for taking
out the game and playing it yeah I think that it definitely can I think it can be considered I guess yeah maybe you're you're bringing me around on everything in the Box including the Box itself as being a component I mean am I a component Eric am I a component you're not in the Box okay well and you're not a box I mean I get if unless you are counting all humans as components and you're skin is the box then then no okay and that feels like a very uh not astute way of describing a person the skin is the Box okay okay okay okay so but something like I don't know like something like set of watch where the box is definitely a component I think oh yeah easy easy Mark but things like I don't know I mean in my mind Gloom Haven has a terrible storage solution in the Box you need to go out and buy a different storage solution just to like make it easy to get into and out like get get onto the table right um and with that like are we are is that a strike against the components of Gloom Haven because I think otherwise the Miniatures are really interesting and do a decently good job I think that the different tiles uh do a really reasonable job of showing all of the different environments you're doing battle in right um so I guess I don't know if I would
consider that game to have good components if we're counting the storage solution as well to me I think it it is part of the experience especially you know like how much I'm going to weight it towards the the experience it's going to take a really bad box or really good box for me to talk about that in a review because time needs to be spent on other things especially when we have as concise reviews as we tend to have you know like if we were doing 20 30 minute reviews where we were much more comprehensive and there are amazing channels that do that incredibly successfully then I think it would be worth talking about that and virtually everything but as it is right now it's just not going matter to me that much unless it it does it does in one way or another um but I think the bottom line is you know like I like to see the production values extend to all aspects of the game and when a rule book is really well done it's really important to me when a rule book is a big giant floppy mess that takes up an immense amount of room at the table then it is annoying and I hate it and it lessens the experience of the game Imperium Horizons sorry what was that yeah yeah yeah exactly um so you know you've done uh a decent amount of design work at this point you've considered the aspect
of making games and you've also done a lot of rese Arch on making games how much do you think about like either as you're working on something or uh you're you're considering other games that you're playing um how much the like limitation of production uh weighs into game creation um in my opinion at least when I'm starting out a design I do not consider it whatsoever like I I at that point I there's so much fluidity in everything that I'm doing that there's no reason to even consider oh I don't know if I can make this component work that'll be something I solve later I've never gotten to a point where I even have gotten to the I never gotten to the stage where I need to actually start considering that I think um right I think when I look at other games and like start considering oh I want there are definitely times when I I start wondering oh I wonder why they made the decision to make that component that way um I'm trying to think of an example here
um while you're thinking about it what what kind of functionality when it comes to components like how how gimmicky can compon get and you to still like enjoy them and get Thrills out of them because like I know you love Treasure Island you showed me Treasure Island and you were like check this out and I was like whoa this is Buck Wild I don't know who signed off on this uh but you know I'm here for it I think that if I am full sinned on gimmicky components if they bring something to the game right like there there are a ton of components that there's no there's no reason for them to to exist like that that weird gun in the game that we played I forget the name of that game at this point uh infiltrators infil infiltrators that has a gun for you to point and guess what card your partner not at another player but point at the table Yeah you point at the card in the whole reason the gun exists is for you to say okay I'm making an official guess and it has a stand it's not just a gut it has a stand forgot about the stand it has a stand that is that is just wildly unnecessary but then at the same time I guess on the complete reverse side functionally we don't need the bridges
in White Castle yeah like functionally the that could just be like Bridges painted on the board that you set the dice on like with specific slots but they bring so much to the like it just elevates the game to the point that it the theme feels so much stronger when I think the theme could easily have been weaker without those yeah I I think they provide an elegant amount of um like verticality uh to the game like it makes it pop almost like a picture book which I think works really well with the art style uh and there is is a degree of like cognitive uh intuition that it provides in the step Downs because the uh dice that are in the middle of the bridge are inaccessible whereas the dice on the outside um are acceptable so I actually do think about like the dice sliding over and getting onto the pedestal that's the accessible sides of it and so I I think it does provide something even if it's ultimately unnecessary like it's an aid that sure could they have gotten around it um maybe but at least in White Castle that game is not expensive and they have some really beautiful production in there and you don't have to assemble or disassemble the bridges so they're super easy to you once you
have to assemble them once and I had a tough time cuz I'm bad at following instructions that's true you have to go through the Ikea the cardboard IKEA Assembly of these Bridges see and I love I love Ikea Ikea is a thing that I I I love building my little puzzle piece Furnitures um I don't know what it was I could not I it took me like 30 minutes to assemble the bridges in White Castle it took me much longer than than it had any right to I still love them I do think they're a really solid board game component but I was just seeing that as kind of a counter example of yeah the gun stand and infiltrator um another we mentioned Treasure Island I think those components are really great for what they are because to me a lot of the tension in the game is you can only Circle within the circle that you're given like it's an actual physical piece that you are drawing on the map uh and it leaves a lot of like little places where you're like I don't know if I got if he hid the treasure like three board game inches higher right then I I missed it completely I think that the fact that it is a really physical proof of where you have searched as drawing on the inside of
that Circle uh I think those components are really great for that reason like they they bring a lot to the game in terms of you're searching on a treasure map for for pirates treasure like that is it brings so much of the theme to the game that I just don't that game can't exist without those components right well yeah I I think you know like an important part of this because I mentioned earlier the the visuals and what brings me in um is also recognizing like like your your own boundaries and where uh components can also be like a degree of gatekeeping I guess I mean or or at least you're you're limiting your audience I'm thinking about something like cthulu Wars which Peterson games has its own whole like hellscape as far as delivering on their kickstarters and other things going on but uh talkstar will be another kstar will be a different podcast yeah um but cthulu Wars is a game where the components are so over the top and so opulent that you know like the the coffee mug that I drink from isn't even as big as some of the Miniatures that are in that game and we have a friend John who has the entirety of everything cthulu Wars he
has everything it is so much money for something that functionally could just be smaller more modestly made still beautiful Miniatures and I think this is a a case where I'm I'm not going to disparage people who want that you know play with your toys make your Investments do what you want but I I do wonder if um you know like there there's a degree of like maybe a more modestly made game would have resulted in some more sales and uh maybe more stability for uh the company uh and they wouldn't be in as many Financial wos as they are right now um or maybe one of the driving points that actually made it get the sales is those gigantic Miniatures but those are similar decisions I imagine Publishers have to think about um when they're considering you know what level of opulence they want to provide personally you know when a component crosses is this obscene boundary I can feel it more instinctively than describe it you know that that's the famous you know description of what uh something obscene is uh by the Supreme Court like I can't Define it but I know it when I see it um which isn't a very good definition but you know like components can definitely cross over into a territory where I go like that just isn't worth it you know
like I could buy five games for that amount and you know like especially if the game isn't one of the best games I have ever played we should we should bring your copy of cthulu Wars to PA next year uh and then go by meeple source and just bu meeples and play cthulu Wars with just meeples to piss off all the cthulu war fans okay okay okay first off that's John's copy second off I had don't you oh I I own cthulu Wars Duel which has the cardboard standies instead of the mles which I I think standies are great full art standies especially compared to just completely unpainted um minis I I'm all for it acrylic standies even better but uh when it comes to uh that it's funny because early on in our gaming John and I were both really big fans of Cycles the Bruno catala uh game um really great game just got a new version um but I was much more of the Euro gamer and there was an optional component upgrade that you could buy to change the minis of the game into little wooden meeples and I bought that and boy did John go like oh God this guy um in retrospect I'm also like why did I do
that you know I should have just been fine I didn't need to pay extra to have wooden bits so I can feel like as a superior Euro gamer or something but you know nonetheless that is there um upgrades have you component upgraded any of your games if so
what I don't think so I can tell you right now I have I have I don't think so unless you count I I have uh leaves for Ascension but that's that's it those on that's the only thing that I can even think of I mean I have uh a meeple first player token for wingspan but uh I yeah nothing nothing else I don't really yeah there aren't many times where I'm like man if only this component was better I will spend $20 I really I will say I did at some Point uh when Board Game Geek restocked the terraforming Mars dual aay player board I did consider that but I that even was that was a step too far for me yeah I mean it adds functionality for sure it does but I I've always dived hard into my hobbies and one of the aspects of that has always tried to be creative in how I address my hobbies and in some ways that's going to be uh like creating new custom components for something you know I've done this uh for ages uh and some people express the same sentiment through like making variants for games you know making solo modes or making variant characters or factions that kind of stuff but I I've always loved um 3D printing stuff carving stuff I I love
making uh like little FAQ index cards and stick those with illustrations and illuminations into uh the boxes um and also purchasing upgrades and to a degree I recognize how that is wasteful but uh if it's a game that I'm going to get to the table if it's one of my favorite games then yeah we will consider it um an example is wingspan we have the uh wooden uh food components on that uh to give it a little bit of a pop um for a game like uh let's see uh arcs well arcs I I love the the component upgrades on those the the washed ships are really cool but I do love the stock wood components in that as well so that was a hard call um but uh the terraforming Mars uh the Aries Expedition we have the upgraded metal cubes um cuz I love them I love them yeah I'd consider that too I haven't I haven't but I would consider that it gives a nice weight to things a tactile nature uh and also stops them from like sliding around as much um but you know like I shouldn't have to that's one of those things like I I don't want just like I don't want to buy an expansion that solves a problem
with a game like I don't want to take a bad game and try to bolt-on expansion to fix it I don't want to buy components that solve problems of um the original production you know like uh at at that point that that was a failure on the part of the game um it would have to be an extremely good game that I love everything else about that it's like oh well this elevates it a little bit more but I I tend to look down on retroactive postp purchase uh availability of something to solv a component problem yeah and I I think that's what that and just the fact that it does indeed cost money is kind of what kept me from doing the terraforming Mars player boards but that is something that I would consider because we do play that game a fair amount my wife really loves that game so I could see myself like we would get use out of having a dual layered player board on that have you ever bought a game purely based off of the components like you saw something in it and you were like oh man I have to check that out I think no I typically I'm trying to I'm racking my brain I have another whole bunch of board games in my uh bedroom that probably would be
another just thing for me to look at but no I mean I I don't think of ever looked at a board game and been like just based off of components I'm buying this for the because this component looks cool I'll figure out if I'm going to like the game or not later but just how cool it looks is worth it um I think I usually go mechanics and feel first I typically also don't buy games that I haven't played before right yeah which is smart and something that I recommend to everyone that I can um since getting into uh covering board games um my habits are slightly different in that I'm looking for content right you know I want to look for things that are interesting eye-catching that are unconventional that are a little bit different that make me want to uh talk about something in a different way and so you know like sometimes I will just buy a game either you know because it looks cool or because you know the designer gave me some Pitch about the game you know without actually having played it or known about it or any of that kind of stuff I I'll get it to the table um a a great example of a game where I lusted for it and immediately went out to play it at least uh based off of the components was uh the first time that I saw ethnos um I was at Dice Tower in 2017 and I saw so many people playing this game and it just come out and I was like what is this game I loved
something that people apparently didn't like about the game or a lot of people people didn't like but I loved that I had this very almost like drab matte board but these like technol plastic stacking pieces on top of it gave it such a presence and a look and uh an aesthetic and the fact that you stack the pieces and they become Towers I didn't know is this like a an area control game or or what is this and I saw enough people playing that I was like I don't know what this game is but I need to get to that has it available and I squeezed myself into a game and then immediately as soon as I played it I went off and bought it um but like licensed to Krill we mentioned this earlier um I you know like I I was reached out based off of the kelp review of all things someone was like oh you like stuffed animals I saw your little skit at the beginning uh how do you feel about whales that are also board game boxes and I was like uh I'm not sure it doesn't really s little suit in tie I know right uh and they were like well you know like it it probably is more of like a family style game but I would love to send you a copy anyway and I was like okay great yeah I'll check it out um and I played it and it's totally a a fine game for the context of something you know like it's it's more strategic than Uno it's more you know strategic
than a lot of mass Market game games um it is the only reason why it would stay in my collection is because of the enduring uh uh whale gimmick to the whole thing and that component does elevate it it's not a bad game it's just not a game that I would otherwise want to keep um my son does really like it and so it's probably something that he'll want to keep especially because a lot of his friends um didn't grow up with hobby board games and so anytime he's tried to be like oh yeah I'll teach you how to play Ticket to Ride and his friends are like this is the most complicated thing I've ever heard of and he's like this is for babies um but his friends come over I'm out here playing ARS yeah you got to Le take get a ride oh oh man he had the biggest win in he taught his friends how to play Skull uh and they were dying and he is so excited because he's about to turn 10 he's about to have a bunch of boys spend the night uh and he is going to play skull with all of them and probably like fortnite and Call of Duty and some other crap but are they bet candy do you think yeah I hope so I hope so little gamblers that'd be so cool two of his friends parents are cops so you know we got to be a little careful here got to be a little careful so the carboard be good if you didn't form an
underground candy smuggling ring that that would that information it's probably good for you to not do that yeah they're Juno cops so they're probably okay with the candy issue they probably chill yeah they're chill they're chill um um for the for the audio listeners I do want to point out something I just noticed about the whale uh that it has Kawai eyes oh yes very much it is it is like right now melting your heart uh it is three dots of reflection in its eyes along with its shirt and tie uh very fascinating production um um I think that it's super reasonable to purchase a board game based on how strong the components are I just don't think that I purchase things component first I I will purchase a thing if I enjoy the game and the components swing me like if I was like on the fence and the components are super solid I'll go out my way to get that game then like I think that there are a lot of games where the components being great Elevate the experience but it has to be a solid game already um but I guess you're I mean you're probably in a similar way especially because you and I think both other than games that we're going to be doing reviews on we typically are playing games before I think we buy them for the most part not always but what about
uh what about components are there any games where the components were such a turn off to you because they were not of good enough quality not aesthetically they weren't your preference but you were actually like G this just doesn't feel good um I'll say stardew Valley the board game the components are just feel so lifeless like everything in that game is a cardboard Cube not even like cute like a cardboard tile Square it's got a kind of like obnoxious tray of cardboard squares uh the components of that game are uh on top of the game play itself being like fine at best the components do it no justice like the components are are just so anti the cute theme of sardu valley right um that's a game that I have jotted down as like one of the worst sets sets of components I think the a game that I find cursed at this point is castles of burgundy because I love castles of burgundy as a design it is a brilliant design fantastic two-player game it is one of the games that like dice can be used in such a strategic and tactical way that you know even people who are like I hate games with dice the dice are are wonderful in it but every production of
castles of burgundy has felt like it has been made a worse game because of the components um and I don't know why it keeps on happening now there is the beautiful like super deluxe version but that again is to me the like ultimate in opulence that the game gets in the way of itself you know castles of burgundy should be a light we're going to sit down and play 45 minutes to maybe an hour and a half if we have a full four players game that's easy to get to the table that's one of its selling points is you know it's accessible it's Poppy it's easy but it still feels so strategic and smart and having this intense big production detracts from that ease of the game and kind of makes it a little bit worse of a game the original version the tiles were like barely thicker than paper um and uh were incredibly beige and hard to distinguish what uh the different types of tiles were and then the uh version that Ravensburger came out with a few years ago which we reviewed on this channel um does have a pretty ugly like green and red aesthetic to everything that it it's not just the visual uh like the art style doesn't mesh with me but it feels hard to distinguish elements of the board like
it it's something that uh detracts from the usability of the game and it's like come on man this is Stephen feld's best game there should be a very good production of this that is just elegant and nice and mirrors the the the breeziness of the game itself and it just has not happened yet castles of Tuscany does a far better job than castles of burgundy even if it's not as good of a game shots fired yeah yeah um we have one viewer question that I think we should get to sooner rather than later yes yeah before I just talk about all the Stephan Bel about cast B castles of burgundy will be the next podcast theme you got you got me worked up you got me worked up Eric all right I said nothing the entire time don't put you getting worked up on me I did not me your you're hosting this podcast now anything that I feel during this podcast is a direct fault of yours I just you're in your own head about this my guy I did not bring up castles of burgundy curs cursed all right L this listener question on me the listener question is from Blue SEC Pearl I think is probably how it's pronounced SE q p RL and the question is what themes or concepts would you like board game games to explore in new ways and I got an answer we we need more board games about
merchants and Renaissance Europe yeah Mediterranean trading is you know so few games about that and I just think that we need more yeah castles of burgundy someone should make castles of burgundy um no I I've thought about this uh this is something that maybe unique to me um but I think immigration would be a fascinating thing to uh take on uh as a board game theme either in a modern context uh like infrastructure governmental infrastructure immigration and immigration uh from like a geopolitical system um you could deal with uh things that are more sensitive topics like uh diasporas and refugees and you know like the the forced immigration of certain populations you could deal with some real weight topics with that um you could also just you know look at uh real bureaucratic aspects of immigration and then you could also look at like historic immigration like I I think uh like an anthropologic view of immigration um on a large scale timeline would be an interesting way to do like some sort of Civ development game um instead of Civ development you're kind of like making culture development um that as well has some really sensitive topics uh but every Civ game
pretty much ends up kind of touching on uh some uh some aspect of colonialism um that you know like there's ways to do it uh there there's ways to do it and you could also do it in like a fantasy world with fantasy races you know you could make them cute Forest Critters until people are like oh wait this is an allegory for us is it yeah um the reason why this comes to mind is because uh I was raised by an immigration officer uh I was born overseas uh we were in the Philippines because my dad worked for immigration from uh like the uh embassies uh in um uh Eastern Europe and so uh we lived in the Philippines we lived in uh we lived in New Delhi India for a while uh we traveled to Thailand a bunch we did all kinds of stuff moved over to the US um and in the US I learned about immigration through that being my dad's career you know like took part in a lot of immigrant Community celebrations that we go to on the weekends you know made uh relationships and friendships with uh people of different cultures and communities and I think it's an essential part to the like human experience is the blending of cultures
uh and there are lots of fascinating sometimes dire uh and also sometimes like really altruistic and optimistic aspects to immigration that could be really explored um that I want to see it so there there's my theme there immigration I I'm off my soap boox what do you think Eric what what's your theme or do you have any thoughts on immigration just to comment on immigration I think that that's really interesting yeah me uh here as as the Washington DC correspondent for the cardboard heral podcast it's time for Eric to talk about immigration um I think that it's definitely a theme that I haven't seen really mentioned other than briefly in board games where it's like just a thing that kind of happens to you during a civilization game or it is like the you are colonizing these people and you know what's Buck Wild uh to provide some context of this uh now I'm just waxing poetic and thinking about my my dad my childhood and stuff um my dad would almost always come in and do a presentation at a classroom about like you know what is immigration as soon as a teacher was like oh your dad works for immigration great we'll do a topic on this um and so I got to hear him like fourth fifth and sixth grade uh repeatedly talk to kids and be like you know what
immigration is how many of you have seen An American Tale uh and how many of you have seen uh uh Men In Black that was his touchstones for uh immigration for fourth fifth and sixth graders was fival of American Tale and the like Russian Jewish mice immigrants into the United States looking for a better land and then also the policing of immigrant aliens from outer space who are coming to our world and hopefully um you know you're you're managing that to make sure that it's a welcoming and uplifting Community but also keeping out the giant cockroach monsters I just think the giant cockroach monsters did nothing wrong I just they more Su stand on yeah um yeah I mean I think that that's I can't think of a board game that I feel like really does that theme and concept Justice um the one like Jack I was not prepared for this int of immigration discuss I should have gone first I think mine's Sports I love it no Sports definitely should have more uh presence Sports I just feel like I haven't ever seen a sports board game that gets it right and it's probably because you're it's so tough to make the mathematic Concepts behind Sports work in a board game and
there's like management games that do it reasonably well like basket boss I think is a pretty fun like you're managing a basketball team game but there isn't a game where it's like oh and I'm saying this with I have not played there's a game called baseball highlights 2049 that I've I've been interested in I have not ever been able to get my hands on um that simulates like the last inning of a Android baseball league I'm pretty sure that's that's the the the gist behind it but like there are so few games where it's like there's no game that I think really properly emulates uh baseball game or football game or hockey in a way that makes me feel like oh this really Nails this theme probably the most successful is maybe uh Within These circles uh I got to imagine is bloodb and not the bloodb team manager but the proper you know has been running for 30 years blood bll playing you know football with your Warhammer Miniatures I had a friend who was way way way deep into bloodb um tried recruiting me several times played a few times with him but it it was never something that really stuck with me but people are passionate about their blood bow yeah that's fair and I not played bloodb so that's another one that I I can't say that I know for sure and maybe that's
maybe that's what I need to get into like maybe I need to to do that there's undoubtedly a community there in DC we could put these two things together mhm where it's getting getting players from overseas and outside America in to be to play to play our sport yeah yeah I I think that makes sense I mean a lot of uh America's tolerance to immigrants may be based off of like celebrity culture you know like you just get a really good hitter in baseball and then social justice follows it it it is amazing how how much people can rally around baseball players that are like oh yeah this is yeah a Big Poppy represents all of the Dominican Republic that is the only fact I know about the Dominican Republic is Big Poppy is from there and therefore everything about the Dominican Republic is about that there are a number of baseball people that I've I've been at games with and been like oh yeah I know everything there is to know about this this small nation like small in the grand scheme of things uh in terms of we are in Florida as a giant State yeah uh you're in Alaska I think we need a Challengers board game uh so not a tennis board game
where you're playing tennis but a tennis board game where you're trying to navigate the Romantic triangle uh between yourself and two best friend tennis players how about that I would be Zena mhm in this scenario I'm here it yeah I kind of want to be one of the one of the gay guys yeah that would be nice mhm I haven't seen the movie it you're okay don't okay I heard it's good I heard it's good it's it's it's fine I want it better after call me by your name but I think it's fine the soundtrack's kind of in your face in a way that I didn't think was good and oh okay what is our film podcast going to be called yeah we need to have a film podcast I'm a huge film fan Eric is a big film fan huge film fan I only say big because I was going to follow that up with and has worked uh previously in the film industry and done like uh you know actual film school stuff whereas I'm entirely just you know like a geek about it and wish that uh uh I had at one point and then through cautionary tales uh perhaps a bullet by not film industry but yeah we could talk movies all the time we could talk about games about running movie theaters would be cool too that would be a great theme yeah well there there are a couple that
I need to try there was one that like the very first conversation we had when I went to your house to buy Imperium Classics and legends from you yeah yeah uh where we I mentioned that I was into I just came from the film industry and you're like you got to play this game and I had never heard of it before and I still don't know what it is something or um I can't remember what it is I imagine based off of the time frame I do recall an interview this is horrible this is horrible I've interviewed so many people for the cardboard Herald um but there was someone that uh was making a game about making movies and I remember interviewing them uh and they were some filmmaker uh who was turned board game designer I know I interviewed them I can't remember what that game is I hope it was good uh I just do just want to point out I did just Google the Silver Screen Herold and that is free oh okay love it all right I I think we're digressing uh to to a certain point here we've entered An American Tail Spin yes oh man oh man I feel good about that one thank you for joining me for this conversation Jack um thank you to the audience for listening us talk about uh America Tale in men and black uh and how that relates to immigration and also sports games uh if you have any listener
questions that that you want to start putting us down a random path to end the podcast on uh please feel free to comment them on the YouTube video or on Spotify you can comment on Spotify now we will be checking that or feel free to email us at cardboard Herald gmail.com uh you can find this podcast on all of the major platforms at this point um so feel free to find it on YouTube if you want the video aspect or Spotify Apple podcast I think anywhere you you find podcasts we should be on at this point for the most part we're there in your face holes of All Sorts yeah uh thank you for listening thank you for tuning in I have been Eric along here with Jack with the cardboard Herald podcast thank you so much for listening and have a good rest of your day bye