Skip to main content
Loading video...

All 14 Stonemaier Games Ranked From Worst to Best

Transcript 42:19

welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and today we are talking about stonemire games and we are going to rank all of them all 14 games that stonemeyer has released so far going from the worst to the best and we do like all of the games so even the ones at the bottom of the list oh no I say we would still we still we do we do they're they're all good but there's got to be a bottom that is true and we are kind of basing it on the best experience of each game so if it means that we've played it with the expansion that is going to include the expansion and we can talk about when that's the case yeah all of these are like for from our experience best possible player count best possible everything thrown into the box uh and that is usually how we play these but let's just let's just get rolling and let's start it off with number 14.

first up we're gonna talk about smitten and smitten is a super simple 18 card it's one of these like tiny Deck card games and it was made for the 10th anniversary or at least it was given away in the 10th anniversary so it almost feels a little unfair to put it here and it is it is a decent experience but it's just a just a smaller experience and that's what it's made to be but what the game is is you've got you got 18 cards so you got two grids of cards and this is a co-op or solo game and you're just trying to put the cards in numbers one to three four to six seven and nine on each side and make a perfect grid and when you make a grid you make this nice little art piece and all the Arts done by Vincent dutrate and it's just a matter of you take turns all though you don't even need to necessarily take turns of playing a card and then that card tells the other person what sort of card they can play so either in this Grid or in this Grid or higher or lower whatever the rule might be and you just gotta get the card cards in the grids and it is weirdly difficult because the trick is you can't just put it anywhere in the grid it has to touch orthogonally adjacent to an existing card and you've got to follow the instruction that's listed on the card so it's those that give it that extra challenge because I think the first time we played it we just lucked out with the cards and we did it super easily and we're like oh I don't think it's that hard then we lost like the three after that because it is a fun little Challenge and it's definitely one of those that you'll play like four or five times in a row because it it takes

like three minutes to play through a game of it and it but it really is one where you know you fail and you fail and you're fail and you're like we can do this we can do this and then you finally get it and it's really exciting uh but it's it's interesting that's trickier than it should be because you just got to be adjacent in a nine card grid that should be easy it's not that easy and I do like the picture it makes at the end because each card is a little nod to other stonemeyer games uh which is really fun too yeah which is the thing Stone Meyer loves to do they got that shared like MCU two of stonemeyer but that is our number 14. next up is one that we were first and the trick with this one is it's a real time game so it's work replacement but it's all based on timers and there's just three different timers that have different amounts of time so you really gotta place your workers just right that when the timer flips they're in position to do their action but then they're also locked so at first when we played it it was a very stressful experience because you're frantically trying to look at what all the actions mean and get them just in position and then your opponent is also trying to move the timer and so sometimes you're just about to get them there but your opponent gets the timer there first so I I got quite stressed I would say in our in our first few plays but when we played it more more recently having played it a few times already it felt a lot better being more familiar I think with just what each of the spaces do

yeah it's an interesting game because you feel like at first you see the timers and you think oh boy we're going to be going fast fast fast fast fast but it's actually surprisingly like a lot of time of just kind of waiting and looking and just trying to quickly think okay what's going to be my next thing and then that timer is going to move here then I got to do this and this and this um so it's it's interesting the pace of the game but yeah I think I think you're understating it by saying we were iffy about it off the top but I think it's got probably a little more to it than people think yeah and we did try it without the timer element it doesn't work that way because I thought that would make it less stressful for me but the part of what makes the game so unique and enjoyable is that timer element and last game I really liked being able to kind of put a worker in a timer that had a longer spot that I couldn't afford the action to knowing I'd be able to get the action later because you have a decent chunk of time to be able to perform it so it is fun to do those decisions on the fly so it's one that we've warmed up a lot more too yeah it's not this is not for everyone though if you're thinking oh it's not for me it's probably not if you're thinking yeah give that a go then maybe but yeah it's and and like you said it it does not work without those timers it falls very flat it's just kind of a simple work replacement game but the timers it is interesting and it's different from anything else that we've got so it's got that going for it and that was our number 13.

and number 12 is between two cities and between two cities it's got this interesting kind of Cooperative it's like a semi Co-op game well it's really a co-op game but it's Co-op game where you're playing on two teams at once so you're building a city with people on either side of you thus you are between two cities and each turn all of you are playing one tile so each City gets two tiles added to it and you're just kind of conversing with each of these people and trying to work best on each of these cities and each of the kinds of tiles there's like six different tiles all have like a different scoring system and then more with the expansion and like like you said we're we're talking about all these in the best situation and really the expansion capitals and you've got these boards that start you off that give you like a little bit of landscape adds a lot to the game as well it's weird how much that adds yeah because we did like it at first but we liked it way better with it and it is just that landscape tile but it makes your city connect and slightly different ways as well but we will say that even though that's how it's meant to be played of building the two with your neighbors is we primarily play as two players and we really like the two player version and so there's a few different suggestions on ways to play with two players there's like five different ways to play it yeah and the way that we like best is when you're you're building two cities at once so you're each building your own two cities there's no shared City there's no um AI City and so you draft

two tiles and you have to decide which city each of those tiles go in and then that's it and then the winner is the person who uh has the highest of their lowest scores between the two cities and it's just it's fun to build your city and to draft your tiles and you can even with the expansion kind of accidentally compete with yourself for some of the goals that come out I always do yeah it's weird because this is totally built on that it's called between two cities it's built around that and we way prefer it without that we chucked that out of the window the whole main premise of the game and way way way prefer it just making those two cities I don't know maybe we're just both selfish we just want to do it all ourselves we can't share with other people if you did like it when we played with other folks though yeah I really like building things together so I enjoyed having two neighbors and working on the cities and we we still do build two cities so there is at least that challenge of trying to maximize both your points because only the lowest one scores I think we tried it with one of the ways where you're only building one of your own and doing another shared one and we didn't like that one as much so we kind of are still doing between two cities yeah a little bit but yeah it's it's one it's just super fun super quick you can play a game in 20 minutes and we're suckers for that sort of thing sometimes so it is a solid one and that is number 12.

number 11 is Red Rising and in Red Rising you're trying to get the best hand of cards by the end of the game and there's a few other little tracks that you're get you a few points here and there but mainly it's to find the right combination and you do that by being able to play cards and you get to do the power listed on the card and then also then get any of the cards that are available in any of the other locations so you're trying to maximize what cards you play for their powers which also tend to be the ones that are worth the most points at the end so as soon as you put it down you're likely not going to be able to get it back again to end up with the best combo at the end and one of the draws for us is that we had read the the red rising book series in anticipation of the game arriving and even though it's not like replicating the book series it uses characters from the books and that's been a huge draw for us I think I've just now realized why I lose this all the time because you just said the the cards are your main points and I don't think I've ever played that way I'm always trying to get because you got like three kind of gay men triggers so you're trying to collect up um you're trying to mine helium from like the mines it's just collecting these Little Gems and you're trying to move up this track which is meant to be like your Fleet power and then you've got um this other thing where you're like collecting up cubes it is cards first and then you got the other things that are going on but those other things are fun and interesting yeah and the cards

first are what I think give the best nods to the books because their scoring is often very reminiscent of the characters want to be with each other that want to be with each other in the books or don't want to be with each other they lose points if again they're enemies in the books as well so that's where having that that Insider knowledge helps one tricky with this though is it is I think a better game with more players when you've got just two players you can end up we've got games where there's like one card left in that main thing so one of the things you're doing is is banishing cards as well there's not a lot that brings cards out so it can get a smidge tail generally we like it too yeah but for a lot of people I think I think kind of the the general consensus is this is a better game it more players it kind of four-ish is like The Sweet Spot yeah we haven't had much of an opportunity to play at higher player counts uh but that's our number 11.

our number 10 is my little scythe and my little side is actually the most recent one that we've got this is the last one we got and it was almost because I was like hey you know we got like 13 out of the 14 stonemire games we may as well just get the last one uh but I wasn't sure about it because it looks like such a just like a little kid version of size so I wasn't sure how it would work for us turns out we really like it it is shocking how good this game is for adults and we played with some friends too and I don't think they were sure and then they were like we really like that we will play that again for sure because it's it's Scythe but it takes out like the top bottom part of the board it takes out moving those cubes it takes out um any of the resource management or kind of the resource management and it still works it still has the fighting although it's a pie fight in this case and then you're trying to make friends and you're trying to make make pies and you're trying to collect up gems and hearts and take them to the castle but it it works surprisingly well as just like a simplified version of scython I think if you took out the cartoonyness and this was just sold with like Scythe art and side didn't exist I think people would still really like this game yeah I do agree although we we appreciate the cartoons we don't mind the kids came because we really like that look so that is not a deterrent at all for us but it is really simple

because your pawns just like Scythe you just move your Pawn to the action space and then you do the action the actions are super super simple but what is nice is there is the opportunity to upgrade those actions and so everyone has slightly different powers in terms of how they can move or how they can like transform resources as well but I I do love the Friendship track and that's instead of the popularity track of of scythe and it is interesting when you play with more players everyone's being so generous like oh yeah here I'll give this to you and I'll give this to you until then across that threshold and they get that that reward or that's it's still a star in mind yeah yeah they get the star for it and then they're like okay all bets are off you are not getting a single thing from me so it has this really nice like shift I think halfway through the game or it's a trophy not a star yeah that's it in this one and it's just super fast you fly through it's like playing a game of size and Hyper Speed which I appreciate too yeah and we like the my little pie expansion yeah Pie in the Sky High oh yeah that's it Pie in the Sky because it it is it is quite simple and so just having the addition of the Airship which is just one communal Airship as opposed to it being belonging to each faction it actually makes enough of a difference that it's just this little extra that that upset a bit more in a necessary way I think and I actually prefer how my little side uses the Airship to help Scythe uses the airships I actually like it way better it's the shared Airship

and everyone has a different Airship power uh it's really interesting and like a faction specific power too I do like the premise of how it got started too of it being like a My Little Pony side version that this guy made for his daughter and then a stonemeyer games being like yeah sure let's do it let's let's turn it into it and so that is our number 10 my little side number nine is charterstone and charterstone is a legacy work replacement game and so you start off in this very kind of barren land with very basic buildings and then each game as you progress you are building to your terrain but you always have access to everybody's buildings you just might get bonuses if people go on your spaces and we can't really say too much about it because it being because it's a legacy and new things getting added in but I do like all the stuff that gets added in I feel like each game there is this nice little addition that gets uh put into it and we really enjoyed playing through the Legacy part of it yeah yeah it was it was at first we were like I don't know and I've heard mixed things I know people have had mixed experiences with this and I wonder if part of the reason we liked it so much is we played through two players which I wouldn't recommend if you're just doing one faction each but because we did two factions each we didn't have all our eggs in one basket and often I found that one of them I was I was killing with I was wrecking shopping the other one was just terrible

we both had that we had like two that were really strong and two that like we're just guardful yeah Clay my clay the bricklayer sorry clay but you're the worst uh but I think I think that made it really interesting for us being able to do those two different ones at once and the story surprisingly it's like it's like weirdly dark at times like surprisingly I don't want to give anything away but sometimes I was like wait what what just what did that King just say um so it's it's interesting and has some interesting surprises some cool surprises I'd say too but it is at its heart of fairly simple Resource Management game so you just you got to be ready for that that's what it is that's what it promises to be that's what it is so as long as you're cool with that it is a pretty cool game and play play two factions each one is not enough and it does come with the caveat that there is a way to play it at the but that's just that experience isn't nowhere near as good as when you're in the middle of the campaign the campaign experience is a much stronger one but it is good that there is a recharge pack so you can just flip the board by the recharge pack and then play through it again but still a pretty solid game and that was our number nine number eight is libertalia Winds of Gale Crest and so this is not originally a stone Mark and this is a remake of an older game it's by Paulo Mori um it's an

excellent game and but I I like the Remake a lot more and I know some folks still like the original that you know it was a little bit meaner it's got some different art um but I love the art in the new one and I just I think it it adds a lot more to what was already a pretty solid game and libertalia is a pretty simple game everyone's got the same cards in their hand which is already kind of an interesting thing so you know what everyone else is holding you start the game with the same six cards each turn everyone plays a card whoever plays the highest card puts it at the end you do all their powers you pick up some stuff you put them on your ship there's not a good explanation but you kind of get the gist and then each round you're picking up six new cards and depending on which cards you played the first time all of a sudden your hands a little bit different and it gets a little interesting you do three of these voyages and then you see who wins at the end but the cool thing with the Remake is it's got two sides of the board one that's a bit more take that one that's a little bit more friendly oh it's not that take that and it's got so many it's got a few extra cards in your hand as well so you're only using like 18 out of the 40 cards in the deck each time so it really changes up and it's got a two player mode which while it's not as good as the multiplayer mode is surprisingly good because I don't think the original can play at two players I don't think so but this one does and we do like we said we mainly play two players and even though we do prefer this at more we will still play libertalia uh at two players

because we do like it a lot as well and I think one of the interesting things with the new version is that reputation track because everybody has the same starting set of cards and adds the same ones each rounds ties are incredibly likely it's often that like more than one player will choose to play the exact same card so having that reputation track in there is a great way to be able to break the ties and just a lot of interesting interactive card play and you know sometimes getting rid of other people's cards making them walk the plank and taking ones back from your graveyard and all these cool things yeah it's it's it's a fun time but that is our number eight libertalia our number seven is Euphoria and it is a a dice placement game but what we really like about it is it takes place in a dystopian society and so the PIP values of your dice represent their their knowledge level so it is an interesting mechanic of making sure that as a collective whole your dice aren't too knowledgeable or else or else they know the society is corrupt and they leave so you lose the workers um but we really just like the the way everything is connected because there's all these again you're just collecting resources but then you're trading those resources in for the markets and again thinking about the best experience we would definitely recommend having the

expansion because those markets are are very punishing for people who didn't contribute to the building of them but in the expansion it makes it way more than just punishing bad dice rolls yeah in the original game most of the markets seem to be when your dice is blah blah blah blah blah when you roll it here then you lose this and in the new one they're they're just they're a lot more creative it's a lot more interesting I can't think of any examples but but they but they are definitely more interesting and and they've got terrific names too they've got terrific names in both but the other thing that the expansion adds that I think is even more important especially for us is it adds a really good Ai and it actually has two Bots that you play at the same time with the same card and that makes it the the original is not really viable as a two-player game with the Bots it's an excellent two-player game it's maybe my favorite bots in any game in just about any game maybe guy a project just Pips it but it's the same person who made both if you don't need the Bots and you're playing at three or four I'd still get the expansion because of the markets like you said but it whatever whatever player count that you've got I I think it is such an interest game this is one that was a little bit higher on my list I know than your list and I'm just a sucker for like the aesthetic I love how the dice look it's got these really cool custom Dice and I think I think a big part for me is

just I I I love I love dystopian yeah the the theme is definitely a huge draw even even though it is like just dice replacing out it really does a good job of kind of capturing that feel but if you are two players only and you really hate using Bots um then this one may not be for you but like you said the Bots are very very easy so as long as you're okay just like putting them out it is it is totally worth it and that is our number seven euphoria

our number six is actually I think the stoneware game we've maybe played the most and that is rolling Realms and a big part of that is it's it's a quick game it's a very travelable and it's just a simple rolling right and I actually started playing this this was originally made um it's a free game during the pandemic and it was just like an online like PDF that you got and played it and it changed each time and I got really into it and then I was excited when it was coming out but I was like I don't know how they're gonna do it how they're going to change it all and uh and they did it with writable cards and it's such a smart idea and I was gonna say I don't know why it wasn't done before but it was with silver and gold which is one of my absolute favorite rolling rights but this isn't too far behind for me the other interesting thing well just to explain what the game is is each time you've got three different cards both players have the same three cards and then they interact in different ways you roll two dice you roll those two numbers on the cards and they all do different things I do not have time to explain all of it it but uh the that expandability of it I think has really been the thing that's made it so interesting because it's not only that stonemeyer universe but they've also started to bring in stuff like there's an arcanova one now A Feast for Odin there's honey Terra mystica there's all of these interesting other games that we also like and it's just cool to see that you know building out the board game Community too within this game and it definitely I'll so it's replayability

because you are always working with with three cards and then each round you bring out three more cards so it's the interplay and interaction of those three cards that does make such a difference and so by having it a larger selection of cards to draw from then there are odds of seeing the same three cards show up in a combination the more you add is just going to be fewer and so seeing how they work together is part of the fun Challenge and part of why we played it so much is because we haven't yet even though we played it tons and tons experienced every single possible combination and I'm I'm really excited because I've seen like uh Jamie put up a whole bunch of like new cards and and I'm really Keen to check those out so it is one that we're we're just gonna keep playing um and they're not I'm going to be straight they're not all winners uh some of them work better than other ones we're definitely we love the Feast for Odin one that's probably my favorite of the expansion ones yeah the expansion ones it probably is and we're struggling with the libertalia one and the nice thing about it it's okay if some of them are really hard because you have the exact same cards yeah so I'm sometimes like oh no I only got like one star two stars on this card uh oh but then I look over and I see that I've got half a star yeah you've only got that you've got one as well because it's a hard one so it ends up working out just fine like that and so that is our number six rolling realms number five is wingspan which is one of the the best selling current learn board games out there and we talk about what the best experience is for it

and for me I really like the Oceania or Oceana Oceania Oceania ocean yeah expansion uh because it adds it balances out kind of the egg strategy a little bit more and it adds nectar which I think works really well so I I do like that one and combined again because we mainly play two players with the new wingspan Asia duet mode because having that shared uh board with being able to put the tokens out makes your decisions of what birds to play and which habitats a little bit more interesting as well yeah it does those those two and those two combined especially too does does make it a more interesting experience but this is one I gotta say in this this whole list is as we both made our own list and then we smooshed them together and we saw where they averaged out and this was a lot higher for Jess than it was for me I just I like I like this game I appreciate it I understand why it is so popular I haven't quite been able to get as into it as as you have yeah and I I think a big part is probably the theme I really like like collecting the right type of food items for the birds that you know there's that it's actually what they would probably eat and putting them in the right habitats and it's just it's it's beautiful I really like the birdhouse and and the boards as well are really lovely especially the the new boards look really great too I just I I

can't get I can't get that into Birds I've just never been that interested in Birds other than like they've got like three in there that are baseball team logos that go for those right away but I do wonder if this game had a different theme I know someone on BGG made a Pokemon one and I would play the heck out of that Pokemon but it's just something where it hasn't quite connected but at the same time I I can totally see the appeal of this and I think it is just a terrific Gateway game and like an ambassador of modern board games obviously because it's sold I don't know how many millions of copies so they're doing something right with it yeah and even though the theme doesn't quite connect with you I think it has brought a lot of people into the hobby who really just kind of associate modern board games as being really dry really big yeah a lot of farming and so I like I know a bunch of people who hadn't really played many and then played wingspan have been like whoa what is this world so like you said it's a great Ambassador it brings a lot of people in and it is our number five our number four is tapestry and I think there are a few stonemeyer games that are a little bit divisive but perhaps none more divisive than tapestry tapestry really seems to be a love it or hated game but tapestry is an abstracted Civ building game in which you're moving cubes around a track and around four

different tracks with the expansion five different tracks and as you move those around the tracks you're getting different stuff and you're getting buildings you're putting buildings onto your capital city is this other kind of like mini game you're doing on your own board um and you've got like this little Resource Management thing going on and you got this area control thing going on in the middle of the board too and it's a whole bunch of different things but there's a few things that I think some folks find tricky first of all one of the real huge pluses is you've got these cool really different asymmetrical civilizations they're very very asymmetrical they can feel a little bit broken they've done a lot to balance them there's a lot of stuff that balances them but they can feel almost too asymmetrical at times and the other thing is this is a two-player only game do not play this game with more than two players but if you play this at two players specifically and if you're not so focused on can I beat the other person's score but focused on what's the most I can do with my thing I think it's a really cool experience and I think that's the trick and a little bit of a different mindset because normally when you are playing against one other person it is about can can I beat them can I get the better score but we track all of our plays we track which civilization we are and so we're able to almost do a comparison of oh how did you do with this civilization when you were them a few games ago and kind of compare it more that way and just push because we're always aiming for that like over 300 score which means you've had a really good game and trying to find

those combos and hope like the right tapestry hard and the right thing at the right time can get you to go just a little bit longer but I I know some people who do play it maybe at three I think the tricky is because you could be at different rounds is some if someone's done they could be sitting there not participating for a while for a while and so the more place you add to that the more likely that's going to happen the more people will be sitting out which any times one of us has finished way earlier than the other it's kind of been a sad finish for the other person yeah of like oh I really want to keep trying because I really want to see what high score I can get but this is kind of boring because you're just waiting for me to finish up because I try and get through it as well but we really like that challenge we really like like staring at the options and then finding oh if I do this and that lets me put a tile out which gives me the resource that I then need to do that and seeing those opportunities but we have light both expansions um the plans employs ones adds a lot more civilizations which is the Crux of what keeps us coming back to the game is is wanting to try a new civilization and then the arts and architecture one adds the really interesting Arts track and that's been really fun addition because it does mix up a bit we used to kind of get in the same path of doing things and having that additional option has helped us just try different routes yeah if you're going to get one of the two the arts and architecture I think is definitely the way to go but both are are still interesting but that is our number four tapestry

tapestry our number three is between two castles and this is very much a representation of our favorite stonemeyer games because in theory between two castles plays a little bit like between two cities where you're building a castle with a person on your left and the person on your right drafting tiles but there's some really interesting scoring conditions each of the rooms almost scores individually but within a specific type of way depending on the color of the tile but again because we mainly play two players we really really like this as a two-player game and again there's a few different ways you can play as two players and how we play it is we are just building our own castle just one single Castle but when we draft two tiles we take one for ourselves and we have to give the opponent one and so you're always trying to give them a tile that's not going to help them and then it's that fun challenge of having to see what you get and make the most of it and there are times when like you've got the most points from some of the tiles that I've given you because you've managed to like make it work for whatever you're doing as well yeah and when we say that we mostly play this with two players we played this like 50 times we've played it in more than two players once yeah yeah so we really just play this in two players and it's a fantastic two-player game it I think has flown under the radar so much and really only if you play that variant there's other variants

too but I think for what it it's meant to be is this Mad King Ludwig the idea of every turn having one tile you do not want that does not fit your Castle perfectly fits that theme because you end up with the craziest castle and you just got to make the most out of whatever it is that you get and it makes this really interesting the like the Tableau you've got at the end the castle that you've built is super fun because all the rooms are crazy and we do this thing where a lot of folks don't love the scoring in this because it can take the scoring honestly it can take like half as long as it takes to play the game there's a lot of different scoring conditions and you got to look at each room individually but we kind of make that part of the game where we walk through and we talk about each room we talk about our castle and it's really fun and we've gotten quick at it too but as a two-player game this is like our number one Comfort game it is one like you said we probably played it 50 times it is when if we're not really feeling like bringing out a game and having to relearn the rules this is one of our go-to's and and like you said the joy is those interesting rooms because we love talking about like the Scythe room and the pig pen and like all of these different places and that is part of how we describe it of is that your cute kitten room is right above like the basement pit that is in your Castle we really like the expansion secrets and soirees as well I don't think it's necessary but it does add a couple interesting elements like the activity

rooms which want to be surrounded except for not touching a specific type of tile and then I can't remember the Wild Card rooms that turn into a specific room depending on where the arrow is facing yeah they turn into whatever they point at as well so you can really make these cool combos with it too and that is our number three between two castles of Mad King Ludwig number two is scythe and Scythe is very much a kind of mishmash of all different sorts of stuff and this did make it a little bit of a little bit contentious at first because this looks like you know you got all these robots you got this stuff going on on this crazy like European dystopic map and you think oh boy this is gonna fight all over the place but it is very much a Euro Resource Management game that's got a little bit of fighting this is much more terror mystica than it is Ruth but it does still have that area control part to it as well and it's got that really interesting scoring system of you've got all these different goals and you don't have to do all of them you only have to do a few of them I think five is a five and six six so you got to do six of these different goals and whoever gets the sixth verse that's it you win game over and that makes for such an interesting play style because you can you can do that in really different ways like if you do want to make this a fighty game that's two of your stars right there but if you you just want to chill out and do the farming and do some goals you can totally get stars that way

too so that is really cool and I think the expansions added a lot to it as well yeah the extensions do add a lot but I think one of the interesting things is even with the base game one of the strengths is the asymmetry between the factions so each of the factions right out of the gate plays very differently and then on top of that is you or your action board is all going to be different as well so you get Delta random action board and that dictates what you can do at the top and you can usually always do the thing at the top and then you can do the thing at the bottom if you can pay the resources so what we really enjoyed exploring was that combination of just trying to figure out the best resource management and economy and how all of that would work together given a faction and given a specific type of action board and then the expansions have added in more action boards more factions and all depending on what expand action routes you've gone down but one of our our favorite expansions is the the rise of Fenris yeah rise of Fenris is so interesting and I don't know another game that's really done this where it added a campaign but it's not just like lip service of a campaign like it's a real legit campaign and a really interesting campaign game and everything's hidden in these little boxes and you're opening up the boxes and you're getting really cool stuff and some cool surprises in there and you end up with like modules that you can reuse in the game a lot of the stuff well I think all of this stuff really you can use in the game

afterwards and so it's like you're getting this expansion but you're kind of getting Dr vetted in this really fun and interesting way and that did make the game really cool for us for two players as well because this is one that does not shine at two players yeah we played through the whole campaign with just two players and really liked it we started again like the next day yeah absolutely and we tried to play through it again and then we also played through it with with four players and it probably does shine at a higher player account I'm not a huge fan of combat and people getting in my way so I I don't love games that have that in it and you're gonna have more of that but also it is a bit of an essential part of the game too so but we still bring it out and play with two players though it's not something that we refuse to play with fewer than three it is still real it's it's it's a really fun game and it's great if if you're playing um with people it kind of an even level this is a real tight interesting game and that is our number two scythe our number one is viticulture and viticulture has really grown on us I think it's one that I just keep liking more and more the more we've played it and it has helped that we've added things to it what I love about the base game is it's a work replacement but the actions just make so much sense because it all ties into the wine making process and the way the components are with the beads that go on the grapes that then get like actually turned into the wine

all of that works so well because you it's intuitive you're like yeah that makes sense I got a plant then I've got to like sew them and and crush them whatever it might be but when we added Tuscany I think both of us preferred it much more yeah it makes it a much better especially a better two-player game um the tricky is with the base game there doesn't feel like as many ways to get points or to make wine like you really have to do that process and whoever's going first can really take those spots so waking up in the morning like the early bird really gets the worm in the original game but with Tuscany it gives you all these different Avenues and I think it takes what's already a very good game and it makes it into just a terrific game yeah I think when we kind of realize the possible potentials of those orange structure cards as well because that can sometimes give you an amazing action that's just on your own board that really helped but what I think pushed this really to the number one spot is viticulture world yes viticulture World adds a Cooperative mode and a really challenging and interesting Cooperative mode I think we've only beaten two or three and there's seven

um and all of those play play differently and quite a bit differently and it's just a really challenging mode where you're both making wine or not even necessarily making wine you're trying to score points and you're kind of running like a wine making company and it's just really interesting and really challenging and I I can feel that scope change like now I don't have this one Vineyard I'm running this whole well I'm with my team running this whole wine making business and I I think what's what's very interesting is we mentioned before that viticulture is really a tight worker placement spot like even at Tuscany they're you still at testing at two players you still feel that tightness but it's a little bit looser which is great and so what's interesting with the viticulture world and making it Cooperative is having to work together and figure it out and be like I really really have to make sure I'm planting this season like okay you go to the planting spot I'll go somewhere else or like we get to expand this one spot so as many of us can go which one is it that we're both going to be wanting to use all the time it feels like a different game almost even though it uses the exact same Principle as the regular competitive version you got to get creative with some of the paths that you take because you're just gonna you're just gonna eke out those goals like if you win it you're gonna win it on the last turn with your last play which is real exciting like that's that's how you want a co-op game to work I think and so whether whether it's viticulture world or even essential

Edition or essential decision with Tuscany we really enjoy viticulture and that is our number one spot and that is it that is everything Stone Myers put out as of right now all 14 games rank from worst to beston generally we do tend to like their games they tend to be well produced they tend to do something a little bit different they tend to not be too mean but you know not all games are created equal so there are some that we like more than others and it is very subjective so that was our list but we would love to see your list or if you've just played some of them which ones are your favorites and we'd love to hear from like if if you like pendulum the best let us know why let us know why we should like it even more and as usual please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you for the next one foreign

Progress saved