Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 20:18

thank you this video is sponsored by game Toppers turn your own kitchen or dining room table into a premium portable game solution at a fraction of the cost hey everybody uh welcome to kind of an intermission video in my what happened to Series so I've been going through all the most anticipated lists on Board Game Geek starting with 2010 I'm up to 2014. we're going to go all the way to 2019. so I'm halfway through the list and I thought uh and I mentioned this the last couple of videos that I will go through and kind of take a kind of a general step back and look at them because I've been looking at them like individually in each of the games on the list and kind of talking about them here and there but I want to kind of just take a little step back talk about some Trends or some general thoughts that we've seen with these lists because the lists I think are important which I have not even talked about yet because it shows what at least the folks on board game geek are interested in so you know not knowing anything else really about the game other than like the designer the publisher the theme you know maybe some inkling about the mechanics you know what would get what gets people excited and I thought that was kind of an interesting thing because it's more of a reflection of what's become before because I'm anticipating you know something coming out in 2023 what happens but why am I anticipating it because of stuff that comes before because this is either looks like something really different and new or it looks like it's more of the same or it has a designer I

like or it has a publisher I like or there's something about it that all of my past references are helping inform my anticipation right so whether it's different or the same it's you're still being informed by that so one thing I want to mention before we cover a couple of notes to go through but I still have glory to roam and I still have uh urban sprawl uh and from those first five years of anticipated lists so out of those roughly 60 games or so um no more than that roughly well because there's some repeats so let's say 80 to 90 games um I have two out of those anticipated lists out of all those five years so I don't know what that means exactly but that's just you know just a data point so I'd be curious you know how many games do you have you know from those those lists there uh so one thing to note is I it to kind of this to this point is how long does the game really really last um because and I would use this example um Forbidden Island uh I really love that game I don't own it anymore it's a great little solo game great with the family I've played it with the gamer group too it's a nice quick fillery type of game but it has a lot of good you know head scratching decision making that exists in the game but I played it I've lost count not 50 times but close like you know at least 30 40 times in there somewhere I played a lot and I don't need to play it anymore and

how much do I need to play a game to have gotten my worth out of it or whatever I'm not talking about dollar amount either it's like you know and I started thinking a lot of people really hold on to games and I see that and I do not now granted I get sent a lot of stuff for free and so I have a limited storage capacity to hold the game so I can't just have a pile of junk off to the side because that's disrespectful to the game first of all in a way and so better to let it move on to somebody else and they can enjoy it and they can pass it on to somebody else as well um and so I wonder like do these games really really last or and I'm not trying to like cycle analyze like the general people in the hobby but I think a lot of times people hold on to things in a way that's like clutter you know in a way and even what I've got here and I I you know I trim stuff pretty constantly I get I get Guff about it with my group they're like wasn't it on your top 10 list like two years ago I'm like yeah I don't have room leave me alone you know and it's like and it's also like I am not a very sentimental person and so I'm like very much like bi you know like it's I'm really no disrespect to the game or you know I didn't like enjoy this game any less I don't appreciate it any less because it's not on my shelf like I appreciate it and I it's not getting plated and this is just going to sit and neglect and so let it let it go to somebody else that is going to get what they can out of it and then the

game can go and move on its life it's like if you have kids they leave when it's 18 you know or something around that and so that's good that's okay um you can't just hang on to them forever as much as you might want to uh so I think that's okay doesn't doesn't it because it's on my shelf has nothing to do with the quality of the game and I see this a lot where it's like this game comes out and like I can only get five plays out of it I can only get you know eight plays out of it good the game did its job like what do you want to have to sit there forever you know you are not gonna play my wife always tells me she's like you've got like 100 some games there are not enough days in the week uh for you to play all of those throughout the year and I 100 you are correct and I feel the same way about that um and so I've trimmed down a little bit I could honestly trim down more you know I could cut this shelf in half and realistically have more than enough game to keep me going so I that went a little bit longer on that than I tended to but I thought it was interesting to kind of take a look back see all these cool games people are excited about some of them are still going strong today and I know many people I'll be hold on to them and they don't need to you know so there's that uh so the next item on my notes is uh kind of two things one I would say war games uh GMT games Lock and Load Games stuff like that and fancy flight um you have seen kind of that war game disappeared in the political game the car driven game uh like founding fathers

Virgin Queen the last I think two years I don't think had any on there really um and I I would predict moving forward we'll see less of that as well and those games are definitely in the minority I think it's very much a niche hobby it's a part of the hobby that I enjoy to a certain degree you know there's definitely people that are out there that play War Games you know a lot more than me as far as YouTubers go you know Marco Coronado who I still will watch and watch his reviews of War Games even though I'm like well I'll never play this but you know I'm interested to how these games kind of work sometimes so I'll watch his videos in that regard um uh but um you kind of see that going away the hobby is getting bigger in a lot of ways I mean we've all seen that over the last 10 or 15 years and so I think in a way it's kind of drowning out some of that stuff some of the 18xx and the war games and stuff they're getting a little bit drowned out and only through the prism of board game geek right um generally a lot of these people probably aren't introduced to it so if they came into the hobby through I don't know critical role or tabletop or whatever um it's going to be a little while before they get to being exposed to something like a Twilight Struggle or an 18xx game or Combat Commander or something so back in the day you know in the late 2000s of the 20 odds or whatever early 2010s those had a more visible presence the war games and stuff like that so we have seen those disappear a little bit no still being made it's still being

played and as we add more people to the Hobby by osmosis some of them are going to you know find out about war games so even though the percentage maybe even has gone down of the people that play those they're still the larger pool of players has grown larger so there's still room for these things of course um but it's just interesting you know to see that go the Dynamics of those demographics is kind of interesting and there's a lot of that speculation the other part is the Fantasy Flight and and there's something I think has been talked about a lot is back then he was like one of these lists I can't remember which year was it like four or five games on it were Fantasy Flight games whether it was a reprint of Nexus Ops or a new descent or um you know anything like that so and there were these big huge games a lot of times with you know Miniatures and like horse heresy was in the first video in 2010 which is just like this way over the top tons of plastic it's a two-player only game um like who would make that now who would make like a two player only game about this one very specific battle in you know the 40K lore Now Grant 40K has some weight with it and some penetration that way because it's 40K is kind of its own a little hobby kind of parallel to board gaming um but you don't really see that I don't think anymore I mean I know we don't see those big crazy games those coffin boxes and those those big splash releases from Fantasy Flight they just really haven't been doing that and so that just seeing that in stark contrast how that company

sort of changed and I don't know how much money they made off those um not that money is all the important things in the world but I mean on the print run of horse heresy did they make enough you know to obviously probably not to make another game like that in that same vein um yeah so that that's been interesting to kind of see that transition in the war games and also Fantasy Flight and their transition um you know even today so we're gonna see over the next five years how the how these two things play out over the next couple of weeks and the next note I have here um and I think we're gonna see more of this in the next five years I'm almost sure we will but towards the end of this in the 2013-2014 video you start to see some of the kickstarters show up on the most anticipated list and some of that I feel like is probably driven by the Publishers of the kickstarters themselves who are Savvy enough to run their kickstarters at a certain time of year and tell their backers to go and vote for uh most anticipated lists or after the kickstarters run don't go and tell them hey you know hey we're nominated for the most anticipated game of the year and then they'll you know if they've got a thousand backers there's a lot of people that may be going and and vote on that as anticipated so I think that's it's fine like it's legal then illegal about it but I don't like that and I don't know that any of the games on the on the last two lists are

like that but I'm sure God I know there was some of that um you know and just by the natural fact it doesn't even take the publisher themselves doing it like it doesn't have to be you know I don't know nefarious is the right word it doesn't have to be nefarious it could take a backer who is subscribed to the page on Board Game Geek just making a post there because a lot of people I think that are back at Kickstarter will follow the game on the board game geek page and so you just make a post there and go and generate that you know and so that doesn't you know it's no different than like let's say GMT or Fantasy Flight or whoever has a newsletter you know that goes out let's say every month an email newsletter and they tell people hey we're nominated on this list go vote for I mean what are you supposed to do as a publisher you should be doing that that is your job to Market your game um so but it's from my perspective it throws the indicator off of a little bit of anticipation like what's the real anticipation there so what is really making you excited other than you have a little bit of a stake in it because you backed it and now you want to see it do well which is a whole other thing about bias and reviews I mean there's a comment I've seen this comment made it's not my comment although I kind of agree with it like a reviewer getting a review copy is much less biased than a Kickstarter backer because the reviewer is not like infested Kickstart backer who dropped three four hundred bucks and they're like this game is great they're like no sorry it's not I know you spent 400 bucks but it's not good um so there's some of that there's that

dynamic in there I'm not trying to like you know point out or anything I don't really have any harsh feelings towards any of this but it's just something you have to kind of be aware of it and absorb that into your you know assessment of it and so you've seen that here the other thing kind of coinciding with this kind of beginning of the kickstarters is kind of the micro game thing I think in the last one we saw coinage which is like this game with coins and One credit card sized card that you played the whole game on and so you see this sort of trend now of that and I think it's interesting because the way the hobby has worked I think going back to the 70s hey somebody will do something and this is the way a lot of things work somebody will do something that's successful and so you get copycats you get people trying to iterate on that so let's look at domain Dominion come out 2008 2009 first deck builder Boom Big Splash Thunderstone comes out pretty much same game but it's a fantasy theme Ascension comes out same kind of idea but you know it's kind of different it's a it's got a ever-changing card pool that you draft from instead of fixed card pools that you set up prior to the game and though again on and on and on you know we have more iterations on that and so some of that is healthy I think in the case of like Dominion to Ascension for example I find that a particularly healthy Innovation on something that's been established in Dominion in a lot of ways is kind of you know an iteration of Magic the Gathering

sort of I mean I think it's a bigger break you know but um and you saw you know work replacement Games come out Kayla's Agricola he saw a lot more I think at this time we're starting to see some of this um copy not driven by Design but driven by marketing you know in a way where it's like okay these buzzwords worked so let me grab that and cook something together and then go to my designers people that I know and say Hey I want a game that does this this and this you know it's a micro game it's um it's uh it's got an app or it's got this or it's got that so you're gonna see some of that as well now that is not too it's again there's Nuance here but that's not to say it's all Sinister it's all like marketing cash grab I don't think that's it because I think 90 percent of the Publishers and designers go in with the full intention of making something that's good and will last and have longevity and people will get their joy out of 100 percent but I think that marketing part creeps it starts to creep in more I think it's you start you just I don't think I don't think you can deny it I'd have to sit down and analyze it this has just been you know somebody that's been Loosely in the hobby since 2004 let's say well earlier than that actually um early in the hot so I started playing Katan and Loan hers and Carcassonne and

magic and stuff and then getting really into it around 2004-5 and then not so much and then really obviously you have a YouTube channel you know around 2010-11 somebody that's been seeing this stuff it's hard to check your own bias sometimes but I see that marketing angle like a lot more I mean I don't know if it's just because I'm like reading press releases now you know but I don't know I don't think it's that important because I think the games are going to be good or they're not at the end of the day and the ones that are good are going to last but we already talked about how long should a game last at the beginning of the video so just some stuff to kind of you know keep in mind okay so two kind of last sort of points or observations that I have one is that I didn't expect this although I probably should have is that a lot of times expansions will show up on these anticipated lists and that kind of says something to the kind of known quantity because there are no a brand new game from a new designer or new publisher or new theme or something you don't really know what to expect so it's hard to get in you know excited about it but if there's an expansion for descent or Mansions of Madness or Battlestar Galactica or something like that some other Fantasy Flight game all three of those examples um that's a known quantity known something that you like like a Dominion expansion showed up Seven Wonders expansion showed up uh so it's easier to get excited about something that is going to theoretically improve something that you already enjoy uh so that's I

just you know I didn't even think of that and I probably should have but uh um yeah so that was an interesting it's our observation and the other part was there was a fair number of games that had a lot of trouble whether it was licensing trouble like glory to Rome nothing personal uh Alien Frontiers or other kind of Kickstarter Shenanigans like D-Day Dice and The Upfront you know reprint and stuff like that so there was a fair amount of kind of turmoil kind of back in the last couple of years like 2012 1314. that I'd forgotten about and you know didn't really expect to see on here especially because you're going to looking at the most anticipated list you know I'm not really thinking about that I'm more thinking about sort of the um the psychology of the anticipation and all that kind of stuff which I mentioned at the beginning of the video but yeah so there was some interesting sort of look back there with you know some of these Publishers and some of these folks that are involved uh especially and they all kind of have to do revolver on Kickstarter in a lot of ways you know Lord of Rome alien Frontiers um I don't think nothing personal was on Kickstarter um but uh you know some of the other ones there I mentioned up front all mostly crowdfunding uh related things uh and so the crowdfunding we're going to see more of that for sure moving forward in the years but it was also kind of still like the wild west back then a lot of people were trying to figure it out

um and I think over time people have to a certain degree figured it out even new games new Publishers new designers there's been so much of a track record now at this point established you know behavior and Cadence and everything with your stretch goals and all that stuff and how your project runs and all that stuff that there's an example of what to follow and what to do and what not to do at this point but back then it was still kind of the Wild West you know and I kind of you kind of forget that sometimes you know back then it was like Kickstarter was still really new and fresh and it wasn't kind of the establishment thing that it is now I mean a lot of ways Kickstarter is it's not a publisher but it's an established Channel an established vehicle for games um and now there's other competitors game found um there's the new one that just come out uh backer not backer kit I don't know the new Dark Tower expansion was on it some other things Frost Haven stuff is going to be on there Frost Haven Miniatures some other things so there's some other competitors and stuff like that two kickstarters so the whole crowdfunding thing is very much mainstream now uh which back then it was still kind of you know experimental in the Wild West okay that's all the kind of the thoughts and notes that I have and so any thoughts and feedback you you have and maybe some I missed or you know comments on some of the things I talked about the beginning of the video uh let me know so next week we'll jump back into 2015.

thanks foreign

Progress saved