Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 1:17:22

Hello and welcome to episode 22 of the All Leak and Board podcast. I'm Carlo.

I'm Dylan.

And I'm Braden.

And on today's episode, our main course will be Collection Clingers. Why are these games still here? Why do we still own these? We're going to be picking three of our personal collection clingers from our own collections. But first, we are going to have a bit of a discussion here and just talk about Well, first off, like what what inspired this topic? And I touched on this kind of a little bit in the Board Game Quest episode that we did. Just the aspect of kind of like the longer you've been playing games, the more games you've played, the further into your, you know, personal board game quest that you get, the standard is kind of always going up, like that baseline of what games do I want to spend my time playing? What do I want to, you know, make a point of like having people over to play? And also, more importantly, as you kind of figure out that more you have like a new favorite game that you played once and you put it back on your shelf and you kind of think about like, okay, well, I probably want to play that game at least like 20 more times in my life or 50 times or whatever, you kind of thinking how many more hours of gaming time is that really going to take up? And now with something on my shelf that was previously, you know, a good game that I thought, oh, I'll come back to this, is that game now slipping off of the kind of bottom of that Is it teetering on that edge of is this still worth keeping or not? And so those games that kind of tend to cling and I just want to go over the the the actual definition of cling here just to be precise, to hold on tightly, stick closely, or stay near someone or

something. So, we're going to get back to afterwards, like what actually qualifies as a collection clinger, what what are a personal like definitions or or criteria, but I just want to set the context like as I've been acquiring more games and had, you know, we haven't been filming as many videos for the channel. There's stuff I want to get rid of, but maybe I want to film a curating my collection video first. I'm starting to get to the point where my personal collection is like not bursting. Um and and I want to ask you guys about your personal collections as well and where they're at, but it's getting to a point now where I'm having to revisit that line of like what stays and what goes. So, I wanted to start this by asking you guys just a general question and factor this into this question as well as throughout the episode. I want to talk about the actual concept of like the mental load and the kind of like the weight of that and if that's something you feel or not.

Um but opening question here, why do we cling to games? And do you think that it can be boiled down to something as simple as like like hope, you know, opportunity, stubbornness, sentimentality? Is there one kind of thing that you can boil it down to?

I I think it's just a it's a combination of a lot of those. Definitely hope, right? Aspiration. We talked about the aspirational games where you're just like there will be a time. I know there will be a time where I will gather seven of my other friends and play Captain Sonar. There will be another time. And for me, there was another time. It was just like nine years down the road in between plays, which is a crazy thing to say actually now that I'm think [gasps and laughter] thinking about it. Uh it's just silly. That's silly. And it's crazy that I know that it's nine years because I know I played in 20 either it was either 2016 or 2017, I think. Um which is just

that you held on to it and played it again, right?

Honestly, yeah. Like it was one of those games where I was like I know I 'm not going to play this a lot, but when those opportunities arise, I need to like push to make it happen. Um and I I was clinging.

If you had hadn't kept it, if you had gotten rid of it, and then the opportunity had presented itself like it did, but you didn't have it anymore, like would you have been legitimately upset or would it not have bothered Would you have been like, ah, you know, it is what it is?

I think it's a great question. I think I probably just would have been like, ah, it's fine. I wouldn't have been like, no, this is Captains, we could have we could have played. We could have had the best time of our lives.

Yeah.

I did yeah. I don't I don't think it would have I think it would have been probably fine.

Sure. Yeah, um Yeah, I mean I have only played I was part of that like nine years ago play, I think. It's the one at our local board game cafe here. Um yeah, it was tons of fun. Um it's interesting uh like my collection, I feel like I had a whole bunch of clingers. And then in the last couple of years, I made some like really tough decisions and like was like kind of forced myself to abide by the rule I had, which was um if I ran out of shelf space, I like I needed to sell stuff to for the new games that were um entering the collection and stuff. And so like I actually like I feel like the the clingers I picked, like it's all I have left for clingers. I don't really have a lot of clingers, unless you count my basement. But we're not counting the basement cuz that's that's the game that's the games that I'm I'm planning to part with.

Um so yeah, like I feel like this is going to be interesting like perspective cuz I know both of you are have much um larger or not I shouldn't say much larger collection, but larger and also like more curating and stuff that you're doing where I'm feeling like I'm in the I I've gotten to the point now where like I have less clingers. So it would be an interesting dynamic to kind of go back and forth here.

Yeah, you were pretty ruthless recently with some of those games you got rid of that I was surprised to see go.

Yeah. Yeah.

I'm excited, man. Like I'm I'm still waiting right now cuz I'm like I want to make uh piece of content and I think that's like my biggest barrier right now, which is also very frustrating. But yeah, for me, I think it's like that hope of like there's there is this scenario where this game is perfect for and I would feel like I'm missing out by not having the option.

Okay. Then for some of them, do you have that specific like day or group of people in mind and

No. No, absolutely not. It's it's it's like it's it's I think it's completely hypothetical. And it's like when the the planets are in a line and the moon is waxing and Mercury's in retrograde and I have a three quarter glass of water ready to go, that's the time.

Yeah, I feel like I like I don't even for like the games there there's games that I've gotten rid of and then like either repurchased or like they're on my list repurchased like News Fjord for instance like I got rid of and I'm going to get it again like I I will rather than have hope and kind of like hold out for some of them like there will be some cases I would say like Oathsworn would be the biggest example I could give where like that I know will happen but like I don't know if it's going to happen in like in the next year or in the next 10 years but that's one I just will not get rid of because I see the value in waiting for that experience but I feel like it's more likely for that to happen with me when it comes like for campaign games or for games that are sort of an investment of time that way where when I start playing it it's going to be an endeavor that I'm undertaking whether it's solo whether it's with other people over and over again like for regular board games I just feel like lately there's so many good ones and like even though I haven't curated my collection in the same way you guys have what I have what I'm down to now down to still like 120 games what I'm down to now is like there's so many great ones that I could I could host game nights on those games alone for the next five years and not not have a stinker of a game night, unless it was a game I haven't played in my collection that we're testing out.

And so I kind of just fall back on that mentality whenever I'm having a hard time like in in the last time I made a bunch of cuts rather than get hung up too much on am I going to want to play this again? It was more just right, but now I'm now it's going to be an easier path to play one of these ones cuz I'm not going to be competing with these ones that I just got rid of. So

Yeah.

Yeah.

Yeah, that's fair. Well, and since you I was going to ask this a bit later, but since you brought up the kind of physical space before, like if shelf space and room space weren't limitations, like those physical barriers, would you feel the same way? Like for for each each of you, I guess, like are these self-imposed limits? Like if you had a bigger room where you like someone unbought you a shelf or something or would you say like no, I don't want more games. I don't want more space for more games.

I think it's two things. Like yes, like I would say the large part is what you just said. Like if I didn't have a space issue, I wouldn't have made as many ruthless cuts as I did. I'd still have games in my collection that I was hoping to play and probably still wouldn't have played. But like I one day I maybe would have. So for me it's that and it's also I would say that the other part of this I want to be careful here so that it doesn't seem like I'm placing any blame cuz that's not what this is. But it's also just that I don't live alone now. I have a partner. And so like yes, I have a basement full of games, but it's not just my basement full of games. It's our basement full of games and we actually just had like her family over the other day and like they hadn't come to the basement before and they did and they're like there's more games down here. And I was like these ones are I'm getting rid of these. I'm getting rid of these ones. I swear.

Oh, and they just started like they were like I am disgusted with you and what are you doing?

that's exactly how it went. Yeah.

So you had a sheet a sheet over them in the basement so for

Yeah, I need to hide them like They're like where's Agricola? But yeah, like I I feel like it's those two things that I factor in more than I like In the past, I had more shelf space. And what I've done now is as soon as a game has to go on to my floor because there's no shelf space, I know something's got to go in. Right now, I have Old King's Crown on the floor and I know it's not a personal copy. It's an AYCB copy. But I I don't I don't differentiate AYCB and my games. I I need to My rule is I need to have shelf space for any games that I'm not currently like convinced I'm getting rid of. Once I'm convinced, I can put them in the basement. That doesn't count to get shelf space anymore. But so right now, Old King's Crown's on the floor. I tried to fit it somewhere and I couldn't. So I'm like, well, I got to get rid of something now.

All right, well, I've got that separate Yeah, I was going to say I have that separate AYCB shelf at my place. So the games are stacking pretty high there, but there's enough room to put Old King's Crown. Don't don't don't be getting rid of that. We haven't even tried it yet.

All right. No, no, I wouldn't get rid of that. I meant like I'd have to get rid of another game in my collection. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Yeah, I think for me too, like it's the definitely the size thing, right? Like if someone was like, hey, here's another uh five Calyx shelves, I'd be like, awesome, great. I just this gives me more options for later on, but I don't think that's necessarily beneficial as well. Like I think with like right now with where my collection is at in terms of size, which is like just over 150 um not including the ones that I'm or including the ones that I am going intending to sell for sure. I think that right now like I feel like I'm I'm pretty good. Like I feel good. Like there's no like large desire to go buy new games. Maybe it's to like I'm seeing holes more so in my collection of like where I want to fill out a little bit more too, but um that's that's a completely different topic, but

A bit more social reduction.

Yeah, I think we're kind of low on that, so um but yeah, I think just like the size thing is is not it is a factor, but it's also not really a factor cuz I think what my current size has allowed me to think about like if someone gave me extra space now, right? Rather than like on on the way to as I was collecting, right? I mean I still am collecting, but I've hit a limit basically was what I'm trying to say like right now and I feel like even if someone gave me more space now, I wouldn't increase my collection size cuz I already feel like it's it's already a lot.

So we're going to need to make some changes to keep it manageable.

Yeah.

I'm a little I was going to say I'm a little surprised by both of your answers. I thought that the kind of like mental load of having those games would have factored it like maybe played a bigger part than the physical physical space. And I know that of the three of us like I probably have the most games now and I'm probably feeling that especially unplayed like the my unplayed amount of games is just like really increased as I've picked up a lot of these kind of like harder to find out of print games lately and haven't been making like a huge effort to like get the unplayed games off my shelf. We've been kind of revisiting games a little more. So those keep piling up and yeah, I don't know. I guess maybe I've been feeling that mental load of the kind of I don't want to say it's like a I don't want to make a bigger deal out of it than it is like saying it's like bringing me like extreme anxiety to see those games on there, but it it but it doesn't feel good to let's say like look at a game and think like okay, I've read the rules for that game like four separate times and I've invited people over and it was up for consideration six months ago and we didn't play it and then I forgot the rules and do I read the rules for it again and like I guess the more games that get added for me it's like I I have that part of the mental load is like how many games can I remember rules for? Or how many games that I am either haven't ever played or have only played once or twice and haven't fully remembered the rules for. Like how many times do I want to relearn rules?

Yeah.

How hard is it to like get something off the unplayed shelf when you have more and more games to pick from, etc etc? And again, that's where it starts to come into play with those games that you have played and they're just kind of clinging sticking around. And it's like I don't know. It kind of weighs on me a little bit seeing all those games not being played. Even if I had the physical space, like I think this is also the difference between whether people want to be a collector more like more of a collector or more of a gamer. And even from the three of us, like I don't consider myself a collector. I cull quite a bit, but I also buy like I have a decent level of churn. So even though neither of us would really call ourselves like collectors, we still have quite a few games, but obviously having like the YouTube channel and the podcast factors in. [sighs] But

Yeah, total totally factors absolutely. 100% like I wouldn't wouldn't even have any close to this many games if wouldn't have the podcast.

Yeah, I don't think I have like I don't think I have any mental load uh in regards to any any games, but like like I would say what I do have is like there's games I'll look at on the shelf and and I will like there's games that I didn't pick that I will get to later for like the game the clingers or whatever in my collection that I didn't really view them as clingers because yes, they're they're clinging on, but they're not like on the cusp of leaving. The reason they're clinging is like I will there are games I will hold until I play them next and I might hold forever because I am fine if I only play them once a year, once every two years, whatever. They're they're not they're not like on the cutting the chopping block or whatever.

Um and so there's there's those games and I like I would say like Age of Innovation is one of them that like I can't remember the last time I played the physical version now, but I will hold I will keep that one until I do because I will always enjoy it when when I do. The only way that I will ever leave is if I I get so addicted to Clans of Caledonia or something like that. But so there's games I look at like that. It's not mental load. It's more just like, I really want to play that again or something. But like, what am I going to suggest that over this game might be a while or something. Like that's the most I'll feel. But there's no games that would say that I look at that it like yeah, I feel like a toll sort of because I haven't played it or because I have to make a decision. Like if I would start if I started to feel that, honestly, I would just I would just sell the game. And like and I and I did that with like News Fjord for instance, and then I would regret it now. But then I my in my the way my head works is like, well, but if I want to I'll just rebuy it one day. Oh, I can't find it. Well, I'll wait until it's available on the secondary market.

or like Carlo probably has it, so.

Yeah.

[snorts and laughter]

Well, and I was so I was going to ask you about like is there is there value in trying to get rid of those games kind of in advance, like being being kind of ruthless and getting onto it when it's like brings you a little bit of discomfort where you're like, maybe, you know, when you're on the fence or is it do you feel better about only doing it when you're 100% sure so that you don't have any regrets about it?

I I I was going to say like the first time I read your in advance I wasn't like I wasn't I was like I don't know if I would even like what how I would classify that for myself, but the way you just worded it like that's essentially what I did. Like these hard decisions I made, I could have there was games in those ones. I wish I had the list of the exact ones I got rid of, but there was games in that list that I probably normally would have held on to for another year or two because there was still a chance that maybe I would play them. Um and I did just sort of decide like, you know what, whenever I start to feel like there's a there's as much of a chance I don't play this again as there is that I do, I just decided to get rid of them because I I always knew that I would never regret it so much that I didn't have that game to play if I had people over because I do have so many other options that I will enjoy playing anyway. So it's never going to like make a game night be less than it could have been because I got rid of like let say I got rid of Age of Innovation and come over and like oh, do you want to play Age of Innovation? I'm like oh, I got rid of it. It's like but then I'll just just Clans of Caledonia or Fey of Swamp or whatever and I'll have I'll have a great night. So it's like because I know I'll still have a great time, I'm not necessarily as hung up on like would I have had a better time if I got to play Age of Innovation?

I'll just wait until I play at someone else's place or something like that. Like it would be a harder thing for me if I knew that it meant I was going to have a bad time and so I'm like weighing a bad time versus good time or whatever and and Braden you're going to you got an idea here.

I just I like the way you first of all you're the way you when you brought up Age of Innovation actually made me add another game onto my list of collection clingers which swapping someone out. But I wonder if like the motivation behind this is essentially like min maxing in terms of let's let's call it min maxing fun or like board game experience, right? Where where when we talked about on the quest like we're on the search for like the best games, right? And like clingers are like this could be the best game. I I don't either like I don't know or I need to I should I should play it more but like there's all these other things but like can it be the best game and being okay with not answering that or like not fully exploring that I think is also okay cuz there's there's just so many other experiences to have as well like not diving headlong into an experience where you're spending 10 sessions you know plus exploring a game just to be sure like you know what this game actually isn't for me, right?

It's like well you know like what what is the the tradeoff there too and I'm I'm wondering if it's like yeah, it's like you're like you're min maxing fun by trying to cling onto these games and saying like hey I'm I am going to play this to get to try and find the best experience when you're I think you're absolutely right Dylan like is there a big difference between Clans of Caledonia and Age of Innovation? Like um like some people will be like, what are you talking about? There's like this all these changes but it's like down to the like the essence of it probably not.

But even even let's let's pick two games that aren't even anything like like let's say Age of Innovation versus like Libertalia, right? Two very different games. If you know what, I'll do even a better example here. Let's say Libertalia and Ethnos, two very different games that both play up to six. So like let's say I got I got rid of Ethnos because I was like I haven't been a game played. I'm I'm ready to I'm just I'm just going to pull the trigger. And then all of a sudden I have six people over and they're like oh this is the perfect time for Ethnos. And I'm like ah I got rid of it or whatever. Like this you're right this would have been great to try six player. Like for me like that's the extent of what I would feel and then I'd be like but now I have this opportunity to like what about six player Libertalia? What about six player Keyflower? What about six player like I I would just suggest other ones and and they're all games that I would be eager to play or I would have a good time playing. So at that point I've already forgotten whether I would have like had a better time with Ethnos or that I'm upset or disappointed that I don't have that. Like for me I just have enough good games now like in my collection and your guys's collection to play that it never really holds me up too much, I would say.

So let me ask you though because for Ethnos specifically that's one where like the rule set is so light that even we don't play it for however long, it's so easy to jump back into and it's a relatively quick game that I imagine the like if you were going to call that one, I imagine it would be because of the size of the box, right? Like imagine that Plate came out with a version and it was in one of those tiny fold out magnetic boxes or whatever and it took the box took up like a third or a quarter of the space that your copy currently does. Could that alone be the difference between feeling the need to get rid of it or not?

Totally. That I I would say like and Ethnos isn't a big box but but yeah like if there was a a way to have the Ethnos experience in a smaller form, it's extending the life of it in my collection because I know that now space is no longer a factor in me keeping it. But I think that that's kind of what it would like even even having said that like Ethnos probably was always going to be one that's on the chopping block for me. I didn't include it today in the ones I'm listing cuz it's not currently feeling that way. Um but yeah like it absolutely could leave any day and up but I think it's going to be something like what you just described or um a game similar in style that plays up to like six as well coming along but I'm like ah you know what this now kind of replaces what that would have been for me and then I ditch Ethnos at that point but

How about you Braden?

[sighs and gasps]

I'm I'm just trying to think like cuz I I like your mentality Dylan, the way that you're approaching this and I'm like why is the way I'm thinking about it different and how is it different, right? Cuz like for me if I was in that situation like I'm like I want the best experience. So I'm like okay this is this is the Ethnos time. I'm feel the vibe is feeling fantastical. We're feeling a little bit light but like a little bit of rules, some area uh majority uh you know this is this it's time. I'm I'm feeling Ethnos. It's got to be it. Libert no not Libertalia it can't be. But it's it's like these are still really good games and when when is good good enough, right? It's like do I need to have that that pinnacle moment and is it really going to like really like shaking myself, looking myself in the mirror and going what what are you what do you want? What do you want? Like do you need this like is it really going to be that much different or is it just is it the people around that make the game no is it which it is it is absolutely it is but like like really talking to yourself and saying hey like is this is this truly different?

Okay. Well I think it's time we jump into what are criteria, our personal criteria is, cuz it feels like we're kind of dancing around what we've each kind of used as our our guiding

clinging, if you will.

Yes, yes, exactly. Uh so before we let that cling any further, let's take a quick break to hear from our sponsor and then we'll come right back.

All You Can Board is proudly sponsored by Victory Pints, our local game store of choice here in Winnipeg, Canada. We strongly believe that Victory Pints is the gold standard of board game stores, not just here in Winnipeg. Their main priority is having a wide selection of games, many of which you won't find elsewhere. They ship Canada wide, $15 flat rate or free shipping for orders over $200 and even take requests to try and order in specific games. They also have a used game section where you can trade in games for store credit and maybe even find some hidden gems that others have traded in. Note that the used game section is only available for in-person purchases and trades. Again, located in Winnipeg at the corner of Henderson and Hespeler, check them out at victorypints.ca.

A massive thank you to Victory Pints for all their support over the years.

All right, we are back and it's time for our personal collection clingers. So Braden, did you set any specific criteria for you that these games had to meet or did you just pick based on what sounded like it fit the the term collection clingers?

I mean kind kind of both in a way, which is like uh doesn't really make kind of sense to answer that way, but let me let me explain. So I definitely picked a little bit on vibes. I was just like, what in my collection just feels like it's teetering on the cusp, but it's like I don't want to let go of it, but I know it's probably going to be best if I let go and I don't have a lot of experience with it, but it's like it could be good. I like let it stay. If I if I hold it for a little bit longer, it'll it'll just get better, you know? It's it's this nice wine. Trust me. Trust me. People say good things about it. So, that was kind of my initial um thoughts about like okay, games that have been around in my collection for a large amount of time. And like we're talking at least seven plus years, something like that. Like something that I've like really been hanging on for realistically no real reason.

Um so, then being honest with myself and just like looking at that stuff too. But then also when when Dylan was talking earlier in the podcast too, made me think about um the games that I probably wouldn't get rid of or one game in particular that I wouldn't get rid of, but it's also not one that I'm actively suggesting either, but it's like one that I would always enjoy playing. So, that that's kind of where I'm approaching it from my point of view at this point. That it may change as we go.

All right. Dylan, what about you?

Uh for me, I it was um like definitely on vibes uh to some extent, but also it had to be games that I've played multiple times and enjoyed so that it like there are games that I know when I if I play them again, I'm going to have a good time. And so like they're clinging on because of that sort of memory or that experience that I had with them. Um but they have to be games also that I play at most like once a year. And and not exact Sorry, I shouldn't say at most then once a year. But like one one or two times a year is like the most that they are getting played. And it might be I would say that's an average. It's possible a year comes around where all of a sudden like one of these games I sat down and played it like three times in a weekend or something like that, but that didn't happen with any of these anytime recently, I would say. So, yeah, those those are like the primary things.

Not getting played a lot, um but I really really like them.

Okay. Okay. Well, I think for me, I just set basically a sort of like what you said, Braden, about having them for a long time in my collection. Like it was minimum five plus years, but when I look at these, like I've definitely owned them all for at least, I would say seven or eight would be the the one I've owned the least amount of time, so it's probably seven to 10 years at least for for all three. Um I didn't pick anything that is from like my unplayed shelf because those ones Like part of it is what you mentioned, Braden, like there are games They have to be games that I've actually considered getting rid of multiple times, but they're sort of stubbornly clinging on. And most of my unplayed ones I either eventually look at and go, I don't like I don't you know, I bought this one I you know, I'm basically no longer interested in easy enough to get rid of or it's staying here specifically because I want to try it once before I get rid of. So I I pick games that are like really I've felt stumped on before as to like why is this still here? Like can I justify getting rid of this? And it just feels like it just sits there kind of

You can You can say it, Grikula. It's okay. You can say it, Grikula. It's fine.

Get out of here. That's inappropriate.

Sorry, Grikula. No, sorry. You went

So yeah, and I I also didn't include any like filler games or really small box games because if it only takes like 10 or 15 minutes to play or it's you know, does barely takes up any space on the shelf, it's just not enough of a barrier to to really be a a tough decision on whether or not to keep it. So um Okay, Braden, why don't you take it away here? Tell us your first collection clinger.

Yeah. Okay. So I I will tell you right now. Okay, this was probably one of the first games that I bought in my collection. I can tell you that it's it's at it's it's probably I probably bought it in 2016 maybe. Um it was featured on uh tabletop with Wil Wheaton. Uh it came out in 2014 uh and this is Five Tribes. So the the reason why it's a clinger for me is because Five Tribes is at least like from from what I've gathered in board game media and you just where it's rated on BGG, it's 98th overall. I'm like this is a good game.

I should In In my brain, I'm saying I'm saying I should really like this game. I do like the game. I like the concept of the game. Where I think like I and I've only played this I think once twice maybe twice in person total since I've owned it 10 years. That's It's It That's a definition grade A plus clinger. Like that is that is wrapped in that is like wrapped to my body stuck to me. You know what I mean? Like it needs to go. Um and the reason why I feel like it needs to go but it it can't is is that the decisions that you have to make and trying to calculate your turn It's just It's too much, man. Like when I play it, I'm just like this is it's it's a it's a fun like when executing and doing everything but it just like to me it there's too much. There's too much to consider when playing it. Um and yes, like maybe you just play it on vibes and you you know you make mistakes whatever but like I want to maximize every little bit of it.

And it's just there's too much to calculate to make that happen. So, um I I I want it to be this game that is seen by others as you know top 100 and I'm like oh that's something that I should have in my collection but when in reality is I think I need to step back and be like hey uh get off me.

That's a really good really good pick. I think that's a game that I you know I considered buying many times like in my first however like many years that I was in the hobby and I think if I owned it, it might also be clinging on because it's not something I'm looking to buy now but yeah, I've also played your your copy once and played it a couple times on Board Game Arena, and you can see the kind of like brilliance of the game. And I can understand why you're like, yeah, you want to see if that potential will come through, but it is also like you got to be in the mood for that much brain burn. [gasps] There's so There's like what like thousands of possible permutations every single turn.

It's Yeah. Just like where you're dropping, which colors you're dropping and then onto what tile and then just it's There There's so much going on.

So Dylan, are you going to tell him it's time to get rid of it or are you going to support his choice? What You want to weigh in?

like I feel like I mean you're you're at you're at like 10 years at this point with it or getting or around that 10-year mark and you said you played it like one or two times. Like I think honestly at this point you should just you should let it go. You should just You should just You should just say I had my time with it. 10 years is enough and

Okay, but I I got to celebrate our anniversary first. Then during the dinner I'll be like, I'm sorry Five Tribes, but There's a There's a sixth tribe. I'm sorry. And you're not on it.

what I'm going to Like I don't know if we're going to have this circle back for each of these games, but like yeah, if you invited us over to play it like Dylan, how excited would you be to play Five Tribes again? And I'll I'll answer too. I'm not just putting you on the spot here.

Uh like I would say the same amount that I'm just excited for a game night. Like I don't know it I Like it's one of those games I don't um I can't honestly remember if I even played Five Tribes.

Yeah, we played at the the the dome cabin.

I always You know it's weird I don't know everyone has these weird associations. I I mix up in my head Five Tribes and Alhambra. The The games for some reason like in my head they just like And so like I'm I I think about one it goes the other, but like I I don't remember a lot from the play. I remember I I liked it. I don't remember dislike it at all, but I wouldn't say that like anything about it stood out in a way where I'm like I can't wait to go back and play it again. But if you said I want to have people over and I think I'm thinking of doing a Five Tribes, I wouldn't be like oh I'm not coming then. You know what I mean? Like it's it's not a hold up for me at all.

Okay. And for me I would say if you plan to have us over to play it, let me know in advance cuz I'd love to play it once or twice on Board Game Arena to like re-familiarize myself with it before playing it again in person. So I don't feel like I'm playing it as like a learning game again.

Yeah. Yeah. I think it's um it's a game that I can respect but I can respectfully distance myself from it.

All right. Well Dylan, what's your first clinger?

Uh my first clinger clinger is Earth. Uh so I've had this game for I think three years three years four years something like that. Um and the reason it's clinging to my collection is because and I should say I played the physical version of this like twice. Um it's mostly been on BGA. I've played this many many times on BGA. Um really really like it. It's stayed in my collection because I think that I enjoyed the series of plays when I was playing it a lot on BGA enough and so much that there's a part of me that wanted to hold on hope that whether it's like uh Kelsey or whether it's uh some like someone I introduced to you to the first for the first time that like would get so sort of hooked on it or like like it so much that they would keep wanting to play it again and then that would be my way into like playing Earth more regularly and and discovering and sort of the meta of it again maybe even more than I did last time. But I just more Unearthing the meta, perfect.

Um but yeah like I just the more I think about it the more I was looking at my collection today I just like it's never going to be the game that if I'm having you know three other people over that it's even going to be recurrently anyways. It's that it's going to be in like the my top five suggestions that I'm that I'm suggesting. Um maybe it like if I were to hold on to it in like you know 10 20 years if my collection is much smaller maybe I am getting around to it or something but it's just at that point like that's so far out that I'm not even factoring that in. So it's just one that I look at that I'm like realistically I could keep this in my collection and I could not play it for the next 10 years and it would be like I would not be surprised if that was the case because of the BGA aspect, because of the competition in my collection, because no one I know is like currently clamoring for it. Um really what's held it there is the fact that like Wingspan, a a game that I didn't include on this list, but it was been on the cutting of room floor of many of my last um calls that I've done is a game that all of a sudden uh my partner wanted to play and really enjoys and now we played it multiple times and so there was a part of me that I'm like you know if if that were to happen with Earth I'd be pumped, but I the more I think about it the more I'm like I just don't necessarily think that's a high probability.

Okay. And for these style of games where you have like a big deck of unique cards and it's a big tableau builder, like I know you previously got rid of like Everdell and Terraforming Mars, but I know you still have Forest Shuffle. Um what like would this would Earth and Forest Shuffle be your favorite ones remaining of that style of kind of tableau builder?

Pro like probably I'd have to Yeah, I was going to say I'd have to think to see if there's other games that fall in that realm that I'm forgetting as well, but like Earth is for sure in in that conversation for me if someone were to ask me like it would definitely come up. Um but yeah and even in comparison to Forest Shuffle theme wise and card wise like we're so far into Forest Shuffle now and we're we're going to get every version because we just that that sort of become our game my my partner and I um that like even just competing with that and and Earth is not an easy game to set up. It's also not an easy game to teach for the first time and understand a strategy for the first time. Lots of fiddly components and I and I I should have said in the criteria like I don't I don't want to make any decisions about cutting games for my collection or I want to avoid it if it's if the answer is because well but I would just play this on BGA instead. Like I know that's a viable and fair enough reason, but I I'm trying not to like default board games to digital space as the reason why I get rid of the physical version. Um but But yeah, so that's kind of where I sit. That's Earth. That's my first one.

Cool. And Braden, do you played Earth as well? BGA only or played with us in person once maybe?

I think I've only played it on BGA. Yeah, I don't remember stacking the little whatever fungus tokens, whatever they were. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

All right. My first one and the one that kind of like is what inspired this topic and I I told you guys before that this is like I called it the Isle of Skye problem in my collection. You remember? Because Isle of Skye for the longest time has been the game that I say was like the best How do I say this? The best game in my collection that probably won't leave or like the least Yeah, but I don't know if I'm going to

Basically the best?

No, I was going to say the least good game that manages to Yeah, that that stick around I guess. Like I don't know. It just it's kind of on that cusp right there where I just like I'm always like, oh, I should get rid of it. Oh, but maybe I you know. And we talked about this game in a video we did long time ago, Dylan. Uh we did a game called Top 10 Games We Love but Rarely Play. This was I looked it up before recording. That was in March 2021. So that was over 5 years ago. And when we recorded that video, I remember saying that like we hadn't played it in a few years at that like at least a couple of you know, a year or two at that point and we were like, oh, we should play it again sometime. Still haven't played it. So it's probably been 6 or 7 years now at least since I played it. And it so for those who don't know when we have game nights now, we do this kind of thing where sometimes we'll like each nominate a game and then we have three, four, five games on the table and we'll do this vote thing where we count to three and vote for which game you want to play the least and then we kind of cut games down until it's down to the last two and then we vote on the game.

And Isle of Skye has been thrown into mix like two or three times in the past year because sometimes people like maybe it it's good with three players. You had it's been a while. Maybe we should play it. And I know they don't always get voted out and removed again. And it's this game that like you know I've talked about before it's tile laying with this kind of cool bidding thing where you like price these tiles um and then you're hoping that people will pay them buy them but if they don't then you have to pay for them so it's kind of like what price are you setting that if someone doesn't buy them you'll have to pay for it yourself. So you want to entice people and there's kind of has this swing of are you getting more tiles some rounds or fewer tiles and every time I think about it I kind of have this smile on my face where I go like yeah that was good those few times we played it like why don't we play this game more often? And I think part of it is the when I want to do bidding and auctions there's other games I would rather play and when I want a tile laying game I usually want tile laying on a shared map where it's a bit more competitive and I think it's like the every time I think of it I'm like yeah we could do that bidding but like there's another game that does bidding better after the bidding when I just take the tile and put it in my little area that part isn't as satisfying and it obviously has the the the scoring rounds similar to cartographers.

I mean this game did it first this came out 2015 where you like alternating scoring like two categories or three categories and they just kind of keep shifting along and you know what's going to score when so I don't know everything about the game sounds like something I should like the fact that it's like 45 minutes to an hour but it just it always feels like it's not anywhere near like a first choice game to play and it keeps feeling like maybe one day it'll be like a good family game to play when my kids are older like maybe one day we'll revisit it. Yeah or maybe we'll revisit it. I know I know. And maybe we'll play it again and it will be like good enough but the other thought that I came to the other day is like if we play it and people were like this is really good we should play it more am I going to then regret that and be like no I don't want it to be

No.

now now other games won't get played as a result of people being excited like that means we don't play another game more that I like more.

That's a dangerous mentality though like as soon as you start as soon as you start looking at it as like yeah but if I play that, am I going to be upset that I didn't play this? Like, all Yeah, always. There's always going to be another game. But like, I just feel

this topic? I need your guys' help.

I feel like this is one you just need to set up one time when you're having people over and not even give us the the option just to almost as a test like for yourself to see like how does the group And And specifically do it when like Like I don't know if if some of our other friends haven't played it before like like Raj and Corbin and stuff. But if if they if they haven't or haven't Like they forget everything about it, make sure that it's when they're there too so that there's more new plays [snorts] happening so in case someone's like, oh my god, I want to play this so many more times. Like that might excite you to play it more or something.

And then I'll just sell it to them.

Yeah, that's right.

Oh, they they've got it. I can play it anytime.

That's That's the loophole here.

Well, I kind of I kind of have this thing where it's like it it has to get its proper send-off. Even if I like came to the conclusion like I am going to sell it, I almost feel like I owe it one play before it's like the door Yeah, yeah, exactly.

Set the boat on fire and then set it off.

Yeah.

Yeah, I mean I I

this one, Heavy Breton?

No, I haven't played it. So like yeah, and I completely agree with Dylan. I think it like In this case, it's like it's probably not going to get votes because it doesn't look I'm going to say it sexy off the Like Like you know, it's like Hans im Glück, right? It's like

Yeah.

The It's On the front The front-facing appearance is like, what is this? Like what's going on? But underlying could be like an amazing game. We played like St. Petersburg is also like one that I think of too where it 's like this game like like it's not apparent that it is like the look to me does not match what the game is. And that's just because of like when it came out and all that stuff and the art style and like it doesn't jive with my taste. Whatever. That's besides the point. I think in this case like yeah, Isle of Skye set that set that thing up and let's You know, if we If we to, like let's send it off.

All right,

We'll do it. We're going to I'm going to make sure that this gets played one time at some point in the next few months and then I'll make a decision on it.

I'm going to veto veto it immediately when I arrive.

This is helpful. This is what I was looking for.

I'll be like, what the hell is this?

Yeah, I was going to say. People are going to show up, oh, I was guys is this good? I'm like, yeah, it's pretty good. Oh, you played it a lot? No, I haven't really played it in like seven years cuz there's other games I'm more excited about. Oh, cool. Well, I guess let's play it. I don't know. Yeah. All right, Braden. Hit us with your second clinger.

Yeah. Okay. Second clinger and this was actually just like a last minute swap um that I added just now while we're talking. And to me, this is uh Decrypto. This is uh and I think it's a clinger for me because I'm I'm clinging onto playing it with a specific player count at six because I had such uh a vivid memory of playing it with um my siblings and their partners, which was so six of us total. And just like that that experience I was just so good and I haven't brought it out since really and I haven't found the opportunity because and I I don't feel like it's going to leave my collection because like it's it's a damn good game. It's so good. Um and I think this is also just one that needs to be like, okay guys, we got six people. We're just we're just we're going to play Decrypto and you're going to see how like this game sings cuz man, yeah, it's it's so good. And I just I do not think I will get rid of it, but I'm I'm clinging onto I think I'm maybe clinging onto it too hard to playing it at a specific player count too. So almost needing to expand my horizons and you know what, be okay you know four, hey, that's say okay. Play with eight? Well, we can play Captain Sonar instead. Um so yeah, uh I think that 's why I'm I am choosing Decrypto for for this.

Dylan, you still haven't played this,

have you? And I haven't either, by the way.

No.

Oh, that hurts so much more now. I thought I thought you played this.

like No, every time we we bring it up you have this painful reaction. I've owned a copy of this for like six or seven years.

that's even Yeah.

I Again, it wasn't I didn't make it eligible for a clinger because it's unplayed on my shelf, but uh I I need to play this.

Yeah, okay. Well

I'm going to say the same thing you said about Isle of Skye. Like just make it happen. I will never be Like even if I don't end up loving the game, I'm not going to be disappointed if you

That's

insist on us playing it. I need someone to be the the one to kind of teach it and have it

I will champion this game. I will champion this game. And then we'll end up playing Captain Sonar instead, but I will champion this game.

Um my second one is Cascadia. Uh Cascadia There's a couple reasons it's clinging. Uh one it is a very accessible game um both in theme, both in play style um and it's one that even though like my partner and I don't Another reason I'm considering like that I might leave one day is because we both really like the Cascadia Roll and Write games, which I've talked about a bunch um and at this point we just gravitate towards those rather than base Cascadia. I think we played Cascadia once in 2026. Um and yeah, we like it and we have friends in in sort of that region of Canada too, like in British Columbia and stuff like that, that like if we were to see them, I think we'd want to like show them Cascadia um and and play it. So there's like it's really the accessibility and it's really just like the the notion that there is a group that might be over at our house one day that I don't even know or I'm meeting for the first time, that Cascadia might be a great option to play. Um but I'm trying to like be I'm trying to base my collection decisions less on those things just because in the past I've I've tried to keep hold on to a bunch of games based on like this would be great for this, this be great for this. And that great for this never really happens, or if it does, there is always usually another option of what we can play. Like, is is are people really going to be is is the

night going to be ruined because I got rid of Cascadia and we had to play in King Gold instead? Like, no. We're going to have a great time playing in King Gold, right? So, um it it's it's going to cling, I think, a little bit longer because it's also not a huge box and there is a a big fan of Flat Out Games and like I do like Cascadia, but I more and more, especially with us playing the Roll and Write versions a lot more, I just think that it's days are probably numbered. I'm just not ready ready to fully call it off yet.

This is a great pick, I think. I I think Do you think that Wingspan kind of fills that a little bit too because you and your partner are also playing it?

I honestly I think that Wingspan might have even been on this list over something like Cascadia or it would have already been gone from my collection if not for uh my partner liking it and and me sort of getting back into like it and and the whole Like again, that's another deck of cards game or whatever and like there's cards in Wingspan I still haven't seen and there's not like cards very very different, but it has been interesting to try new things in it. So, yeah, like it it is in a way competing with Wingspan, Cascadia that is for like that kind of play, that kind of session.

I I look forward to hearing your review of Wingspan Pocket. Thank you.

You can keep looking forward to that because it's not happening. Not right now, anyways.

I just want to touch on what you mentioned about like is it like a like great for this or like great for this Like that aspect of like does it need to be just unconditionally great? Like, does it feel like you like it needs to be without these qualifiers? Like, you're almost making excuses for it to be like instead of just saying like, yeah, this is an awesome game, we should play it, or it's great for when I have those people, it's great but in this like you should just be able to say it's a great game.

The Well, it's not even so much that, it's just more that like I liked having games from multiple situations that no matter what group came over, I had options. But I feel like lately the only the only um one I want to hold on to from of that mentality is party games. I don't want to like get even if I don't play a party game for a full year, I don't want to have no party games in my collection because there is the chance and then I'm going to have to be boring all the games me I already as it stands I I borrow wavelength from Carlo all the time. Um I got my own copy of Monikers now, but like I feel like the for party games for instance there's probably like a limit of like I need to always have five party games minimum or something like that and they need to like encompass different styles, different amounts and stuff. But beyond party games, I don't feel like there's I I feel like I've gotten away from like I need to hold on to this game for this reason because all the other games in my collection if I got rid of one, I could suggest another one in its place that would still lead to a successful game night.

Yeah, fair enough. If it's not a niche that needs to be filled, you shouldn't be holding on to a niche game for

Yeah.

if you're not excited about it I guess, right?

Yeah.

Yeah, interesting cuz I've looked at my copy of Cascadia and it doesn't get played a ton. I'm not at that point. Yeah, my kids are, you know, probably not too far off from being able to play it so I'm it's going to stick around for a while, but I really surprised yeah I yeah but it's but it's not one that needs to you know it still gets played often enough. I played it with Anna like less than a year ago. She liked it quite a bit, so yeah, but it's about that's a good pick, Dylan. All right, my second clinger here is Hive. So this is the two-player abstract game about bugs where you're trying to surround you have these six-sided yeah hexagonal tiles and you are trying to surround the other person's queen bee and the first person to surround the other person's bee wins and you have grasshoppers and what else? Mosquito or no this came to Mike as expansion. Yeah, ants and spiders and beetles.

Yes, and beetles and they all move differently. So I remember like this game came out in 2001 and it was probably one of the first 10 games that I bought. Uh, I probably bought it maybe around like 2000 I don't know, 2010, 2011. So I've owned it for a while and I This is Of the games on this list, of the three that I'm mentioning today, it's definitely the one I've played the most. There was a period where I played it in person quite a bit. But because it's one of those abstract like deterministic games where there's no randomness, no luck, it kind of has that same thing as games like chess and go where like you don't want to be playing where the it's a wide gap in skill or experience levels. So whether that's just like age, like someone playing it with their kid or just like you've played it 50 times and you teach someone for the first time, I feel like I'm I have This is clinging more for the like I would love to show this to my kids one day. They might play it with each other. They might play it with their friends. It's a great travel game.

It has that little bag that you can just zip the pieces into. The fact that it has that it's like you don't You know, I remember the rules so easily. There's no score track. There's not You can easily just take like it's one of the best travel games because the tiles that you can play on the beach. It's honestly one of the best like outdoor games. You can play out in the rain. You can play take it camping. So there's like all these uses

You're not playing it out in the rain, man.

No, no. I I No, sorry. I To be clear, I'm not going to be playing it out in the rain. But if someone actually said like if if I you know, and I don't do a ton of camping, but if I went camping, like it's probably one of the games that I would actually bring because again, I'm not going to bring card games or anything that could get affected by the weather and stuff.

You know, it's only What's It's November now. This Valentine's Day, you and Anna should play hive in the bath. That's the big thing. Make a date night out of that. Right at the Right at the bottom of the tub.

Get the shower going so it feels like it's raining.

Yeah. Oh man, that is that's a great idea.

But okay, all of that is like good, you know, fair fair selling points. You're you're setting a good victory here. But that's not a game she would have any interest in playing, like a two-player

but it have you suggested in the tub yet?

I don't think that's going to have the the the kind of pull

You never know.

if it's a game she has very little interest in trying probably. I love the yeah. I'm not looking for you to solve the problem for me. I can for you to hear me out and tell me that you understand how painful it is that I look on look at this on my shelf and every time I think should I get rid of this? I haven't played it in however long and even when I did play it I played it on Board Game Arena and I kind of like two of the three expansions but don't really like the third one. So if I did like what does it make sense to invest in the expansions if it's not even getting played? And even to the other thing is the two-player issue that we talked about episode three I believe, the two-players not enough time. I don't play two-player games that often these days. I'd much rather have a game night with three or more people. And so if I am going to play two-player games it's just like it's stiff competition. There's a lot of other two-player games I'd put ahead of it. So I don't know. I feel like again for the size of the package and the kind of like the amount of situations it fits into and it is a very cool game. Even just the way the theme of the bugs surrounding the queen like I don't know.

There's something unique about it and I feel I know it's not actually going to leave my collection for a while. This one is clinging on more stubbornly than Isle of Skye, I think.

Do you feel like you enjoy or would enjoy Hive less because of that like of the skill gap like playing it with someone else? You know what I mean? Like if you were playing with someone and that prevents you from playing it or enjoying the game in a way?

Um I don't know. Like so I actually I played this probably I want to say 15 20 maybe 25 games in a row with Gavin um like who we know in person but it's also in our I was going to say from our Discord but like a few years ago on Board Game Arena and we started getting pretty into it but I think it was the games after a while if you're playing with the same person and you kind of develop that meta of like what does this like to do? What am I, what do I tend to do? And then you start like I start getting into my own head about the thing that Dylan brought up in a past episode about like, well, this is the obvious best move, but then do I want to do the obvious best move or does the game start to feel scripted? And I think that's what bothered me is when I started to realize when this happens, I know that I have to do this to kind of unlock this, to be able to get access to that piece and to be able to get the queen. Now I'm going to have to do this and then it starts feeling like, well, I don't want to remember a series of openings or feel like I have to have studied and memorized the best series of moves or what to do in this situation.

Yeah, there's almost like with abstracts like this, it's like there's a level that you want to know, but then going beyond that, it's just it's now like it's too much. It's it's too it's too technical to get the most out of it.

Yeah, it again ties into what Dylan has brought up a couple times about optimization as well. It's like I really enjoyed it those first however many plays and then once I started playing it over and over and over, I was kind of like, I don't know. I also wasn't particularly good at it, but that that doesn't usually affect whether I like a game or not, but anyway. Braden, hit us with your third and potentially final clinger here.

Nice. Um Kingdom Builder, and this is the one that you gave me actually. And I'm considering it a clinger because I I don't think I've actually played Well, no, I think we've played that copy because we played it at the live stream. Is that your copy?

That was yours.

Well, it's my now.

Well, yes.

Um and I think this is the game This is the one that I added when Dylan was talking because it's the game that I I super accessible, fantastic that I really really enjoy, um but is not one that I'm going to be regularly pulling out to play and suggest because, you know, we've like we've played it a ton on especially on Board Game Arena. Um it's probably one of my most played games on Board Game Arena if not one of my most like

really good implementation.

Yeah. Like I have 55

games. I think it is my most played game on Board Game Arena. Um.

Amateur numbers, 55.

True, yeah. Um. So, yeah, it's it's I don't And I just don't see myself suggesting the physical version that much cuz like we like we've played it a bunch. We have that history and stuff and I play mainly with you guys. Like there's other people I would play it with, but like you know, there's just other games. But I think I don't see myself letting go of it because it's it's just such a it's a solid game. It's almost like an Ethnos, right? It's it's easy to get into. Really great game. It's not It's not hurting me. It's not It's not keeping me hostage, but like you know, I don't want to let go of it.

It's a It's a good comfort game too. Like that place for me, I should say. Like it like playing it even if it's something that is going to be, you know, my favorite nowadays with other games that are out there. Um I just feel like I'm never going to play it and be like, oh, I like that was a bad play. Um there might be frustrating things about it or it might show its flaws a little bit, but I'm never going to overall not have enjoyed that play and it will kind of feel comfort light to go back to just because yeah, I have played it a whole bunch and have good memories of it.

Yeah, totally.

Such a good game. Dylan, you got rid of your copy a little while ago, right?

I did, yeah. Yeah.

But I know it is on Board Game Arena and you guys know I'm a huge fan of Winter Kingdom especially, which I still have and Dylan insists. Honestly, Braden, I think I might make [snorts] that decision easier. Play Winter Kingdom a few more times with me and that might make it easier for you to move on from Kingdom Builder. Listen, I love Kingdom Builder. Don't get me wrong. Kingdom Builder is still an incredible game, but

I can see it. I can I can Like from the one time we played like four or five years five years ago maybe even like um I did really enjoy it. I thought it was great. Um and I'm definitely interested to play it again.

I'm just waiting for I'm

to wait out for Autumn Kingdom.

Yeah, that's right.

I'm waiting for Galaxy Kingdom.

That might happen. I'm telling you right now. Space Kingdom Builder, it's going to happen.

Dude, yes.

Doesn't mean you have to go into space.

[gasps]

All right, Dylan, what's yours?

In Winter. Sorry, go ahead. My last one is an interesting one. This is Enchanted Plumes. And so this is one that I think is going to always cling, and there's two reasons it's going to always cling. One, very small box. So it's really hard for me to like feel like it needs to go because it's not really fighting for shelf space. I slide it, it changes spots, I slide it wherever wherever it fits. It it it is not a space issue whatsoever. But on top of that, there's this nostalgia aspect. And it's nostalgia is the wrong word, but it's it's sentimentality, I think is what I'm looking for, where it's it's a game that I felt like I kind of stumbled upon, really liked, was able to highlight it on the channel, was able to show people. I know that we in like were able to influence some people discovering the game that otherwise would not have discovered it and bought it because of seeing it on our channel.

And that felt kind of cool to be able to have had a hand in that for a game that I feel like is is worth discovering because it's sort of this undiscovered gem for a lot of people. And so for those reasons primarily, I'm just like I it's going to keep clinging to my collection, but at the same time, I don't remember the last time I played it. And it's my own fault. Like I don't I don't suggest enough and there's a few reasons for that. You know, I wouldn't play it even though it goes to six, I wouldn't be suggesting it with six because of the table space it takes up. And I don't even know if it would fit on my table with six people. But but like two to four, two to three especially, like yeah, I I would play it and I would have a really good time. I just and there's probably a good chance that I would say in the next year or two I show it to um to Kelsey and and I bet you that she will enjoy it and maybe then all of a sudden it'll see this resurgence and get a bunch of plays, but I I feel like I've just I'm fine with it getting the amount of whatever amount of plays it gets at this point. I'm fine keeping in my collection and and having it be that just because I do really enjoy it and it does have this kind of special place for me.

It's kind of a real shame that we haven't played it again together since the first like couple times you you showed it to me and we played it that however many years ago that was now. I haven't gone back to it in probably a good four years or so and I I really like it. I want to ask you, do you think um it not getting played has anything to do with the fact that you like have and really enjoy games like Lost Cities and Arboretum that are so good at like you know Lost Cities is such a good two-player game. Arboretum we really like with three and four. Does that take it out of the running like sometimes at those counts?

Not anymore. No. It used to compete a little bit more with Lost Cities and stuff, but now it I I would be I would feel like I'd be using that as an excuse to say that that's why it's not getting played because I also have been playing my physical copy of Lost Cities and Arboretum's been played like once uh that two players for me with my partner and then I think another time we might have all played it or I played it with someone other group, but those aren't stopping it. No, it's it's really just um I haven't suggested it enough and I feel like next time like we're looking for that kind of length of game and it's say like the three of us, that would be one that I should just suggest especially if I'm hosting um because we'll have a good time and it and I think it is like a 45 minute to an hour game probably for three, so.

Yeah. I would say 45 minutes max. I don't think it would go close to an hour

Yeah.

from what I remember. Braden, you have played this with us, right, once?

Yeah. Yeah, I played it once. Um it was good. Yeah, I enjoyed it. I think um the decisions of like which plumes to pluck or perform um and like the way you choose to build up from there and like if you're making a whole another like spreading out. Yeah, it was interesting.

Yeah, it's a it's a great game.

Yeah. clinger here is Lisboa. So this is a 2017 release, Vital Lacerda. Um this was another one that was in a Well, this was in a different video actually. We did games we wish we liked more. Do you remember that one, Dylan? We did that in I think like 2022. So that was like yeah, almost five years ago. And this is one of those games I've described before like that it's a First off, a massive box and I should say right now for anyone who doesn't know, Dylan and I are Portuguese and Lisbon, Lisboa is my probably my favorite city in the world. And not that I've like not claiming to be some epic traveler or anything, but it's definitely a place that has a special place in my heart and play like buying I bought the game, you know, probably not too long after it came out. It was the second Vital Lacerda game I bought and played after Vinhos, which was another one obviously like set in Portugal.

And part of it is the my ties and like my love of Lisbon as well as the sort of like obligation like I feel like the sense of obligation to Vital Lacerda as such a like well probably the most famous well-accomplished Portuguese board game designer. I almost feel this duty to like try like play more of his games and like play this one more, play Vinhos more, all this kind of stuff. But I'm also at this point where like again, we talk about this board game quest and the older you get and the more games you have and all this stuff. And like am I ever going to really be someone who actively plays Vital Lacerda games? Or is this just like you know, for a long time I held on to this thinking like it's a cool thing to show even just to show people when they come over. Like I remember showing my dad who doesn't play board games right being like, Dad, look, there's a game called Lisboa and like showing him and like the artwork you see like the blue and white like the Portuguese tiles and it has the history of what happened with that big earthquake and stuff. Like there's And the theme is so rich. But again, we've played it. We played it together once, Dylan, at the cabin, like whatever that was now four, five years ago.

Yeah, I'd say five, maybe even six years ago. And we both liked it, but also like it took a while. Again, I've forgotten most of the rules by now. Are we going to play it again? Am I just holding on to this to like show to my kids one day? Like, yeah, I keep going back and forth on what am I actually holding on to this for other than the sentimental Like of the other one, you know, I don't have the sentimental attachment as much to Hive and Isle of Skye, whereas this one that that Portuguese factor and specifically the city of Lisbon is what's making this be like Ah, I don't know. I've only played it once and it was also pricey, right? It's a more expensive game, so there's also that like Have I given it a fair shake yet? Is there going to be a time in my life where I have more time for these kind of games? And like maybe I should play it one or two more times. I don't know. Where are you guys at with like Lacerta games and and interest in trying this or trying it again in your case, Dylan?

Uh, like there's Lacerta games I certainly want to try, but it's not something I'm rushing to or thinking about often that I haven't played them. Every so often when a new one comes out, I'm like, oh man, another one I still haven't played X, Y, Z, you know? Um, but it's something I feel like I'll get to at some point, the ones that I'm really interested in less so that I'll get to like his whole catalog.

I think I think the question I want to ask is one that Dylan has been asking and saying throughout this episode is like what are you what are you missing if you don't have it? You know what I mean? Like it is like I think the you talked about the sentimentality for sure, but like playing the game, like are you really going to feel like you're missing out by not playing it?

No, that's the thing is like [sighs and gasps] Again, as much as I would like to play it again, the aspect of thinking that I'm going to have to relearn it and reset it up and teach it to another person cuz I don't just want to play it solo. If I do, like I know I've heard it's pretty good solo, but I don't really play solo games that take like that long, or at least not the ones that I've tried, I haven't found the like that burning desire to go back and play them again. So, I don't know, like I guess I guess this feels like a tipping point of like if I get rid of this and Vinhos, it's almost like I'm I'm not going to go buy other Vital Lacerda games, and nobody in our group is the person buying those and teaching. Like it almost feels like getting rid of this is closing the door and saying I'm done with playing Vital Lacerda like being the one to buy them and teach them. Like if someone wants to host a game, Nate sure I'll try one out, but to get rid of this almost feels like I'm saying I am not interested in Vital Lacerda games anymore.

So, that's that's part of it, too. It feels like closing that door, which is also okay. Like it's okay to

It is. It is. Okay.

that about myself, I guess, right? Like more time for games, more time to play those Stefan Dora games and games and and whatever, right?

I think the only question I have is uh how much of the consideration to get rid of uh factors in that you could just get the smaller and more superior much better game.

The one that we had access to that I want nothing to do with ever again. No, it wasn't that bad, but it's uh just a shell a shell compared to I want to ask you guys. I mean, first off, are are there any other like rapid fire extra like did you have any honorable mentions you want to throw in in like a minute or two here?

None on my end. Like I said, I've got rid of a lot. Been ruthless in in the last little bit, so those are the ones I would feel safe uh and right sort of say calling clingers right now.

I I would say King Domino fits in like the similar of of um Kingdom Builder as well almost everything I said about Kingdom Builder just instead put a me saying King Domino, and that's that's exactly how I feel basically. I think it could swap in and out pretty much.

For me, I'll just mention I had that time you killed me was in consideration here. It's only about five years old. It was on the cusp and it's it's it's got that similarity to where it's like the two player abstract thing, but there's just so much cool stuff with the time travel and the different pieces, and I haven't When we played it, Braden, we played through I think it's like the first three or like we we basically didn't play quite with the full rule set.

Yeah.

So I want to actually play it a couple times with the full rule full set and see if I can maybe get into that before it fully leaves. And then I will lump in Trick Shot and Guards of Atlantis II. They're both by the same designer and and publisher, so and from Wolf Designa. And they're both like expensive games that you they're just group dependent. Like they're I've played them both um and they're both like very well designed games that I just don't Like they're very niche.

Trick Shot's so fun.

two player only. I know. It it's great. And I even got the extra dice so you don't have the issue anymore where you run out of dice and you have to set one Like you know what I mean? Um and Guards of Atlantis II is also great, but it feels like it's the crypto theme issue of like I'm probably only going to We're going to play it with four or six players and want to revisit it with the same people and stuff. So yeah, I'm not ready even consider getting rid of those yet. I do want to make more of a push to get them played, but uh those are some of the ones I had. So last thing I'll ask you guys then, does I mean I was hoping that you would say that there was more mental load before so that I could ask you now if the mental load feels any lighter, but uh does it? Do you feel any different Like has talking about these or talking about why we cling to them or like you know maybe getting some encouragement from some of us, do you feel any differently about clinging games in general or games that have clung on or these specific ones?

And is that going to make it any easier to get rid of some of these?

I I think just just hearing Dylan's mentality makes me feel like I need to uh cling onto more games and just so I can keep horting No. I think I think it's I think I feel will will feel better getting rid of games that I'm not playing because Yeah, there there is always going to be like these scenarios where But like if there are if there are I'm going to have games for those scenarios. I have enough games that covers so many scenarios, right? And I don't need one specifically for those, you know, that time where we have six people and all this other stuff. Still going to have a good time. And though I I don't need to have still exploring those other games that are out there, absolutely, but then needing to make those decisions and not just holding on to something that just for the sake of whether it's this is a great game, I should have this game, even though I'm not sure how I feel about it, or this could be the best game, but I'm not willing to invest the time on it, but I could, but I'm not going to, but I could, but I'm not going to, really, right? So really just being real with yourself, I think, so. And I think that's [sighs] If I take a breath, I feel like my chest is maybe a little bit lighter just thinking about that.

Excellent. Dylan?

Uh I feel like I I I'm I still have the same mentality. Like I I have maybe a little bit more clarity on these three just as I was talking them out and and whatnot, but in general, I just think that the last couple times that I was a little bit more ruthless than I would normally be with with cuts didn't leave me in any with any regret. Like the closest I have, and I brought it up already, to like a regret of a game I got rid of is New Fjord, and like I just borrowed it from you and I played it solo a couple times and we played it multiplayer recently and I'll play it more. So like I know that the worst thing that can happen is that I get rid of a game and then I'm like, oh now I have an itch to play it I really wanted again and I can't find it, but like can't find it like if I could if I if I was willing to pay more or whatever than I did the time before, I will find it unless it becomes like very very rare, and at that point, yeah, go back to one of the other 150 games that I have. So like I'm I'm not losing any sleep over it, I would say.

Yeah, and the rarity thing is interesting because if you were like if it is a game that would be tough to reacquire, you would know about its rarity when getting rid of it and that would factor into like, do you really want to get rid of something that's that rare?

Yeah.

I don't know if you have before anyway, right? So

Yeah.

Okay. Well, I'll I'll say right now that the mental load for me is a little lighter specifically on Isle of Skye and Lisboa. Cuz Hive I still think I I after talking through it, I think I still have feel like I have enough good reasons to keep it there and it's small enough and I legitimately do think it will get played a decent amount even if it's just like a phase of maybe showing my kids the game at some point or or what not, but um yeah, I'm going to make a point to get Isle of Skye to the table so that we can I can either finally let it go or maybe remember that it's better than I better than I thought and then uh yeah, this this might have been what makes me make the decision on Lisboa finally. We'll see. All right. Well, what are your collection clingers? You can let us know in the comments either of the YouTube video or wherever you have been listening to this podcast if you're listening rather than watching on YouTube.

Um so you can find our YouTube channel, youtube.com/all you can board. You can also find us on Patreon, on Discord as I mentioned. You can find these links in the show notes. Um otherwise, thank you so much for listening as always. This has been episode 22 and we hope you'll join us again in a couple of weeks for episode three. Sorry, 23.

Live long and prosper. Now, you may be asking, why did he say that? Cuz it's part of Klingon.

Wow.

Wow. I'm not even going to say bye. That's just Klingon and prosper.

Progress saved