The 28 Games i got rid of in 2022
Transcript
this video is brought to you by the three minute board game patrons keep us Independent by supporting us on patreon welcome to the games I got rid of in 2022 the purpose of these videos really is catharsis it's to go through the games I got rid of in the last year and really have a look at them and go yeah that probably deserves to get out of my collection and the funny thing is I looked at my collection while preparing for this video on Board Game Geek and I have 161 previously owned games now I have not done remotely now 161 games worth of games I got rid of content to camera before so I'm going to cover a bunch of games here but I'm absolutely positive there's more I'm missing so from this point on I'm gonna really track the games I get rid of each year so that I can make sure that this is a definitive sort of final version I might even do one halfway through the year uh if I get rid of enough games and I'm planning on getting rid of hopefully another 15 to 20 games in the next few months anyway that's just background stuff the real purpose of this video is to take a look at the games that I got rid of in 2022 and let's start it off and we're going alphabetical alien Frontiers was one of the games that really kicked off Kickstarter when it first hit Kickstarter was one of the first really big campaigns and the kind of game that got people really interested in oh we can crowdfund things and there'd be stretch goals and there'll be all this extra stuff alien Frontiers was there on the ground level and the thing is alien Frontiers is a
perfectly okay game and it's a really good game for 2012 but I only picked it up a couple of years ago and we sat down to play it my groups were like that's fine that is a perfectly adequate game and it probably fell flat because we played so many games that have been influenced or inspired by alien Frontiers but that doesn't change the fact that we sat down we it felt like a dated experience so alien Frontiers perfectly serviceable game and I'm sure there are plenty of people out there who are big fans of it but when we first encountered it maybe back in 2020 we're like yeah it's okay so that one's been got rid of Anno 1800 is a strange bastard of a game for a lot of reasons the is its thematic stuff you see instead of setting it in a traditional Colonial setting where they just kind of sweep the dirtiness of colonialism under the rug no 1800 boli goes no this is colonialism if it was done great which is a very strange Hill to decide to go live on and something that just didn't sit quite right with me in some ways I don't know revisionism that completely erases things is somehow less offensive than revisionism that just goes actually what if what of this terrible thing was actually good for you so that that was uncomfortable uh to me from from day one with the game the second thing is just how the game works it's truly an odd game you've got this
really weird win condition which is all about shedding cards you want to score a lot of victory points and you have these this big hand of cards and it gets bigger as the game goes on and you're trying to get rid of them and score them and to me that led to a really weird feeling in the game where I just kind of wanted it to be over at times but I still had these 10 cards to get rid of so I'd have to plan out all right here's my next 20 actions uh to get rid of these cards and yeah led to this weird end game where you're like okay I know what I'm going to be doing for the next 20 turns which is get that resource play this card chain that card play this card and it was just it felt like rote playing in the end the other thing with the game is the big huge collection of uh buildings and resources that you technically never ever ever need to buy if everyone else at the table if you're playing a four-player game um You probably can win if everyone else gets into building stuff and you just pick up a minimum number of cards and then just use their buildings and just bring them down so I've heard of people winning that way and yeah overall ATO 1800 from from mutton water so I really liked Australia and I love brass I think brass is one of the best board games ever made for me this this was a complete Miss like first couple of times I played it I was like I feel like I'm not getting this but this is a good game but in the end I was like no I get this and it's not that good a game it's not that it's not clicking with me it's just this is a really
really strange experience so yeah quite glad to be got rid of that one so betrayal at house on the hill is a bit of a classic and it's a game I've been critical of in the past as far as I'm concerned the first half of the game is complete utter waste of time it really is when the haunt starts that the game kicks into gear but the haunts are also so screamingly unfair or just bizarre at times the trailer Builders gate does absolutely nothing to change that I picked the game up because my friend Dan is running a descent into a Vernis campaign for us which was set in Boulder's Gate and then later Inverness so I was like oh cool yeah let's get a game that you know thematically ties into uh the RPG that we're playing and it was quite a good thing to play on a night where we weren't going to be doing DND but after playing it a couple of times with a few other groups it still has exactly the same issues as portrayal at house on the hill first half of the game is absolute bollocks and the second half of the game is a crap shoot whether it's fun or interesting or not and having played plenty of betrayal at House Of The Hill in the past I don't really need to do it again with Dungeons and Dragons and I probably should have known that before I picked the game up but I was hopeful I was hopeful black angel is another odd game I was sort of pitched to me as oh this is like Tri but Deluxe it's like you know the next version of 12 it's even more cooler and better and it just kind of isn't
it's a beautiful looking game um there's plenty to do in it but trois itself is far more elegant uh far Tighter and far more interesting to me I thought black angel was kind of a wibbly wobbly bloated version of um of Tor so I've got one um I had black angel I don't need both um again I don't think it's a terrible game it's just 12 was such a good core I don't think it needed all the extra gubbins put on it that black angel tried to do and it just it just didn't feel as tense or tight as the original so um fine enough game I would play it again but felt no need to own it I got rid of my copy of castles of burgundy because it is a terrible game and I absolutely hate it I actually got rid of my copy of castles of burgundy uh one because it was missing a piece um I didn't sell it I gave it to a friend of mine I just gifted it to him um because he really likes the game and he's really enjoyed playing it around here now the main reason I got rid of my copy of castles of burgundy is I've got that funky special edition coming um later this year and I was like well I've got a friend of mine who really likes playing in and he wants to play all of his partner so yep here's a copy um I've got another one coming I kind of will miss the game for a little bit because it is one of my favorite games now but he lives like five minutes drive away if I really want her back I'm sure he'll come over here and play with me as well so Castle's a burgundy I got rid of the
copy I don't have a copy copy but I will have a copy in the future so stefanfeld fans are don't murder me in the past I've talked about game Space where you have an idea that a game occupies a certain Niche so you don't necessarily need to have 10 games to do exactly the same thing for most people if they've got a game that does one thing they don't necessarily need a game that does virtually the same thing and that is why I got rid of my copy of the crew which is one of my games of the year a while back and that's because the crew 2 is just all crew mission deep sea it's just the crew but better to me at least there is no reason I can see to keep both copies uh to keep a copy of the crew and the crew too the only thing I can think of is if I had two groups of people around who both wanted to play crew experiences at the same time but then I'd feel bad that one was playing the crew and not the crew too because same game just with a few of the bugs ironed out and a lot more variety in the missions and a lot more interesting so yeah there's zero reason unless you're attached to the Space theme of the crew to keep the crew over the crew toe so I gifted my copy of the crew to a friend of mine this theme park is not the game it looks like when you look at the boxer if you look at the box side it looks like it's going to be a midweight Euro even on the light side but it's really not that kind of game it's more of a very tight very strategic dice manipulation game the
problem with it for me is that it's one of those games and there's a lot of games like this these days where there's a little bit of interaction out there up the front but there's an awful lot of doing computations on your own board so on dice theme park you put down dice you activate them and you move them around your Park and you keep scoring points and you can do a lot of the manipulation in your turn and it's this kind of puzzle you're doing by yourself a really extreme case of this is Merchant's Cove where everyone's got an asymmetric puzzle they're doing by themselves there's a little bit of interaction out in the middle um but most of the time you're really doing your own thing or rolling rights um where you're doing your own thing on your board and that's not really a A vibe or a feel I enjoy very much in games so yeah the dice theme park fine game uh but ended up having just not enough player interaction for me to keep around so I've moved that one on fired up with something a little different and the only reason I didn't keep it is it's too damn big the box it's just one of those Deluxe Kickstarter boxes it's ginormous and for me to keep a game like that it has to be one that I really like it has to be a terraforming Mars uh it has to be a superb it has to be one of those games that I really really want a castles of burgundy even um but fired up was a game that it's quite good it's a novel game uh it's about giant robots and stuff fighting each other but you're not really
controlling the robots you're fans in the crowd and you're trying to influence and bet on the outcomes so it's not quite as direct as I'm going to take my rogue one and smash you your you know influencing them to go smash certain things so there's there's a really neat layer of gameplay there and it's short and it's fun but it takes up way too much space and takes far too long to set up for what is essentially a filler game and this is a thing that's happening quite a bit in um board gaming in general these days is you have games that probably shouldn't be that big and that massive um and and they just are and really you'd like something simple so you could just put it on the table play instead of having to you know pull this giant box off the shelf get all the things out and set them up so yeah fired up quite a fun experience I would gladly play again but it takes up like an almost like an entire Cadillacs Cube spot it's a big big game and on that justification I ended up at my local Board Game Cafe I feel like I'm saying this a lot in this video but Fort is another odd game and it's a game that I can see a lot of people really enjoying but for me it just drove me up the damn wall the fact that you can't control anything for any extended amount of time that you put something down and then it gets taken away like uh well I'm trying to plan something but I can't play anything it's a very chaotic game it's a game where you have to adapt your strategy on the
fly but to me it just it didn't quite have enough um for me to latch onto like I can appreciate what it's doing and I can see why people find it fun but I found it really really frustrating uh because I like planning multiple turns ahead and Fort just said no no you're not allowed to do that you really have to take advantage of what's in front of you right now you can have a little bit of planning but don't expect it to come to any kind of uh fruition so yeah Ford very frustrating experience for me uh glad to get rid of that one but it's a game I respect for what it did because it has shaken up dick building and that style of game quite a bit and it's novel and it's interesting and it's Unique uh it just it just pisses me off so it's very rare for me to get rid of a game that I'm actually considering giving an award to in my end of year Awards so normally if I'm giving a game an award it's because the intend is that I'm going to keep that game uh but I'm contemplating giving an award to this game oath sworn into the deep wood and I've already got rid of it and the reason I've got rid of it is it's a game that requires a commitment I don't have at the moment so a friend of mine Dan who I've mentioned before who's running our DMV campaign he's on a model painting binge so he's been getting a whole bunch of 3D printed models he's been painting he's really enjoying the painting hobby so I gifted Earth's one to him because he's going to paint it we're going to
play the game we'll continue playing the game because we got through the first four scenarios we're going to keep playing the game later in the year or whenever the hell we get around to it because we all have busy schedules in our land but he is painting the game at the moment and we've got some of the pictures I'm bringing up now of uh what he's done so far so really looking forward to him kind of Hosting those games of Earth sworn we go around to his place uh he sets it up and he's like boom here's the painted monster because that'll be really cool it'll be really cool for us to sort of experience the monsters fully painted as they come out of the box and he's having a ball painting them so yeah also on a potential game of the year on three minute board games but I've already gotten rid of it because I do not have the capacity to paint models right now and that's entirely toddler driven like I'll be able to get around to painting models uh hopefully sometime this year but six months ago no no it was no chance in hell and uh is doing a really good job with them so I have absolutely no regrets passing on my copy of oh Swan to my good friend hi Frontier for all was a game I ended up with uh just out of a weird scenario so uh one of my patrons got sent four copies by mistake I had ordered one but four percent and he was like um do you want these back and they're like well it's gonna cost a fortune to ship them back to the US from NZ so keep them so he gifted one to me and it sat
on my shelf for well over two years and I just never got through setting the game up and playing through the tutorial like I just I found that the whole hyper Frontier for all game pretty opaque plus there was a huge amount of Desire there either because I've got space Corp I've got leaving Earth I've got two really good games about Space Racers and also like then there was a whole bunch of stuff around the designer Phil Eklund being quite blatantly an ass on social media a few times and I ended up being like ah do I really want to cover a game that I'm not really getting into I've got Alternatives in the same game space that I really enjoy and I'd rather just play leaving Earth another time than try to figure out this game plus the design is a bit of a deck so with those three factors I just like no I'm not going to get to High Frontier for all it's just it's a game I'm not going to be able to cover so yep flick it on pass it on to someone who will have more fun with it there's a few games I play each year when I look back and I go huh what the hell was that game really about and On the Origin of Species was one of those it's fine like you move around the boat you place things down um it's it's got like a nice science core and the whole idea of it's good but ultimately pretty just one of the many many games out there that doesn't necessarily you know push itself ahead of anything else so yeah this one simply left my collection through lack of interest and attrition
um as the shelves are only a finite size when a game comes in that I like I find one that I've either don't like or I've forgotten about and it goes on the out pile and that's just what happened on the Origin of Species I think it's a fine game if I recall but it's really just not hugely memorable ah perseverance Castaway Chronicles this was a really disappointing game for me I had so much high hopes for it it's my clash games and I've played a fair few mind clash games that are really really cool I love anacrony and acrony is one of my all-time favorite games it's probably my favorite worker placement game really cool game quite enjoyed her carry on as well um but perseverance uh took the premise of your landing on an alien world there's dinosaurs and somehow managed to suck all the fun out of it it was so cumbersome as a game experience uh it was also two heavy games in one so you play one version and then the other but that would be like that's a that's a lot of game and yeah there's just it was just a bit of a joyless experience so you set up a game going wow we're going to be like space dudes and there's dinosaurs and it's so dry it's really really dry the dinosaurs could have just been any kind of wooden Cube
all the different resource types all the missions all that kind of stuff all of the Thematic stuff just didn't come to life for me so yeah I've played this uh with a bunch of different groups and each time people were like yeah and it just it was a bit of a damp squib in the end which is really sad because it's it's beautiful looking uh it's got fantastic production values a lot of effort went into this game but the effort didn't necessarily make it that fun first and foremost I think a game should be fun it should be fun or it should be interesting or it should be thought provoking and I didn't find perseverance to be any of those I was probably a little harsh about On the Origin of Species calling it a forgettable game because that's that's kind of a bit mean there are some games that just don't stand out that's one thing and then there are games that stand out but all the wrong reasons and risk Warhammer 40 000 is one of those this game is an absolute MVP a minimum viable product it would be almost impossible for them to have done less to make the game uh work it's just risk with a few tweaks of the rules and the barest effort to uh put some 40K stuff on it some little plastic Minis and stuff and oh we played it and it was just we were laughing about how bad it was like Risk is you know it's not
everyone's cup of tea and I'm not a huge fan of core risk but some of the risk variants like Risk 20 2010 are legitimately fun and risk God swarm and we're hoping that risk will have a 40 000 would be one of those it'd be one of those Risk games where they go okay we've got the core system let's do something fun with us and no they did the minimum they possibly could to be able to slap the 40K logo on this absolute trash uh I can't even remember if I gave this one away or whatever I just like sold it for five bucks or something it terrible absolutely must skip probably not as bad as Monopoly 40K The Adventures of Robin Hood was a story game that we played a couple of scenarios for and I thought it was quite a neat little game it had some really cool stuff in it about how you flip the board over and the narrative was was all well and good it was a little childish for me a little um family family friendly I guess uh as far as an adventure game goes but perfectly fine and a game I'd be happy to play but one of my friends one of my regulars really loved it he thought it was just the bee's knees so once we've done the testing we've done the first couple of scenarios I just passed the game to him and said you love it so much uh you take it home so that was very much the case and I do this occasionally of when you finish the test session with a bunch of players and I haven't really felt the game myself I haven't really got into it but one of them really has I'll occasionally just go yeah you you
take this one um once I'm done doing all the photos for it it's yours to take home so yeah Adventures of Robin Hood uh I thought it was fine be happy to play it through or play it again if I had the time but someone I played with love did a hell of a lot more than me so yeah share some love pass a good game on role players are deeply frustrating game for me uh for many reasons first of all it's actually a reasonably good um dice placement game so you can compare this one to selfie stacker or Sagrada in terms of drafting Dice and putting them on the board and you know on that level it competes reasonably well with those two games the thing that sort of causes me a bit of I don't know dissonance with the game is the whole narrative that it's about making up a character because for me the important part of making up a character are you know who they are their identity their motivations their drive it's not the [ __ ] six stats they get and that's what this focuses on it's like oh roll up your stats that's your character and there's a few little bits and Bobs around the outside but to me I I think I like the idea of Call to Adventure more where the game and calling Call to Adventure Games a bit of a stretch it's sort of like a little storytelling exercise um but that's more about creating a character that does stuff and does things and isn't just 18 16 14 whatever numbers so role player something I
really wanted to like more than I did uh perfectly serviceable game and again um selfie stacker and Sagrada compare very well to it and those are both good games so I just got rid of it because I don't need a selfie stacker um Sagrada and role player and I've got rid of Sagrada and uh role player so I've only got a selfie stack left and that's largely because uh that's published in Wellington so I know all the people yeah role player ultimately the rolling up a character just that was something I thought should be cooler it should be more fun uh but ultimately it is literally just putting the numbers on the sheet it doesn't really create you an interesting or novel character most of the fun decisions are made at character creation here's a class uh here's your um ancestry and um here's your alignment uh that's all candid to you you don't really make that character it's just it's a side and then you've just got to put the numbers there so to me that's not character creation uh that's just rolling numbers Santa Monica is another pretty yet ultimately forgettable game that I just kind of got rid of because didn't really do much to justify its existence it's fine it's totally inoffensive perfectly harmless looks kind of cute leaves absolutely no impression after the first couple of plays so you know fine game pass it on to someone else
uh terraforming Mars Aries Expedition I'll give you a really short version if you want to know my long version I did a full video um on my issues with this game but to cut a long story short I found this a very cynical and very tepid game um very very forgettable and just totally uninspiring um it's kind of weird that I've now played three games by the designer of terraforming Mars and I love terraforming Mars and I think the other two are just terrible so there's uh this one and star Scrappers orbital they're both to me just not great games and uh at least orbital seems like it's original um Aries Expedition as I say just felt like a a cynical and boring um design thunderbird's danger zone is a game that makes me a bit sad because Thunderbirds 50th anniversary is one of my all-time favorite games it's probably my favorite Co-op game it's just a really neat game um so Thunderbirds was created by the Andersons uh jury and Sylvia Anderson and uh their son emailed me and said I said oh we've got a new game coming out we heard you love Thunderbirds so here it is I was like fantastic sign me up and with parts it's just not good it's just not a good game it's one of those games I think was put together by a toy store game designer or something they just kind of randomly threw some mechanics on on a piece of paper it's
it's functional as a game but if you're a hobby board gamer you'll find it really dated and really uninspired and it's just it's just a bit sad it's just a waste of a really cool IP um a waste of a really cool moment where I was you know being contacted by the person who runs the estate of Thunderbirds because they liked my video on the other Thunderbirds game and I kind of had to turn them down because I just after playing I was like I'm not going to review this because it's just there's not enough here to review it's just not a very good game so um yeah I kind of hate that it's one of the things in um the reviewing gig that I I don't like is when people are really amped to put something in front of you and it just it falls flat and you have to be the guy who goes I'm really sorry your thing that you've invested in is it's just it's [ __ ] awful it's it's just it's no good it's no good I had to do this with District nine um that was a game that I told them just do not publish this game as is it's absolutely it's not worth it it's it's going to bomb uh no one will play it and it'll be a horrible experience um they went ahead and published it anyway but that's a detour anyway one of the things I don't like in this hobby is or this gig of reviewing is you know being the guy who pops the balloon of people's hopes and dreams sometimes and that was Thunderbirds danger zone for me it was just having to write that email saying this sucks and yeah not a
pleasant experience I got rid of that bucket load of hammer related games this year uh mostly unpainted they sent me a whole bunch of games this year despite me saying um can you slow down because there's no way I can actually paint all these models little or assemble these models let alone bake them so I did a combination review on the channel where I went through a bunch of them I was like this is how I I played them with proxies because I didn't assemble the models so just to give people a rough idea of how those games worked but again there were just models were backing up um it's something I just don't have the time for with with Ann still being at home I can't paint um is late the evening like like it is now and that's usually when I'm filming um playing games or editing videos so painting has to come at the cost of one of those things uh for now so yeah I got rid of a bunch of Warhammer games some of them are okay but most of them are pretty pretty average so uh but if you want to know more about those Warhammer games there is a full video where I break through which ones are good which ones are ordinary and which ones are just downright terrible because Games Workshop really slung out a whole bunch of mixed quality this year another game I had super high hopes for was waste nights uh waste nights post-apocalyptic game it's got some
really good writing in it too there's a thing that kind of irks me about weights Knights is the writing is really really cool um the problem is the mechanics are really arbitrary so each time I played this and done it with multiple groups some players would have a really good run where everything went their way they got good roles they got good luck on the draw and they would get a whole bunch of power-ups and do really well and then there would be one or two players who everything went wrong for they're like fell a key role early in the game or draw a really unfair encounter and then just end up in this Doom cycle and this this is something that pops up in a lot of random event driven games you can get it on Talisman and Relic uh you can get an Arkham Horror to a lesser extent uh but there's more mitigation Nakamura but waste nights in particular it just felt so [ __ ] arbitrary who was having a good game and doing well and who wasn't it wasn't any player decisions it didn't seem like it wasn't anything we were doing as players to show our skill that was elevating us and making make it that I was having a good game but my friend wasn't because I'd made the right decision no it was just pretty much I flopped over a good card they flopped over a card that screwed them over and to me that got in the way of the good writing and the good story and the good ideas there because yeah uh having a couple people sitting at the table who are like well I guess I have to go heal again I have to get rid of
this radiation poisoning again um this stunk my yeah and it's not like even like uh this world of this war of mine where you know there's a there's a central pool of characters and if something bad happens it happens to all of you and waste nights you are like you're one hero so if your hero is having a rough time you're having a rough time so yeah ultimately I got rid of that one just because it wasn't that fun uh good riding aside and some really neat story design and scenario design in it but ultimately the core mechanics of the game were just a crap shoot and not that much fun if you ended up on the bad side of it and the final game on here is welcome to the Moon uh the big sequel to welcome to uh which is like a 10 part uh rolling right game with a whole bunch of different games in it I got given this in a bundle of uh review copy games a while back I tried it rolling right to me really they don't mix very often Hadrian's Wall is about the only one that I've really gone oh I like that and I and I quite like cartographers is okay uh cartographers I'll I'll be happy to play if other people bring it up but Hadrian's wolves really the one rolling right that I've got oh yeah that that's a bit of me and coincidentally uh my copy of Welcome to the Moon I got sold to Bobby Hill the designer of Hadrian's wool so who knows Bobby's
working on another uh big Roland right maybe some of the things from Welcome To The Moon will end up in there who knows um but I figured if I'm not enjoying a rolling right game uh he's probably the guy I should give that game to and go yeah here's some more you know um fuel for the fire of making the sequel to Hadrian's Wall so hopefully Bobby's had a good time with it anyway let me know what you think in the comments uh was I too harsh on some games uh I probably was but you know this is my opinion um yeah what are you gonna do have you heard me go I didn't like this about a game and then you're like oh actually that sounds like you might prefer this game instead let me know about those because that's far more interesting than being told actually the game you got rid of is excellent and I'm a big fan I [ __ ] I don't care I really don't care if you um if you really like a game that I got rid of like cool um it's gone I'm not gonna talk about it again but if you did hear me talk about something and go actually I think you would like this game really interested to know about that sort of stuff so until next time take care everyone kakitaano and farewell