Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ruining Game Night - Episode 2: The BEST and WORST Board Games for ANY Situation!

Transcript 20:09

hi I'm Adam Porter and this is the second installment of my new video series ruining game night which is a series of videos where I take a bunch of different possible scenarios some of them provided by you the viewers and I shuffle them up into a deck of cards I reveal a scenario and roll a dice to see how many players I've got and then I choose a great game to play in that situation but more than that I also come up with a game which is going to ruin game night okay a game that is the worst possible game to play in that scenario and guaranteed to upset that group of players so here's my deck of cards I'm going to shuffle them up these have all got different scenarios on the back some of them written by me some of them written by the various viewers who watch that first video and then I've got my die here from uh rolling Realms this is the probably the biggest fanciest die that I own I got in lots of trouble last time for using the word dice as a singular so we'll be sticking with die as long as I remember today and the next thing we're going to do is deal 10 cards off the top of the deck which are going to be the cards we're going to be using in this video so I've got my 10 scenarios I've got my die so let's kick off with the first scenario and the first one is an economic game so we've got a bunch of players who love economic games maybe they're a bunch of accountants or something like that and how many players have we got we got six players so a six player economic game um well I think in my previous video I talked about power grid and that would be a really good

example here but because I've already used that example let's try and think of something else we could play something really massive like a really big 18 XX type game that would be very economic so my preference for that would be to play Poseidon does it play with six players though uh where is it it's up here somewhere let me check the box Poseidon Poseidon caps out at five so I'm racking my brains with this because everything economic uh that I really really love seems to cap out at five players so whether that's Harbin gut or the the the the the rich and the good I think is the the new English title for that that's a classical game caps out at five uh automobile by Martin Wallace I really like that but again doesn't play with six modern art that doesn't play with six so I mean we could go really simple with something like for sale that's a very simple card game with a with a lot of auctions it's all based around auctions um so I suppose that is an economic game that plays really really well with six but I suspect if a group really liked economic games they want to get their their teeth into something a little bit more substantial than that I would probably go for speculation as a stock market game I don't think stockpile plays with six yeah probably speculation would be the way that I would go but I don't know how good it is with six maybe it would be fine maybe it'd be fine I'll probably tend towards playing it slightly slightly fewer so that would be

my choice well to be honest let's go power grid let's stick with power grid that's my honest choice is six player game economic we go power grid if um we wanted something that would ruin game night an economic game with six players that would ruin game night do you know I can't think of anything worse than playing a six player 18xx oh my word that would take I mean it takes hours and hours and hours to play those games and they're fascinating they're really good games but why do they have to be so so long I can't imagine how long it would take so I think that would probably ruin ruin game like bringing out something I don't know the name of all these 18xx games I only know 1830 and frankly I played that with uh two players once and we gave up after about seven hours I think so next up then is uh well the scenario is it's before 1995 so we're looking for a game to play we're in the year I don't know 1994. so we're looking for a three-player game that we want to play and it's before 1995. so I can't play anything from you know like Katan onwards nothing like that what would be a good three-player game before 1995. I I went to University in 1996. so if I think back to the sort of games that I was playing before I went to University something with three players because I probably would have played stuff like blood bowl and stuff like that that's two player only I think it's quite a hard task that three players before 1995. we could look at some of

our modern Classics surely some of them have been around before 1995. what about something like um like modern art you know was that before 1995 I'd need to look that up I'm not sure I don't think I can rely on that one oh do you know what I'll tell you what I'd go for before 1995 I'd go for Scotland Yard absolutely loved Scotland Yard as a kid still love it now really good with three players you'd have one player as Mr X you'd have two players as as the the um the detectives working together to try and catch him that would work really really well with three players before 1995. what would a game that would ruin game night before 1995 well you could pick most of them frankly um let's stick something like Game of Life on the table you know if you want to play that with three players most games before 1995. not all not all there's some good ones but most games before 1995 would ruin game night if you tried to play them today it's two scenarios down next one then is this one is from a viewer called Chris and he said we're still waiting for a player to arrive so how many players do we have we've got six players and we're still waiting for a player to arrive God what are we gonna play we're playing we're gonna be playing something with seven players and we've got to find something quick to play with six players I guess until that person turns up I you could play something like um happy salmon that would be really quick it works really well with six players I mean that's over in two minutes isn't it

they could turn up at any time you could play over and over again you might have a game of Doodle Rush in there as well very similar concept plays really well with six players in six minutes and No One's Gonna care if you stop halfway um I should say Doodle Rush is one of my own designs so I'm always promoting that one so those would be good options what would be a terrible option that would ruin game night you're waiting for a player to arrive some really long game I'll tell you what if you got stuck into a game of flux flux plays with up to six players and it might only take you a couple of minutes to play but the rules keep changing and the end game conditions keep changing and it can go on and on and on so you could easily fall into the Trap of thinking right I've got 10 minutes or 15 minutes before this player's gonna come we've got six Players let's have a quick game of flux and you might get it in there in that 15 minutes or you might still be playing an hour later so next up then the group they don't speak your language and again we're playing with six people who don't speak the same language what do we do there I mean you might go with something like I might go with something like a dexterity game um games which I think are obvious to what how you play you know you can just learn it just like that speed cups would be a great example so in speed cups you've got a bunch of different plastic cups you turn over a card it's got an image on it and the colors are laid out in a specific sequence you've got to rearrange your cups faster than the other players to meet that sequence hit the bell in the middle of the table you can learn that game without even speaking it's obvious what you're supposed to do you could there's a

similar game to speed cups called Ringle ding you could do it with dexterity games like Bando something like that would work quite well I don't know if you could play it with six it would depend on how many pieces you've got uh I think it plays up to six band do if you wanted to ruin game night for people who don't speak the same language well then it's fairly obvious isn't it something with lots and lots of text in it or even something that requires lots of communication between the players lots of talking between the players I think something like mysterium would fall apart if they didn't speak the language and that's odd isn't it because it does isn't a game that has any text in it in Mysterion there's one player who plays The Ghost and they reveal cards they can't speak to the other players it's a Cooperative game the ghost is revealing images and the other players have to try and guess what the ghost is telling them about a murder like what the weapon was what the location was who did it but the other players were working together discussing before they decide on their answers and it would be a really dull game if you played it without speaking to each other okay now that's odd because it should be a game that would be really good if people didn't speak the same language because there's no text so you don't have to read anything but actually I think it would be terrible so next up then is at a funeral reception and this was suggested by Arno and we're playing with four players so we've just had a funeral we're at the wake and we want to play a board game I think we're going to have to assume that the person who's died really loves

board games and they would really approve of it otherwise I don't think I'll be playing a board game at a funeral and awake so we're assuming that the person who died was a gamer and maybe their partner and their family they're Gamers too right so we're not offending too many people that said we don't want to upset the aunts and uncles and the other people who are grieving who may not understand that we're playing a board game so what we're really looking for I think if we're going to do this at all okay what we're looking for is something very discreet okay something I can play very subtly in a corner where nobody's even going to necessarily notice unless they're looking for it what about something like Quicks it's you know tiny little package roll them right you've got your little sheet of paper you can easily keep that hidden right you roll in dice so you've got to keep that quiet we'd need to have a soft surface or something like that but other than that you're not really talking to each other you can keep it nice and quiet I think Quicks would be a really good option there what would ruin game night and in this case of course we're talking about ruining the funeral wake the aforementioned happy salmon would be the worst possible option running around shouting high-fiving and fist bumping um frankly any game is probably not a good game in this scenario but thank you Arno for the suggestion next up then is somewhere I'll do the opposite okay so this is from Rachel and this is a game where it's very noisy and we're playing with six players lots of six player games coming up um I wish I

rolled like this when I play games normally so maybe again this is a game where we don't want to be talking to each other right because we're not going to hear each other it's going to get on our nerves something frantic I'd go um magic maze so magic maze is a game a Cooperative game you're not allowed to speak to each other and you're playing against the time so it's very frantic and you can get really sort of cross because the other players aren't doing what you want them to do but you're not allowed to tell them the only way you're able to communicate is by tapping this wooden token to say look I need you to do something but they've got to work out what you want them to do so I think that would be a great option for somewhere very very noisy six player game for somewhere very noisy where it really wouldn't work where we'd ruin game night got to be something which you know you've really got to think about you know you maybe you're talking to each other you really need to concentrate do you know let's go wingspan all right I think we expand with the expansion you can play with up to six players maybe even more right I think it's a terrible idea there's not that much interaction and the game gets longer with each player that you add and you know you're waiting for it to come around to your turn and your turns are fun but they're not that fascinating that you're going to wait for ages for it I love wingspan as a two-player game or a three-player game I wouldn't want to play it with six and I certainly wouldn't want to play it with six players in a really noisy environment okay so the T the the the the the players really want uh table presence they really like table presence okay and okay so we're looking for a one player game with lots and lots of table

presents a solo game with table presence that's an interesting challenge certainly game of table presence actually you know what I would play solo um the the smart games right these are not really board games okay these are puzzles but they're beautiful puzzles so beautifully made and um and they've got so much table presence but essentially you're going through a series of of challenges that are all laid out in a book you know so for example in the game I think jump in you've got to get rabbits jumping over mushrooms to get them into holes and they're all laid out the borders laid out in different positions depending on which difficulty level you're playing at but there's loads of these different games where you've got to achieve different things all single player with loads of table presents what would be a terrible game for a solo player who likes a lot of table presents I'm thinking something like decathlon by um by Reina canizzia decathlon is a a print and play game by Rhino conicio dice game sort of a yahtzee type game but you've got all sorts of different ways you're going to roll the dice in order to attempt to beat Personal bests in different you know decathlon events like different athletic events a nice little game no table presence because you're just printing it off on a sheet of paper one player has broken both their wrists and this one comes from Rachel again we're looking for a game with three players so we've got two players who have got

their hands functioning normally and we've got one player Who's Got No Hands probably best we go with something Cooperative isn't it yeah I would think because then the third player with the broken wrists they could you know they could join in with the decision making but maybe not have to actually move the pieces um so you could go with something like Forbidden Island maybe I'd go with something like that keep it simple what would ruin game night well it's got to be a dexterity game hasn't it something like flick of Faith they're gonna have a pretty tough time playing flicker face which is a brilliant little flicking game with uh two broken wrists next up teenagers who are buzzing from energy drinks um and this one is adapted from a suggestion by psychic Lord so thank you psychic Lord and we're looking for three players we've got three teenagers buzzing from energy drinks um so they're feeling a bit manic um we don't want to be playing anything too too thoughtful here do we we want to be playing something a little bit more chaotic a little bit more crazy you know turns out Doodle Rush and and happy salmon are so versatile um so many different scenarios they work for so I can't use those again so let's go with something else teenagers buzzing from energy drinks I should have a game for this I'm sure I have a game for this do you know what we could go with anomia here anomia would be really good it's

it's hilarious um or big bizarre you could play my game big bizarre very similar to anomia actually but it's just got loads of pictures but in both these games you're turning over cards and then if they match each other the the color or the symbol matches then you've got to call something out relating to the other card before the other player does so there's kind of a race element but the thing you're calling out you've got to get the words out right so you might have to call out like a flavor of ice cream or um or in big Bazaar you might have to make the noise of the animal that you've turned over but you've got to think of that before the other player thinks of their thing and you've got to shout it out before them you're falling over yourself trying to get your words out and uh everybody's laughing it's really frantic chaotic that would be a great game for a bunch of teenagers buzzing from energy drinks either in omia or big bizarre what would be a terrible game for teenagers who are buzzing from energy drinks it would be anything where you'd have to sit down and really think about it I'd go with something like Kaylas that's pretty dry isn't it Kayla's 1303 nice simple version maybe would go with the original version even but trying to sit them down teach them a good old dry Euro game you know um Castle Building worker placement um I think they'd hate that so last one now kids four to six years old and we've got four players oh that's going to be a fun session what would I play with four players of four to six years old this is easy I've got so many options for this I'd go with something like depends on the ability of the children between four and six that ability could vary a lot

but I might go with something like too many monkeys if they if the children were really new to gaming and you know that's great little game that sort of pretends it's a game it goes through the sequence nothing doesn't matter what you do but it feels like you're playing a game Sleeping Queens from game right as well that's great for this age range perfect for this age range a little bit more going on in that one I might go with something like Monza the racing game from Harbor that would be fantastic for this age range um those are all really good options what would I not play with kids four to six years old is going to ruin game night I don't understand the people who put down a big you know they stick down Scythe in front of kids or boast about the fact their four-year-old can play sides and you know really um so let's avoid that let's try and think of a children's game that is intended for children but actually isn't any fun okay we'll try and stick to the brief I mean I love children's games so it's quite hard for me to find one of those particularly I guess we're looking for something that's totally random and just a bit boring like um you know Snakes and Ladders Candyland those sorts of things they're going to get pretty tedious pretty quickly um you could imagine playing something like snap you know getting a bit tedious after a period of time um maybe that's a bit of an obvious answer but I think that probably is what

a lot of kids age four to six year olds are being taught by their parents when there's this whole world of other things you know can you imagine teaching the monser or or is amazing and it scales it's great for adults as well but you can play a nice simplified memory game um just with your kids Turtle Splash similar maybe it's a little tricky the flicking bit of it but it's such a great game for kids Moonlight Castle um Diego drakens on these are fantastic games for that sort of age range so there's no reason to be playing um Snakes and Ladders or or Candyland I would say not that Candyland is a big thing in the UK we don't see much Candyland around here like I know the uh the Americans do so there we go there is our 10 games for today we have made 10 game nights and we have ruined 10 game nights if you'd like to see more of this series and there's no guarantee that we're going to be doing it again you might hate it let me know and give me more examples so I can build up that deck I've already got a pretty nice selection of cards uh here which you know so there are a bunch that we still haven't covered between the gate the cards that I've come up with myself and and the other suggestions that people have given me so far but I'd like more and they can be as silly as you like um so keep them coming and if uh this video proves popular I'll make another one tell me if you enjoyed it by the way and you haven't seen the first edition go back and watch it here's a link and if you enjoyed the video and you haven't

come across the channel before then there are loads and loads of other videos on this channel you might want to check out including lots and lots of stuff about game design that's the main focus of the channel frankly game design game industry production but there are a loads of reviews top tens I'd like to dive into mechanisms if you're new to the channel welcome please check out the previous videos please subscribe comment share the video and I'll see you next time all the best

Progress saved