Ask the Chairman - Board Game Q&A 9
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another edition of ask the chairman this is a board game related Q&A session where you guys can ask me anything concerning board games as usual thank you to everybody who submitted questions and if you want to keep the series going then please do submit your questions in the comments below and I'll be sure to answer them next time and as usual sometimes YouTube hides comments so I can't see them um so apologies if you asked a question and I didn't answer it um it's not on purpose it's just because YouTube has hidden it from me for some reason um but before I get started on the Q&A session I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor k. co.uk who are my goto online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order but let's get started and we're going to get started with a couple of questions from Kor or Kure so thank you Kure uh the first question is what is the main difference between modern euros and Euros from the '90s or 2000s so in my opinion the general difference is that more modern Euros are either spins on the initial Euros from 20 years ago or they are more convoluted as in more rules pasted on top of more rules in order to make them different from other games so generally speaking the older games are less as more and the newer games are more as more because if you go back to those old classical Euros
there's normally just a mechanism or two maybe maybe a couple of mechanisms that are synergized with each other and that's it they don't try to bolt on all these um bells and whistles to make it really heavy and complex they're normally tough decisions but boiled down into simple mechanisms you know you think of games like raah or hand Tonica and they're very easy to play but the depth is there whereas new Euros you think of more modern ones like I don't know like T wakan things like that um there's just tons of rules in order to get the complexity and the richness rather than the boiled down simplicity so that's my general view on the difference between older euros and modern Euros of course there are exceptions and outliers but that's just a general statement uh he's also asked what area must have expansions so I'm not going to give too many because I think I'm going to make a list like this soon and you'll probably see some of these game um appear on that list um some that stood out for me were the backstage expansion to Shakespeare an aari game that was a fantastic expansion definitely an essential for me uh the ladies of twah which was a really good one for one of my favorite games just more stuff um but yeah just Vari as variety rather than additional rules the Arthur expansion to Merlin by Stephen Feld I thought that was a fantastic expansion and took a a decent game into a very good game and also like the nobility expansion for um War chest which again just adds more variability
more pieces you can play with without changing any core rules those are generally the expansions I like just more stuff rather than additional rules um he's also asked a question saying will I ever play a three or four player game of Katan uh if yes which expansions or house rules so I have played a three or four player game of Katan I I really don't like Katan at all so I wouldn't know what to suggest in terms of expansions or house rul I don't think I've ever played with any of the expansions so maybe they make the game better but as it stands I don't like Katan I think it's very boring so sorry about that one but thank you for the questions uh Richard has asked have I ever tried designing a game myself yes I have I do have a few basic concepts um but sadly I've not really had the time to do a deep dive and try to polish the game and make it work to the degree I would like it to um so you know who knows maybe um maybe later in life I will look to revisit those designs try to um you know sand the edges off and make it playable um but as it stands I just don't have the time to do that unfortunately but something I'd like to do for sure uh he just to asked what ingredients make up my favorite games um normally my favorite games have a good ratio of low rules overhead in comparison to the complexity and decks or so more of the depth of the game thinking of games like El Grande h of Tonica raah as I've mentioned those are the kind of games that I really love
they're very easy to teach get back to the table but still have lots of interesting decisions to be made every single time you play it and more and more importantly I think the time duration is becoming more important so I like games that are kind of 90 minutes maximum again there are exceptions but a general rule is that I like games to be under 90 minutes he's asked me what are my thoughts on board game Arena um I've only tried it a few years ago I did not like it at all I don't like using computers to play board games um I like physical components so I sadly didn't get along with board game arena and I'm not really looking forward to revisit anytime soon uh he's asked me do I give my family a wish list for birthdays or Christmas um not really no um generally you know we we don't go mad on Christmas or birthdays so normally my parents will say you know you've got x amount of money and I might spend some of that on a board game or two so um it's not like I'll give them a a list of games and they'll come back with a few of them you know I I I have too many and I have pretty easy access to get games so it's quite difficult for friends friends and family to buy me games um but yeah normally I'll just buy it myself and put it back for Christmas he's also asked do I have a cap on the quantity of board games in my collection yes but it's not number-wise it's more um capacity wise you know I have three uh 3x4 calaes behind me um that is my limit really I don't want it
to over spill anywhere else so um yeah if it starts going above that I will look to trim the fat and refine down but I've managed to keep it below that for quite some time now so um yeah that's that's your answer but thank you for the questions Richard Bradley has asked what are my favorite mechanisms excluding the big ones so I assume when you say the big ones you mean things like worker placement or area control um and I've come up with a few um I generally like games that have a degree of uh incentive building so I what I mean by that is the longer you neglect something the more something or resources build up on that particular action so that you're incentivized to take it you know thinking of games like foren or Puerto Rico I love that mechanism um also I like supply and demand you know and kind of know Buy Buy Low sell high that kind of thing I'm generally commodity speculations so you know I'm collecting this thing and I'm trying to manipulate things in the background to make the things I've collected worth more I like that mechanism as well and I'm sure there's tons more but that's just a few examples there um he's asked me would I consider rating fans shelves um I.E their collections um no not really I'm not really interested in judging anyone's collection you know everyone has their own um wants and needs and the things that they like I'm sure people look at my collection and say it's crap um and I love my game so um yeah it's kind of a pointless exercise I think because everyone's got their own tastes
uh he's also asked me what are my thoughts on nature as a theme so my thoughts are pretty neutral um I'm pretty numb about the subject to be honest I I appreciate that a lot of people would feel the way I feel about nature not not in general but in board games um as like the classic Dusty Euro know I love the dusty Euro themes the medieval themes the the Mediterranean trade trading themes I like that um whereas that seems to have been completely replaced by you know nature um for me it's not something I hate but it's not something I gravitate towards either so again I'm pretty neutral on the subject um but it looks like it's here to stay um and I can see why because it is so it's so widely appealing I suppose you know you can take it from a mature perspective you can look at it from know almost like a child perspective and it always works because obviously nature is so vast but I can yeah I can certainly see why it has taken off to the extent that it has he's also asked me um do I have any third party inserts for my games no I don't I've never I've never ever bought an insert for any game um I don't really see the points I'll just put them in bags instead um I know some people are very dedicated to um getting inserts Etc for me I've never seen the need he's asked me what are my thoughts on John deca's card crafting games and this is quite good timing because
recently I have played Mystic Veil um I thought it was fine I I quite like the game but for me it just felt like a generic deck building game and but instead of having more cards you are just boosting up the cards you already have so for me it felt the same now I do appreciate he's made more than one I've only ever played Mystic Veil so maybe the other ones are better and improvements On Mystic Vel I'm not sure but I'm not a huge fan of deca building anyway um I generally find them quite I make I find that they feel similar in their approach so again I'm not really that interested in doing a deep dive in any of his other card crafting games because the one I tried um I thought was fine but it felt pretty generic uh he's also asked me what are my thoughts on games with crazy high scores so I'm assuming you mean the kind of Stephan Feld Point salad style games um you know Stefan Feld is one of my favorite designers definitely top two or three and for me I like Point salad style games and I don't really see it as a matter of you know being a point salad I just see it as you know you get eight points on your turn I get three points on my turn therefore you've gained five points and I haven't so that's that's the kind of way I frame it I think they they do this to make all the players feel good at all times kind of gives you those constant do mean hits rather than saying you know you get five points and I get none I if you say I get three points and you get eight it just makes you feel a little bit better um but yeah all in all I don't mind it at all um
it's never bother me tons of my favorite games have Point salad feeling style games you know games like traun or castles of burgundy I love those games so I have to say that I like them uh he's also asked how big of a factor is set up when choosing a game now if You' ask me this a few years ago I would say not really an issue at all because I used to quite like you know before a gamees night setting things up and getting everything ready um nowadays I I'm quite opposed to games that take so long to set up because it is a huge obstacle for me to get them to the table I don't have as much time now as I did a few years ago um so I like I like games I can very quickly assess the components and get them all the way they need to be in a pretty rapid time so actually games with a heavy setup is quite a big um deterrent for me uh he's also asked what is the best size for a collection of games for average people so I assume you mean people who aren't fanatical about the um the board game hobby I would say you can get a really good collection in 10 to 20 games you can cover a lot of mechanisms um filler games to big big Gam tons of different um player counts being accommodated um so yeah I would say you could easily get a great collection in 20 games or even less than that but thank you for the questions I'm Brady I really do uh appreciate that
um sport cion has asked if you had to choose what would be my lifestyle game so this is a game with deep Investments with a committed group of players so for me um it was quite an obvious choice um I would choose a game called Lord of the Rings The Living card game so this is a a game where you have an assembly of characters and you are basically putting equipment on them getting a deck of cards and trying to beat these scenarios there's a ton of these living card games out there um and there have been kind of refined versions for example um I think the Lord of the Rings living card game was reimplemented to like Marvel Champions which of course has taken off to massive Heights but I did actually really like the system I thought it was a very cool game very difficult and it was fun to craft that deck of cards to try and overcome the scenario um but for me and I like variety so this question is a bit of a a jarring one really because I don't have a lifestyle game um I like dipping in and out of tons of different games rather than doing a deep dive into one particular game but if I had to choose it would be Lord of the Rings The Living card game cuz I thought that game was pretty excellent Zenith has asked is there a mechanism um that i' I'd enjoy that I'd like to see distilled into a smaller
game um and I wish I did a bit more research into this one here um let's have a look at some of the games behind me now I did like the the dice system in tetum you know either choosing a dice for the resources or for the action strength I thought that was a cool mechanism that could definitely be um explored further um other games let's have a look um know maybe the Concordia card system the idea of collecting cards for actions but also them contributing to towards your final score I think that's a great idea it's probably been done before in a small the game um so yeah that's a couple of examples there I'm sorry I should have um I should have looked deeper into into this question but hopefully that answers your questions zth Mike has asked what are my top three game creators I assume you mean Publishers um if I go on quantity wise in my own personal collection then it would be companies like Pegasus Spiel I've got tons of their games ala Rio Grande um after that is companies like crano Creations um deep print games are ones that are up and coming for me Lookout games Cosmos I've got got tons of their two-player line um so just a few examples there um he's asked what is the best game that I have played but never owned and ironically this is a game that you own and this is Nauticus by Kramer and keing I know it's Kramer at least I'm not sure if as keyling I really enjoy that game about building these ships um and yeah very cool
mechanically and I enjoy that one a lot uh sacko is my final um final questions here he asked why do I think that the board game industry has grown so much over the last few years and I reckon this is kind of a p kind of a perfect storm really I think more and more in modern days people are starting to lean towards those nostalgic more wholesome activities that they used to enjoy as a family um you know everyone remembers playing ball games when they were younger with their families and enjoying it and having that now with so much variation and things to explore and the sense of Discovery is kind of good blend of why it's popular now and for me and this is kind of a big reason why I personally enjoy Bard games so much is that it's a face Toof face um social activity rather than being behind a screen though I I don't like I don't like sitting behind screens I don't like playing computer games and stuff like that um you know we do too much of it in our in our work lives Etc so I love having a hobby where it gets me away from a TV screen and I can do something more tactile with more tangible components to play with to mess around with and of course that mixed with the social element and being an excuse to meet up with your friends and family um is again just a perfect storm of um things that make a great Hobby in my opinion so I I reckon that's why uh in general the board game Space is becoming more and more popular and to be honest I see it continuing to do so for quite a
while and that's a good thing so um yeah hopefully um more people will enjoy the Hobby and discover how many great games there are out there to play and but that's it really that's all of the questions that have been submitted again thank you so so much for submitting those questions because I do enjoy doing these and hopefully you do too again if you have any more questions please submit them below and I'll be sure to upload the next video if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye