Stefan Feld Board Games Tier List
Transcript
hey everyone today I'm doing something I've wanted to do for quite a long time and that is doing a staff and Feld tier list so if you watch my content regularly you'll probably aware that I'm a huge fan of steffenfeld he certainly is the most prolific designer in my collection so what I'm going to do is I'm going to take a look at the 20 games of his that I've played so there are gaps here but I thought this is quite a nice round number to do this list with and I'm going to put them into one of five different tiers starting from s tier which for me is the best of the best all the way down to D tier and to be honest detail isn't as bad as it sounds because I think even a bad step and fell game by his standards is better than most of the stuff out there and I'll probably still rate them probably around six out of ten or so so they're still pretty decent games even if I do put them in that D tier but before I get started on the games I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK put my go to online retailer when it comes to purchasing board games here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order okay so I'm going to talk about these games in the order in which they were released so the earliest game of his that I've played is in the year of the dragon which funnily enough is actually unlike most of his other games in fact all of his other games because of course steffenfeld is known for his point salad style games this is the polo opposite we're getting any points in this game it's like getting blood out of a stone a game of attrition where you have to weather the storm and overcome all these hardships a really cool game and I love this one a lot and
I was kind of in a dilemma here do I put this in the top tier of games at least an eight here or do I put it in the beat here because I do have to be in the right mood to play it I think because of that reason um I have just put it probably in The toppest bracket of a beat here that I possibly could so yeah this was definitely on that Fringe of going into the AIDS here and you know depending on which way the wind was blowing it might have fallen into that eight here but just because it is so polarizing and I can't always find a group to play this one because it is so punishing It just fits in to that beat here Arena Roma 2 is the next game of his that I played and much like in the year of the dragon this one feels unlike most of his other designs because this is a head-to-head two-player dueling game that uses dice to trigger the actions of cards there's some really cool Concepts and combos that go on here but generally these style of games don't work for me even if it is a staff and fell design so I actually paid this one quite a few times in a quite a quick succession and kind of tired of it quite quickly I didn't really see the incentive to go back and play it much more because I'd seen all the cards all the combos Etc and I also thought that it could be a bit grindy and a bit too long at time so unfortunately this one's right at the bottom of the pecking order for me despite appreciating it I put this one as a d tier game next up is Macau also known as Amsterdam if you're going by the steffenfels city collection this one is quite a strange game actually and one of the I think it might be the most recent game of History I played because I have got the Amsterdam version of it so bear in mind that if I am talking about a reprinted game with
the steffenfeld city collection I will kind of put them hand in hand with the original version this one is kind of a pick up and deliver game one of the coolest Concepts in Resource Management that I've seen in a long time where you can take a bunch of resources but you have to wait for a while to get those resources or you can take fewer resources but get them sooner love that mechanism definitely my favorite thing about it now I put this as a bead here because I am kind of exposing myself to its still I've not wrapped my head around the game completely definitely got a lot to learn with this one but I do think it has potential um I'm not sure if it will go into that eight here you know once it's all said what's all is said and done but I definitely like a lot of things going on here and I definitely think that once I get the um cards with the language on them because the version I have is all iconography on those cards and it's quite hard to decode what those icons are I think that will help my ranking of it or at least my positioning of it but as for now it sits at B tier next up I have a Luna Luna definitely a weird and wacky game kind of an area control Style game as you're activating these different kind of disciples on these different Islands getting resources moving them around I'm getting area control in this main kind of Central Area really cool especially as the game goes on as you start to learn how to maximize how to use all these different disciples and string bigger and bigger turns uh together um this was another game I I played a loads in quick succession um and I haven't played it for quite a while actually and that might be why I'm gonna put it at a beat here but I've
never had a bad game of this one I actually think it works quite well at any player count that might be a kind of a minor opinion or a minority opinion um but I think this is a really quirky game that is Luna definitely a strong beat beat here for me next up probably his most popular game his macular mopus this is the castles of burgundy now completely transparency I've never played any of the expansion material for the castles of burgundy I've only got the original a Leia version which I'm more than happy with because there's a ton of tiles in there but yeah this is definitely his most popular game rolling dice I'm collecting tiles building up a little Province getting combos so much fun this one I'm definitely fits that really nice Nisha being so Euro but still so fun um maybe the aesthetic isn't for everybody but I suppose if you want a more bright version a nicer looking version this newer versions come out since the original one that I have um this is an a tier no doubt about that um I've kind of had a long relationship with this one I've played it so much over the years and I still enjoy it and still anticipate all I'm eager to get it back to the table which is always a great sign after so many plays next up trajan uh trajan again if you watch my content regularly you'll know this is one of my favorite games that's currently ranked and number two on my overall ranking so this is the S tier game for me this is the Holy Grail of Stephen fell designs um a kind of a series of mini games that are strung together all held together through a mancala system absolutely genius um
check out my content on it it's just great and maybe I'll even release a new review on it because I think my other ones may be a little bit outdated but um yeah love this game um held its own in my top three rankings for many years now because I think it is a masterpiece so that has the S tier game and moving on to Bora Bora also known as Cusco with the newest reprint of it Bora Bora um got this into the table last year after much headhunting because it's quite difficult to get a copy of the original and dice placement Style game um High values are great because they give you more options or more powerful abilities but the lower value dice are more versatile and more flexible as you can sneak in and to take the same actions as other people loads going on here lots to juggle some cool little abilities and combos you can get um yeah I was enamored with this one really impressed and went straight in to an a-tier steffenfeld game for me yeah no doubt about that every time I've played it I've loved it so that is Bora Bora a definitive eight-tier game moving on to Rialto so Rialto one of his games that's not so much spoken about this is another area control and drafting game um as you're drafting these kind of columns of cards I Believe been a long time since I've played this one you're putting presents down on these different kind of um well segments in Venice I supposedly with the original and the newest one is um it's called New York City um but I'm not quite sure the differences between the two but I think they're minor um I did like this one I definitely think it had some cool quirks
to it um definitely down there for me though I was kind of venturing on a sea tier maybe a d tier and probably somewhere on that bracket so either a low seat here or a high D tier and you know maybe I'll be a bit negative here I'll put it in that D bracket to give a definitive answer so there we go that's Rialto moving on to Bruges also known as Hamburg with the reprint another game I've recently played due to the reprint and the original is so hard to find this is um kind of a step away from a lot of his other games I think out of all the games I've talked about maybe if you're not so keen on Stephenville designs I would still recommend maybe giving um Bruges or hamburger go because I think this game does engine building so well especially if you like card games because some of the ways these cards are used are fascinating it it's definitely the strongest example of a multi-use card game that I've ever played so many different ways you can use them which is the best way um you know building building the buildings getting the abilities from these characters using them as kind of tracks it's absolutely brilliant I think this game is great I put this as a b tier for now um but I do feel much like with Macau or Amsterdam once I get those language dependent cards because I don't have to keep cross-referencing the rule book and I do think it's got potential to slip in to that a category for me or that a tier so yeah this one's um definitely gonna we've got room for movement I think I don't think it's gonna go down but it's got potential to go into that a tier
bracket for me so that is Bruges also known as Hamburg moving on to Amerigo Amerigo very quirky game this one you are putting these cubes into a cube Tower and they're going to show these actions you can take because some of these cubes are going to get stuck in the tower some are going to filter through the actions you take are going to be um decided by the color you draft but the most numerous pool of um certain type of um of these tubes that come through is the strength of the action and you're going to do them use those cubes to do tons of different things such as exploring these Maps kind of setting up these colonies on these islands and fighting off Pirates at a really Dynamic and fun game um I love this one this is so much fun this is an a tier for me through and through and one of my favorite games ever so that is Amerigo 80 for sure next up another game that was kind of getting a bit obscure this is La Isla and there is a reprint coming out called Vienna now I believe out of all this stuff and felt Collection Games this one is going to be the most different compared to the original version so I'm not quite sure um if it's fair to put them in the same category with each other you know Vienna and La Isla but I know they are directly inspired or you know Vienna is directly inspired by La Isla now I actually really love uh the concept for this game as you are using these cards in much or in lots of different ways so I think you can use them to use the abilities on them and you can only have three of these kind of abilities active at any time or you can
use them to kind of raise the value of these different animal tokens you're collecting on this area control board I'm actually a really smooth game I love the little temporary engines you can build here but I do feel like after I played it a few times I kind of was done with it and normally I don't feel that way with Stefan 12 games and I have to kind of use that against this one so I think maybe maybe being a bit brutal I'll put it in a detail but maybe more objectively I put in a seat here so yeah I did like actually like the mechanisms here but yeah ultimately I've played it I don't really see the desire to go back to it so therefore I'm gonna have to put it in a detail unfortunately uh moving on though on to Aqua Sphere another game that's kind of overlooked and this is more of a programming game loads of cool things going on here um lots of ways to get points some area control going on and I love that programming where you have to kind of gain the actions before you can use them a really weird game that's that's for sure and I think this is one of my favorite stuff and build games which is again I'm probably in the minority there because most stuff and fell games don't think too much of this one but I was really impressed with it I've replayed it again and again and each time I kind of um you know reaffirm my thoughts on it so yeah atmosphere 80 for me right up up there with the best of them on to Merlin so if you'd asked me to put Merlin in a tier list a year ago I would probably rank it higher than it is right now so if you'd asked me a year ago I'd probably put it in a b tier if you ask me now I would put it in a c tier so
this is a kind of a Twist on a roll and move game really as you are allocating these dice to move these pawns around these rondelles and take these actions now there's tons going on here I have loads of ways to get points much with with a lot of other failed games you're fighting off threats um you've got a bit of error majority going on here as well with this kind of a sideboard and again one of the reasons this one has slipped for me is because the game is massively bloated if you want to get the optimal version of it you have to pick and choose from a bunch of different expansions and modules and it becomes a bit of a table hog there's loads to filter through there's the sort pack up you know set up and pack away and for me my tolerance for that has gone you know to the to this basement really I've got no real desire to do that anymore um so I think it's been hurt by my own personal preferences but I do like the game it's definitely my favorite looking Board of all time I think it's a stunning looking game but yeah the um the actual gameplay has been hurt by not kind of um ironing out those creases and editing and posting out one product that is the optimal version to play Merlin so for that reason it's gonna sit at a c tier for me moving on to another game that kind of came and went this is Forum trading them it's actually going to be quite difficult for me to kind of Huck back and bring some thoughts about this one because I remember liking it but if I don't have strong feelings on it it's not going to you know hold up too well um in my you know obviously in this Taylor so I put a seat here and I think it's worth a play if you like your fell
games I know some people think it is underrated some people think that people have missed a trick or two with this one and it should be back to it but hey it's very mechanical and that's saying something with a with a stepping belt game because a lot of these games are just purely mechanical but this one might be one of the strongest examples of that moving on to a game that I think I'm probably in the minority of in terms of where I'd grade this one this is carpe DM so Carpe Diem is one of his most accessible games it's a tile placement game with a really cool scoring mechanism I think that scoring mechanism needs to be used again where at the end of a round you are putting a clay Market in between two objectives and you're the only player who can score that perfect pairing or that exact pairing of those two scoring objectives then you're basically building buildings out in different spots on the board and getting points Etc now I put this at a c tier for me because I thought there was so much more potential to add more on with the tile placement part of the game because it was kind of not easy but it was quite straightforward and I thought I would like an extra wrinkle or two to the complexity and to the strategy I suppose but I I see what he's done here because it's good to have a game or two out there that do fit that medium light bracket and this one definitely has appeased a lot of Gamers who are looking for that style of thing from a felt game but for me I think I'd lean towards one of his other games before I would choose Carpe Diem so therefore I put it at a c tier getting into the more recent games now so we're moving on to bonfire so bonfire was for me this was a bit of a a
reminiscent game because after all the other games I've just talked about more recently this was a bit more of a hug back a bit more uh familiar with the staff and fell games that I really came to love you know games like aquasphere games like um you know uh Bora Bora and trajan this one you know is only a few years old now but it didn't feel a lot a lot more familiar with games like that so this one you are kind of claiming these objectives and then trying to achieve those objectives and you're climbing these tracks from your personal player board and you're getting help from these different Little Helpers you can use um very interesting game I think this is it has that kind of trajan minigame element which I tend to like I'm rubbish at this game I'm absolutely terribly at it I've never done well at it and despite that I still love it so this was a really difficult game for me to put on a tier list because I think if you caught me making this video as soon as I played a game of a bonfire I'd probably put it in a tier list because maybe my um you know recency bias has drained a little bit in terms of not playing it for a while I put it at the top of a beat here um for me but hey I think you know if you caught me in the right day it would be an 80 again moving on to uh the castles of Tuscany so this was kind of piggybacking off the success of the castles of burgundy of course it was a slightly more streamlined version of the castles of burgundy but I really did struggle to find who this game was made
for because I thought that the game wasn't super simple but it wasn't super complex but the castles are burgundy wasn't super complex either so I thought that you're cutting a lot of out of the castles of burgundy to make the castles of Tuscany where you could have just spent an extra five minutes teaching the castles burgundy and having a much richer experience so this was kind of left void for me I didn't really feel the need to have it or to play it anymore it was just completely rendered useless because the Castle's burgundy did everything it did but better and was not even that much more complex so therefore I put this one out of deed here not not like I disliked it at all but I just didn't feel the need for it so therefore castles are testicony what a d-tier game and moving on to Coco Pele Kokopelli really was a step away from his usual um tropes so Kokopelli was a card driven game a very simple engine builder put your play cards in front of you temporarily get the abilities of those cards until you played enough cards to score for them and then you'd lose that ability and have to maybe play another card to use it again I actually really like that push and pull of how long do I want to exploit this ability to how long am I going to wait to score it because if people score before me then they're going to grab the higher points tokens loads of combos here I love the way there's tons of different decks to use and you know initially I was really impressed by and I still like the game a lot actually now I did choose to remove this one from my collection because I wasn't really feeling the itch to go and play it and pull it off the shelf um maybe time will tell on me regretting
that decision I'm not quite sure um but I put this at a c tier game much like Bruges I think out of all the games that if you don't like Sevenfold games you might like this one because it doesn't feel like a staff and fell game again it is more card driven and it's a lot more simple and straightforward and has a very nice flow to it so I put a seat here and I think that's fair and the final game I'm talking about here is Marrakesh so this is the latest Game of his that um is of course unique um this was the only game so far in the Stephen Feld City collection that is not a re-implementation or a reprint now this much like um trajan is a series of mini games held together through a kind of central user interface I suppose and in this one it is a cube Tower which is kind of Superfluous I didn't really think the game needed that Cube Tower because it doesn't change the gameplay too much but you have a ton of different Minigames on your board you're synergize with each other if you're climbing tracks you're collecting resources you're getting and you're trying to get end of round objectives end of game scoring criteria um tons going on here lots of Euro deliciousness I suppose um and I put this a b tier for now because it is a heavy game of his it is a um again you might have to relearn a few times if you wait long enough to play it again and I currently am in that bracket where I've played it initially really enjoyed it but I need to play it again before I solidify my thoughts
and be prepared for a two-hour game here um and normally staff of all games are a bit shorter than that but I'm really happy that this has turned out it goes to show that Steph build still has the magic um and I beat it is certainly really respectable you know this is like an eight out of 10 for me which of course is is massive um praise and I think again if you like um if you like those mini games and Style style games like you know Bora Bora trajan um and games like that you're gonna like this one so um I think yeah if you like stealth fell games don't shy away from this one despite the very high price points which is sadly a bit of a negative with this one but that is uh Marrakech a strong beat here on First Impressions I suppose so there we have it hopefully this video has been useful to my fellow Stefan fell fans and if your tastes align with mine this might be a good list to help you prioritize which games to pick up um if you have enjoyed it please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye