Skip to main content
Loading video...

Should You Take Games to Game Night Without Reading The Rules? Your Board Game Questions, Answered!

Transcript 14:52

Hello everyone and welcome to another question and answer show here on watch it played. My name is Matthew and together with a lot of your help, let's answer all of the internet's burning board game questions. Our first question this month is what is going on with all these dual editions of games? There are a lot of dual games out there. two-player versions of popular games that we know and love. I wrote a small list. Splendor, King of Tokyo, Azour, Everdell, Living Forest, Flamecraft, The White Castle. That one surprised me, but I'm very happy about it. Duel for Middle Earth, Isisle of Cats, Quacks of Quidenberg. That is a short example list of the many games that are doing this, but it's not the newest phenomenon in the whole world. There are older games that did this. Carcasson the Castle. I love Carcass on the Castle so much.

Two-player version of Carcasson. Who thought that was going to be something that was ages ago. Medici versus Strazzi. Two-player. Those are both Kitia games. Two-player version of all the Medici games and the game Strayz. They made Medici versus Strazzi. It was fine. I suppose Lost Cities Rivals sounds like a two-player version of Lost Cities, but it's not. It's two to four player version of Lost. It doesn't matter. That's a complicated family of games. thing is I love two-player games. Playing games at two players is my favorite way to play games, frankly. So, I'm happy about it. And I've seen people who are positive about this new trend and people who are negative about this trend. And we've seen trends before. Micro games was the trend. Roll and rights and draft and rights and draw and rights were a trend. Legacy games are a trend apparently. But when you look at actually how many legacy games there are, it ain't many. My first real opinion about this is who's it hurting?

If it's a great two-player version of a game, then great, go for it. I mean, what's the problem? It's not like because this two-player game's being made that another game probably isn't being made, cuz if there's another great game, they just make it. People want to make great games. But making a two-player version of a game that is already incredibly popular, it sounds like the amount of risk-taking I would expect a board game publisher to want to take. The same as the whole making sequels to games, making reimaginings, retheing of games, making new versions of older games that people we already know people like. It's just not quite as risky as putting it all on the line and saying, "I've got an idea. I've got a new plan. This is going to be fun." Why do that when you can make a two-player version of a game that we already know and love? And often these two-player versions add new elements. You know, they are brand new kind of ideas and they hit and they miss. They're not all fantastic. Some of them I'd rather play the original game they're based on just at two players.

But it's a trend that's here to stay. because it's low risk. You can't expect people not to do it. I wrote a little list of games that I'd love to see two-player versions of, but I don't even know if they need to exist, but if they did exist, I would buy all of them instantly. And that's the reason that people make these new games, these two-player games. I'm gonna buy these instantly if they ever come out. I've got Five Tribes Duel. I love playing Five Tribes. I love playing it at two players. That's four. I like playing it at two players the most. I really love playing Five Tribes at two players. But if they release a Five Tribes duel, two tribes, I would buy that sight unseen.

I've wrote down Ticket to Ride duel, which let's face it, that's going to happen. Even though Ticket to Ride Switzerland is already the perfect two-player ticket to ride, it's so good. Ticket to Ride Switzerland are two players. H magnificent. But if they came up with a ticket ride duel, I'd get it. There's loads of games I would like to have dual versions of and I would probably buy them straight away because they come in smaller boxes and I already play mostly at two players. Would I need these games to exist? The best thing for me would be games that really do play better at wider player counts condensed into a great two-player experience. And those are the ones that are most intriguing to me. How about you? What dual versions of games have you really enjoyed? And what this is what I really want to know. What games would you love to see a dual version of?

But before the next question, here's Rodney with a very caffeinated message from the sponsor who made this episode possible. I couldn't be more excited about the support we're getting for this episode from Many Worlds Tavern. Because a couple of years ago, I fell deep down the coffee rabbit hole. Can you tell? If you like coffee and you want the easiest way to up your coffee game, you don't need all this stuff. This only happens when you get a little carried away. For good coffee, you want well-roasted whole coffee beans that you grind fresh before you make your cup. And that's what you get with Many Worlds Tavern. They know games are fun, but when you get people together for a game night, you want to create a great experience, too. And now you can surprise your guests with a fresh cup of coffee based around themes of adventure, coziness, treasures, magic, and even Aldrich horrors. Roasted at their facilities in the US. This is a company of passionate individuals doing exciting and personal work. I'm going to make an espresso using their homely house blend. But check out these information cards that give you details on the coffee that you can flip over and then use as tokens in Magic the Gathering. I know you can get your coffee from a variety of places, but supporting a company that shares a passion for gaming, uses beautiful and sustainable packaging, and roasts coffees that give you a variety of great tastes to enjoy, that's a choice I'm delighted to be encouraging you to make.

And if you want a quicker and even easier way into brewing a cup of coffee at game night, they also have instant options, and I was able to prepare a cup in the time it took me to talk about it. Not a coffee person? No problem. Many Worlds Tavern also offers a variety of teas as well. But either way, a big thanks to Mini World's Tavern for sponsoring this episode and helping make this show possible. If you like this show and want to help support it, pick up a great bag of coffee or tea from Mini World's Tavern and let them know that Watch It Played sent you. But now, back to the show. Question two is, ah, it's one of the classic board game gripes. I love a good board game gripe. Something that grinds everyone's gears. Is it wrong to bring games, especially large ones, when you haven't read the rules? How dare you? I've been in this situation. Hey, I've got a game. I brought it to game night. I really want to play it. Page one, paragraph one. You are No, I don't. Don't read me. Don't get the rule book out. Start reading.

Just No. Absolutely not. I understand. I get it. Why am I so understanding and forgiving and bitter? We all get really excited about a brand new game and sometimes we forget ourselves. We get so excited about it that we don't learn it. But we do bring it with us and then want everyone to play. You get one. You get to ruin one game night with the rules reading. Like not all rule books are made equal. We know that, don't we? I mean, if it's a small game, fine. Let's do it. Let's just read the pamphlet and get going. See, even some larger games. We got four pages of rules. You know, Kitia has done his genius again. Condense the fun down. Read me the four pages and let's get going. Any more than that, we're playing something else. I'm sorry. I'm standing up for myself and everyone else at this table. We're playing something else. Come back next week knowing how the game works. I personally, and I'm sure many of you are the same, do love to bring a new game to play that we're excited about. But I and you, I'm sure, try to learn that game as best as you can so that you can teach it really well and quick and efficiently to everyone else. I like to know what we're going to be playing that night beforehand. game nightpix.com. I've just thought great gamepicks.com. Go over there. Chaz does it. Brilliant. Just exactly for this. But I like to know what we're playing beforehand so I can then learn the game as well. So I don't have to learn the rules from what could be a dubious rules teach anyway. I want to know what I'm doing so I can win.

That's why I'm here. I'm here to win. I mean often when I bring a game to game night, I want to learn it as best as I can because I'm always I like a lot of weird games. I like a lot of games that haven't been in print for a while. And I like to learn those games really well because I'm often trying to I'm worried no one else is going to want to play it. Often they don't want to play it. I'm worried that no one else is going to enjoy it. I see. Well, if I know the rules really well and everyone's got rules questions, it can kind of negate some of those. Yeah. What happens when this happens and what happens when this happens? And those kind of like dismissive comments that you get, I get sometimes, you know. So, if I learn the rules really well, it kind of stops that. But look, no. If you bring a giant game to game night and you haven't learned it and you we're going to be reading the rule book, absolutely not. No. I'm uh you get one maybe if we're all feeling kind. And yeah, normally I'm more amicable than that. Not this time.

No, no, not again. Launching soon on Kickstarter, it's Goat Simulator, the card game. A dead serious card game where goats are the only thing that matters. This is a chaotic three to six player card game almost exclusively about goats and goat accessories. Don't believe a game could have this much goat content? Well, hang on. I've got examples. Goat Simulator, the card game, is a fast-paced party game where you draw goats, play goats, battle other goats, and gear up your goats to sabotage your so-called friends and unleash chaos so marvelous it'll make even the most stoic goat bleet with existential conflict. Who needs friends anyway when you've got goats? Not me, for sure. And I'm willing to bet the farm that you'll also agree with the publishers's assurance that this is quote the most legit goat card game you'll ever play. Wish you were playing it right now? Well, you can't. But you can follow the link in this video's description to the Goat Simulator, the card game crowdfunding page to find out more and back this game with the bleet that can't be beat. That was a Goat reference. And our final question this month is, if you could only take one small card game with you on a really long backpacking trip around the world, what game would you pick? And you can't pick a pack of cards. Oh, yeah. Well, you've caught me immediately because I would have said a pack of cards or I would have also I think cheating if I'd have picked a game that has just a pack of cards in it. I think you could probably find a whole pack of cards in the game The Gang. So, pick the gang cuz

it's got a pack of cards in it. The first game that I really thought about for this was The Crew Mission Deep Sea because The Crew Mission Deep Sea has so much replayability. It's wonderful. It's infinitely replayable. It's fantastic and I love it. But then I thought the crew isn't that great at two players and I'm not that great at making friends. So I'm not going to have more than I mean how many times we're going to you know it's going to be a two-player situation most of the time. I'm forcing someone to play a board game where we could be going to Matthew Pichu. I thought maybe not the crew and also the crew is it's complex, right? And no one wants to ruin a game of the crew by not knowing trick- taking games as much as everyone else. And then I thought about Lost Cities cuz that is a two-player game. And then I thought Lost Cities: The Arrivals because that's a four-player game even though again sounds like a two-player game. But I landed on a game called Infiltrators.

And while I landed on Infiltrators, and I think Infiltrators is going to be my pick for this. I don't know. I mean, there's so many times that that's not going to be the right game to play and I'm going to wish I had something else. But I love Infiltrator so much and which is surprising because I'm not the biggest fan of deduction. Coming up with a onesizefits all, great at all player counts, smallbox card game that could work in almost any situation from hotel rooms to bars to on the beach to in the middle of a rainstorm on a in a tent. I don't know if that game exists. Nana could work. Trio it's called now. I think Nana would work. I like the artwork of Nana better. I think it's slightly more charming. That's a good pick. But the game that I see always getting played and I've seen this because I do a lot of travel. I try to and I I see it all the time and it's people playing Uno. And it's because Uno is silly. It's very easy to learn.

Everyone knows pretty much how to play Uno, even though we all play it wrong. So, it needs to be it needs to be an Uno replacement because Uno plays a bunch of people. Two players if you want to play two players, I guess. And also plays unlimited amount of people. I think this is definitely a category where I say with a lot of your help, you know, I say that at the start of the episodes. I don't know what game to pick. You can't pick Fuji Flush. That's a wonderful game that I would always bring to a convention, but you need more you need more players for that to work. I really like this game called Little Tavern, but you need space to play that. It's great in a bar, though. You can play it like that, but you need room. I'm stumped. I am actually stumped on this one. This has never happened before. I think about these beforehand, but I've read what I'd written and I I I'm stumped now. How about you? What do you think that game could be? small box game, not a deck of cards that you can play pretty much with anyone. Large player group, small player groups, play it anywhere, easy to teach, easy to pick up, understandable, language independent. Do we need to design this game? Is that what's going to happen?

Should we No, no, no. That's crazy. What is that game? Let me know in the comments because I don't know. But what I do know is that that is it for this month. Thank you so much for being here. I really do appreciate you. I love doing these episodes and reading your comments and having that discussion. It I really do enjoy that. So, thank you so much. If you got any comments or questions or answers to any of the questions this month, let me know in the comments, especially about the game. What game is this? I'm I'm kind of like tearing myself apart here. What is that game? Thank you so much for watching and I'll see you next time. Bye.

Progress saved