Ask the Chairman - Board Game Q&A 5
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another episode of ask the chairman so this is a board game related Q&A session where you can ask anything you like about board games now as usual thank you to everybody who has submitted questions for this episode you know without those questions I can't continue doing this so if you want to keep the series going please be sure to leave your questions in the comments below and I will answer them on the next episode now before I get started on the questions as usual I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kea.ai go-to online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get a 5% off your first order but let's start with the questions and we're going to start with a questions from Mr J maretti who has asked what are my favorite or my top five um isari games so I'm going to I'm probably going to do a video ranking these games but um I'll just um read out the games so you know what they are but in no particular order um and you probably see some of them to over my left shoulder here um we have Salah we have Kus and we got Assyria mamies um is is another fantastic one and um also I'll mention spum as well so there are six there again I'll probably in the future do a ranking video um of all the star games that I've played he's also asked um do I have any favorite board game artists um yeah I suppose I do um familiarity I like artists like
Dennis lausen um artists like Clemens France because you know that you know connection between a lot of my favorite games and that art um is is so strong but I do like some other artists um particularly I really enjoy the artwork of um weberon weberon Santiago um he's made some really kind of eerie creepy cartoony style art which I really like and um of course more predictable artists like vinor D Tree um I think is immensely um talented so I do like the the way all that games look he's also asked am I going to any conventions this year um you know that that question was asked quite a few months ago so um I won't go to any more conventions this year you know I did not go to S and of course I did not go to Gen Con the only conventions I tend to go to are the UK games Expo um you know in June every year um in the UK of course and um sometimes I go to one called Devcon which is in EXA in the UK as well but I've never been to um I've never been to a mention overseas and I don't know if that's going to change anytime soon but thank you for the questions Keith has asked how important is Art and component quality um to me I would say you know to a to a reasonable extent um there certainly not going to be a game breaker um for me I know a lot of board gamers it's make or break when it comes to the artwork and design um you know and it can raise the um the kind of rating of a game several points for me it's gameplay play um at the Forefront of everything yes the extra
nice artwork nice production is going to um you know it's going to be a nice um luxury to have but again it's not a gamebreaker unless it's completely unplayable due to opponent quality I'm generally quite happy so um yeah probably less so than most board games I would say he's also asked and this is a good question would I ever rate a game a 10 based purely on the fun factor of a game and I had to think about that a bit and I I actually don't think I would um if I think a game is immensely fun but maybe there's not much to it and for example games like telestrations spring to mind I think the game is amazing um and you know I probably never had more fun playing a game but ultimately it's just drawing on a dry erase board and um you know drawing rude pictures is that going to be a 10 out of 10 maybe for fun Factor it should be but for um you know for gameplay mechanisms Etc I don't feel right in myself to give that a 10 so for me the 10 out of 10 games are the ones not only have the fun Factor they have the the clever mechanisms to support that as well so I still rate it very high you know telestrations is it's an8 out of 10 for me but ultimately it's just drawing on a on a dryer race board so um I don't think I would but maybe I could be proved wrong Someday I'm not sure um he's also asked what is my tolerance for take that um in board games and over time my tolerance is actually increased um I'm a lot less sensitive now to take that than I was um but there for me there are so different categories of take that you know there's meanness in games there are times when
you have to be quite aggressive to opponents but as long as that is to benefit myself I don't really see that as take that for me the kind of take that that I cannot really swallow that I don't like at all is when you are just targeting someone for no real reason and destroying something they've built you know and some some Euro games will have cards and saying you know still resources from a player of your choice why am I choosing that player well I don't know maybe they're winning something like that that for me doesn't feel quite right and um yeah never really a good feeling for me to use use abilities like that or have them done to me either so it's a very particular type of take that that I don't like but everything else I can generally um I can generally take but thank you for the questions Keith um till um thank you for all your questions you've sent a ton of them I'm not going to answer them all on this episode so I'm going to answer six of them I believe um and I'll be sure to answer the remaining ones on the next episode but thank you so much um without your questions you know I couldn't do videos like this so till has asked um his first question is um what is my biggest old game Discovery for game playay um and mechanisms so old I'm not quite sure what you meant by that but um a mechanism from an older game that's certainly not not new um that really stood out for me recently is the money allocation mechanism in a game called pergamon it's a very cool mechanism that I've never seen used before where you have uh an uncertified amount of money but you know the vague kind of
boundaries of that money and you are putting your Meo on this time track saying which order you're going to take money from the bag from the earlier you go the kind of smaller amount of money you'll take but you guaranteed that money where later you could be being a bit greedier but all the money could have run out of the bag by the time it gets to you um absolutely love that mechanism it is fantastic so that is definitely the game that popped into my head um when this question was asked he's also asked what is an older game that struck me as the most original um I think the Tower of Babel um was very original you know again an older game by Dr R Kenia um an area control Style game but you are trying to build these different Wonders of the World by using these cards but when you nominate to build one of these um wonders all the other players can put forward an amount of cards and you can either accept the cards to help you contribute to build it which will kind of add toward towards this AA control part of the game or every card you reject gives them a victory point and it really is a bit of a a plate spinning exercise to say you know what I don't really want to reject five cards because I'm going to give you five points but there but if I don't do that you're going to get all of the area control there so it's a really interesting game and again I've never seen that mechanism used before he's asked which older game hits the table most often for me I have quite a few of them um some I've written down here are Manhattan a game that goes back back to the 1990s I play it very regularly very simple area control game that's super easy to play and fast I'm
ingenious another kinia game um Vikings I play a lot and you know one of my favorite games of all time raah um hits the table all the time again going back to the late 1990s for that one he's asked um do I have any or know of any infinitely replayable um games that are not abstract games or cannot be small card games um there aren't many of them but a couple I've mentioned here are TWA I think TWA especially if you have the expansion um the amount of variability is huge and they changed the game a lot as well these from Cars you're using so every game feels massively different and also one that definitely I think is the most replayable game that I've ever had in my collection I don't have it anymore ironically is um legendary the Marvel deck building game so this game has like 20 expansions um so many different modes you can play tons I hundreds of characters hundreds of villains and um again the gameplay does feel very different depending on which characters you use and you know if you use some kind of random generator you will never play the same game twice so yeah that one is just off the charts with replayability um he's also asked what are the top games with a strong game Arc or sense of escalation um as I mentioned before I think legendary did a great job of managing the game Arc because somehow almost cinematically every single game of legendary would have this kind of
flow where you start getting battered by The Mastermind you would very get very close to the brink of Destruction and very nearly losing the game the tide would start to turn as your deck would get slightly stronger and um then ultimately you'd either kind of come to that final you know crucial point where you're going to win the game or you're not so I think every almost every game of legendary would play very cinematically and have a great game and also Rumble Nation as a simpler one great sense of escalation as you're deploying your troops on the map and watching them all resolve and Cascade into each other to resolve all these different areas and also I think condotti air has a great sense of um escalation as you are managing that hand of cards you know you don't get to refresh your cards every um every round you have to manage them quite carefully knowing which battles to pick knowing when to commit knowing when not to commit as the board populates you know which um which areas you you know are must win and you can't afford to lose so I definitely think the tension Rises strongly in Kier and the final question of tals for this episode um he's asked what are or do I have any recommendations for top intro games um but with substance and there are a ton of them out there and I don't think substance has anything to do with um how light the game is to be honest there are some very light games that have um tons of nuances and depth that you can explore um I think first rat is a great one um is it an intro game I I think so maybe on the brink it does have a few extra rules but first strat's a good one um
ingenious very easy to play but there are some special elements you need to manage and just a smaller card game I wanted to mention is nalia very simple Drafting and puzzly Style game there's a massive brain burner um but still rule set easy as can be anybody can play it but playing it well um is going to be definitely a mental strain so that is nalia but thank you so much for your questions um till again I'll answer the remaining ones in the future episodes um Sako has asked am I a game collector or just a gamer um I'm a gamer I don't really have any um emotional attachment to these games um you know I don't really like collecting them I like having a small as collection as possible but there are so many good ones out there that I need to have quite a big collection um but yeah I'm happy to sell any I think really I've had great games that I've sold because they're not getting played I've had very rare games in my collection before that I've sold you know I've sold games like Lord of the Rings to confrontation games like Zango uh nepon um yeah very rare games I've had um that I don't have anymore which would really well people would love to have some of these games in their collection which I got rid of quite you know without any hesitation really um he's also asked um what are my thoughts on new editions of games that are already already in print uh I'm kind of indifferent really um it's you know it's a commercial business if these companies think that a new printing is going to make the money then why not for me personally and that's all
I can control you know if I'm happy with an existing addition of a game and a new one comes out then um I'm I'm more than happy to keep my original one if if it satisfies me enough you know uh I know games that I have my collection are coming out games like Camala are getting a reprint soon games like craft wagon are getting a a reprint soon I'll probably keep my original same goes with Brussels I'm 1893 all getting reprints I've got all the originals um and I don't really feel like I need to own the um own the new ones but to be fair those games are out of print but know even games like castles of burgundy um two new additions have come out since the one I've had and I don't really feel the need to replace it cuz mine's absolutely fine so um yeah I'm not really um I'm not really bothered by it because it doesn't really affect me too much but thank you scko um Tony has asked do I ever use components of a game that I own as a proxy to play games that I don't own now I think I've done this a few times before now the only one I think I have in my collection at the moment is that I do use the mysterium components to play Dixit so a very easy one you the cards are very similar but you can actually use the other bits and Bobs to um you know to to track things as well um so yeah that's a very easily proxy um you can play dicks it with the mysterium components um I'm sure there are others that I've done but I can't um think of any that spring to mind you know immediately he's also asked um who do I Target to sell my cold Gaines to um
basically I just put them on um Facebook groups you know and then post them off to whoever needs them you know you're getting them straight to who they want to go to tons of board games you can see them within you know 5 minutes and um you know it'll generally sell pretty quickly if you price them fairly if I got something that I think is worth a bit more and has a bit more of a specialist buyer I might put it on eBay because it's probably going to attract someone who wants that particular game um and he's also asked um would do I worry that we'll run out questions for this series not really I mean I don't worry um worry is quite a strong word but um will I run out of questions quite possibly if I do I do no problem we'll just stop the series and maybe start it up again later but right now you guys are doing a great job of getting the questions in um and I don't want to do these too often you know I'm keeping them once every other month or so to um to give it enough time to breathe so um but hey you know who knows if I don't get any questions for this video um the series will be over and that's it really so um you it is what it is um Brett has asked um if I designed a game what would Inspire it or would Innovation be my main goal um interesting question and I I know I have designed a few games that I've played around with definitely not gotten published I've got some prototypes basically um to be honest being inspired purely by Innovation for me is a bit of a I think you'd be chasing your tail a bit I think reaching for Innovation isn't necessarily going to get you a great result because you're just you know being Innovative for the sake of it I
suppose um you know you want to have uh Innovation that's good you know I think quality is what inspires me I want to make a good game and ironically as I'm not I'm not a very thematically driven gamer I doesn't really doesn't really bother me but a lot of things think about when designing games or when I think about designing games are thematic ties you know I might see a subject that's not really been explored in BO games and I think well this mechanism would actually um you know link quite well with that game style or that that theme so yeah weirdly enough I think theme would inspire me more than anything and maybe some quirky some different themes that have not already been been seen before and would be the kind of the Catalyst of me designing um a game so yeah that's your that's the answer thank you for the question so probably be theme more than anything else um Board Game Fan girl has asked are there are the games from my favorite designers instab buys um no matter the style um no um but you know there are games like your designers like stanfeld I I've play play pretty much all of his games and I probably will play all his games yet to come out but he makes a very particular style style of game if say someone like Stephen Feld said I'm going to um release a trading card game I'm not going to play it I've got no interest in playing trading card games even if it is from someone like Stephen Feld so you know in a pure literal sense of the question the answer is no um but
you know is it realistic that Steph Feld is going to come out with a trading card game no it's not so generally speaking I I'm pretty sure that every Stell game yet to come out is going to be an instab buy for me um but yeah as a literal sense the answer is no thank you for the question um Alan 87 has asked how will Euro games evolve over the next few years obviously a very difficult question to answer there I have a feeling like the more complex fiddly Euros of the last few years are going to get toned back a bit and they're going to pull back into the more accessible style of Euro their coues such as Dev are putting out at the moment because they're making smaller box Euros that are attractive um more simple mechanically and I suppose have a wider audience you know games like the red Cathedral and um White Castle have done very well commercially I think maybe games like that are going to be where are going to are going to be the kind of focus for the next few years um do I see any major Innovations in Euro games coming out over the next few years I don't think so I think it's going to be a continue refinement and I'm Cher picking from different games to make new ones um because you know Euro games have been done to exhaustion and it's very difficult to do anything new without adding more in but now people are adding so much more in they're getting a bit you know it's hard to play these games because they're so they're so heavy and hard to learn and there are so many of them I think it's going to be a tone
back to uh to the kind of yest year of simpler Euro games but with a fresh look of paint nice to look at because for me all the best Euro games are ones that were 20 years old or so they're not to everybody's tastes in terms of the look of them because they do look that beige drab style you know um colonist going around in boats and trading resources that's not really the style at the moment it's going to be more anthropomorphic animals and Pirates and all this kind of stuff so you know I think it's going to be the oldest style of game rehashed with a new fresh lick of paint uh Bradley has asked um what games do I sleeve and why I pretty much don't sleeve anything um I only have a few games in my collection that are sleeved and that's normally because I bought them secondhand and they are already sleeved and the only games I would insist on sleeving are games um or kind of hidden traitor know soal deduction style games I'll definitely sleeve those um because of course the a Nick on a card can be the difference between um you know the game being playable or not that's the only reason I'd really sleeve the game I don't really see the need to be honest um he's also asked do I buy storage Solutions um no I never ever have bought a storage solution um you know any of the kind of folded space ones anything like that I've never ever felt the need to get one they're very expensive sometimes you know half as expensive or even as expensive as the game itself which to me is just ludicrous um I've got no issue at all
with just plastic snap bags get your components in there put them in the box and I'm good to go so no I haven't and he's also asked are there any essential expansions for me now I don't want to go too much into this because I have got a top 10 Brewing um of a top 10 expansion video or top 10 essential expansions um but the one that always Pops to mind and you know spitter this will probably be high on that video um is the Arthur expansion for Merlin I think it makes an average game pretty good so um I don't if you know Arthur it's a sorry Merlin it's a a Rondell Style stanfeld game that's very polarizing um but I think with the expansion I think a lot of people would find it a lot more palatable because the decision space is pretty much doubled and um the complexity doesn't go up too much and it's just a very well done expansion to make you know for me a good game great but a lot of people think it make an okay game good um so that's um that's my kind of go-to essential expansion that I normally talk about Richard has asked um have I ever heard or checked out the bones collector videos no I don't know who they are um I'll be sure to check them out because apparently their tastes are quite similar to mine um Jan koku has asked um am I excited for the age of innovation um game which is the kind of the newer version of Terror mystica um I'm not excited for it because I have terysa in my collection already I'm far from an expert on teror mytica I've not
played it that many times I need to play it way more and familiarized myself with it so I think I've got a lot more exploring to do with teram mytica before I move on to this one and I think you know I think teristic is a great game anyway and bit like the other question I'm more than satisfied with that game so why do I need another version of it um unless it's that much better but I've heard it's a bit more complex which is a bit of a red flag for me because terisa is kind of on the border of what I'm comfortable with in terms of gamees complexity and game length as well so anything more than that is just not going to get played in my collections unfortunately but I'm sure it's really good I've heard it's excellent um but yeah probably not not one that I'm going to pick up myself anytime soon Gary has asked and what are my thoughts about game group members refusing to play light games uh that's a bit of an awkward situation to be in I suppose um and it all depends on the power Dynamic if there's a group of four of you three of you are happy to play the light game and one isn't then you know screw them play with a three of you and they can just watch but if it's the other way around you want to play the light game they all don't then I'm afraid you're going to have to um you're going to have to take it on the chin and you know give your game up and play what they want to play um so yeah you know for me I'm always I'll play anything as long as you play anything I put to the table as well um he's asked following up from that put is it rude and should they just play I don't know if it's rude I don't know if it's rude at all um maybe it is maybe
it's not cordial um again I would say play their game they can play your game um you can't just to have it your way all the time and he also asked um have I ever have I ever said no to a game myself yes I have but not when it's the only option if we go to a games night there's a couple of tables going on somebody's playing a game that I'm not too keen on there I'm going to say no I don't want to play that one I want to play this one instead but again even if it's a game I don't like someone's bought it to a game tonight and they really want to play it I'll say yeah of course I'll play it because they're going to play a game that they not they might not be too keen on that belongs to me a bit later so it's all about give and take um and you know you have to work with the people you're playing with of course and you're not always going to have it your own way um but again if it's the only option then um then I've not said no but if there are several options then I have said no so thank you for the questions Gary um yeah definitely have good questions there um Edward has asked do my workmates know about my hobby um and that I have a board game channel um I think most of them do um I've had a few people ask about about it you know very politely inquisitively asked about about my hobby because I think a lot of people don't realize how big board gaming is now or how how many different types of games are out there and they have kind of nostalgic views on when they were younger when they used to play games with their family so they're quite you know they're quite curious about what the hobby is now and they've always been completely polite about it so yeah I've never had an issue there and um yeah I'm not I'm not shy about it I don't
actively share it with people but if they ask what what my hobbies are I will I will tell them um and fleap has asked um what us uh what my favorite easy to teach but difficult to master games a great question and again I have got a top 10 video Brewing um with this one so I don't want to say 10 games here I'm going to give a couple that will probably feature on that top 10 list I'm know War chest a game that I played semi- recently simple mechanically genius abstract Style game with um tons of nuances um if even raah I think raah is a very deceptive game where you might think at first well I'm just going to use my biggest bid chips to get the best Lots yes that's the idea but the delicacy and the intricacies of raah and playing it well I think are are very apparent the more you start to play it um and I think probably maybe one of the strongest examples of this question is Hannah makoi so Hannah mcoi is another game that could mislead you thinking it's quite random and not really having much control but if you play someone who is very seasoned and experienced with Hannah makji they will read the board State very carefully and have an intuition about the game and how to play it optimally so you know Hannah mcoi is a game that I went on a weird Journey with because I played it so many times with the same opponent um we were kind of terrible at first we got better and better and better to a point we were playing to a very high level I thought where the smallest mistake would cost you um and I've not played it for a
while now and all my skills have completely depreciated and I feel like I'm back get square one which makes me feel like Hannah mcoi is a difficult game to master because you need to stay with it and keep on playing the game to maintain your skills but great question there thank you uh flee zap so that is all the questions um again apart from some of the ones that till asked which I will answer on the next episode but thank you so much for submitting these some really fantastic questions there and again I want to stress if you want to keep this the series going um please be sure to ask some additional question questions in the comments section of this video and I will answer them on the next video but thank you for tuning in again thank you again for the questions if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye