Skip to main content
Loading video...

#21: Calculation Conundrum

Transcript 1:12:42

Hello and welcome back to episode number 21 of the All You Can Board podcast. I am Dylan.

I'm Carlo. And I'm Braden. Hey, thanks for being here.

Wow, a little additional intro uh introduction there.

Dylan and I are thankful too.

Yeah, I'm also thankful. Uh today's episode, our main course is a calculation conundrum. We're going to be talking about all things to do with math and outote scores in games. Uh planning your your turns around how much uh how many points you're going to get off of what you're going to be doing, whether we like that in games, whether we don't. There's a whole bunch of other stuff we'll get into at that. But before we get into the main topic, we're going to do an appetizer that ties in really nicely uh to it because it is sort of the game and game session I should say that inspired uh me to sort of bring up this topic and for us to go with it. And that is the game Sardia which Carlo owns and uh graciously invited us over and we played it uh just this past weekend as of the time of this recording. Um, so I'm going to throw it over to Carlo as it is his copy of the game to give us a little overview of Sardia for those who don't know or haven't played it.

Yeah. So Sardia is a kind of a remake of a game that was uh initially released as Krata Krea uh back in 2005 designed by Stefan Dora who's probably best known for sale which is one of our three AYCB Hall of Fame games as of today.

[clears throat]

So, this new edition was um from Plate, a publisher in Korea, and I think is distributed in North America by Crafty Games. And before we get into like a brief overview of the rules, I just need to mention this because we've talked about this game a couple times on the channel before, and I wasn't aware of the slight um I guess involvement of like generative AI art in here. And I guess there's a I'm not going to get too into the details. I recommend if you're curious about this, go check out the thread on the Sardinia forums called 2024 reprint. And um someone from Crafty Games, the North American distributor, has kind of commented on here to clarify kind of what happened. But the long and short of it is that the illustrator from Plate named Wanjin apparently experimented with a program called Midjourney as like a sketching tool early in the project. Um he was apparently really like not satisfied with how it turned out and ended up re-electrating the whole game. And the people at Crafty Games weren't aware of this at the time and they kind of talked to the folks over at Plate and voiced their concerns as well as concerns that have come from the community and they kind of made it clear like the kind of ethical concerns they have and they're all in agreement now that Wanjin won't be using AI as part of his design or art process going forward. And it was kind of just an experiment sort of I guess in the sketching phases. Um they reiterate that no artists lost work as a result.

it was just the same person who was always going to be doing the art anyway. Um, and it's not to excuse it entirely, but someone kind of said, "So, in other words, 20% of the art is AI generated." And I just want to read that response, which was, no. 20% by the studio's estimate may have AI generated elements like basic blocking or general composition since it was used in the sketch phase only, then rejected. 80% is completely AI free, done traditionally from start to finish, and 100% of the final product was drawn and finalized by Wan Jin, the illustrator. So we take [clears throat] that to mean basically that the in initial inspiration begun partially from generative AI art but the artist didn't like it. They scrapped it, redid everything himself and vowed to never use it again. So it's not, you know, 100% ironclad ideal necessarily, but I think it's the right response and I appreciate the transparency as well as the commitment to not uh do it again. Okay, so with that out of the way, let's get into a brief overview. And I'm not going to get too into the details cuz again we've spoken about this on the channel before and we'll if not uh altogether I will definitely do some type of deep dive on this game in the future, but it is basically an area majority game with 11 um rounds or scoring scoring rounds based on locations on the map. So you have this map and there are I think 26 uh different like these fort locations that are stationed at these kind of intersections of various provinces.

There could be either two, three or pro four provinces that will kind of like intersect with these fort spots. And it's kind of reminiscent of games like uh Sentry like Spice Road or or Golem Edition or Concordia Fyum etc. where you everyone has a hand of cards, you play a card, do what it says, the card stays down in front of you and then at a certain point something happens to kind of reset and everyone gets their cards back or the player gets their cards back. So it kind of follows that basic idea. Everyone has the same seven character cards at the start of the game. you can't gain any new ones. And on your turn, all you do is basically play a card, do what the action says, or sometimes there's two possible actions or whatnot. And then the next player goes and one of the roll cards is called the Sentinel. And when any player plays their Sentinel, the game stops. We do one of those 11 scoring uh phases basically. And then after we score, everyone gets their cards all back in their hand. And then play continues clockwise. And we just go through that kind of process 11 times. So sometimes someone might play a Sentinel really early and we'll score. Sometimes we might play out a bunch of cards in our hand and the round might draw out before we score. And of these 11 scoring locations, there's again there's 26 spots on the board and there's always going to be the first two face up. So you know what are the next two places that are going to score and the rest of the cards after that are face down. So just a real quick summary, the summary character cards are like there's an admirable which will let you either place a ship on the board or move some ships around. There's a commander which can let you like place a villager from your supply or gain four movement points to spread amongst the villagers that you have out there. And you only have five total for the game. Uh there's a farmer which let lets you harvest an

agricultural token off a spot. But in order to do that, you need to have a chain of your villagers connected to a harbor where you have a ship. There's an architect that allows you to build a fort. There's three of these that you have in the game, three forts, and you build it at an intersection. So, that can be pretty powerful because it'll influence all the surrounding provinces when those scorings happen. Or you can use the architect to build a village. Um, but there's a limited villages placed based on the agricultural tokens you've harvested. So, I won't get into the specifics of that. There's a priest card which lets you either place your own like everyone has one priest in the game. It's the most powerful piece and you can either place it on the board or move it up to three spaces and it sort of get it locks down an area in a way. I'm not going to get into the specifics there either. And then there's the queen card, which basically lets you duplicate one of your cards that you've already played face up. And then the Sentinel is the one I mentioned before, which triggers the scoring. And then it also gives the player that played the Sentinel the ability to turn over the next scoring location card, and they get to see the number. They reveal to everyone else as well. And then they decide if they want to put that on the bottom of the deck um and draw a new one or if they want to leave it there. So, whoever is the person that decides to trigger the scoring gets that extra control over what may or might not not score later.

Last couple things I'll mention is just that there's a limit of seven pieces per province. And again, there's all kinds of different I think you have five or six different pieces that you can place there. So, the provinces can fill up, but things are constantly moving around. Like only the villages and the forts stay where they are once they're placed. Everything else can be moved throughout the game. And the last thing I'll mention is about scoring is it's area majority as I mentioned and the provinces [clears throat] all uh are worth either anywhere from two to six points and the majority of influence will get the full points and it's interesting to note that the if players tie let's say three players tie they all get the full points and second place will get half of those points rounded down. All pieces are worth one influence except the villages which are worth two. So, I'll leave it at that just to give you some idea of the sequencing of actions as well as the amount of math that can come into play when things are constantly moving around and there's different pieces that have different values and that kind of thing.

So, what did you guys think of the session? Dylan, this was your second play and Braden, this was your first.

Yes, it was my first play of Sardia. And when you say like pieces moving around too, that's kind of how I felt about this session was there was a lot of like push and pull almost like uh a tide at times, right? Where you know at one point depending on how the scoring locations came out. For us it was like towards the end it was at at the one end of the map and then back at the very top of the map and trying to go back and forth and balancing. Do I move my characters over here? Um, or is it even is it worth should I try to plan for something at the top maybe? I don't know what's what's going to come up next. Do I Sentinel to to get some more control over that too? Right. I It was It was interesting. It was very similar to um other games I found. Um like in terms of like obviously being like area majority and that kind of thing like there's a lot of that tension that you would expect there, right?

um choosing different cards that give you different actions uh maybe similarish to El Grande if I will um in in some way. And uh yeah, it I I enjoyed it. I think that there and we'll we'll probably touch on this when we get to our main course, too, but I found it at near nearing the end it was a little anticlimactic. Um, and yeah, like the the choices you have to make of like when you're committing different buildings like your forts that can't be moved, I thought was also very interesting. Same with villages and the requirements you need to get that stuff. Like it all fed in really nicely. I'm surprised actually how well that it worked and there was some good tension there too. Um, but overall like I felt like it was um in the middle for me for Sardinia. What about you, Dylan?

Uh, yeah, this is my second play, I believe. Definitely not. Yeah, I think it's two, but definitely not my first. Um, and I I really enjoyed it. Um, I I have like similar like it was anticlimactic in some ways, but I also am like part of me well again we'll get into this in the main course more, but like part of that I'm not holding against the game because I feel like I need to play it more times to just see if the way that those aspects of what I felt in this session were just tied to like the numbers of the territories that came out in in the order that they did. I feel like how those territories get fought for and which ones get fought for last versus which ones like see a lot of traction uh throughout the game of players competing for it might make it so that that was just something that I felt in this session and other sessions feel like very climactic I guess like right up until the end. Um so that that's something I felt too but I I I'm just not sure if like whether that was just session related or not. Um, and then the other one which I I'll say for the main course is just yeah the the the mathy note element uh of certain things in Serena at the end is what contributed to it feel a little anticlimactic. Uh and that's something I feel like is less session related. It might just be something that the game sort of carries by the nature of what it is when you have [snorts] like uh scoring done the way that you're you're doing in this game. But um overall I really I really liked it. like um I I think I had a better time with my second play than I did with my first play. Um they were very far apart, so it's hard for me to really compare, but

I left I felt like I left with a stronger impression of it. Um and there and Oh, and the only other thing I would say is I just [clears throat] both of our sessions have been very long. Um and I I would say even just they've been too long. Like never where I'm like looking at the clock being like, "Oh my god, this game needs to end." like not in that way I mean but just like for this size of game for this content of game it's a game I would like I very much want to sort of like land in that hour and a half absolute max and I would feel so good about that length but like this last play was like 2 and 1/2 hours I think or 2 hours and I mean like obviously we're talking during it and there's things that we're doing as a group that are causing it to be longer but we both of our plays have been much longer than it says in the box and so either we are just very slow gamers at this game and that that absolutely could be case or we're just or this game is just like under represented when it comes to the time um that's listed on the box. But that's just the other thing I felt about it. It just it felt too long for for what it was.

Yeah, that's fair. I I agree. And we we laughed because remember we checked the box and said 30 minutes. It's not doesn't even say like 30 to 60. I'm like I can't imagine anyone playing this in 30 minutes unless you're just racing through turns and everyone's playing the Sentinel and round their second card or what? like it that doesn't make any sense to me. Um we, you know, we do have a tendency to talk a lot as we play games, especially when it's the first game of the night, we haven't seen each other for a few weeks, whatever. So, I 100% agree. If this is a game that's going to regularly be over two hours, that's going to really knock it down uh a spot or two for me. I think I would love for it to fall in that space where it's like Ree or Web of Power or Rumble Nation like those an area majority game that can play in like 45 minutes to an hour, maybe slightly over, like you said, 90 minutes max maybe. I feel like I'm always on the lookout for those because I just don't really like long area majority games where we're doing that for like 2, three, four hours. Like I've mentioned that before with like Rising Sun.

I just don't really like when we're playing those for that long. So yeah, it does feel like it's quicker than games like El Grande or Tam Hall, but uh it hasn't gotten quite down to as quick as I'd like. So yeah, my after our first play, however long, a year and a half ago or so, I remember thinking this could be an eight out of 10 or nine out of 10. And I feel like after this last play, I kind of settled on it's probably an eight out of 10. It's like a top 50 candidate for me, but I'm not really sure where yet. Fair. Um so that's a little overview of Sardinia. Uh that's our appetizer. But we are going to have more to say about Sir Daniel from the perspective of mathing and calculations and things of that nature. But before we get to all that, we're going to take a little break for our sponsor. All you can board is proudly sponsored by Victory Pints, our local game store of choice here in Winnipeg, Canada. We strongly believe that Victory Pints is the gold standard of board game stores, not just here in Winnipeg. Their main priority is having a wide selection of games, many of which you won't find elsewhere. They ship Canadawide, $15 flat rate or free shipping for orders over $200, and even take requests to try and order in specific games. They also have a used game section where you can trade in games for store credit and maybe even find some hidden gems that others have traded in. Note that the used game section is only available for in-person purchases and trades. Again, located in Winnipeg at the corner of Henderson and Hespler. Check them out at victoryypines.ca.

A massive thank you to VictoryPines for all their support over the years. Okay, welcome back. Uh we are ready to talk about calculation conundrum. And so if you're wondering exactly kind of what uh this entails and what we're going to be diving into, uh we're talking about the aspect of board games that really like all board games have uh to an extent but are you know masked better than others or intentionally not masked in other cases where you are having to like almost tied to analysis paralysis like in in that realm of things when you're having to really math out your calculations. A lot of times this will come into play at the end of board games when um you know you have your final couple turns and you're like what can I do to maximize uh what I'm going to do with these turns to to get as many points as I can. Especially if you're like competing for for the win um or you find yourself like down by five points.

What can I do to make that up? How's that going to impact what my opponent does? And you get into these sort of spirals of decisions and things like that. Um and so when that we've play um when we played Sardania, what inspired this is that that's um sort of how the end of the game felt. We had had what I thought was a really good session, but at the end I like even I can just only say from my perspective like I was really I was in second place or in third place or something and I thought I had a potential to get close to first. I didn't think I was in it, but it was like me trying to figure out what the most points I can get at that point is. And it just it involves a lot of calculations in your head where you're looking and say, "Okay, if I do this, okay, well that'll give me four points. I do this give me five." But then I also give up this one point to Carlos. So, it's really kind of a tossup and you just like find yourself in these spirals of like, you know, at some point do I just choose something and then, you know, I I just live with that. And so, that's the topic today that we're going to get into. And we're going to start this all off by kind of just talking about how we feel about that. So, like when we play games, is there a certain level of math it out that we expect going in? Is there a certain level that we don't want or that we like try to avoid games that seem like they're going to encourage a certain amount of that or do we do we enjoy it? um all the all all in that realm of stuff. I'm going to throw it to Braden first. When it comes to this type of uh topic and when we're talking about math and things out and calculating the score in that sort of way that leads to AP, how do you feel about it? Is that something you feel good about or what? I I like it. I like it a lot. And to me and how I approach it is when I'm playing a game that has like a lot of calculation, I'm looking

at different avenues to whatever it is, maximizing points. The the moment for me is like when you find the way you're like, "Oh, I could do this." And like it becomes something clever that maybe you didn't think of before. Um whether it's, you know, in the context of Sardania, right? Like moving you're like, "Okay, in the order of operations of this, I need to move my priest here to prevent people from moving their troops um over towards this area first." And that allows me actually then to Sentinel and that you know like doing something like that, right? Like that gives you that clever play that you had to figure out, but you had to math it out first to think of okay, you've got this here. If I move this, right, it it it can be tedious um tedious.

Absolutely. But I think like where that really shines for me, what I really enjoy is is finding those solutions. Um key to the city, London, right? like what is going to give me more points? Do I go for a boat strategy, which you know, maybe I can chain stuff from there? Um,

can I ask you a follow-up question? Yeah. Why don't you just sec? Cuz I'm interested. So, when you're mathing these kind of things out and and getting that like satisfying thing of like figuring it out, do you have like and I'm not saying a hard limit, but do you have like this limit in your head of like how long you're going to let yourself try to figure it out before you're like, you know, it's getting to the point where now even if there is a solution I haven't found, I'm fine not having found it. Like, you know, if you find yourself and you're sitting there and you're turning, you're like 5 minutes in, you're like, man, there's still like three other options I can consider and at this point they're all kind of similar. I'm just going to pick one. And does that frustrate you? like how how do you re like reconcile that?

Yeah, I think if it's going on too long then that's the sign of the game kind of preventing me not preventing me from enjoying it but I do feel that pressure for sure. So basically as soon as my turn is done it's like start calculating what the next move is what I want to do and then based on what everyone else has done until it gets back around to me maybe that slightly adjusts or changes. So it's like start with a goal and then adjust from there. Um that way I'm not taking too long. Um because sometimes I will sit there and like and I know that I was definitely guilty of this a couple times during my turn in Sardinia where I I had sat there and I was like, "Okay, I have one extra move for one of my guys. Which way should I move it? Do I move it here? What are the possibilities? Do I move it here? Where do I want to go with it?" And I was like, "Uh, I'll just I'll just move it here. It's it's fine." Um I don't

And then suddenly someone goes, "Oh, but there's a priest there." So you can't and you go, "Oh, okay." Think this

that's exactly

that happened a lot in this game. It felt like

Yes. Yeah. Oh, you can't. Don't touch it. You got to There's a priest. There's a priest. [snorts] Um so I like it's it's a fine balance for me, you know, something like um and I have here five tribes notorious for analysis paralysis. And just because there's so many permutations of not only like the choices you're going to make of like which group of meuples you're going to pick up, but also where you're going to drop those meuples and then how is that going to affect other people's choices of like what they have access to, right? Like just thinking about the branching depth that that is is it almost hurts my brain just thinking about that too. So, what I will give Sardinia credit for is it definitely limits your decision space. Um, for sure with the the cards that you have, those are the actions that you have. That's all you can do. Um,

and even even in what you're scoring for, right? Like you're you're looking at what's going to score now, what's going to score in one round. And so like yes, you can think of what might come up, but you're really guessing if you do that. So like you're kind of limited to like these two things, which is kind of nice.

Yeah. No, I completely agree. And I think that's very smart for them too cuz if you just if you had let's say like the whole board was deterministic of like what is scoring when I think that changes the entire game very easily.

Yeah.

Yeah. In that way.

Yeah. And when you mentioned the cards I'm glad you brought that up Ren because even though as the game [clears throat] goes on there's more and more pieces on the board. it becomes harder and harder to calculate later in the game. Certain cards like your farmer becomes useless when there's no more agricultural tokens out there and there's a you know your architect might not be useful if you've built all your forts and you can't build any more villages. So your focus starts to narrow a little bit in terms of which cards you can play even from a pool of seven. And I think that really helps manage a little bit how much it spirals with how many things are on the board to calculate.

Yeah. And especially with that the queen card which lets you copy a card that's already been played, you know, if imagine you having two queen cards, like you're just you're adding extra complexity or it's like, you know, the the joker, you know, whatever it is, right? Like it's Yeah. You'd be adding even more to that. So it it still gives you some flexibility, but it's also not out of this outrageous, let's say.

Yeah. And then so Carlo, I'm going to throw the same kind of question to you, but I'm going to kick it off with a different question for you, which is, does it frustrate you when you play a game where the ideal move can't be figured out very easily and you have to take leaps? Like, how does that make you feel when you're playing a board game versus if it's like you can sit there and figure it out and and figure out this is the ideal play for me to make on a turn? And

no, I I love that. I love when the lines are blurred and you get to and you have to take a leap. Those are most of my favorite games are ones where you can't calculate every single aspect. And I'm going to quickly mention some of this like there's a lot of intertwining of this topic with things like competitiveness um and optimization which we've touched on. We did the uh sweet defeat bitter victory episode. Some of this ties into spirit of the game as well, winning and losing all that kind of stuff. And for me, a lot of it is like the longer the game is and the higher the stakes feel, the more invested we all are at the table, right? It's not just me, it's everyone. And the more the calculational aspect starts to feel okay to me when like to spend time on. So when you're talking when you're asking Braden like how much time do you want to spend or what's the cut off? Like if we're playing a 20 or 30 minute game, I'm rarely going to sit there mathing anything out because who cares? In 5 10 minutes this game's done. We're moving on something else. like it's so inconsequential in the grand scheme of things. But if we're sitting down to play like a three-hour game and this big, you know, whether it's midpoint of the game or end point of the game, this is the difference between winning and losing. That's where I am have a lot more patience and a lot more kind of like grace for someone to be like, "Yeah, sure. Go ahead. Take five minutes on your last turn of the game. Take 10 minutes, whatever." Maybe not 10, but like I don't care. It's the stakes are high. This might be the difference between winning and losing. And I kind of want to compare it to like like if you were watching a 20-minute episode of The Simpsons that ended on kind of a whimper versus, you know, the finale of

Breaking Bad after you've been watching for 6 years or whatever. Like, yeah, the disappointment is going to feel a lot um bigger and a lot more impactful when it's something that you're so invested in, right? Like you spent years on this. So, that's kind of where it comes into play for me. And I want so and I want to ask you guys something here because I'm I'm going to put one of you on the spot. So I want to bring up a term that whatever it's not a there's a better term for this because it's too long as this but unnecessary convolutedness.

Okay. So things that are

okay to basically to make something that would otherwise be simple feel more challenging or time consuming than it has to be.

Wouldn't that just be convolutedness?

I guess so. Never necessary. But I mean, but but I mean you say but you saying unnecessary convolutedness kind of really hits

maybe necessary convolution.

Maybe it's needlessly unnecessary convolutedness to really drive.

Okay. But no, Dylan, I'm going to ask you two two math two math equations I'm going to give you to solve here. Okay.

And I'm going to ask after the math equation Yeah. After the math equation, I'm going to ask you a follow-up question. Okay.

Okay. The first math equation 10 + 10

27 20 20.

Okay. So, was that fun or interesting or challenging to you in any way?

No. There's there's a there's a slight bit of satisfaction. Maybe not for 10 plus 10, but there's a slight bit of satisfaction when it's something that like you know that you're like, I recalled this very quickly that you get, but it's very

Yeah. But in this specific example, you don't gain anything at all. And you did that in half a second, right?

Mhm.

Okay. Now, I'm going to give you another math equation. I'll say it fast, and if you need me to break it down, go for it. 5 + 2 + 4 + 6 + 3.

5 + 2 + 3. Is that 20?

The same thing.

Okay.

Exactly. So, was that any more fun or interesting or challenging or did it just take longer? Uh, no. Like I would say I didn't have any more fun doing that one. It just took longer.

It just took an extra 5 10 seconds. Right. So when games do this and they take something that is relatively simple, like most people that we game with can do these types of calculations,

but some games break it down into these like this minutia where it just feels like this kind of tedious like basic arithmetic that we all at the table know we would all be able to solve this basic math equation, right? So, I bring this up to lead into an example of a game of Babylonia that we recently played. Uh, it was a three-player game and Braden, it was you, me, and Dave, correct? A few weeks ago.

No, no,

no.

No, Mr. All right, then. It was me, Dave, there.

Oh,

someone was there with me and Dave.

Okay, so I'm going to give this example then. Okay.

Um, so we're playing a three-player game and Babylonia. I'm not going to get into the specifics of the game, but all all I need to get out of the way in terms of rules here is there are things that you can calculate on your turn where you say I could do this to get this many points, this to get this many points, and that's fine. But without factoring in the long-term ramifications of what that means, like what are the trade-offs, what am I not doing instead, right? All these kinds of things, you don't know. A lot of it is long-term planning. So to just say this gets me seven points right now versus four, getting the seven points isn't always beneficial. Okay? You can play for the long game. So, and there's these cities. Um, when when a city is scored, when someone gains a city, let's say I get my first one, and you guys each have four. Well, you each score four points because you already have four cities and I only get one. Okay? So, I'm bringing these things up for reason. So, we played this three-player game. It's very near the end of the game. I'm falling be I'm way behind both the other players the whole game going into like what I what ended up being the final turn. I think I was 40 or 50 points back. Okay. I was right at 100 and both players are at like 140, 150 or something.

There's two ways the game can end. You either get there's two or fewer cities left on the board or one player uses up the rest of their tiles. And I basically had a calculation to make. And I almost wrote it all. I almost just said, "I'm so far behind. Let's just do like there's no way I can come back into the game." But as the other players were taking their turns, I remember sitting there thinking and looking at the board and thinking, "Well, I've been building towards this whole thing. I've been playing the long game. I've I've been the whole time I know that I'm playing for this long. I have to at least see it through to see if it'll pay off. And I did a bit of a calculation. It only took maybe about a minute, minute and a half or so. And I ended up scoring 62 points on my final turn and I won by three

and triggered the end of the game on that same turn. And something and and I'm I'm going to make it clear right now. This is not the brag that you think it is because I told the other players they would have made the same move in my position. I don't think I did anything particularly brilli. It was just like I followed through on a plan. So yeah, I could take credit for the plan I made earlier, but in terms of that last turn calculation, we at the table all would have made the same calculation. It was, you know, I got this big big huge chunk of points and it was either I could do this one thing to get a certain amount of points and end the game or I could do this other thing and get a lot of points and not end the game and then I have to leave it up to my opponents. And I kind of was able to just go, "Yeah, if I do this, I get this many points. Yeah, they'll get a couple of they'll each get some passive points for the cities, but I think I I'm going to come out ahead."

And then I did it and it kind of felt underwhelming. Like I was torn because it's in one way I was like it's awesome that you can be 40 or 50 points back on the last turn of the game and get 60ome points out of my total of like I got a you know a huge percentage of my points my final turn with four tiles but at the same time it didn't really feel satisfying to win on something that everyone could have calculated and I think any of you would have done the same move in the same situation. So, it felt like a game, Babylonia is a game where like it blurs the lines so well for so much of the game, but because like at the end you can kind of just calculate it to make the difference between win or losing. And I I didn't like the way that that felt. It didn't feel like a satisfying win. Do you think Carlo that it wasn't satisfying because you could have been prevented in this long-term plan and because you like do you think that it was because a mistake was made by the players in this case?

That's a very good question. I will note that they were both in each other's way a lot more. This was one of those times where the three player problem did surface where I kind of was left to build this giant chain.

The carlo the Carlo Dylan problem. The cousin the cousin conundrum.

But I think they I think they saw how far behind I was and they wrote me off as like, "Oh, this guy's like 40 points. We don't need to worry about him." And they just let me keep doing my thing. So it was like, yeah, it was a mistake on their part for sure. And I think if we played again, they would probably remember like someone can come back with a vengeance at the end. and this this thing they've been building towards that hasn't amounted to anything can suddenly be worth a lot at the end. So I think I think it was a a matter of lack of experience maybe. But do you think that the I'm curious now. Do you think the part of that last play because what when you were describing it like that I thought you were going to say that was very satisfying. And so when you're describing it that it wasn't do you think that that what like what I'm curious about is is it because that last decision that got you to those points felt like not a hard decision to come to like it was a formulaic decision based on yes you crafted the strategy. Yes, you got to this point by your decisions, but now being at that point, it felt like this is just this is just what I would do with this strategy. So, it didn't feel it felt anticlimactic or like what exactly wasn't good about that for you?

I guess it just felt like there was an I don't want to say obvious best move, but to win the game

on a turn where the best move to me felt obvious even just with like

and I again I didn't really hold up the game that long. Like I was doing a lot of this calculation when it was the other players turns. I guess it was just like I like there to be a little bit more of like hedging your bets, going out on a limb on something. And it just felt like the closer it got to the end, I could kind of see if I can score this, it's going to be worth this many points. If I can actually get this, this might be enough. And then to kind of just be able to go, okay, do this. Yep. Yep. I'm going to math it out. And and I think part of that too is with Babylonia when the game ends. Like a lot of board games have that kind of like, okay, the tri end of the game is triggered now. You like reveal these cars. What else do you score points for? What else do you score? In Babylon, it's just like the game ends. What the score is is how it like there's no additional points to add. So it was purely like it was fully calculable and I think that's what made it unsatisfying to me.

Okay. So I I Yeah, sorry. Go, you go. Oh, I was just gonna say I think that like anticipation of being able to execute that long-term plan and then finally get to but I think maybe what's making it not as satisfying maybe in this case and you can correct me if I'm wrong here is that once you got to that point you were like okay I'm going to double check my work to make sure that it like this does work out to be and you're like uh-huh okay yeah and I win and you're like that's it's like an inevitable end like where whereas maybe if you didn't double check you were like oh this is this could be big this could be big I'm going to place it here I finally got what I wanted and then let's count it up now right like that the difference in moment I think is what maybe makes it satisfying or not

yes and I think it was the potential to be like if I do manage to win this would be a ridiculous comeback on the final turn so like I amped myself up for it, but then at the end it kind of just felt Yeah. I don't know why it felt I I I wish it would have felt better than it did.

I I'm very curious now if like if it had been something where you you won the exact same way, but you weren't able to calculate it as like as such. You had to kind of just play it out. You were banking on what the the other players were going to do a little bit more and whether that was going to shift it. And then it was sort of this like not not reveal but a bit of a reveal at the end being like, "Oh, and and I won." and if it would have felt better than sort of you doing the calculation and realizing okay well it's not a foregone conclusion but it's like okay well I win this game kind of thing I think about it's been so long since I played but I think about sometimes feeling that way when playing key forge knowing that someone was going to like for uh get one of their keys and like you can't stop them on your turn like you almost don't even need to go to the next person's turn or you don't even have to like play the next couple turns you're just kind of like okay well the game's over. Or I felt like that in Marvel Champions sometimes where you're just like you look ahead and you're like, "Okay, well, as long as the villain doesn't draw anything from the their deck this turn, I know I'm going to win next turn." So you can play it out, but it feels like

so the ending kind of almost ruins everything you got. Not ruins, but you know what I mean? Everything you did to get to that point because the ending is feels a little decided or on rails.

Yeah. So then are you both in agreement that it feels less satisfying when it's determines the result at the very end of the game whereas mathing stuff out earlier might feel a little more like it doesn't maybe detract from the experience quite as much if it's earlier in the game. I think I think like if out of those two options I definitely prefer mathing stuff out during the game than at the end. Um, I mainly for me it's like the end of the game, especially when you're playing a long game. It's not that you want the game to end, but like everyone's fought hard to get to that point and it can kind of feel like yeah, everyone's doing these calculations and sometimes everyone does it and the positions that people are currently in stay the exact same or one person moves ahead or the like not that it always goes that way, but I would say that there's often when you're doing those calculations, it kind of just turns into this thing where everyone's like, "What's the most optimal play for me to do?" and having to and you're also not going to rush someone when you're already at the end of the game to do it.

You're like, "Yeah, I like take your time." Whereas during the game, everyone kind of polices themselves in our groups and know and like you're like, "Okay, I'm going to I I'm going to take this amount of time or like ah, you know, I'm just going to make a decision now." And so like you can you're like, "I got to get better next time of thinking on the fly and those kind of things. it just if he hits differently. And so I I kind of like it during the game whereas at the end of the game it always kind of deflates the experience just a little bit for me in most cases and in some cases it'll deflate a lot more. But um yeah, that's how I feel about it.

I think it's the the uncertainty. Um you know, let's take Tigers and Euphrates for example, right? If we just had open information of who had what points, right? like the ending of the game would be like, "Oh, and you know, now it's now it's over um with everything, right?" Like in some cases that could be again if it's a comeback and then you get you rake in all these points, these tiles with um maybe a large brawl, let's say a war breaks out or something like that and then you win that way. Fantastic. That's that's great. But that extra reveal and having that tension up until the end I think is is critical in that way and then helps you know give that climactic moment at the end because we don't know what is going to happen. You don't know who is ahead. You might have an idea but you get this result that happens at the end. Same thing with El Grande too. Like the Castillo is a great example of that, right? Where, you know, things may look on the map one way, but then all of a sudden these reinforcements come out of nowhere and you're like, "Oh my god, what's going right?" Like this, it could be a game turning moment. I'm glad you brought up El Grande because this is a perfect little segue because uh one of the things I wanted to talk about is games that you know we think do that blurring of the line so to speak well um in the sense that like yes you can mask certain things out but there's an element of the

game that is going to regularly upend what you're trying to plan or that you just can't account for. Um and so El Grand is one I had written down. And I'm going to name a few more that I had written down. Then I'll throw it to you guys to kind of like let me know your thoughts on these or weigh in with your own. But I had El Grande as one, I had Root as one because of the asymmetrical powers. I think asymmetry in general, especially when you have your own distinct scoring conditions compared to other players, really helps. Um, modern art is one I had that I thought was interesting because you have your money that you're you can keep track of. But because it's so hard to keep track of everyone's money um and the values that they have, you can have an idea, but like and so you might feel like you still want to math things out, but really you don't know like if you need to math things out or if it's like helpless or you're already way ahead and and like the values of the paintings are changing.

So glad you brought up modern art cuz there's so many people out there who say you can math out the game and I I couldn't disagree more with those people.

There's so much information. You can math out what you're doing, but I just think that like to what end would be the question because I don't think you're ever going to really know what you're mathing against.

You can math what you get in that turn or in that round, but there's no way to say this is without a doubt the best move because there are again long-term ramifications that cannot be calculated.

I'm writing notes on my phone about who's getting what?

Yes. But do you know if three artists are going to score in that final round? What if only one artist scores?

you haven't seen half the cards and you know

and then the other one I'll bring up uh that I I've only played twice and but I found it hard to kind of do that kind of mathing out is Rumble Nation as well and that's cuz I heard it mentioned here and that's just because it feels like you're kind of programming on things a little bit and seeing how how it plays out. And um I find that that's in both the plays I've had it's it's I never cross my mind trying to like math out what the best play is. I've kind of just let the pieces fall. I've made the best plan I can and then let it fall where they may. So, factoring these in and then as many as many others or whatever other ones you want to um bring up, how do you like what other examples do you think are there of games that do that blurring well and like how do you feel about that versus when it's a little bit more more overt and say like a euro or a resource management game where you're very much just saying I can do this conversion for this amount of points. Braden, I'll throw it to you first. Yeah, it's Well, you you actually took I think almost all of my examples that I have written down, too. I I have Rumble Nation written down. Um I've got Modern Art on here. I I said Tigers and Euphrates as well. And I think the one the one point without giving another example because I I can't think. Oh, no.

It doesn't really blur the lines. Actually, I've got actually one for the uh opposite perhaps. Um I'm I'm not going to give it right now, though. We're going to tease it out a little bit. Um, but I think I want to speak to one of the reasons why this happens, right? Is that that tension to the very end, having that there and that uncertainty at the end. Um, maybe revive also is part of this as well, right? The actually it's it's a great example because those um what are they? Eggs like the different colored uh stones. You know what I'm talking about?

Yeah, they're not they're not eggs. Oh, maybe they are. Maybe I'm wrong. I don't thought I thought they were crystals or gems or something.

Let's go with crystals. It sounds way better.

The purple, orange, and ones or whatever.

That's right. Those like depending on like what the condition is for what you're scoring, right? Like you we don't you don't know until the end, right? So someone may have some sort of lead, but obvious behind whatever if you've got a certain amount of these, but you don't know what they're for, right? So [snorts] blurring those lines helps create those moments so that the game doesn't feel like a a foregone conclusion unlike something like um an abstract game, right, where everything is on the table. You're you're you can you can see the end kind of.

Yeah. And then throwing it to Carlo, but I'm going to again start you off with a question. This one's a tough one or one I think super interesting. Is it just as simple as like maybe more games need to have hidden scoring? Is it is it really that simple? Like if you just hide scoring and you don't know what you have to math out against, you can still optimize your turns, but are you incentivized to do that less if you don't know what you're competing against? Hiding the scoring is a big way. even just hiding the value of something like how much it's worth to different people or just hiding some of the information in a similar way as like when Braden brought up Tiger Neades. You you remember weeks ago I brought up the the the game where Raj beat me on like a the third or fourth tiebreaker whereas like that would have never happened if I could have mathed everything out, right?

So, I think a part of it is hiding some of the information and some of the examples I wanted to give for this section when you asked me games because I have some specific games to bring back to later, but it relates a little bit more to the topic of randomness. So, I'm just going to mention three games here and it's going to be comparing different player counts for the same game. So, arburitum with two players versus four. I've mentioned this before with two players. There's it is a way more calculational game because you have more uh you have a you know you take 50% of the turns rather than 25% of the turns. You know more of the information out there. There there's only one player with seven cards in their hand that you don't know rather than three players each with seven cards in their hand. There's only one, you know, fewer discard. Like it's all so especially the later the game goes, you can kind of be like, well, I know that I have these cards and this is in my tableau. So, I know that the three is either in their hand or it's in one of those cards in the deck. Like, you can do a bit more of that. Whereas, with four players, I like that that's more hidden and you kind of have to go off a hunch. I don't know. I know these cards. I don't have them, but I don't know who has them. Is this going to work out in my favor or not? Uh, I'll also mention Medici, uh, the Rhino Canitia auction game where there's a deck of these cards, and when you play at the max player count of six, there there's this one special gold card basically, and it's a 30 card deck, and every round you go through this deck of cards, and with six players, you use the full deck. So you can always kind of be waiting that gold card's somewhere in there. You know the gold card is coming out. But when you play with fewer players, you remove some cards at random. So then there's that kind of unknown like is it worth holding off?

What if that gold card was one of the five cards that was removed? It might not be there. You can't just say I know that if I get that gold card, I'm going to get this or if I get that other five green or whatever the value is. So I like when things are taken out. And the last game I'll mention, same thing is forest shuffle. And that's one of those ones where at the max player count of five, which I don't think we've ever played with five or would want to. Um, but you use all the cards. And we've talked about before that we think that game is best with two. And a big reason is not only the reduced downtime and stuff, but you remove a huge chunk of the cards in the deck. Yeah. And so every time you play from one game to the next, it feels more different cuz one game you might only see like half of the deer cards that were there. One game you might not see a particular tree that much. So each game has a bit more texture and nuance to it just based on player count and how many of the cards are removed to kind of again blur the lines of what you can calculate from the deck. I think that's a really good point about the player count because like that's not by any stretch the only game where there's a certain amount we see this all the time a certain amount of cards a certain amount of tokens res whatever removed or added based on the player count and yeah you're right like that alone can turn a game that can be calculated a little bit more easily even if not easy overall um into a game that's like I can't even begin to start because I don't know if all the bats in this game are in the cards we removed so like why do I go into baths and stuff.

So yeah, that's a that's a great point. I really like that.

And but yeah, you forgot to me the arburedum does hide the scoring like you mentioned though, right? At the end it's the reveal. Everyone show your you know jackaranda cards. It's like am I going to score? So yeah, I think to your initial question, I think you were on to something there about the scoring as well.

Um something uh I'll throw it in here because I I didn't don't know where else to insert it, but something interesting about uh the way I approach games. I think I might have brought this up to you one time, Carlo, to do with when we've played Han Hans Tutonica is I have a really hard time sometimes just accepting what the best like when I can see what I think the most obvious or what I think the best play is making that play. Sometimes me knowing what the best play is makes me want to make a different play to see how it goes. And that's just something about the way my brain works. Like even when like I I'm bringing this up now cuz when you played Sardia, I went first and there was a play I'm not saying it was the best play, but there was a play that I and I ended up making it that I looked at. I'm like, well, yeah, that card's going to I think it was that I put one of my towers onto a spot that was around one of the scoring cards coming up and I'm like, that seems like a really strong starting play. Whether it's the best or not, I don't know. I I was not going to make that play. I felt myself do what I normally do just because it felt like well the game is telling me that this is a good play and so I'm going to do something else and see if I can make it work anyways. And for some reason I default to doing that in games more often. And it probably I'm not saying it's cost me wins, but it's probably cost me performance just by being like cuz in Hans Tutonica I like I remember struggling with that the first couple times we played where there was plays that I'm like it seems like when you're first or second you want to go for this and I was like that just makes me not want to do that. Yes. Exactly. And so

that's something where it's like I inherently I think of my brain does not want not only does it not want to do calculations. If it does them, it's probably going to lead to me doing something that is against what the calculation outcome was. So it's just like it's an interesting way of approaching it.

Well, and do you think that comes more from you thinking that like the designer designed this in a way that they want to kind of set this trap and you you think it's like a next level like big brain, you know, 4D chess move where you're saying like that's what the game wants me to do. So, I'll actually do this and get them more points or is it more like you don't tell me how to score points, I'm going to score points my own way?

I think it's close. Yeah, it's a stubborn stubbornness. And it's also if something feels too obvious, sometimes I I have this weird thing where I feel bad making the obvious play. It almost feels felt in Babylonia. So you do understand like I if I basically like if if I'm first and there is a very clear optimal first turn that everyone at the table knows I feel like me taking that makes everyone even if they're not going to do it roll their eyes internally being like well Dylan went first and of course he made that play so I'm like well I'll leave that for someone else and I'll take another play. So like, and it make probably makes me look like someone who can't see these plays, but like I just like for some reason that's how my brain defaults and it it's like I have to fight against it.

And it's so interesting because thinking back to Babylonia, how you have this long-term plan, I don't know what it was about Trans Europa, right? Where on the second round we played, I had this plan where of where I'm placing my peg, getting you guys to come to me. And for me, when I saw that all start to develop and then I knew like before it got to my turn, I was like, "Oh, this this is over. I I've won, right?" Like for me, when I had that moment, I was like, "This was so satisfying because I tried something and it worked and it and like it had all connected and I placed the last piece and I was like, "Sorry guys, this is it's over."

Yeah. And that's probably that's like not even probably that's definitely like a a healthier way to approach something that you're putting the the brain power and the strategic thinking into to get to a desired outcome. But and maybe maybe it's because there's there's less like number crunching calculation here. It's just like connecting roots. It's like do all these connect? Yes or no? Um and it's it's it's faster. Like there's there's less involved there too. Yeah. So um container thinking of the ones that obuscate a value, right? How different containers are worth different things to different um players is also a really good example of this too. If everyone just knew what the values were and they were all the same for everybody. Like it's

that's a great I'm glad you brought that up because I something I'll mention about that is that like I felt super satisfied. So, I won the game of container replay and I felt super satisfied with how I ended up winning that game, but I didn't feel like I was making a calculation like being like, I'll get this many points, this points. I felt like I assessed the board and I saw a route to victory that was not risky, but like had holes in it if if someone did certain things to stop me. And so, me following through with a strategy and having it work and being able to win the game that way felt good. And that feels different to me than like making a calculation being like I can get this amount of points to win. So for some reason it's like I need there to be a certain level of like this might not work and and whereas making a calculation feels conclusive in a way that doesn't give me that I guess.

And I think that's what I was trying to get at with Carlos Babylonia game, right? Like you literally counting out the points versus you going, I know it's going to be a lot, but I don't know if it's going to be enough, but I'm still going to do it anyway, right? Like not double-checking, just going for it. And then being like, oh, it was actually enough. Like it's they're so similar, but one I think reaps a reward because you're kind of taking that like leap of faith. I have two questions that'll take us into two like more topics to kind of close up this episode. And the first one I'm going to throw to Carlo, the second one I'm going to throw to Braden. Um Carlo, because we're kind of on the topic, how does randomness and variability and stuff factor in uh to everything we're talking about now, especially with like blurring the lines and everything. How do you feel if a game the way I the way a game sort of blurs those lines is by introducing something that is like a level of randomness where it's like well there's really no I can't even think about calculating cuz I got to roll this 20sided die and I only get the result I want if I get above 10 or something like that. It's honestly randomness is I think the thing that I've come around to most in appreciating in board games compared to like when I first got in the hobby or like when I used to play chess back when I was a kid or teenager or whatever and now I don't really care to play chess because of how deterministic it is. So when you asked me earlier, I got a couple examples here that I think just handle randomness like just incredibly well. Uh can't stop. There

are people who will dismiss this game as a pure luckfest. whatever the odds are not only always changing as you move up these three tracks, these three columns, but it is impossible to calculate everything because even if you can even if you know even if you can calculate the permutations of each specific die roll, you need to also factor in where on the tracks that your opponent is and the state of the game. So like if you you know it's the first of three top of the three tracks wins. If your opponent has two points already, they just need to get to the top of a third track and there's only one track that they're near the top of. Let's say it's the number three or four. Yeah, odds are pretty low that they're going to roll there, but at the same time, this is, let's say I have zero points. I'm not at the top of any tracks. Sure, I could probably get to the top of the seven or the eight track. Those are common, you know, roles. But my only way to stop my opponent really is to try to beat them on that number four track. Even though the odds are way not in my favor, if I don't go for that chance, like there's a very little chance I can win. But all those factors, there's no way, there's no math equation to factor all that in. So you have to take a leap one way or another and it's a lot of it just comes down to like gut instinct or kind of understanding a bit of the probability and kind of hedging your bets and just leaning towards something.

And would you say that you enjoy more the idea of kind of weighing probability and and risk versus like cuz prob like weighing probability and percentage like that's that could be people could view that as a calculation but it's different in the sense like you're not seeing like this gets me five points. You're seeing this gives me x amount of percentage chance versus this. How am I going to take that risk? You prefer that probability.

Absolutely. Because when you pull it off and it wasn't a known that's that's what it comes down to is kind of what I mentioned before about the Babylonian move was like I think either of you would have made the exact same move as me. But in can't stop. If I gamble and go to try and beat someone on that four track when the odds are against it and I actually take it from them and now they have to start at the bottom of other tracks and if I come back and win, I don't think other people might have made that move necessarily. It's not an obvious move. So that's when it feels satisfying because it feels like that came from my brain, not from a math problem that was just plugging in numbers and saying this is obviously better. And that's where it makes it feel like I'm taking ownership of it a little bit more. Um, and the other I'll just race through these real quick. Carcasson is does it beautifully as well. Not only are the field battles kind of left in the balance until the end, but you only see one tile at a time. So even if you know the tile count, it's like how many turns are left? How many meles do I have? How many meles do my opponent have? when are we how likely are we to get back meeples?

Are we going to be able to do anything with those? And it's really only on the last turn or two where you kind of know what tiles are or aren't left where you can maybe math out on the final turn, but like that's a 74 turn game or whatever. So, it's such a small portion. And the other one I'll mention real quick is challengers. You don't know which cards other people have or don't have, what they have or haven't kept, even if you're going up against an opponent that you played in a previous round, what was discarded during the draft. So that affects your odds of do I go for duplicates of this or not? What's going to come up in what order at the end? Like there's so much uncertainty that you just have to kind of hedge your bets and see how it goes.

Yeah.

And I like that it's not just a solvable like I do this, this wins, therefore I'll do the same strategy again. I think that's the other thing, too, is it prevents you from being able to say, "Oh, well that's a winning strategy. I'll just do that next time."

Yeah. I I like that you brought the ones you brought up cuz it's different degrees of randomness. And like I won't get into the reasons why here, but like for instance, like I don't like the level of randomness that exists in challengers. We've talked about this before. Whereas like what you discussed in Carcasson, I I do really like and I even like like you're not just weighing which like tiles come out, it's who draws that tile, how are they going to use it, who's waiting for what tile, and stuff. So yeah, great great points. Um, the one I the question that I'll throw to Braden, um, being someone who I know is, uh, because one of my reference games here is Dune Imperium and you being a Dune Dune fan, uh, is how do you personally feel? But overall, how do you like what do you think about this topic in terms of is it affected by a game that is, you know, only you only need 10 points to win versus a game that the scores are going to be in the 400s? And I'm going to use the example of like Fa Swamp I play played recently. The winning score was 400. Some the last play score was 200. That's a very very big gap to have to do calculations from versus a game like Dune Imperium. You're making a decision saying I need two points. How do I get those two points?

Right. I think obviously the ones where there are fewer points available, you're going to be scrapping and clawing your way to really trying to achieve those versus thinking of the design space when it comes to um higher point games, let's say. You might be just getting points all along the way, right? So, kind of like little either dopamine breadcrumbs that take you, right? You're like, "Oh, I get two points here. I get two points there. I get five points. Oh, I got six points on my turn. My goodness, look at me, right? Like there are these all these options here, too. Um, so you know, it it depends on what a game wants to make you feel, right? Like with Dune, there are these battles that happen after every round, right? And they're all they all feel very important because you're trying to battle for that one, two points. if they were just for, you know, if they were like for a point, but then you also got like three points elsewhere and four points, you're like, "Okay, I guess we'll just add up the battle at the end of this." But it's like, no, like the battle's got like a ton of rewards. There's a lot of stakes for that, too. So, every time the end of the round comes up, that's like a big moment in that game. So having, you know, having those moments throughout, whether it's a few points here or many, many points, I think, is important for the game to like keep you going, right?

Keep you um pulled along in in some ways. And I I'd say like if we if we thought of Dune Imperium as like um a wave, right? There'd be higher spikes and then it would come down. Whereas like something like Sardinia or um FA swamp would kind of just kind of be like this constant like slow rise in points

and the spike might not even just might not even come until the end basically.

That's exactly it. And so, but as you as probably the person out of the three of us who it sounds like might enjoy the the like the calculations solving that to get like either maximize your points on a turn or win the game or like does does it feel different if you're doing that in a game where like say let's say cast as a burgundy and you win with like 190 points and you do a calculation that gets you 30 points to kind of pull off that win versus in Dune you do something that gets you one more point than your opponent. and you win, does it feel different or less satisfying with less points or does it all sort of is it a wash because as long as you can figure it out, it's satisfying? I would say the fewer points feels more satisfying be because every point you are you're trying so hard to achieve. We we talked about this a little bit before.

Not every point in Dune Imperial

with bus. Well, I mean, a lot of them a lot of them are, I would say, right? Like

a lot. But how do you feel about the ones where it's just like you take one water, next round, take another water? Oh, now I gained a point cuz I'm two steps up on the Fman track,

right?

Just by that point for just gaining two resources.

True. But I mean that like Okay, that's a good point.

I know that's just like two or three of the points that you'll get through the game maybe, but does that sully it at all for you?

I don't think so. like that. Like doing those is not super satisfying, but it's also it's pushing you closer to the end to your goal, right? So, it's still increasing the tension of the game because you have this your uh reputation goes up and then well maybe you get the most and then oh someone surpasses you now and then now takes away that, right? You lose a point and then that starts to trade back and forth. So, um I guess I was thinking primarily just about the battles, but the reputation obviously does matter too. It's not that like that's not super sad. Like it's great to have you got like okay you're like okay I got one in my pocket. I'm I'm doing well but I think it's the battles that really strike you where you get a lot of those rewards coming out too. Um, and yeah, I think just [snorts] I I would say the the fewer points like in bus, you know, just like just getting those few points. It's setting it all up and then vrooming and then you're like I got three points and it feels incredible.

Yeah. I'm like I'm I I I am surprised in the sense that I thought you were going to save the other one, but I'm I'm like pleasantly surprised because I like I also and we've talked about this recently, I'm realizing more and more that I really like games that have fewer points um and and they mean more and it's like harder to get them or when you get a point it feels like a bigger deal. And that's just like something that's changed in in me over the years and even it's in video games, it's in board games. So, it's kind of interesting to hear you from that. And I ask also just like Taj Mahal related to this a little bit too, right? Like where again after every

round the points are divvied up in some way, shape or form, right? But who's still left over or you know who's got the princess or whatever it is, right? There's different abilities and stuff too. Do you think that that is a similar feeling like to like getting fewer points? Like I don't like I can't remember how the scoring works other than like getting the spices and stuff I guess too. That one's got a few more but like it's not it's not a ton of points. I I would Yeah, I would I would say that like it's even though it's not quite what like where I'd want it in terms of like the value of a point and and how many points you still need. It's closer to even like I'll take one of my favorite games, Castles of Burgundy. Even with it being one of my favorite games, there's something about you always in a two-player game getting around 160 to 220 points that it's so many points that like sometimes having a really good turn and getting 20 points doesn't really make me feel that proud anymore. Whereas like getting a single point or two points in bus makes me feel more proud than getting 30 in Castle of Burgundy. and and like it's not necessarily it's not necessarily fair to say that about the game cuz like there's different things that make me feel satisfied in Castle Bernie that bus doesn't do but there is something I think that we've lost recently with a lot of the Euros and like these highcoring games and like civil evolution things like that where a point doesn't necessarily feel super like a big achievement and um I think like

having the game back to the grounded level of like when you get a victory point. It should It feels like a big achievement would be something I've just really loved to see more games do. I think it could be really really interesting to see that be something that we see more of.

I didn't expect you to say that. Knowing how much you love games like again Castles of Burgundy, Evolution like you mentioned, even a Feast Road in these games that often have scores in the triple digits. But um yeah, I I guess that also makes me wonder if your opinion of Feld like Stephan Feld as a designer and his kind of point salad style games. I wonder if that's going to decrease over time for you, like if you're going to cool on his games and those point salads because of that style.

And I I will say too, I think where you're playing the game matters. And what I mean by that is are you playing on BGA or online asynchronously, right? Like I love Nittoalier on BGA because I could just sit there and then math it out and I love that. like I it's probably one of my top games on BGA. Um and I just you know kept kept mathing it out the entire time and because I had infinite time if I was playing it in person I think that would change massively. So even just the medium I think completely matters too.

Very true. We didn't actually mention the BGA thing about assisting with calculations. We talked about it with Sardia. If if it was online and you could just look and be like okay in this region purple has four, yellow has six. Okay, that's it. Like if it was just easy instead of having to calculate it each time, like having that visual aid would be so beneficial for cutting through the the slog of the calculation that some of these games have.

Yeah. But to what you said too, like I I think that maybe what I'm almost getting at is with like the feld stuff you were talking about is like I'd be curious to see and I'm not being I'm not a game designer so I don't know where the limitations are here, but I'd be curious to see like what is like a point salad feld game look like where it's point salad in terms of your options but not in terms of like the highest scores you're achieving. Like is there a game where you can get like winning scores, the highest you're going to see is like 30. And so like it's still like it's it's more than like a game like Dune Imperium, but the points matter more. Gain 10 points is a third of the score you might be getting. That's a huge deal. And so it makes a turn feel more impactful. It makes big plays feel more impactful, but you have to like maybe have to go down a certain route or like commit to something to try to get them.

And maybe it doesn't work out at all and you get zero points and it feels horrible. But like maybe that's kind of what I'm getting at is that like can we make them feel more impactful and risky and maybe you can still get 50 points that way. But like I just feel like you the lower you go the more it matters. A point matters. And like I don't know I want to see more games where like five points is the winning score. And not because like it's first to five but because like that's all someone is able to get. Like I that's the example I wanted to give is like original like Mario Party and like Mario Party 2 getting the stars. like like someone would win with four stars or three stars. Oh, there's been games where you uh I've played of Mario Party where someone gets one star and because of all the steals and losing stars, one star wins it. And so when you get a star in Mario Party, it feels so big and and you steal a star, it feels so like insulting. It's just so good. And so like that's kind of the feeling I'm missing in a lot of board games aside from like yeah, Dune Imperium bus stuff like that. I want to see more of it.

Careful, Dylan. Feld's going to hear this thing. is going to start incorporating decimals. This is 0.1 points whereas this is 0.25 and

I want fewer points.

Yeah, exactly. You want fewer points, fine. Do more math then.

I feel like there's I feel like we've played games that had do.5s like

for sure. Glass Road and the scores are often like 22.5 or like 20

which I think is getting kind of ridiculous but like at the same time. Yeah. Yeah.

Um cool. Is there anything that before we uh wrap this up that either of you want to say about this topic that I didn't give you the chance to to say?

I think the one thing I want to talk just just briefly touch on is the opposite of like blurring the lines and having the information out there like what are your thoughts on Millie Fiori cuz that is essentially you know who is in the lead right at any point in time. What the to me the design space here is stop the leader, right? You see who is in the lead. Maybe that tries to incentivize you to get in on different sections of the board to stop them to claim points in some way, shape or form. Um where you know again the end of the game is not it's not blurred like that's just straight up. And and I'll another example I'll tie in with that that is also Kitia is even rebirth. Like Rebirth has very high scores and like the scores are moving constantly throughout the game and you're always aware of who's in the lead. And especially when you're playing with like three or four, the decisions you're making are like I I have to not just make a decision that gets increases my score and optimizes it. I have to know who I'm blocking, who I'm stopping, who I'm prioritizing, who I'm leaving alone for a while. And you can place anywhere in that game. So you're kind of just like you're there's a lot of considerations and I would I would say that like I even though my least favorite part of games like Mele Fury and and Rebirth is I think like that aspect or one of them anyways it is interesting to me when you add in the um

the aspect of like I have to manage which of my three opponents I am prioritizing to block or if I'm going to leave someone else to try to block them or if like I'm like if I don't stop them what does that if it comes back around to me, like that makes it more interesting to me when I'm not really just calculating my uh turns and optimizing, but like there's this element I can't account for, which is do I stop Carlo? Do I let Braden stop Carlo? If I don't stop Carlo, is that going to be a turning point for the game or can I sacrifice him having a good turn right now? Like those are more interesting decisions for to me.

I agree. And just to your question, the only thing I want to add here that I think we it it economic games, especially like heavy economic games and like train games, 18xx games, all that are is a big blind spot for the three of us, I think. So there's probably some people listening who are like, "You guys didn't even talk about economic games. Those are the mathiest ones." And like just something like Power Grid, that's the one one of the things I actually don't love about it is like you can math something out and if you don't take your time and you're one or two dollars short, it can completely kill your game. And so I don't know, there's a lot of heavy economic games that we just don't have any experience with. And that's just a massive blind spot, I think, for this for this topic. I just think it's worth mentioning.

Yeah, good call. And then I'll I'm not going to we won't want to answer this here, but I'll throw out a game uh brass Birmingham which I I will throw it out for the reason that it it is what you just uh mentioned like in terms of calculation stuff and yet in my two plays of it, it has not bothered me. And that's one I don't have an answer. I don't know why it hasn't bothered me. I don't know why I've enjoyed those kind of calculations in that game specifically. And I probably won't have an answer until I play it like a few more times and and see if that changes. But I wrote it down as why is brass the exception? Because for some reason that one it goes against everything I've said about how I feel.

It bothered me less in brass than in Power Grid as well. And I also don't know why.

Yeah, we'll figure it out. That's that's going to be a whole future podcast.

I was going to say

uh well that is our episode for today. So thank you once again for joining us. As always we have our YouTube channel at youtube.com/allboard. We have a Discord you can find in the show notes. We have a Patreon if you're looking for ways to support us financially or get some bonus content as well. Um, otherwise, this has been episode 21 of the audio board podcast. Thank you so much for listening and we'll see you in two weeks for episode 22.

Happy Halloween.

Carly, you have to close it like every episode now. Of course, you've just you've just sealed your fate here. Every

stop horsing around

different. You know what? I'm going to request different farm animals every episode, please.

Yeah.

Progress saved