The 10 Oldest and Newest Games on the BGG Top 100
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Mackle from Board Gameco and today I thought we'd take a look at the 10 oldest and 10 newest games on the Board GameGeeek top 100. I will say this video is being filmed on May 22nd, 20125. Uh, just for the record because of the fact that games do move around on spots at any different point and so these might have shifted a degree in some way. But for the most part, this is semi accurate to the current top 100 and Board Game Geek. I'll also say that despite me saying the 10 oldest and the 10 newest is actually going to be the 12 oldest and the 12 newest because there are ties on the dates. And no, I did not go down to which month a game was released. And so we actually have the 12 oldest and 12 newest. And what I'll be doing is I'll be going through the 12 newest games on Board Game Geek in order of uh how uh old they are, I guess, or how new they are. We we'll get to them soon. I'll explain it all as soon as we go through it. And then we'll do the 12 oldest games on Board Game Geek. And then I will also give you my average rating of each of them, of each of the two pools, like which one. In fact, you can go ahead and guess down below.
There's no bonuses, no prizes. There's just brownie points. You can earn brownie points. I don't track them, but you certainly can. But if you want to earn brownie points, you can go ahead and guess. Do I on average have a higher ranking for the 10 12 for the 12 oldest games or for the 12 newest games on board GameGeek? And I guess I'll let you answer again. You can actually have two answers. You can have an answer now and you can have an answer after you see all 12 of both of them. All 24 games we're going to go over today. With that said, let's go ahead and dive into it. This is the Boardgame Geek Top 100. Again, as of May 22nd, 2025, it is a constantly changing list, although they generally do have a degree of consistency, especially as you get higher up the list. Things do tend to stay still as much as possible, but there are things that like to move up the list. For example, what's the newest one we have in the top 100 up here? I don't know. Dune Imperent Uprising certainly pretty new, but there's others. There's others.
Uh, what else is there? What else is actually that high? That moved up the list pretty quickly. I don't actually know what's what's here. I mean, we'll see as we go through it. That's that's the whole point of this video, I guess. Let's go through the video. Let's do the video. So, we have coming in at number 12. And again, there's going to be three in the four, five, six. No, how many? Six, seven. There's like seven or eight games in this category. Basically, 2023 has most of the new games in uh the top newest games. It's going to be 2023, 2024, and 2025. except there are no 2025 titles, at least not yet. A lot of things rising pretty highly through the ranks, but currently nothing listed as 2025. It's all 2023 and 2024 titles. To that end, we have coming in at number 12. And again, there's no real order. I say number 12. What I really mean is eight of the 12 are 2023 and four of the 12 are 2024. But coming in number 12, we have Dune Imperium Uprising, the newer version of Dune Imperium. Uh coming out of the 2023 release date and an 8.7 score. or the scores I'm going to give are BG. I'll give my average score at the end. Uh, Age of Innovation is going to be another 2023 title with an average score of an 8.5, ranked 63 over here.
So, we have a Jun Imperium being Jun Imperium Uprising being 12, Age of Innovation, Age of Innovation being ranked 63. Then we have a Geminy Legal Class to victory ranked 46 over here, which by the way, these things already changed. It was 47 yesterday when I was putting together this list a day later and it's already 46. It's rising to the ranks with an 8.4 average score. Sky Team is another 2023 title which is currently coming in at 35 on the BG top 100 with an 8.2 rating. I like it not that much. Darwin's Journey, one I still need to play with a 94 on the BG top 100. It was 96 a day ago. 94 in the BG top 100 and 8.1 rating. That's Darwin's Journey. Then we have Great Western Trail New Zealand coming in at 96 on the uh 96 on the top 100 over here. And we have sorry 96 top 100 with an 8.5 average rating. Then we have Ticket to Ride Legacy: Legends of the West with an 88 average rating and a 2023 title.
Again, this is an 8.7. Deserves every single bit of that. I think it's a fantastic experience. Then we have The White Castle coming in at 87 on the Board Game Geek Top 100 with a 8.0 average rating. This is the White Castle, another 2023 title and the last of our 2023 titles. That brings us to our 2024 titles where we have Sevi, an 8.4, probably the fastest rising. I think this is the newest from the four if I'm not mistaken from the four we have I think this is the most recent but studi the search for extra restdale intelligence I believe it was an ess release so like towards the end of last year but coming in at 60 on the board game top 100 which means it is going to climb I anticipate this one making its way into the top 20 especially once the expansion is released like if it's 60 this fast that's only going to grow as it continues to get its way into more gamers hands the BG top 100 is a combination of how po how how wellranked a game is but also how many people have it and have ranked it. That's going to be a factor as well. And with it coming out the most recent, it's going to continue to climb. I'm anticipating a top 20 title, especially once the expansion makes the game even better.
From there, we have Slay the Spire. An 8.7 rating, a 50 on the board game top 100. Another new to the list over here. Incredibly popular game based on the video game and did a great job as far as the adaptation to the board game. A 2024 title. We have Harmonies coming in at number three. Again, these rankings are all arbitrary because they're so when we get to the oldest games, it at least makes more sense. But over here, it's just all 2023 and 2024, but Harmony is an 8.0 ranked 83. Uh, another 2024 title. And then lastly, we have Lord of the Rings duel for Middle Earth. I believe this was a Gen Con release, but I could be wrong. But, uh, 41 on the BG top 100, a reimplementation of Seven Wonders Duel. Similarly, we had like Dune Imperium coming with like, you know, Dune Dune Imperium had uprising. We have uh Age of Innovation which is a follow-up of the entire line of Terrammystica and Gaia Project and all of that. Great Western Trail New Zealand was you know a follow-up to Great Western Trail. Ticket to Ride was a follow to Ticket to Ride. So a lot of these games are kind of based on existing things although some of them are certainly new. So we have Lord of the Rings like I said already 41 8.4 average rating. But again going through this list from these 12 games Dune Imperium is already existing audience in play. Agentation an already existing audience in play. Hijgemony was new and new creators new designers knocked it out of the park. Sky Team over here and not a new publisher but definitely a new team as far as like you know this this one became incredibly popular. We have Darwin's Journey another new one. Great trail based on something prior. Ticket to Ride based on something prior. The White Castle from Diver Games not a new publisher but you know a new game. STI a new game. Slay the Spire based on something prior not a board game this time a video game but still harmonies and then we have the Lord of the Rings
duel for Middleear. So six of these 12 games already kind of had existing audiences. In the case of Lord of the Rings duel for Middle Earth two existing audiences. 71 is duel as well as the entire Lord of the Rings IP. And so these are the 12 newest games on the Board Gang Geek top 100. I am curious what 2025 title like a little intermediary before we go into the newest. What 2025 title do you think is the most likely to make its way into the top 100? Like I'm curious what when we're going to see a 2025 game in the top 100. It does take some time to climb those ranks, but it does happen every single year slowly but surely as we can see from the four from 2024. Like it's only May right now. It's only May. Like that means like these things climbed. Like it didn't take that long to climb. And again, STI being the newest fastest climber. Like do you remember when Ark Nova like at this point we're looking at 2023 24, but like Arch Nova is a 2021 title. Do you remember when that went from nothing to the top 100 in like months? It was insane. Things pick up.
Things pick up. Anyways, that is going to be your first batch of games, which means we go to the newest uh batch of games. These are the oldest games on Board Game Geeks Top 100. And we're going to be going from the least old all the way to the oldest. Because we're doing newest, we went from the oldest to the newest. And now in the oldest category, we're going from the least old to the oldest. Coming in at number 12, there are three tying for number 12. We still ended up with 12 total, but at least this this list makes more sense. In fact, I think from these, we have a few ties for 2011. We have a few ties for 2007, and I think the rest were pretty distinct. But with that said, we have Major the Board Game, a 2011 title, an 8.1, and ranked 36. An excellent game. Well worth your time. Eclipse Second Off for the Galaxy. This is like our first like is this our lowest score so far? What is the lowest score we have so far? These are all above eights. All above eights. We have an eight at the White Castle. That's our lowest score.
The lowest BG score is an eight. I didn't actually do like when I went to the most popular, I didn't actually rank that. I just went with mine. Oh, harmonies is also an eight. Okay. Okay. When we go to the oldest idols, we have Maze Knight coming out with an 8.1. We have Eclipse second down for the Galaxy. Our first title that dips below an eight average rating, but with 28,000 people owning it, it still makes it into the top 100, although at the high end at a 91. Then we have over here, we have the Castle Burgundy being our number 10 over here. An 8.1 average score with like 81,000 people owning the game, coming in at number 16. Welld deserved. Uh I'm obviously loving this one over here as my favorite game of all time. Then we have La Hav, another title that dips below an eight. It's interesting. I do wonder if there's like a newness effect to to games and I wonder if over time that depreciates or whether that's just, you know, I don't know. I'm curious. I'm curious how this this maps out. Anyways, coming in at number 74, we have Laav from Rosenberg. Fantastic game. The first U Rosenberg game that I truly loved. Like I dove into this hobby and Rosenberg was someone I quickly found because I mean obviously, but then I started playing his games and they were all good, but La Hav was the one that stood out to me for a long time until the Feast Froden came along and is probably my favorite from his. But La Hav is excellent. Coming in at 74, we have Race for the Galaxy 7.7. I'm definitely starting to notice that trend. The BGG average score is definitely going to be worse on the second list over here. My average score, we'll see that. We'll see. But the BG average score definitely depreciates over time. We have 7.7 over here, ranked 85. Race for the Galaxy uh is going to be our number. Um, and this is a 2007 title. We went from 2011 to La Hab in 2008 and then Race for the Galaxy in 2007. But 2007 is the year I said we have multiple ties. We have Brass
Lancashire going over that that that 8.0 rating over there. We have ranked 21 on Board Game Geek. Brass Lancashire, this is before the like the new version of the game, but an 8.2 very very popular game and the newest version has done nothing to hurt that. We have a Gria, another below the eight. Wow, it hurts. It hurts to see all these old good games being like degraded like this with all those sub eight ratings. Anyways, 7.9, a 2007 title and ranked 59. This is one of those Zur Rosenberg games that I loved. I still love it. I'm excited for the Awaken Realms version. They did wonders with Castle of Burgundy as well as Puerto Rico, but uh Agricow over here 2007 title and one that I liked had it for years and I'm excited to return to it with this new version. Then we have Twilight Struggle above that eight. This is ranked 14 overall and 8.2. A game that I definitely tried because it was the number one game on BG for a long time, but I I don't love it. I don't love it. I think it's a good game. I understand why it's popular, but it's not for me a 2005 title. Then we have Power Grid coming in at 7.8. It looks like those older titles have those high sevens. Uh, but we have 2004 title 7.8 coming in at two at number 70 on the board game title on the board game hotness. This is one I wouldn't be surprised to see a deluxified version. I think this one can bear a deluxified version as well like we're seeing with all these old titles. I think it's a very good game. I never fell in love with it, but I always enjoyed it. Then we have Puerto Rico. A game that I barely remember playing the original version way back when, but I have been playing through the Awaken prototype.
Uh, and I I think it's great. I think like the the the the deluxification of this game really matters. Like Castle of Burgundy is a game I loved despite the game not looking great, but Puerto Rico is a game that I think this this level deluxification I think will boost that rating. I do wonder although I wonder I wonder how like if it's going to be its own listing on BGG, but I think it is actually. But either way, this is a game that I think a lot of people are going to like that deluxe version. It does it does the game so much justice. It is it is worth it. A 7.9 on Board Game Geek. Uh 51 rated and a 2002 title. Then we go to El Grande. We drop down to 1995. We go from 2002 to 1995 in the BG top 100 coming in at 98 which is a shame. Honestly, this is one of the best games in the BG top 100. It's a game that stands the test of time so ridiculously well. Again, 1995, although we do have one more coming up. I do wonder if you can guess. Some of you already know. If you want more brownie points that once again only you can calculate. You can go ahead and post your comment down below right now at this point before I go forward as to what the number one game is, meaning the oldest game in the BG top 100. And I do love it by the way.
But going to Al Grande, Al Grande is a 98 98 ranking, a 7.8 rating. It is 1995 title and it's so good. It is the best five player game I own. I want to say that with almost absolute certainty. I'd have to go through my collection, but it's such a good experience. And then number one, which many of you guessed, is Crokenol coming in with 1876. We dropundred and what's the math now? 119 years, I think that is. We drop 119 years into the past and we pick out Crokinol coming in at 44 and carrying that above eight rating. This game is so good. It is worth getting. It's expensive though. It is expensive. But and shout out to Tracy Boards. Tracy Boards, which is not not a sponsor for this video, but they do make great boards. But Crokinol, an excellent dexterity based game that really holds its own, and I cannot tell you how many times I play this. It is so ridiculously good. uh an 1876 uh 8.1 and a 44 44 ranking on the BG top 100. And this is where you can go ahead and for those last rounding points, you can log in your little guess as far as which ones you think I rank higher. Obviously, we see that I mean, I haven't done the math on this, but I'm pretty darn sure that if you look at the BG top 100, the newer games have an average higher average an average higher an average higher ranking uh than the older games. We can see that pretty across the board from everything being above an eight to like a whole bunch of straddling that line and some dipping below it. But on my end, and I did not play all these games. I have not played Age of Innovation. I have not played Darwin's Journey. Um, technically I haven't played Great Western Trail New Zealand, but I have played Great Western Trail. So, I'm still going to count that, although that might not be fair.
And in fact, not only is that not fair, that would actually probably change the answer here. I also have not played Eclipse New Dawn from the older titles, and I think that's the only one. So, I haven't played three from the newer stuff. from the newest stuff I haven't played, which makes sense I guess. I haven't played Darwin's Journey, Age of Innovation or Great Western Trail New Zealand, but I still did count that one as Great Western Trail. And then I haven't played the older title of Eclipse New Dom, but I have played all of the rest of these games. And to that end, I have a Duna Uprising with a 4.5, Hijgemany with a four, Sky Team with a four, Great Western Trail New Zealand with a 3.5, although technically I've not played that New Zealand version. Have I played the New Zealand version? I've played I've played multiple Great Western Trails, but give me a second. I don't think I played Argentina. I played Argentina. That's what it I play G and Trail and Argentina, not New Zealand. Uh, but Grace and Trail with a 3.5. We have Ticket to Ride Legend of the West with a five, The White Castle with a 3.5, STI with a 4.5, Slay the Spire with a 4.5, Harmonies with a 4.5, and The Lord of the Rings: Dual for Middleear with a five out of five, by the way, for me. And my average rating for the newer games is coming in at a 4.3. My average rating for the older games, on the other hand, we have Mage Knight with a 4.5. We have Eclipse New with nothing. We have a Castle of Burgundy with a 5 to five. La with a 4.5. Race for the Galaxy with a four to five. Great older title. I've been meaning to pick it up. Brass with a 4.5. Agricola with a four. Twilight Struggle with a 3.5. Like I said, it wasn't for me. Lots that I appreciated, but way too long for what it is. Too much luck in my opinion. Yes, I know you can mitigate stuff. Just just This is me. We have Power Good with a 3.5. We have Puerto Rico with a four, Ele with a five, and Crokin with a five. And that means we went from a 4.3 on the newer titles to an average rating of
4.318 on the older titles with the asterisk that technically Great Western Trail New Zealand could come in at a four, which would change things. That would make the difference, but like I'm giving it I shouldn't really or just or just take out entirely, which honestly would uh would would technically even boost the newer ones even more. Anyways, that has been the oldest and newest games in the Board Game Geek Top 100. I thought this would be an interesting video to kind of cover like from the 100 games in the top 100, 24 of the 24, a quarter of the list basically just a quarter of the list. We have the 12 oldest and the 12 newest. The 12 newest are comprising eight games from 2023 and four games from 2024. That means 12, what's the math on that? Like uh 12 and a half% or 12%, I guess it's 12. It's 12 out of 100. That's pretty easy math. Uh 12% of the BG top 100 is made up of games from the last 2 years. Well, last three years cuz 2025, I guess technically. But then if you go to the oldest games on the top 100, the oldest 12 spanned from 1876 to 2011, which a a much bigger range. Honestly, even if you remove Coconol from 1995 to 2011, that is a 16-year range if I'm not mistaken, a 16-year range as opposed to the 2-year range we're seeing in the top newest games. In any case, and until next time, I'm Alex Radical from Board Gameco. I hope you enjoyed this video, and I hope you got your brownie points, too. And as always, I hope you have a good one.