Skip to main content
Loading video...

Where Are They Now? - January 2026: Black Forest, Primal, Carnegie & More!!

Transcript 14:27

Hey, I'm Alex Radical from Board Gameco and this is where are they now for January of 2026. This is where I take a look at the games that I played for the first time a year ago as well as five years ago and see how they've fared over time. But before we do that, thank you to AllPlay for being a channel sponsor. You can check out a whole bunch of things at allplay.com, but also check out their active crowdfunding campaign for Mountain Goats Legacy and more importantly, Enchanted Ivy, which I've been having a lot of fun with. But with that, let's go ahead and dive into the Look Back series. I love this series because it's a good opportunity to see not the cult of the now, but see how things really do fare over time. Do they hold up or were they only a passing fad? Let's go ahead and dive into it. In both years, I'll be dividing this into four categories. The games that I didn't like, which doesn't necessarily mean that they are bad. It just means like they they just didn't work for me. Then the games that I liked but didn't feel the need to keep because that's the vast majority of games out there. They're good, but what enters my collection is a whole another story. Then there are the games that I kept and then left. I do try to keep this category as little as possible because I do want things to stand the test of time. If I add something to my collection, ideally I want to see it there a year from now, at least a year from now. Five years is a different story because I want it to stand up over multiple plays. And then lastly, the category of games that I kept that are still here. I always love seeing which ones truly have held up over a year and 5 years. Let's start off with the category of games for January of 2025. The games that I did not like.

This is going to be only two in this category. Generally, this category is pretty small. I think most games are pretty good. Some just don't work for me. There was a tall was a reef building game, which I don't know what it was about the game that didn't work for me. There's lots of games that are like this that worked for me. I just didn't find the whole way it came together to be particularly satisfying, unfortunately. And then there's Propopolis from um from oh my gosh, from Flat Games. They had a bunch of these small box games and medium box games. Propolis was was it propos whatever it was the bee game and hive and all that stuff. I I didn't love it. It wasn't bad. It just felt like a worse version of other games that do similar things. Even their own point city I enjoyed significantly more. Splendor as well. Propulolis felt a little fiddly within those games. In the category games I liked but didn't feel the need to keep. There were strange forgeries of Dr. SC Shriber. Loved the concept of this game. I thought the execution was pretty bad. I heard they were doing a second edition. I hope they did. It's something that it's one I'd love to check out in the future. But the the concept was great. Execution not so great. Uh there was Aventuria. Aventuria was a card building uh dungeon crawleresque, but it's more about the cards than anything else. Overall enjoyed it. There's lots of games that do this. There's Disney Animated. I like that one. I will say I was kind of excited for Disney Animated, and the end result was a game that was just totally fine. It was It was fine. It was basic.

I had fun. It was just very much the same game every time you played it. I wanted more from it. But I wanted to like it more than I actually did. There was Finsspan. Finsspan is great. Arguably possibly one of my favorite within the span series. I think Worms Span does more as far as how strategic the game is, but I think Finsspan is the most accessible overall and I really enjoyed it. I just think that the Span series is one that it's the kind of game that I would add to my collection and then I just wouldn't end up playing it as much as I enjoy other tableau builders. Then there's Teot Turacon. A loved game. For me, it just was okay. I found when it comes to these heavyweight Euros or mid to heavyweight Euros, some of them blow me out of the water as far as how good they are and others are good games. Toton was a good game. Uh it's well-loved by many. For me, it was just a good game. There was Hearts of Iron.

This is a upcoming game. This a preview I did or not preview is a review of a prototype that I did. Hearts of Iron from Steam Forge based on the video game. I never played the video game. The board game was good. It felt like one of those game systems. It kind of reminded me a lot of um of a Game of Thrones the board game. Definitely very different thematically, lots of difference as far as the execution as well, but strategically speaking, I thought it was a very sound game in that genre. And there's Azul Duel, which to me, I really enjoyed Azul Duel. I have cooled in a little bit over time, but I never ended up adding to my collection anyway because I again trying to juggle the amount of games I actually have. And Azul is a game that I find I usually end up playing on board game arena. I don't need to have an in-person copy. Don't get me wrong, when I truly love a game, doesn't matter where I'm playing it, I want it everywhere. But Zool Duel, it's a very good game. and the CO games that I kept and then left. There's only one which is good. I I like to keep this for I like to have this down to zero for the games from a year ago. Again, five years is different, but Captain Flip, Captain Flip is very charming. Speaking of Board Game Arena, I played on Board Game Arena for the first time, ended up getting it.

Played it a bunch of times, but it has become one of those games that it doesn't it didn't enter my go-to fillers for my game group, and my kids, while they enjoy it, they don't ask to play it. And I find games like that eventually do leave. If no category of people are specifically intentionally trying to play it, then it might just become one of those games that I just play on board game arena. I think it's fun. I think it's charming. I see why it got the love that it did, but it kind of fell into the space where it wasn't heavy enough in my game group and my kids didn't vibe with it enough to become their favorite game. In the category of games I kept that are still here, there are a lot. Some of these are a bit more in the kids category, but they're games that I kept that are still here. This Bamboo Rally Cup, a racing game from Hoba that my kids really enjoyed. much more fun than it has any right to be based on how it actually works, but it's still fun, so it is what it is. There was Point Galaxy. I mentioned Point City earlier, but Point Galaxy was uh in combination with Polus and Point Galaxy, but Point Galaxy my daughter really enjoyed. It has that set building system that's very fun and uh engaging and overall had a lot of fun with it. There's Frost Punk, which kind of gets a disclaimer in this one. I don't know how to count this one. It's not that I I played Frost Punk. I played half a game on TTS. I haven't really fully truly played Frost Punk yet, but I still played it. I played it. I enjoyed enough what I played that I wanted to keep it to dive into it more, but it's still kind of in that weird testing grounds. It's almost more of an unplayed game that I happen to play half a game.

Count that as you will, but I liked it enough that I wanted to see more and just haven't done so yet. There's the Fellowship of the Ring, the trick taking game. Really enjoy that one. It actually became one of my most played games of 2025. Uh I still think I prefer The Crew, but I still like Fellowship of the Ring, and it's one that I have the new one, The Two Towers, as well. I don't know if it'll be a forever game. I think The Crew is going to be my forever game, but Fellowship and the Two Towers, I'm still enjoying enough that they're holding on to for now. There's Black Force. I loved Black Force. I had a chance to play this at Level Up Retreat last year in 2025. Uh I I I I've played it several times since then. It is such a good implementation of the Glass Road system. I almost ended up getting rid of Glass Road in favor of Black Forest, in favor of Black Forest, but I ended up keeping both. There's Lord of the Rings Duel. This is the Seven Wonders Duel variant with the Lord of the Rings theme. Love it. It's great. Again, it has cooled on me a little bit. At the time, my first year of it, I kind of liked it more than uh Seven Wonders Duel, but I think Seven Wonders Duel with the expansions has really elevated that experience for me. Base game to base game, I prefer Lord of the Rings Duel. Once you incorporate the expansion, Seven Wonders Duel is better for me. I do hope they expand Lord of the Rings Duel. I don't know if they will. Like, I know they have the little allies pack, but I want like a real expansion for it, but I don't know if that will happen. If they do, that would be great cuz I think the expansions for 71 duel add so much depth to the experience that you are having. Then there's Avid Silverfrost. Again, don't know if this will be a forever game for me. There's too much Avidel at this point, and I'm starting to realize I can't and don't want to keep it all.

There's there's too much. They put out a new system every single year at this point. And they're not different enough that I want to keep them. So, while Evidel Silver is currently here, I don't need the giant big box of Evodel plus four offshoots. So, I think three offshoots. So, I'm going to have to be picking and choosing which one stay. I think Evidel Silver probably will go. I just haven't found myself willing to make the decision as to which one leaves quite yet. There's Twinkle, a Twinkle Twinkle smallbox game from Allplay of optimizing your points, optimizing your stars as you place them out into the galaxy. Uh enjoy that one a lot. Again, I don't know if it's a favorite game. I think that I still want to continue to experience it and see the various expansions. Like I've played through all the expansion modules, but I haven't I haven't done so enough in the combinations that they provide that I still think it has legs for right now. I do find that it's not my favorite of those points going optimization games. So, I don't know. I don't know if they'll be here in 5 years, but it's still here for right now. Then there's C Casino. This is from Buttonshy. It's a new game in their Sprawopoulos system. I don't know if I have a favorite, but I do enjoy Casinopoulos as far as I think it's doing some things that are different that are very fun. And they're small wallets, so I'm much more forgiving as far as keeping those under the category of my Sprawopoulos collection. And then lastly, there's Mino's Dawn of the Bronze Age. This is from Bord and Dyson Stan Kodonsky. I think it's a fantastic game that utilizes Stan Konowonsky's system that he has in Rurick and applies it to a Euro game and the combination I love. I love Rurick more, but I love that combination in a Eurogame system.

Thoroughly recommend it. That is 2025, which brings us to 2021. Five years ago, which is crazy to think that 2021 is 5 years ago, but it is what it is. The math is mathing. Uh, but in the category of games that I didn't like, we have five orphan. This is I was it a Hoba game? I don't remember who did Five or Fendon. I just remember that I think it was a Hava game, but I could be wrong. I didn't love it. I thought it was fine. There was Chai, not Chai Tiva 2, but Chai, the original Chai. I played it. I thought it was way too basic. It just wasn't There's a good category of games that are light enough for what they're trying to do. I think Chai is appealing if you want a light game and you're there for the theme. That's the only reason I'd really recommend it. Uh there's Candy Wars, a game that was a prototype that never came to life. It was fine. It was No, it wasn't fine. It was in the category I didn't like. I didn't like it. I actively did not like it. It was a skirmish game that felt like in a complete mess. Uh it didn't end up funding unfortunately and um or fortunately depending how you look at it and uh I don't know if it ever came back to life in any form, but Candy Wars was not for me. In the cate category of games that I liked, there's the Court of Miracles from Lucky Duck Games. Uh I really wanted to enjoy this. I heard some really good things about it from various content creators at the time. Uh but the Court of Miracles was good. I liked it. It was totally fine. It was a kind of sequencing system as far as how you place things out, but it was just it was just fine. It was not amazing. It was fine. There was a Rune Lords, another campaign that never ended up funding. This is kind of a semi-skrmish game with a big board. A whole ambitious project never ended up funding, so I don't think it actually exists right now. There was Ignite. Ignite was a uh a skirmish based deck building game, a tactical on a board, skirmish deck builder. I overall enjoyed it. I wanted

to like it a lot more. There were definitely some systems that held it back for me as far as the balance, the way the the board is set up, the way you have to run out, but the overall concept of a deck building skirmish game, still love that. But I have found that the ones that exist have never wowed me completely. There's always been something wrong with it. Like Ascension is good, but like none of them have wowed me. They've all been fine. There's Clank Legacy, the first one. I enjoyed Clank Legacy. I didn't actually end up finishing it. I played like five games of it, but I enjoyed it. I just didn't love it. And for a legacy game that's asking me to give it multiple plays. Uh my group wasn't into it enough that none of us felt the need to finish it. There was The Night Market, which took like 5 years to deliver, but I believe it finally has delivered. I actually never actually got a copy of it, but I really enjoyed it when I played it. Uh, it was an interesting system as far as how you place your people and try to get all the resources you need based on the sprawling out. It's been a long time. I don't remember much about it. I do remember enjoying it and it never really entered my collection. Then there's Qatara. Qatara was I want to say from yellow. This is a fun little interesting sequencing game as far as the cards you play. It was charming. It was fun. It was fine. In the kind of games I kept and then left, there's a few over here, but again, 5 years later, this does happen a bit more. We have Mutants from Lucky Duck. I first came upon this game because OneStop Co-op Shop was highly praising it. I played it. I loved it. I thought it was very very good. Stayed in my collection for several years.

Eventually it did get uh depp prioritized because of other games that were getting played more. But Mutants was fantastic. There was Carnegie. Carnegie from I always forget the name of the company. Quinned I think Quinned Games. Uh Carnegie is absolutely or Carnegie. Carnegie I think it's like the hard E or whatever. Carnegie. Uh it's a fantastic game. Interesting selection system where every turn you choose what action is going to be selected and every player has to choose that action. There's only 20 turns. So having control over which actions and more importantly setting yourself up so that you can benefit from each action that players choose or paying attention to what the players are doing and reading into what they're likely to choose. It's a big part of the game. Brilliant game system. I've often debated getting it back, but it's one of those things that it's a great euro that other Euros were getting favored over, but a great game. And then there's Unicorn Fever, a reimplementation of Horse Fever. A very charming, funny gambling game. I think it's very fun. I think games like Ready Set Bet or Hot Streak are kind of the new Unicorn Fever of today. I think they do a better job of being that kind of feeling but in a faster, easier, more accessible system. And then lastly, we have the category of games from 5 years ago that are still here. Games that I've kept since then. There's Cloak Cats. I want to say it's a Hoba game as well.

Charming little game. A little bit of a kind of hidden deduction game. My kids still enjoy it. I still enjoy it. Cloak Cats is a lot of fun. There's Kingdom Rush Elemental Uprising. This is not the original Kingdom Rush. I had already played this by now, but Elemental Uprising first I first played 5 years ago and it's still here. I have debated whether I keep them all or get rid of them. I It's just too many games in my collection, but I think Kingdom Rush is fantastic and I really enjoy the tower defense mechanic of it. I have a lot of fun with it. There's Oatsworn played 5 years ago for the first time on TTS with the creators before it even delivered. Uh but I really enjoyed it. I really enjoyed it. It is still here to this day. It has survived campaign purge after campaign purge. It's just a good system that doesn't ask too much of the players as far as their game time and gives you a lot of engagement. It gives you so many characters, but you can actually play through it again with those characters because it's a short enough campaign to be able to utilize and learn from the various characters in the game. There's Corest, which I played for the first time. I keep saying play for the first time. Corquest, uh, Corest is still here. My daughter actually made a scenario for it. It's a charming dungeon crawler. It's very kid-friendly.

Uh, great game, very charming, and a lot of fun. There was Fleet the Dice game which has gone on to have many more games in that system from three sisters from uh a Motor City Dream Motor City Motor City Dreamworks Motor City whatever it is but there's a bunch of games and then there's also French Quarter now there's a bunch of games that have followed up on in the system but Fleet the Dice game was the one that started it from that trio of designers or two designers Ben Pinchback and Matt Riddle I want to say maybe there's a third one I can't remember but they they they designed a bunch of these games that involve that rolling right chaining goodness and Fleet the Dice game was the one that started it all and it's absolutely amazing and then lastly There's Primal. Primal is absolutely incredible. I love that game. Again, I've said this time and time again. My first play, I was like, "It's fine." My second play, I was like, "This is good." And my third play, I was hooked and I have been hooked ever since then. And I've seen that play out with others, by the way. I've seen that happen with people who played it and were like, "This is fine. I don't know why I love it so much." And then as they play it more, as you get into the card comboing, it becomes such a great game. Primal feels like a forever game for me.

There's no such thing as a truly forever game for me, but it feels like a forever game. There's so much satisfaction to the way you are doing things in that game that I am I am hooked. I'm absolutely hooked on it. I love Prime. That is basically my look back for five years ago and a year ago of January 2025. I hope you found this video helpful in some way. And as always, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Gameco.

Progress saved