Skip to main content
Loading video...

Games that Fell from our Top 50 Board Games of All Time

Transcript 24:56

I don't understand I don't want to know if you creeping why are you now closed hello everyone welcome back to our that was a weird way for me to

start hello everyone welcome back to Foster the neele a Channel all about andam things exactly we are here today with a video that was actually a suggestion in our comments of some of our top 50 videos and that was some people were curious what games fell off of your top 50 this year like just poof off completely where did they go nobody knows somewhere down the list apparently so we went through our top 50s from last year to see what games fell off and I figured we' just chat about that a little bit Jeffy I think we both have a nice handful quick disclaimer all of these games are very good this is not us yeah slagging games off or negative connotations so just because something fell off our top 50 does not make it a bad game because I know some people will interpret it that way these are all incredible games even if something's like a number 600 from 700 it's probably still a good game all the games we play are good well that's not true but most of the games we play most games are objectively good that's our opinion most games are objectively good yeah deal with it but maybe we'll start with like the highest ones that dropped off or like the low like lowest to highest lowest to highest so lowest as in lowest like ranked ranked last year yes so the first game that fell off of my top 50 this year was size from ston Meer games

um and I think that this is just I I'm pretty sure you talk about side on your top 50 for me this one has just fallen off because it's just the way the times go you know we love sidethe still love it but it's just not there anymore someone actually made a really really good point in our comments and to give context even like top 50 of all the games we've ranked is like 5% yeah of our games yeah like that's an really Elite level of a percentile it's elite do you know what I mean so like I I just want to make sure people understand that context because like some people will be like why is that outside your top 50 like blah blah like we have played a lot of games lot of games and it's really like a very small percentile of games is going to make it in the top 50 yeah and if you're curious I will you have like your whole list there right so ended up at number 62 for me so it's still within the top 100 and I think that that like you mentioned it in one of the videos like anything within the top 100 is a really good game is a really good game even anything within the top like 300 we consider still it's still top 50 percentile cuz we ranked like almost 800 games each so anyways scye is the first one that fell off of my list Planet unknown this year was 115th uh so it was 48 last year um I

think Planet unnown fell off because I've just identified that polyomino games I just don't really as I've explored more in the Hobby and find and find new mechanisms and new types of games that I enjoy uh it's refined on what I don't also enjoy a ton of yeah um polyomino being one of those things um and wild to West came out and I think I prefer wild TI West to Planet unknown we've played a fair amount of Planet unknown in this point it's still a really good game it's still 115 but um I I just think Paul omos are going to have a really really hard time yeah uh cracking cracking that list for me we were riding High last year on planet unknown because we played at like end of the year right the next game that fell off of my list it was 45 last year this year it was 65 that is ugly Griffin in so a lot of the button shy games fell off of my list this year and I just think it's because the nature of the games you know like we've just played so many games and I really love the button shy games but sometimes it's really hard for me to like yeah rank them against something like conon like how do you how do you do that yeah I don't even know I think that uh invokes a really interesting conversation that maybe we can just briefly have here and how difficult it is to rank things yeah because how do you rank a 18 card game like ugly Griffin in with to combon yeah you know like we have our own criteria

uh which we won't get into here which is part of our top 50 you can go check that out but yeah it's really really difficult to rank games like how do you rank a party game versus you know a game like Twilight Struggle yeah like it all of these lists everyone's lists are subjective it really doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things but it is it's challenging yeah I think some people take their rankings really seriously as well whereas like we're a little bit more Loosey Goosey with it like we rank in the moment based on our gut feeling and that's just how the chips fall sometimes y next up for me was 45 last year and this year is 80 uh and that is neros Shima hex um it's still top 100 neros Shima hex is still a game I absolutely love again just a product of maybe not playing it quite enough we've played it a few times last year mhm um and one I just want to explore more of the factions we have pretty much every faction I think that exists for neima heex and it's one that I want to just play with other people and introduce to more people this is a very very good two in my opinion two-player game we haven't played it anything higher than that but just one that uh you know a lot of these is going to get you're going to hear similar conversations because they are just floating in this ever evolving list like there's no specific reason these are all really really great games but just uh by the nature of what and how many games we

play it's going to happen yeah the next one for me was number 43 last year H and that is overboss which I'm sure was insanely High the year before it was my number two in 20122 then it was my number 43 in 2023 and now I wonder where it fell hold please 95 listen I still have a huge love in my heart for overboss I just think that it's it's a it's a very cozy game we've played a lot of it we' played so much over boss and it's one of the games that we got super into when we first started within our content creation side of board gaming um and played it all the time and now it just doesn't really hit the table although I will say that this is a game that if somebody was just like what do you want to play this is still one of those games that will automatically be like oh we play over box because I just know it so well this is a game I would introduce to people uh very very frequently next up for me was 41 last year and this year is 136 and that is innovation um Innovation is a game that I played to death to the point where I started to get a little bit kind of over it uh because Innovation is complete random chaos MH again I think it's one that's kind of a product of me developing like I like to have control a little bit more than I think I realized yeah um and the

struggle with Innovation is like you can have a really awesome Synergy going and you're like oh I'm going to run away with this game and someone just blows you up which is part of the fun and it is part of the fun but is also equally frustrating I think also Innovation I was playing like too much constantly replaying innovation in some games I can do that with like root because every game is somewhat different but in Ovation started to feel really Samy I haven't played any expansions or anything but again like still 136 like you're still in the upper threshold there for sure yeah uh so the next one for me is another button shy which was 42 last year and that's Fu chain Island um honestly I would say that Fu chain island has just gotten bumped for me in Solo button shy by numers yeah because like if I'm reaching for one now I'm typically reaching for numers uh it dropped so far like so surprising and said 94 this year but I freaking love that game still it is like it's probably the number one button shy game that I recommend people who are just getting into like solo button shy I'm like you got to get food chain Island because it's amazing so my number 40 last year is a game called Quantum this year it was 57 so it didn't drop a ton uh I still love Quantum a lot uh we were lucky enough to get a copy of quantum uh in the last couple of years it's very difficult to find I have nothing to say about Quantum I still love this game it's just outside my top 50 uh it is on BGA I've played it on BGA uh we streamed

it this year physical copy uh it's very Chessy spaced theme game uh that I still adore my next one that fell off is number 41 it's funny because I have like a stream that fell off uh and that is boomerang Australia so I think when we did our rankings last year Boomerang Australia which by the way I I wonder where it fell but I still love it was like almost a replacement of Silver Bullet for us where it's like what let's just play Boomerang Australia cuz we freaking love it 134 that's shocking to me I feel like it should be higher it's just because it's the type of game it's just a simple little fliping right but it's so much fun like I if anybody wants to play this with me on BGA I'm always down to play but it was it's on BGA it's on BGA yeah oh yeah yeah and it's just like it's a very cash very cash game and there's not really much to it but it's it's I really like it but it has fallen for me my number 39 last year is now 266 not surprising though uh not surprising though and that is Android Netrunner um I had a very very strong uh infatuation with Android Netrunner uh in the past two years mainly around the fact that it felt magic adjacent um it was a SE or is a ccg um I have a ton of Android Netrunner content I've bought a ton of expansions it's a game that I I want to play more of but it's really difficult to get those lifestyle game play those games

played now and this is one that I think is a product of that it's just oozing with theme in the rule book which I actually think is detrimental to the user experience of board games yeah but that's a whole other topic uh Android netrunners won that I I would probably increase if IID played it a bunch more and I just don't know what environment I'm going to get to play this enough to give it the justification it deserves Fair okay so my next one was my number 40 so my number 40 41 42 43 all fell off my list uh and that was aul listen aul is an amazing game we all know this but like as the years go on it's just it loses a little bit of its luster but I still think it's a brilliant designh I still think that like I'm almost always in a game of it on BGA but this used to be a game that saw our table constantly and now we like never pull it out physically but I'm always in a game of it on BGA I'm in one right now um anyways it fell way down uh it's at number 115 now it's not that far back I know but like I feel like it's it's constantly dropping which is kind of sad to see but uh next one up uh was 37 last year and this year is 62 so still my top 100 and that is black angel um black angel would probably be in my top 50 if we owned it and we could play it more um it is somewhat hard to find around here it's a game I would buy if I saw it on the Shelf somewhere it's not one I'm going to order it's not one I'm looking like that heavily for but I very very

very much enjoy black angel uh I love the theme I love the mechanisms that are in the game um I think again if if I had owned it and we played it more it probably would be still in my top 50 we just haven't played it in a while what is it the spiritual successor to um twah tah the next one that fell off my list is also my number 37 and that was an Acron uh just I think by the sheer fact that we didn't physically get it to the table this year and I played it once on BGA and did not remember what was going on I hate playing big games like that on BGA when especially when I don't know what I'm doing I think I'm better at clicking around and not caring than you yeah I'm not I like to care about care about it 71 still in my top 100 cuz I did like I remember our first play of that game game yeah I was like whoa I did not think I was going to like this we should play that one Nick when he comes to visit yeah I'm trying to paint it before he gets here that's what I'm painting right now oh yeah Nick from the brothers murf is coming to his us I'm very excited we're gonna play 7500 million games it's gonna be great uh last year this game was 36 on my list this year it is 71 and that dice thr um listen I absolutely love dice Throne Jamie beating me in the tournament really impacted this no it didn't just kidding I do love dice I absolutely love dice Throne I will always pull dice R out when I just want like a I don't want to think about

something I just want to play a game and Chuck some dice and have some fun uh I think Dione has a perfect niche in this Hobby and it is incredible in within that niche of what it does uh I'm so excited to see the continued characters this is one that will always be in my top 100 it might even crack my top 50 I will mention I'm not a huge Marvel fan I do like X-Men though so the expansion stuff I'm definitely interested in uh I think it's cool no matter what they do I just like seeing the new art and new mechanisms and stuff but if they were I I think they've recently announced they're going back to some of their OG stuff which I'm really excited for but Dione is just one that I think it's going to continue to float around these spaces for me I love D but I also love Marvel so like all the Marvel sets I've also been super jous I really liked I like some Marvel like Deadpool yeah all day um X-Men like I mentioned but like Thor Thor yeah Thor and Spider-Man like he's just bit on Spider-Man because of how annoying he is to play against he's so much fun to play though my next one was number 36 last year and that is downforce now this I still love downforce but I will obviously say with all of the new racing games that out like heat pedal of the metal uh Thunder Road Vendetta it's just it bumped downforce off of my list that's fair um which I think is fair like even on BGA now I used to always be in downforce and now

I'm always in heat you know what I mean heat heat was uh yeah Heat's a Heat's a game so uh downforce is now number 101 on my list it's just like I don't know this game still we played this so early on and we really loved it when we first played it and I still love it and I always want to play it I still really like down Force I do too it's it's great so anyways it just it's fun they are different enough too that I think they they different enough I think the other issue is that like downforce you really do need a lot more people whereas like best at like six with heat you can play lower player counts because the AI uh is really good in that game um but yeah so that's down Force it's really good point Jamie yeah last year this was 35 and this year it is 112 uh and that is Gloom Haven jaws of the lion I'm not going to say anything much about this one it's just you played it it's done it's still an incredible game it's a campaign game I've gone through it I've completed it it's still 112 I still have really fond memories of that game and that experience um and I think it's the highest of the Gloom Havens for me it pro yeah I would have not played Frost Haven yet but Frost hav might supersede this one but I really I wish they would have done Frost hav like they did JS of line with the book and everything oh my God it just made it so much better to table same so my next one was my number 31 another racing game which is flam Rouge which I still love um this one dropped down to number 106 which I think is wrong I

think it's wrong honestly I think it should be higher because I really do like this game and like the mechanics and stuff but I don't know I haven't like thoroughly gone through the list I just trusted Pub meele to not do me dirty but anyways um flam R did another racing game which which we love but it's just yeah I guess it doesn't see the table a lot also doesn't play great it too you want to play it at more players but anyways that's flam Rouge uh last year this one was 27 this year it is 87 um and that is return to Dark Tower uh last year uh we actually got a chance to play Return To Dark Tower mhm and this one would be in my top 50 if we played it more um this is a mi game this is such a mi game it's got this awesome toy factor in the middle this massive tower that spit skulls out maybe we should play that with Nick when he's here yep um and it's a Cooperative kind of uh scenario based game where you're kind of going around this map and you're fighting baddies and you're trying to complete objectives this is 100% top 50 game for me if I had a chance to play it more I just have only played it a once yeah um and I think last year when I had ranked it that high it was coming off of that high but again caveat that with this game 100% it's going to float around this 50 if I uh play it more so my next one that fell off the list is camel up it was number 29 last year it's number 100 this

year which is another one I think is wrong that needs to be hired I agree actually that should be way way way way higher for me it should be I have it higher than you yeah it and I love this game like this is one of like I will say still say this is one of my favorite games of all time so I do think Pub meele did me wrong I think camel up should be within maybe not top 50 anymore but for sure within like top 70 I have it at 84 M it should be in my top I think is pretty right for me c is freaking amazing it deserves better than this it deserves so much better 24 last year uh 55 this year so just outside my top 50 and that is unmatched I'm not going to say anything I still love unmatched it's incredible uh this is just a product of uh other games getting bumped up unmatched is amazing my number 21 last year that got bumped off was brass Birmingham which uh landed for me at Number 103 doesn't surprise me uh and I think honestly we just had a less fun play of it this year that bumped it down for me and I'm just like uh it's also like every time you play it you have to totally relearn it like so and not just like refresh it's like relearn every time we play and so it just yeah hinders it for me just a little bit still a great game though yeah last year number 22 this year number 54 uh and that is the Godfather again incredible game uh it's right there just slipped down because of other games we haven't played it in a while but it is a incredible

area control game yep last year my number 11 was Scot and that fell off of my list and it's now 131 wow we don't pull it out anymore it's not our chosen card game anymore it got it's not the chosen one it got it got pulled by Nana it and sea salt and paper it did yeah and I think that's a big part of it I still think Scout is awesome super fun fantastic convention game fantastic like pallet cleanser kind of game I love it but like the high that I was riding I was last year apparently riding lots of highs on games but like it dropped and I didn't replace it in my top 50 with Nana or another game like that just because these games do have a tendency to was in my top 50 Yeah well yeah yeah it was Jeff it was wasn't it number 21 uh last year number 73 this year is fantasy Realms uh fantasy Realms was a was a a victim of a game called sea salt and paper coming out and other uh small box card games like Nana fantasy RS was one that we always used to pull out that filled that void um and I still love fantasy Realms I'll play it anytime but it's not one we tend to carry around with us anymore like we used to um so it was in my top 50 yeah whatever ched the last one on my list uh was number nine last year was Fuji flush which is 115 this year which

I also think that can't be right that can't be right because I love this game but this game is so situational group dependent for sure group dependent and Convention dependent we don't play this unless we're at a convention you will have an amazing time playing Fuji flush with us that's but I've seen some people playing Fuji flush uh no one I know but I've seen people playing Fuji flush and there's like no cheering there's no yelling there's no nothing's that's not how you play Fuji flush you're gonna have a terrible time yeah but I do think that this should be higher than 115 because like we freaking love this game it's in your 208 yeah that feels wrong that does feel wrong oh my gosh I don't know Pub meele I don't know man my number 17 last year my number 99 this year's dwellings of elderil uh again product of not getting played D Tower West the last time we played it yeah I last played at Dice Tower West and had a really great experience playing that game I do own it just haven't played it uh maybe it's something we can play when it comes but uh I very much enjoy dings elderil uh I'm sure it would go up uh with repeated plays but just didn't get to the table so those are some games actually all of the games that have fallen off of our top 50 our top 50 is like a living breathing thing that changes every day by the day by the minute and it might be right and it might be wrong and we don't know but it's right because it's objective we're curious if there's any surprises from that list let us know down in the comments but with that being

said that's everything that we have for today so if you're interested in buying board games like any of the many that we mentioned today that fell from Grace you should first start by checking your friendly local gaming store and for us that is boardroom Game Cafe heck yeah do you like snacks I do perfect where people get snacks Munch pack that's right and if you like what you see sub we hope to see you again soon and now we say goodbye goodbye There It Is Got a Friend in Me You' Got a Friend in Me Up ahead in your mouth and miles from your nice warm bed well just remember what your old pal said you got a bring I don't want to do that oh we we'll just do monthly pay $33 I'm gonna go check on Juno while you're around do you need anything no next for you I'm curious where this landed I just need to I just got distracted I looked over at Jeff's laptop you have like 75 tabs open yeah welcome to my job that's wild I was like whoa over and you know what's funny you use all them I use every single one of them crazy sorry

um

Progress saved