Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Favorite Big Games in Smaller Boxes

Transcript 20:31

Hey, I'm Jamie from Stonemire Games and today I'm going to talk about big games that fit into small boxes or that really that come into small boxes. I've been thinking about this a lot lately. I took some shelfy photos and posted them on Instagram the other day and I realized as I was doing that that just how kind of full my shelves are. I'm very grateful that they are full of games. um but how I want to continue to explore many more games in the future and I just don't have room for them. And so I am valuing more and more games that fit into a smaller space. Now I certainly don't mind when a game comes in a more standard gameiz box like the size of of Wingspan or Ticket to Ride.

It's a great size, especially if you there are lots of expansions that you want to fit into the box. But I do really appreciate games that feel pretty big, that feel substantial, highly replayable, and that they fit into a box that is smaller than that. I'm going to use standard because there really is no standard box size when they fit into that uh that that wingspan box size, especially if they can avoid sacrificing quality or anything about the experience by doing so. And uh and even better for the publishers, smaller games mean that you can put more games in a carton, more games on a pallet, more games on a shipping container or a or a truck or a train, however you're transporting them around the world, and so it's uh more cost-effective to freight ship these games, too. Better for the environment, too. You're using fewer components to make these games. Um and less materials, basically. So, let's jump into our panelists picks for their favorite uh games that feel big game. They don't necessarily have to be giant epic games to just feel big, but fit into a smaller than normal game box. Smaller, smaller than wingspan size game box. And I will share my other screen here so you can see the pick from Dylan, our heavy gamer. Dylan picked a game that isn't I wouldn't quite call this heavy. I call this probably a mediumweight game. This is Brew by Pandasaurus. Dylan says, "It's got a small footprint, but it feels like a very full dice placement and territory control game. My favorite parts of the game are actually managing resources and animal companions to brew the potion cards, which are both one-time abilities and points. I really like the aesthetic of the game and the

color the custom dice in particular. It's been a while since I played it, so I can't say much more about that, but I appreciate Dylan for bringing it up. Next up, we have Caitlyn, our digital gamer, mentioned Mountain Goats. Caitlyn says, "Mountain Goats is a small box game with a big table presence. Really, it practically took up the whole table. It's fun. It's got the randomness from the dice, which I believe makes it replayable. But there's a rule that lets you mitigate dice rolls if you roll too many ones, which if there was no mitigation, would make the game less fun. When game designers and producers and whoever is in charge of filling the boxes, I love when people make it so we, the customers, are not paying for air. Perfect amounts of components, and the game is great for the whole family without taking up shelf space. Mountain Goats is one that I I think about this in comparison to um uh uh uh Oh, I'm blinking on the game now. uh stop, don't stop, or can't stop, can't stop. Uh uh where you're you're trying to decide how high really you want to go at any given time in this game. And I really like it.

It's a good game from All Play, which I'll mention a little bit later as well. Skyler, our family gamer, picked my favorite game from the panelist picks. And so I won't put this game, the Fellowship of the Ring, the trick- game. I won't put this on my top 10 list, but I really do love this game, and I agree that it feels like a lot of game in a very small box. Uh K Skyler says, "This game managed to manages to pack a full 18 chapter cooperative campaign into a tiny box with each chapter introducing new characters and mechanisms. It is so impressive. Also, after you complete the campaign, you can shuffle all the different characters and quest cards together to create new unique scenarios, making it incredibly replayable. It's an excellent choice for families with easy to learn rules, cooperative play, and it's storydriven. Highly recommend checking this one out if you're a fan of trick- Skylar recommends it. ES scholars are family gamer recommends it for ages eight plus.

Some other games that weren't mentioned on um uh that I'm sorry that were mentioned by people who were aware of this category before I was filming but I haven't played yet are Witchcraft, Kinfire Delve, and Pax Renaissance. All games bigger game games that feel big fit into smaller boxes. I have not played those. And another game from our panelists that I also haven't played, so I can't really comment on on it is Gloom Haven: Buttons and Bugs. Aaron, our solo gamer, mentions this one. Uh Aaron says, "It's Gloom Haven in a box the size of your palm. A truly epic solo Gloom Haven experience with more than 20 scenarios, multiple characters. There's a lot in such a tiny box. Play it on the train, in a plane, or in your domain, wherever you play it. Do your best to not get slain." I did I wasn't aware there was going to be a ride at the end end of this Aaron, but I love that you included that.

Now, let's shift gear. Oh, I'm sorry. I didn't even show you. I I had the wrong screen up. There is Blue Loom Haven Buttons and Bugs. What I was just talking about Blue Haven Buttons and Bugs, Aaron's pick for solo gaming. Uh, a a game that feels big in a small box. Let's shift gears temporarily here because I want to mention before I get to the top 10, I'd like to mention my favorite examples from specific companies that consistently focus on smaller boxes. Uh any of these could have been or some of these maybe not all of them but some of these could have been in my top 10 but I think they're worth mentioning because these companies seem to have decided uh all all due credit to them that they want to make games in smaller boxes whenever possible but include a lot of game in that box and these are uh Garpill games that's architect my favorite pick from theirs is architects of the west kingdom uh deve games my favorite pick from them is the white castle uh game I wrote found the name of the games but not other companies there.

Gameland Games makes uh their favorite my favorite game of theirs is Tiny Epic Galaxies. Buttonshy Games, my favorite game of theirs is Hierarchy. Um there is Key Master Games. I love Parks from them. Allplay, which was mentioned earlier with Mountain Goats, my favorite game of theirs is QE. Oh, I'm for I'm gonna forget on this this uh I believe it's Jasper Jasper Games. They make the game Hear Lies that I have really enjoyed lately. I'm almost I'm almost there. Can I make it? Uh, Burger Brothers made by Tim Fowers. Root made by Leader Games and Deep Sea Adventure made by Oink Games. All games that to me feel like a big game experience. Not necessarily, again, not necessarily epic, but highly replayable, substantial game, um, but fits into small boxes. And all many of the the games from these companies do that. My personal honorable mentions are that didn't quite make the top 10 were Star Realms, Innovation, and Magic the Gathering. And then I'm filming this before we've announced this game, but I'm going to schedule this video after we've announced this game. We have a new game coming out in the near future called Origin Story. And this is a substantial engine building, tricktaking game co-designed by me and my friend Pete. And uh it is I think it fits really, really well into this category.

We packed a lot into the box. Um, and I think sometimes sacrifice sacrifices do come sometimes when trying to fit a lot into the box. For example, sleeve cards probably aren't going to fit all that great into the uh the origin story box. So there there was a satis a slight sacrifice there, but all the components do fit into the box if you're not sle. Um, but I'm really happy with how origin story came out. By the time you're watching this, hopefully you're aware of what that game is all about. It is a trick- taking game where you are um becoming a superhero or potentially a super villain and uh you're doing this through trick taking but with a strong engine building element. So, you're going to feel much more powerful at the end of the game than you did at the beginning of the game. That is origin story from Stommy Games. Now, my top 10, I'll show the other screen here. There we go. My top 10 starts out with The Resistance Avalon. This is a large group deduction bluffing game. It's the type of game that you can play in 20 minutes, but it could extend beyond that depending on how much talk you table talk you have. And oftentimes I found find when I play the resistance Avalon is that we play multiple games in a row, making it feel like that big substantial game even though it uh might require a few different sessions in a row to feel that way. Uh this is largely a game. I mean, there aren't that many components in the game. In fact, the number of components in the game could probably fit into an even smaller box because there are different roll cards that you get to align yourself with with Camelot or the the forces of Morrid. Um, a few different tokens. But, uh, but the experience of playing this game, the the I guess the the memorable experiences

that can be created from the shenanigans, the lies, the trying to convince people that you actually are who you are, uh, can lead to some some really great gameplay experiences from The Resistance Avalon. At number 10, at number nine, we have a game that I've still only played once, but it left quite a mark on me because I really in enjoyed Rogers, the Rogers of the Ganges: Cards and Karma, which is not an expansion to Rogers of the Ganges. It is a standalone game that is inspired by the Rogers of the Ganges game, which is which is a bigger game. It takes up, you know, a full wingspan size box. Um, but Rogers of the Genji's Cards and Karma is a card driven game. almost only cards with a few tokens that fits into a much smaller box, but it has the same substantial feel as the original game.

In fact, if the original game didn't exist, I don't think you would even know that this was a card game based on another game. Uh, I guess the core idea in this game is that you're gathering cards so that you can turn in the cards to get uh to move I guess essentially you're moving one way on a sixc card track, but more literally you are uh you are placing a card or or you're you're uh advancing along a a track the the a six card track um trying to get it to meet in the middle. So, you're using these six cards as a track, as the the same type of track that you see in Arc Nova, you where you have two different types of victory points. You're using six cards to accomplish that goal in Rogers the Ganges Cards and Karma. At number eight, we have probably the heaviest game on this list. This is Clans of Calonia. And this designer, this company, I think, made a really interesting choice because they made a substantial game that could have gone into a much bigger box and felt like a bigger game, but instead they included a ton of components, a a vastly replayable um variable board, a ton of wooden components, player mats, a a economy chart over here. There's all sorts of components in in this game, but it fits into um I would I don't want to say a much smaller box, but definitely a noticeably smaller box than a Wingspan style box. Um so I applaud I applaud them for for doing this and for packing such a big great engine building game uh where you're where you are oftentimes throughout the game you're removing tokens from your mat and putting them on

the board a little bit Terrammystica style. I think it's heavily inspired by Terrammystica, but in a way that is uh really it it feels completely fresh. It doesn't feel like terrammystica. You're not terraforming. Um uh yeah, it's a fantastic game in a in a small box. That is Clans of Calonia. Next up, we have Bonanza, a trading game and and probably as far as I can as I can think of my favorite game where you are trading cards with other players. Uh, this is a game where you're to plant beans in two fields and um and then eventually turn them in for points and potentially even add a third field at some point. And there there the game makes you draw cards. The game makes you play gards from a certain side of your hand. And so you have these restrictions that lead you to trading with other players with getting rid of certain cards so you can play the cards that you really want and so that you can get the cards that you want from other players and potentially trade cards to them that they want. uh to plant in their fields. It's a I don't know. It's kind of a miracle of a game how well this game works and how long it came out. I think it came out in 1997 if I have that correct. And even though it doesn't have that many components, it's just a a couple a big deck of of these bean cards. It really feels like a a full substantial highly replayable experience. That's Bundance number seven.

And number number six, another trick-T game. I mentioned a few of them here in the form of our game origin story fellowship of the ring trick taking game. This is Cat in the Box. I've played Cat in the Box so many times and continue to love it. And it's not just a deck of cards in the Box. There's this whole board uh where you are relaying to other players and to yourself which numbers have been played because the cards in Cat in the Box don't have a suit. You declare the suit as you play it, but the game needs to remember that a two, a green two has been played. So, you have this board, you have a bunch of tokens that players have. You have this other little map where you keep track of your bids and you keep track of which suits of cards you've said that you no longer have in your hand. There's a lot of this box. Uh there's a lot of replayability. Um and it feels to me like a it to me this to me is not a like a a filler trick taking game. This is a a really substantial trick taking game.

Um yeah, I I really really enjoy Cat in the Box. Cat in the Box at number six on my list. At number five, we have adjacent to the category of tricking, we have the gang. I've fallen hard for the gang over the last year. I think this is a cooperative poker style game where you're working together with up to five other players to determine the strength of your poker hands with very limited communication. The game is essentially just a deck of cards, but it is more than that because it's also these poker chips. Um, you could also use any poker chips, but the the number of icons on the poker chips does matter in this game. But crucially to make this game extra special, and that I think really elevates it is these cards that you gain if you fail a round or if you succeed a round, you gain a card temporarily to make the game a little next to make the next round a little harder or a little easier. It's another 20 cards in the game, but those cards make a big difference for adding replayability to to get making you feel like you have a chance even though you failed a few times. I think they're really really well-designed cards in the game. My number five pick for a big game in a very small box. And really a box, you know, if you're going to make a smaller box, why not make it feel really special by adding, I don't know, whether it's beautiful art, they have gold foil on the box of the gang. I think that's a great approach to go with a smaller box.

Next up, we have Oh, I didn't pick an image for Harmonies. Harmonies. Uh, here's one. Harmonies is another game that packs a lot of components into a very small box. It isn't the tiniest of boxes. You can't put it in your pocket, but it is a smaller than standard box size. There's all these wooden components. There's these cubes that you're putting on the different uh towers that you've built um to show which animals you have. They represent animals um that you've that you've put out here. right? You can't put more than one cube on the same tower. There's a bunch of beautifully illustrated cards in the game. There's a big bag uh that holds all these wooden tokens, and you each have your own little player board that's doublesided as well. There's a lot in this box uh for the size of the box and just the the gameplay. I I keep talking about the number of components in the games, but this isn't just about the the sheer amount of components, but it's also about the gameplay and how substantial a game of harmonies feels as you are rather quickly building up this island, creating these habitats, defining which animals are um are in the different habitats so you can actually score those cards. Um it's a really really satisfying game that I find myself whenever someone brings Harmony to Game Night or wants to play harmonies, I'm in. I I really really enjoy the experience.

At number three, we have one of my recent favorites, Duel for Middle Earth, the sequel or the spiritual successor to Seven Wonders Duel. I am completely enamored with this game, and I I did take into consideration that this is a two-player only game. Not that it should necessarily knock this up or down the list, but when I think about big substantial games, I do often think about slightly higher player counts, not just two-player games. But still, I love this game so much. And I love the next game on this list, which is also a two-player game, so much that I think that this game deserves to be on the on the list. I there there's so much rich gameplay from the public card draft that emerges from a game of uh of Seven Wonders Duel and how quickly you you level up and you're advancing towards multiple victory conditions very early in the game and then the other player pulls them away from you and then you go full charge on one of them and try to get it because the game will end instantly with a victory if someone accomplishes one of those those victory conditions. I keep coming back to it over and over again and playing it multiple times in a row. I love Duel for Middle Earth. is my number number three pick. And number two is the Star Wars deck building game. I now have both of these games. It's two separate games that can be mixed and matched together, but I now have both of them in one box.

So I essentially have two games of this in one box. And that one box is still about half the size of a Wingspan box. This game is a delight. You've probably heard me rave about it on this channel. I really need to do a video where I just rave about it for a while because I love talking about the game. I love playing Star Wars, the Star Wars technology game. Um, what's one thing that I haven't said about it in a while on this channel that I can throw out there? Uh, I love um, what do I love about it? I because I I often mention the the card row in the middle and how you can either buy a card or remove a card so your opponent can't get it. I think that is such a clever mechanism. It lets you kind of build your own asymmetry throughout the game and you impact the opponent's asymmetry as well. It's one that I often talk about, but I think it's worth mentioning again because I still haven't seen this accomplished in another game. And I'm still trying to figure out a way to to use this system in a multiplayer game. I know technically you can play this game in teams, but I'm not really looking for a team game. I'm looking for a a multiplayer game where you can use a card row in a similar way. I'll figure it out. Or maybe I won't and someone else will, but that is the Star Wars deck building game. At number two, number one though, I'm going to break away from the two-player games and go with Forest Shuffle. a one to five player game where so much is fit into this tiny box. This box is almost a fourth of the size of the Wingspan box.

It's only almost only just cards. You can see that it's just a deck of cards. And you can almost think that this box could have been even smaller, but they have added so many expansions since then that that I'm glad the box isn't any smaller than this. Uh Forest Shuffle is a game. Let's see if I can show you a little bit what it looks like beyond just the box. Force shuffle is a game where you are inserting cards under trees in your tableau. You're building a tableau of trees and you're inserting these cards uh above or below or to the left or right of trees to have ongoing abilities, to score, to have instant benefits, a wide variety of of of benefits that you're getting from these cards. But really, I think the thing the game does so successfully to fit so much content into a smaller box is that every card is two cards. It isn't just one card. So, like this card, I can play it for the salamander or I can play it for the bird. Um, so it's two cards built into one, which is great for the design space as well because I'm giving players two cards with a single card draw that they can decide later how they want to actually play this card. It's brilliant.

It is so so clever. I love force shuffle. It is definitely my number one pick on this list for how much game is packed into this tiny pocket. You know, it's a good sign when I'm talking about a game and I'm already thinking about playing the game. Like I I would go play this game right now if someone were up for playing for shuffle. It is on board game arena, but I prefer to play it on the tabletop because it looks great on the tabletop and it's so easy to set up. It's you just shuffle the deck of cards. You insert some winner cards in the bottom third and you start to play. Uh yeah, I love this game and uh yeah, I do want to give a shout out to actual LOL um who has a video about the idea of fun density in games. That is essentially what I'm talking about today, where you've packed a lot of fun into a smaller box. It's a great video. I'll link to it in the description of the video so you can go check that out. And um yeah, I'd love to hear your favorite game that feels big, that feels substantial, that feels highly replayable, or is highly replayable, but it fits into a smaller than normal box size. Let me know what your pick is in the comments below. Thanks,

Progress saved