Revisiting our Top 10 Board Games of 2024 - Did We Get It Right?
Transcript
Welcome back. It is the year 2025, but this video, it's about 2024. It's about our games of the year for 2024. Uh, interestingly enough, if you watch the channel, Ryan and I didn't even record our top 10 for 2024 together.
That's true.
So, uh, and of course, we watched each other's videos, so we know thoroughly the games. I'm kidding. Uh, I don't know that
Well, it was a year ago. I
I'll I'll be honest. I don't know if I watched all the way through your video. I skimmed it like probably most of you. Uh, but we're going to be talking about we're going to revisit our top 10 for 2024 as we get into the season of gearing up for our top 10 for 2025. Uh, and to start that, we're going to rattle off really quickly. I promise we're not going to go through each and every title and say, "Oh, I regret this." Or, "Oh, I stand by this." We will for some, but just to list our titles. 10 to one, I had Stalker. That's from Awaken Realms. Uh, Primal, Wondrous Creatures, Lord of the Rings Duel, Tidal Blades 2, Agamonia at number five, Seaside at number four, Bomb Busters at number three. Spoiler alert, I stand by that. Has nothing to do with the fact that it won the spiel.
It's a good call.
Uh, STI was my number two, and number one was Saltard.
All right. Well, my number 10 started off with Sor. My number nine, Misttor, then Slay the Spire, Black Forest, Arcs. I also had Lord of the Rings Duel. I had Manfer, which is one that I'll stand by, and Inventions. I'll stand by both of those. My number two being STI. And my number one, Star Wars Unlimited, which even at the time I was like, I'm it didn't really feel like a board game, but like
yeah,
it was the game I played most in 2024. Yeah, I would say the two two big takeaways. I I do remember that about your list and I remember thinking like, "Oh, wow. You're putting a CCG or a TCG at number one. That's interesting." But
to be fair, Ryan has You've probably played more of that than anything else this year. Even this year, right?
Probably even this year. Yeah, I would say. Well, if you're if you're looking at individual plays, Yes.
then for sure. I played more Star Wars Unlimited. I was in a league with Nelson who's been on the channel before and our friend Brandt
step into the portal. Like we play over Discord quite a bit. We've done some
uh Three Suns which is or whatever it's called the the multiplayer format which is
these are things I know nothing about because you know how many times I've played Star Wars Unlimited in 2025?
Zero.
Yeah, that sounds about right.
And that's no offense. That's just my taste. I don't get into those games. If I play with Ryan, it's futile because I feel super intimidated whenever I play you or someone like Nelson and I'm sitting there looking at the cards like I'm looking at them for the first time because it often is the first time where Ryan knows every single card in the in his in his whole deck. So, he's just like,
well, sure. I mean,
which puts me on edge, too, when someone's sitting there doing the little like
Oh, that's like classic Magic the Gathering right there. The card shuffle. and I just feel like I don't know what I'm doing. But yeah, now on the other hand, my list was unique. I think the biggest most unique thing about my list for me last year was that I had so many bigger campaign style games on it.
Yeah.
Um, Primal is not exactly a I mean, it can be a campaign game. Um, but it does probably get played more often as a one-off boss battler, just session by session. But I played a fair amount of that. We did a fair amount of content on the channel for it. Um, but also Agamonia, which
yeah, it was big campaign.
Honestly, I can't even remember when it was that I'd played so much Agamonia.
I know you and Alicia played quite a bit of it. Right.
We did, but I can't remember if that took place prior to that list. Probably some of it did. Some of it a little bit afterwards. But I can tell you
here too, right? a little bit because I will tell you it we had it set up under the table under the tabletop
and it remained there for most of 2025. I think it was maybe September where I was sort of like we were preparing to record some stuff and I knew we needed to record a few things. So I I wanted to set up a game underneath and on top so that we could get things recorded.
And I remember asking Alicia because it'd been months since we'd played it. It was it was like it wasn't collecting dust because it was covered by the table, but effectively if it was. So I said, "Hey honey, uh are we ever going to play more Agamonia?" And she's like, "Probably not."
Oh.
Now again, none of what we're saying today and any reg it's not really regrets. It's just, you know, we move on. We are if if anyone is called of the new in this hobby, I'm very much that. So the fact that I even stuck with campaign games long enough to play some is quite something. And the same could be said for Title Blades 2, which is on my list as well. I played We didn't play as much of that as we did Aamonia, but we played through like seven. We played at least through halfway through the campaign with Title Blades, and I kind of want to go back to that.
It's tough. It's tough to finish these campaign. That's why I was surprised because you're not ever the first to be like, because I know your your mentality for games is like you don't want to play 12 of the same game, especially in like such a short period of time. I remember
attention span problem. We used to play. We played that that Journeys of Middle Earth and it was like we're gonna play 10 games in a weekend. You were like no count.
Oh, no. I didn't play one.
I know. I know. I let you.
Uh I just feel like So what happened last year that you had like Stalker was a big box game. Primal big box game. Title Blades. Edgeimonia. Those are all like big campaign stuff.
Yeah, Stalker is another one that just barely made my list last year. And I will admit there was some recency bias at play there. I still stand by that game though and it's something I definitely want to get back to. In fact, uh, very recently, a local friend of mine who's not really a big board gamer,
uh, but he's a big video gamer, and I thought, you know what? I I really want to get Stalker back to the table because I played through the tutorial and a little bit sort of like two-handing it um by myself just to learn the game.
And we played a bit of it, too.
Yeah, we played a little bit. I really like the system. It's a lot of game to sort of set up
and and like remember and digest all of the rules. Like you kind of have to stick with that. You can't play stalker once and then come back to it six months and go, "Oh, I remember exactly how to play. I remember all the tiny little nuanced rules." I mean that is one of the downside of a lot of those games. Like Primal would be the same way. Primal felt in many ways like a lifestyle game. it like Nelson played it with me quite a bit and I knew he would love it because it really tickles that same sort of living card game sort of vibe uh in terms of what you're doing and the puzzle that you're solving and it is a fantastic game. Uh but yeah, I've not played too much of that this year, although I have played some.
Oh yeah, and yeah, and we'll get back to some of those. I mean, that's that's the thing about about playing campaign games, especially you mentioned it with the Call of the It's hard to get a game to the table 12 time. I mean, some of these are 12 missions long or longer, and it's just difficult to get a game to the table that many times. Of course, like Star Wars Unlimited, I did, but because games are 20 minutes, and I
Those are those Yeah. And they're they're in and of themselves just one game. Yeah. Like they're not contingent on the last game you played or the next game you're playing.
And I have a friend that plays it pretty heavily, so it's always easy to get a game. Uh, we both rated SEI pretty high and I I stand by that. I still enjoy SEI. I'm very much We should have that Space Agency's expansion
for sure. It was I think SEI ended up being if you had to pick one title that popped towards the to the most people's top 10 list, it was probably that last year. Like most people had STI in their top three of Euro fans.
Yeah, I think we all four did because Jeremy and Emily filmed that with us as well. And I think we all had STI pretty high. And I reme remember when I was debating my list, uh, I had two games from Thomas Hollik on there, which was SEI and Galileo Galile. I'd only played Galileo Galile one time. We did it on our Essen live stream last year. Uh, and I remember I liked it, but like for whatever reason, I just decided, okay, I I don't want to have this list dominated by the same designer, which might have been a mistake because and that was kind of
you could have because I think you would have put Tea Garden on there, too. Well, here's the thing is I hadn't played Tea Garden at that point
and I'd only played Galileo Galile once. I've played Galileo Galilee like three or four more times this year and Tea Garden twice this year.
You really like Tea Garden?
I did really like Te I I don't know that Tea Garden would have still made my top 10. Okay.
But Galileo Galile definitely would have and that's another one with an expansion we've talked about on the channel. Very much looking forward to. I just played Galileo again, I don't know, maybe two weeks ago at a game day and I was just like, man, this this still really holds up that mechanic of moving that
the telescope and the timing. Like that's a game that I'm I'm learning more and more about every time we play. I think we discredit ourselves a little bit
in in just this call to the new thing where it's like some of these games you really need three or four plays to like you're just uncovering new and more uh strategies and depth to the game. like Galileo has just so much under the surface, but it's tough to get a game played four times or five times to really see that.
A lot of uh YouTube channels or other people in the board game space will feel like they need to play something like four or five times before they give it a full review. You know, full disclosure, we do not feel that way. That's oftentimes why we don't do fullblown deep dive reviews. We'll do sort of like first impressions if we've played it, like this is how we feel. Um, if we don't like a game, we've said this before on the channel, if I've played it once and I didn't care for it, we generally won't record anything because I don't I I can often change my mind. The first play could have some other factors affecting it. Uh, revive is a classic one like that for me. Um, but if we've played something and we're like, well, this is good and we'll talk about it in our first impressions. Generally speaking, those don't fade
right
in a big way.
It's very rare. I think it it's common for a game to be bad on the first play because you didn't understand it or something didn't click and then the second play, oh, it clicks now and this mechanic that makes the game now I'm able to really use that mechanic and enjoy it. Whereas, if you love a game the first time, it might fade a little bit. But generally, when I play the second or third time, I'm not like, oh, but you know, if I play it like maybe 10 times, I might go, okay, well, I've seen everything this game has to offer. I've done the same strategy 10 times in a row, but that's still 10 plays of a game. Like, that's quite a few.
Yeah. I would say in this hobby, if you're really into board gaming, if you get 10 plays of any of your games, I think that's above average, honestly. I mean, I think um I mean, people's collections are so out of hand and there's so many games published that it's really hard to get them all played. Now, the ones that are easier to get to played are ones unlike what we've just talked about, the campaign games, even the Euro games that are a little harder to get to the table, but not too hard. But things like uh we both had Lord of the Rings Duel
and I've I've played that probably 10 times.
That that game gets played. It's like we said I think in our video for it, we think it was better version of Duel for me anyway.
Um I think it's streamlined but streamlined in the right way. And then another small one, at least that was on my list, uh was Seaside. This is like the lightest of games on anyone's list. In fact, of all of my top 10 lists over the years, is probably one of the lighter, simpler, family weight style games. And I do stand by this. Now, I'll say about this now, probably what I said then, this game is not going to set the world on fire. This is not like going to be remembered as a classic that will be in everyone's homes. But I said then, it should be in a lot of people's homes. I don't see any collection. If you ever find yourself in a situation where you're playing with casual people, uh people who aren't into the hobby, if you want to take some games on a vacation, this game is great. Uh but it is very simple. Have I gotten it played since? I have. But usually it is only in those cases, right?
It's good to have a game just for that.
And it just sits pleasantly on my shelf uh in in its little bag that you can just grab off the shelf. But yeah, if Y, me, Emily, and Jere Jeremy are going to get together and we say, "What do we want to play first?" You know, no one's going to say Seaside, but it's still a great game.
I was also I was kind of surprised also that I didn't have Castle Combo on my list. I don't And I don't know why because I I love Castle Combo. You didn't have it on your list either, and we've played that.
Emily did. Emily had it on her list.
Emily is the smart one of the whole group.
That ended up being the game that I've played consistently and I played on BGA. It's become such a like
that's a good one
a game in my pocket to just pull out. Castle combo I missed.
And then I had Black Forest on my list and I still stand by Black Forest. I think it's good. That's one that has I've played it a few more times. I probably would have replaced that one with Galileo Galile.
And then Men Nefer again one that I stand by. I just I thought this was going to end up being a huge game. I don't know that it really got a big US release. It definitely didn't enter sort of the zeitgeist. There wasn't a period of time where everyone was talking about manfer the problem was that an Essen release.
It was
but I don't know if it came over to the states.
Yeah. One of the tricky thing I don't know.
So that's why that's why I wonder if it didn't.
But one of the tricky things about those Essen releases those sort of like medium plus or medium to medium plus weight euros that come out at Essen. There's a handful of them. And if you're not a
handful,
if you're not one of the top three that everyone's raving about, it is harder to stand out. Like for example, this year we've got Oroy was a biggie.
Um, recall was in the mix, but not quite. And there was like maybe one other that that is escaping. Oh, Covenant,
which is from the designer of Mennefer, actually. So, he's getting his second shot at this. And I already think Covenant is getting more buzz than Men Nefer got. I think Mennefer might be a better game. I love Covenant, but I really I'll still go back and play Men Nefer whenever anybody asks.
Yeah, I would say Covenant and Oroy. I know we're off topic right now, but those are probably the two coming out of Essen that are they're going to hit that. But yeah, Mfer. I never played. Yeah, you should.
I I would like to try it.
You liked Covenant?
Yeah, I liked Covenant quite a bit.
He did Bku as well, which
I love Bku. Bku I really like quite a bit. Covenant kind of feels like it shares some DNA with both of those games. But Men Nefr, if you can get a copy of Men Nefer, if you can find that game and you like Eurogame, that is definitely one to try. Everyone that we've introduced it to has really enjoyed it.
So, uh, there's only two more on my list that I want to talk about. I'll talk about one of them very briefly. I already mentioned it earlier, Bomb Busters. Obviously, it won their spiel. Um, a lot of people put Bomb Busters in their mix. I don't I didn't I may have been the only one.
Did Emily not have Bombers? might have had it on her top 10. Um, but I definitely really enjoyed this game quite a bit and obviously a lot of people did and acknowledge that by the spiel. Um, and I've played this a fair amount since and I've played it with people where I introduced it to them. Um, some of which didn't take with them, you know, and some of which were pretty outspoken honestly. Some people on some podcasts that I won't mention uh
said uh that they didn't see why Bombbusters got the name nomination. I
well the win even
and that but I completely see I mean that that has spiel written all over it in my opinion. Um but it's a great great great game. If you haven't played it try it and you can play through this whole sort of like I mean it in and of itself is kind of a campaign as well if you want it to be if you want to play that much. The other game, and this was my number one, this was the one for me that beat out STI was Saltfield. Saltfield I 100% stand behind. I've taught this a number of times since last year, and I don't I don't think I've played it with anyone who didn't really really enjoy it. Now, I did play it once with Isaac Childris, and it's not Salt Fur's problem. It's an Isaac Children's problem. Did
he just solve it instantly?
He destroyed everybody just like he always does. And it felt like, you know, and again, this is not unself because I played uh what was the one Sor also with him
and he destroyed everyone in that to the point where I was like, "Oh, what? Either we're dumb or the game is broken and the games aren't broken."
It might be the first one.
Maybe we're dumb.
The I don't even Yeah, I was going to say I don't even want to say this is a problem because this is what makes Isaac such a great game designer. And this is how we get games like Gloom Haven because I've played plenty with him where he just can look at the game. You give him the rules explanation. He goes, "All right, he's already planned out his entire game. He knows exactly. He's figured out the most efficient way to score and he is like the only games I can beat Isaac at are party games."
Yeah.
Because he just even if I'm the teacher and I could have played the game multiple times, he's played it his first play just instantly can figure out any game and see the mechanics and understand how they all work together. It's really tough to beat him. So
really annoying that way.
Don't take it too high.
Hi Isaac. Uh, so I figured I hadn't played when it came time to make our list. And
would you have put it on your tent?
I would have 100% put it on my tent. I'm going to give a call. Adam, I bet you're watching this right now. Adam's a good friend of mine. We do this Cabin Con every year and he brought Saltfield specifically because it was I he knew I hadn't played it. He was like, "You're going to love this game." So like he basically hounded me and not in a bad way, but he was like, "I'm going to make sure that you get Selfiard played." And it came down to the last day we hadn't played. He's like, "No, we're stopping everything we're going to do. we're going to play Selfie because we're not leaving without playing it. And I fell in love with it and I'm I'm really glad that I got the chance and I've played it since and it held up.
Yeah, it I mean it probably would have. I liked Santa Maria back when that originally released and this is different.
It used to I think it's better.
It makes more sense. The theme makes it work a lot better.
Set the theme aside even. They they've added some stuff mechanically.
Yeah. Well, the the way the theme is is incorporated in it. It doesn't feel like a bunch of abstract tracks. you're going out in the water bringing back the fish, which is the nice fun lowhanging fruit of the game, which I really like doing, is just trying to go out there and bring back tons in in my boat and upgrade my boat. I still haven't played with the little mini modules that they're included
that let you do some really crazy things on your
to do that. But the the problem with some of these games, and it's like I look back at my list, I'm like, well, should SFear be like I didn't get to play until 2025, early 2025. But it's like these Essen games. There were Essen games like Colution that I was really excited to play Colution. I didn't get it played until this year. I mean, when you come back from Essen with 20 great games, and I'm having the same problem right now looking at all these Essen releases that just came out, there's still like three that I really feel like I need to play before I can kind of decide what I liked best. But the ones I didn't get to play, they're just going to get shoved over to the 2026 year. like it it's kind of hard to to decide, you know, based on when it came out or based on when I played it if I'm going to put it on these lists.
Yeah. No, I totally understand. In fact, let us know in the comments below. Ryan and I talk about this a fair amount. Uh when we come to the end of the year, we're like, do we want when where do we want to put the cuto off? Do we want to do a cutoff before the end of the year? I personally don't like doing a cutoff like that because I think you guys want to see and hear about the latest games. Um, you know, and a lot of these ones that come out of Essen, most people award season.
Yeah, exactly. Most people won't play these in the States until next year.
But I think we serve a better, you know, we we provide a better service by telling you what we really loved that you might be able to play in the not too distant.
Well, and that's and that's the thing, too, like I kind of balance it because like Shackleton Bass came out of Essen. I didn't get to play till this year, but it's readily available now. If I tell people
Oh, same with Phoenix.
Yeah. Oh, yeah. Phoenix. New Horizon. It's like if if you want to if I tell you these games are good, you can go get them. Whereas if I tell you that Covenant is good and you might have to wait till March or April before Covenant actually like has
or or they have been getting better about making some of these euros available before the end of the year.
I mean we've got some companies that are like D'Ve published Covenant. So they they have a straight US publication, but there's plenty of games that are just wait like I don't know who's bringing them out in the US. We just have to kind of wait and see. Like I said about Menfer, I don't know that it ever did or if it did, it wasn't like a widely publicized release.
Yeah, we'll have to look into that. Let us know in the comments below if you know if Manfer came out. We'll do a little research too before we edit this for sure.
Uh but anyway, that is sort of our look back at our 2024 top 10 lists. Uh I feel pretty good about it. I don't feel like I have any regrets. Do you have any regrets? I think Ryan only regrets not having played some games.
There's the regrets I had were not Minos. Another one like Minos and uh Phoenix New Horizon and all these games that I didn't get to play before the end of the year.
Did I play Minos before the end of the year last year?
I don't know. You did. You and I.
It had to have been on my short list.
It must have been. But I really liked Minos, but it's like
I didn't get a chance to play until January, February. So,
it was a lot of games. But yeah, that is typically our our regret is not having had the chance to play a game and like it's not going to be on my list.
Yeah. Uh, but let us know, should we put those games on this year's list because most people will have a lot of those on this year.
It came out in December of 2024. Not a lot of people got to play in 2024.
Exactly. So, let us know in the comments below what you think about that. But those are our lists. Let us know what you think about them. Let us know again what what your list for 2024 were. Or even if you want to talk about your 2025 list, that's okay, too. Until next time, though, make sure everyone has fun at the table and we'll see you then.