Grogu, Dinner Parties, UKGE, and More! (March 27 2026 Livecast)
Transcript
Hey, good morning. I'm Jamey Stegmaier from Stonemaier Games and I'm here to spend the next hour with you to chat about board games, tabletop games, card games, uh Survivor, anything that you want to talk about including in the in the uh description here I mentioned Grogu dinner parties, the UK Games Expo and more. Uh most importantly, I hope you are having a wonderful week so far. It's been kind of a I don't know if you're in the US, it was Memorial Day this past Monday and I don't know I don't know about you but I'm I'm always thrown off when there's a Monday that kind of feels like a holiday. I worked a little bit but I also played a little bit. And it it uh today doesn't quite feel like a Wednesday as a result. It feels like a Tuesday but also a little bit like a Thursday. It's confusing for my my time brain.
Um Looks like RJ Games Guy mentioned uh is asking everyone if you've played any Stonemaier games lately. We do have the new Sharks and Reef expansion and the new uh Euphoria essential. Um Garrett says he played some Viticulture over the weekend with five players, made great use of the new trailblaze action on the quest. So this is from the sale and trail pack or the trail and sale pack. Although even if you don't have that pack, you can apply it to pretty much any quest card where you're struggling to find the destination in Viticulture. You can just use rule pop to take the trailblaze action. It's a it's a move action and that will help you uh I believe it's move action or look action. I think it's move action. Um that will help you find the destination.
So, what are we talking about today? I have Let me start with a few low-key things. Um My favorite game I played I played a lot of delightful, wonderful, immersive games at Geekway to the West recently. And I I had a great time playing with different people, different uh short games, long games. But I think and I I posted this video on Tuesday. I think my the favorite game I played, the game that I most wanted to play again is a game called Three Chapters. And the designer, Joe, uh I believe Houte, h o u t is his last name, um reached out to me. He saw that I was talking and saying very nice things about Three Chapters and he said that he had some extra copies from the publisher and he was very kind to send me a copy of Three Chapters. I usually don't accept free games. I'm not a reviewer.
I'm not a content creator. But Joe was sending it to me, designer to to designer, and he knew one of the reasons I don't accept free games is that I I feel an obligation to play them, but I really want to play Three Chapters again. I'm excited to play again. I really loved it. I even sleeved it yesterday. I hardly ever sleeve games, but I wanted to sleeve it cuz I I know I'm going to play it a bunch. So, thank you, Joe, for doing that. And Joe also in the package included my treat of the day or chocolate treat of the day, including this game treat of the day, a Ferrero Rocher, um 70% cocoa. I feel like I've butchered that name. How do you all pronounce Ferrero Rocher? Um are there silent r's in there? But that is my treat of the day. I hope you are treating yourself to something fun today, whether it's a game, an experience, a person, a uh or an experience with a person, some time with a person, quality time, or or some some food, some chocolate, some delicious drinks.
Um People are talking about Oh, here's Joe. Hey, Joe is actually here. Thank you so much, Joe. Uh I I I really appreciate you sending me this game and I'm so excited to play it. I I have game night tomorrow night after virtual game night tonight and I'm hoping to get this to the table tomorrow. I see that it does play down to two players, so Megan and I might play it, but I think I'll generally play this at the higher player counts, three, four, five, six. I see a bunch of people saying so Aaron taught uh their mom Euphoria. I see Dan played Vantage, completed both the quest and the destiny in epic victory for Dan. See, Steve played Viticulture Bordeaux. Nate played a game that felt like Vantage called Winnie the Pooh Serious Detective. Yeah, I love the art in that game. I haven't played it but I've seen the art.
And Paul does mention that the Board Games Hot Takes podcast did a nice segment on Euphoria and the concept of essential editions. I didn't know they talked more about it about I saw that they they did Euphoria but I didn't know they were delving into other essential editions. So I'll have to listen to that.
Steve has a joke here. In Egypt they recently unearthed another mummy that was covered in chocolate and nuts. They believed it was Pharaoh Rocher. Thank you Steve for that. Tim says question related to Let's Go to France, the follow-up to Let's Go to Japan, one of my favorite games of the last few years. Tim says Kickstarters are all in the demo copies look pretty final but the fulfillment is in April. What typically takes 11 months at this point? Oh, what what would take 11 months? Um well, most likely well, I don't know. I can't speak for the publisher. I I it if it looks like the game is final then they are probably just padding what could be a 6 to 7 month process of production and freight shipping and fulfillment. They're probably just padding that.
Um but maybe they do have a few final touches. Maybe they wanted to leave a little room in the schedule to see if backers had any ideas that would improve the game in in tiny incremental ways. But you're right, from what I've seen the game looks pretty final and so they are probably just putting, you know, final touches on it and they're going to most likely beat that scheduled time. That would be my best guess. Justin got in his 77th play of Vantage. He started at brazen so the game didn't last long. Yeah, that is I often do that too. I typically when I play Vantage, I play at or I choose three or four. Other players can choose other starting levels. Three would be would be brazen. I think four is what daring. I usually choose that. I like that that pressure right from the start.
Rocher, thank you Helen. Rocher is pronounced Rocher. That makes sense. Silent silent R. So Jeff had a good Memorial Day game session with Finn's game the clue VCR game Bomb Busters the crew deep sea and so clover. That's a great combination of games. So that real quick with some games that I played over the weekend or since we last talked at game night last week. I played the knop. I played 10b. The knop is kind of like Scout where you can flip your entire hand of cards, but unlike Scout you can rearrange your cards a little bit and you are trying to generally play better cards than those are on the table, but it has some nice twist beyond that in this shedding game. I also played 10b, which is a a panorama card building game where you're trying to um complete goals that you are choosing to put within your Tableau and and outside of your Tableau as you build the town of 10b.
Both of these games were a lot of fun and I will gladly play either of them again. I also taught and played a game night Sunday split one of my favorite I cut you choose games or lighter I cut you choose games and also the game that I bought in Dublin the Lorcana Palace Heist, which can play up to four players. Out of the box it plays one to two players. Megan and I tried the easy level yesterday and it was actually pretty difficult. Like it came down to the last turn where it was either going to be us or Jafar and we won. I will say I enjoyed it. I don't know you know, I'm always looking for a heist game that really feels like the heist movies that I love. I wouldn't say this accomplishes that goal, but this is a neat cooperative version of Lorcana that I enjoyed. So, we played that yesterday. I think there's one other game that I played recently.
I don't see it here, but yeah, that might have been it. Tim says, "What did I think of Survivor and the live TV glitch?" You know what made it memorable. I That's what happens when you have some live TV. Uh I'm I don't want to spoil anything here, Tim, so I'll speak a little vaguely. The person I was rooting for didn't win, but I I I'm happy certainly happy for the person who who did win. Part of the Survivor is, you know, getting the votes of the people on the jury, even if the people watching at home don't necessarily agree with the decisions that they're making. But, uh yeah, I thought it was a a great entertaining finale. I had a great time. I I usually host the Survivor finale for friends, and that's what we did this year. We had a good good group of little over a dozen people watching, which was a lot of fun to watch Survivor with.
And I cooked um I cooked the rice and beans because Survivor's uh the fans somehow didn't vote to give Survivor's rice and beans this year. I I voted to give them rice and beans, so I made it for friends. Kind of elevated fancy beans, not just uh not just plain beans. And uh among other dishes, I also served uh the Mr. Beast brand of chocolate candy bars as a as an ode to Mr. Beast appearing on the show this season. Um but yeah, I had fun watching the the finale. Nate says, "I know you're not into racing." That's true. Racing games, but not racing as a sport. And Nate says, "This weekend's Indy 500 was fantastic and had the closest ever finish. The winner had a touching radio message to his wife who was home with his 2-week-old daughter."
Was this also the protege of um the person the racer who who died um a week or so ago? Um I heard there there was kind of a a touching moment related to that as well. Uh I'm just looking through comments or questions right here. Dan says, "Have you ever played a game that was really hyped, that people were excited about, and people seem to love it, but you didn't click with it?" Absolutely. Yeah, I mean, definitely. I I I think I I I would guess that anyone has had this experience where you play a game that everyone else seems excited about, and it just doesn't hit home with you. Um I've definitely had that happen, yeah. I don't I don't uh You know, I I guess if you ever want to see the games [clears throat] that uh I if you ever see my opinions about games that I really like or really dislike, um you can you can always check out my ratings on BoardGameGeek. I don't like to to broadcast the things that I don't like. I'd rather speak positively about them. But, for sure, yeah, I'm I'm, you know, I'm a human being. I have preferences and tastes. I always try to take something positive from the games I play and learn from them, whether it's a product design element or game design element, or both. But, um but certainly there there are many many games that I play, really, that that I'm glad that I played once, but I'm not itching to necessarily play again. And there are certainly some that I like just outright wouldn't play again, because I I really didn't enjoy the first play. I do try to
give Just like I try to give people second chances, I do try to give games second chances, but that's also come back to bite me. Uh I have one memorable game in particular that uh I I was really told that the second play is the one that adds upon the first play, and it gets much better, and it was just as as miserable as the first play. So, um I I kind of regret going back to it and giving it that second chance. But, I do try to I I generally try to do that if I if I don't mind. If I if I have like a mediocre, but curious uh perspective on the first play. Arnauho says that all of our gaming friends had a mild cold this weekend, so we took advantage of having a babysitter and dinner out and did a painting class. That's lovely. A little date night. Have you ever done a painting class?
Not as an adult. As a as a when I was younger, I took um some photography classes. I took some art classes. Not painting specifically, it was more focused on drawing. Uh but I haven't done a painting class as an adult. I've I've heard it's a lot of fun and it sounds like a a great date night, maybe a memorable date night, too. Corey from Blue Falcon says, "What's the etiquette of pitching or negotiating a game to a publisher? Would it be overstepping to request that the original art commissioned, originally planned to self-publish, um be given the first right of refusal or forgoing an upfront payment to the rights for X amounts of copies of the game from from the initial print run?" So, a couple of things here. So, um great question, Corey. So, I I think it is uh valid. I'll peek over the comment here. For a designer to have uh to have deal breakers. I think it's fine for any of us to have deal breakers. I think you also have to know that the more deal breakers that you share with a publisher when you're pitching to them, probably the less likely they are to decide to publish the game cuz you are taking decisions away from them that they might otherwise want to make on their own for what they think will be best for the game.
Um so, I think that is a a gamble in general. As for these specific request, I'm going to I'm going to pull the comment Well, I'll leave the comment up. I'll I'll just be a a just a head here for a second. Um Would it be overstepping to request the original art commissioned be given the first right of refusal? I think the way you phrased that is perfectly fine. And some publishers might see that as a huge asset. They might really like the art and they might say, "Okay, sure. We will give this a chance first. We will at least test this art out and if we don't think it's the best for the game, we'll commission more art." You That even might be a nice thing for some publishers to hear because they don't have to go spend a bunch of money on art. That's I think I like the way that you phrased it there, rather than have it as a deal breaker, right of first refusal.
As for the second one, forgoing an upfront payment to the rights for X amounts of copies from the game from the initial print run. This is um I think it depends on what X is. I think it's reasonable for any designer to expect to get at least a half dozen to a dozen copies of the game from a publisher for free. Not to sell, but to give to friends and family. I guess technically you could sell it, but they're intended for you to just give it to people, friends, family, playtesters, people like that. That is fine. If X is 100 copies because you want to go to like a local convention and sell it, or you want to sell them to local stores, or you want to give them away to to to charitable organizations that you're passionate about, things like that. I think there are reasons that a publisher might be fine with a much higher X like that.
Not necessarily even to forgoing an upfront payment, but just as part of the conversation. So, if you are passionate about how you want to use a bunch of copies of the game for specific purpose, talk to the publisher about it. They might be on the same page. Um Again, I wouldn't recommend making it a deal breaker, but I think it is something to discuss with the publisher. Again, I'll come back around to say real quickly that I unless those are deal breakers, I wouldn't necessarily mention them in the initial pitch. I would focus on the merits of the game and what makes the game stand out, what are the hooks of the game when you pitch to the publisher. And then if they want to have another discussion about the game, if they want to see the prototype, that's when you might talk a little bit more about some of these things. So, Garrett's bringing up Grogu, which is the first topic in my subject subject line today, which I can talk about real quick. So, I saw Megan and I went to see The Mandalorian and Grogu, the new Star Wars movie, in the theater on Monday, and we had a blast. I really I really loved it. I I um I think I had lower expectations because I had seen that reviewers weren't super high on it, but uh but I loved it. I I I had a lot of fun watching the movie and that's what I want when I when I go to the movies. And I thought it looked great. I thought the practical of the mix of practical and CGI effects um yeah, Jon Favreau I think does a fantastic job of mixing the two. And there were some funny moments that were some great action scenes. The music I thought was fantastic. Uh
yeah, the music in particular I've been listening to the music as I'm as I'm working which I rarely do because I I really really like the music in the movie. Grogu was adorable as always. And um what was the last thing? Funny beautiful and uh and emotional at times too. Yeah. I thought it was great. I really enjoyed it. I would recommend seeing it seeing it in the theater for sure. And the last topic, UK Games Expo. Yes, I wanted to mention um that if you are going to the UK Games Expo which I believe starts tomorrow. Obviously, I am not there. I have some co-workers, Dave and Alex who are there. And if you are looking for Alex or Dave or if you want to see some of our games, we uh have some of our games at the Inside Up booth which is booth uh I believe it's hall four booth 302.
That's where you can go to see our games at the UK Games Expo. I'm going to take a short break to open my door because Walter wants to get in here. One sec. Walter, you want to come in? Come on. Come on. Okay, Walter wanted to say hi while we're talking about UK Games Expo. Yeah. Yeah, I know. Um anything else that wants Walter wants to share. Walter has been looking at the bunnies in the backyard. We have a little baby bunny who's in our backyard right now and uh we're making sure that Walter stays a safe distance from the bunny through just through the window. But Walter mostly he still has been asking to go outside a lot and he just walks around out there. He eats some grass. He gets a little sun and uh smells he smells a lot of stuff. He hasn't actually seemed interested in any of the animals at all just smelling where they were.
Cuz he's a good boy. He's also almost 17 years old so I think that stage of his life of hunting is is well over. But we're still keeping an eye on him and we have a little bell that we put around his neck to to warn animals that he might be coming. Steve says, "What games have you seen that you that were recently released or coming soon that excite you outside of your company's games?" Um Steve well one of them was this one that I mentioned the Lorcana Palace Heist. I was really curious about this because I love the heist theme and I was curious about a cooperative version of Lorcana. It also kind of pairs with the Magic the Gathering Turtle Team Up cooperative mode of magic that I played recently that was that I had a lot of fun with. On my table in shrink right now I have the new Earth expansion. I am excited to give that a try. I think it adds a lot of animal meeples to the table.
And at Gateway to the West recently I played a lot of games that are relatively new. Um Among them let me I'm going to click over and probably freeze but some of the ones that I played that were somewhat new Actually no most most of the games that I played that were brand new Okay some of the games that I played that were fairly new were Emberheart and Flip Tunes were two of the newer games that I really enjoy enjoyed at Gateway to the West. Um Yeah those were some of the newer games that I've had a lot of fun with. So let me throw as I continue to talk about and answer questions you you can ask me anything. I have a question for you today for you all. Speaking of Magic the Gathering because there's been a little bit of a controversy recently regarding a secret lair drop the magic layer that Magic the Gathering does. They have they they take a specific theme or archetype in the game and they typically commission a specific artist or a couple different artists to make custom art for that theme and they sell custom decks with that theme. Recently there was a goblin theme deck with a really unique art style from famous artist that they made and it sold out really quickly and then people were like immediately put it in on the second market at a really high markup. Um and uh it it's such kind of an interesting space of the gaming industry to be because I think ideally Magic the Gathering wants to make the right amount of
product for this. But Magic the Gathering is also in the business of of selling things that people are hoping they can sell at least parts of those things for later or that there is some added value to those things on the secondary market. Even if you don't sell your rare mythic rare foil card for $100. I think some Magic players like the idea of having opened that card in a pack or having or just that they own it in a pack. So there there is an element of like rarity and scarcity is core to the experience of Magic the Gathering. Like it it is just part of what it is. Um So there's that but there's also Magic the Gathering. I think they would they would rather make the right amount of cards of sets for for the secret lair so that everyone who really wants it can have it but then they want it to be scarce so they can fit this model of the game that they've that that is very popular for the last 30 years.
Um and and along with this they they yeah I don't know. This this dichotomy between um scarcity and figuring out the right demand of things to make. It isn't a puzzle that I necessarily have to figure out at Stonemaier Games because our model is we're happy to make more of anything. We can do that. We're not we're not selling scarcity. We might not make the right amount up front, but we can make more in the future. Um but it it just this element of it of of this secret lair drop and the controversy around it, which I understand that people wanted to buy this thing and they weren't able to, partially because people are buying it and selling it on the secondary market almost right away. It's fascinating to me and I'm curious about it. Not as not as a business person, not as someone running Stonemaier Games. I I am at least currently not interested in the in the business of scarcity.
But I am curious when a when a game is built upon that model. Um what you think about it if you follow this whole secret lair goblin drop thing. How how you wish Magic the Gathering would act um in the future to to better serve fans. Do you think it is serving fans is one of the questions I'm trying to figure out. Is this serving fans the best to their to the best of their ability? Red Sash Games says, "How many times would you say that you've played Vantage both playtesting and for fun?" Um I would estimate around 150 times. Definitely over 100. Probably less than 200. Yeah, I would say less than 200. Um yeah, that would be my best guess, I think.
Papa Patrick says, "Have your game taste changed over time? I used to prefer heavy Euro games to lighter strategy games. Now I feel like I appreciate a larger variety of games." My answer would actually be very very similar. Um although I was I don't think I was ever into heavy Euro games, but maybe medium weight Euro games, which I still love. Uh I think the way that my tastes have changed is that they have expanded. I've become much more of an omni gamer or types of games that I like, that I'm open to trying um and that I'm open to playing again. Shad says, "Just wanted to say that I love Vantage. After months of struggling to find a board game that appeals to me, Vantage has absolutely consumed me." Shad, thank you so much for saying that. I I I that that really means a lot to me. Um that that you've connected with Vantage and that you're having fun exploring it. I got a really nice comment this morning from um from Kelly who said something very similar and it it uh I can tell you and I I'm not saying this to garner any compliments or any praise for anyone. Please do not take it that way. But if you ever play a game that you love uh and you want to take the time to reach out to the designer uh publicly, privately, however you want to do it it really does mean a lot to us. Uh or to me. I I I I can't speak for every other designer, but I'm guessing that if you reached out to a designer to say, "Hey, I really connected with your game.
Maybe for this one a specific reason." Um it doesn't have to be a long email or a note or a comment. It can just be a little short thing. It really does go a long way. I would you know yeah, I'll I'll leave it at that. And this is not truly not for me. I just know that after hearing this from Shad and hearing that note from Kelly this morning it just means a lot um to know that you've spent so much time on something and it brought joy to someone. That That's why That's why we make stuff. That's why That's why I'm here. So um that really does go a long way.
Uh Nick says, "Do I have a shelf of shame or opportunity? If so, what's next on your list to get played?" I don't have a shelf of shame. I have a shelf of opportunity. That is definitely the way that I like to say it. Uh and next on it I think is the the Earth expansion. That with the the little animal meeples. That's next for me. Chad says, "What questions do you find beginner game designers do not ask?" Ooh, that's a good question. Chad what question do they not ask? It's hard for me to answer that if they're not asking the question. Um So, I'll give a roundabout answer to this. I'll try to keep it brief. The uh The The thing that I notice the most for both game designers and people who are looking to get into the game design business, whether it's crowdfunding or just making a game, is uh they are often And this is a very generalized statement, but I've noticed a pattern of people who um their first contact is often uh contacting me privately to ask for uh advice, just like general advice.
They They want They want either the number one piece of advice, they want general advice, or they want advice about their game. And uh it's almo- in 95, maybe 99% of these questions, these private questions, it's very apparent that they didn't just look on our website to see the resources that I have there about game design and crowdfunding and marketing and the game design business. And so, while it isn't exactly a question, it's um it's I would say effort. The effort Just putting in a little bit of effort to do a little bit of research to see the doors that that research opens up because I think the resources are out there. Um And rather than I While I appreciate someone coming to me, I think there are better ways to come to approach me, ideally in the public comments, so that you can add to that general conversation. Um So, and I've made the same mistake. I Years ago, I definitely reached out privately one-on-one to people and I said, "Hey, can Can you help me with this product?" That was my first contact with them. And I think uh that isn't the first question. That isn't the first request. The first step is to put in a little bit of effort and a little bit of work to do a little bit of research and to see how many resources are already out there for you to for you to learn from.
Yeah. Papa Patrick says, "I'm teaching a board game design class this coming school year. Do you have any advice about how to get inexpensive copies of games to to play in class? I'm looking on the Facebook Marketplace and thrift stores." Um I don't I I personally don't buy I second-hand games so I I don't have advice about that. If you're looking to get games from publishers then um I would look at their their donation policy their donation forms like Asmodee Games we have a donation form. It's a very specific type of donation that we're willing to do um but uh yeah we do have a form like that. Other publishers might have forms like that as well. Uh and yeah.
That's that's how I would I I would say how to go about it if you're looking to go to the publishers directly. Um Let's see. RJ Games guy says, "I learned from one of your favorite games or I learned one of your favorite games on Sunday Planet Unknown. Have you tried the expansions? If yes, what do you think of them?" I have tried one of the expansions but probably not the full extent of the expansion. I played the Supermoon expansion but the only element I really played of it is uh I tried a different planet that I hadn't tried in the past. I don't think I tried anything else beyond that. In general when I play expansions, I generally just want more stuff of the stuff that's working for the core game already. Aaron says, "If I recall the composer of the Grogu film is the composer of Oppenheimer and the NBC sitcom Community. He's such a good composer."
Yes, uh Ludwig I I is his name. Um he's awesome. Yeah, he's fantastic. I think he's still pretty young, too. So, hopefully we're getting music from him for many, many years to come. Everybody sign sign a hi to Walter here. I guess I'm a few minutes behind on comments. I'll try to to jump forward a little bit. Okay, Mud Song says, "I'm glad to see your YouTube issues got resolved." Yes, I'll mention this real briefly. If anyone popped onto YouTube last Thursday evening through, I think, Saturday afternoon, you may have seen no YouTube channel from Stellar Line Games. And that's because the uh the hacker got in again. Didn't fully get in, they only got into YouTube, and they posted a like they seem to always do, they posted some streaming video um that is completely unrelated to to our channel.
And this time, even though I had some people, including Jeff who's watching here, who notified me right away, I was able to remove this this entity, whatever they are. I don't know if it's a person or a program. Um, I removed them right away from YouTube. Um, but YouTube decided to take the whole channel down to investigate it, which I think was I appreciate what they're trying to do. I also think it was overreacting cuz it was completely clear what the problem was. Um, and but it did, of course, you know, it's it's any type of hacking, even a even a minor one like this where they didn't get into my whole Google account, but just that part of it is is pretty invasive and kind of shakes me a bit that they're still in there somehow. Um, so I've taken even I took, you know, a number of measures to prevent them from doing this, and now I'm tried to take some more measures to do that as well.
Uh, specifically involving the cache on my computer. Not not cache like in money, but uh c h c a c h e, that type of cache. So, working on that, trying to figure out how to how to make sure they can't get back in, and uh closing closing some doors that will make some things more inconvenient, but will hopefully keep them out of the YouTube account. Mark from Panda says, "Just want to thank you for the P20 sponsorship competition blog post. Hopefully it will have a big reach this year." Yeah, this was I thought an incredible opportunity that I posted about on the blog. A thing that Panda is doing where they are offering essentially prize money in the form of manufacturing credits to up to 20 different people um who who submit to the P20, who share their games with Panda through the P20 games that they want to self-publish presumably.
And uh you have a full year to do it, so you have a lot of time to do it. You own the game. This is not like Panda doesn't own games, they make games. So, you still have the rights to do whatever you want with the game. Um I think it's really an incredible opportunity, especially if you're making a game that doesn't cost a lot of money. Well, even if if you make a game that costs a lot of money, yeah, it's I think it's worth it because it's manufacturing credits. It's it's money that you can use to to make the game at a place that I believe is the best place to make games. So, yeah, pretty incredible. Mark, thanks for bringing that up. What was my blog post on Tuesday about? Or Monday? I posted that stuff on Monday. Yeah, I'll risk freezing again to see what I posted about. Oh, games that shine in Plainview. Yeah, I looked at the the Plainview data from Geekway to the West and tried to find some patterns and commonalities among that data in case you are a publisher considering Plainview as a as a target for your games. Which I I think is a a great opportunity to have your games be exposed to a number of people.
Next is if you own an older version of a game, will you buy a a new re-themed version? In the case of something like the Star Wars Queen's Gambit versus the Lord of the Rings King's Gambit. Is re-buying it worth it in your opinion? I think it depends on what they've done with the game. Um for example, I think restoration games and 25th Century Games are do a fantastic job of taking older games and really making them better. Sometimes in terms of gameplay, I think restoration games does that quite a bit. 25th Century Games tends to focus on the graphic design and the art, but also that I think that does a good job.
[clears throat]
But if I own an older version of a game, am I likely to do that? It's pretty rare that I do that.
[clears throat]
Excuse me. Yeah, they I think it's if I'm happy with the version of the game that I have and it's been on my shelf for a long time and I still get it to the table from time to time, it's pretty rare that I would uh go buy a a newer version of that game. Trying to think if that has if I've ever done that. I've probably done it, but I can't think of a specific example. Steve says, "Are there any out of print games that you wish your company could buy and put back into print?" Not right now, no. I I No, I don't think so. Um I think it takes a very specific game to do that and all often times I found that it's not really worth the it's not really worth the money to buy the rights to the game because you're still going to be spending so much money to uh refresh the game and and just even print the game.
Um Yeah, I I I think like getting the rights to the game is one thing. Uh like that's what happened with Libertalia. Uh Libertalia, the designer had the rights to the game. We signed the rights from the designer. There wasn't a a fee. It was just an agreement to pay royalties for all the games that we make, all the copies of the game that we make and sell for Libertalia Winds of Winds of Galecrest. Uh that is the arrangement that I'm looking for because I think we pay our designers really well and we make a lot a lot of game a lot of copies of the games and then end up selling paying them a lot of money over time. But paying a a publisher the rights to use a game is something that um that I'm I'm interested in doing. Yeah. Right, Halo X30 clarifies something maybe I misspoke, but yeah, I know that Secret Lair is not print to demand. Um, it is uh It So, I wasn't saying that's print to demand. That is a different thing. I was saying that I think Magic is In my opinion, I think they are trying to make the right amount of games for people, but uh print to demand or print on demand is is very different. That Magic is investing well in advance for a specific quantity that they think will sell.
Um, and they're making that amount, but that's a decision that they made months or even years ago for this product. But yes, they are selling scarcity. And that that is the the puzzle here, I think. And people I think not only are they selling scarcity, I think people are also buying scarcity when they when they buy a lot of Magic products. Andy says, "What leads you to dis- discontinue a game such as Charter Stone?" We haven't discontinued Charter Stone. In fact, we haven't discontinued any of our games. Um So, uh the There are games that we make less often. I'm going to take your comment down, Andy, cuz I don't want to mislead anyone into thinking that we do discontinue that we have discontinued Charter Stone or any game. That is not something that we do.
Uh we If there if there is demand for a game, we will make more of it. Um, and we continually gauge demand typically via our our back in stock form on our website or webstore. Uh and Charter Stone specifically definitely is I don't think it's even out of stock right now. Is it out of stock? Um, if it is out of stock, then we are then we are making more of it. Let's see. Is Charter It does look like Charter Stone, at least in the US, is out of stock on our webstore, but we are actively making more of it. Um, so Andy, I guess my question for you is, what made you think that we had discontinued Charter Stone just because it's showing out of stock on the web store or something else? And I would say in general, if you do see something out of stock on our web store or any web store, that doesn't mean that it's been discontinued. It just means they currently don't have inventory and likely they are making more so that they do have inventory then.
Yeah, this is so S1 Puma says there was a talk in the team Covenant channel, a great talk, where they were talking about trading card games and living card games and how more profitable trading card games are. Um, and maybe some of the predatory business practices that relate to that. And so yeah, this is actually one of the things that I was thinking about. I really love what Covenant is doing lately with these long form discussions that are available on their YouTube channel and also as a podcast. I've really been enjoying that from Covenant and has been some great food for thought. Tony says, "What do you think about random game effects that speed you to the end game?" His example, he played Deep Regrets last night and they randomly drew a card that immediately began reducing available cards at the beginning of a player's turn. One of the end game specifications is that when all cards are are gone, the game ends. We drew that card very early and couldn't help but feel disappointed that it impacted the entire game.
Perhaps if it was later, we wouldn't have felt the same. That's interesting. Um, that that a random occurrence would speed up a competitive game in particular so much. I wonder if maybe it was put in there because the designer thought the game was running a little long in general. They wanted another way to speed up the game. My I've only played Deep Regrets once, but it lasted over 3 hours, which did feel a little long for the game. Um, but I can see how that coming up completely randomly catching you off guard and having that happen at different times in the game, early in the game versus late in the game could have a big impact on it. I would say if something like that happens again, that just isn't vibing with your group, you could just ignore the card for the rest of the game or or put it lower down in the deck for the rest of the game.
So, here's Corey had a great question about pitching to publishers earlier and he's giving some context for the artist that he commissioned and how he He He has already paid for the art and he's hoping to see He's hoping to give the artist more exposure, I think. Which Corey, I think is is a wonderful sentiment to do for for any artist. Aaron says that they loathe, not love, but loathe the aftermarket aspect of trading card games. That makes me want to not play that game. Why should I spend so much energy and time to try to get a pack with art I love and want to get and then not get it. I definitely hear that. Um Yeah, and I hope it is very clear that I am not condoning by any means what happened with this recent Secret Lair drop from Magic. Uh I I just know as as a publisher who um who makes products and has to pick the amount of product that we're making well in advance of when people actually buy it, uh that it is a very difficult puzzle to solve. The advantage that I have is that I'm not selling to scarcity. I'm not selling to FOMO.
If there's demand for a product that we sold out of, um maybe faster than expected, we'll make more of it. We're happy to make more of it. Um yeah. Darius says, "Does scarcity add anything to the game or to the community? I don't think so, but they have their own community as long as the community is happy with the business decisions, good for them. Trading card games is a business model which I'm not a fan of." Yeah, it definitely is. It's a very different uh type of environment. And every time that I thought about making a game even with like and whether random random packs of cards or um or like little packs of cards like living card game, I just can't help wondering, why don't I just put all this in the game box for players to have? Like why am I making you buy why would I think to make you buy random packs or buy a bunch of little packs when I could just put all the packs of cards in one box as as the full experience?
Uh that happened like I really when I was designing the game Expeditions, I went into it from the approach of potentially making it a living card game. I filmed a video way back then. You could see it in my video about living card games cuz I was actively thinking about it. And the more as I designed it, I was like, why wouldn't I just put all this stuff in the box? Why would I separate it out into all these little card packs that you have to seek out and buy it individually? Uh it just didn't make sense to me. At the same time, I am someone who has played Magic the Gathering off and on for most of my life, and there is something special about opening a random pack of cards. Uh just like it's special to get a random hand of cards in Seven Wonders or drafting game. Um so I get that too. I get both sides of it.
Corey says, regarding the questions that beginning game designers don't ask, how much does this component cost to manufacture? I could kick myself for basing the whole game around 36 D6 dice. That is a fair question to ask. Um yeah, that that is fair. I think it's a good question to ask yourself. Like how how much um if I'm putting a component that I think will cost quite a bit to make, how much value is that adding to the game? And is there a more efficient or optimized way for me to put that component in the game?
Here's the name of that composer, Ludwig Goran- Goransson is the is the composer. He's done some great things lately. Hello X30 says, do you have any Do you have regrets on decisions you made while designing a game or production decisions on it and have had a chance to make it right on a second printing or sequel game? So, second printings in general, so reprints in general, we uh if we find typos or in clarity in the rule book, things like that, um we sometimes on specific cards if we make a mistake. There was one small mistake in Origin Story where we we had the wrong card type. Yeah, for for reprint we we definitely all the time we fix like tiny little things that you barely probably don't even notice, but we do fix them in reprints all the time. I do have a recent video about uh regrets. In fact, I have two videos about regrets, so you can see um the types of things that I regret about game design and product design decisions if you want to check out those videos.
And every now and then we do make a like an essential edition, but we make very We have a very specific guidelines about making essential additions of games. Like most recently is um Do we have it over here? Oh, yeah, Euphoria is essential right there. And we have Between Two Cities and Between Two Castles essential as well. And Viticulture essential. Um the the the commonality between all those games is that we have taken an expansion that we decide that we decided is can be seamlessly integrated into the into the game without adding complexity and is worth like teaching from the start. It's worth just being part of the game without significantly increasing the cost of the game if we can combine these two things. So, uh I think Euphoria, I don't think we actually increased the price at all that I can recall by adding the expansion. If we can combine those two together for a seamless experience without increasing the price, we're happy to do that. And typically we just we we don't change all that much. In Euphoria, I did revisit the design and I did in my opinion improve some elements of the design from the previous version to make it at least at the very least easier to teach cuz I found Euphoria to be somewhat difficult to teach in the previous version.
Here's that it's about does does scarcity in any type of game serve anyone better? Does that serve customers? And I always says I I think too much scarcity doesn't serve anyone. A little scarcity is marketing to get someone to buy something if they were on the fence. That's fair. It's fair. Nick says, "May I ask why you don't buy second-hand games? Is it because of the risk of damage or games in bad condition or is it because of the money for the game sales doesn't go to the designers publishers?" A fair question here, Nick. Um it there's no I would say there's nothing on principle guiding me to not buy to buy to not buy games second-hand. Um I have nothing absolutely nothing wrong with that at all. I think typically if I see a game that I really want it is either on crowdfunding or it is the the easiest way for me to buy it and know that I'm getting a real version real complete version of that game is for me to buy it unopened. Um from either directly from the publisher or from my local retailer that I like to support.
Um I would say that is what goes through my head typically when I when I buy a new game. If I think often buying second-hand adds extra time as more time to actually make sure I'm getting the right thing that I want and uh and and there is the all typically the doubt in my head that I'm getting the full either the the authentic or the real experience. And I also know as a publisher that when we see counterfeit versions of our game show up um they're always on with they're either always on secondary market marketplaces or they are on um cuz they're less regulated and or they are on places uh like places that seem too good to be true in terms of their prices like Temu. They're That's where we see the counterfeit show up. So, I think I'm hesitant in general about that.
Darren says, "Do you have any recommendations on playtesting a game with tons of variability? I'm designing a superhero game that has a ton of special powers in it, and I'm worried that I'll miss a game-breaking combo." Darren, I two recommendations here. Whenever I design a game that has a lot of variability, replayability, asymmetry, I typically try to playtest the game at first without without at least any starting asymmetry, because I want to make sure the core experience of the game is good and solid, and maybe even great without the asymmetry. I want the asymmetry to be a cherry on top of a a great game, a great thing foundation of a game. And then I add it later in blind playtesting as we're trying to balance and balance and analyze that data and get get all that data about the asymmetry and the variability. So, I think um getting uh quantity of blind playtesting with that asymmetry and variability, and also analyzing that data. I think a common refrain, I think when a game is a little unbalanced, when maybe a faction is perceived as unbalanced, is that they didn't playtest it enough.
I think that's actually rarely the case. I think it's more so that the publisher didn't analyze the data of the of the playtesting data that they had, cuz they probably did playtest it quite a bit. So, I think that's the key here, Darren. Combine strong foundation with a lot of playtesting, and then good data analysis of the uh of the data that came through from that playtesting, this blind playtest. Mudsong says, "I'm a beekeeper, not a game designer, but I can report that 95% of the questions I get, which I kindly answer, reveal a lack of effort by the questioner, process perhaps a symptom symptom of our social media age." And I think in some ways, like it it is nice that we can reach out to peep person to person to ask questions. I think that's great. But, um but I think it's also good to use to do a little research, right?
And it isn't that hard to research anymore because Google is right there to ask anything and and look up the sources on Google right away. Uh, yeah. Do you have a favorite woodland creatures themed game? Probably Well, let's say let's say slightly fantastical woodland creatures. Because if I went with non-fantastical, I'd say Forest Shuffle. Fantastical, probably Everdell. Um, and these are excluding still my other games from these from these selections. Justice is acquired Downforce. Is it renovation game or yeah, restoration game not making Downforce anymore? I love Downforce, but I I assume they still have the rights to it.
What's your favorite Star Wars movie or project? Mine would be Andor and Rogue One. Yeah, two that's a great combo right there. Um, I do love Andor and Rogue One. Um, I I posted on my personal blog jamestegmaier.com, I had posted my favorite list of my rankings of the Stegmaier projects of Star Wars projects. I would probably put Episode 5 up there in the top three. I would put Rogue One I think in the top three and I would put I really love Episode 7. I I it scratches all the issues for me when I first Star Wars experience. For shows, I'm currently watching very slowly watching the new Darth Maul show and really enjoying it. Really really good animation in the show. I'm enjoying that. But I think there are at least certain episodes of The Mandalorian show that I really love.
But I I I I've loved a lot of the Star Wars TV content. Um I just know there's there's one scene in The Mandalorian show that I've rewatched multiple times because I love it so much. It's an intense scene that ends in a touching moment between Grogu and the Mandalorian. Well, I love that touching moment and I love the intense intensity of the action scene that that precedes it that that I really love. So, that kind of stands out to me as a really awesome Star Wars moment.
Okay, Andy is clarifying that the out of stock leads me to think it was discontinued. Now, out of stock doesn't mean discontinued. Out of stock just means we don't have inventory in our warehouse right now. Bernice says, "Any thoughts on season 50 of Survivor now that it's over? Do you think it lived up to the hype and celebration?" Uh So, the way I think about a hype is was I excited about this season? Yes. And am I glad that I watched this season? Absolutely. Yeah, I I had a lot of fun watching it. Um I think I really enjoyed it in general. Pretty much talked earlier in the video about the Survivor 50 gathering that I hosted watch gathering that I hosted on Friday. We had a great time watching the finale. And the one thing I would say about it about the current state of Survivor is that uh people the contestants on Survivor have gotten really focused in my opinion of on trying to bring people to the finale that they think they can win against.
Which I think is great. I think that's great strategy. I don't know if it makes for the most entertaining show because often times I think the most entertaining contestants on a show are are also the best maybe best {slash} most deserving to win the show. And if we only get one of those in the finale instead of three as I think we've seen a lot in in recent seasons. That to me is just a little unfortunate as someone who wants to be entertained by Survivor. I want to see the best people in the top three. I don't want to see one of the best competitors take two weaker competitors to the finale. Um but I do think that's just part of the Survivor DNA, too. Like because it is eventually a decision made by a jury of your peers who are right there in front of you who have played the game with you.
And uh so I think navigating that element of it I think is core to the experience of Survivor over 50 seasons. So uh I think it just makes just makes me a little extra happy when we get to the finale and there are at least two people in the finale that I think played a fantastic game. I'd love to see that.
So I have a few actually both Aaron and Michael mentioned the Dragon Eclipse booster packs. How they were fun to open and you didn't know what was inside of them, but they were preset and so it gave you the feeling of opening a pack cuz you weren't literally opening a pack um without actually dealing with any of the randomness randomness that we see from trading card games.
Uh let's see. Your inner child saw Grogu last night and my fun my son thought he was baby Yoda so I was confused about the timeline. Can you use this to remember that even fans of Star Wars can forget critical details? Yeah, I I I don't I don't know if I can I can use this, but uh but it is it is, you know, easy to forget critical detail details especially since it's been a little while since the last since the last Mandalorian show and 7 years since the last Star Wars movie. Chad says that his four-year-old son is now getting the games where he can make decisions. Let me ask how many decisions per turn is the threshold of fun and analysis paralysis? A tough balance between the two. Um I don't know exactly I think it depends on the game, but it is something that I think about when I think about the weight of a game. Like if I'm looking to publish a lighter game, I don't want players to have to remember much at all. I want them to have very simple streamlined decisions, maybe even simultaneous decisions. Whereas in a more complex game, I can give players a lot more decisions to or not more Yeah, a heavier longer game.
If that's the design intent, I I might be happy giving them a lot more decisions. Simon says they're in a conundrum on game design. I've developed a Euro card engine builder and at present the payoff is all in dice rolls. I'm torn about the structure that careful gameplay lands in the hands of probably probability. What thoughts do you have? So, Simon, I would look at games that have uh here's I always forget the term if it if it's either input randomness or output randomness. I think it's input randomness. Games that use input randomness with the dice, where you're rolling the dice up front and making decisions based on the dice that you have rolled and or dice that you're drafting that are also pre-rolled, rather than um investing into decision and then rolling to see what the outcome is. So, I think you there are lots of Euro game examples including Euphoria, including um uh Creature Caravan.
Uh Uh What's the What's the There are lots of dice drafting games out there. Um I'm forgetting the I'm not telling my head, but you can look for videos on my channel about that. Where you roll the dice up front and make decisions either drafting them or if they're your own dice, what you decide to do with those dice. Uh that Oh, Castles of Burgundy, classic example there. I think that is maybe the way to go so that uh you can just have that careful gameplay based on that input randomness. Matt says, "What was the most notable and unorthodox game you discovered in the in the last few months?" Most notable and unorthodox. Let me look at my favorite games so far of the year.
You know, I would actually probably say Cozy Castle. Like that's one that really caught me off guard. Where at first I was like, I I don't I don't know if like I definitely wasn't looking for another campaign game. It looked very light. But I've had a delightful time playing Cozy Castle. Matt says, "Also was interested from your perspective on what was the most notable influence AI has had on Stonemaier Games more more related to game production management or in any other part of your work?" I continue to not be interested at all in generative AI and using AI as a resource, as a tool. I don't use it. I don't care about it. I have not seen it impact what we do at Stonemaier Games at all. We don't use it at Stonemaier Games, quite frankly. I think the only way that it has impacted me at all is that when I search on Google now, I get an AI result before I get the normal search results. And I do sometimes look at those AI results. I look at both.
Um but that is the only way that it's impacted me as a person or as a professional. I truly truly am not interested in using AI at all. Uh and I'm actually I'm glad you asked about that cuz I do plan on I wrote I wrote this in an article in 2024 and I'm planning on revisiting it soon to kind of say see like has it changed over the last few years? And it really hasn't. Like I'm just truly not interested in it. Um yeah. Uh Oh, I did have one other question for you. Do we have time? No, we don't have time. I'll have to wait till next week to ask this other question. Let's see. I'll I'll just focus on your questions for the last few minutes here. Tishul says, "Did the Between Two Cities Essential Edition need to be in a bigger box than the original considering that the original expansion was designed to fit with within the original base box. Does this mean there are further expansions?" No, we don't have any expansions planned for it. Um I think part of it was consistency. I kind of wanted a box size that fit better with our other box sizes. This was before I I Well, probably now I don't Well, actually no, I will say this. In the original Between Two Cities box, I think it was too small. All the tiles did fit.
We were asking players to shuffle all the tiles in the box, and I think the box was a little bit too small for that. And oftentimes on my shelf, when I'd put it vertically on my shelf, the box lid would become separated because of all those tiles kind of falling down and pushing against the box. I would say that was the main reason that we went with a bigger box. You have just have more room to swish around those files the those tiles, and so that on the shelf it doesn't come up part of the seams. Um yeah. Aaron notes their favorite Star Wars projects: A New Hope, The Last Jedi, and Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic. A video game in there, too.
Montsong says Survivor season 50 of Survivor was excellent, one of the best. Though the episode with the country artist seemed pointless. So, I would say I for me I think the amount of time they spent on the country artist for he was named here, I I like some of the songs. Um I I thought it was the amount of time they spent on him that was I don't I don't want to say pointless, but it just went a little went on a little long. But I don't mind seeing other people excited about Survivor. And this guy was really excited about Survivor, so I thought that was really cool. And just to think about it a little bit more, like when when he does a guest spot on Survivor, that is a big time commitment. He's flying out to Fiji. He's probably spending a couple days there and then flying back. He went spear fishing for it. So, I I kind of appreciate the amount of time that he spent to do that. And I kind of understand why they spent a little bit more time on him.
Um yeah, we've actually yeah, we've started What is it kind of amazing to me about one of the one of the many bad things about AI is that people now assume that something is AI rather than assume that it isn't AI. And so we've started to put on our boxes uh, that This is what do we put? Like human made Yeah, here we go. Human made no generative AI. We have that on the box of the the reprint of the Wingspan European expansion. Um, yeah, cuz we want to reinforce that. We want to let people know that that uh, our stuff is is made by people. Creative people. Jason's dropping by right at the end. Just wanted to stop by and say, "Thanks for the little care package that you sent for Tremendicon. Some of our games will definitely be well represented this weekend." Yeah, this is for the play and win section. I I send out a lot of games month by month for play and wins. And that was the Jason, if you want to check it out, my article on Monday was about the types of games that publishers might want to consider sending to play and wins because uh, that maybe they go over better than other types of games um, at play and win sections. But in general, I think play and wins are a great opportunity for conventions, convention attendees, and for publishers.
Um, it's a kind of a win-win-win situation. Let me see real quick if I didn't talk about anything. Yes, actually of course I I missed some topics here. One big important thing is that if you have been waiting for the Folded Space Folded Space custom insert for Tapestry come back in stock on our webstore, it is now back in stock on our webstore. Uh, so please check that out. The Folded Space custom Tapestry insert that fits all Tapestry stuff, the core game and all three expansions inside the original box for Tapestry. That's back in stock on our webstore. I also wanted to give a shout out to Paul Solomon. He is the designer of Stamp Swap, which is right in there. Today is Paul's birthday. Happy birthday, Paul. Hope you're having a great day. And I think that is it. I was going to talk about dinner parties this weekend cuz we had a lot of a lot of dinner parties including the Survivor party, but I kind of touched upon that.
Um Chip on with a chip comment here. Chip says the Google AI has its moment moments. It told me that you can't fit all expansions into the nesting box. It pulled a faulty answer from Reddit without seeing that it was downvoted and corrected down in the thread. That is That's the risk, Chip. That's why That's why I think it's worth looking down scrolling down and looking at more source material for that type of thing to get the real answer, not just the one potential answer that the AI pulled from from Reddit of all places. So, yeah. On that note, on an anti-AI note, let's end today's live cast. I hope you have a great week, that you're having a great day, and that you give yourself some sort of treat today, whether it's a game, um chocolate, food, a drink, whatever it may be. Uh yeah, we're still marathoning if that's the case, if you're going to play a still marathoning today.
Take care. I'll see you next Wednesday for I don't think it'll be a newsletter. I think it'll just be a normal Wednesday chat next week. We'll see. I'll see you. Bye.