My Third Year Reviewing Board Games - Going Over My 2022 Reviews
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Radical from Board Gameco. And we are continuing our series of review lookbacks. Not really review lookbacks. That's kind of like another series. I have more aggregating my reviews for the entire years. To that end, I've already done one for 2020. I've done one for 2021. Now, we are doing 2022, which means we still have 2023, 2024, and then a summary video, and then 2025 eventually, but uh that's not done yet. In any case, just a quick recap. We had an average review score of 3.69 69 in 2020, 3.61 in 2021, and we are back up to a 3.69 in 2022, but the next two years it goes lower. 2023 and 2024 are going to be lower, but we'll talk about those in future videos. Uh, we went from 72 reviews in 2020 to 209 reviews in 2021 to 262 reviews in 2022. And then 2023 will be higher. Again, I'm not I shouldn't spoil. Let's just focus on where we are now, 2022. So 262 reviews with an average score of 3.69. The specific breakdown on that is we had one two eight 2.5s, 40 three out of fives, 101 3.5 out of fives, 81 four out of fives, 14 five 4.5 out of fives, and 17 five out of fives. That is the total count making a 3.5 with 101 of the reviews being a 3.5. that is the uh highest the highest individual score given out in 2022. So that's the 3.5 is
the most common rating given. The two by the way was Kingdoms for Lauren which is actually I think liked by others but I felt that you had to break your teeth on the rules to get to a game that was a whole lot of messiness. That was my own two cents on it. Uh there were things I liked about it but overall I really really did not love Kingdoms for Lauren but I respect that it's a game that will work for others. As far as my 4.5s, and in general, I only really tell you the extremes in these videos because I don't really care about all the middles, but I tell you the lower scores as well as the higher scores. My 4.5s, we have a bunch. We had Aries Expedition, we had Burn Cycle, Dune Imperium, Rise of I, that's specifically the expansion. We had Gollum, Hands of Tatonica, Lacrosa, Roleplay Adventures, uh, Root Marauder, Slay the Spire, The Loop, The Reckoner, Steel Slayer, Twilight Inscription, and Viticulture. Those are going to be my 4.5s. Specifically, my 14 4.5s out of fives. Most of those are still four 4.5s out of fives. I think a few of them dropped. Hans Tatonica went down to a four. I don't know if any others dropped off hand. The loop may have gone up to a five. Actually, the loop may have even increased uh as time has gone on. I've been a bit more cautious about my five out of fives and sometimes they actually increase more. Although, we'll see this even more in future years. I I'm back to talking about future years. Let's talk about 2022. So, those are my 4.5s out of fives. For my five out of fives, five out of fives, we had again 17 of these.
Although a whole bunch of them are not necessarily counted. I'll explain that in a second. But specifically, we had Acropolis, Blood Rage, Brass Birmingham, and Brass Lancer. That counts for two. Cthulu death may die and Cthulhu may die, Fear of the Unknown. I'll explain that soon as well. We had Encyclopedia, KT Arnack, Expedition Leaders. Uh we had Oswan, Paris, Lasar, Tac, Castle, Burgundy, The Crew, Unconscious Mind, Unsettled, Zombicide, Undead or Alive. Those are the 17 five out of fives. I said I'll explain a little bit about Cthulhu May Die because I actually covered Cath May Die multiple times, but this is the first time I did a dedicated review with the introduction of Fear of the Unknown. I took the time to do a dedicated review of Cthulhu Death May Die as well. So, it's the first time it got like a full and dedicated review, which means the rating showed up in 2022. Speaking of which, actually, if we go over those, Acropolis has dropped down to a four out of five. I've covered this that one. That one definitely shifted downwards. I liked it a lot, but the variability just wasn't there. I touched upon that in my init my initial review, but it took time for that to slowly drop to a 4.5 and then a four.
Blood Rage is still a five out of five, but again, well, in fact, from from this list, a whole bunch of them were pre202 ratings that I happen to review in 2022. Specifically, Blood Rage, uh, one of the brasses, Brass Birmingham, was Brass Lancashire. Which one's which? I always forget which one's which. Which one do I have on my shelf? I have brass brass brass brass brass brass Birmingham. So Lancashire. So Brass Lancasher was from before. So Blood Ridge was from way back when. Brass Lancer was from way back when. Cthulhai was from way back when. Uh any others? We have Castle Burgundy was from way back when. So those four I think from the rest of them are previous five to fives that happen to get a review in 2022. And there's also some expansions. We had I said uh Arnack Arnack expedition leaders Zombat undead or alive is like the same but different. So those are two as well that are expansions. cuz I don't know if there are anything else that were oh Kemet.
Kemet was also Kemet was a previous five out of five as well. So again like five of these were from before two of them were expansions which leaves 10 new five out of fives. 10 that were like really new to me and those specifically would be Acropolis although brasses also. So really nine nine of them. Nine of them are newish so to speak. Uh Acropolis, Encyclopedia uh Oath Sworn Paris attack was an old one too. Sen County that attack was an old one just happened to get a review. Uh, The Crew, Unconscious Mind, Unsettled. Yeah, those seven, I guess, are the newest five out of fives. The other 10 are all peripherals, so to speak. They still count, which is why I include them here. But in that in that sense of like what's being highlighted as new and exciting, like for example, right now, influence in 2025, the only five out of five I've given in 2025 went to Evol Silverst, which is Evidel that I already know and love. So like I haven't given any new five out of fives, but I did give out a five out of five, if that makes sense. Anyways, that's basically what we have as far as the breakdown of 2022. No specific major changes over there. Some of the previous videos I've talked about how reviews changed over time. The average score didn't shift significantly. I think it went from a 3.69 of the new score to a 3.65 on average of current score. But again, not a major shift. They they don't really tend some go up, some go down. There's usually not major adjustments as far as where something was versus where I currently feel. And that is your 2022 recap. We'll be back with more in the series, specifically with 2023 coming soon enough. Until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. I hope you
found this informative, enlightening, something in some way. And as always, I hope you have a good