Episode 99 - My Best & Worst Mechanics
Transcript
you're listening to the broken me show a podcast that speaks passionately about board games for the benefit of those who play them my name's Luke Hector best known for the broken meeple YouTube channel and I'm an everyday gamer just like you and I'll be talking about reviews top 10 and just about anything that connects me to board games as long as I have a tea or coffee in hand that is so grab a cup relax and enjoy and remember it's only a game howdy hey everybody Welcome to podcast 99 we're on the penultimate episode to the top one top 100 no the number 100 podcast that is still going to be a thing so two weeks time I have basically cated a bunch of questions from uh patreons uh no doubt um if you've got any questions by all means fire them into this comment section I suppose I can answer some of those as well and I'll do my best to answer as many as I can on an offline Q&A basically so one giant questions and answers podcast to commemorate the fact that this show has been going on for 100 episodes even though technically the Channel's been going on for a lot longer and the actual YouTube channel has got like a thousand plus videos on it it's like yeah but we're talking like this particular podcast has gone on in this format for 100 episodes so I thought well I got to do something but I didn't want to go like bunkers but you know there's a bunch of questions I've got some of them look pretty interesting and it gives me a little bit of time to I mean I don't
want to like sit down and prepare answers for every single one because it would just take me forever to do that kind of research but it's it's more that I you know I've had a glimpse over the question I thought okay these are the kind of things I should be like sort of starting to think about you know so they're not completely you know on the fly like brand new when I see them but yeah that should be pretty sweet otherwise it's been a bit of a stressful couple of weeks I mean as I said work's been definitely high on the workload you know there's various bits at work that are kind of grating me little and you know things will improve they are getting better and better as time goes on as stuff gets done and completed it's just a case that I need to get to ideally the end of September you know once I get past September not only does uh things like Essen and gridon and handy con and all these other conventions start res servicing but then also my holiday in December two weeks in the Arctic Circle I'm looking forward to but it just means that also my workload will be a bit less yes I've got to constrain it down a bit because I need to get my work done for early December which is shutting off a couple of weeks but I'm confident a lot of that work is going to be done by the end of September and then all I've got to do is just sort of casually move through the rest so as long as other things at work don't screw me over I'm you know things are on the menend but there has been a bit of stress with that you know there's obviously sorting out bits um at home I've got my parents visiting literally this week end I'm recording this on Saturday morning they arrive in an hour and a half so I'm literally recording this podast podcast to get it done
because tomorrow when they leave I'll only have enough time to edit the podcast I won't have time to record one uh but you know so I got obviously prepped some of the house for that uh I've you know just generally had quite a lot on next week's going to be a lot less active like after Tuesday I don't think I've actually got anything planned for a while and then we've got bank holiday weekend which I've got no plans for so it's like you know it should be a nice relatively chilled few days minus work you know but that should be pretty good and otherwise uh you know the blog stuff has obviously been a little bit on the uh stressful side as well I've put out quite a lot of heavy content lately so I mean since the last one we had a a full review for wild Gardens we had a full review for Daybreak one for arcs more than that in a minute and check game editions best and worst you know and these videos have done pretty well some better than others but you you know those were quite intensive reviews to put out maybe not so much wild Gardens but Daybreak are and that check game editions one they took a long time to prep they took a long time to edit and they were big monster reviews but also the stress does come with some of those reviews because Daybreak and arcs are are kind of you know not they're not like well ARX in particular is very popular among mon Anish group you know and you know it's definitely getting a lot of Praise from people which is great you know by all means and daybreak's had a decent amount of praise and won the kener Spiel so I went into the these two and came out with a more critical
opinion of both you know I don't think any of them are particularly well I know day breaks almost close to bad but ARX I thought was average you know I didn't think it was bad I didn't think it was great either I certainly didn't think that either of the two deserved the hype they got the problem is when you go after a game and give a critical opinion of it oh boy do you get backlash from it particularly with arcs arcs got me a lot of anxiety stress through dealing with some of the backlash and that's not to say that oh everybody you know suddenly disagree with it and that's a problem no by all means I mean you know stick your comments in there and say yeah I don't agree with these points but you know cool video thanks for doing it I just reckon that I think this is better like this I think this is better like this you know when you're talking about the characteristics of the game but I got quite a few posts that went more on the personal attack side and certainly more of the insulting my game group side you know like you know your game group's just dumb or too slow or whatever and I I'm sorry but those are my friends you're talking about or people that maybe I only see at game clubs that I consider to be good people if you start attacking them you have no business here all right okay so you know I will I am very much one of these people that if you go after my family or friends there will be hell to pay you know I will not stand for that kind of thing but you know by all means yeah I disagree with the points race that's fine I ain't got a problem with that but yeah there was quite a few personal stuff going going around and uh the borain geek Fred has a similar deal but the problem is you know
YouTube actually filters out a few comments when they start getting hateful or swearing or you know they they pick up the the YouTube is a little bit overly sensitive though it picks up like a fair few stuff in held for review and even if it doesn't have a swear word in it sometimes it seems to bit I don't know what AI algorithm they use but it's a little paranoid I think but it does pick stuff up and you know it's you know when you look over them it's kind of like there's nothing wrong with that one they just disagree with the points that's fine stick it in there but then you get ones where it's like you know they're insulting my credibility and insulting my friends and that and it's just like no okay so there is definitely I do of that but yeah I mean the vast majority of people agreed with the ARX review I mean you know it is one of my lower percentages in terms of like and dislike ratio but it's still 88.9 it's not like it's a terrible thing it's just whereas all my other videos are typically 100 98 95 96 98 you know last one I had with 8 was uh a podcast episode where I mentioned about Euro Gamers don't screw other players no idea why that one got a lower ratio to be honest but you know all the rest on this page are 90s hundreds 90s 90s hundreds hundreds 90s you they're already good so for this one to have it but then this one is like 500 likes and 62 dislikes so there's quite a few fans of the game who don't like the fact that somebody is talking critical about their game and it's like fair enough you know you're not going to please everybody I still maintain the 5 out of 10 average rating I gave it I still maintain the points I raised you know people harped on me
because I forgot about Prelude actions which to be fair hand on you know hand up I did forget that you know there was a lot of stuff in there I was talking about the game I forgot to talk about Prelude actions Prelude actions are an important factor of the game you know you can spend resources in order to you know do various actions per your player board and sometimes you might lock yourself out of those but you know they are cool and they are a part of the game but if you took them out it doesn't suddenly make the game far worse for me and then having them in doesn't suddenly make the game far better for me so yeah fair enough I forgot that bit sorry but uh it's not like it would have fundamentally changed the you know it doesn't change my rating of the game put it that way it's not like oh yeah if I talked a little bit about Prelude actions I'd suddenly give it a six out of 10 it's like no I'm giving it a five out of 10 and to be fair five out of 10 remember this is my scale five out of 10 is average it's a game that I would still play if you put it on the table and say you know what you know we fancy playing this this week you want to jump in as the fourth player I'll play arcs it's not like I refuse to play the game again when a five out of 10 but everybody is so brainwashed into this idea from other you know from watching a lot of other critics where the scale literally starts at 7 and a half and goes up to 10 and anything below seven and a half is considered complete garbage that you should never touch with a barge pole that's not the case with me that's not how I do reveal use so you know certainly that plus the Home Stuff Plus that plus life in general there has
been quite a few uh you know heavy chest you know to deal with and and but when they say heavy chest this is kind of how the anxiety stuff manifests with me it's basically I it's it doesn't affect my respiratory system too much but what it does is that it makes my chest extremely like heavy so it you know you feel like somebody's constricting it it's bit like somebody's grabbing a fist around like the center of your rib cage and sort of just giving it a gentle like squeeze not crushing you know not like oh I can't move or anything like that but you notice it it it aches a bit and it it's like uh it's not a particularly Pleasant feeling and so I have to do like breathing exercises to try and get it like I mean if I know something bad's going to happen at work I could be having that feeling on the car journey and I have to put on relaxation music and do some breathing stuff in the car you know there there's stuff I have to do and I know I need to manage my stress a little bit more because of the fact that I do this as a hobby and have a day job and all this stuff live alone you know a lot of stuff that basically adds to that factor the only thing I don't have doesn't that adds to that does that normally adds to stress is kids you know so I'm probably saved from that bit but I tend to make up for that with other things so it you know I need to regulate that a bit more but you know I think it's just that this is a bad couple of months you know the summer is typically not a good period for me because you know there's a lot of work to do there's a lot of like major reviews there's a few major major like big releases that obviously you have to try and get through uh it's hot it's humid I don't like the weather I have to keep cooling
the house down so I feel like all the time and that's never a good feeling so there there's just that I don't like summer frankly I think summer is just where things in my life generally go bad you know and there's not much to look forward to in the summer because I don't really go to conventions in the summer because it's too hot and I go to plenty of other conventions during the year and I don't like going on holiday in the summer because everywhere is EXP expensive there's kids everywhere and it's too hot anyway unless I got North you know so it doesn't really work out for me so my favorite times of the year is basically from kind of late September early October through all the way till about late April uh possibly miday although May it's starting to get a bit hotter there's the games Expo then but that's about it you know so we're talking yeah from from October to April those seven months is my favorite time of the year where things are just great loads of stuff going on temperatures great you know and you know birthdays and you know holidays and stuff like that the summer is just like June to August with a bit of September and may thrown in is just not my period of the year um so yeah I mean it's been a bit of a a tough week but by all means you know thanks for watching the vids thanks for the support whether you agree or disagree with the points I rais in the video is fine I totally I totally welcome you know civil debates I just don't welcome unil debates you know that's basically the deal but yeah there's more stuff on the way and one thing I do want to do from a format perspective is change well not change I
want to basically do some of those quick Speedy reviews again and I don't mean that oh that that weird segment I tried to do where it was like you know the different intro and then I tried to do quick reviews and it didn't work no no no not that that that and I'm still doing Normal reviews all I'm talking about is for tiny games where a full video doesn't work because I've tried to doing them in the podcast but podcast reviews don't work because the problem you've got is if I do a podcast review let's say yeah which one have I done recently where I did an actual review here we go yeah podcast 98 in fact I did um a review of free of aind in here right and I'm probably going to do another little mini review for free of a Kind actually the problem is if I want to now share this on the internet I have to tell people timestamp between A and B is the review for free of a kind people don't want to put in the effort to mess around with time stamps and stuff and they don't want a shared episode on all a bunch of stuff that they're not interested in if they've got to just go to like a 4minute segment to talk about a game it also is a problem on board game gek because if I put this video on board game gek which I think I did actually for this one you know again I have to put a time stamp saying go between these two timestamps this is when I talk about three of a kind but the thumbnail doesn't work because it's got all this other stuff on there that isn't relevant and it just makes it a bit of a nightmare to share I mean even Publishers aren't going to share something something like this they want a pro full dedicated video so it's not working on that respect so what I want to do is something similar to kind of what the dice tower does at the moment you know D vower does like three and a
half minute four minute reviews on very light games and pretty much all he does is gives a tiny background rules overview quick summary and verdict done and that's essentially what I'm going to do so I've got three of a kind I've got a game called clink by Rebel studio and I've also got draft and right records by uh inside up games these games do not warrant a full 25 plus Minute review and my reviews are getting long but then there's a lot of detail I mean you know what did my what was my arcs review like I mean that was arcs was a 40 minute review near 39 minutes 15 seconds that is the longest review I think I have ever done even Daybreak was 30 minutes while Gardens was 30 minutes the fact of the matter is is that I go into so much detail into games because obviously I want people to find them useful that it takes a while to do them I can't spend 30 minutes talking about drafting right records with and it's not worth the the effort to put in like all the movie clips all the music all the all the like cutscenes the editing the transitions all of that for a game that's you know something like free of a Kind which is literally a tiny little party game that you know people might not even notice so you know I've got to obviously balance the time to put in the video with the game itself speed reviews are literally just going to be normal intro no new fancy intro no nothing like that I'm not going to over complicate it with stuff like that cuz that always get takes up time I'm literally just going to put in the normal intro overview summary and verdict done no movie clips
no extra little jokes thrown in you know basic music for the thing and that's it you know no fancy stuff the stuff that takes a million years to do any editing and hopefully won't take me that long to record either and these will just be normal they'll just be called speed reviews or whatever or quick reviews whatever or Mini review I'll just slotting the name whatever and that's it so I don't have to spend ages trying to design a whole new format I don't have to spend ages trying to edit a ton of stuff in these but it just enables me to do one video one game one that I can share on the internet and social media and it doesn't take up a ton of my time and it keeps producing content for the show so you know those ones I think even if they only get like 500 to a th000 views tops for those videos the effort that's gone into them will kind of justify it because obviously if I spend all the time that it takes me like hours and hours to edit a 30 minute review for a game that only gets 500 views it wasn't worth doing all that effort but then you know as much as ARX has stressed me out completely doing that one it is nearly at 10,000 views I mean my reviews barely get above 5,000 let alone anywhere near 10 so uh certainly you know as much as it has caused me a bit of stress it definitely kind of is worth it from a views perspective so it's uh you know definitely one of those things I have to deal with but yeah that's basically the case some Speedy reviews will come and that's it anyway 16 minutes in let's get on with the main event now that I can Swig my
drink lovely um I suppose side F uh side actually quickly side F I do want to mention uh Essen uh when I go to Essen this year I haven't yet decided if I'm going to help out a booth although given that you do get an exhibitor badge I might actually want to do that so I am going to see if I don't know if Flat River group want me back um there's a couple of Publishers I'd like to talk to maybe help them out so we'll see but you know one thing I am doing is a meet and greet event so there is a meet and greet thing that goes on at Essen and I'm going to try and bring up the screen for it uh while um while I talk but basically the idea is is that this allows you to meet and greet your like content creators that you want to talk to now a lot of this is taken up with um like German and European uh yeah ger German and European creators but I do want to also stress that there are some you know British and American uh ones that do that so was it meet and play here we go I have found it so meet and play uh and Paul grogan's done this a couple of times in in the past with uh gaming rules but I've never really had the time nor remembered to do it this year I am going to do it so basically I think it's downstairs in yeah Saturday October the 5th from 2:00 p.m. to 6:00 p.m. in what they call S Europa that's one of the rooms at the bottom of the building I think underneath Hall one
like the entrance or the hall one I think that underneath that Lobby if I remember right and basically it's you know it's just basically going to be right okay you can now meet your creators well I'm you book in slots you could be there for the whole day I've only booked in one hour a they to stay longer or stay longer but you know I have booked in an hour and I wonder if they put my thing up yet no they haven't put my logo up yet but they have acknowledged my application but basically at 3:00 on Saturday in that room s Europa I will be there so will Paul Gren from gaming rules you can chat to him there and there's a bunch of other creators here that are worth chatting to so you know I will be there at 3:00 whether I stay any longer than 4:00 remains to be seen it depends on whether they allow us to be in there much longer in terms of space or what to do but Saturday is one of those days where it's nonon impossible to be able to uh you know play games because it's so busy it's a nightmare to get into any demos so Saturday is almost a bit of a write off for essn I'd rather teach games at Saturdays or I'd rather do stuff like this so if I can stay there longer than an hour I will but at least definitely between 3 to 4:00 I'll be there meet and play you want to come and meet me like I mean if you bump into me during the show but I don't mean shake my hand and say hi but if you want to properly sit down and chat with me maybe play a filler game I might bring something like vegetable stock you know like some five six minute fillers or something along but yeah if you want to sit down and chat to me in a you know
quieter location you know ask proper questions where I'm not rushed to move somewhere else or anything like that then by all means come along to this event you know and I'd love to see you there I I will keep reminding people of this on future podcasts and stuff leading up to Essen and as I get more details right okay so there's no reviews on this episode no news I just want to get straight into the main event which is uh you know another topic that the patreons have suggested for me I wonder if I've still got the here we go math yeah Matthew Bailey thank you for this one this one was too long to do for the hund episode I figured this would actually be a podcast episode in itself and what I'm going to do is talk about some mechanisms that I like and dislike so and I'm going to give games as examples and kind of just break down what it is about these mechanisms that I like and what I don't like and it's not to say that any game with this mechanism I immediately buy or immediately hate there are certainly exceptions to the rule but these mechanisms are ones where if I know they're in a game I'm that much more interested yeah or sometimes this mechanism when slotted into a game could potentially make it better so we're going to start with uh games that are you know good uh sorry mechanisms that are good let's and this is in no particular order so it's not like this is my favorite mechanism or anything like that I can't really rank these but let's start with seven wonders so we're going to talk about Drafting and I'm more concerned about closed drafting open drafting is fine with seven wonders
du and stuff like that but I like a game that introduces the drafting of cards just simple here's a hand of cards pick one that you like and if you you know once you've done that you'll then get a new hand of cards and you'll try to you know you know make the best out of that hand and this sort of stuff I just really like you know I I like this agonizing choice that you've got where the the things that you have like the sorry the uh the the choices that you've got are limited by what hand you've grasped and then you get a new set like oh new stuff to look at but I've still only got to pick one of these and you have that agonizing choice of but I really want this but I really want that too which one do I pick and then if the game is designed well you have an element of hatred crafting which is looking to the neighbor to your left or right whichever way you're passing and going hm you want this I probably should deny you this but is it worth me taking the card got to weigh that option up okay I don't like anything in this hand I'm going to use one of them as a build my underneath my Wonder for example in some wonders well if I'm going to put one of these under my wonder I should probably pick one that you're going to like well you want science and I know you can build this science card for free because of the one you bought before so I'm going to put this one one underneath and I'm going to deny you that card you can't build this Palace very easily CU you don't have all the special resources haha in your face so you know that sort of thing works well in Seven Wonders and a really good drafting game has an element of hate drafting bad drafting games sometimes you have that choice but
then it's like well you could deny someone that card but honestly it would just completely screw you over in the process of why would you bother you know those are a little bit lacking the other thing I like with this is this idea that the hand can come back round so when you play this with less players I like it more with less players because you have this situation where you look at this hand of cards and you're thinking oh okay I like this but I also like this well it could come back round to me but will I get it back again you know I look at this Vineyard card here and it's like well you know there's a lot of red cards to my neighbors I don't have many but my neighbors do this could get me a decent amount of uh you know a decent amount of money well in that case I need to think well what's the likelihood that one of these people are going to pick it well they're not likely to cuz they I don't know he's got a lot of money will he really want more money you might pick it that's the risk I don't think you will so I'm going to pick this card that I really need now this one's going to go around and hopefully yay it's comeing back and now I can play it I like that decision as well it's I mean you could almost call it pseudo Pusher luck although as we'll get into later it's not quite Pusher luck but it's it's not really pushing my luck it's making an educated decision based on what I believe the other players are planning and making my assessment on that so I do really like closes drafting in games uh Sushi go Seven Wonders uh I mean even the draft and right records I've got there I mean it's mostly just a roll and right but it does have a drafting system in it which
does improve things a bit but then also going back to my already Point hate drafting does not exist in the game so there is an up and down in that respect but yeah I like um a terraforming Mars another example you know if you play terraforming Mars just by uh you know picking the cards randomly off the deck then you're playing basically a three-hour luck Fest but if you do the drafting it does mitigate it up to a point I mean it certainly doesn't uh you know completely alleviate the fact that there definitely is an element of luck of the draw because of how tight some of the stuff is but it is quite cool to have that drafting element in the game and certainly I would only pay Terra Mars If you are going to draft the cards they do it does add a bit of length to the game that is the problem that is the downer of drafting but for the most part I quite like drafting used in you know smaller games now you know sometimes it's shoehorned into the setup for games like oh right you've got some uh starting setup cards you could have well we're going to draft these around it's like can't you just dish them out at random or can't you just give people four and they pick two two out of them or something it's like they shoehorned into a lot of setups and it really doesn't need to be but yeah I still really like drafting all right uh runstone as the example over here but I mean I could pick pretty much any uh you know game that has this I do really like deck building and for the most part I am talking pure deck building now it's not to say I don't like deck building when it's put into other games but sometimes it is really shoehorned into some some games it works you know lost ruins of
arac love the game but the deck building is a small part of it yeah you buy more cards than that but you know you can easily get your deck to be relatively streamlined and you only have so much control over the deck so the deck building is there but it's not like a Forefront of the game compared to something like doing Imperium and the deck building is a little bit more on the Forefront but then you have so little control over the composition of your deck that it doesn't really feel like a deck builder either and it just feels like I'm lucky to draw the decks I'm talking about a game where deck building is really like the major aspect and so you could go to the the original Dominion for example where that is clearly a deck building game but there are other games where it's pure deck building with a bit of a Twist runestones here is a perfect example of that this game where you are you know this the the actual mechanisms are pretty straightforward you're collecting these color gems you trade them in for these artifact tokens you trade them in for sets which are worth points and every time you trade a set you get this cool runestone ability which gives you a power up for the rest of the game and you decide whether you want to go for more points or quicker Powers you know there's that's the Simplicity of the game but you then have the card mechanism in it which is brilliant I really love this I mean firstly kudos to run Stones the fact that they make it so that left and right-handed people can read the cards fine you know you don't trigger both sides you only trigger one side it's just left and right-handed people can use it not a lot of card games do this and I wish more did cuz I mean I'm not left-handed but there are
people that exist that are left-handed you know why not C for them but the great thing with this game is that it throws a little twist on it by saying that when you play your card you have to play two cards and it the number value dictates which one of them gets trashed after you're done so you have to get rid of the card out of your deck that has the higher value which typically is your starter cards but then the more powerful cards tend to be higher values this is just such a cool little mechanism and it just adds a little twist to it but what I love about deck builders is the idea that I do have this deck that is basic at first and then as the game progresses I make it better and better and I see the engine spinning and it's rewarding to not only get cool cards to add your deck but to see them come out and be used in cool ways this game also adds another mechanism I like which I'm not going to talk about uh separately I don't think uh I don't know maybe I could Sho on it in uh well let's see I've got four I'm not a fan of maybe I'll talk about that well tell you what let's just make it my two and three here so you know we're talking also nah nah I'm going to save it for the next point but yeah so I like a deck build Builder where you get to create you know combos with cards and runestones is one of them dominions another but you know any game with just pure deck building is still one that I like I mean if I go to Advanced Search and look up deck building as a mechanic could blind me do you get a lot of stuff in here and the the thing with this
though is that it shoehorns every type of deck building that you can so when you look at the list on Board Game Geek oh blind me does it uh go on forever come on work with me here I mean look it considers Gloom Haven to be a deck builder I mean yeah you customize a deck sort of but it's not really what I would call the Forefront and terraforming Mars you don't customize a deck now is that even deck building in the slightest that doesn't make any sense so yeah this game does like to throw up a lot of stupid ideas for it but yeah in fact yeah in fact this this is all full of rubbish how is any of this deck building what kind of oh man this is one thing I hate about board game G it's just such a like I mean deck bag and pool building is apparently including stuff like Scythe that doesn't make any sense whatsoever uh there's got to be better examples here come on seriously this is what it is I mean I'm and I suppose I will get clear I'm not talking about deck construction like Lord of the Rings the card game Marvel Champions and all that no no no I'm talking about the deck is basic in the game and you create it during a game uh all right well this is no use well done uh um BGG for being usess but you know off the top of my head as I now remember star round star round brilliant lovely little quick game uh doesn't take very long at all comes in a tuck box or you can buy more sets but this is a pure deck builder you know you literally have you know some cool basic rules for it but the Crux of the
game is I play these cards I can use them for battle or money with money I buy more cards my deck gets better I can customize it with four different factions you know and it's so simple and streamlined and I love this game but you know I I do like a pure Deck Builder and certainly you've got to throw a little bit of a Twist in it now you know we've got so many deck builders that you can't just simply give me a deck builder roomstone perfect example you know Star Realms is one of the best of the pure simple deck builders so I still really like it I still really like Dominion but if you come out with one now in 20204 I need more than just what we've seen before so but yeah I mean uh what's another game I played I played a Tanto core recently and my friend has um oh what's the there another one they make uh ah some rise of the princesses or something like that uh I can't remember I think it's by the same uh let me have a look at Art like games maybe they got the same uh thing come on oh God no that's not it I can't remember it's it's something to do with princesses and it's got the same anime thing I mean this one's about uh recruiting Maids which um yeah it certainly has a bit of an evocative theme to to be typical sort of anime maids and girl pictures and that but it's a fun little deck builder again pure you try and build it up and stuff but yeah I'm going to struggle to remember what that one is and I'm going to kick myself and not being able to uh think of it uh japanime games let's have a look maybe I can find it let's see taner heart of crown there it is heart of crown so my friend has this one and
this one is basically Dominion with a Twist but this one is a cool little deck builder to play as well so I enjoy this you know takes a bit long with three or four players but you know pure deck builders I do get a kick out of right uh next one I'm going to go back to runestones because this one illustrates this particular mechanic that I really like and that is oop that's not working there um that is multiuse cards this is the thing I was trying to get out with run Stones because deck builders work great with multi-use cards cuz you know after all you're using the bunch of cards and they don't always just have one thing but where's the hand of cards in runestones mind me where's that image but the idea with this is that yes you could use the cards for their abilities great but what you can also use the cards for is to buy other cards so there are two things that a card is useful for why is it so far hard to find a picture of the game with the cards here we go let's go back to here we go there's one here so yeah you can use these for the gemstones or the abilities that are on them but the top of the card shows a manner cost and if you play so many with the same color you use that as currency to buy the card so you're thinking well I could use it for this but I could also use use it for that that is something I really really like another cool example for this is um uh oh it's right behind me uh there we go Valley of the Kings Valley of the Kings another cool deck builder in fact this one actually goes well into the last one I just mentioned but in this one the cards again they are currency you also have to put them in
your tomb so in tuming and you have them for their ability so they have three uses a piece and you have to decide how you're going to use those pieces this is something I really enjoy uh even let's go for something that is not a deck builder at all um I'm not the biggest fan in the game anymore I kind of give it an average maybe above average rating but marra Kaio it's got its Mega fans I think it's okay it's it's got some problems but the one thing I do like in maraio is the card system the card system I quite like and this is another example where the cards are multi-use so the whole map aspect I'm actually not that big a fan of but the cards you know they are used to the resource they're used as the travel thing they've got their ability on there and so I'm I've got these cards available and I thinking hm what do I want to use this for do I want to use it for a b or c and that part of maraio I really like so even like a dry Euro can throw this aspect into games and still make me you know really like it uh to a lesser extent you could consider stuff like Earth where the card could be its ability but then it could also be be just used as compost and so their worth points you know that's still really cool um but you know games where you have alternate uses for cards are still ones I quite like oh I got to be careful that my voice doesn't go before my parents get here he is getting that way all right and then lastly quite briefly another uh mechanic I really do like this one is only in two games unfortunately though this is a mechanic that I do really like but I really do want to see it in more
games I want to you know to I want to see this like used more often and this is what I call the typewriter mechanic uh I don't even know if it has an official name really cuz only two games have done it but I call it the typewriter mechanic because it's basically a system where your card action selection system or your action selection system behaves very much like a typewriter so uh let's see what we got here somebody these done a blind me they've done a Lego organizer for Arc Nova that is that is pretty cool looking I must admit but called Blind me that's a little bit Overkill but whatever um the main thing I want to get across here is those five action cards so the way it works in arcn NOA is that you choose one of these cards to resolve this position dictates the strength of the action and then once you have done the action it then typewriter style moves back to the left everything slides across they get more powerful that one gets weaker so you can spam the same action but it will be weak or you can take time to wait for an action to build up and up and up and then it's super powerful and then you trigger it I love the way that you plan for this sort of stuff the way that you can plan several turns ahead going right well I'm going to use a let's see if I use Association now I can get that University I really need that I want to be able to build an Avery so a so build needs to get from two to five I need to use fre cards that aren't build in order to get it there like I say Association that will give me a university great um you know but maybe I should put sponsors first because if I do sponsors first then when I do Association I can then
level up sponsors quicker but then somebody might Nick my University I need to be careful about that but you know well I need some money I don't have a sponsor fine I'll sponsor is five get some money then we associate get the university then cards is a bit better now I'll draw some cards right build at five now or maybe I've got a temp X token I can boost it at four but you know one way or another I'm planning turns in advance in a simple manner not crazy strategic manner like you know big lurds and stuff but I'm sort of going through my tight rer thing going hm that one there that one first and then that one moves to the back then I can shift that one all that ability lets me shift another one to position five all right well that's cool let me do that and on the on the third action cuz then that will be in five that will be in one and yeah that sort of stuff just really worked for me now Arc NOA is the second game to have done this the first game that did this mechanic was a new dor which I really do need to get out again actually this is definitely going high on my uh has not been played in far too long uh pile especially as I've got the expansion in it but I really like this it's a slightly more abstracted sidmar civilization game but those photos aren't particularly good all right this all do but you know it's it's one where you know with the expansion Terror Incognito or whatever is you know the maps there for you to explore you do like a bit of trade you do a bit of travel you do a bit of combat you know it's it's a bit of tech upgrading it's classic sidmar civilization stuff and I really enjoy it but this one as far as I'm aware correct me if I'm wrong on this if I'm wrong please tell me where
this came up before but I think this pioneered the typ writer mechanic so I want to try and get a better view of the ah here we go that's a better View for the card so you have these five cards and they can be upgraded throughout the game much like Arc noova can once but again the card is dict the strength of the card action is dictated by its position in your row and in the new dawn you've got right well how many spaces does it level you up the tech track well that depends on its strength all right I want to move my Caravan well how fast can it move but also where can it move this bar above tells you the terrain you can move so it's all right saying well I'm only going to use my you know my travel action in space one but then I've only got to go across Meadows that's fine but it's like now I got to get over this mountain range I need it to be at strength five before I can do a mountain travel so what can I use before then I can use my tech I could uh do some masonry and you know these will upgrade as time goes on and it's just such a cool mechanic I love it and you know certainly this is you know a very cool Civ game for me AR over's was my favorite game of all time in the last top 100 so you know this is such a cool mechanic and I want to see it more often I know it seems weird talking about a mechanic that's only appeared twice but the fact that I love it so much means I want to see it more often and honestly I don't pay attention to Kickstarter but if somebody on Kickstarter comes out with a game that utilizes a mechanic well I want to know about it because it really is one that I gravitate to at the moment and I want to see it done more
stop rehashing the same trash and give us something that's not been done a lot before I swear you could do some really cool stuff with this mechanism and people just aren't exploring it enough it's it doesn't have to be the most phatic implementation of it I mean there's no real formatic reason why you're using a typewriter mechanic for these two games but it works it's so much more interesting than just simple basic action selection you know so I want to see it more all right well that's the ones I'm going to talk about from a good perspective and it's not to say I don't like other mechanics I mean I like point up to a point no pun intended I like the Dixit picture interpretation mechanic you know there's a lot of mechanics I like but these are four that I just want to highlight because they're a bit more common well with the exception AR okay that's a bad reason um I don't know these are just four that really stand out to me it's like oh yeah if I know it's got these mechanisms I'm definitely a bit more interested but um you know there's plenty of other games I do like all right well let's talk about ones that I'm another fan of and these may be games I like these may be games I hate parag grid is certainly a game I hate um but this is auctions I'm not the biggest fan of auctions now there is a little caveat with that quick fixed bidding I'm kind of fine with biblos is a quick filler game you barely bid up to a maximum of like five coins before somebody says right that's it and they're done nice and fast and um raah that's on my shelf still raah uses free number tokens in your collection that is
what you are bidding with it is a fixed number your choice is simple that I don't mind okay what I don't like is drawn out auctions where you're flexible as to what you want to do and they take forever power grid is the worst Contender for this auctions in this just refuse to freaking end because you're bidding on these power plants and because this is a heavy Euro game where it's very punishing people can screw you over every dime counts it is impossible to get through one of these auctions quick because you can bid whatever you like you know from the minimum bid onwards so you've got total flexibility but because you've also got to consider how much it's going to cost to get between various points on your map you know these connection bits I don't is the UK a promo map or is that an official map I don't know but you know you've got to factor in right how much is it going to cost me to connect from here to here oh god I've got to factor that in but then I've also got ah but you know hang on I can just about afford it if I carry the one deduct the three uh at the two right fine that's okay so as long as he doesn't out bid me I can do it right I'll bid 31 32 oh God's sake hang on I got to rethink this so uh 33 I can just about do it 35 oh man can I but then I can't afford the A on a minute let me just do the mouse again oh my God will you freaking get on with it and this freezes a lot of people and then parag grid is not the only like one that causes this there's a lot of other games with auctions that do this but you know it's just the fact that they go on
forever um what's another auction game I'm not a fan of it came out by alycat games um I want to say oh man it's a Martin Wallace game I'm going to try and find it it's about mining in Cornwall I found this to be a kind of basic but I I'll have a look aliat games but you know it's just the fact that these auctions can just D drag out and they're not quick and they're not you know straightforward um you know does does uh Qi uh Q I think QE has auctions as well although that's a weird one where you get to write down any amount I wasn't a big fan of here you go tinner's Trail yeah I found this one barely average at best I mean it's not I think I did a review of it and my ratings probably gone down since that review but it's Martin Wallace don't tend to go for his games that much but this one again it's got auctions and money is par Mount and I don't know just it's not even just the fact that they can drag on for ages and they're a bit too AP and juicing I just don't find them that fun auctions are not a fun thing for me if I sat at an auction in real life I think I'd just probably be bored because I'd just be sitting there going it's going to be FR it's going to be 36 is he going to bid 37 he's taking his sweet ass time oh he's B 37 he's 39 whatever I mean I don't stare at an eBay auction waiting for it to finish you know I just put my maximum bid that I'm willing to spend and if someone out bids me so be it all this thing with sniping at the last minute it's like whatever I'm prepared to pay this much here's the amount I'm putting in if it falls at that price great but I'm not there going come on
it's like no I'm not it's I don't know I just find this a boring mechanism more than anything else you know some games like parag good really does my head in but for the most part if I get auctions in the game I'm just like me but quick bidding fine fixed bidding fine it's just these drawn out flexible auctions like the more realistic ones yeah just me right this one I'm going to use fall on the Mountain King as an example though to be honest this could apply for a lot of games in this hell even a world order that I played the new one from the makers of hegemony it's a me mechanism I'm not that big into but this one's just another sort of poster child for this mechanism area control yeah I'm not really a big area control fan and now area influence up to a point I don't mind but it's usually always the weakest aspect of a game take her Vindication Vindication you have all these cool cards you can get and all these two like cool things you can do but one of the ways that you can get points relatively reliably is to control locations and all it means is that you get a couple of points and if someone visit it you get a couple of points and at the end of the game you can score more but it's really boring you just basically just go right I visit it stick a cube on it it's mine I control it I don't know I just area control just isn't that fun to me and this is full on the Mountain King is a classic example CU you've got all your different ogres or trolls or whatever it is I think it's trolls and you know you try to control these different sections in the cave and it's about who's got the most and you can get screwed over and
you might spend ages trying to control an area and then somebody pulls off some random lucky move and suddenly it's like oh now I control it I get all the cool stuff you don't and I just don't find this fun it's also it's a mechanism it's a little bit dated like it's been done to death you know I mean so are some of my favorite me mechanisms but you know these ones I still like these ones I wasn't a massive fan of before and now they are just going on and on and on but world daugh was another uh example of this I mean you know I I demoed it at uh you know the games Expo and it still has some good stuff about it but at the end of the day the game is area control and I don't know how much I enjoy that to be honest you know this you aspect where you literally are just putting cubes on these little spots and whoever has the most Cubes at various scoring bits you know scores the most points and you know you get areas where you're locked out of them because frankly like you know if I'm playing yellow for example I've got no interest in going to these two over here there's no chance I'm going to beat them here I've gone yellow in these first Cubes but then you know by the time it's finished you know you get nothing for it and it just isn't that fun me mechanism I just don't really get a kick out going oh I'll put a cube on this area oh I've slightly got more control now he it's it doesn't really fill me with that much joy and yeah not a lot is done with this I mean people praise the likes of El Grande I have still not played El Grande now I want to try El Grande because the card mechanism
sounds quite cord it but I didn't have to realize that the game is basically just a Bare Bones area control game am I going to enjoy it on the basis that it's just a Bare Bones dry area control game I don't know I feel like I'll play it and just be like me and it's not I say area control games don't typically end up as games that I hate they just end up as games where I'm like it exists whatever so I'm really that big on them uh you know I try to think if is there any game in my collection that is predominantly area control that really well I suppose actually no I've just spotted them thematic ones do have a place and exceptions to the rule could include chaos in the old world I do have chaos in the old world still I have not played it in ages though and maybe that's a problem with the mechanism but this one is predominantly an area control game so you know and it's one that I still enjoy although some of it is down to the car cards rather than the fact that you are controlling majorities of areas but then you could also argue that some games that are big Mammoth space epic games like forbidden stars for example how the hell is this still rank 139 on Board Game Geek when was the last time you saw anybody play this except Paul Gro I know he played it recently but uh you know I've got it it's still an amazing game but when was the last time I ever got it out I've probably forgotten every single rle in it now there's no way I could bring this out and play it in a quick time this is an event game but yeah you are playing factions and you're battling each other and controlling areas but I guess there's more to it than just simply the
area control there's the fighty aspect there's all the other cool Tech upgrad and stuff and it's formatic to the game so you know these are exceptions but I do think they are special cases for the most part area control is just kind of meh speaking of meh rolling right flip and right X and right whatever the hell and right you want to call it this mechanism is is so dated so quickly I mean man it just got overused and it infuriates me because if a game comes out that is rolling right flipping right but it's Unique fine and I do have some in my collection are pretty good I like get on board that's kind of a flip and right game I like the next games next London next Tokyo and all that I think they're really nice flip and right games you know but they are their own games they're not based on something else stuff like this for example I'll Hamra Rolland right who the hell is playing Al Hamber Roland Wright rank 13,000 alhamra is a decent old dry Euro game was anybody that desperate for a roll and right impl implementation of this you know it's just it's just unnecessary and you know this is on the search where I looked up more so Imperial settlers roll and right Woodcraft has a rolling right I mean for crying out loud L cities rolling right cop rolling right Escape rolling right yokohoma Yokohama not yokohoma Yokohama rolling right Tris mesus roll wait minut
when the hell did Tris magistus get a rolling right game what the hell was this like a fan-made one was it oh print and play right so this was a print and play I was going to say when the hell did Trish magistus get a Rolland right but you know just and some of them are unique games I mean walking in barano rolling rolling right um I know walking and brano is his own card game and you although the rolling right is actually not too bad but yeah it's just so many of these games are just like oh we need to make a quick Buck we need to capitalize on something that we've already made a bit of money on what's the laziest way we can do it we make a rooll and right game it's just a matter of fact because if you really were like you know full of inspiration full of ideas you would create a different game you wouldn't create some Rolland right spin-off of something you've already already made now sometimes the Rolland Wright ends up better than the original I mean Copenhagen Rolland Wright I would actually argue is better to play in its Rolland Wright version and it is its a you know normal version but that's only because the normal version of Copenhagen is pretty bland and dull anyway so it's like whatever Woodcraft wrong and right well I didn't even know there was such a thing and oh look it's print and play and that's another thing I mean these things appear but they're not even full releases they're just printing plays and that just gets annoying but that being said Woodcraft only gave an above average rating to maybe I would prefer to play it in a Rolland wri version but I don't know it just feels like a lazy cash grab for the most part and you know
sometimes they are unique ones I mean I've got draft and right records here and certainly I'm like oh God it's another flipping right so they have to bring something new to the game in order to make them stand out or something more interesting and sometimes as I say the next games I really like uh U tell you what this one Twilight inscription you know this is a roll and right I actually do quite enjoy particularly solo and I can't get it off the shelf because it's wedged with all my Marvel Champion stuff oh here we go oh bloody hell right you know this one I do enjoy this game you know it's ridiculously complicated it's got all the you know different maps and stuff that you use and it is a bit of a monster but I think some of that is kind of the reason why I like it it's something that you'd think oh my God this is never going to work but it did work it did provide a very fun game to play not necessarily with more than three players but certainly even more solo I enjoy this one even if it is just a bit crazy I mean look at the amount of stuff that you've got to draw on it's but however in Combos and links I don't know I just this one was unique enough to stand out from the crowd and so these ones I can get behind but for the most part I am just done with this whole X and right stuff can we not come up with something a bit more original and a bit more interesting all right and then lastly uh before I wrap this up my throat is getting quite sore we're going to talk about push your luck push your luck is fine if you want it in a very
short game I mean a lot of these dice Ro games like zombie Dice and stuff are mostly Pusher luck hell can't stop is literally a 15minute pusher luck game you know the whole thing is just push your luck but those sort and no thanks no thanks there a filler card game and it is essentially push your luck but they are like what 5 10 minutes a piece they're quick what I can't stand is push your luck when it's in longer games and this is the poster child for where it really doesn't work now push your luck can also go hand inhand with other mechanisms cuz technically this one is bag building but it still push your luck to an extent it's still an element of like right well could do better but I'm going to push my luck and draw more and see what happens but you are basically basing it on luck so you can get screwed over in a short game that is fine wonderlands war is not a short game it says 45 to 125 minutes on that clock you are not playing this game in 45 minutes get out of here with those lies okay this is a game that regularly takes 2 hours at least and people will play this for three and a half hours this game can go on crazy long it really does inflate over 125 minutes on a regular basis I don't want to play a game that's push your luck that takes two and a half to three hours that's not what I'm here for okay and so this one put me off a lot because of it I mean it looks gorgeous and it certainly has some other fun aspects to it I like the uh the act the
mechanism where you move around the middle and get like cool bonuses and stuff you know that's really cool um you know I like these card abilities that you can use I mean the artwork is gorgeous you know it's good little asymmetric player Powers although they're not balanced to say the least but you know the idea that it is a lot of push of luck I mean it's basically quacks of queden BG if you added an extra two hours to the game length and qu quinber kind of works because it's about an hour long but even then it's getting to that point but stuff like Wonderland's War where it's uh um you know just way too long for a pusher luck mechanism you know Pusher luck needs to be in short games because I don't want to be going Bri well I've spent two and a half hours doing this stuff and now I'm basically going to go right well it all comes down to this push your luck push your luck oh it didn't work oh well there goes the game and there's 2 and a half hours worth I'm not even like screwed over it doesn't does not work for me but if you keep the game short nice and short I'm totally fine with that and can't stop is the pure the purest form of why did that come up as a tossup when I said can't stop how's that work yeah I definitely said can't stop right there you go Can't Stop 19 80 that came out Jesus but you know this game is at its purest form a simple push of luck you know you roll dice you try to get the tokens you move your Fe up but at the end of the day you're pushing your luck as to how far you can go before you bust fine but it's a cheap easy push your luck dice game it takes what it
says 30 minutes it will take you about 15 to 20 really it's just nice and easy nice and cheap not saying it's a game that I want to play all the time it's a push of luck game I don't generally go for this mechanic even in the smaller games but at least in a smaller game I can take it and it's done with and it's done in dusted but in a long game oh man this is not a mechanism I like to see uh anything else that's uh kind of push you like oh distilled distilled is another good example I wanted to like distilled it's got other problems the cardex is way too small the game takes a bit longer for what it is but I don't like this top and tail thing or whatever it is when you have the cards you're trying to brew a drink and then you random I forget how it works you take like cards off the top and the bottom shuffle them and one gets discarded or something I forget how it works in the mechanism but it's basically push your luck because you are trying to make this drink but then you might find that your key ingredient gets shuffled out because of this mechanism but that's annoying because you've only got seven rounds you need to make these drings it's Paramount that you succeed yes you get a small bonus if you don't but it's not worth it it's I mean it's not to say it's a horrible bonus I don't want to take it but at the end of the day I wanted to make the goddamn drink you know I didn't make this so I could fail I made it so that I could succeed getting a consolation prize is just to you know put a plaster on the wound basically but I really don't like that mechanism in this game and it kind of kills it for me
it you know one of I mean I really do think the card Tex is way too small and they should have thought about that in the graphic design process but yeah you know that whole pushup mechanism in a game that is not that thought I mean what does it say on here what lies would it tell me here um oh no that's actually pretty accurate actually 30 to 150 I although I dare say you are not going to play this in half an hour solo but yeah you are talking a game that can go on for two hours two and a half hours this is not a short game so why do you base the whole game on a bout of luck it's just not on um uh septe oh this was another example I gave this one a four out of 10 you know it's got other problems but you know the Tri mechanism in this is at the end of the day push your luck you know you are what was it yeah here you go you know you've put these things into a bag and you draw them out and the majority gets the witch getting these witches is of Paramount importance to succeed in the game and you could put in as many as you like and your luck could still bounce back and hit you and you don't get anything for it and there's not enough time to recover from a spout of bad luck it's a stupid mechanism in this game I really did not like like it and again it's another one of those things of why are you putting push your luck in a 3our game it's just it's not right so yeah not one not one I'm a fan of so yeah there you go uh that's kind of like a summary of like four mechanisms I really get behind four hang on I'm going to take a drink oh yeah fruit's really going but
yeah four mechanisms I get behind four that I don't and there are other mechanisms I don't like there are other mechanisms I do like I can't go over every single one but I just wanted to talk about some key ones that either grate me a bit more or when I see them I'm like oo you know tell me more and aren't just unique to a particular game like I mentioned the whole Dixit mechanic I do really like the Dixit picture card mechanic but it's it's kind of unique to those styles of games it's not like any game can simply throw in the mechanic it's a very specific genre of games that are having that mechanic and I do love them but you know I was trying to think of something a little bit more far reaching I mean as much as the typewriter mechanic can only be is only in two games I feel like a lot of games could use that typewriter mechanic they just need to do it anyway that's it for me on this episode I'll see you on the big Bonanza Q&A 100th episode I look forward to that one so uh what's that two weeks time so end of August start of September you will get that episode so by all means hope you see it uh I'll talk about the meet and play event more so by all means um when I finalize details you know come and see me at at that time if you want to talk better in person quieter but by all means just say hi to me at Essen regardless of where I am that would be great hopefully I'm in a demo of you at some point uh other than that I'm going to go uh sort myself out dry myself off a bit because I'm sweating a little bit and prepare for my parents arrival in literally 27 minutes so uh yeah I talk about how stressed I've been
lately and this is just sort of adding to it a bit but things will be good when the parents are here they they help me out with a bit of house were they're nice that dad's going to help me out with some gardening bits we're going to go out for a meal it's nice you know this will be a time for me to chillax starting from now okay take care and I'll see you in the next episode and remember it's only a game bye for now